This kind of thing just shows how utterly empty and useless marketing buzzwords like 'open' are.
[1] http://arstechnica.com/security/2014/02/e-z-2-use-attack-cod...
[2] http://www.walmart.com/search/search-ng.do?search_query=andr...
I'm happy for Android but saying that Android is winning only because it's "more" open is just non-sense.
Because App.net cost money ($50 per head/year iirc) and twitter despite being a closed service was free (as in beer).
App.net didn't have a chance.
a) they're aiming more for phpBB et al b) they launched a year ago
And I mean that on top of network effect. And the fact that it was mismanaged. And that it was mostly vapour-ware.
It hardly had a chance.
I've never heard of Discourse.
App.net didn't beat Twitter because of network effects. And it costs more.
Windows has a very open ecosystem. It's not open source.
Arguably the parent has missed the difference between open source and open ecosystem. The iPad has a moderately open ecosystem too - though less open than Android (which in some ways is less open than Windows since it has a centralised distribution method).
Did you mean Diaspora? Also, those are not "ecosystems".
"I know a family member who had an iPad and used it all the time. For his next tablet he got an Android tablet and he doesn't use it at all. Why? No good apps."
Android tablets are good when cost is a major consideration but if you can afford to spend an extra $100/200 I believe you'll get more value from an iPad still.
I didn't say that at all. From my personal experience it seems they get less value from them. They are certainly useful devices but I think the extra money an iPad costs provides more value than the added expense.
>> Why doesn't your family member return the tablet if it's useless?
He's trying to sell it.
Apps that register for opening certain file types will also be available in 'Open in' dialogs of other apps (if the developers of both apps added the same file extension) so it's easy to move files between apps. Silos for app files only exist if the developer is lazy or ignorant, the platform itself has supported file sharing between apps for years.
Wait, what? Connecting to iTunes is not part of any regular file explorer workflow.
> I guess the Android advantage is you can initiate this transfer from the device instead of the computer, but that's not really "too much work" IMO.
Wow, can't disagree more. That's an enormous difference. one is a computer and one is a periphery. Peripheries are fine, some people can live with just a periphery, but if you have real file management needs like the one I pointed to above, a periphery won't cut it. It's entirely too inconvenient to have to dig out the computer that has iTunes installed (for me it's 1 of 4 laptops in my house), get the files onto that computer (probably over the network) and then transfer them onto the device.
And you've only got to physically connect to iTunes once, after that you can just upload files over local wifi. You've constructed yourself a scenario where iOS is the loser for you, but for anyone with a Windows or Mac computer (what, 97% of the world?), "finding the iTunes computer" is not a difficult task.
How about we call a molehill a molehill instead of a mountain?
Come on, the newest Apple computer costs like 3000 $ . Anyone who wants it, is willing to throw out cash.
Even a friend of mine (who is a serieus Apple fan), is going to buy a Windows pc (but he'll keep his iPhone). I suspect that he is going to get frustrated by the frustrating experience that Apple brings on other platforms.
I think if Google sold Android like Microsoft does Windows it still would have won (albeit somewhat more slowly). Apple always limits its bandwagon effect by limiting the availability of its platform to a rather small collection of devices. There's simply much more, and much cheaper choice of Android devices than there is with iOS. That defines what platforms wins, not the source code license or the details of their application policy.
That doesn't make much sense as the two concepts are not directly correlated. Good user experience doesn't guarantee market share nor does market share point at good experience.