News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dkhenry on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:13AM (#6211242)
I understand the point the article is trying to make, but its not realistic. Having worked with the Navy for a few years I know that the biggest use of airplanes is not air to air combat ( which is what this article is complaining about ) It is air to land bombing. So why are we complaining about making an air force that serves our needs rather then one that might be useful for some other task.

As a note he says this will be the "new mainstay of the air force" however we still have the F-22 as our air superiority fighter which is still believed to be better then anything out there, and indeed in their simulation the only limitation to the F-22 was there were too few of them. So this isn't really about America losing air superiority its about a few analysts not taking into account the entire mission of the three branches of the military. Maybe this plane doesn't stack up well against the F-16 or F-22, but It sure beats the Harrier and the F-18.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:46PM (#6213761)
"So why are we complaining about making an air force that serves our needs rather then one that might be useful for some other task."

Because the JSF is a shitty bomb truck too. It doesn't have the range, capacity or loiter time of nearly any other option. And for CAS vs bomb hauling, the JSF simply doesn't have the gun (and again, lacks the loiter time).

"As a note he says this will be the 'new mainstay of the air force' however we still have the F-22 as our air superiority fighter which is still believed to be better then anything out there, and indeed in their simulation the only limitation to the F-22 was there were too few of them."

We aren't dealing in hypotheticals where we can have any number of planes we want. That's the basic lesson of the RAND study: dollar for dollar you can have so many more SU-3 7 derivatives that even if the F-22's have a perfect kill probability, they quickly exhaust their magazines and have nothing else to do. And that's the outcome of the simulation: the F-22's live, most of the rest of the blue force dies, and red gains air superiority over the straight of Taiwan via the remaining flankers.

"It sure beats the Harrier and the F-18."

The FA-18 is more capable than the F-35 in both the A2A and A2G missions as a result of its superior capacity, range, and time on station. Comparing the FA-18 to the F-22 is more muddled, and IMHO comes down to an assesment of the relative performance of stealth vs EW. The prevailing attitude among the Russian military designers is that stealth is mitigated by state of the art communicating radars and passive emission detection (they claim detection of the F-22 at 50km on passive IR alone). And of course, as soon as the F-22 takes a shot stealth is no longer a consideration. Thankfully the F-22 is fast enough that it can turn and run. The F-35 can't, which is why they were decimated in the sim.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by neurotech1 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:49PM (#6214143)
The F-35 has EODAS for spherical optical threat detection vs OLS front only on a Su-35 Flanker.

Also, a Su-35 Flanker cant fire a missile at 50km without radar lock, which would be difficult against a F-35. Even if they did fire a future Long-Range IR missile, the F-35 would detect and release flares to avoid the missile. Also, the kinetics of the missile would make it hard to track a F-35 during terminal phase.

A F/A-18 has significant less range and time on station than F-35, with both internally fueled. The F/A-18 carries all weapons externally.

As for your comment about stealth when the F-22 fires a missile, that assumes the F-22 doesn't change course after firing said missile. The F-22 would most likely turn away from the target, so they are not staying behind the missile relative to the target.

Pretty much everything you said in this entire thread is wrong or at least misguided.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:10PM (#6215763)
I stand behind what I've said and encourage you to dig into the open source docs on this. The RAND study is worth a start but there's a lot more, including English language materials from the SU design staff.

"As for your comment about stealth when the F-22 fires a missile, that assumes the F-22 doesn't change course after firing said missile."

Doesn't matter. Once you've got a launch flare that gives you a position fix to hand to the radar to do localized searching, dramatically weakening the likelihood of avoiding continued spotting.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by neurotech1 on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:52AM (#6216495)
The 2008 RAND study has been widely debunked. Any idea of the RCS(X-band) of a F-22, or a F-35 for that matter?

F-22: 0.0005 m2

F-35: 0.0015 m2

F-16C: 1.0m2

Su-27/Su-30 Flanker: 10.0m2 (China has this series and J-11 "Flankers" built domestically)

Su-35 (Advanced) Flanker: 1.0m2 (Russia only)

From the front a stealthy F-35 is basically noise against the background using X-Band radar. The latest L-Band radar on a Su-30MKI (Bars N011M) or Su-35 AESA couldn't actually track a stealth target but might get a faint return.

My comment about the missile is that most missiles don't maintain full thrust the entire flight over 30NM - they have an initial boost to Mach 2.5+, then they coast at lower thrust until reaching the target. Newer missiles might have terminal boost but this would likely not be enough to hit an F-35 that sees the missile on EODAS. Very few Russian (or US made) missiles can shoot down a jet fighter at 20NM+ when that fighter detects the missile.

I'm familiar with the strengths and weaknesses of the Su-27 and Su-30. The Su-27 OLS is the best feature against a stealth adversary but its nowhere near as good as the F-35 EODAS.

A F-35 would be almost impossible to track at 30NM using AESA radar much less a F-22. An F-15C with the latest APG-82 AESA can't track a F-22 for radar lock at 1000 ft range so what chance would a Su-30 have at 30NM. The SU-30 pilot would have to manually cue the OLS without radar. Auto-cueing a heat source would lock onto the flares.

In around 60-90 seconds into the merge an F-35 would be within range for an AIM-9 Sidewinder missile shot while the Su-30 pilot is trying to cue the OLS manually. Most recent dogfights are over in under 2 minutes.

Take a look at this documentary on the F-22 program. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-Sh1SAaJz0

And here is the RAND press release about the previous report you referenced. http://www.rand.org/news/press/2008/09/25.html "Those reports are not accurate."

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Tloewald on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:22AM (#6216995)
Before the battle of Midway the Japanese navy wargamed the battle and cadets (playing the US) did to the Japanese exactly what the actual US navy did. Naval command debunked the results, changed the rules, ran a new wargame, and won. They then went and got the core of their actual navy destroyed.

Any argument like this in favor of the F35 is very dubious. You're talking about the F35 allegedly defeating older technology with radar, stealth, and missiles. Yow know what will win using radar, stealth, and missiles? Drones. Who might suddenly show up to a battlefield with a lot of drones?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jasonwatkinspdx on Thursday August 15, 2013 @05:26PM (#6220714)
Yeah, it's also hard to do an apples to apples comparison. Should the F-35 be compared to competitors that are in operation now, or ones that will be available for purchase at the same time the JSF is? This gets even more difficult with the SU jets, because they've shifted to a very aggressive continuous upgrade program. So in particular with the radars and the EW stuff it's not clear what gear a given model will actually have.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by 6d0debc071 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:07PM (#6215029)
> Also, a Su-35 Flanker cant fire a missile at 50km without radar lock, which would be difficult against a F-35. Even if they did fire a future Long-Range IR missile, the F-35 would detect and release flares to avoid the missile. Also, the kinetics of the missile would make it hard to track a F-35 during terminal phase.

If you know how much heat is coming out, then you know roughly what thrust should be being produced. Couple that with known performance characteristics of the aircraft - i.e. aircraft don't just go from manoeuvring in one way to manoeuvring in another - and I would imagine you can tell the two apart fairly easily.

After all, fighter jets don't, at least in the course of normal operation, just change their emission profile and fall out of the sky.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by neurotech1 on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:59AM (#6216505)
Actually, A-6Bs on SAM suppression flights idled their engines and dived for the deck to avoid SAMs fired at them over Vietnam.

There have been cases of MiG-21s and Mirage F1s releasing flares and successfully avoiding an AIM-9 missile fired at them from less than 10NM. The engaging fighter usually speeds towards the target and fires a second missile at closer range and shoots it down.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by zobzu on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:32PM (#6214432)
Sounds pretty much like the latest gens of the french rafale, except for the VTOL ;-)
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by neurotech1 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @06:56PM (#6214947)
Rafale has reduced RCS and OLS(FLIR) but its not spherical either. Only the F-35 has spherical Electro-Optical systems. The Rafale also doesn't have mature A/G capability. Laser targeting and AESA radar have only recently been added to the Rafale F3 version.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by VladRussian2 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:10PM (#6213906)
>the only limitation to the F-22 was there were too few of them.

...

>the F-22's live,

F-22 is cheaper than F-35 (and btw looks better - weapons look is important for projecting power - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtahqXjFcxU :), yet F-22 program was closed because of cost while F-35 continues (and still seems to be in R&D stage, though the late stage of R&D). Something bad about F-22 vs. that being good in F-35? Or just government spending logic?

Interesting also that there is a ban on export of F-22 (even to good friends like UK/etc) while F-35 is supposed to be available for export.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:27PM (#6214003)
"Or just government spending logic?"

I believe it's just this. Too much of our military's decision making is influenced by the contractors that build the weapons. The F-35 is the largest single military purchase we've ever done. Too many people would lose too much if the program was abandoned, so the politicians involved cannibalized budgets from things that could be a competitor.

"Interesting also that there is a ban on export of F-22 (even to good friends like UK/etc) while F-35 is supposed to be available for export."

It is. I think that may be partly to do with materials used on the F-22, particularly the coatings. It has to be 'repainted' every so often in a very precise way, so to sell them to allies we'd also have to transfer knowledge of the materials and process.

It's worth noting that many of the customers that were in line to buy the F-35 have pulled out or are at least voicing concerns in their media.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by rdl on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:41AM (#6216470)
I thought the issue was the F-35 could be multirole, and F-22 couldn't, so they needed to replace F-16/F-18/A-10/etc., which the F-22 couldn't do.

I still think manned combat aircraft are probably on the way out, and absent a current threat, we should be life-extending our existing aircraft, spending 10% of F-35/F-22/etc. on combat UAVs, and end up with ultimately better capability (like, 100x more UAVs than manned aircraft, the ability to go on one-way missions, etc.) Kills the aviator officer career path, though.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bradleyjg on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:38PM (#6213719)
In addition to being a crappy fighter the F-35 is also a crappy bomber and close air support aircraft. Not that it's a surprise that a plane designated fighter (or 'strike' or 'fighter/attack') isn't good at these things.

We've virtually abandoned A and B line planes because the testosterone blinded fighter mafia in the airforce would rather have fun toys than useful equipment, and the navy is right there with them because heavy planes can't take off from aircraft carriers. It doesn't help that the one bomber the air force begrudgingly agreed to acquire is an obscenely expensive hanger queen, designed for nuclear bombing runs deep into the Soviet Union.

If the army wasn't barred from operating fixed wing aircraft by the pernicious Key West agreement, maybe they would operate as a voice of reason.

We should be working on a replacement for the AC-130 (1968), the A-10 (1977), and B-52 (1955!). To the extent we actually need more air superiority fighters they can bring back the F-22 line.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by spartango on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:19PM (#6213958)
There is money going toward the development of a replacement for the B-52, although the exact form it will take is still up in the air/under wraps. Suffice to say that the "Next Generation Bomber" project currently has funding.

Two observations along these lines, however:

* The B-52 originally was the US Air Force's all-purpose bomber when it rolled out in the 50s. It was a conventional heavy bomber, a strategic nuclear bomber, and a cruise missile platform all in one. Over time, however, the USAF's bombing roles have become split; the B-1 now takes on the role of a conventional bomber, while the B-2 is used for deep-penetration strikes and standoffs.

* One big hurdle in the development of a B-52 replacement is the limitations on the number of strategic bombers allowed under the New Start treaty. The US cannot easily develop new nuclear-capable bombers under this treaty, and thus must keep a chunk of the B-52 fleet around to maintain the nuclear capability.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jacques_chester on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:41PM (#6215220)
My understanding is that a major role of the B-52 these days is tactical support. It can carry a very large number of small, laser-guided bombs; can loiter over a battlefield for about a day and flies high enough that it can't be harmed by shoulder-fired weaponry.

Conceptually it fills the role of a very large drone.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bradleyjg on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:57PM (#6216076)
The nuclear triad always seemed a bit circular to me. We have three main means of delivering nuclear weapons, so it must be a good idea to have three different means of delivering nuclear weapons. I don't see it. With geographic diversity and at least one delivery system that is mobile and easy to hide we should be more than capable of asserting a second strike capability.

What's really needed from a modern bomber is a high munition capacity, a large combat radius, and long loiter times. Cheap to build and operate would be great too. Super stealth as well as high speeds and maneuverability are simply expensive distractions.

For the rare situation where we need to deliver something like a conventional bunker buster deep inside of territory that we don't wish to first completely destroy the AA cababilities of first -- i.e. an Osirak type mission -- we still have 20 of those $2 billion B-2s.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by spartango on Thursday August 15, 2013 @03:34AM (#6216578)
I think specifying the requirements for a modern bomber is made difficult by the variety of ground attack missions a "bomber" might fulfill.

The requirements of "high munition capacity, a large combat radius, and long loiter times" closely fit the description of a close air support role, which has been the primary role for bombers and strike aircraft in recent years (Iraq and Afghanistan).

With that said, there are certainly other roles for bombers; missions where strategic facilities, supply lines, and bases/defenses must be destroyed. These are rooted in more conventional warfare than we've seen recently, but I'm less than convinced that they would be rare in a major conflict.

These conventional missions demand speed and stealth not only to penetrate evade enemy air defenses, but also to keep up with intelligence on mobile/time-sensitive targets. This timely delivery problem is hard to accomplish with small numbers of loitering aircraft or where the target has advance warning.

Also, given the proliferation of advanced mobile SAM and radar systems, I'm unsure of the assumption that US aircraft will have clear skies in a future conflict. Certainly in the early days of any conflict this will be untrue, and those are the days where strategic bombing will be most valuable; disrupted enemy infrastructure allow ground forces to move without resistance.

Thus, I think there's a need for both roles--CAS and penetrating bomber--and it seems to me that the USAF is actually tackling these separately, efficiently. While the Reaper lacks a large payload, it seems that the large numbers providing spatial coverage will have sufficient munitions in aggregate. The B-2 was designed to be the penetrator.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:49AM (#6217427)
The nuclear triad is designed so that technical advances can't obsolete any one leg of the triad. Currently, ICBMs are vulnerable, and are out of favor due to the accuracy of SLBMs and ICBMs in a first strike role. So we put our emphasis on SSBNs and stealth bombers. Now what do we do if an opponent manages to work out an effective means of tracking our boomers on patrol? Perhaps some odd trail of bioluminescence kicked up by the sub's wake underwater; who knows. Then we're down to one leg. B2s. We only have 19-20, and they can only fly so many missions, plus their bases a vulnerable to ICBMs and SLBMs as well...
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bradleyjg on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:35AM (#6218014)
Could the exact same arguments be made about a nuclear dyad or quad? What makes three so special?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:54PM (#6219116)
Well, I think the designers of SIOP were fond of tripods. ;)

Two legs is obviously less secure than three, and we don't have a fourth because we haven't developed a fourth technology for delivering nuclear weapons.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by ansible on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:05AM (#6217797)
What's really needed from a modern bomber is a high munition capacity, a large combat radius, and long loiter times. Cheap to build and operate would be great too.

Those requirements make me thing of schemes where cruise missiles are dumped out the back of a C-130J Super Hercules for air-launch.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by nknighthb on Thursday August 15, 2013 @01:27AM (#6216325)
> the navy is right there with them because heavy planes can't take off from aircraft carriers

This seems an inadequate and/or overly-simplified explanation. The F-14 was a beast, far heavier than the F-35 or, for that matter, the A-6. And that was 1960s technology. Surely now we could build a capable, carrier-launched ground-attack craft with weight comparable to an F-14?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jloughry on Friday August 16, 2013 @12:14AM (#6222137)
We did. See the Navy's A-12 stealth bomber, a design that never flew [1].

[1] Stevenson, James P. The $5 Billion Misunderstanding. Annapolis, Maryland: Naval Institute Press, 2001. ISBN 1-55750-777-5.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Thursday August 15, 2013 @05:16AM (#6216831)
we did. The F14B ;)
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by nknighthb on Friday August 16, 2013 @03:09AM (#6222584)
I was thinking in terms of something designed from the start for ground-attack/bombing, but my point is that the Navy can't possibly think it needs the same lightweight fighters the Air Force wants just because they operate from carriers, since they spent >35 years running a big-ass plane off carriers.

(For that matter, there were the C-130 tests on a carrier, which was probably pushing the bounds of good sense, but it did work.)

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:51AM (#6217433)
Yep, I loved the Bombcat. Oh, and we also flew the A-5 Vigilante, which was huge. Heck, we've even had C-130 Hercules to take off and landings on a CV.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:12AM (#6218276)
Thanks for reminding me of the A-5, I completely forgot it!
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by InclinedPlane on Thursday August 15, 2013 @04:15AM (#6216680)
The idea that there is "one F-35" is also part of the problem, there are 3 very different planes that just happen to be named F-35A, F-35B, and F-35C, in actuality they share only 30% of their hardware with each other.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by rdtsc on Thursday August 15, 2013 @01:56AM (#6216368)
Do we have to? In other words are our opponents (strategic only so far) China and Russia have aircraft that would be superior? In other words do we need to improve or it would just be nice to.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by UnoriginalGuy on Thursday August 15, 2013 @04:35AM (#6216729)
Read the article. It covers this. Yes is the answer.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by 650REDHAIR on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:50PM (#6213784)
What?

I think you may have missed the B-1 and the enormous focus on UAVs by all of the branches.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bradleyjg on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:06PM (#6213884)
The B-1 was an even bigger debacle than the B-2. Its development time and cost overruns were enormous, and involved a curious scandal where the Carter administration tried the kill the project, but the Pentagon illegally kept it alive off budget so that it was still around to be revived by the Reagan administration. When it finally did roll off the production line almost two decades after the RFP went out, its obsolete stealth, engine problems, and initial inability to deploy non-nuclear weapons kept it from being used in the Gulf War. So it was widely deployed in Afghanistan, 35 years after the design phase began and almost 20 years after production. After so long time had passed the stealth technology was no longer particularly effective and so the bombers were deployed after complete air dominance had been achieved, thus negating one of the chief supposed benefits of the plane over the B-52.

I am optimistic about UAVs as a relatively inexpensive replacement for a lot of aircraft, but I fear that once their successes start to endanger the justifications for testosterone toys, internal factions within the military as well as politicians in the pockets of defense contractors will hit back hard.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by stcredzero on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:39PM (#6216026)
What about the F-15 Silent Eagle?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bradleyjg on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:59AM (#6216249)
I don't mean this in a snarky way, but what about it? Are you saying it will be a good bomber or close air support plane?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by stcredzero on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:59PM (#6221129)
I was thinking along the lines of an interceptor/air superiority platform. Is it really meant to be a bomb truck?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by conformal on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:28AM (#6211320)
the F-35 is one of the largest wastes of government money that is publicly known. by the time the aircraft has all the bugs ironed out, it will have cost USD 1 tln and be easily destroyed by much cheaper drones. the entire contract should be converted into drone development, which will actually pay dividends.

trying to argue that we need the F-35 or that it will provide any kind of strategic military value is absurd.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by demallien on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:21PM (#6213619)
"easily destroyed by much cheaper drones"

To a certain extent, this has been true for more than two decades. I used to work as a radar engineer for the RAAF, and every time we went on exercises against US forces (both teams flying F 18s, but with different missile payloads, we had AIM9s, the Americans had AMRAAM), we would see our aircraft swatted from the sky before we could even get the bogeys on weapons-system radar. Talk about dog-fighting maneuverability and visibility is just ridiculous - if you're using those characteristics, you've already lost the battle. In the control room we used to joke that the USN could have sent P51s equipped with AMRAAMs and AWACS support and they would still win.

Modern fighter aircraft need to:

a) not be seen b) be fast (time to target is still important!) c) carry a decent payload of weapons.

Ideally target selection should be provided by AWACS, and missile-sensors provide the final kill guidance, allowing the fighter (AKA missile-launch platform) to remain stealthy. In the absence of AWACS, the fighter will need to carry it's own sensor suite.

Modern air warfare is all about sensors, ECM and stealth. The airframe is almost inconsequential.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Retric on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:28PM (#6213660)
What I think most people miss is that Air to Air missiles are effectively beyond-visual-range Mach 4+ drones at this point. Stealth works, dog fighting is pointless.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tlear on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:49PM (#6216049)
That was the theory in Vietnam, then jammers happened.. reality intruded and Mig17 with a cannon savaged far more advanced US craft that outnumbered them by orders of magnitude. oops. Drones are even more fun, notice how Iranians took control of one and got in perfect condition. Want to be defending your carrier then realize hmm I dont think we have concat with our toys oops indeed
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:14AM (#6216120)
This is the best comment in this whole thread:

>Modern fighter aircraft need to: a) not be seen b) be fast (time to target is still important!) c) carry a decent payload of weapons. Ideally target selection should be provided by AWACS, and missile-sensors provide the final kill guidance, allowing the fighter (AKA missile-launch platform) to remain stealthy. In the absence of AWACS, the fighter will need to carry it's own sensor suite. Modern air warfare is all about sensors, ECM and stealth. The airframe is almost inconsequential.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by rdtsc on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:02AM (#6216383)
A drone?

Why even bother putting a pilot into a steel tube with wings so it can fly some distance ahead, launch another faster steel tube with fins, then turn back.

The only reason to even have a person in there is for dog-fighting for what I see. Otherwise with specs you described, it is just a pointless waste of money.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:53AM (#6217441)
Because a pilot can control a plane when GPS is down, when jamming prevents remote control from Creech AFB, and because the Mark One eyeball is still pretty good.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by rdtsc on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:23AM (#6217915)
A pilot still uses eyes, gyroscopes and has an understanding of terrain and how to manipulate a flight controls to make the aircraft go a certain way. Presumably all those things can be done by technology, terrain following, and autopilot systems are not new. If jamming detected it can return back to destination. I am sure it can be done for less than $1TN
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:58PM (#6219148)
Return to base automatically didn't work so well for the drone the Iranians managed to capture.

Drones seem sexy and safe, but I'd be very surprised if we didn't keep pilots in the plane for a long time.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by PeterisP on Friday August 16, 2013 @04:26AM (#6222798)
Current visual systems are worse by Mark One eyeball - but they'll get better. At that point, a drone brain can do everything a pilot can, and more.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:20PM (#6218840)
The article isn't about drones vs piloted aircraft, it's about one type of piloted aircraft vs another.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jessaustin on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @06:33PM (#6214813)
How are AWACS defended? Are they too far away for the enemy to engage? Is it possible to stealth a plane that constantly broadcasts radar? Do they have other means of missile/drone defense? I hope that "assume AWACS doesn't get attacked" is not the first assumption in all these war game exercises.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by gchpaco on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:05PM (#6215546)
Attacking an AWACS is very much on the table, it's just hard. It's like being a battleship captain saying "well, if we sink the bloody carrier then the problem's solved, right?"--you're not wrong but you're vastly underestimating the difficulty. AWACS radar is so strong they can be (and should!) very very very far away from anything that could possibly reach out and touch them, and actually attacking an AWACS will draw so much attention and fire that the attack is probably doomed to failure unless the air force in question is enormously overextended (very possible). I suppose you could use it to divert attention while you did something else, but it'll be a costly diversion.

Now if you did get close to one, considering that the popular ones are visibly repurposed airliners they would probably go down pretty easy. But that's a little like saying "I can sink your aircraft carrier with my 16" gun" without the proviso that "... as long as you let me get way too close first".

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jacques_chester on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:43PM (#6215232)
The point being that the radar range of an AWACS vastly exceeds the range of any air-to-air missile in production or under design.

So when you see hostile planes driving towards you, you send some fighters to go and shoot them down.

Meanwhile the AWACS can be supporting air, sea and ground battles happening for hundreds of kilometres in every direction. They really are powerful tools.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by rdtsc on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:05AM (#6216390)
How about disabling it from space. Load a cruise missile onto a satellite and launch?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jacques_chester on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:50AM (#6216492)
Why not railguns? Or laser beams?

The point is to deal with what exists currently and what is likely to exist in the service life of a military system.

You're right though. Space will eventually and inevitably be much more militarised.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by rdtsc on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:33PM (#6219731)
> Why not railguns? Or laser beams?

But at the price of $1T they better be thinking of the future and think about opponents who are also willing to spend around that order of magnitude on defense.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jessaustin on Thursday August 15, 2013 @07:09PM (#6221171)
Well if this tactical situation goes like others have recently, it will more probably be a weird, cheap-ass, out-of-the-box attack that will dominate AWACS like roadside IEDs dominated Hum-vees. I don't know what that will be, but some possibilities are: network or systems hacks, airborne debris dispersal, swarm of cheap drones released inside the fighter shell, etc. The concept of a fighter escort perimeter reminds me of the firewall on a network boundary. That's not defense-in-depth, and by itself it doesn't work too well anymore.

Sure the space-borne laser or railgun is fun, but it's probably not the first thing that the Taliban or their equivalent will attempt. Unless they can find a way to hijack one that we've conveniently installed for them.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by rdtsc on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:51PM (#6222096)
Good point.

Yeah it seems big defense is building for two opponents. Strategic opponents -- basically anyone who has nukes and is not an friend.

Then there is a need to build for guerrilla warfare, roadside bombs, urban combat, target assassinations.

Recently the later seem to matter more. But big and high tech projects will get funding and will do so. Now the system is broken and often the only reason these projects get funded is because there is some defense contractor extending its hand waiting for the next $200M to keep profits up and people employed.

Now it would be interesting to research how to combat or counteract drones? What can someone in a poor country oppressed by a more powerful enemy with drones do to defend against them. Can they be detected easily?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Thursday August 15, 2013 @05:21AM (#6216846)
AWACS in combat historically have had fighter (or interceptor) escorts. Sure, I miss the Phoenix, but even without that, you can usually intercept any threat before it reaches the AWACS.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:47PM (#6214129)
But Vietnam? Don't you think that the US might not eventually have problems when missiles get jammed and drones stolen?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by AsymetricCom on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:10PM (#6213904)
A monumental fuckup of this magnitude makes me wish that this was some kind of smoke screen to cover the cost of some other kind of R&D of technology we can scarcely comprehend. $1,000,000,000,000 for a plane that doesn't work and has been outsourced to a dozen foreign contractors? I don't buy it.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by gchpaco on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:17PM (#6215592)
Are you kidding? My father works in aerospace for firms doing subcontracting on non-black projects and every time he talks about work it would be about some new ridiculous boondoggle. I remember some idiots conducting testing managed to pick up and drop a piece of flight hardware the size of a car about six inches, which probably cost about $100K to realign and repair. The ISS went through I think three or four--or maybe five?--ground up redesigns requiring everybody throw everything they had already done completely out the window and start over. Many of us on the sidelines watching marveled quietly that it ever flew at all.

Small teams with tight deadlines can do wonders. This is why Skunkworks stuck. But it's important to note that Kelly Johnson was behind a lot of the big successes there and he was an amazing man. Absent organizational genius, you can run into trouble. The JSF is pretty much the antithesis of "small teams with tight deadlines".

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mikegagnon on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:04PM (#6213528)
The United States economy is based upon Military Keynesianism.

The federal government does not analyze spending the same way we do because __spending benefits the economy__, which is part of the government's responsibility. They intentionally spend money to stimulate the economy.

So when the military spends $1 trillion on planes, they are really trading $1 trillion for planes plus economic stimulus.

In other words, the planes don't literally cost $1 trillion. Rather the cost of the planes = $1 trillion minus the economic benefit of spending.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_Keynesianism

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jamoes on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:14PM (#6213581)
So, if spending unilaterally stimulates the economy, then why stop at $1 trillion? Why not just spend quadrillions of dollars and really stimulate the economy? The answer is that the there is a very real opportunity cost to their spending. That trillion dollars could have been spend on other infrastructure, or education, or even a more efficient warplane, and all of those expenditures would have resulted in greater value creation.

Hayek originally debunked this line of thinking in the Parable of the Broken Window: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mikegagnon on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:26PM (#6213650)
There is always a debate about how much to spend and what to spend it on. I believe these issues are what primarily distinguish republicans from democrats.

I agree that Military Keynesianism is not the best way for the government to stimulate the economy. That does not change the fact that it is the de facto economic policy of the United States.

Here are some relevant analyses from inside and outside the Pentagon.

- Spinney's "Defense Power Games" http://www.dnipogo.org/fcs/def_power_games_98.htm * Chomsky's -

- "The Pentagon System" http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Chomsky/PentagonSystem_Cho....

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by guscost on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:42PM (#6215226)
Indeed there is a very real opportunity cost to having the government redistribute that trillion regardless.

/libertarian

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by guiomie on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:22PM (#6215823)
Sir, thanks for the link! I feel like I am going to bed more intelligent tonight.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by sshconnection on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:09PM (#6213554)
Not all spending is equal. If they want to pour money into projects, there is plenty of infrastructure that needs to be built here.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by michaelt on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:01PM (#6213851)
Ah, but you forget the myriad other benefits:

1. If you don't believe in globalization, you can legitimately lock out foreign competition and insist on an all-American supply chain, keeping jobs and money in the US.

2. It allows you to bring home the pork. Military contractors have a proven willingness to situate assembly plants to deliver jobs in politically convenient locations.

3. It's compatible with Libertarian/Tea Party beliefs, as military spending tends to get a free pass from the balanced budget brigade.

4. People will call you "a hawk" and "strong on defense" and "supporting our troops". Or at least they won't call you the opposite of those things.

5. Spending on things like DARPA funds cool things like the internet and the DARPA Grand Challenge and robots and things. Pretty sciencey and cool.

6. $60 million in lobbying in 2012 https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/indusclient.php?id=D01&yea... with Boeing, Northrop Grumman and Lockheed Martin all in the top 20 individual donors https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/top.php?indexType=s&showYe...

Compare that to funding boring old schools and bridges and things which have none of these benefits.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by shirederby on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @08:30PM (#6215418)
> 3. It's compatible with Libertarian/Tea Party beliefs, as military spending tends to get a free pass from the balanced budget brigade.

Tea Party, maybe, but not libertarian. Reason, Cato, and the like are highly critical of military spending and very frequently chastise mainstream Republicans for focussing on discretionary and entitlement spending while ignoring the military spending.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mikegagnon on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:29PM (#6213670)
I agree. I think Military Keynesianism is a bad economic policy.

I have seen lots of articles that discuss wasteful DoD spending. But I see very few that discuss __why__ the DoD spends money this way. And why it continues. This type of spending is not a new phenomenon.

To me these "why" questions are the most important and intellectually interesting aspects of these issues. But they are often ignored.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mparr4 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:46PM (#6213042)
> the entire contract should be converted into drone development, which will actually pay dividends

...or, maybe, education?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tsotha on Thursday August 15, 2013 @03:25AM (#6216565)
No. We already spend too much on education. The one thing we've managed to conclusively prove in the last 30 years is you can't improve education by throwing money at it.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by newnewnew on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:59PM (#6213129)
I don't understand. Is education good for killing your enemy? Why would that be the purview of the military?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by lostlogin on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:05AM (#6216392)
Is this a joke? Some basic thought processes would probably have avoided some of the BS that the US has engaged in. Which recent wars have been fought that didn't involved US weapons being used against the US? Long term thinking is required. Less fixation on war, killing, rendering, torturing, interrogating dominating and conquering might, see something productive happen with the vast sums of wasted money and lives. Edit: Words and stuff.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:08PM (#6213186)
To be honest, if the US education stays the same, the military and it's contractors will crash and burn. Education is desperately needed there, or else both engineering and strategic capabilities will soon (1 generation) fall short of usefulness.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mparr4 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @08:40PM (#6215453)
I'd rather not take it as a given that we are going to spend $1T on our nation's next war plane. That it is potentially ineffective further compounds what surely must be a disastrous waste of a considerable portion of our nation's financial resources.

The $3k cost per person of a $1T plane makes me feel inclined to think about what else could be done with that kind of money.

So, while drones might be a "better" way for the military to spend $1T, I think it's worth entertaining the idea that there might be a better way for a nation to spend that money. Like, say, on education.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:00PM (#6213842)
> Is education good for killing your enemy?

Education is good for figuring out how to acheive your goals, including if those goals are "killing your enemy".

> Why would that be the purview of the military?

Because its a substantial force multiplier.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by venomsnake on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:20PM (#6213967)
It's the educated people that make all the fun toys that enable modern warfare.

And a insurgency with smart engineers and chemists will be one hell to contain.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by lostlogin on Thursday August 15, 2013 @03:12AM (#6216534)
I'd go so far as to say that it WAS one hell to contain. That wasn't a dumb insurgency, and I suspect it achieved a fair few of its aims.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tptacek on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:46PM (#6213044)
If your whole argument is that all manned air-ground mission planes should be replaced with drones, it's a stretch to call the parent "absurd". Your comment would be better without its first and last sentences.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by ImprovedSilence on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:12PM (#6213209)
Drones are great, but not failproof. what happens when you command links are taken down? (RF jamming, satellites destroyed, etc) You're gonna need a "human powered" "analog" fallback.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by shabble on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:59PM (#6214215)
I imagine it's not a novel idea, but taking something along the lines of an airliner/AWACS platform and stuffing it full of drone pilots in cubicles and using line-of-sight optical or tightbeam microwave comms direct to your drone herd[1] a few hundred km away would be pretty hard to block. Tightbeam comms also make it a lot harder to find than a radar emitting AWACS, and you can have multiple redundant controllers for your drones to avoid a SPoF if it does get found. Being closer to the action and avoiding satellite uplink means you don't have nearly the same latency issues as current drone controls do.

The increased performance of unmanned vehicles, as well as the cost savings of the whole life-support system (and perhaps, reduced pilot risk = lower training/HR embodied costs as well) seem like they might make such a system practical.

[1] Taking it a step further, you have a central control platform surrounded by defensive drone cloud responsible for point defence, active sensors (which you don't want to do personally since it tells enemies exactly where you are), and mesh/onion routed control links to your offensive drone swarm (so enemies can't infer the controller location from lines of sight intersections to the stuff they can see).

Even even further down the line, distribute the human controllers into the defensive swarm, so they're hard/impossible to distinguish from the "dumb" drones, and less of a Single Big Target worth hitting.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jacques_chester on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:46PM (#6215244)
> Even even further down the line, distribute the human controllers into the defensive swarm, so they're hard/impossible to distinguish from the "dumb" drones, and less of a Single Big Target worth hitting.

You'd look for the larger drones that never pull turns over 8.5g.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:56AM (#6217466)
Jamming doesn't need to always block the source transmitter, you can also block the receivers on the drones by flooding the frequencies, or spoofing GPS, etc etc. At this level though, it's just easier to send up a fighter to shoot the drone down, since most drones are on par with a Cessna 172 in terms of performance.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by shabble on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:50AM (#6217707)
> Jamming doesn't need to always block the source transmitter, you can also block the receivers on the drones by flooding the frequencies, or spoofing GPS, etc etc.

AFAIK it works by lowering the signal/noise ratio to the point the channel is useless for it's intended purpose.

Something with extremely tight focus via aimable directional antenna or phased array, along with spread spectrum hopping would be extremely hard to jam, because you need to get enough energy into the channel to mess with it.

GPS jamming can be countered by a better inertial nav system, and even the tightbeam comms themselves can be used to locate approx positions with enough links.

Regarding combat capabilities, is there any fundamental reason for their relative lack of performance beyond it being unnecessary/risky with high-latency comms? From a quick scan of current costs, you could get >10 Avenger/Predator C drones (~15M ea) for a single F-35 (~200M) or F-22 (~150M).

I suspect (but am utterly unqualified to say) that such an encounter would go badly for the (human) fighter, especially if everyone has modern AMRAAM or similar BVR weapons ("... we only need to be lucky once").

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:56PM (#6219137)
Well, the Avenger/Predator drones can't engage in A2A combat; they lack radar for tracking and targeting another aircraft. They could use an infrared missile like the AIM9, but that is often cued via radar as well. Plus, the Predators maneuver like crap. I don't have the specs at hand, but I think they're g limited to under 3g. A single F-35 would have no trouble defeating 10 Predators.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by EliRivers on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:20PM (#6213251)
Unless you tell the drone beforehand what you want it to do, so it knows what to do when comms go down.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mpyne on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:41PM (#6213733)
Even the military isn't yet on board with the idea of allowing drones to autonomously choose when to kill.

In fact that's one of the big reasons the U.S. requires their pilots to be commissioned officers, is because they have to be cognizant of the laws of war, current Rules of Engagement that are in force, the effect of a given attack on the geopolitical framework, etc. and this has to happen in an environment where they are the only ones with an accurate (or semi-accurate) understanding of the actual picture on-the-ground.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by donavanm on Thursday August 15, 2013 @03:59AM (#6216635)
I do believe its your friendly neighborhood JTAC/ANGLICO/JFO/etc who has the picture "on the ground".
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by stcredzero on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:55PM (#6216069)
By the same token, missiles and stealth are not fail proof either.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by nkuttler on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:29AM (#6211321)
> the biggest use of airplanes [...] is air to land bombing

But what happens to your bombers when you don't have air superiority?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bradleyjg on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:34PM (#6216013)
Check to see if you are in a Tom Clancy novel, because you certainly aren't in any war the US is plausibly going to be involved in. Every country with fighters >= 4.5th generation is locked into either nuclear or economic (or both) MAD with the US.

What would China's economy look like after they decided to launch an invasion of Taiwan?

SEAD, CAS, precision bombing, cargo and personnel transport -- these are missions that our military will actually be called on to perform, not the dogfighting the fighter pilot mafia wishes was needed.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tlear on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:57PM (#6216078)
Successful invasion of Taiwan? Most likely mad boom, total economic and political dominance of Asia would do that. Not to mention internally it would cement the government for a generation or two
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tptacek on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:47PM (#6213054)
Didn't he answer that? The A-10 also turns out to be a useful bit of materiel, but it too relies on other equipment to provide air superiority.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by zobzu on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:59PM (#6214611)
yeah.. the A10 will do well against pure fighters... nope, it won't. i'd rather be in a B2 and avoid the fight. The A10 is not made for the same type of missions thought. it can fight helicopters and ground forces, while avoiding light AA and light air support.

funny how the planes here, like on youtube, are rated by reputation, and not by knowledge, experience, or dare i say, facts.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tptacek on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @08:54PM (#6215510)
His point was that we have different planes for standoff air superiority against serious hostile fighter jets, and (implicitly) than the F-35 can be "good enough" for air-to-air while optimizing for it's air-to-ground mission.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by VLM on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:51AM (#6211453)
A solved problem, you launch cheap cruise missiles until you obtain relative superiority.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by moocowduckquack on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:43PM (#6213024)
Tomahawks work ok against midrange opponents, but I suspect that the Chinese have SAM systems that can knock them out of the sky, given their lack of stealth capabilities and low speed. Given that the Chinese government can hit a satellite from the ground, I think they might be able to target something that is 500mph and radar-visible.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:34AM (#6211711)
Cheap? Hardly. A Tomahawk is far north of $1M a shot, and JASSM is above $1M as well.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by VLM on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:44AM (#6211778)
Yes, dirt cheap. Even if you use Hollywood accounting like "flyaway costs" you can get 100 Tomahawks for the cost of one F-35, and the point of the wargame was you only get roughly one sortie per F-35 unless you have air superiority.

So economically its far cheaper to not build one F-35 while buying 100 Tomahawks, then cruise missile every airfield, than to lose your entire stock of F-35 on one sortie.

Another way to phrase it, is every sortie you can either lose all your F-35, or "lose" one by not buying it and carpet bomb every single enemy .mil airfield minutes before the F-35 sortie. It seems pretty obvious which is cheaper, even before we get into pilot training costs and the long length of the .mil pilot training pipeline, etc.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:42AM (#6212151)
You have to include launcher costs: either an SSGN like the modified Tridents, or the SSNs that carry them. Plus, with an aircraft, you can use it multiple times, and often in unique and unexpected ways. A missile, not so much.

Plus, TLAM isn't expected to be very survivable in a contested environment, especially around S300/S400 sites. That's the impetus for developing the troubled JASSM.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by chiph on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:18PM (#6213604)
The GLCM launchers got treatied away with the Soviets. The transporter/erector/launcher was a 8x8 MAN truck that had good off-road capabilities. Compared to a sub, they're dirt cheap.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:30PM (#6214018)
Yep, the INF treaty gutted them, and that's why we rely exclusively on SSGNs, SSNs, and the B1/B52 for delivery. All of which are extremely expensive. We're also range limited with cruise missiles by the same treaty, though I'm not sure if it's still in force since the dissolution of the USSR.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by stcredzero on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:48PM (#6214138)
The thing to do is to launch 100 Tomahawks so that you can then use stealth aircraft to trash the SAM sites and interceptor aircraft that reveal themselves to shoot them down.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:31AM (#6217368)
The problem is that against a peer opponent with S300 or higher SAM networks, the TLAM will get shot down.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by astrodust on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:35PM (#6212951)
The bombs they drop are not free either, some of the smart munitions cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dkhenry on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:45AM (#6211786)
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:17PM (#6215800)
Once you factor in the entire program cost and logistics footprint, the Tomahawk is the absolute cheapest way the US military has to put a bomb on a specific spot on the map.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by SEJeff on Saturday August 17, 2013 @10:35AM (#6229186)
That's why we fired 1 tomahawk (on average) every 12 seconds for the entire 48 hours of the opening to the war in Afghanistan. It is mind blowing to think how destructive that was
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jzwinck on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:51AM (#6211456)
They hang back while you launch ICBMs?
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by turar on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:10PM (#6213194)
>> however we still have the F-22 as our air superiority fighter which is still believed to be better then anything out there

I'm just going to leave this here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBKvlLzGkvU

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by s_q_b on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:26PM (#6213282)
There's also this:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/11/13/olsen_raptor_case_ge...

And the fact that the F-22's stealth coatings, even if they work, ablate in rain.

http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2012/11/f-35-gets-stealthier...

And of course the ludicrous idea that the F-35 can replace the A-10 Warthog in combat.

http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2012/01/a-10-f-35-air-force-...

The A-10 problem bugs me more than the others. The A-10 is a proven warplane that ground troops count on for cover. The F-35 doesn't have the capability to fulfill its role, which could place our troops in greater danger.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by spartango on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:09PM (#6214288)
It's strange...I love the A-10, both its rugged design and its crazy anti-tank capability. Keep in mind that retirement plans for the beast are slated for 2028, and all plans to retire it sooner have been shot down. That's 52 years of service, which is a solid service lifetime.

But that said, I think there's a decent argument that can be made for phasing it out given current operational needs:

The A-10 was originally designed in the Vietnam-era as a close air support(CAS) aircraft for conventional wars, armed with a payload of unguided bombs and shells to destroy tanks.

Helicopters at the time couldn't carry these types of anti-armor heavy weapons, and strike aircraft like the A-1, A-6, and F-4 couldn't survive anti-aircraft fire at low enough altitudes to put their bombs on target. In CAS roles, missing the target meant killing friendlies, obviously unacceptable.

Thus, the A-10 was built like a beast so that it could survive SAM/AAA fire at the low-altitudes needed to deploy these weapons accurately.

Over time, however, CAS munitions have evolved with guidance, from missiles like the AGM-65 and Hellfire, to laser-guided (GBU-27) and GPS-guided (JDAM) bombs. These have longer ranges and thus don't require the carrier aircraft to be nearly as survivable. The A-10s resistance to AAA and small arms fire seems less relevant.

This suggests that the A-10 may be less necessary for strike roles, even if it carries them out admirably.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by SEJeff on Saturday August 17, 2013 @10:45AM (#6229207)
You know, I was a UAV pilot (look up shadow 200 3rd Stryker brigade combat team, second infantry division) an targeted for many A10 strike missions around Tall'Afar, Mosul, and Samarrah in Iraq around '03-04. The A10 was fantastic for taking out large weapons caches or convoys. Sure it can take out tanks and such, so why not keep them around. I speak from experience that in today's insurgent and less conventional warfare, I'd rather target for an A10 than a Harrier. Besides, it is hard to beat the sound of that main gun firing. Nothing like it in the entire us military.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Thursday August 15, 2013 @05:26AM (#6216853)
It will be necessary when vietnam happens all over again because of jamming and we need 'analog' weapons.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by VladRussian2 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:00PM (#6213841)
>The A-10 problem bugs me more than the others. The A-10 is a proven warplane that ground troops count on for cover. The F-35 doesn't have the capability to fulfill its role, which could place our troops in greater danger.

It is hard to beat A-10 in its role, instead i think something new will be developed on the edge of its envelope, specifically on the low end - big RC planes (mid-size VTOL drones carry-able by one Hummer) with Hellfires/etc controlled by the troops who need the cover - that would provide more prompt (though less powerful) air support than calling in for big guys help and waiting for it to appear.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jfb on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:49PM (#6215683)
It's hard to envision a conflict where the A-10's advantages over the F-35 are dispositive, given that there aren't divisions of Warsaw Pact T80s massed on the German border any more.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by zobzu on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:54PM (#6214577)
its not like if the F22 didn't have supermanoeuvrability - it does. but then again, when was the last important dog fight ? yea..
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by caycep on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:45AM (#6211425)
That's pretty worrisome considering the costs of a F-22, as well as the costs of an F-35 vs. a Hornet (which can outperform it apparently). From it's specs, it's a terrible bomber compared with the A-6's...

Compromised designs are compromised designs.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:26AM (#6211657)
I love the Intruder, but it simply wouldn't survive in today's environment, especially against S300 etc. It was relatively slow, had a huge radar profile, and was pretty much a single role aircraft. It did pack a huge wallop though, and had great range.

What's really sad is comparing the capabilities of today's carrier airwing with what was available in 1991. Then you had F-14D, F/A-18C, S3, A-6. A great array of aircraft that had the range to take the fight to the enemy.

Now you have the F/A-18E, F/A-18C, and that's it. No S3 for ASW, no long ranged tactical bomber, an "interceptor" that has short legs, and you've also given up your KA-6D for inflight refueling, relying on buddy tanks off the already shortlegged F-18.

sigh...

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by thufry on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @08:33PM (#6215429)
Here's the reason that nobody likes to say: at some point, we're going to have a war with China, and then we'll need air superiority.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by est on Thursday August 15, 2013 @03:43AM (#6216603)
You should have war with your congress, an entity which borrows money from China and make monopoly crap.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by krichman on Thursday August 15, 2013 @04:39AM (#6216745)
Seriously, the US government is a larger thread to US citizens than China is.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:27AM (#6211307)
Won't the air to ground bombing mission be done mostly by drones? Manned aircraft will be increasingly reserved for special operations and dirty little wars, which is pretty much the Marines' job description.

Also, the vertical takeoff capability will be mandatory for a hypothetical future war against a major power. Once the huge, lumbering aircraft carriers are sitting on the sea floor, they will be replaced by heavily armored battleships. In a major war, the only sea launched aircraft will be VTOLs.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mehwoot on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:46AM (#6211428)
> Once the huge, lumbering aircraft carriers are sitting on the sea floor, they will be replaced by heavily armored battleships. In a major war, the only sea launched aircraft will be VTOLs.

Huh... there isn't a single battleship in service in any navy in the world.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battleship#Modern_times

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by newbie12 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:00AM (#6211511)
When the carriers are sunk, it is our submarine fleet with its cruise missiles that will carry the day.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Symmetry on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:39PM (#6214076)
Though modern cruisers and destroyers aren't that much smaller than the dreadnoughts that fought at Jutland, 14,000 tons vs 18,000 tons.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by spartango on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:24PM (#6214391)
Most modern cruisers or destroyers aren't over 10,000 tons fully loaded, and are thus comparable to the light cruisers of WWII. The Dreadnoughts were a fair bit bigger (2x at ~20,000 loaded), but indeed were not nearly as heavily armored as the WWII battleships of 30 years later. A loaded Iowa-class battleship displaced nearly 60,000 tons.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:09AM (#6211564)
There will be in a major war. Nothing else can stand up to nukes and lasers.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by moocowduckquack on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:52PM (#6213083)
The only way a battleship would help against nukes is if it somehow fell on whoever is in charge of the nukes.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:11AM (#6216110)
Battleships can survive close hits by airburst nukes. To defend against this, the opponent must either use massive overkill, or use underwater bursts near their own coasts. Either approach has dreadful economic costs.

War is the art of making the opponent's costs exceed their resources. One way to create costs is to make weapons that are unreasonably durable—the battleship is the extreme end of the spectrum.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by moocowduckquack on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:49AM (#6216229)
There was an airburst test that battleships survived, but the nuke was way off target, even well shielded animals onboard died so if it was crewed it would have been a floating coffin and the nuke was a 20 kiloton device. One single Trident missile holds up to twelve 500 kiloton bombs.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:36PM (#6221029)
1940s battleships were designed for just enough shielding from chemical bombs and bullets. We can assume that future battleships will have comprehensive radiation shielding. Of course, building a fleet to soften up the Chinese coast is more an exercise in science fiction than military planning.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:44PM (#6221072)
> 1940s battleships were designed for just enough shielding from chemical bombs and bullets. We can assume that future battleships will have comprehensive radiation shielding.

We would do better to assume that future battleships won't get built, and that future surface combatants for the foreseeable future will be all carriers and destroyers.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by lmg643 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:39AM (#6211387)
Agree on drones and unmanned aircraft. Manned combat planes are going to be the cavalry of war in a few years (if not already) for the simple fact that a pilot cannot withstand the g-forces that an unmanned plane or missile can.

US hasn't realized this yet because we are currently using our military might to pick on folks who are decades if not a century or more behind us technologically but would likely be a different story against a more up to date competitor.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Nelson69 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:30AM (#6211685)
Has it not been realized? I think it has, there is a ton of drone stuff going on. The DoD hasn't rewritten the war fighting manual and strategy yet though so manned fighters and bombers are still part of the plans but I don't think UAVs haven't proven themselves. This is a titanically slow moving organization... lives and deaths are on the line with their decisions.

One of the real lesson of the JSF is the amount of institutional inertia surrounding it. We were effectively pot committed before they had demo planes to play war games with. They spent 10+ years selling the idea. How do you kill a project like that? There is a certain irony to how the US picks weapons platforms too, everybody wants a new toy so who says "no" when the toy isn't quite up to snuff? So politically, we kill all the things the JSF is going to replace, we build love for the new platform, promise the world when nobody has even seen it.

The whole "jump jet" fascination is an interesting one, why do you need to land or take off a fighter/bomber from a place where you can't fuel it, can't reload it, and it doesn't carry cargo and people? Now the concept is cool, I get that, I just don't see where it fits in to the war fighting plan in a general way, not until planes have like nuclear reactors for fuel or something like that. It just doesn't seem generally useful.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Spooky23 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:53PM (#6212636)
The Marines have "amphibious assault ships" that are sort of like aircraft carriers for helicopters. S/VTOL aircraft can operate from these locations.

I was told by a Marine that the Harrier obsession stems from Guadalcanal in WW2. The waters in the Solomons were heavily contested and the Navy basically took off and left the Marines stranded. That institutional memory is hard to shake.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:06PM (#6213880)
> The Marines have "amphibious assault ships" that are sort of like aircraft carriers for helicopters.

There actually very much like medium-deck carriers, which are the biggest carriers anyone not the US Navy operates anywhere. The Marines seaborne aviation capacity carried on its various amphibious ships outclasses, IIRC, all the non-US naval aviation in the world combined.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by spartango on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:30PM (#6214424)
Further, the next generation of Littoral Combat Ships (LCS, Freedom- and Independence-class) have large enough "flight decks" that drones and other small aircraft can be launched from them.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by whatusername on Thursday August 15, 2013 @01:56AM (#6216367)
The OP has quite a large section on S/VTOL and Guadalcanal.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:24PM (#6213273)
+1 on the amphibious assault ships. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_carrier Also, corvettes and the like can rearm and refuel the helicopters they carry.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by ImprovedSilence on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:16PM (#6213229)
Drones are great, but their control systems are ridiculously easy to take down. What happens when you command links are taken down? (RF jamming, satellites destroyed, etc) You're gonna need a "human powered" "analog" fallback.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by PeterisP on Friday August 16, 2013 @04:24AM (#6222792)
When command links are taken down, you're gonna need autonomous drones, not humans. The resistance for autonomous killers is political/ethical, not technical - so as soon as they're really needed (i.e., a single serious combat incident with command links failing), they'll get a chip upgrade to continue combat themselves in case of comms breakdown.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jzwinck on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:58AM (#6211501)
One punchline at the end of the article seems to implicitly agree on drones:

> Ward said any future warplane should have clear and narrow requirements, as opposed to the F-35's broad, incompatible guidelines. Development timelines should be fast, budgets should be inexpensive, the overall concept should be simple and hardware should be as tiny as possible.

The one way we have today to accomplish all those goals together is unmanned aircraft. Simple because no life safety systems. Tiny because no human factors (displays, radios, windscreens). Cheap because no need to get every plane home safe (mission success largely determined by delivery of sufficient quantity of planes to the theatre).

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Spooky23 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:59PM (#6212696)
I'd argue that most of the truly successful military aircraft in the US inventory started out as single-purpose aircraft. The F-4 and F-15 were pure fighters. The F-117 and A-10 were pure attack aircraft.

The political process drives the insanity of trying to serve multiple purposes with thousands of design engineers strategically located in as many Congressional districts as possible.

I think drones should be used for every application that they are appropriate for -- why put people on the line when computers can do the work? But just like the JSF project attempted to serve many masters, assuming drones are the optimal decision for all military aircraft requirements is dumb.

The Chinese and Russians are building high performance aircraft for less than $1 Trillion. There's a reason for that. We can too.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by caycep on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:07AM (#6211546)
Also, not glamorous enough to attract the attention of Important People in the Pentagon...that's the most important requirement. Let the Designers work in peace!
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by caycep on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:57AM (#6211485)
I think there is what the Pentagon "wants" to do, and what will naturally evolve despite whatever direction they throw their money.

Drones will probably get good enough to do most air to ground, at 1/10 or 1/100th the cost or whatever figure is being thrown around. Maybe even air-air, although I don't really think anyone has seriously tried this yet.

Manned aircraft in the meanwhile will pad a a large number of Pentagon manager's retirements and kid's college educations...

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:06AM (#6211540)
People have been saying the demise of the carrier is upon us for 5 decades. Yet nothing offers the flexibility and power projection capabilities of a CVBG. And guess what submariners call "heavily armored battleships?" Targets...

And if you think CVNs are expensive, you should research how much retrofitting an Iowa Class with a STOVL flight deck would cost. And then factor in manning costs for a ship that needs close to 5000 sailors.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by JackFr on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:42PM (#6213009)
And when (if?) energy weapons and railguns become a reality, all of a sudden a 100MW reactor is not a bad thing to have.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by antubbs on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:33AM (#6211350)
Gotta be careful about history; when the F-35 program started, drone-based warfare was pretty infantile.

Drone payloads are still relatively light compared to heavily-laden fighter-bombers (or indeed outright bombers). This will likely evolve over time (the future bomber program requires both manned and unmanned capabilities in some proposals).

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Zimahl on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:30PM (#6212920)
Even if we were to face China in a war, we'd own the seas. Once their one (maybe two by now) carrier is sunk, even assuming they sink one of ours, we just bring in one of the other 12.

I know people fear China but they are no cold-war Russia. Anything conventional and the US is in the lead by a lot. There's no reason to discuss anything nuclear because everyone loses in that case.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dctoedt on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:43PM (#6213022)
> Even if we were to face China in a war, we'd own the seas. Once their one (maybe two by now) carrier is sunk, even assuming they sink one of ours, we just bring in one of the other 12.

There have been reports that the Chinese have developed and brought to initial operational status the DF-21D, a medium-range, hypersonic, anti-ship ballistic missile specifically designed to be a carrier-killer [1]. The concern is that our carriers might be chased from the Western Pacific.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D_.28CSS-5_Mod-4.29_... -- also http://thediplomat.com/flashpoints-blog/2013/06/12/why-china...

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mpyne on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:49PM (#6213781)
Maybe there's something I'm missing about the DF-21D, but even assuming it doesn't miss the carrier while traveling at a hypersonic speed, Big Explody Things dropping on top of American carriers during wartime is not exactly a new thing in the annals of warfare.

It's one of the reason that warships in general (including carriers) are designed to be compartmentalized, to have redundant backups (and backups to the backups), etc., is because it is expected they might have to survive battle damage.

Obviously an ASBM may change the calculus of whether you send carriers in early in the conflict (preferring instead to use submarines with cruise missiles to take out Dong Feng launch sites or whatever you'd have been trying to bomb in the first place). But I don't see how ASBM is a guaranteed single-shot carrier kill by any stretch either.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dctoedt on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:22PM (#6213976)
> It's one of the reason that warships in general (including carriers) are designed to be compartmentalized, to have redundant backups (and backups to the backups), etc., is because it is expected they might have to survive battle damage.

For a carrier, not-sinking != operational. The flight deck, catapults, and arresting gear are necessarily exposed to anything that explodes above them. Take them out and the carrier is basically useless.

A carrier can be severely damaged or even sunk by just a few comparatively-small bombs if they're well-placed, intentionally or fortuitously. This was vividly demonstrated at the Battle of Midway in June 1942 [1], where four Japanese carriers and one American carrier were sunk. (It only took one U.S. bomb to sink the unfortunate Akagi.)

In January 1969 my former ship, the USS Enterprise, was taken out of action for several weeks by an accidental fire on the flight deck that cooked off ordinance, spread, and killed 27 sailors [2]. (It was before my time there.)

I would imagine that a ground-launched ballistic missile could carry a much bigger payload than I've been talking about. But yes, it'd be no small navigational challenge to make sure an ASBM actually got to the (moving) target and past the last-ditch defenses.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Midway#Attacks_on_the...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Enterprise_(CVN-65)#Vietnam...

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mpyne on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:28PM (#6214007)
You're certainly right WRT OOC vs. sunk.

However USS Yorktown was "taken out of the action" a couple of times in WWII and still put back into the fight and playing very important roles in that fight, before eventually being sunk by a Japanese submarine. So it's definitely fair to say that simply damaging a carrier is not nearly as catastrophic as sinking one.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bdunbar on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:07PM (#6215026)
> So it's definitely fair to say that simply damaging a carrier is not nearly as catastrophic as sinking one.

It is fair to say that the situations are not equal.

If the carrier can't fight, it's out of the battle until it's fixed. Fixable don't count if the war is over in weeks, or months.

Fixing a modern carrier might can take a while.

Yorktown was not a complex warship. She takes a hit on the deck. Patch up the holes in her deck (I'm simplifying) and she's back in business.

Hit Ford in the same location and you damage catapults, arresting gear. Ford is out of the war until she is fixed and this will not happen soon. How long to replace a catapult: I'd guess months at best. Where do they even keep the spares?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jeltz on Saturday August 17, 2013 @09:27PM (#6231184)
Quote from the linked Wikipedia article: "United States Naval Institute in 2009 stated that such a warhead would be large enough to destroy an aircraft carrier in one hit and that there was "currently ... no defense against it" if it worked as theorized.".
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:40PM (#6214084)
10. That's all we have, not twelve, and definitely not the 15 we had at the height of the Cold War. The problem is that we don't have twelve carriers that can function all at once. Some are being refueled, some are returning from a deployment, some are doing training workups prior to deployment, and there's a lot of ocean out there. That's why talk of cutting the # of CVNs to under the current totals is extremely dangerous. The way to look at it is for each carrier you have deployed, you need two more. So we currently have four carriers deployed, for ready to surge if needed, and three unavailable for maintenance reasons. And it's not as if a carrier can transit from its homeport to the far side of the ocean quickly...
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by takluyver on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:43PM (#6214492)
The rest of the world put together has 9 active carriers, all smaller than any of the US carriers. That's including the Chinese one, which they're still practising flying from, and the UK one, which doesn't have any aircraft until our JSFs turn up in a few years. Besides the US, only the French have an active nuclear powered carrier. So I don't really agree that discussion of reducing the number of US carriers is "extremely dangerous".
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:27AM (#6217353)
And the rest of the world hasn't taken on the obligations that the US has.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by myko on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:04PM (#6214999)
There are two types of ships in the Navy: submarines, and targets.

How is a carrier going to protect itself from coordinated submarine attacks?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tlear on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:26AM (#6216153)
You need to find the carrier first, ocean is a huge place. If you found and got close you do not need to coordinate single sub will do the job. But getting that sub there is non-trivial. You could ambush the carrier as it transits a straight but that will only work as open strike at the start of the war
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by JackFr on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:38PM (#6212987)
Aircraft carriers on the sea floor? Not if they're refitted with megawatt lasers, railguns, UAVs and USVs.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:19AM (#6216134)
Sea mines and stealth torpedos are still hard to defend against with anything besides a very thick hull. At that point it is a battleship.