Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo...
by SEJeff on Saturday August 17, 2013 @10:45AM
(#6229207)
You know, I was a UAV pilot (look up shadow 200 3rd Stryker brigade combat team, second infantry division) an targeted for many A10 strike missions around Tall'Afar, Mosul, and Samarrah in Iraq around '03-04. The A10 was fantastic for taking out large weapons caches or convoys. Sure it can take out tanks and such, so why not keep them around. I speak from experience that in today's insurgent and less conventional warfare, I'd rather target for an A10 than a Harrier. Besides, it is hard to beat the sound of that main gun firing. Nothing like it in the entire us military.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo...
by TsiCClawOfLight on Thursday August 15, 2013 @05:26AM
(#6216853)
It will be necessary when vietnam happens all over again because of jamming and we need 'analog' weapons.
But that said, I think there's a decent argument that can be made for phasing it out given current operational needs:
The A-10 was originally designed in the Vietnam-era as a close air support(CAS) aircraft for conventional wars, armed with a payload of unguided bombs and shells to destroy tanks.
Helicopters at the time couldn't carry these types of anti-armor heavy weapons, and strike aircraft like the A-1, A-6, and F-4 couldn't survive anti-aircraft fire at low enough altitudes to put their bombs on target. In CAS roles, missing the target meant killing friendlies, obviously unacceptable.
Thus, the A-10 was built like a beast so that it could survive SAM/AAA fire at the low-altitudes needed to deploy these weapons accurately.
Over time, however, CAS munitions have evolved with guidance, from missiles like the AGM-65 and Hellfire, to laser-guided (GBU-27) and GPS-guided (JDAM) bombs. These have longer ranges and thus don't require the carrier aircraft to be nearly as survivable. The A-10s resistance to AAA and small arms fire seems less relevant.
This suggests that the A-10 may be less necessary for strike roles, even if it carries them out admirably.