News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:27AM (#6211307)
Won't the air to ground bombing mission be done mostly by drones? Manned aircraft will be increasingly reserved for special operations and dirty little wars, which is pretty much the Marines' job description.

Also, the vertical takeoff capability will be mandatory for a hypothetical future war against a major power. Once the huge, lumbering aircraft carriers are sitting on the sea floor, they will be replaced by heavily armored battleships. In a major war, the only sea launched aircraft will be VTOLs.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mehwoot on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:46AM (#6211428)
> Once the huge, lumbering aircraft carriers are sitting on the sea floor, they will be replaced by heavily armored battleships. In a major war, the only sea launched aircraft will be VTOLs.

Huh... there isn't a single battleship in service in any navy in the world.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battleship#Modern_times

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by newbie12 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:00AM (#6211511)
When the carriers are sunk, it is our submarine fleet with its cruise missiles that will carry the day.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Symmetry on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:39PM (#6214076)
Though modern cruisers and destroyers aren't that much smaller than the dreadnoughts that fought at Jutland, 14,000 tons vs 18,000 tons.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by spartango on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:24PM (#6214391)
Most modern cruisers or destroyers aren't over 10,000 tons fully loaded, and are thus comparable to the light cruisers of WWII. The Dreadnoughts were a fair bit bigger (2x at ~20,000 loaded), but indeed were not nearly as heavily armored as the WWII battleships of 30 years later. A loaded Iowa-class battleship displaced nearly 60,000 tons.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:09AM (#6211564)
There will be in a major war. Nothing else can stand up to nukes and lasers.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by moocowduckquack on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:52PM (#6213083)
The only way a battleship would help against nukes is if it somehow fell on whoever is in charge of the nukes.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:11AM (#6216110)
Battleships can survive close hits by airburst nukes. To defend against this, the opponent must either use massive overkill, or use underwater bursts near their own coasts. Either approach has dreadful economic costs.

War is the art of making the opponent's costs exceed their resources. One way to create costs is to make weapons that are unreasonably durable—the battleship is the extreme end of the spectrum.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by moocowduckquack on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:49AM (#6216229)
There was an airburst test that battleships survived, but the nuke was way off target, even well shielded animals onboard died so if it was crewed it would have been a floating coffin and the nuke was a 20 kiloton device. One single Trident missile holds up to twelve 500 kiloton bombs.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:36PM (#6221029)
1940s battleships were designed for just enough shielding from chemical bombs and bullets. We can assume that future battleships will have comprehensive radiation shielding. Of course, building a fleet to soften up the Chinese coast is more an exercise in science fiction than military planning.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:44PM (#6221072)
> 1940s battleships were designed for just enough shielding from chemical bombs and bullets. We can assume that future battleships will have comprehensive radiation shielding.

We would do better to assume that future battleships won't get built, and that future surface combatants for the foreseeable future will be all carriers and destroyers.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by lmg643 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:39AM (#6211387)
Agree on drones and unmanned aircraft. Manned combat planes are going to be the cavalry of war in a few years (if not already) for the simple fact that a pilot cannot withstand the g-forces that an unmanned plane or missile can.

US hasn't realized this yet because we are currently using our military might to pick on folks who are decades if not a century or more behind us technologically but would likely be a different story against a more up to date competitor.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Nelson69 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:30AM (#6211685)
Has it not been realized? I think it has, there is a ton of drone stuff going on. The DoD hasn't rewritten the war fighting manual and strategy yet though so manned fighters and bombers are still part of the plans but I don't think UAVs haven't proven themselves. This is a titanically slow moving organization... lives and deaths are on the line with their decisions.

One of the real lesson of the JSF is the amount of institutional inertia surrounding it. We were effectively pot committed before they had demo planes to play war games with. They spent 10+ years selling the idea. How do you kill a project like that? There is a certain irony to how the US picks weapons platforms too, everybody wants a new toy so who says "no" when the toy isn't quite up to snuff? So politically, we kill all the things the JSF is going to replace, we build love for the new platform, promise the world when nobody has even seen it.

The whole "jump jet" fascination is an interesting one, why do you need to land or take off a fighter/bomber from a place where you can't fuel it, can't reload it, and it doesn't carry cargo and people? Now the concept is cool, I get that, I just don't see where it fits in to the war fighting plan in a general way, not until planes have like nuclear reactors for fuel or something like that. It just doesn't seem generally useful.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Spooky23 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:53PM (#6212636)
The Marines have "amphibious assault ships" that are sort of like aircraft carriers for helicopters. S/VTOL aircraft can operate from these locations.

I was told by a Marine that the Harrier obsession stems from Guadalcanal in WW2. The waters in the Solomons were heavily contested and the Navy basically took off and left the Marines stranded. That institutional memory is hard to shake.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:06PM (#6213880)
> The Marines have "amphibious assault ships" that are sort of like aircraft carriers for helicopters.

There actually very much like medium-deck carriers, which are the biggest carriers anyone not the US Navy operates anywhere. The Marines seaborne aviation capacity carried on its various amphibious ships outclasses, IIRC, all the non-US naval aviation in the world combined.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by spartango on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:30PM (#6214424)
Further, the next generation of Littoral Combat Ships (LCS, Freedom- and Independence-class) have large enough "flight decks" that drones and other small aircraft can be launched from them.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by whatusername on Thursday August 15, 2013 @01:56AM (#6216367)
The OP has quite a large section on S/VTOL and Guadalcanal.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by TsiCClawOfLight on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:24PM (#6213273)
+1 on the amphibious assault ships. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_carrier Also, corvettes and the like can rearm and refuel the helicopters they carry.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by ImprovedSilence on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:16PM (#6213229)
Drones are great, but their control systems are ridiculously easy to take down. What happens when you command links are taken down? (RF jamming, satellites destroyed, etc) You're gonna need a "human powered" "analog" fallback.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by PeterisP on Friday August 16, 2013 @04:24AM (#6222792)
When command links are taken down, you're gonna need autonomous drones, not humans. The resistance for autonomous killers is political/ethical, not technical - so as soon as they're really needed (i.e., a single serious combat incident with command links failing), they'll get a chip upgrade to continue combat themselves in case of comms breakdown.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jzwinck on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:58AM (#6211501)
One punchline at the end of the article seems to implicitly agree on drones:

> Ward said any future warplane should have clear and narrow requirements, as opposed to the F-35's broad, incompatible guidelines. Development timelines should be fast, budgets should be inexpensive, the overall concept should be simple and hardware should be as tiny as possible.

The one way we have today to accomplish all those goals together is unmanned aircraft. Simple because no life safety systems. Tiny because no human factors (displays, radios, windscreens). Cheap because no need to get every plane home safe (mission success largely determined by delivery of sufficient quantity of planes to the theatre).

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Spooky23 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:59PM (#6212696)
I'd argue that most of the truly successful military aircraft in the US inventory started out as single-purpose aircraft. The F-4 and F-15 were pure fighters. The F-117 and A-10 were pure attack aircraft.

The political process drives the insanity of trying to serve multiple purposes with thousands of design engineers strategically located in as many Congressional districts as possible.

I think drones should be used for every application that they are appropriate for -- why put people on the line when computers can do the work? But just like the JSF project attempted to serve many masters, assuming drones are the optimal decision for all military aircraft requirements is dumb.

The Chinese and Russians are building high performance aircraft for less than $1 Trillion. There's a reason for that. We can too.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by caycep on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:07AM (#6211546)
Also, not glamorous enough to attract the attention of Important People in the Pentagon...that's the most important requirement. Let the Designers work in peace!
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by caycep on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:57AM (#6211485)
I think there is what the Pentagon "wants" to do, and what will naturally evolve despite whatever direction they throw their money.

Drones will probably get good enough to do most air to ground, at 1/10 or 1/100th the cost or whatever figure is being thrown around. Maybe even air-air, although I don't really think anyone has seriously tried this yet.

Manned aircraft in the meanwhile will pad a a large number of Pentagon manager's retirements and kid's college educations...

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:06AM (#6211540)
People have been saying the demise of the carrier is upon us for 5 decades. Yet nothing offers the flexibility and power projection capabilities of a CVBG. And guess what submariners call "heavily armored battleships?" Targets...

And if you think CVNs are expensive, you should research how much retrofitting an Iowa Class with a STOVL flight deck would cost. And then factor in manning costs for a ship that needs close to 5000 sailors.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by JackFr on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:42PM (#6213009)
And when (if?) energy weapons and railguns become a reality, all of a sudden a 100MW reactor is not a bad thing to have.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by antubbs on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:33AM (#6211350)
Gotta be careful about history; when the F-35 program started, drone-based warfare was pretty infantile.

Drone payloads are still relatively light compared to heavily-laden fighter-bombers (or indeed outright bombers). This will likely evolve over time (the future bomber program requires both manned and unmanned capabilities in some proposals).

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Zimahl on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:30PM (#6212920)
Even if we were to face China in a war, we'd own the seas. Once their one (maybe two by now) carrier is sunk, even assuming they sink one of ours, we just bring in one of the other 12.

I know people fear China but they are no cold-war Russia. Anything conventional and the US is in the lead by a lot. There's no reason to discuss anything nuclear because everyone loses in that case.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dctoedt on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:43PM (#6213022)
> Even if we were to face China in a war, we'd own the seas. Once their one (maybe two by now) carrier is sunk, even assuming they sink one of ours, we just bring in one of the other 12.

There have been reports that the Chinese have developed and brought to initial operational status the DF-21D, a medium-range, hypersonic, anti-ship ballistic missile specifically designed to be a carrier-killer [1]. The concern is that our carriers might be chased from the Western Pacific.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D_.28CSS-5_Mod-4.29_... -- also http://thediplomat.com/flashpoints-blog/2013/06/12/why-china...

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mpyne on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:49PM (#6213781)
Maybe there's something I'm missing about the DF-21D, but even assuming it doesn't miss the carrier while traveling at a hypersonic speed, Big Explody Things dropping on top of American carriers during wartime is not exactly a new thing in the annals of warfare.

It's one of the reason that warships in general (including carriers) are designed to be compartmentalized, to have redundant backups (and backups to the backups), etc., is because it is expected they might have to survive battle damage.

Obviously an ASBM may change the calculus of whether you send carriers in early in the conflict (preferring instead to use submarines with cruise missiles to take out Dong Feng launch sites or whatever you'd have been trying to bomb in the first place). But I don't see how ASBM is a guaranteed single-shot carrier kill by any stretch either.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by dctoedt on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:22PM (#6213976)
> It's one of the reason that warships in general (including carriers) are designed to be compartmentalized, to have redundant backups (and backups to the backups), etc., is because it is expected they might have to survive battle damage.

For a carrier, not-sinking != operational. The flight deck, catapults, and arresting gear are necessarily exposed to anything that explodes above them. Take them out and the carrier is basically useless.

A carrier can be severely damaged or even sunk by just a few comparatively-small bombs if they're well-placed, intentionally or fortuitously. This was vividly demonstrated at the Battle of Midway in June 1942 [1], where four Japanese carriers and one American carrier were sunk. (It only took one U.S. bomb to sink the unfortunate Akagi.)

In January 1969 my former ship, the USS Enterprise, was taken out of action for several weeks by an accidental fire on the flight deck that cooked off ordinance, spread, and killed 27 sailors [2]. (It was before my time there.)

I would imagine that a ground-launched ballistic missile could carry a much bigger payload than I've been talking about. But yes, it'd be no small navigational challenge to make sure an ASBM actually got to the (moving) target and past the last-ditch defenses.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Midway#Attacks_on_the...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Enterprise_(CVN-65)#Vietnam...

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by mpyne on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:28PM (#6214007)
You're certainly right WRT OOC vs. sunk.

However USS Yorktown was "taken out of the action" a couple of times in WWII and still put back into the fight and playing very important roles in that fight, before eventually being sunk by a Japanese submarine. So it's definitely fair to say that simply damaging a carrier is not nearly as catastrophic as sinking one.

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by bdunbar on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:07PM (#6215026)
> So it's definitely fair to say that simply damaging a carrier is not nearly as catastrophic as sinking one.

It is fair to say that the situations are not equal.

If the carrier can't fight, it's out of the battle until it's fixed. Fixable don't count if the war is over in weeks, or months.

Fixing a modern carrier might can take a while.

Yorktown was not a complex warship. She takes a hit on the deck. Patch up the holes in her deck (I'm simplifying) and she's back in business.

Hit Ford in the same location and you damage catapults, arresting gear. Ford is out of the war until she is fixed and this will not happen soon. How long to replace a catapult: I'd guess months at best. Where do they even keep the spares?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by jeltz on Saturday August 17, 2013 @09:27PM (#6231184)
Quote from the linked Wikipedia article: "United States Naval Institute in 2009 stated that such a warhead would be large enough to destroy an aircraft carrier in one hit and that there was "currently ... no defense against it" if it worked as theorized.".
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:40PM (#6214084)
10. That's all we have, not twelve, and definitely not the 15 we had at the height of the Cold War. The problem is that we don't have twelve carriers that can function all at once. Some are being refueled, some are returning from a deployment, some are doing training workups prior to deployment, and there's a lot of ocean out there. That's why talk of cutting the # of CVNs to under the current totals is extremely dangerous. The way to look at it is for each carrier you have deployed, you need two more. So we currently have four carriers deployed, for ready to surge if needed, and three unavailable for maintenance reasons. And it's not as if a carrier can transit from its homeport to the far side of the ocean quickly...
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by takluyver on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:43PM (#6214492)
The rest of the world put together has 9 active carriers, all smaller than any of the US carriers. That's including the Chinese one, which they're still practising flying from, and the UK one, which doesn't have any aircraft until our JSFs turn up in a few years. Besides the US, only the French have an active nuclear powered carrier. So I don't really agree that discussion of reducing the number of US carriers is "extremely dangerous".
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by greedo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:27AM (#6217353)
And the rest of the world hasn't taken on the obligations that the US has.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by myko on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:04PM (#6214999)
There are two types of ships in the Navy: submarines, and targets.

How is a carrier going to protect itself from coordinated submarine attacks?

Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by tlear on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:26AM (#6216153)
You need to find the carrier first, ocean is a huge place. If you found and got close you do not need to coordinate single sub will do the job. But getting that sub there is non-trivial. You could ambush the carrier as it transits a straight but that will only work as open strike at the start of the war
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by JackFr on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:38PM (#6212987)
Aircraft carriers on the sea floor? Not if they're refitted with megawatt lasers, railguns, UAVs and USVs.
Re:How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Wo... by Daniel_Newby on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:19AM (#6216134)
Sea mines and stealth torpedos are still hard to defend against with anything besides a very thick hull. At that point it is a battleship.