217.197.84.140 codeberg.org
2a0a:4580:103f:c0de::1 codeberg.orgThis is so crazy.
How are high-availability services supposed to block this failure mode? Become your own registrar?
Their targeted harassment/doxxing drove many good people to suicide themselves (e.g. byuu emulator developer from Bsnes/Near fame).
Basically, he just held a mirror (his thread) against himself, realized that what he saw was extremely embarassing, and took his life, instead of working on himself to improve what he saw.
I don't mean to be facetious, but cheap domain registrars don't have enough margin to have decent abuse departments.
Last I heard, there was a ~$10k/year minimum spend, but that was a good few years back
I'm not sure what this will demonstrate, but it is undeniably this sub-thread's destiny.
Capital drawdowns might be from grants.
I suppose the gap is that there are domain providers between namesilo and Markmonitor.
Is this something specific to the `.org` domains? I don't think you can "suspend" a `.com`?
Not sure why people are acting surprised about this. This seems like an extremely obvious thing that would be in place...
(The hilarious part is Namesilo doesn't even action valid malware abuse reports I send them but apparently does for codeberg, which is a legitimate service? Figures. Maybe I will submit that ICANN complaint after all.)
They are required to suspend for example if the contact details are invalid. Not saying it is the case here.
https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/registration-data-accu...
Oh you can suspend and destroy anything – not limited to domain names. The important part is – can someone stop you, or can someone prosecute you by virtue of you being from certain countries and the power and reach of said countries?
I've learnt and acknowledged that all this talk of "use your own domain", "degoogle", "pay for the email" (and I do), etc are safe until someone resourceful enough eyes your domain with the wrong kind of look.
I expect the domain will remain permanently suspended since Codeberg violates US law, and .com and .org are US TLDs. They should have done codeberg.de witha German registrar, since they're operating within DE law they would be able to sue the registry or registrar for contract violation.
Good time to remind people that there are direct registration TLDs. Obviously not always a viable option but I prefer to use them as there is one less (useless and often scammy) middleman to deal with.
For example .is and .at offer this.
Given codeberg has a German nonprofit it seems like a good fit to run de domain too.
There’s precedent too, in 2016 Namecheap suspended Openload's domain because of DMCA reports against the domain (they later reinstated it tho).
And Codeberg has removed malware that Microsoft & Google refused to remove for obscure reasons, so this makes no sense.
source for this claim?
And its back :-P
Maybe Codeberg should use whatever registrar TPB is using.
Why do people use these penny ante companies for anything important?
Fight the system!
MarkMonitor prices are "contact us". So, it's NOT cheap.
Of course Codeberg is more than that, but it does not mean they're rich. If they have non-profit status, they are also required to not waste money, and the German tax authorities occasionally audit that (since they hand out non-profit status).
(Source: I've registered two BGB §21 associations, both non-profit, and one BGB §22 association.)
This is from some forum from 2014.
And Meta, they run their own registrar that is just for them.
Internationally, porkbun has good customer support despite the silly name, I haven't had bad experience with them yet.
Although for anything truly important the company I work for uses registrars with a physical presence in my country, where they can relatively easily be reached through court, or by going to the office and "yelling" at someone until the problem is resolved. Probably the best solution for an organization, even non profit?
But then what else because for .org: registrar -> PIR -> ISOC or ICANN -> the US of A.
Something like .eu might have been better. Maybe?
As the domain was already restored (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50545191 ), I imagine it had been suspended in error, probably in reaction to some bogus takedown notice from someone with an ax to grind.
I got attention by creating a post on social media, some higher level people reached out to me and resolved the issue.
Is there anything one can do to prevent the entire company from going dark?
- What if my registrar suspends my account? => Use different registrars for different domains. - What if the whole TLD has an outage (DENIC had that before)? => Fallback tld?
Should I really setup all SaaS apps with fallback-domain support that is registered by a different registrar on a different tld?
What happens to my company mails?
I wanna be a plumber!
That's incredibly scammy.
All other points are useless if you don’t follow the first one and the shite hits the fan…
Damned if we do, damned if we don't.
Even if you have to terminate later, you could differentiate by doing so in a more "civilized" manner.
> We do not give in, no matter the cost to us in legal fees, security arrangements or peace of mind.
https://1984.hosting/policy/ https://litigation.1984.hosting/
> 1984 ehf. reserves the full and unconditional right to decide whether to terminate services to the Subscriber, with or without notice, if 1984 ehf. considers the materials stored by the Subscriber to be illegal, unethical or harmful.
> In house we refer to this as the Nazi provision, because even if we are a freedom of speech host, we will not have the fruits of our labor used to spread racism, anti Semitism, instigation of violence or hatred.
This is a broad enough cutout that it could be used for just about anything - in modern discourse, people routinely describe any political stance they disagree with as "harmful" even if it is something as pedestrian as zoning regulations. If some company or individual sues to have my website taken down, prima facie they must have concluded that it is harmful to their interests - how do I reckon whether this hoster will concur?
I miss the era of actual principled free speech advocacy (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_Am...), as opposed to what appears to be plain old political activists cynically wearing the name. Even the CCP wants free speech it agrees with.
Free speech protects you from the government handing you consequences for saying things (and even that has limits, try yelling "fire" in a theater or "bomb" in an airport). But it does not require any private citizen or company to do business with you (well, almost - stuff like regulated public utilities usually are exempted).
And in addition, companies are not living in a vacuum by themselves as the far-right edgelords always try to claim. Companies, even individual people, are all part of society - and stuff that falls under the "Nazi policy" is generally considered to be like a cancer for societal cohesion.
If the consequence we are talking about is blocked speech, that is exactly what free speech means. Here it is the host advertising themselves as a free speech platform, that's an empty guarantee if all it refers to is actions taken by a government.
Clearly they want to allow some legal expression and not others. That's fine, but it is not a free speech platform.
In my opinion, for free speech to be a meaningful principle at all, it has to be an obligation upon everyone to believe that if someone has something to say and someone else wants to listen, you as a third party ought to not interfere to prevent them from doing so. Regardless, this "free speech host" is actually not even promising free speech in the narrow sense of protection from the government only - after all, they prominently declare their intent to take down illegal (i.e. unwanted by the government) content!
So, whoever does it is doing it out of some personal belief and not for the money. So it's going to be some kind of activists anyway. Might as well be these activists. I prefer it this way for things that matter the most to me. Real people with names and opinions instead of big corporations.
Although I most likely don't agree with most of their opinions, I know what their line is. It's a human approach vs corporations / lawyers / ToS.
There is no way to have a registrar that can guarantee they will block all actual abuses, while also guaranteeing that they will block nothing else, in a way that can be spelled out in black and white, requiring no human judgement, and no trust in them.
And this is generalisable, too. There is no way to universally specify "good" and "bad", or even "good faith" and "bad faith", in any domain, in a way that does not require human judgement, and thus trust in the ones making the judgements.
That's just part of living in a society. Either we agree, in some measure, to trust each other and work together, or we rapidly come to the conclusion that the only way forward is to code our own DNS system, registrar, and OS from scratch, and then run it only on hardware we have designed and built from scratch with our own hands. And run it only on solar power, so we're not dependent on the grid. And have it directly connected to at least a half-dozen separate ISPs, so you don't have to trust any single one of those. And... And... And...
It was registered with namesilo and entirely disappeared from our account. We're waiting for their customer support to investigate the situation.
Update: We have received the confirmation that our domain was suspended and our case got forwarded to the abuse team. We're still waiting for a final decision.