Google makes it very hard to use their shit and it was full of bugs.
Anthropic's current run is based entirely around Claude Code in this space and the last time I used the gemeini-cli it wouldnt give me access to the latest models and I was paying them for the privilege
https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/discussions/2727...
I get the complaints in that thread but I still think it is hilarious. That repo is a gong show to random shit and perhaps one of the best worst examples of "opensource" LLM development.
Sometimes you have to tab across and give it a PW, but it seemingly is incapable of parsing that, and just asking.
Kiro, what we use at work, on the other hand will just prompt you. (And doesn't like taking credentials directly)
In any case, it's well known that devs in Google have liked anthropic/openai models for coding more than gemini, so unless they're hiding their best models from the people within, I think it's just the case that they're behind.
Even with anthropics record breaking revenue growth I don't see how the pure AI companies can sustain, but the catch-22 is that any obvious pivot proves that. This puts the more traditional tech companies in position to ride the back of the wave until the growth curve tops.
Google has gone all in on AI. To the point of challenging their own core product. Apple is waiting and seeing. Google is building and distributing, albeit with terrible marketing.
I don't think that's true, mostly in that a lot of usecases are solved via coding models + a harness.
> Google's models are driving cars right now.
Yes + other models like alphafold. But those are (relatively) specialized models. Besides, the comment I was responding to was saying Google is sandbagging the market to keep it calm or something. I don't disagree that Google is doing well overall and has some clear advantages
https://www.theverge.com/news/627849/auto-draft
But I believe since then Anthropic have raised more money, almost certainly diluting Google's stake (I could be wrong and misremembering that Google didn't partake in the additional fundraising). I have in the back of my head that Google is down to something like 10% now, but don't have time to go and find details to fact check that, sorry!
If you ask questions, it will enable "AI overview" , but if we search about particular object/platform like "Google stock" or "bbc news", it will give the old classic search experience and we woulnd't need to swallow "AI overview" pill in that case.
Turns out licensing is separate for "code" and "pro"...
I highly suspect they opaquely lowered usage limits on me.
Depends on the product - whether protein bars, salty chips, cellular service, or IPhone or something else. If your product has a flavor, it’s never going to get commoditized. Coke still tastes better than Pepsi.
It will be interesting to see if the LLM companies can establish their own "brand" and how they will do that. LLM voice is a thing but not sure if it's a good thing people will use to hang their self identity on. Distillation of models and constant training also make this complicated. Claude code is winning on harness and ux right now but it seems precarious and also easy to commoditize. I think elon tried to add branding to his chatbot pretty intelligently by being iconically crude/evil/"anti woke" since it's both highly visible and less likely to be copied.
We live in fascinating times!
Well done lads
Kiro is of course really good to back into AWS stuff, it knows more about AWS than Amazon themselves!
Gemini is really good at understanding my inane ramble and mis-spelling
we started model testing the cost/performance of our skills and agents and flash 3.5 wins in most things.
As people develop harnesses for their codebase i think the intelligence required comes down a lot.
I'm pretty sure they do. They already index metadata (you can see it in the web search results) so indexing the transcript is relatively easy.
Google's main revenue is ads based on search. LLMs are a competitor to search. Creating better LLMs will cut into search volumes.
In any large organisation this is extraordinarily difficult to manage - they have to incentivise the new tech that is actively harming the current revenues, while maintaining as much of the old revenues as possible, without creating internal conflict between these two parts of the organisation that will kill it.
Though in fairness to Google they do seem to realise this and are trying to adapt - they're letting the LLM folks mess with search. It'll be interesting to see how this goes.
Sundar and many of his executives have certainly read or heard of The Innovator's Dilemma, and I expect they're all moderately paranoid that it will be their downfall.
Also, that's not it. Google has a great ai app called Gemini where they have at various points hosted the top ai image generation model (certainly for speed, and for a while for accuracy) and have innovated with features like deep research
They are monetizing their ai conversations more effectively than OpenAI could dream of via ads and chat in Google search.
They are heavily investing in compute and talent.
When they've added llm results to Google search it has _increased_ engagement and re-engagement.
What part of the competition are they blissfully ignoring?
(I have counter arguments to some of these points, but I would rather hear other people's)
Are they actually implementing ads in chat yet? I haven't seen an ad in Gemini yet.
Again, the results I've seen is that LLM results in search have resulted in more zero-click searches (as a proportion of all searches), which isn't increasing engagement? But again, I may be wrong, what are you basing your assertion on?
I didn't say they were blissfully ignoring anything. I gave them credit for knowing the situation they're in and doing something about it.
The problem that I was talking about (probably badly getting my point across) is that it's internal conflict and strife that causes the pain here. One part of the company is incentivised on increasing revenue on the existing business. The other part of the company is incentivised on increasing revenue for the new business. But the new business is at the expense of the old business, so it sets up internal conflict where each part of the business tries to protect its own incentives. And Google has always been afflicted with rife internal politics.
ChatGPT's growth is incredible, but they essentially have to get all of their growth from inside codex or ChatGPT apps. Google can auto query Gemini with every search. There's an interesting piece of data which is that this tells them (on a conditioned basis^^) when is the chat result more effective than the search and vice versa?
Google can force growth of Gemini by leveraging their existing properties. This is a huge asset, and if you're wondering why Meta has artificially high usage of their LLMs it's because distribution is hard and Meta and Google have a lot of surface area to distribute on
^ no, I don't mean this as a compliment, although it does lend credence to the idea that Google is willing to update its current products with AI.
^^ ie conditional on the user's willingness to view the chat result
Have you seen their Cloud business?
Moreover, Google has continued to drive search growth since ChatGPT arrived and is executing competently. Their models are good (not great), but they have enough compute and one of the best ML-focused chips such that they aren't beholden to Nvidia (instead, they're beholden to fabs: tsmc - this is a much better dependency since Nvidia is hell bent on extracting as much value as they can from their position in the stack and it would be against the nature of tsmc to behave similarly)
Will Google's ad revenue decrease? Advertising is an incredible business because it is anti fragile.^ Even if search revenues decrease from their current highs (I would bet heavily against this), they still have YouTube with shorts and a robust display ads business that is going to improve if AI supercharges the economy (more companies - # startups founded in Jan 2026 is much higher than # founded the previous January, more products, advertising and distribution become the differentiators for these products)
If you're wondering how anthropic is going to continue to grow its base, the answer is advertising. In fact, Google is situated to fundamentally support everything that anthropic needs. Who cares if they make worse margins than anthropic? They'll benefit from the entire ride up, and they'll do the same for the next startup of that scale.
However the agent-based conversational future simply does not support that level of valuable [1] ad volume, which collapses Google's carefully optimized tech+business stack.
Like I said, they will still thrive, but more because of GCP (which might see the biggest growth due to AI and the other tech + infrastructural advantages you mentioned) and the other businesses (YouTube, Waymo, etc.) However, their current cash cow is being disrupted, primarily by themselves, and I don't yet see how they can monetize agents nearly as lucratively as they've monetized search.
[1.] Sure, they could keep stuffing ads into each turn of the conversation, but 1) as I theorized in the linked post, those would be meaningless and low-value, and 2) that could just push users to competitors like ChatGPT, Anthropic or Perplexity that can offer a cleaner UX because they're starting from a clean slate and don't (yet) have the same revenue expectations to meet.
While your linked post was explicitly about ads, this line wasn't and is just baseless
If you think that (the quoted line) you should short Google (haha you will lose all your money even if you're right, market...irrational...solvent)
Search is going to be fine. It's about half their revenue. Display is another large chunk and feels largely immune to the affects of AI, and Google is not a static entity. And their Cloud business is seeing unbelievable growth.
I mean, the ad business is still by far the largest chunk of their whole business, which is why I think their overall revenues, profits and dominance will decrease ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Display is another good example of why. Like half (?) of it is YouTube, which will be fine, but the rest comes from non-first party properties, which are already seeing drastic drops in traffic. Just as with the shrinking of SERP ads, there's no way to stuff enough ads in chatbot conversations or to compensate for the display ad revenue dropping either.
I'm long Google (monopolies are usually good bets, bullish on AI + GCP, plus it is disrupting itself before others can so has good long-term prospects) but I can't see how that will compensate for its main cash cow today being cannibalized, so I fully expect future returns to be less than historic ones.
I mean, the product might not be called Google search, but the thing that Google search transforms into will likely make more money than it does today and my bear case is that it would still make >80% of today's watermark.
Also Google's going to grow auxiliary businesses around AI that will change the balance of their assets dramatically (waymo is ~nothing right now, cloud is growing well, and there's no reason Google shouldn't be able to produce a top coding model for speed if not frontier level)
coding models? their own devs use claude code.
If there is a "crack" there you might be able to get out of it, or it will let a disruptive idea to grow, but my way of thinking about innovator's dilemma is that is it a "culture bias": knowing about it give you some small advantage but it needs a real change to maybe have a chance to escape/act on it and the most important part is that under pressure it will quickly and imperceptible run the entire process or decision making.
But I also disagree with your reading of the innovators dilemma. You're being far too absolute
Google is well positioned to earn from this service, especially if they can prove that their search service is superior to competitors. While they lose some of their moat, they are well positioned to dominate the market, just like they did in the consumer space.
People asking any AI chat interface for ideas for their honeymoon will trigger some kind of search. SEO is still relevant and Google might still be able to sell top spots in their search so LLMs will pick it up.
"You tried to find a recipe for cupcakes, well all I can offer you is an advert on kitchen appliances"
Some already do, and some of the ones that don't will in the future.
See for example https://help.openai.com/en/articles/20001047-ads-in-chatgpt
Of course that's not to say that the advertising situation will be identical to that of pre-LLM search engines, and the differences may lead to radically different economic models and user experiences. But I was just correcting your statement.
It's actually incredibly useful if you just want to summarize a video, or my use case, want a text tutorial of something that's a video.
I have a boss who loves to rattle on for ages, and it gives a breakdown of what on earth he was on about
cries in Google Glass
Wild that Meta has that product now decades later, which isn't even half of what Google offered.
Doing a little bit of RAG on the transcript hardly sounds impressive.
And they have a massive amounts of TPUs. And yet... their models are way behind.
Auto Dubbing on the other hand is incredible, translating Russian/Ukranian speech with different voices and accents for each speaker, during a fire fight is wild.
How recently have you looked? I think nowadays it's quite good.
Not my impression. Lately I think Gemini is superior to ChatGPT and Claude in coding (I'm mostly using it with scientific stuff in Python).
Google knows LLMs are the new UI, not the new IDE.
I'm still on Anthropic models to code but I'm on Gemini 3.5 Flash for everything else. How can you say Google is bad at LLM when their little flash model is literally SOTA on many benchmarks?
> ... yet OpenAI and Anthropic are eating their pie.
They're eating nobody's pie: it's a new pie. Google is a $4.5 trillion company, the 2nd biggest in the world as I type this.
Seen that fact and seen how good Gemini 3.5 Flash is, I'm not really sure Google is "bad at LLMs".
I'm actually impressed by how much the Hackernews crowd is sleeping on Google & Gemini. Yes, it's lagging behind in coding, but it's consistently much better and more reliable at literally everything else.
Also there was a period of time when Gemini was the best model out there...
Recently I have been asking YouTube's new AI about some videos ("when is Steam metrics mentioned in the video?" for example), which means they also index videos. This is an unthinkable amount of data.
I'm actually impressed at how bad Alphabet is with LLMs since they invented the thing as we know AND have all the data to train on, yet OpenAI and Anthropic are eating their pie.