News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by u1hcw9nx on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:03AM (#47659308)
>However, an operation to repatriate its gold holdings began in the 1960s leading up to the US termination of the Bretton Woods system, which effectively stopped foreign governments from exchanging dollars for gold.

French-US monetary history after WWII:

Under the Bretton Woods agreement (1944-1971), the US dollar was the world’s reserve currency, and it was pegged to gold at $35 per ounce. Other countries pegged their currencies to the dollar.

around 1965, De Gaulle initiated a systematic, aggressive policy where they converted USD into physical gold every time French acquired USD from trade, then French Navy picked those gold bullions from NY. By 1971, the US gold reserves had decreased so much that they did not cover the dollars circulating globally and Nixon "closed the gold window,"

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by hypeatei on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:16AM (#47659417)
De Gaulle was ahead of his time. He was very skeptical of the control that the US had over Europe through NATO. He left the alliance to build an independent French nuclear program which is paying dividends today amid the current leadership situation in the US.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by byroot on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:43AM (#47659651)
Nitpick, but France never left NATO proper, only the integrated command, and reintegrated it in 2008 under Sarkozy.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by simgt on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:13PM (#47665475)
Sarkozy, who renamed what descended from De Gaulle's party into "Les Républicains" because of his obsession for the US. Who also got sponsored by Gaddafi, and invited him to pitch his tent in the Elysée's garden. And who ten years ago was still spewing climate change denial crap. He probably still would, but he's too busy talking about how his 10 days in prison was the most atrocious experience a human being had to endure.

Funny how much his pathetic 5 years in office keep on giving.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by c7b on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:29AM (#47659522)
He also called Brexit before the UK had even joined.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by stingraycharles on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:58AM (#47659777)
I think that is the part that the parent is referring to.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by corford on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:57AM (#47660318)
IIRC, De Gaulle & Churchill proposed a UK-FR union at one point (1940?) but it didn't get sufficient support within the French government. Interesting to ponder what the war and later EU trajectories might have looked like if that had happened.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by philistine on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:39AM (#47660793)
That union was a last ditch effort to try and keep France in the war. If they had implemented it, it would have been undone once the nazis were beaten you can be sure.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by UncleSlacky on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:48AM (#47661650)
It was suggested again in 1956 in the context of the Suez crisis:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/6261885.stm

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by weitendorf on Monday April 06, 2026 @01:09PM (#47663734)
That was also a last-ditch effort to maintain pre-WW2 geopolitical structures rather than a bipolar US-sphere vs Soviet-sphere world. Note that this was basically the nail in the coffin that led to their full-fledged decolonization in the following years. At the time the UK still held very significant military and political sway over the middle east, east africa, and asia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Empire#/media/File:Bri...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by thmsths on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:45AM (#47661618)
From my recollection, the plan was to grant French citizenship to every British citizen and vice versa, in effect "forcing" the governments to defend their citizens to the end. This was very ambitious, hence why it probably did not happen. But if it had happen, I have a hard time seeing how it could be undone, stripping people of their citizenship, even if they have a second one is no trivial matter.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by throw0101c on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:55AM (#47659744)
Certainly debatable.

De Gaulle started this 'policy' in 1965 and it's mainly the current leadership situation that's been a problem—60 years later. So to a certain extent the policy in question was 'wrong' for decades. How "right" can you really consider them when it was a problem year after year, decade after decade:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henny_Penny

It reminds me of the folks that keep saying there will be a major crash on Wall Street year after year after year… and then it just happens to be occur.

* https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2023/12/rich-author-poor-re...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by c7b on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:03AM (#47659810)
In what sense was the policy wrong? Emphasizing independence when it comes to security doesn't strike me as self-evidently wrong. Curious to hear your arguments. "They were very happy about it 60 years later" alone isn't evidence of it being wrong.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by dkga on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:43AM (#47660195)
I disagree. It was a right policy in the sense that it bought France an insurance policy that essentially no other Western country has. Like all insurance policies, you hope to be wrong, but when the time comes, you are protected from some of the worse case scenarios.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by throw0101c on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:56AM (#47660989)
Yes, this is the debatable part: the policy is "wrong" for 60 years and extracted a cost to France over those years (at least when it came to nuclear weapons?).

There just happened to be a whacko that got into the White House, but if ~70k (out of >100M) had gone the other way in 2016, Hillary Clinton would have won and the world would be a different place. (See also ~500 votes in Bush versus Gore.)

I'd be curious to know the 'insurance premium' that was paid by France every year and the total.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by slfnflctd on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:32AM (#47661454)
> There just happened to be a whacko that got into the White House

My counter to this is that such an occurrence was increasingly likely starting around the time the massive US Evangelical base was essentially fully captured by (and became a wing of) the Republican party. It was more and more obvious over a period of at least 40 of those 60 years you mention.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by wat10000 on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:51AM (#47661691)
If you prepare for a crash to happen on September 23rd, you're a fool. You can't point to a crash that happens a year later and say you got it right.

But if you prepare for a crash to happen at some point, that's just good sense. Only a fool would think that there would never be a crash. If you arrange your finances to withstand a crash, and there's eventually a crash, then that was the right thing to do even if it took a long time.

Ensuring the independence of your nation is more of the second kind. And it pays off even when there isn't an outright crisis. The policy wasn't "wrong" for decades. It was fine the whole time.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by dboreham on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:42AM (#47660179)
Time to make the "De Gaulle was Right about everything" baseball cap.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by UncleSlacky on Monday April 06, 2026 @11:48AM (#47662479)
Or a "De Gaulle Apology Form":

https://i.redd.it/opw3zv6x4qke1.png

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by kergonath on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:27AM (#47660630)
Let’s not get carried away. He was also wrong about many things. He was a good strategist, which was useful during WWII and helped France massively in the post-war years. His domestic policies were very much a mixed bag. He was not exactly authoritarian, but built himself a strong presidential political system. Which would have been fine if he had been right all the time, but he was not.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by doe88 on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:56AM (#47660314)
> to build an independent French nuclear program

For which France was helped by the UK, so it certainly would make sense if France helped the europe and uk to build its own nuclear deterrence.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by aubanel on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:24AM (#47661323)
That was a cooperation, both sides benefitted. So there's no debt to repay.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by mistrial9 on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:40AM (#47661560)
France is currently contacting selected partners to build a collective nuclear weapon coalition, probably focusing on Norway due to their location and recent oil wealth. Given recent events, reasonable people may disagree strongly on the directions that is leading.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by lostlogin on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:12AM (#47672124)
Europe isn’t pulling its weight in defence spending.

But if it tries to it’s also a problem?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by xorcist on Thursday April 09, 2026 @06:03AM (#47701507)
The problem is that Europe does not spend enough on US weaponry. Bulding nukes domestically does not help with that.

NATO was explicitly built to keep Europe in line. That worked to the benefit of everyone, until national security intrests and land expansion put a stop to it.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by ur-whale on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:40AM (#47659621)
> De Gaulle initiated a systematic, aggressive policy where they converted USD into physical gold

The dude was a visionary for many things, but I didn't know about this. Borderline prescient. What a guy.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by okanat on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:58AM (#47659766)
Just like the majority of the classical economists and policymakers, you would call him a blithering idiot and overzealous nationalist two decades ago. It was thought that this kind of behavior caused world-wars. I mean it did cause them. It is just we're speed running the next one that changed the narrative.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by Iulioh on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:07AM (#47659844)
This behavior is economically inefficient, that's why it's criticized. And it's undeniable

But the point is that "economical efficiency" is not the only metric that matters, stability and power do not come cheap.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by ivell on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:28AM (#47660051)
I think many academics are often specialized in one area of their expertise and overfit in that dimension. Journalists pick this up and promote those views a bit too much. This results in non-optimal decisions due to skewed public perceptions.

We need to promote holistic thinking considering multiple dimensions and not just one where academics are proficient in.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:09AM (#47661161)
> many academics are often specialized in one area of their expertise and overfit in that dimension

An economist saying a national-security measure costs this much is fine. Where it goes off the rails is in turning costs into damnation without accounting for what one gets in return. In an attention-driven media environment, that sells.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by Iulioh on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:32AM (#47660079)
The problem is that there isn't simply an efficient solution for everything. At one point every problem has solutions with pros and cons

France could do it as it is a rich and big country but smaller countries do not have a viable choice. This reasoning could have been applied to France too in another universe.

It's a balance impossible to totally tilt one way or another.

So no amount of extra information could help when it's matter of opinion at the end of the day

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by expedition32 on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:32AM (#47660678)
De Gaulle was not an overzealous nationalist. He actually ended French colonialism and started an alliance with Germany.

He was a patriot and very pragmatic. He knew France had been diminished. He had no time for delusional ideas.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by moffkalast on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:37AM (#47659600)
De Gaulle of this man.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by iamsomewalrus on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:57AM (#47661020)
Underrated comment
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by rdtsc on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:38AM (#47660123)
> trade, then French Navy picked those gold bullions from NY

I couldn’t find any clear news source or academic reference to that event. I see a lot of references on gold buying/selling sites mostly. I would imagine a Fench Navy ship docked NY and loading tons of gold would make quite a stir.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by kipchak on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:06AM (#47661136)
I seem to be having more luck with French language sources, mostly the Bank of France records. From what I can tell the shipping was done mostly commercially with some later by air[1]. Reportedly De Gaulle was frustrated with the speed of change wanted to use the Colbert warship but was dissuaded by the minister of finance.[2]

[1]https://archives-historiques.banque-france.fr/ark:/56433/115...

[2]https://www.lesechos.fr/finance-marches/banque-assurances/st...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by Reason077 on Monday April 06, 2026 @01:30PM (#47664081)
Gold is routinely transported across the Atlantic (and the world) by air today:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRt_Ld5vtHI

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by avianlyric on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:44AM (#47660210)
Gold is very dense. 10 Tonnes of gold takes up less than a cubic meter of volume.

Moving tonnes of gold doesn’t look like huge pallets of gold with tarps over them like a James Bond movie. It looks like a handful of supply crates.

I imagine that the French Navy visits NY ports of a regular basis. Pretty normal for Navy’s to sail into the ports of allies during peace time. There would be nothing unusual about a French Navy vessel sailing into NY loading up with some supplies and leaving.

https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=10tonnes+of+gold

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by rdtsc on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:25AM (#47660608)
For a country like France it would be on the order of hundreds or a thousand tons. So that’s maybe on the order of hundred trips by delivery trucks at most. Yeah I suppose spread out over a few years it wouldn’t be noticed. At least not by the general public. But since the claim is that this triggered the collapse of the Bretton Woods system it would be documented and referenced a lot more, still.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by lazide on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:35AM (#47660719)
Most delivery trucks (like a box truck) have capacities more like 10 or 20 tons. A heavy freight truck, like used to load ships? Even more.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by _heimdall on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:44AM (#47660858)
Was that the case in the 60s as well? I know trucks of that era had much lower capacity than today, even when comparing across class like "half-ton" trucks.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by bigfishrunning on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:57AM (#47661008)
A half-ton truck is a consumer pick-up truck, not a commercial shipping vehicle. Much much smaller.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by _heimdall on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:31PM (#47669681)
Yes I understand, that's why I was asking about box trucks of the day. I'll dig into it myself as I am curious now, I've only ever really looked into cab-over bread trucks from that era and those aren't a great comparison either. I was just curious if the GP already knew what 60s era box trucks would have been rated for.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by rdtsc on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:58AM (#47661026)
Yup that's what I had in mind, a 60s city delivery truck, not a semi, so googled that and came up to about 10t.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by vel0city on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:52AM (#47660955)
The Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956 set the gross vehicle weight limit for trucks at 73,280lbs. I imagine trucks of the day probably at least came close to that limit?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_trucking_indust...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by _heimdall on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:34PM (#47669694)
That was likely targeting tractor trailers of the era though, not box trucks.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by jjk166 on Monday April 06, 2026 @12:51PM (#47663450)
The gold would be moved by cash-in-transit trucks which have relatively modest payload capacities of 5000-9000lbs today, a bit less in the 60s. 3 tons per truck is probably on the high end.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by therealpygon on Monday April 06, 2026 @01:06PM (#47663697)
You don’t generally just throw gold in a box truck… it typically moves by armored freight.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by oasisbob on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:49PM (#47666874)
Maybe in some volumes, but I think most people would be shocked by the overall volume of gold that moves by UPS in small brown boxes.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by bruckie on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:19PM (#47668697)
The Hope diamond was famously transported by... USPS.

"The postage cost him $2.44, plus $142.85 for $1 million worth of insurance." —https://about.usps.com/who-we-are/postal-history/hope-diamon...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by bhouston on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:02AM (#47661083)
> I couldn’t find any clear news source or academic reference to that event.

It happened though. Here are the sources for it:

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock#Criticism_and_decl...

- https://www.thegoldobserver.com/p/how-france-secretly-repatr...

- https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/001/1994/128/arti...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by rdtsc on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:30AM (#47661431)
What happened is the gold got repatriated. I was looking for a source that a French warship docked and started loading thousands of tons of gold.

Your source confirms it as well:

> Involving the French Navy was considered, but that would have blown the operation’s cover. Instead, BdF used ocean liners from the Compagnie Générale Transatlantique

So it was multiple trips and in commercial liners.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by rkomorn on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:32AM (#47661455)
It's something that sounds like a plot point for a heist movie.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by haddr on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:44AM (#47661615)
Check what happened to the Spanish gold before the end of the Spanish civil war. I think it would be even more dramatic movie: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_Gold_(Spain)
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by xethos on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:56AM (#47661759)
Which almost might have been one of the arguments the Minister of Finance used to dissuade CDG
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by esseph on Monday April 06, 2026 @11:27AM (#47662171)
You should look into how often nuclear weapons are moved by truck.

You've probably driven past more than a few.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by JackFr on Monday April 06, 2026 @11:56AM (#47662592)
One armored car can carry a ton of gold. If they left and drove to the closest US Navy port, where the French ship would dock. it wouldn't raise eyebrows.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by rdtsc on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:44PM (#47665094)
It’s just that they repatriated close to 3000 tons. That’s one long convoy of armored cars, all going to a French warship docked in New York.

Based on some sibling discussion it seems it just never happened. It was multiple shipments, over many years, going over commercial liners. It may have well been armored trucks but they just didn’t all do it at once. It worked well that it didn’t create much of a media uproar.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by mrb on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:04AM (#47661112)
As a French speaker, I looked up French sources and found https://www.lesechos.fr/finance-marches/banque-assurances/st... - here is a snippet translated to English below. But many more references can be found by googling "opération vide-gousset".

1963: Operation Empty-the-purse ("vide-gousset")

It was also by warship that De Gaulle planned to conduct "Operation Empty-the-purse" in 1963, the code name for the repatriation of French gold deposited at Fort Knox in the United States (1). More than 1,150 tons—the result of converting French dollars into gold, a decision made by De Gaulle in response to the lax monetary policy of the United States—were being used to finance a growing trade deficit through the printing of money.

Valéry Giscard d'Estaing, then Minister of Finance, recounts (2): "De Gaulle was getting impatient and asked me at every meeting: 'So, has that gold finally come back?' One day, he told me: 'We need to move much faster: we're going to send the navy cruiser 'Colbert' which will bring back all the gold that's still there.'" “I told him that if we did that, we would alienate American public opinion forever.” Ultimately, De Gaulle abandoned the Colbert plan, and French gold returned from the United States in small quantities. Not for very long, it's true. The events of May 1968 and the ensuing monetary crisis depleted the reserves, which fell from 4,650 tons to 3,150 – 1,500 tons had crossed the Atlantic again to defend the franc, which De Gaulle refused to devalue.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by rdtsc on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:28AM (#47661393)
Thank you, this helps and clears up my confusion. I just couldn't imagine this kind of an event, a warship loading this much gold, not triggering some media commentary, even mockery or criticism to defend the US establishment.

> Ultimately, De Gaulle abandoned the Colbert plan, and French gold returned from the United States in small quantities.

So I think the story about the warship got twisted from a plan or threat to "it actually happened". Doing it in small quantities over a few years was the right way, indeed. Looking back it seems like it didn't make many waves in the news at the time, so Giscard was absolutely right.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by enoint on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:56AM (#47660312)
https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art...

Whether the exact ship was a battleship or a destroyer might make the search result.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by enoint on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:59AM (#47661040)
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by janandonly on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:42AM (#47660837)
I can’t open that link. Too bad.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by esseph on Monday April 06, 2026 @11:28AM (#47662195)
Cloudflare DNS?
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by enoint on Monday April 06, 2026 @12:30PM (#47663114)
I think I munged the link. Anyway, the answer is in a search result, with some discussion about whether it was a battleship or destroyer.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by snikeris on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:51AM (#47660942)
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by Tangurena2 on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:48PM (#47665999)
Historically, if a ship carrying gold sinks, whoever salvages the gold/loot gets ownership of it. However, if the ship is a warship, the loot belongs - FOREVER - as the property of the nation-state (or their descendants). This has led to some legal battles over nautical salvage in the Atlantic (were those "Spanish Galleons" military or non-military? Hundreds of millions of dollars depends on that answer during some lawsuits in the 1990s) or nautical salvage in South East Asia where artifacts from long gone kingdoms (that didn't reflect borders created centuries after they collapsed) end up in court over what country gets to show them in museums.

So yes, if you need to move national quantities of gold/silver across the ocean, then for legal reasons, it is best to ship it via your navy.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by BrtByte on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:23AM (#47661303)
From Franceэs perspective, they were just playing by the rules
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by bombcar on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:28AM (#47661405)
The whole of international politics is the real rules vs the unwritten rules.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by forshaper on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:30AM (#47661426)
Goes for local politics as well.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by gedy on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:32AM (#47661450)
Sounds like corporate politics too!
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by mohamedkoubaa on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:28AM (#47661402)
"closed the gold window" is a weird euphemism for "defaulted"
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by flowerthoughts on Monday April 06, 2026 @01:09PM (#47663736)
"I am altering the deal. Pray I do not alter it any further."
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by kccqzy on Monday April 06, 2026 @11:04AM (#47661871)
You seem to imply that Charles de Gaulle and his policy of converting dollars to gold caused the collapse of the Bretton Woods system. That was a myopic view. The whole Bretton Woods system was doomed from the beginning due to design defects.

The system was conceived with the primary goal of maintaining balance of payments equilibrium for all countries at the expense of economic growth and liquidity. It had become clear that if a country wanted its currency to be the world reserve currency it had to run a balance of payment deficit. And the United States clearly wanted its dollar to be the reserve currency unbridled by any balance of payment constraints.

If the United States had balance of payment surpluses as it had in the early years, the system lost liquidity (other countries wanted to buy U.S. exports but had neither gold nor dollars to do so), reducing the surplus. And if the United States had balance of payment deficits, well, gold would flow out of the United States, and the United States could not meaningfully increase public debt or spending.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by regnull on Monday April 06, 2026 @01:59PM (#47664466)
Ok, bear with me for a moment - what if the US would use actual physical gold coins instead of dollars? Then your argument of "gold would flow out" would not hold - so the only reason for it to flow out was that the gold standard was fake - the lax money policy of the US was the issue, not the gold standard itself.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by RealityVoid on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:18PM (#47665554)
Gold is silly as a measure of value. It's just a piece of shiny metal. The amount of value in the world is increasing so you want to exchange medium to grow with it else you're pulling breaks on the actual economy.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by butlike on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:09PM (#47666338)
Well it's also soft, bacteriostatic, and conductive.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by RealityVoid on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:17PM (#47666437)
OMG, we should totally base our economic exchanges on copper instead!
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by engineeringwoke on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:38PM (#47666711)
Yes, it's just a shiny piece of metal. However, it is a pure element and there is a limited amount of it, unlike pretty much anything else except maybe silver.

Otherwise this happens.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL

This is the origin of the entire white collar world and all of its odd bedfellows, and it will die in our lifetime. All of our jobs will go with it, unfortunately.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by newguy1000 on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:39PM (#47666725)
Gold is actually really good at transferring and measuring value. Think about what a "good" measure of value would be have. It needs to last over time, not corrode or dissolve to the forces. It needs to be distributable, Divisible.. to be ubiquitous. Hard to create/refine, hard to find, so supply can't easily be inflated. It doesn't matter what the object that is being used for exchange of value or holding value, that's why you can trade and barter random objects. But if you condensate down the properties that make a GOOD money, then gold is more than just a shiny metal. "The amount of value in the world is increasing so you want to exchange medium to grow with it.." we find more gold every day, so there is an easing already happening naturally. And even if there wasn't, imagine having an exchange currency that literally never inflated... that's GOOD. We have been hoodwinked into thinking that we need inflation to keep up with goods and services, literal stockholm syndrome taught by the FED.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by SR2Z on Monday April 06, 2026 @05:34PM (#47667471)
Hold on - you say "we find more gold every day" and then go on to suggest that the money supply doesn't actually need to keep up with economic growth?

If we had the technology to maintain 0% inflation, we would do that. We can't, and rather than risk deflation we instead target low positive inflation. This is because deflation leads to nightmare spirals where people start stuffing money into their mattresses instead of investing in useful things because holding has risk-free guaranteed returns that the unpredictable real world can't match.

The amount of gold being mined is not sufficient to keep up with economic growth and gold is therefore inherently deflationary. It's not a good way to store value, because a coin that's going to double in value over two years or whatever is obviously not a stable store of value.

You can argue about corrosion resistance or whatever other physical properties gold might have, but unless the civilization collapses you will find just as much luck storing your wealth in the database of a major bank. Needless to say, designing a civilization around the idea that it could collapse at any moment is unnecessary and expensive.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by zahlman on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:00AM (#47671240)
> If we had the technology to maintain 0% inflation, we would do that. We can't, and rather than risk deflation we instead target low positive inflation.

I don't think this is quite right. My understanding is that a low positive inflation would be targeted anyway, because it stimulates the velocity of money; i.e. there's a downside to hoarding, since you need to beat inflation to come out on top. So people will be willing to invest to at least some extent in risk assets, or to buy things now rather than later.

Which, yes, makes inflationary spirals possible, but they've proven less damaging. The inflation numbers seen in regimes that actually collapsed as a result are absolutely dizzying; whereas the deflation seen in the Great Depression was... significant, but not nearly comparable.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by SR2Z on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:13PM (#47679993)
The main advantage to keeping inflation as low as possible but positive is also that it makes interest rates cheaper. Individuals are incentivized to spend when there's inflation, but banks have a harder time writing loans because the interest rate on the loan is the product of inflation and the bank's desired ROI.

Low interest rates are a good thing because they allow people to explore new ideas and new businesses - the entire modern tech industry would not exist without ZIRP because the scale of investments has only gone up as technology has advanced.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by autoexec on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:27PM (#47682143)
> Individuals are incentivized to spend when there's inflation

That's not what's happening currently. Inflation has driven up prices to the point where people can't afford to spend. They're forced to cut back on spending just to keep a roof over their head and food on the table. Inflation promises that things are cheaper now than they ever will be, but that just means that anything you can't afford you either have to go without or take an even bigger hit to your wallet after trying to save money at a rate faster than prices are increasing. That sort of thing leads to less spending.

Credit cards were the solution for many Americans for a very long time, but that was never sustainable and now the US has record amounts of household debt and homelessness.

Deflation makes things more affordable and so people buy more. Yes, they could horde all their wealth, but you can't eat money and it isn't much fun. When times are good why would anyone bother going without when they can easily get what they want today. Consumerism is strong enough to keep people buying things. Decreasing prices gives consumers confidence that they can make risky purchases and investments.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by xorcist on Thursday April 09, 2026 @05:39AM (#47701348)
> the entire modern tech industry would not exist without ZIRP

The problem with zero interest rate is that it doesn't incentivize better ideas. Why would you work to increase productivity if capital has no cost?

The period 2016-2021 was one where interest rates were the lowest, sometimes even negative, and you saw companies hiring endlessly, and acquiring competitors with no intention of doing anything their their products.

It is very hard to compete on talent and good ideas in such an environment when your all competitors are burning through loaned and venture capital (which itself is also largely loaned at some point).

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by RealityVoid on Monday April 06, 2026 @05:01PM (#47667037)
> And even if there wasn't, imagine having an exchange currency that literally never inflated... that's GOOD.

I fundamentally disagree. Value comes from building stuff not from hoarding. I maintain my intense dislike for gold. And I grant that it had the property of having most people on this earth consider it the peak of value. Sure common belief is a useful property. But I disagree that it's a positive outcome or that there couldn't be many many other variations except gold.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by bartvk on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:55AM (#47671598)
Your dislike aside, is it part of your investment portfolio? If not, what did you replace it with?
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by habinero on Monday April 06, 2026 @06:38PM (#47668288)
> that's why you can trade and barter random objects...imagine having an exchange currency that literally never inflated... that's GOOD. We have been hoodwinked into thinking that we need inflation to keep up with goods and services, literal stockholm syndrome

Gahhh. Stop taking your economics advice from bitcoin bros and goldbug weirdos. They don't know how anything works and don't want to learn. It's like taking legal advice from sovereign citizens. It's not even that difficult to understand why it's a terrible idea!

High inflation is bad, sure. Deflation is an economic nuke. You know those people who spent like a whole bitcoin buying pizza way back when? "If I'd just held onto it, I'd have $HUGE_NUMBER now".

Yeah. If your money goes up in value, you have a huge incentive to stockpile it and not buy pizza. It's not just Dominos that loses out. All of the people and suppliers that go into pizza do, too. You need people to spend and lend to have liquidity and money flow.

> we find more gold every day, so there is an easing already happening naturally

That's not how that works. You're tying your entire country's economic growth to the production output of a single mining industry. Gold is not distributed evenly across the globe, either.

And yeah, we did all that in the past, and it caused deflation, which caused numerous financial panics [0], broke the British economy [1] and after two world wars, the US ended up with like 70% of the world's gold [2].

[0] https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/banking-panics-...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_crisis_of_1914

[2] https://www.imf.org/external/np/exr/center/mm/eng/mm_dr_01.h...

--

TL;DR: Tying your entire country's economic growth to the production output of a single mining industry is stupid and we don't do it for very good reasons. Everything is a conspiracy if you don't know how anything works.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by tw04 on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:13PM (#47669536)
I do find it rather ironic that economists can pretty much universally agree on this concept. And yet when you point out the very existence of the billionaire class inherently causes the exact same issue you're suddenly a communits.

How is it good for an economy to have a small subset of individuals hoarding wealth through property, artwork, and offshore bank accounts - not spending it in the economy from which they extracted it? "Job creators" is a farse, the subset who you can point to who ACTUALLY create(d) jobs a-la Page and Brin have long since stepped away from that job creation and have joined the ranks of: number go up.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by xorcist on Thursday April 09, 2026 @05:48AM (#47701402)
> If your money goes up in value, you have a huge incentive to stockpile it and not buy pizza

A lot hinges on this being true, but being deflationary is not unique to gold. It is also true for a lot of other things, including stocks. Yet we think it is good that regular people spend their earnings on stock, and it is generally considered to be one of the things which made American economy uniquely strong. So much so that other countries seek to mimic it.

The argument should cut both ways: A strong stock market which is deflationary should lead to economic stagnation. Why buy a pizza today when you can buy S&P500 and buy two pizzas tomorrow?

Reality seems to disagree here. People buy what they need and want, today, and whether the rest is stored in fiat currency, stocks, or gold seems to matter very little for economic productivity.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by habinero on Thursday April 09, 2026 @05:39PM (#47710533)
> Yet we think it is good that regular people spend their earnings on stock, and it is generally considered to be one of the things which made American economy uniquely strong

I...don't think you know what stocks actually are. Your argument doesn't make sense because stocks are the literal exact opposite of a deflationary good lol.

Companies issue stock to raise money. If you buy stock from a company, you're giving them that money in exchange for a small stake in ownership.

It gets more complicated with stock markets and all the other stuff, but the heart of it is taking money that would normally sit for decades doing nothing and giving it to those who can use it right now.

> Reality seems to disagree here.

It only does if you don't know how things work and don't want to learn lol

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by xorcist on Thursday April 09, 2026 @07:39PM (#47711729)
> Companies issue stock to raise money

There is certainly some misunderstanding here, and I am unsure about where it is. Perhaps another example could have been more clear.

When you "buy the S&P500" you do not buy stock from companies. No S&P ETF takes part in private placements or IPOs. They buy "used" shares on the open market, with the single intention of selling it on the open market to someone else.

When you buy the S&P, at no point do you give money to any of the S&P companies (except perhaps a small fee to the ETF issuer, most of which are public companies, but let's not split hairs about that).

There are of course other methods of buying the S&P500, such as tracker certificates, but they only add layers of indirection to the above, they do not change the fundamental facts about it.

> you don't know how things work and don't want to learn

I am not sure how to respond to this.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by panarky on Monday April 06, 2026 @05:59PM (#47667820)
Just because a social construct is silly when you think about it doesn't make it any less real or useful.

A national border is silly as a physical reality; it is just a cartographic whim. These invisible lines, drawn by long-dead men, pretend that the lithosphere is fundamentally different on one side of a coordinate than the other.

Fiat currency is silly as a store of value; it is just a digital ledger or a piece of cotton-linen blend. Its "worth" is derived entirely from the collective hallucination that a central bank’s promise is more substantial than the paper it is printed on.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by atoav on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @01:49AM (#47671165)
Yes. And we should never forget that these ideas are just that: useful ideas. They may seem without alternative to most people, but that doesn't mean they necessarily are.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by JTbane on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:01PM (#47669012)
Yeah I don't get why people don't understand this- there is not enough gold to base the entire global economy on it.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:37PM (#47669715)
That makes no sense, do you think people are talking about using gold coins instead of paper money in their wallet?
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by RealityVoid on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:07AM (#47672500)
In effect, some of them are. Look how many decry the death Breton Woods. They don't want to necessarily have good coins on them, but they want them to be tethered as a proxy. Why?
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @08:18AM (#47674096)
In effect, some of them are.

No, not in effect, no one is talking about physically exchanging gold coins, so it doesn't make sense to say "there isn't enough".

but they want them to be tethered as a proxy. Why?

That's a completely separate issue. People want to not have to deal with inflation where they are on a treadmill of needing to get paid more to support the fact that companies can raise their prices easily.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by RealityVoid on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:03AM (#47674693)
> No, not in effect, no one is talking about physically exchanging gold coins, so it doesn't make sense to say "there isn't enough".

I think my point still stands. If you can't create more gold [1] and you say - I am pegging 35 dollars to an ounce of gold. Then you are limiting the amount of dollars to the mass of gold[2]. The money works as an IOU for gold. You aren't exchanging pieces of gold, but the idea that you have 35$ is as if you have 1 ounce of gold, _that is what people pine for_. It's effectively, an IOU for 1 ounce of gold that you keep in a safe. Yes. I think the point still stands that in effect, that's what people are asking for.

[1] - You can, but it's a much slower process, deff rate limited, it's actually what people really seem to like about gold.

[2] - Yes, I am aware about the concept of fractional reserve, but that's exactly the part that goldbugs want to avoid.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:21AM (#47674991)
I think my point still stands. I think the point still stands

I'm not sure what point you are making, it seems like you're just describing a gold backed currency and repeating the same things multiple times.

If you aren't using gold directly how would there ever be "not enough" unless a penny became worth too much? People did this for hundreds of years, this isn't some theory or experiment, it's basically how the world worked for most of human history.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by RealityVoid on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:54AM (#47675434)
> If you aren't using gold directly how would there ever be "not enough" unless a penny became worth too much?

If you peg an amount of money to a mass of gold, would you or would you not limit the amount of money in existence?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:57AM (#47677304)
It worked before, you do know money is divisible right?

There is already a quantifiable amount of money in existence, can we at least establish that?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by kccqzy on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:11AM (#47675683)
Mild inflation is a good thing, at least according to modern economists. In a deflationary environment, money is worth more when you don’t spend them. And when people don’t spend them, there’s no economic growth. It’s just like having very high interest rates but the central bank cannot act to lower them.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @12:11PM (#47677514)
This thread was someone saying you can't peg a currency to something else because "there isn't enough of it" which is nonsense.

there’s no economic growth

Printing money doesn't create economic growth, it just inflates assets and depresses nominal wages.

money is worth more when you don’t spend them

People say this stuff like it's gospel, but if someone understands currency dynamics in the first place they would have their money in investments, which already should appreciate and act like a deflationary currency. People can already buy stocks and leave money there to get more valuable, so why does anyone spend money now?

You also have to figure out why it already worked for hundreds of years. People act like it would be an experiment. Floating currency is the experiment and it has lasted 50 years so far. Currency has lost almost all of it's value from before the 70s and minimum wage is a fraction of what it was nominally while asset prices are sky high, then people wonder why people can't afford a house or beef or gas or just to live alone.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by kccqzy on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @12:47PM (#47678093)
Economic growth comes from spending. Households must be incentivized to spend either through inflation or low interest rates.

Buying stocks hoping that it would appreciate doesn’t work when there is no economic growth. So we are back to square one.

And for hundreds of years we didn’t have the same kind of international trade, or the same financial markets. One must wonder whether a new kind of currency must accompany a new era of economy and trade.

Currency losing almost all its value is by design. Modern economists target a 2% inflation rate. This means currency is supposed to lose value. It’s another mechanism to encourage spending to increase economic growth.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:58PM (#47679780)
Economic growth comes from spending.

Who told you that?

Households must be incentivized to spend

Says who? What about governments and companies? People are already incentivized to spend because they need things.

Buying stocks hoping that it would appreciate doesn’t work when there is no economic growth.

You're contradicting yourself and going around in circles. If there is "economic growth" according to you, then stocks will go up, which means they end up being a deflationary currency, which means people will put there money there and not spend it.

They already go up due to inflation, people do buy stocks and other liquid assets, people still spend money anyway.

Also, gold still exists. By your own logic, because anyone can still buy gold or gold futures they should park their money there and never spend it.

Currency losing almost all its value is by design.

It is by design by governments and for governments. No person wants an inflationary currency, governments want it because they can they can borrow and print money they don't have and hand it out to people who in turn help with political power.

People don't want their currency to inflate away unless they own a business that can raise prices while their employees make less nominally.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by xorcist on Thursday April 09, 2026 @05:32AM (#47701296)
> Buying stocks hoping that it would appreciate doesn’t work when there is no economic growth

Why? If you and I earn $100 per year, every year, that means there is no economic growth. We spend half of it on food, clothes, and other necessities and buy stocks with the other half, stocks will go up in value.

An non-growing economy has aspects of a zero-sum game. Speculation can still occur, and can continue unbounded. Stocks, gold, bitcoin, have historically all been deflationary.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by 1718627440 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:52AM (#47672785)
There is also not enough paper money to base the entire global economy in it, so I fail to see the problem.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by ajross on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:56PM (#47666122)
That doesn't make any sense to me. Under Bretton Woods, a "dollar" was a contractual equivalent to a fixed amount of gold. There's no difference. When people are talking about "flow out" they're not talking about literally motion of currency[1], just who owns it.

[1] Which is backwards in your reasoning anyway. If you're a foreign power wanting to hold dollars, and dollars are physical gold coins, then you quite literally need to move them physically out of the country, right?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by cyberax on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:23PM (#47664827)
> Ok, bear with me for a moment - what if the US would use actual physical gold coins instead of dollars?

You'll get a bear economy, leading to the eventual deflation and collapse.

Fun fact: it was not hyperinflation in Weimar Germany that led Hitler to power but _deflation_ because of its insistence on sticking to the gold standard.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by kr1m on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:35PM (#47665821)
> Fun fact: it was not hyperinflation in Weimar Germany that led Hitler to power but _deflation_ because of its insistence on sticking to the gold standard.

Do you have a source for this? AFAIK https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation_in_the_Weimar_R...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by cyberax on Monday April 06, 2026 @06:25PM (#47668144)
"Hyperinflation caused Hitler" is one of the common narratives that "everyone knows". But German economy was actually growing during the hyperinflation era and by the time of Hitler's ascension, the hyperinflation had long been in the past.

I personally edited this very Wikipedia article several times, but my changes got reverted by goldbugs who want to memory-hole it.

This article has a nice explanation: https://www.hertie-school.org/fileadmin/user_upload/20191101...

If you don't believe the numbers from it, they can be corroborated easily.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by kr1m on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:57PM (#47669850)
Thanks for sharing. I can corroborate some of the unemployment numbers in Lords of Finance and have no doubt there was some deflation. I do think the seeds of the Third Reich were sown well before this period mostly due to the insistence of France wanting full reparations and Germany borrowing in foreign currencies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lords_of_Finance

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by cyberax on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:37PM (#47670110)
Hyperinflation undoubtedly left a huge psychological scar, especially because it happened right after the loss in WWI. But it did not cause a long protracted unemployment period that directly resulted in mass disgruntlement.

And most importantly, the deflation was directly caused by Germany's insistence on staying on the gold standard. And this has been an almost ironclad law: large countries that insist on gold standard end up with stagnating economy.

If you want another interesting tale from the opposite side of the spectrum: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%B6rgl#The_W%C3%B6rgl_Expe... - it's a town that was issuing "decaying" money in 1930-s and this helped to revitalize its economy.

Another example often cited by Paul Krugman was Washington's childcare coöp, but it's a bit too small-scale.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by atoav on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @01:57AM (#47671210)
I always thought it was the musical energy of Bertold Brechts "Die Dreigroschenoper" that lead Hitler to power. /s

Just because two things are correlated in time, doesn't mean they are necessarily causally linked. Surely there are multiple factors at the same time behind the rise of a demagogue. In the case of Hitler the grievances of WWI played probably a much bigger role than economic problems.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by dmoy on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @01:15PM (#47678458)
Fair, but at the very least "hyperinflation caused Hitler" is a significantly weaker statement than "deflation caused Hitler", given that the former was replaced by the latter like 8+ years before Hitler's takeover.

Economic problems was a big part though, the 1929-33 great depression. It features heavily in political literature pushed by the Nazi party leading up to takeover. You know, like "Arbeit und Brot", etc.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by dmoy on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:25PM (#47668743)
Hyperinflation in weimar Germany ended by what, 1924-ish with a return to gold standard? Hitler came to power 8+ years later
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:42PM (#47669741)
Fake economics to "stable money causes hitler" in two sentences.

Countries used gold or metals either directly as currency or to back paper currency for hundreds of years. If their governments overspent they collapsed.

Saying you need inflation or you get hitler is pretty wild.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by 8note on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:55PM (#47670222)
those hundreds and thousands of years were basically before humanity learned that prosperity could exist.

no growth that whole time, other than when you go to war and expand your gold supply by taking somebody else's.

the positive sum present is much better than the zero sum past

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Monday April 06, 2026 @11:41PM (#47670486)
those hundreds and thousands of years were basically before humanity learned that prosperity could exist.

No, it was pretty much up until the early 1900s

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by cyberax on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:38PM (#47670113)
> Saying you need inflation or you get hitler is pretty wild.

Not really. You need inflation, or you end up with stagnation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%B6rgl#The_W%C3%B6rgl_Expe...

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:08AM (#47674791)
Your proof that the economic system that worked for hundreds of years doesn't actually work is a small town that issued their own currency, which allowed them to nominally pay people less and there were more jobs?

That's what inflation does, everyone gets paid less, but they don't realize it because they just see the same number coming in and more going out.

And then because of that, somehow noninflationary currency results in hitler in 8 years (even though it was used for hundreds of years).

I think you should look at the other end, which is governments going broke and not being able to inflate their way out of it.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by cyberax on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @01:23PM (#47678566)
> Your proof that the economic system that worked for hundreds of years

It did not. The economic system that was in place for hundreds of years kept the population in a permanent state of depression. Most people had barely enough money to buy necessities.

The economic growth exploded, surpassing _millenia_ of innovation within mere _decades_ once we got rid of the golden chains.

But I guess that you fancy yourself being landed gentry and not a landless serf?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:37PM (#47679519)
kept the population in a permanent state of depression.

Says who?

people had barely enough money to buy necessities.

Where are you getting that? I think you're confusing and conflating all sorts of things like human advancements with inflationary money. I'm sure what you're saying makes sense if you think every invention, discovery and gain of knowledge was from people having their money inflated, but there isn't any evidence of this, it's just you restating it.

The economic growth exploded, surpassing _millenia_ of innovation within mere _decades_ once we got rid of the golden chains.

That really only happened in the 70s, it wasn't exactly the dark ages before that.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by cyberax on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:12PM (#47680752)
> Says who?

Err... Have you ever studied history?

> Where are you getting that?

From learning the basics of history? Before 1900-s famines were common, and most people were illiterate.

> That really only happened in the 70s, it wasn't exactly the dark ages before that.

Got it. You live in an imaginary world.

In reality, the first inflation happened when the European civilization established contact with South America. It rapidly expanded the monetary base and provided an impetus to economic development.

Then paper money (and equivalent debt-based mechanisms) were invented and became popular, and this turbocharged everything.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:41PM (#47681092)
Err... Have you ever studied history?

I just explained history to you, you realize being patronizing and repeating yourself isn't evidence right?

From learning the basics of history? Before 1900-s famines were common, and most people were illiterate.

Do you think the printing press, the engine and large scale agriculture might have more to do with food and literacy than inflation?

All those problems were solved before the US went off the gold standard anyway.

In reality, the first inflation happened when the European civilization established contact with South America. It rapidly expanded the monetary base and provided an impetus to economic development.

You realize this doesn't make sense right? This idea that printing money somehow leads to all human advancement is bizarre, even for someone who is ignoring all the things I said before. If two cultures crossed oceans do you think the advancement might come from international trade or do you think some tribe in the jungle could make up a currency, start printing it off, then go straight on to skyscrapers and video games?

All this is just a gish gallop anyway, you never bothered to explain how not having inflation "causes hitler in 8 years" even though it's only been the last 50 years that we have been off of backed currency.

You also didn't confront the fact that anyone can put their money in stocks, bond or gold and essentially have a deflationary currency but they still spend money anyway.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by killjoywashere on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:58PM (#47670239)
Uh, yeah, I'm gonna need more of an explainer on that.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by AnthonyMouse on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:31PM (#47669680)
> what if the US would use actual physical gold coins instead of dollars?

The problem here is, what if the demand for dollars increases?

In principle the US would get more gold and mint more currency, but gold is a finite resource. "All the gold ever mined" is around 200,000 metric tons, ~32k troy ounces per metric ton is ~6.4B troy ounces.

In 2022 (just before the recent gold rally) the price was ~$2000 per troy ounce, i.e. "all the gold" was worth ~$13T. Meanwhile the M3 money supply in the same year was ~$20T. What happens if you try to buy $20T worth of gold to mint currency when only $13T worth has ever been mined, and not all of that is even on the market? The answer is that you can't, so instead the result is deflation, which is bad.

Or to put it a different way, what do you think the economic effect of the recent gold rally would be for a country whose currency was still pegged to gold? It just got way cheaper to import foreign products than buy domestic ones, and way more expensive for foreign countries to buy your exports, so how's the unemployment rate looking? The amount everyone owes on their mortgage hasn't changed but the nominal value of their houses just got cut in half so now they've lost their jobs and are underwater. What happens when they start to default and foreclosures don't allow the banks to recover the principal?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by 1718627440 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:50AM (#47672771)
> The problem here is, what if the demand for dollars increases?

The price for gold and dollar would rise, until the worth of dollars is as high as the demand is?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:01AM (#47672844)
> The price for gold and dollar would rise, until the worth of dollars is as high as the demand is?

The name for that is deflation.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by throwawayqqq11 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:49AM (#47673206)
To explain why de/inflation is bad:

The primary function of money is its trade value, to "lubricate" the real economy to let goods and services flow. When the value is unstable, people are inclined to not spend or not accept that currency, which contradicts the free flow of it and in severe cases harms the economy.

Crypto'currencies' have the same problem. By nature, they are no currency but investment for which instability is required. No crypto bro would hype their 'currency' because there would be no pumping. Arbitrage trades are considered being for fools or insiders.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:56PM (#47692906)
> Crypto'currencies' have the same problem.

Bitcoin has the same problem. There is no inherent reason you can't have a cryptocurrency where there is no maximum number of coins to ever be mined and instead the limit is that mining them requires a fixed amount of computation.

That would give you the characteristics you want from a medium of exchange, because there is a rate limit on how much can be created (doing so requires e.g. electricity). Then the value is relatively stable, if you accept it as payment on Monday it would still be worth around the same amount on Friday, but the long-term result is a slow reduction in value on multi-year timescales as compute gets cheaper, so you don't get the speculation that results in high volatility and it doesn't strongly compete with real economic activity for investment resources.

The argument you'll get from goldbugs and whatever is that nobody would want a currency which is inherently inflationary like that, but that's clearly contrary to evidence. Most government currencies are inflationary, even on purpose, and it doesn't matter as long as the rate of inflation isn't so high that people holding it transiently for use as a medium of exchange are losing a significant amount in that short period of time. Especially when the rate of inflation is predictable (the rate at which computers get faster is reasonably consistent) so that anyone entering into a long-term contract denominated in that currency can reasonably predict its future value on the delivery date. Or people could just use it as a medium of exchange and denominate their contracts in something else.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by throwawayqqq11 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @06:04AM (#47729189)
You are right, the harm of unstable currencies is a matter of public perception but boiling the frogs slowly still does harm. Inflation is a significant, longterm, bottom-up wealth pump and simply pointing to empirical evidence is a point against unstable currencies, not for them.

How cryptocurrencies are mined is secondary in that regard too because their values is also purely based on perception, since there is no large authoriry backing that currency by eg. demanding , spending and regulating it.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=k3NN_NZOdhY

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by Nevermark on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:22AM (#47671775)
So as trade increases, and the need for dollars increases, gold and the dollar increase in value together.

That sounds benign until you realize that is: deflation. It incentivizes everyone to hold their dollars instead of spending them, and parasitically gain from gold's increasing utility use as currency by others.

This further decreases dollars available on the market to use in trade, further increasing their value. Which ... yes this can be an economic death spiral. Or at least, a strongly growth conflicted world.

A world in which you can make 5-10% a year by avoiding economic activity or investment is not a healthy world.

(And you can't increase gold supply to counteract this, because gold supply is also always balanced against the cost of extracting gold. Unless everyone else on the planet except the US government is prohibited from mining gold, there is no play there.)

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by stinkbeetle on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:55AM (#47673260)
Can you make the same arguments for holding land and activity that requires land? Or holding any other valuable, limited commodity vs activity that requires that commodity, copper for example?

Investors in those things haven't caused an economic death spiral. It's considered shrewd and good business to buy and hold things that are seeing increasing demand.

> This further decreases dollars available on the market to use in trade, further increasing their value.

... thereby reducing the amount of dollars required to trade a given amount of other things. Where does the spiral come from?

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by Nevermark on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:52AM (#47685430)
Holding land isn't as straightforward as you describe it. Every parcel of land is different. It takes a lot of knowledge of many kinds to be the one who makes money from real estate, instead of losing outright for overpaying, underselling, or simply being whittled down by taxes and other expense. And its lack of liquidity creates high situation risk, for anyone who doesn't have a large enough csh buffer to weather life's turns, unscathed by any immediate needs.

But yes, sophisticated investors do make money on under utilized land. Parasitically.

And it is an economy damper. Under utilized land is poor economic optimization by definition. Not to mention the undertow it creates, in terms of unproductive scarcity, for people who actually need to utilize land - whether that is for homes or businesses.

The solution, as economist Henry George pointed out, is to tax land, but not the property on it. Tax the exlcusionalry holding of a limited resource, don't tax productive value created by people.

Taxing land and not property isn't as simple as taxing both, but it isn't rocket science either. There are lots of standards and practices, because distinguishing between the two is important for many reasons.

The irony of taxing property, the stuff that makes land productive, is that it is a wealth tax that hurts rich and poor alike. A poor person, unemployed, who spends their time bereft of reliable income improving their own home will now be taxed on the value added - every year for the rest of their lives or until they sell or lose their home. That is a very perverse situation.

So yes, the taxation situation that subsidizes under utilized property, which is also parasitically rewarded by gains in value far exceeding the lower taxes they pay (for having no development to tax), is continually damaging the economy.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by stinkbeetle on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @10:28PM (#47698659)
I didn't describe anything as straightforward, the fact remains that there are limited goods/properties/commodities that are in demand, not just money. It's not up to me to show why it's exactly like money because that was the only property of money used to describe this detrimental problem, it's up to the person who says that is a problem with deflationary money. Money can also be taxed too, so that also is insufficient to make the case for why it is different than land. Or alternatively you could take a limited non-renewable commodity (say, copper) that is in demand but not taxed. Also you have still not addressed that increasing value of money naturally reduces the required amount of it necessary for making a particular trade. A fairly striking omission when claiming there are feedback spirals in such a system.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by doctorpangloss on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:00PM (#47664491)
I agree with you that Bretton Woods was doomed from the beginning, both Keynes and Friedman said so, and this should be a better known POV. Economists are not historians though, and historians write human-driven stories (i.e., it was Nixon who ended Bretton Woods, it's not that it was going to inevitably collapse as an econometric question).

All that said, Bretton Woods matters because people look at the gold standard as a time when wages in the United States rose. Like that's why Bernie Bros on HN care. It's the same reason they oppose globalization: me me me. So it's worth knowing why it was flawed. They don't comprehend that before and after Bretton Woods, hourly wage charts measured a fundamentally different thing.

I think it's better to attack the charts - I mean, you're responding to a Charts Guy, a guy who's like, look at this Gold Denominated Chart guy - because that's what their brains work on. Don't worry about economics. These guys are not economists. They are Charts. The real attack on their worldview is that, well, just because the year in the X axis is an increasing, doesn't mean that you can compare a bigger year to a smaller year. They would really like the world to be ordered that way, but it's not, and taking leadership on convincing them of that is very hard.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by TheOtherHobbes on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:55PM (#47665231)
Perhaps you could expand on why you're convinced the entirety of neoliberal economic dogma isn't "me me me"?

The gold bugs are almost entirely on the right. The left are far more likely to be MMTers.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by doctorpangloss on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:17PM (#47665525)
> The gold bugs are almost entirely on the right. The left are far more likely to be MMTers.

see, i don't want to generalize about left and right. it's much simpler than that. look at what this thread is actually about: "chart for $/GLD is going up and to the right, therefore, gold good." okay? it's not complicated. it's not left vs right as much as it is, for every 1 person who's like, "things are complicated, economics are interesting, let's talk about it" there are 19 who live day to day in a relentless grind, and get-rich-quick is literally their only apparent salvation. they want the world to be ordered where they are a Green Wojack, where some random bet or gamble makes them a ton of money. that's why we're talking about it, not to figure out economic policy. same reason we talk about cryptocurrencies and startups. to most regular people - and programmers are regular people - it's about, $$$.

it is a totally valid complaint to say, "floating exchange rates do not produce charts that go up and to the right." I mean, that's their problem! They made the wages per hour chart stop going up and to the right! It's not that they are bad policy!

Do people on HN care about joe schmoe hourly worker? No. You can certainly make tons of money trading currencies, but look, these people are not trading. They're gambling. This class of get-rich-quick person likes: real estate, cryptocurrency, gold, startup stock... are you getting it?

You are making it about, "neoliberal dogmas" and "gold bugs" or whatever. Trust me, those people are not the morons. The gamblers are 10x as stupid. They are the antagonists.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by slopinthebag on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:22PM (#47664813)
The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by doctorpangloss on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:32PM (#47664934)
government policy definitely has the greatest power to create (or destroy) wealth, there are a lot of things wrong with economic policy in this country, but floating currency exchange is not one of those problems.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by slopinthebag on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:24PM (#47665669)
I would argue that any policy that allows the government to print money freely and inflate the currency is a major thing wrong with a country.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by timeinput on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:38PM (#47665856)
Several of them would have protested if they could have found the right arguments.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by doctorpangloss on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:43PM (#47665928)
the best way to expand your worldview is to consider that time series charts do not tell a whole, or even accurate, story, a lot of the time. for example, looking at a chart of a line going up and to the right for money supply isn't as meaningful as you think it is.
Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by habinero on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:06PM (#47669057)
And you'd be wrong. It's not even difficult to understand why. Uncontrolled inflation is bad. Deflation is much, much worse. You do not want deflation. It rots your economy and nukes lend and spend. We trade a small amount of inflation to avoid the nuke that is deflation.

This is, like, one of the few things economists -- even most of the crazy ones -- agree on.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by slopinthebag on Monday April 06, 2026 @09:17PM (#47669571)
That's an oversimplification. Demand-side deflation can be bad for the economy, but it's also because our modern economies are basically reliant on inflation to manage our insane debts. Typically, critique of inflationary principles is coupled with a broader critique of MMT and how our economies are run. Deflation is fine or even beneficial when it comes from increased productivity (supply-side). Heck, we have deflation in some sectors of our economy (eg. technology) and consumers greatly benefit from it. Unfortunately the good type of deflation we see in our economies is overshadowed by the money printer going brrrrrrr.

Deflation is bad for the elites and politicians, and good for consumers. When the former are running the show, of course they will claim that deflation is the worst thing ever, despite the immense harm inflation inflicts on the average person. And if you spend like 5 minutes pondering the justification for why that is, you'll see it's mostly BS.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by habinero on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @06:27AM (#47688142)
> Deflation is bad for the elites and politicians, and good for consumers.

Hahahaha no. Other way around. I assume you meant "consumers" as a short hand for "normal people" and not its actual meaning of "people who need to buy things on a regular basis" because you do not want to be a consumer in a deflationary market. You're constantly having to piddle your wealth away because you're forced to exchange money for goods and services. Like food and shelter.

Deflation means no access to modern lending because there's no incentive to do anything with money except hold it. That's fine if you're already wealthy, because either you have it on hand, have assets for collateral, or can call in a favor. If you're not wealthy, you're just fucked.

Having easy access to debt is, overall, a phenomenal thing for the non-wealthy. Can you abuse it? Yup. Can it be predatory? Sure. Does it mean the average person gets access to capital without access to generational wealth or decades of saving? Absolutely. The middle class kind of doesn't exist without it. See also: The Ability to File For Bankruptcy is Good, Actually.

> And if you spend like 5 minutes pondering the justification for why that is, you'll see it's mostly BS.

I'm always a fan of examining things, but there's a prerequisite. You need enough education, critical thinking skills, and maturity to understand why you start at the null hypothesis: any "Secret Knowledge They Don't Want You To Know" theory is conspiracy bullshit.

And enough cynicism to know when people start talking about "elites and politicians" like they're one homogenous lump of evil agenda, it's usually a shibboleth for other, ah, less socially acceptable beliefs.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by pessimizer on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:03PM (#47665320)
All the facts are true here, but "design defect" is silly. The entire purpose was to keep a country like the US from exploiting its position, and becoming the "world's reserve currency" which is just a euphemism for running up massive debts to poorer states.

Bretton Woods was sabotaged by the US and the USSR through the single vehicle of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Dexter_White. Without a Bancor, the entire system simply became a mechanism to exploit the poor.

Re:France pulls last gold held in US for $15B gain by chvid on Monday April 06, 2026 @01:09PM (#47663738)
Excessive debt build up in particular due to the Vietnam war caused the US to cancel the dollar gold convertibility.