For those that do, your scaling example works against you. If today you can merge three services into one, then why do you need full time infrastructure staff to manage so few servers? And remember, you want 24/7 monitoring, replication for disaster recovery, etc. Most businesses do not have IT infrastructure as a core skill or differentiator, and so they want to farm it out.
This is really the core problem. Every time I’ve done the math on a sizable cloud vs on-prem deployment, there is so much money left on the table that the orgs can afford to pay FAANG-level salaries for several good SREs but never have we been able to find people to fill the roles or even know if we had found them.
The numbers are so much worse now with GPUs. The cost of reserved instances (let alone on-demand) for an 8x H100 pod even with NVIDIA Enterprise licenses included leaves tens of thousands per pod for the salary of employees managing it. Assuming one SREs can manage at least four racks the hardware pays for itself, if you can find even a single qualified person.
AWS charges $55/hour for EC2 p5.48xlarge instance, which goes down with 1 or 3 year commitments.
With 1 year commitment, it costs ~$30/hour => $262k per year.
3-year commitment brings price down to $24/hour => $210k per year.
This price does NOT include egress, and other fees.
So, yeah, there is a $120k-$175k difference that can pay for a full-time on-site SRE, even if you only need one 8xH100 server.
Numbers get better if you need more than one server like that.
Hiring 1 person to run the infrastructure means that 1 person is on-call 24/7 forever.
If there's an issue with the server while they're sick or on vacation, you just stop and wait.
If they take a new job, you need to find someone to take over or very quickly hire a replacement.
There's a second bus factor: What happens when that 8xH100 starts to get flakey? You can't move the jobs to another server because you only have one. You can start diagnosing things and replacing parts and hope it gets to the root issue, but that's more downtime.
Going on-prem like this is highly risky. It works well until the hardware starts developing problems or the person in charge gets a new job. The weeks and months lost to dealing with the server start to become a problem. The SRE team starts to get tired of having to do all of their work on weekends because they can't block active use during the week. Teams start complaining that they need to use cloud to keep their project moving forward.
> Hiring 1 person to run the infrastructure means that 1 person is on-call 24/7 forever.
> If there's an issue with the server while they're sick or on vacation, you just stop and wait.
Very much depends on what you're doing, of course, but "you just stop and wait" for sickness/vacation sometimes is actually good enough uptime -- especially if it keeps costs down. I've had that role before... That said, it's usually better to have two or three people who know the systems though (even if they're not full time dedicated to them) to reduce the bus factor.
By doing this, you're guaranteeing a bus factor of below 1. I can't think of any business that wouldn't see that as being a completely unacceptable risk.
I’ve seen this before. It turns into restrictions on when you can schedule vacation times.
Not fun when your family wants to go on a trip but you can’t get the time off because it’s not one of the allowed vacation times.
I never understand the drive to stay away from cloud services for small scale operations. It’s not your money that’s being spent on the cloud, but it is your free time being asked to be on call when you encourage your company to self-host!
You can still use cloud for excess capacity when needed. E.g. use on-prem for base load, and spin up cloud instances for peaks in load.
they come with warranty, often with technican guaranteed to arrive within few hours or at most a day. Also if SHTF just getting cloud to augument current lackings isn't hard
Companies following consultant reports will usually end up offering 50% ranges, which for SRE/SIE roles in major metros comes to around $163k. If they study BLS/FRED/CPI data and aim to pay someone enough for a 50/30/20 budget in a major metro at median rent, they’ll offer $175k to $200k+. If they want someone to stick around, buy an average home, lay roots, it’s $210k+, minimum.
“Six figures” doesn’t cover essentials anymore for almost every major city in the USA, and the last thing you can afford to cheap out on is the labor supporting your IT infra. Every corner you cut today on TC (outsourcing, offshoring, consulting) is just letting fires rage until you either parachute out or everything burns down, and that’s not a game you can afford to play with critical business technologies.
If a business can’t afford a properly staffed crew with enough allowance to cover a rotation of on call duties and allow for vacations, they should prefer the managed cloud services.
You’re paying more but you’re buying freedom and flexibility.
These come in a non-flakey variant?
And the other argument: every company I've ever know to do AWS has an AWS sysadmin (sorry "devops"), same for Azure. Even for small deployments. And departments want their own person/team.
My favorite are the responses from people saying the warranty will have someone show up in “hours” and fix it. Best of luck to you.
You can ask AI to troubleshoot and fix the issue.
> $120K isn't going to cover the fully loaded costs of an SRE who can set up and run that.
Literally this. I can do SRE on-prem and cloud, and my 50/30/20 budget break-even point (as in, needs and savings but no wants - so 70%) is $170k before taxes. Rent is astonishingly high right now, and the sort of mid-career professional you want to handle SRE for your single DC is going to take $150k in this market before fucking off to the first $200k job they get.
Know your market, and pay accordingly. You cannot fuck around with SREs.
> Hiring 1 person to run the infrastructure means that 1 person is on-call 24/7 forever.
This is less of an issue than you might think, but strongly dependent upon the quality of talent you’ve retained and the budget you’ve given them. Shitbox hardware or cheap-ass talent means you’ll need to double or triple up locally, but a quality candidate with discretion can easily be supported by a counterpart at another office or site, at least short-term. Ideally though, yeah, you’ll need two engineers to manage this stack, but AWS savings on even a modest (~700 VMs) estate will cover their TC inside of six months, generally.
> There's a second bus factor: What happens when that 8xH100 starts to get flakey? You can't move the jobs to another server because you only have one. You can start diagnosing things and replacing parts and hope it gets to the root issue, but that's more downtime.
This strikes at another workload I neglected to mention, and one I highly recommend keeping in the public cloud: GPUs.
GPUs on-prem suck. Drivers are finnicky, firmware is flakey, vendor support inconsistent, and SR-IOV is a pain in the ass to manage at scale. They suck harder than HBAs, which I didn’t think was possible.
If you’re consuming GPUs 24x7 and can afford to support them on-prem, you’re definitely not here on HN killing time. For everyone else, tune your scaling controls on your cloud provider of choice to use what you need, when you need it, and accept the reality that hyperscalers are better suited for GPU workloads - for now.
> Going on-prem like this is highly risky.
Every transaction is risky, but the risk calculus for “static” (ADDS) or “stable” (ERP, HRIS, dev/test) work makes on-prem uniquely appealing when done right. Segment out your resources (resist the urge for HPC or HCI), build sensible redundancies (on-prem or in the cloud), and lean on workhorse products over newer, fancier platforms (bulletproof hypervisors instead of fragile K8s clusters), and you can make the move successful and sensible. The more cowboy you go with GPUs, K8s, or local Terraform, the more delicate your infra becomes on-prem - and thus the riskier it is to keep there.
Keep it simple, silly.
and somehow i have this impression that gpus on slurm/pbs could not be simpler.
u can use a vm for the head node, dont even need the clustering really..if u can accept taking 20min to restore a vm.. and the rest of the hardware are homogeneous - you setup 1 right and the rest are identical.
and its a cluster with a job queue.. 1 node going down is not the end of the world..
ok if u have pcie GPUs sometimes u have to re-seat them and its a pain. otherwise if ur h200 or disks fail u just replace them, under warranty or not...
>> $120K isn't going to cover the fully loaded costs of an SRE who can set up and run that.
> Literally this. I can do SRE on-prem and cloud, and my 50/30/20 budget break-even point (as in, needs and savings but no wants - so 70%) is $170k before taxes. Rent is astonishingly high right now, and the sort of mid-career professional you want to handle SRE for your single DC is going to take $150k in this market before fucking off to the first $200k job they get.
That's $120k per pod. Four pods per rack at 50kW.
What universe are we living in that a single SRE can't manage even a single rack for less than half a million in total comp?
The kind where TC isn’t measured by pod managed, but by person hired. Also the world where median rent in major metros is $3500 a month.
If you think $120k is rich, you’re either operating in the boonies, outside the USA/Canada, or incredibly out of touch with the cost of living today and need to seriously go study BLS/FRED/CPI data sets to understand how expensive it is to live right now.
Indeed, there's no reason for a company to host this kind of batch compute in North America. You can get very good people in Eastern Europe at 1/3 the cost.
The first is that SRE team size primarily scales with the number of applications and level of support. It does scale with hardware but sublinearly, where number of applications usually scales super linearly. It takes a ton less effort to manage 100 instances of a single app than 1 instance of 100 separate apps (presuming SRE has any support responsibilities for the app). Talking purely in terms of hardware would make me concerned that I’m looking at an impossible task.
The second (which you probably know, but interacts with my next point) is that you never have single person SRE teams because of oncall. Three is basically the minimum, four if you want to avoid oncall burnout.
The last is that I don’t know many SREs (maybe none at all) that are well-versed enough in all the hardware disciplines to manage a footprint the size we’re talking. If each SRE is 4 racks and a minimum team size is 4, that’s 16 racks. You’d need each SRE to be comfortable enough with networking, storage, operating system, compute scheduling (k8s, VMWare, etc) to manage each of those aspects for a 16 rack system. In reality, it’s probably 3 teams, each of them needs 4 members for oncall, so a floor of like 48 racks. Depending on how many applications you run on 48 racks, it might be more SREs that split into more specialized roles (a team for databases, a team for load balancers, etc).
Numbers obviously vary by level of application support. If support ends at the compute layer with not a ton of app-specific config/features, that’s fewer folks. If you want SRE to be able to trace why a particular endpoint is slow right now, that’s more folks.
That's vastly overstating it. You hit nail in the head in previous paragraphs, it's number of apps (or more generally speaking ,environments) that you manage, everything else is secondary.
And that is especially true with modern automation tools. Doubling rack count is big chunk of initial time spent moving hardware of course, but after that there is almost no difference in time spent maintaining them.
In general time per server spent will be smaller because the bigger you grow the more automation you will generally use and some tasks can be grouped together better.
Like, at previous job, server was installed manually, coz it was rare.
At my current job it's just "boot from network, pick the install option, enter the hostname, press enter". Doing whole rack (re)install would take you maybe an hour, everything else in install is automated, you write manifest for one type/role once, test it, and then it doesn't matter whether its' 2 or 20 servers.
If we grew server fleet say 5-fold, we'd hire... one extra person to a team of 3. If number of different application went 5-fold we'd probably had to triple the team size - because there is still some things that can be made more streamlined.
Tasks like "go replace failed drive" might be more common but we usually do it once a week (enough redundancy) for all servers that might've died, if we had 5x the number of servers the time would be nearly the same because getting there dominates the 30s that is needed to replace one.
You could have SRE do it, but most places don’t because you can get someone to swap a dead drive for way cheaper (it’s not really a complicated operation).
That growth of SRE teams comes from wanting reliability further up the stack. If you’re not on AWS, there’s no Aurora so someone has to be DBA to do backups, performance monitoring, configuring failovers for when a disk dies and RAID needs to rebuild, etc. Same for network, networked storage, yada yada
Never been an SRE but interact with them all the time…
My own personal experience is there is commonly a division between App SREs that look after the app layer and Infra SREs that looks after the infrastructure layer (K8S, storage, network, etc)
The App SRE role absolutely scales with the number of distinct apps. The extent to which the Infra SRE role does depends on how diverse the apps are in terms of their infrastructure demands
It sort of comes back to support levels. Your Infra SRE teams stay small if either a) an app SRE team owns application specific stuff, or b) SRE just doesn’t support application specific stuff. Eg if a particular query is slow but the DB is normal, who owns root causing that? Whoever does needs headcount, whether it’s app SRE, infra SRE or the devs.
Most companies I have seen have never updated the BIOS of their servers, nor the firmware on their switches. Some of those have production applications on Windows XP or older and you can see VMware ESXi < 6.5 still in the wild. The same for all kinds of other systems including Oracle Linux 5.5 with some ancient Oracle DB like 10g or something, that was the case like 5 years ago but I don't think the company has migrated away completely to this day.
Any sufficiently old company will accrete systems and approaches of various vintages over time only very slowly ripping out some of those systems. Usually what happens is that parts of old systems or old workarounds will live on for decades after they have been supposedly decommissioned. I had a colleague who was using CRT monitors in 2020 with computers of similar vintage, probably with Pentium III or early Pentium IV, because he had everything set up there and it just worked for what he was doing. I don't admire it, yet that stuff works and I do respect that people don't want to replace expensive systems just because they are out of support, when they do actually work and they have people taking care of them.
If you're doing regular inference for a product with very flat throughput requirements (and you're doing on-prem already), on-prem GPUs can make a lot of sense.
But if you're doing a lot of training, you have very bursty requirements. And the H100s are specifically for training.
If you can have your H100 fleet <38% utilized across time, you're losing money.
If you have batch throughput you can run on the H100s when you're not training, you're probably closer to being able to wanting on-prem.
But the other thing to keep in mind is that AWS is not the only provider. It is a particularly expensive provider, and you can buy capacity from other neoclouds if you are cost-sensitive.
You wanted sysadmins / IT / data center technicians.
no shortage of IT talent in 2026, the market is literally overflowing with resumes and wages are dropping. huge gluts of fairly generic online degree holders.
they can use AI to write basic Ansible just as well as my Seniors
The company did need the same exact people to manage AWS anyway. And the cost difference was so high that it was possible to hire 5 more people which wasn't needed anyway.
Not only the cost but not needing to worry about going over the bandwidth limit and having soo much extra compute power made a very big difference.
Imo the cloud stuff is just too full of itself if you are trying to solve a problem that requires compute like hosting databases or similar. Just renting a machine from a provider like Hetzner and starting from there is the best option by far.
That is incorrect. On AWS you need a couple DevOps that will Tring together the already existing services.
With on premise, you need someone that will install racks, change disks, setup high availability block storage or object storage, etc. Those are not DevOps people.
Real Devops people are competent from physical layer to software layer.
Signed,
Aerospace Devop
This is usually not the case because DevOps are often people that mostly worked on cloud services and Kubernetes clusters and not real hardware since most companies do not have on premise hardware anymore.
we have 7 racks and 3 people. The things you mentioned aren't even 5% of the workload.
There are things you figure out once, bake into automation, and just use.
You install server once and remove it after 5-10 years, depending on how you want to depreciate it. Drives die rarely enough it's like once every 2 months event at our size
The biggest expense is setting up automation (if I was re-doing our core infrastructure from scratch I'd probably need good 2 months of grind) but after that it's free sailing. Biggest disadvantage is "we need a bunch of compute, now", but depending on business that might never be a problem, and you have enough savings to overbuild a little and still be ahead. Or just get the temporary compute off cloud.
And depending on the problem set in question, one can also potentially leverage "the cloud" for the big bursty compute needs and have the cheap colo for the day to day stuff.
For instance, in a past life the team I worked on needed to run some big ML jobs while having most things on extremely cheap colo infra. Extract the datasets, upload the extracted and well-formatted data to $cloud_provider, have VPN connectivity for the small amount of other database traffic, and we can burst to have whatever compute needed to get the computations done really quick. Copy the results artifact back down, deploy to cheap boxes back at the datacenter to host for clients stupid-cheap.
Not quite. If you hire a bad talent to manage your 'cloud gear' then you would find what the mistakes which would cost you nothing on-premises would cost you in the cloud. Sometimes - a lot.
Is it still a problem in 2026 when unemployment in IT is rising? Reasons can be argued (the end of ZIRP or AI) but hiring should be easier than it was at any time during the last 10 years.
Before I drop 5 figures on a single server, I'd like to have some confidence in the performance numbers I'm likely to see. I'd expect folk who are experienced with on-prem have a good intuition about this - after a decade of cloud-only work, I don't.
Also, cloud networking offers a bunch of really nice primitives which I'm not clear how I'd replicate on-prem.
I've estimated our IT workload would roughly double if we were to add physically racking machines, replacing failed disks, monitoring backups/SMART errors etc. That's... not cheap in staff time.
Moving things on-prem starts making financial sense around the point your cloud bills hit the cost of one engineers salary.
Like what?
In AWS, it's straightforward to say e.g. "permit traffic on port X from instances holding IAM role Y".
You can easily e.g. get the firewall rules for all your ec2 instances in a structured format.
I really would not look forward to building something even 1/10th as functional as that.
Meanwhile lots of enterprise firewalls barely even have a concept of "zones". Its practically not even close to comparing for most deployments. Maybe with extremely fancy firewall stacks with $ $MAX_INT service contracts one can do something similar. But I guess with on-prem stuff things are often less ephemeral, so there's slightly less need.
Kubernetes is running on bare metal quite a lot of places.
S3 has excellent legal and auditory settings for data, as well as automatic data retention policies.
KMS is a very secure and well done service. I dare you to find an equivalent on-prem solution that offers as much security.
And then there's the whole DR idea. Failing over to another AWS region is largely trivial if you set it up correctly - on prem is typically custom to each organization, so you need to train new staff with your organizations workflows. Whereas in AWS, Route53 fail-over routing (for example) is the same across every organization. This reduces cost in training and hiring.
Network engineers do network engineering :)
That's why nowadays one would use a managed collocation service, not hosting a rack in the office basement.
That's partially true; managing cloud also takes skill, most people forget that with end result being "well we saved on hiring sysadmins, but had to have more devops guys". Hell I manage mostly physical infrastructure (few racks, few hundred VMs) and good 80% of my work is completely unrelated to that, it's just the devops gluing stuff together and helping developers to set their stuff up, which isn't all that different than it would be in cloud.
> And remember, you want 24/7 monitoring, replication for disaster recovery, etc.
And remember, you need that for cloud too. Plenty of cloud disaster stories to see where they copy pasted some tutorial thinking that's enough then surprise.
There is also partial way of just getting some dedicated servers from say OVH and run infra on that, you cut out a bit of the hardware management from skillset and you don't have the CAPEX to deal with.
But yes, if it is less than at least a rack, it's probably not worth looking for onprem unless you have really specific use case that is much cheaper there (I mean less than usual half)
On top of that no one really knows what the fuck they are doing in AWS anyway.
This comes up again and again. It was the original sales pitch from cloud vendors.
Often the very same companies repeating this messaging are recruiting and paying large teams of platform developers to manage their cloud…and pay for them to be on call.
Generalists (it me) typically command lower market rates, remain far more flexible, and can replicate much of the experience on-prem while knowing when and why to put something in the public cloud. A few examples:
* 24/7 Telemetry and Monitoring: if you have the talent to roll your own with OpenTelemetry, Grafana, Prometheus, and a database to store the telemetry involved, then great! If it’s me wrangling a hybrid environment though, I’m likely leaning on New Relic to save on headcount and deliver similar results.
* DBaaS: this is increasingly just offered by hypervisor managers since it’s often just spooling up a container and pointing to storage. Not quite a “solved problem”, but enough of one that a single DBA can cover both estates if needed - or a moderately skilled generalist can at least secure it for internal use before offering it out to customers
* Vulnerability Management: as much as I’d love to have an internal Red Team, it’s an order of magnitude cheaper to leverage Nessus, Wazuh, Wiz, or any of the other fleets of continuous scanners to identify vulnerabilities or misconfigurations
That’s just me cherry-picking. The point is less “do everything possible on-prem”, and more “diversify workload placement depending on cost advantages relative to risk models”, and on-prem wins quite handily for a lot of LOB software that just quietly sits and does its thing with minimal fuss.
At my job we use HyperV, and finding someone who actually knows HyperV is difficult and expensive. Throw in Cisco networking, storage appliances, etc to make it 99.99% uptime...
Also that means you have just one person, you need at least two if you don't want gaps in staffing, more likely three.
Then you still need all the cloud folks to run that.
We have a hybrid setup like this, and you do get a bit of best of both worlds, but ultimately managing onprem or colo infra is a huge pain in the ass. We only do it due to our business environment.
> At my job we use HyperV, and finding someone who actually knows HyperV is difficult and expensive...
Try offering significantly higher pay.
All of the complexity of onprem, especially when you need to worry about failover/etc can get tricky, especially if you are in a wintel env like a lot of shops are.
i.e. lots of companies are doing sloppy 'just move the box to an EC2 instance' migrations because of how VMWare jacked their pricing up, and now suddenly EC2/EBS/etc costing is so cheap it's a no brain choice.
I think the knowledge base to set up a minimal cost solution is too tricky to find a benefit vs all the layers (as you almost touched on, all the licensing at every layer vs a cloud provider managing...)
That said, rug pulls are still a risk; I try to push for 'agnostic' workloads in architecture, if nothing else because I've seen too many cases where SaaS/PaaS/etc decide to jack up the price of a service that was cheap, and sure you could have done your own thing agnostically, but now you're there, and migrating away has a new cost.
IOW, I agree; I don't think the human capital is there as far as infra folks who know how to properly set up such environments, especially hitting the 'secure+productive' side of the triangle.
I’ve had success with this approach by keeping it to only the business process management stacks (CRMs, AD, and so on—examples just like the ones you listed). But as soon as there’s any need for bridging cloud/onprem for any data rate beyond “cronned sync” or “metadata only”, it starts to hurt a lot sooner than you’d expect, I’ve found.
Folks wanting one or the other miss savings had by effectively leveraging both.
(For various reasons, I just care about VPS/bare metal, and S3-compatiblity.)
I'm looking at those because I'm having difficulty forecasting bandwidth usage, and the pessimistic scenarios seem to have me inside the acceptable use policies of the small providers while still predicting AWS would cost 5-10x more for the same workload.
If that's you then the GraniteRapids AP platform that launched previously to this can hit similar numbers of threads (256 for the 6980P). There are a couple of caveats to this though - firstly that there are "only" 128 physical cores and if you're using VMs you probably don't want to share a physical core across VMs, secondly that it has a 500W TDP and retails north of $17000, if you can even find one for sale.
Overall once you're really comparing like to like, especially when you start trying to have 100+GbE networking and so on, it gets a lot harder to beat cloud providers - yes they have a nice fat markup but they're also paying a lot less for the hardware than you will be.
Most of the time when I see takes like this it's because the org has all these fast, modern CPUs for applications that get barely any real load, and the machines are mostly sitting idle on networks that can never handle 1/100th of the traffic the machine is capable of delivering. Solving that is largely a non-technical problem not a "cloud is bad" problem.
Darkmont is a slightly improved variant of the Skymont cores used in Arrow Lake/Lunar Lake and it has a performance very similar to the Arm Neoverse V3 cores used in Graviton5, the latest generation of custom AWS CPUs.
However, a Clearwater Forest Xeon CPU has much more cores per socket than Graviton5 and it also supports dual-socket motherboards.
Darkmont also has a greater performance than the older big Intel cores, like all Skylake derivatives, inclusive for AVX-using programs, so it is no longer comparable with the Atom series of cores from which it has evolved.
Darkmont is not competitive in absolute performance with AMD Zen 5, but for the programs that do not use AVX-512 it has better performance per watt.
However, since AMD has started to offer AVX-512 for the masses, the number of programs that have been updated to be able to benefit from AVX-512 is increasing steadily, and among them are also applications where it was not obvious that using array operations may enhance performance.
Because of this pressure from AMD, it seems that this Clearwater Forest Xeon is the final product from Intel that does not support AVX-512. Both next 2 Intel CPUs support AVX-512, i.e. the Diamond Rapids Xeon, which might be launched before the end of the year, and the desktop and laptop CPU Nova Lake, whose launch has been delayed to next year (together with the desktop Zen 6, presumably due to the shortage of memories and production allocations at TSMC).
It's unfortunately not so cut and dry
On-prem wins for a stable organization every time though.
* sign the papers for server colo * get quote and order servers (which might take few weeks to deliver!), near always a pair of switches * set them up, install OSes, set up basic services inside the network (DNS, often netboot/DHCP if you want to have install over network, and often few others like image repository, monitoring etc.)
It's "we have product and cashflow, let's give someone a task to do it" thing, not "we're a startup ,barely have PoC" thing
Im pretty sure a box like this could run our whole startup, hosting PG, k8s, our backend apis, etc, would be way easier to setup, and not cost 2 devops and $40,000 a month to do it.
The core density is bullshit when each core is so slow that it can't do any meaningful work. The reality is that Intel is 3 times behind AMD/TSMC on performance vs power consumption ratio.
People would be better off having a look at the high frequency models (9xx5F models like the 9575F), that was the first generation of CPU server to reach ~5 GHz and sustain it on 32+ cores.
AMD has had these sorts of densities available for a minute.
> Identify the workloads that haven't scaled in a year.
I have done this math recently, and you need to stop cherry picking and move everything. And build a redundant data center to boot.
Compute is NOT the major issue for this sort of move:
Switching and bandwidth will be major costs. 400gb is a minimum for interconnects and for most orgs you are going to need at least that much bandwidth top of rack.
Storage remains problematic. You might be able to amortize compute over this time scale, but not storage. 5 years would be pushing it (depending on use). And data center storage at scale was expensive before the recent price spike. Spinning rust is viable for some tasks (backup) but will not cut it for others.
Human capital: Figuring out how to support the hardware you own is going to be far more expensive than you think. You need to expect failures and staff accordingly, that means resources who are going to be, for the most part, idle.
I agree, but.
For one, it's not just the machines themselves. You also need to budget in power, cooling, space, the cost of providing redundant connectivity and side gear (e.g. routers, firewalls, UPS).
Then, you need a second site, no matter what. At least for backups, ideally as a full failover. Either your second site is some sort of cloud, which can be a PITA to set up without introducing security risks, or a second physical site, which means double the expenses.
If you're a publicly listed company, or live in jurisdictions like Europe, or you want to have cybersecurity insurance, you have data retention, GDPR, SOX and a whole bunch of other compliance to worry about as well. Sure, you can do that on-prem, but you'll have a much harder time explaining to auditors how your system works when it's a bunch of on-prem stuff vs. "here's our AWS Backup plans covering all servers and other data sources, here is the immutability stuff, here are plans how we prevent backup expiry aka legal hold".
Then, all of that needs to be maintained, which means additional staff on payroll, if you own the stuff outright your finance team will whine about depreciation and capex, and you need to have vendors on support contracts just to get firmware updates and timely exchanges for hardware under warranty.
Long story short, as much as I prefer on-prem hardware vs the cloud, particularly given current political tensions - unless you are a 200+ employee shop, the overhead associated with on-prem infrastructure isn't worth it.
You can technically have backblaze's unlimited backup option which costs around 7$ for a given machine although its more intended for windows, there have been people who make it work and Daily backups and it should work with gdpr (https://www.backblaze.com/company/policy/gdpr) with something like hetzner perhaps if you are worried about gdpr too much and OVH storage boxes (36 TB iirc for ~55$ is a good backup box) and you should try to follow 3-2-1 strategy.
> Then, all of that needs to be maintained, which means additional staff on payroll, if you own the stuff outright your finance team will whine about depreciation and capex, and you need to have vendors on support contracts just to get firmware updates and timely exchanges for hardware under warranty.
I can't speak for certain but its absolutely possible to have something but iirc for companies like dell, its possible to have products be available on a monthly basis available too and you can simply colocate into a decent datacenter. Plus points in that now you can get 10-50 GB ports as well if you are too bandwidth hungry and are available for a lot lot more customizable and the hardware is already pretty nice as GP observed. (Yes Ram prices are high, lets hope that is temporary as GP noted too)
I can't speak about firmware updates or timely exchanges for hardware under security.
That being said, I am not saying this is for everyone as well. It does essentially boils down to if they have expertise in this field/can get expertise in this field or not for cheaper than their aws bills or not. With many large AWS bills being in 10's of thousands of dollars if not hundreds of thousands of dollars, I think that far more companies might be better off with the above strategy than AWS actually.
Sure, but it doesn't solve the issue of "the datacenter is on fire" - neither if you're fully on prem or if you use colocation. You still need to acquire a new set of hardware, rack it, reconfigure the networking hardware and then restore from backups. That's an awful lot of work, and yes, I've been there.
Not a shortage - price gouging. And it would mean an increase in the 'cloud' prices because they need to refresh the HW too. So by the summer the equation would be back to it.
Its hard drive and SSD space prices that stagger me on the cloud. Where one of the server CPUs might only be about 2x the price of buy a CPU for a few years if you buy less in a small system (all be it with less clock speed usually on the cloud) the drive space is at least 10-100x the price of doing it locally. Its got a bit more potential redudency but for that overhead you can repeat that data a lot of times.
As time has gone on the deal of cloud has got worse as the hardware got more cores.
That makes a lot of sense. Cloud providers are selling compute, and as cores get faster, the single core gets more expensive.
>Anyway, I wasn't able to test using proxmox or vmware on there to split up cpu/memory resources; we decided instead to just buy a bunch of smaller-core-count AMD Ryzen 1Us instead, which scaled way better with my naive approac
If that was single 384 (192 times 2 for hyperthreading) CPU you are getting "only" 12 DDR5 channels, so one RAM channel is shared by 16c/32y
So just plain 16 core desktop Ryzen will have double memory bandwidth per core
And 384 actual cores or 384 hyperthreading cores?
Inference is so memory bandwidth heavy that my expectations are low. An EPYC getting 12 memory channels instead of 2 only goes so far when it has 24x as many cores.
cloud = opex
The accounting dept will always win this debate.
- request some HW to run $service
- the "IT dept" (really, self-interested gatekeeper) might give you something now, or in two weeks, or god help you if they need to order new hardware then its in two months, best case
- there will be various weird rules on how the on-prem HW is run, who has access etc, hindering developer productivity even further
- the hardware might get insanely oversubscribed so your service gets half a cpu core with 1GB RAM, because perverse incentives mean the "IT dept" gets rewarded for minimizing cost, while the price is paid by someone else
- and so on...
The cloud is a way around this political minefield.
Until the bills _really_ start skyrocketing...
As other people have pointed out: what happens when the PSU or mobo shits itself, what happens when the new version of vmware or docker (or whatever) shits itself, etc
Context: been helpdesk, sysadmin & network admin, DevOps, Site Reliability Engineer, in that progression, starting in the 90's. Max on-prem was 40 racks, scaled up and down over years.
Many comments talking about how staffing is a key element of this equation that can't be overlooked, but I decided to reply to the root comment, which doesn't say whether/how it considers staffing.
This is a complex equation - and it is relatively easy to present an incomplete or misleading picture management to push the move into the cloud.. or out of the cloud.
Some factors, in no particular order:
1) Scaling: it is self-evident that pulling a single physical server worth out of the cloud is not worth it.. even for 288 cores. Or perhaps 1152 for 4xXeon in a single server. Still likely not worth it. Why? Because a single server is never just that. Someone has to swap components when it goes down. When it goes down.. ALL 1152 cores are down, along with everything they are doing. Is that acceptable for all applications running on all those cores? It is also appropriate supporting infrastructure - power, cooling, physical space. The "fairly obvious" minimum scaling is "enough servers that one can be entirely down for maintenance while keeping everything else running." But now you're paying for some overhead. At 2 servers, you're buying 2x what you need, half that capacity is idle all the time. And so on.
On this point - I think the other comments talking about "each SRE managing 4 (or 5, or 7)" racks missed the point entirely. SRE's should be doing scalable work, whether in the cloud, or on-prem. And they should NOT be swapping failed hard drives and power supplies. Designing a larger-than-one rack install is probably worth hiring consultants for if you don't have that expertise in-house, though the SREs that would be supporting it would need to supply lots of input. To some extent, server & network equipment vendors can also help. It is not trivial as the scale goes up. But then it should run for some years, with relatively unskilled people handling hardware failures and you can re-engage consultants if necessary to do upgrades as hardware and needs evolve.
But your SREs should be on-staff, and probably on-call to handle the software running on that hardware.. and to some extent to call the remote hands to deal with hardware failures.
2) Business needs: does the business need the tech skills that self-hosting requires for the core business? For example - if the business itself is cloud SAAS, maybe DIY-ing at least some of your infrastructure is right in your wheelhouse. If so - a modest increase in staff could mean a huge cost savings. But if not, all the cost of skilled staff to run it is simply part of the cost of in-housing this stuff.
3) Staffing: the people that swap broken hardware are not the same people that respond to pages because the business critical application crashed due to a bug. You can pay a colo facility for all this, typically by the hour - but it isn't cheap and you've got to supply all the spares etc. Is that part of your budget for on-prem?
4) On-call: maybe your self-hosted ERP system can be down every night and weekend without issues.. and even business hours can tolerate 98% uptime. But that doesn't mean you can get away without having someone on call - presumably you're hosting more than just this lowish-requirement ERP system. I'll disagree with other comments - the "no burnout" number of on-call staff you need is 6-7, not 4! Remember people take vacations too. This is well studied, and established, I'll reference Tom Limoncelli's books. This could be relatively cheap and require fewer staff with geo-distributed staff, and it would tend to overlap with staff you already use to provide on-call for anything you host on the cloud - so maybe for your situation it is close to a wash. But you can't forget to budget for it even if the line item is $0.
5) Vendor support: maybe you already have your own data center or colo and are hosting a ton of stuff. Why not move all your Atlassian stuff in house and save the hosting cost. Oh.. wups, Atlassian simply doesn't support that any more. Host it with Atlassian or GTFO. A minor point as most vendors would give you enough notice you can simply run out the lifetime of the hardware it is on and not replace it.
6) Market pricing: At one point Amazon was starting "by the minute, by the core cloud" (as opposed the older "cloudish" model of leasing only an entire physical server by the entire year) and priced a bit under market to get going. Then once they established dominance, they cranked the price WAY up for profit extraction. But now they do have some competition and they're a bit more selective about how they extract profits. In my perception they've shifted a lot of the profit taking to the value-added services rather than raw instance time, but I could be wrong. And they have HUGE costs - it is beyond naive to look at the per-hour cost of an instance and compare it to purchasing an identical physical server solely on the purchase price of that server. Corey Quinn / Duckbill group has spent a huge part of his career in this space - if you're already in the cloud 100% it is well worth optimizing those costs before you start comparing it to what on-prem might cost.
* Identify the workloads that haven't scaled in a year. Your ERPs, your HRIS, your dev/stage/test environments, DBs, Microsoft estate, core infrastructure, etc. (EDIT, from zbentley: also identify any cross-system processing where data will transfer from the cloud back to your private estate to be excluded, so you don't get murdered with egress charges)
* Run the cost analysis of reserved instances in AWS/Azure/GCP for those workloads over three years
* Do the same for one of these high-core "pizza boxes", but amortized over seven years
* Realize the savings to be had moving "fixed infra" back on-premises or into a colo versus sticking with a public cloud provider
Seriously, what took a full rack or two of 2U dual-socket servers just a decade ago can be replaced with three 2U boxes with full HA/clustering. It's insane.
Back in the late '10s, I made a case to my org at the time that a global hypervisor hardware refresh and accompanying VMware licenses would have an ROI of 2.5yrs versus comparable AWS infrastructure, even assuming a 50% YoY rate of license inflation (this was pre-Broadcom; nowadays, I'd be eyeballing Nutanix, Virtuozzo, Apache Cloudstack, or yes, even Proxmox, assuming we weren't already a Microsoft shop w/ Hyper-V) - and give us an additional 20% headroom to boot. The only thing giving me pause on that argument today is the current RAM/NAND shortage, but even that's (hopefully) temporary - and doesn't hurt the orgs who built around a longer timeline with the option for an additional support runway (like the three-year extended support contracts available through VARs).
If we can't bill a customer for it, and it's not scaling regularly, then it shouldn't be in the public cloud. That's my take, anyway. It sucks the wind from the sails of folks gung-ho on the "fringe benefits" of public cloud spend (box seats, junkets, conference tickets, etc...), but the finance teams tend to love such clear numbers.