News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by kllrnohj on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:07PM (#45541963)
Platforms usually deliver significant value that is hard to replicate. OpenAI doesn't have any such thing. It's trivially replaced, and there's many competitors already. OpenAI is ahead of the curve, but they don't seem to have any particular way to do sticky capture. Migrating to a different LLM is an afternoon's work at most, not nearly the complexity of porting an app between OS' or creating a robust hardware driver model.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by yen223 on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:17PM (#45543308)
A lot of the points also apply to Google as a search engine, yet we're still seeing Google owning about 90% of search engine usage.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by Andrex on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:50PM (#45545097)
Google was always terrified by the fact that they had no moat in Search. This was clear from interviews and articles at the time. That's why they decided to roll up the ad market instead, and once they had the advertisers Search became a self-fulfilling monopoly.

Google Search would be moatless if not for the AdMob purchase.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by BeetleB on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:26PM (#45543392)
Google search requires a lot of resources to crawl, keep indices up to date, and provide user level significance (i.e. different results to different users). Then couple it with their other services (Google Maps, etc).

The competitors have not come even close to Google's level of quality.

With LLMs, it's different. Gemini/Claude are as good, for the most part. And users don't care that much either - most use the standard free ChatGPT, which likely is worse than many competitors' paid models.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by psychoslave on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:58PM (#45544780)
It's not just the quality. The are people who do complain about how they perceive it significantly decreased over time. Yet there are many other factors, including presence as default search engine in so many setup out there.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by kllrnohj on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:50PM (#45543637)
Google is a product not a platform. How many companies are still using Google search for their intranets? (yes yes I'm old, don't remind me)

Meanwhile bing search is actually a platform, and is what then powers other "search engines" (duckduckgo, kagi, etc...)

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by aerhardt on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:32PM (#45542226)
Yeah, I'm extremely loyal to ChatGPT Plus and Codex, but is't because OpenAI has a native Mac app that I like, and Codex included with Plus and has served me well enough to not look at Claude. I like GPT-5 quite a bit as a user. I'll concede none of these are small things - they've had my money for 2+ years - but they're not gigantic advantages either.

At an enterprise level however, in the current workload I am dealing with, I can't get GPT-5 with high thinking to yield acceptable results; Gemini 2.5 Pro is crushing it in my tests.

Things are changing fast, and OpenAI seems to be the most dynamic player in terms of productization, but I'm still failing to see the moat.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by Insanity on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:07PM (#45543210)
I don’t think they will get any moat. I might be wrong on this of course, but I don’t see a killer feature for these stochastic parrots that can’t be easily replicated
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by ebb_earl_co on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:19PM (#45543333)
> … stochastic parrots… What a wonderful phrase, mind if I borrow it?
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by airstrike on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:40PM (#45543539)
It's commonly used at this point, for what it's worth
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by CamperBob2 on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:41PM (#45544660)
Never mind the phrase. If your parrot can compete in international math and programming competitions at the gold-medal level and make entire subreddits fail the Turing test, I would like to borrow your parrot.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by cmrdporcupine on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:49PM (#45543624)
"the term stochastic parrot is a metaphor, introduced by Emily M. Bender and colleagues in a 2021 paper, that frames large language models as systems that statistically mimic text without real understanding"

https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3442188.3445922

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by ajkjk on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:59PM (#45545923)
you don't have to get permission

plus, they didn't come up with it

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by airstrike on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:41PM (#45543549)
OpenAI is dynamic for consumer apps. Anthropic seems much better at productizing AI that you can actually build with, while also catering to enterprise in their own productized offerings

Also Claude Opus 4.1 runs multidimensional circles around GPT-5 in my view. The only better use case for GPT-5 is when you need it to scrape the web for data

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by moomoo11 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:15PM (#45543868)
Too bad Anthropic fucks over their 20x max subscribers. Their whole opus usage limit bullshit in favor of sonnet 4.5 which is objectively worse regardless of whatever they say. They clearly want to save money and take our $200.

https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/issues/8449

I hope they get destroyed in the AI race.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by airstrike on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:30PM (#45544580)
FWIW I don't disagree
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by moomoo11 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:12PM (#45543835)
I think their moat is ironically the platform.

Like Apple vs every other computer maker.

Their platform mostly just works. Their api playground and docs are like 100x better than whatever garbage Anthropic has.

I think their UX is way better, and I can have long AF conversations without lagging. I can even change models in the same conversation. Basic shit Anthropic can’t figure out (they can fleece their 20x max subscribers tho)

I think if they get the AI human interface right, they will have their iPhone moment and 10x.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by dabockster on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:29PM (#45544571)
The platform is just a search tool and extended processing modes. That is easily replicated elsewhere.

The only moat they have is the fact that you still need a GPU of some kind to reliably run even a tiny LLM. But the gap between what absolutely needs a server farm and what can be ran on a store bought gaming computer is quickly closing. You can already run mixture of experts models on gaming rigs with a high degree of usability compared to just one year ago. And that tech continues to be pushed further and further. It's only a matter of time until we see ChatGPT levels of access running on a quad core laptop totally offline. And once that happens, all such a system would need is the correct tooling on top of the AI model "brain" to make it usable.

And beyond that, what if you could have an AI model on an ASIC-style add-in card? Where's their moat then?

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by int_19h on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:35PM (#45545015)
Don't forget about Macs. Top models can run even fairly large LLMs (although time to first token is... not great). But even midline can certainly run LLMs in the ballpark of ~30B params very well, which is where things start to get interesting IMO.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by dabockster on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:54PM (#45545120)
> although time to first token is... not great

The token cache works on CUDA too. So yeah, the initial loadout sucks, but almost everything from then on is solid.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by int_19h on Saturday October 11, 2025 @10:23PM (#45554601)
This works for scenarios like a simple chat. But the moment you start throwing large documents on it, or lots of code, it's back to waiting.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by moomoo11 on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:31PM (#45545324)
I'd say their DX is way better compared to the competition. The playground, tooling, and web experience with documentation is far superior to the competition (even tho it has issues sometimes). User experience is key in a sea of the same shit.

I mean you could say the same about a Macbook or iPhone/iPad, but for the actual people (not HN users lol) out there, they vastly prefer Apple to HP, Dell, etc. Due to their wallet some can't though.

There are literally thousands of other laptops that do the "same thing" (computer for doing shit).

Those who say otherwise are usually broke and know deep down that given proper purchasing power, they too would prefer to use a $3k Macbook Pro than some POS Dell.

Same with android.

Everyone knows it is cope based on PP, it is just in poor taste to actually call it like it is (idc)

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by hattmall on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:59AM (#45546696)
Apple had innovative products that they went very heavy in brand based fashion merchandising. In addition they were a legacy brand with a generally favorable reputation and solid recognition. They built a strong moat based on those characteristics and finally hit the mass market non-tech target demographic with the most widely used emerging technology since the personal vehicle. Apple did this while successfully merging a hardware, software, and marketplace platform. OpenAI has some interesting software but has an incredibly long way to run and extremely unlikely path to becoming anything like Apple. Not only that, they are in a market that a lot of the general population finds questionably valuable if not outright unappealing.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by moomoo11 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @03:59PM (#45552197)
Apple was not an overnight success
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by auggierose on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:14PM (#45543854)
Actually, Anthrophic has a Mac app I can use, and I cannot use the OpenAI one.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by mettamage on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:15PM (#45544454)
Fun fact, it’s an Electron app
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by ks2048 on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:27PM (#45544970)
The irony of Claude being pretty good at writing Swift code.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by auggierose on Saturday October 11, 2025 @03:19AM (#45547303)
Yeah, and it works great on my Intel Mac. The OpenAI app doesn't work at all.

So guess which app I prefer. That's the argument for Electron, and it is a good one.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by int_19h on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:31PM (#45544988)
Interesting, so it's not just me who's finding Gemini 2.5 Pro to be the quiet leader? Deep Research also seems to be better in it, and the limits for that are far more generous to boot (20 per day on Gemini!).

Makes one wonder if Google will eventually sweep this field.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by yubblegum on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:17PM (#45542063)
> Migrating to a different LLM is an afternoon's work at most, not nearly the complexity of porting an app between OS' or creating a robust hardware driver model.

I question this. Each vendor's offering has its own peculiar prompt quirks, does it not? Theoretically, switching RDBMS vendors (say Ora to Ingress) was also "an afernoon's work" but it never happened. The minutia is sticky with these sort of almost-but-not 'universal' interfaces.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by mgh95 on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:21PM (#45542109)
> I question this. Each vendor's offering has its own peculiar prompt quirks, does it not? Theoretically, switching RDBMS vendors (say oracle to postgres) was also "an afernoon's work" but it never happened. The minutia is sticky with these sort of almost-but-not 'universal' interfaces.

The bigger problem is that there was never a way to move data between oracle->postgres in pure data form (i.e. point pgsql at your oracle folder and it "just works"). Migration is always a pain, and thus there is a substantial degree of stickiness, due to the cost of moving databases both in terms of risk and effort.

In contrast, vendors [1] are literally offering third party LLMS (such as claude) in addition to their own and offering one-click switching. This means users can try and if they desire switch with little friction.

[1] https://blog.jetbrains.com/ai/2025/09/introducing-claude-age...

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by RussianCow on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:11PM (#45543249)
Moreover, it's trivial to run several LLMs side-by-side for a while and measure the success of each, then migrate to the one that performs the best. And you can even migrate in-progress chats since all the context is passed on each call anyway.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by gretch on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:53PM (#45543047)
The current LLMs support data export/import inherently because the interface is pure text.

All one needs to do is say something like “tell me all of personalization factors you have on me” and then just copy and paste that into the next LLM with “here’s stuff you should know about how to personalize output for me”

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by kllrnohj on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:38PM (#45542276)
> The minutia is sticky with these sort of almost-but-not 'universal' interfaces.

True, but that's not really applicable here since LLMs themselves are not stable, and are certainly not stable within a vendors own product line. Like imagine if every time Oracle shipped a new version it was significantly behaviorally inconsistent with the previous one. Upgrading within a vendor and switching vendors ends up being the same task. So you quickly solidify on either

1) never upgrading, although with these being cloud services that's not necessarily feasible, and since LLMs are far from a local maxima in quality that'd quickly leave your stack obsolete

or

2) being forced to be robust, which makes it easy to migrate to other vendors

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by iamflimflam1 on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:25PM (#45542146)
If you are doing things “properly” then you have good evals that let you test the behaviour of different LLMs and see if they work for your problem.

The vendors have all standardised on OpenAIs API surface - you can use OpenAIs SDK with a number of providers - so switching is very easy. There are also quite a few services that offer this as a service.

The real test is does a different LLM work - hence the need to evals to check.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by jgalt212 on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:21PM (#45543345)
If you took any of current top 3 models from me, I would not miss the deleted one in the least. I run almost every non-trivial prompt through multiple models anyway.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by BeetleB on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:28PM (#45543428)
> Each vendor's offering has its own peculiar prompt quirks, does it not?

That applies even when you switch models within a vendor, though.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by impossiblefork on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:34PM (#45544028)
It's reasonable to question it, but there's a fun Chinese paper (https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.15855) where they attempt to create a system of prompts that can be used with commercial LLMs to solve hard maths problems.

It turns out that they can use the same prompt system for all of them, with no changes and still solve 5/6 IMO problems. I think this is possibly iffy, since people might have updated the models etc., but it's pretty obvious that this kind of thing is how OpenAI are doing their multi-stage thinking thing for maths internally.

Consequently if prompt systems are this transferable for these hard problems, why wouldn't both they and individual prompts, be highly transferable in general?

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by psychoslave on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:08PM (#45544852)
No, changing rdbms is a totally different challenge. They provide predictible reproducible output which are very sensitive and brittle to the slightest minor change in the input, while with LLM you expect the exact opposite.

Changing the LLM backend in some IDE is as complicated as selecting an option in a dropbox for those who integrate such a feature. They are other scenarios where it might be a bit more complicated to transition of course, but that's it.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by pants2 on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:54PM (#45542433)
Much of the value I get from ChatGPT is based on it's memory system that has a good profile on me. For example if I ask it to find me something to eat at X restaurant, it will already know my allergies, dietary preferences, weight goals, medications, other foods I like, etc and suggest an item based on that, all workout me explicitly telling it.

Moving from ChatGPT to Claude I would lose a lot of this valuable history.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by cool_dude85 on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:29PM (#45542791)
Or you could type up "My allergies are X, Y, Z, I have the following preferences..." etc. and put it into whatever chat bot you like. Obviously this is a bit of a pain, but it probably constrains significantly how much of a premium ChatGPT can charge. You might not bother if ChatGPT is time and a half more expensive, but what if it's 3x as much as the competition? What if there's a free alternative that's just as good?
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by pants2 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:02PM (#45543755)
I pay for the $200/mo ChatGPT, to me that's insanely cheap compared to the value it provides. Better pricing is highly unlikely to make me switch. If a competitor were able to sustain a lead in model intelligence/capability then I'd consider it.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by sumedh on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:30PM (#45543994)
> Or you could type up "My allergies are X, Y, Z, I have the following preferences..."

Why use a car when you can just walk?

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by nbngeorcjhe on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:39PM (#45546119)
tbh most americans could do with walking more
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by yannyu on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:54PM (#45544230)
Even simpler, ask ChatGPT "How would you describe my dietary preferences and restrictions?", maybe throw in some personality guidance of "You are training my executive assistant".
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by Fuzzwah on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:31PM (#45542812)
I like to ask each llm what it knows about me. I feel like I could take that output and feed it into another llm and the new one would be up to speed quickly....
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by scottyah on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:51PM (#45543026)
Have you tried asking ChatGPT to output everything it knows about you to a format easily digestible by LLMs? Does the memory stick between model switches?
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by pants2 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:03PM (#45543760)
I suspect it does RAG on my previous convos, so this wouldn't work fully, but to some extent yes that would help.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by labrador on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:48PM (#45542997)
The memory in Claude Sonnet 4.5 works differently. You can ask it to reference named chats such as "Here's what you should know about me" in your prompts.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by mattmanser on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:35PM (#45542864)
Still not much of a moat, especially with data portability.

In the EU/UK you might not have rights to the memories right now, but you've rights to the inputs that created those memories in the first place.

Wouldn't be too hard to export your chat history into a different AI automatically.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by cmrdporcupine on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:50PM (#45543646)
You could literally ask it to write out everything it knows about you into a form usable in a CLAUDE.md file, put that in the directory you're using e.g. claude code in, and boom.

No moat.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by threetonesun on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:23PM (#45542125)
The play OpenAI is making has nothing to do with the underlying models any more. They release good ones but it doesn't really matter, they're going for being the place people land when they open a web browser. That is incredibly sticky and not easily replaced. Being the company that replaces the phrase "oh just Google it" is worth half the money in the world, and I think they're well on their way to getting there.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by scottyah on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:53PM (#45543056)
I do say ChatGPT when referring to LLMs/genAI in general, but I do hate saying it as it is nowhere near as nice to say as "google". I will switch immediately once something better comes up.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by wilsonnb3 on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:35PM (#45544621)
“Chat” is already in the youth lexicon, originally referring to an amorphous blob of live stream viewers. It now kind of refers to a non-existent but omnipresent viewer of your life.

I think ChatGPT might turn into just “chat” as the next evolution of the term.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by kllrnohj on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:34PM (#45542240)
But that also makes them the product itself and requires standalone profitability which is not at all like the Windows' analogy being presented.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by threetonesun on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:47PM (#45542365)
I agree, in general. I don't know what the world looks like in 10 years if all of the weird attempts at fitting an LLM as a replacement to what we have currently actually works, however. Facebook is probably the closest analogy, where there's plenty of room to grow, but at some point you're going to have the OS builders shut down your efforts unless you want to build your own OS.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by Mistletoe on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:12PM (#45542002)
I actually prefer Google Gemini. 2.5 is free and works awesome for what I need AI for. It just made my resume I uploaded immeasurably better last night.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Bard/comments/1mkj4zi/chatgpt_pro_g...

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by llmslave on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:19PM (#45542089)
They only invented modern AI, can easily be replaced!!
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by kllrnohj on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:48PM (#45545090)
They did nothing of the sort. Google invented modern AI: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attention_Is_All_You_Need

OpenAI turned that research into a product before Google, which is a huge failure on Google's part, but that's orthogonal to the invention of what powers modern models.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by mallowdram on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:14PM (#45542039)
That's a precise, incisive observation: OpenAI is trivial (any AI provider is), supported by evidence as demonstrated. It has no claim to operating software that's specifically distinct from others.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by wahnfrieden on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:09PM (#45541984)
That's why they're working on consumer hardware
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by an0malous on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:21PM (#45542104)
And business partnerships, government partnerships, and AI regulation (to establish laws that keep competitors out). Sam knows they have no moat and will try every avenue to establish one.

As Peter Thiel says: “competition is for losers”

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by jorblumesea on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:09PM (#45541981)
they understand that, and that's why they're making it sticky by adding in app purchasing, advertising, integrations. also why they hired OGs from IG/FB. They are building the moat and hoping that first to market is going to work out.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by dantyti on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:24PM (#45542138)
I do not believe that advertising and purchasing is at the top of the list of things what make software sticky
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by jorblumesea on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:28PM (#45542178)
they are trying to become/replace google. they are first to market for an entirely new query paradigm and in app purchases and advertising are just one aspect of a platform.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by barrenko on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:09PM (#45541979)
You could say the same thing about Facebook...
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by chmod775 on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:15PM (#45542045)
You mean the social network that is currently dying the same death as countless other platforms before it, just on a larger scale?

Maybe some are too young to remember the great migrations from/to MySpace, MSN, ICQ, AIM, Skype, local alternatives like StudiVZ, ..., where people used to keep in contact with friends. Facebook was just the latest and largest platform where people kept in touch and expressed themselves in some way. People adding each other on Facebook before others to keep in touch hasn't been a thing for 5 years. It's Instagram, Discord, and WhatsApp nowadays depending on your social circle (two of which Meta wisely bought because they saw the writing on the wall).

If I open Facebook nowadays, then out of ~130 people I used to keep in touch with through that platform, pretty much nobody is still doing anything on there. The only sign of life will be some people showing as online because they've the facebook app installed to use direct messaging.

No, people easily migrate between these platforms. All it takes is put your new handles (discord ID/phone number/etc) as a sticky so people know where to find you. And especially children will always use whichever platform their parents don't.

Small caveat: This is a German perspective. I don't doubt there's some countries where Facebook is still doing well.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by nextworddev on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:21PM (#45543344)
Last time I checked 99% of normies are still happily scrolling FB and Instagram
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by cmrdporcupine on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:52PM (#45543659)
FB in particular is becoming deader and deader every month, and it's only a matter of time before something else comes along that sucks their attention away.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by nextworddev on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:31PM (#45544009)
The beauty of Meta is that they can just fake engagement metrics. Not defending them, just knowing that they do
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by nemothekid on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:32PM (#45543464)
>No, people easily migrate between these platforms.

No? It's rare for these platforms to survive, the one that was closest to challenging Facebook was kneecapped by the US government.

The time between the founding of MySpace to Facebook was a little over a year. Instagram has been the largest social network for close to decade now, and it's not like others haven't been trying. META is up 600% over last 3 years. I'm really question your definition of the word "dying"

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by HDThoreaun on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:16PM (#45550300)
meta made over 60 billion dollars last year. The idea that it is dying is lunacy
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by yc349833874923 on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:17PM (#45542066)
People say you're wrong but I agree. Facebook is nothing more than a rent-seeking middle man between you and your friends/family. Instead of just talking to your family normally, like over the phone, now you have to talk to them in between mountains of Sponsored Content and AI-generated propaganda. It provides no productive value to the world except for making the world more annoying and making people more isolated from one another.

When you realize this, you realize that a lot of other supposedly valuable tech companies operate in the exact same way. Worrying that our parents' retirement depends heavily on their valuations!

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by Karrot_Kream on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:22PM (#45542115)
> Worrying that our parents' retirement depends heavily on their valuations!

Maybe you should short the stock to hedge your parents' retirement :)

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by warkdarrior on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:12PM (#45542010)
FB has network effects (your friends/neighbors/etc are there). When I use ChatGPT, I don't care whether anyone else uses it as well.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by pixl97 on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:10PM (#45541993)
I mean, technically no, FB has a network effect of the other people on it either being the people you want to talk to, or the people you want to advertise to.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by wahnfrieden on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:10PM (#45541987)
Not at all, because it is not easy to replicate and move its social graph
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by ryukoposting on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:44PM (#45544682)
OpenAI's moat is the data you give it. It's the same reason so many people have GMail accounts, even though we all know Google sucks. It's not that you like GMail better than any other email service, it's because migrating to another service is a pain in the ass.

OpenAI will either use customer data to enshittify to a level never seen before, or they will go insolvent.

Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by DebtDeflation on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:47PM (#45544714)
That's why OpenAI is hard pivoting towards products now. The big one IMO is Instant Checkout and Agentic Commerce Protocol. ChatGPT is going to turn into a product recommendation engine and OpenAI is going to get a slice of every purchase, which is going to disrupt the current impression/click adtech model and potentially Google and Amazon themselves. It's an open question how hard they can do this without enshittifying ChatGPT itself, but we'll see.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by int_19h on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:38PM (#45545026)
The notion that people would be willing to let LLMs spend money is, frankly, insane given the hallucination problems that still don't have any clear solution in sight.
Re:It's OpenAI's world, we're just living in it by djmips on Saturday October 11, 2025 @01:22AM (#45546805)
Was windows hard to replicate? Not really.