News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by drawfloat on Monday August 11, 2025 @02:14PM (#44867506)
The law was passed by the previous government and everyone assumed the next government would take great delight in reversing it.

I wouldn’t be so sure that any next government (which, by the way, there is still a non zero chance could be Labour) will necessarily reverse this. Maybe Reform would tweak the topics, but I’m not convinced any party can be totally trusted to reverse this.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by adamm255 on Monday August 11, 2025 @04:19PM (#44868964)
If the current government reversed it, the 'oh think of the children' angle from the Tories/Reform against them would be relentless. I cant say they have been amazing at messaging as it is.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by weavejester on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:51PM (#44871478)
The current leaders of both the Conservatives and Reform are on record as being against the Act. While this doesn't preclude them changing their mind, it does make it more difficult for them to reverse course.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by petre on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:00AM (#44872272)
They will reverse it when politicians visiting pron sites are exposed through a leak or something. Everybody else uses VPNs.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by tomkarho on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:44AM (#44872484)
Politicians already use VPN and even expense it. They've got their ducks in a row.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mrandish on Monday August 11, 2025 @04:49PM (#44869317)
> I wouldn’t be so sure that any next government will necessarily reverse this.

Agreed. I think the supposed justifications for mass population-wide online surveillance, restrictions and de-anonymization are so strong most political parties in western democracies go along with what surveillance agencies push for once they get in power. Even in the U.S. where free speech & personal privacy rights are constitutionally and culturally stronger, both major parties are virtually identical in what they actually permit the surveillance state to do once they get in office (despite sometimes talking differently while campaigning).

The reason is that the surveillance state has gotten extremely good at presenting scary scenarios and examples of supposed "disaster averted because we could spy on everyone", or the alternative, "bad thing happened because we couldn't spy on everyone" to politicians in non-public briefings. They keep these presentations secret from public and press scrutiny by claiming it's necessary to keep "sources and methods" secret from adversaries. Of course, this is ridiculous because adversary spy agencies are certainly already aware of the broad capabilities of our electronic surveillance - it's their job after all and they do the same things to their own populations. The intelligence community rarely briefs politicians on individual operations or the exact details of the sources and methods which adversarial intelligence agencies would care about anyway. The vast majority of these secret briefings could be public without revealing anything of real value to major adversaries. At most it would only confirm we're doing the things adversaries already assume we're doing (and already take steps to counter). The real reason they hide the politician briefings from the public is because voters would be creeped out by the pervasive surveillance and domain experts would call bullshit on the incomplete facts and fallacious reasoning used to justify it to politicians.

Even if a politician sincerely intended to preserve privacy and freedom before getting in office, they aren't domain experts and when confronted with seemingly overwhelming (but secret) evidence of preventing "big bad" presented unanimously by intelligence community experts, the majority of elected officials go along. If that's not enough for the anti-privacy agencies (intel & law enforcement) to get what they want, there's always the "think of the children" arguments. It's the rare politician who's clear-thinking and principled enough to apply appropriate skepticism and measured nuance when faced with horrendous examples of child porn and abuse which the law enforcement/intelligence agency lobby has ready in ample supply and deploys behind closed doors for maximum effect. The anti-privacy lobby has figured out how to hack representative democracy to circumvent protections and because it's done away from public scrutiny, there's currently no way to stop them and it's only going to keep getting worse. IMHO, it's a disaster and even in the U.S. (where I am) it's only slightly better than the UK, Australia, EU and elsewhere.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by autoexec on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:53PM (#44871491)
> The reason is that the surveillance state has gotten extremely good at presenting scary scenarios and examples of supposed "disaster averted because we could spy on everyone", or the alternative, "bad thing happened because we couldn't spy on everyone" to politicians in non-public briefings.

Those politicians who are vocal against mass surveillance tend to change their tune the moment they're in office and I doubt they were all intending to go back on their campaign promises from the start or that they were really convinced by horror stories of terrorists told over powerpoint in closed door briefings.

I wouldn't doubt if they were also giving politicians examples of the kind of dirt they already have on them and their families. This is one of the biggest risks of the surveillance state. Endless blackmail material made up of actual skeletons, as well as the resources to install new ones into anyone's closets whenever needed.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by 20after4 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:14AM (#44872350)
Do what we say or we might get a warrant and find that stash of CP that we installed on your hard drive. How do you even defend against planted digital evidence? It would be easy to fake and very difficult to disprove.

But when it comes to politicians and people with power, I think it's even worse than all of that. It's kind of obvious what Mr Epstein was getting up to with regard to blackmail.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:28AM (#44872726)
> How do you even defend against planted digital evidence?

With your good name. In the end, it is not important what the politician had or did not have on the disk, but who the public will believe more, the secret services, who claim that there was something there, or the politician, who claims that he is being set up and groundlessly persecuted for the purpose of political pressure.

And as long as public opinion about the special services is what it is, politicians can safely stash CP on their disks without fear that they will be charged with anything even if they are found.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hopelite on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:39AM (#44874237)
You’re dismissing something way more complicated. Many people with good names have supposedly had CP hoards. How would you even go about checking out confirming that it even is CP? You can’t, and would you even want to look into that? No, of course not.

Frankly, it could even just be made up. How would you know? I’m sure in most cases it is true and correct, but with as much corruption in every and all aspects of policing and justice, there is absolutely zero chance that when it involves something with such huge and hidden levers as CP, that there would be zero corruption. Cops still plant drugs on people even though they know they are on body cam and they still shoot people to death for no reason and are simply absolved by the system that protects itself; you don’t think that the black box of CP accusation that no one wants to or can look into is not used for corrupt reasons?

The whole system is rotten and corrupt, why wouldn’t it be corrupt in this case where there is a huge lever and no one dares look into it?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by account42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:21AM (#44874456)
I bet you have never witnessed someone being accused of even a much less severe social taboo. They won't even be given the chance to defend themselves.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:21AM (#44872695)
I don't think it's blackmailing. Total surveillance by itself is just a great tool (when you have it in your hands). Why give it up?
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by john01dav on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:55PM (#44871505)
If these claims are accurate, then the solution is obvious: elected officials who are themselves domain experts in this. They can then explain to their colleagues why these arguments are bullshit.

But, I expect that that won't help because your claims don't tell the while story. Most representatives don't act in good faith and like the government that they're a part of having such power.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:18AM (#44872669)
Why do you think politicians are idiots?

Yes, many of them are really stupid people. But they are not idiots. I think 95 percent of them are perfectly aware of why the laws they pass are really needed. And they pass them EXACTLY FOR THIS, and not at all for protecting children and internet safety.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hopelite on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:57AM (#44874332)
There irony is that people who call politicians stupid are generally not very smart people themselves in my experience, regardless of various forms of advanced degrees they believe disproves that.

They may be puppets, they may be manipulators, they may be con-artists, they may be liars; but what does it say about oneself if an “idiot” managed to become one of a few hundred most powerful humans on this planet and in all of human history (in the case of an American politician) and you did not?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by imtringued on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:38AM (#44877729)
Considering the average age and net worth of American politicians. I certainly know that it is almost exclusive to rich old men.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by account42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:22AM (#44874465)
Why do you think politicians look out for what is "really needed" rather than what is beneficial to themselves.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:57AM (#44874677)
What do you mean "why"? They do not.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by pyuser583 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:05AM (#44872933)
A big problem is private entities do so much spying, it becomes hard to argue against.

We collect tons of data on people to sell ads. Why not to save children?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by autoexec on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:44PM (#44871440)
Governments do seem to hate weakening their power over the population.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hilbert42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:38AM (#44872777)
If Wiki had the guts it'd leave the UK. Nothing will happen unless there's a backlash from the citizenry.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by verisimi on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:45AM (#44872808)
Wiki isn't the citizenry.

And no one voted for this.

When one votes in this so-called "democracy", one votes for a representative to represent 'you and thousands of others' on thousands of decisions.

And even then, if both parties want to do something, as in this case, there is nowhere to go.

This is force. If you can't say 'no', this is immoral, coercive force, even if the person or party doing the forcing says it isn't.

And no, the forcer (government) won't give back freedoms (the right to privacy) that it takes away.

In the end, the only moral, respectful and free way to proceed, without force, ie where people opt in. Individuals would opt in/out to paying tax for wars/schools/online safety, etc.

"But it is impossible that everyone should be allowed to only opt in to the decisions they like!" .. is only the case because we think it is normal to endlessly abused by governments and because so many citizens are dependent on its handouts.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by novok on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:26AM (#44873391)
They are not, but they are central resource that the citizenry uses. If enough of the internet enters an embargo with the UK, they will probably capitulate because more and more of the citizenry will realize what is happening, be greatly inconvenienced, reduce the UK's GDP and complain. IMO I hope more big websites do block the UK.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by bratbag on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:18AM (#44875293)
The libertarian fantasy where its possible to exist without the choices of others impacting you, doesn't work in the real world.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hilbert42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:17AM (#44877371)
True, but in the UK (and many other so-called democracies) it's not fellow citizens/voters who impact our lives the most.

Rather, it's vested and sectional interests who control power and or have the most effective means to bring the citizenry around to their way of thinking.

As Chomsky would put it, these few have the means to manufacture consent.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hilbert42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:48AM (#44876941)
"Wiki isn't the citizenry."

I never said or implied it was. If Wiki packed up and deserted the UK we'd have an actual measure of the opposition. At the moment we don't.

"When one votes in this so-called "democracy", one votes for a representative to represent 'you and thousands of others' on thousands of decisions."

I'm well aware of that. Also the argument that a politician when in government gets to see a broader picture than his or her constituency and thus may vote against its (narrower/sectional) wishes.

I'd also remind you of the perils of voting against the wishes of one's constituency. The famous case of the conservative Edmund Burke the Member for Bristol illustrates the point. He was summarily booted out at the following election for voting against the wishes of his voters.

If Wiki leaves it'll polarize the electorate, we'll then see what happens. If Wiki stays with some mushy compromise the issue won't be resolved.

At the moment democracy isn't working properly which allows vested and sectional interests to slip in and rule (and in this respect the UK is arguably the worst).

The other point is nothing frightens government more than truly angry voters. Trouble is, UK voters are so under the thumb of government they're frightened to show who is actually in charge in a democracy. De facto, the gnomes and bureaucrats rule.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by madaxe_again on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:36AM (#44873435)
The way this works is that the backlash would be directed at Wikipedia.

Your average citizen neither knows nor cares about the legislative landscape - they just know that the daily mail says Wikipedia hates the U.K. and is staffed by communists.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by neltnerb on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:53AM (#44873557)
Can't they make it so that anyone from that geographical location is required to prove their identity and log in to view the articles? That seems like it'd be sufficient and sure I'd be annoyed at Wikipedia but if they linked to the law I feel like people would get it.

Of course now no one needs to visit Wikipedia because Google has already scraped them with AI so you can just see the maybe accurate summary. Seems risky, as if you should have to log in to use Google since the AI might have forbidden information.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by tracker1 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:56PM (#44879719)
Given the size of Google, I'm not sure if/how they're excluded from this and may actually ask for real identities of UK users they don't already "know" via other means of Google Wallet, etc.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by monooso on Monday August 11, 2025 @10:21PM (#44871633)
Every single Labour politician who voted on this bill voted against it.

Peter Kyle was one such MP, and now he's making statements like:

> I see that Nigel Farage is already saying that he’s going to overturn these laws. So you know, we have people out there who are extreme pornographers, peddling hate, peddling violence. Nigel Farage is on their side.

It's maddening. The worst part is that they've somehow put me in the position of defending Nigel Farage.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Jimmc414 on Monday August 11, 2025 @11:33PM (#44872105)
> The worst part is that they've somehow put me in the position of defending Nigel Farage.

I've come to believe that is the point of forcing people to choose between extreme polarizing positions. It makes disengagement feel like the only moderate move.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by ozim on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:02AM (#44872916)
Feels utterly demoralizing when you have to vote for lesser evil and not for someone you feel will be better for the future.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Jolter on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:06AM (#44873257)
”The lesser evil” is the essence of any two-party system. Which I would somewhat facetiously classify the UK system as. Abolish ”first past the post” and introduce proportional representation now!
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by bell-cot on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:41AM (#44873470)
Disagree. If the society is essentially "broken", with little sense of everyone working together to build and secure a positive future, then two-party systems can degenerate into "but they're even worse!" races to the bottom.

But in better circumstances, there is enormous social pressure (at least on mainstream parties) to be much higher functioning, and willing and able to lead the nation toward a positive future.

(Yes, I think that political reform could be of some use in the UK. Some. The underlying problems would mostly remain.)

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Jolter on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:41AM (#44873868)
I would say that what you wrote in the first two paragraphs is all equally true of a system with proportional representation. But you’d avoid a lot of problems:

- people in ”safe” constituencies being permanently represented by an MP from an opposing party, with no recourse except for moving

- policies that constantly pander to voters in ”swing” constituencies

- the two major parties constantly triangulating their policies around the center, rather than voters moving their votes to the party representing their opinions, which ensures that government is always centrist or near-centrist

Etc — these are just my pet peeves about the US and UK systems, I know there are more.

Plus, I think it’s good if a system is more robust against loss of trust that you mentioned. You could argue that in the UK, society hasn’t yet been broken, but looking at the US, don’t you think it’s better not to have that vulnerability?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:51AM (#44873936)
> But in better circumstances, there is enormous social pressure (at least on mainstream parties) to be much higher functioning, and willing and able to lead the nation toward a positive future.

No, there isn't, and comparative study of democracies has shown that there is a pretty direct relationship between effective degree of proportionality and a wide range of positive democratic outcome measures, as well as producing a richer national dialogue.

A two-party system doesn't just break down into an us-v-them negative dialogue in bad conditions (it pretty much gets permanently stuck there because it works in a two-party system, and it is consistently easier than deepe discussion of issues), it also narrows the space of of potential solution sets that are even available for discussion to an approximation of a one-dimensional space. Multiparty proportional systems leader to a search space with greater dimensionality, as well as making “well, they are worse” politicking generally ineffective.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mrmlz on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:26AM (#44874152)
Sweden has more parties than two and it's the lesser evil here as well - in what world would a party perfectly align to every single thing you like?
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Jolter on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:37AM (#44874214)
It is far, far more likely that you can get most of your opinions represented in a parliament with 8 parties than one with 2 or 3.

In Sweden, in the past 50 years, people with ”new” or fringe opinions have successfully started parties, and won seats in either the national or EU parliament, on these issues:

- Christianity - Environmentalism - Racism/populism - Internet freedom/privacy - Feminism - Racism/populism, again

Most of these have had their issues adopted by larger parties through triangulation, and thus shrunk away to nothing, while others persist to this day (christianity, environmentalism, racism).

I think if you tried to start a new labor party in the UK today, you should not expect to win any seats. Likewise if you attempted what the Swedish Feminist Initiative did. But I hope I’m about to be proven wrong on the first point.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mongol on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:20AM (#44874455)
I don't think the racist label applied to Ny Demokrati is clear cut. It turned out that some of their elected representatives acted this way, but it was not part of their message or program as they won their seats. I see it as more a side effect of quickly populating a party with members without proper wetting.

As background, this party was founded about 8 months before the election in 1991, almost like a fluke. It was not a grass roots movement, but by charismatic founders that quickly had to build an organisation around some hollow ideas about less bureaucracy and lower taxes.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Jolter on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:34AM (#44874543)
You’re right! And you’ve written up a very good description of the concept of a fundamentally populist party.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mongol on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:52AM (#44877013)
Yes, Ny Demokrati was textbook populist. Can't think of a better example
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by pastage on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:57AM (#44874334)
The christianity party in Sweden could have been classified as "rascist" because that is how they voted many times, but they also had a humanist streak which took over in a lot of issues they engaged in.

I find these changes in tides between parties interesting. Populism is only applicable on specific takes issues not parties.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Jolter on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:00AM (#44874353)
I agree regarding the Christian Democrats.

But wouldn’t you agree that both NYD and SD were both founded on populist principles? Apart from racism, neither had any clear cut policies when they started, yet they both got pretty massive boosts from their populist streaks. I think the populist label on them is pretty well established by policy researchers. It’s in the first sentence on both parties’ Swedish Wikipedia pages.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mrmlz on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:49AM (#44875578)
My point being - i might agree with SDs migration policy and not much else. I might agree on Ms taxcuts etc. etc. But I still have to pick and chose the lesser evil.

Maybe 8 parties narrows the lesser evil down a bit.. But they all end up in coalition anyway so I'm pretty sure i get the same amount of evil as in a 2-party system.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by jpfromlondon on Monday August 18, 2025 @04:06AM (#44938396)
the problem with proportional representation is that nothing gets done, it's a permanent logjam with conflicting ideologies attempting to block or outdo each other.

Admittedly there is a bureaucratic logjam in the UK that hampers any progress but I don't see that going with fptp, I'd anticipate it getting much, much worse under prop-rep.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by account42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:27AM (#44874161)
It's the essence of any representative democracy - you'd need as many parties as there are citizens for everyone to be able to vote for one that truly represents their views on all relevant topics.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by eru on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:10AM (#44874769)
That might be true in some theory, in practice you can find reasonably good alignment for most people at five or six viable parties.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by account42 on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @03:47AM (#44885679)
No, in practice I don't find that. In practice I find people actively voting against their interests because no matter who they vote fore the party is going to push for something they don't want.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by eru on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @11:56PM (#44896595)
What countries (or states or counties or cities etc) or time periods do you have in mind here?
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Jolter on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:47AM (#44874281)
True, but please see my reply to the sibling comment.

I suppose when choosing between electoral systems, the choice is indeed a matter of the lesser of two evils!

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by MrGilbert on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:54AM (#44873193)
> Feels utterly demoralizing when you have to vote for lesser evil and not for someone you feel will be better for the future.

Always go for your gut feeling, not for what people are blaring. Especially populists will, as the name suggest, crave for people's attention and a cheap "Yeah, they are totally right!". That's how they win elections. And three months into the new period, they will show their real intentions.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by bigfudge on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:23AM (#44874469)
Surely gut feelings are how we get populists voted in? I’d prefer people sat and thought carefully for a while than trusted their gut!
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by MrGilbert on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:43AM (#44874595)
I directly addressed the "feelings" OP was having.

Besides, the past has shown that facts are opinions for some folks, so even that would not work.

My advice assumes a mentally stable person with somewhat modest reasoning.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by stuaxo on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:33AM (#44873823)
Kier Starmer seems to be doing everything an establishment plant would - an establishment that really doesn't like the idea of a Labour government.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by eru on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:12AM (#44874789)
Are you somehow suggesting that Labour isn't (or shoudn't be) part of the establishment?

Labour has been part of the reigning duopoly in British politics for most of the last 100 years. How could they not be part of the establishment?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by johnisgood on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:52AM (#44874301)
http://anthonyflood.com/rothbarddemocracy.htm still gets down-voted here, but perhaps we will finally see more people realizing that it is true, as it always has been.

You talk about the lesser evil here, well, it is exactly what is written there.

Some parts quoted:

> Democracy suffers from many more inherent contradictions as well. Thus, democratic voting may have either one of these two functions: to determine governmental policy or to select rulers. According to the former, what Schumpeter termed the “classical” theory of democracy, the majority will is supposed to rule on issues.[23] According to the latter theory, majority rule is supposed to be confined to choosing rulers, who in turn decide policy. While most political scientists support the latter version, democracy means the former version to most people, and we shall therefore discuss the classical theory first.

> According to the “will of the people” theory, direct democracy—voting on each issue by all the citizens, as in New England town meetings—is the ideal political arrangement. Modern civilization and the complexities of society, however, are supposed to have outmoded direct democracy, so that we must settle for the less perfect “representative democracy” (in olden days often called a “republic”), where the people select representatives to give effect to their will on political issues. Logical problems arise almost immediately. One is that different forms of electoral arrangements, different delimitations of geographical districts, all equally arbitrary, will often greatly alter the picture of the “majority will.” [...]

See the italic bit ("we must settle for the less perfect").

He talks about IMO the greatest contradictions after this part:

> But even proportional representation would not be as good—according to the classical view of democracy—as direct democracy, and here we come to another important and neglected consideration: modern technology does make it possible to have direct democracy. Certainly, each man could easily vote on issues several times per week by recording his choice on a device attached to his television set. This would not be difficult to achieve. And yet, why has no one seriously suggested a return to direct democracy, now that it may be feasible?

The whole thing is worth a read with an open mind.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Gormo on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:45PM (#44878800)
One of the biggest problems with a lot of the modern theory of democracy is that it sees democratic mechanisms as being not just necessary but sufficient to justify any action undertaken by the state.

Another major problem is the lack of clear bounding principles to distinguish public questions from private ones (or universal public questions from public questions particular to a localized context).

Together these problems result in political processes that (a) treats every question as global problem affecting society an undifferentiated mass, and (b) uses majoritarianism applied to arbitrary, large-scale aggregations of people as means of answering those questions.

This leads to concepts like "one man, one vote" implying that everyone should have an equal say on every question regardless of the stake any given individual might have in the outcome of that question.

And that, in turn, leads to the dominant influence on every question -- in either mode of democracy Rothbard refers to -- being not the people who face the greatest impact from the answer, nor the people who understand its details the best, but rather vast numbers of people who really have no basis for any meaningful opinions in the first place.

Every question comes down to opposing parties trying to win over uninformed, disinterested voters through spurious arguments and vague appeals to emotion. Public choice theory hits the nail on the head here, and this is why the policy equilibrium in every modern political state is a dysfunctional mess of special-interest causes advanced at everyone else's expense.

Democracy is necessary, but not sufficient. And I think the particular genius of the American approach has been to embed democracy within a constitutional framework that attempts to define clear lines regarding what is a public question open to political answers and what is not. The more we erode that framework, the more the reliability of our institutions will fray.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by eru on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:09AM (#44874760)
Vote with your feet (and wallet).
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Roark66 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:35AM (#44873430)
And that is exactly how someone like Trump could win (there are worse people than Nigel Farage). I'm amazed people have not thrown out these two parties in the UK already. Yes, the voting system makes it hard, but not impossible. It happened before.

However, I think the key reason why Conservatives and Labour are so entrenched is that people make their voting habits a part of their identity. I had a number of face to face conversations about politics with people born and raised in the UK. Every single one agreed with me about many stupid things the back then conservative govt pushed (the idea to ban encryption and more). And every single one of them said they will continue voting Conservative. Why? Because this is who they are. It's a part of their family identity (being quite well off financially, having expensive education etc). And they only see two choices, with the other being much worse.

This is how democracies die. They even agreed with this being far from optimal, but they see no other option.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by ifwinterco on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:33AM (#44873819)
That was true until recently, but in the last 12 months it's all cracked wide open.

Reform are leading in the polls, the lib dems are picking up disaffected tory wets, new left wing parties are threatening labour from the left on gaza etc.

A long time until the next election but right now it's all to play for

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by bigfudge on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:25AM (#44874486)
But this essentially has to collapse down to 2 or 3 parties unless these preferences are for graphically concentrated. Which they don’t seem to be. Reform might wipe out the tories with Lib Dem’s cleaning up the scraps, but that doesn’t really move us forward. In fact it’s likely to entrench the moderate left into holding their nose and voting labour?
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by ifwinterco on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:10AM (#44874771)
Yes, with first past the post it will probably get pretty messy. Right now Reform are polling so well they would get a majority, but I'm not sure they'll sustain that until 2029, and whether they'll actually fix anything is questionable.

My gut sense is labour have pissed off people (including or perhaps especially the left) so badly that they are toast at this point. Those left wing votes are up for grabs by anyone who makes a decent case for them

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by account42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:24AM (#44874138)
Oh no not Trump. We wouldn't want that, better vote for the other extreme who will end up passing largely the same kind of laws but with slightly different excuses.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by PUSH_AX on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:25AM (#44873042)
Why? People make all kinds of empty promises to get into power.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Lio on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:38AM (#44873106)
True but all the other parties are currently saying that they 100% will not reconsider this stupid law[1].

I don’t like Farrage. At all.

He’s also currently the only MP questioning this law and he’s making fair points about it.

The government response is not a clever rebuttal but Jess Philips and Peter Kyle making ad hominem arguments comparing him to one of the nastiest people in our country’s history.

This is government overreach and they know it.

1. It’s stupid not because of its goals but because it doesn’t protect kids but does expose vast numbers of adults to identity fraud just to access Spotify or wikipedia.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by vixen99 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:03AM (#44876348)
> Don't like Farage. At all I love the way folk feel they have to apologize to HN users (guess which way the majority lean) when they recognize someone like Farage has a point.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by phatfish on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:50AM (#44876987)
Spotify has my PI already. Wikipedia I was using today as normal.

The only people moaning about this are the ones ashamed of jerking off. Just own it, and this issue goes away. Who cares if a random company has your mug shot to do an age estimation, they know you jerk off, so what?

Just keep porn away from your kids please and let's hope we do better for the next generation.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Lio on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:07PM (#44878223)
> The only people moaning about this are the ones ashamed of jerking off. Just own it, and this issue goes away. Who cares if a random company has your mug shot to do an age estimation, they know you jerk off, so what?

Sorry but that misses the point. This isn't about porn or being embarrased about it. It's about having to present identification to gain access many different types of site.

We now have the situation where a site, any kind doesn't have to be porn, can look legitimate and ask for required personal identifcation but actually be a run fraudsters.

You might personally have an issue identifying sites like that many adults will and once they're handed over a copy of their passport or drivers licence they are in for a lot of trouble.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by globular-toast on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:29AM (#44873064)
They're all using it to virtue signal their hatred of child porn. It's basically religious at this point. You stray from the line and someone just shouts infidel and you get stoned to death.

Unfortunately the atheism movement of a about ten years ago didn't go far enough in making people aware that religion isn't just about big men in the sky who are the same colour as you. What it actually is is a deficiency in human ability, a bypass for the logical centres of the brain and a way to access the animal areas that can get people to do terrible things to each other. Some of them, like Hitchens, definitely understood this, but nobody seems to be talking about it any more and we didn't learn to be vigilant of this deficiency.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by philipallstar on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:25AM (#44874141)
> Some of them, like Hitchens, definitely understood this

He seemed pretty fixated on "monotheism" being a particular problem, as though two gods were fine.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by umbra07 on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @05:13AM (#44886227)
Was that not just his way of referring to the Abrahamic faiths?
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by PeterStuer on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:01AM (#44873228)
Did it occur to you they only voted against it because they knew it would pass anyway, so they could afford scoring some brownie points?
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by c16 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:49AM (#44873527)
That's not necessarily a position you have to fight. You can also take the standpoint that if the UK government can't protect your private data, then how can a data provider. There are many such cases:

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2025-08-06/hacker...

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2007/nov/21/immigration...

[3] https://www.reuters.com/technology/cybersecurity/britains-nh...

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by ChrisRR on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:25AM (#44873769)
I genuinely thought that Farage would finally fuck off after brexit happened. I hadn't really figured that he's in it for the attention rather than the politics
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by philipallstar on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:24AM (#44874136)
He did. He came back about 6 years later because immigration was up not down.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by fakedang on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:53AM (#44874653)
UKIP was dead when BoJo was in power. But of course, the Tories under May, BoJo and Sunak amped up immigration to record levels, so now there's a stronger case for Farage to contest. While UKIP was largely about Euroscepticism, Reform has openly racist undertones in their pitch to voters.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by toyg on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:45AM (#44875026)
> UKIP was largely about Euroscepticism

Or rather euroscepticism was the dog-whistling for racist arguments that, since Brexit happened, don't need to camouflage anymore.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by philipallstar on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:16AM (#44874081)
> The worst part is that they've somehow put me in the position of defending Nigel Farage.

It's the UK's Stop Making Me Defend Trump[0].

[0] https://pjmedia.com/charlie-martin/2017/01/20/stop-making-me...

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by ulrikrasmussen on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:53AM (#44874656)
Ugh, that quote is a disgusting way to argue. It's akin to saying that all vegetarians are nazis because Hitler was a vegetarian.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by bratbag on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:15AM (#44875273)
They voted against it because they thought it didn't go far enough.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by monooso on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:58PM (#44878982)
Do you have any sources for that? I'm genuinely interested. I've heard it mentioned before as fact, but a quick search of Hansard[1][2] only turned up one very vocal Labour politician (Alex Davies-Jones).

[1] https://hansard.parliament.uk/ [2] It was a very quick search.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by lambdas on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:27AM (#44875379)
The only time a labour majority voted against this bill was when an amendment to make category 1 sites have optional controls for users (something that would have prevented this).

I’m going to guess that our MP’s are tech illiterate enough as it is, that when an opaque term like “what is a category 1” came up, someone hand waved over it and said “think Facebook or Twitter”

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by fennecfoxy on Thursday August 14, 2025 @04:14AM (#44898020)
That's politics/democracy for you. It's broken. It's just a popularity contest and it is this way because people vote for political parties like they're sports teams, rather than voting based on policy.

I feel like during an election, policies and election promises are what should be presented, make it illegal to vote for a specific candidate, or for specific candidates to say what their policies are; they can only register policies with the election process.

Then people vote on the policies/promises they'd like to see implemented and whoever made those then gets in.

If policies and promises are not upheld during an election cycle, then that is illegal and those involved get charged and sentenced, though allowing for mitigating circumstances (say if the Tories promised x houses built in the last cycle, the pandemic would be mitigating circumstance for fewer houses built - but not _not_ houses built).

But meh, nothing will change and I really cannot be bothered with many people out there. Nothing will change the way people act, how apathetic they are.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by stephen_g on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:13AM (#44872632)
What? I can't imagine anybody who was paying attention through any of this would have expected that Starmer's Labour would reverse this...
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by ExoticPearTree on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:18AM (#44874095)
> The law was passed by the previous government and everyone assumed the next government would take great delight in reversing it.

Unless a law is a mortal threat to the current party in power, it will not be repelled. Even so most likely they will try to wash it down instead of actually abolishing it.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hilbert42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:30AM (#44877598)
"Unless a law is a mortal threat to the current party in power, it will not be repelled."

Trouble is, like the frog in warming water, the UK is by a series of steps falling into ever-increasing irrelevancy on the world stage. By the time it wakes up to the fact it'll be too late.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by gpderetta on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:35AM (#44874204)
They voted against it because they thought it was not strong enough [1].

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jan/01/labour-pl...

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by captainbland on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:02AM (#44875719)
I think something like reversing it in one specific domain (e.g. softcore porn or static images). Then retooling it so it applies to e.g. people viewing info on immigration rights etc. is likely on the cards.