News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by mrandish on Monday August 11, 2025 @04:49PM (#44869317)
> I wouldn’t be so sure that any next government will necessarily reverse this.

Agreed. I think the supposed justifications for mass population-wide online surveillance, restrictions and de-anonymization are so strong most political parties in western democracies go along with what surveillance agencies push for once they get in power. Even in the U.S. where free speech & personal privacy rights are constitutionally and culturally stronger, both major parties are virtually identical in what they actually permit the surveillance state to do once they get in office (despite sometimes talking differently while campaigning).

The reason is that the surveillance state has gotten extremely good at presenting scary scenarios and examples of supposed "disaster averted because we could spy on everyone", or the alternative, "bad thing happened because we couldn't spy on everyone" to politicians in non-public briefings. They keep these presentations secret from public and press scrutiny by claiming it's necessary to keep "sources and methods" secret from adversaries. Of course, this is ridiculous because adversary spy agencies are certainly already aware of the broad capabilities of our electronic surveillance - it's their job after all and they do the same things to their own populations. The intelligence community rarely briefs politicians on individual operations or the exact details of the sources and methods which adversarial intelligence agencies would care about anyway. The vast majority of these secret briefings could be public without revealing anything of real value to major adversaries. At most it would only confirm we're doing the things adversaries already assume we're doing (and already take steps to counter). The real reason they hide the politician briefings from the public is because voters would be creeped out by the pervasive surveillance and domain experts would call bullshit on the incomplete facts and fallacious reasoning used to justify it to politicians.

Even if a politician sincerely intended to preserve privacy and freedom before getting in office, they aren't domain experts and when confronted with seemingly overwhelming (but secret) evidence of preventing "big bad" presented unanimously by intelligence community experts, the majority of elected officials go along. If that's not enough for the anti-privacy agencies (intel & law enforcement) to get what they want, there's always the "think of the children" arguments. It's the rare politician who's clear-thinking and principled enough to apply appropriate skepticism and measured nuance when faced with horrendous examples of child porn and abuse which the law enforcement/intelligence agency lobby has ready in ample supply and deploys behind closed doors for maximum effect. The anti-privacy lobby has figured out how to hack representative democracy to circumvent protections and because it's done away from public scrutiny, there's currently no way to stop them and it's only going to keep getting worse. IMHO, it's a disaster and even in the U.S. (where I am) it's only slightly better than the UK, Australia, EU and elsewhere.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by autoexec on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:53PM (#44871491)
> The reason is that the surveillance state has gotten extremely good at presenting scary scenarios and examples of supposed "disaster averted because we could spy on everyone", or the alternative, "bad thing happened because we couldn't spy on everyone" to politicians in non-public briefings.

Those politicians who are vocal against mass surveillance tend to change their tune the moment they're in office and I doubt they were all intending to go back on their campaign promises from the start or that they were really convinced by horror stories of terrorists told over powerpoint in closed door briefings.

I wouldn't doubt if they were also giving politicians examples of the kind of dirt they already have on them and their families. This is one of the biggest risks of the surveillance state. Endless blackmail material made up of actual skeletons, as well as the resources to install new ones into anyone's closets whenever needed.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by 20after4 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:14AM (#44872350)
Do what we say or we might get a warrant and find that stash of CP that we installed on your hard drive. How do you even defend against planted digital evidence? It would be easy to fake and very difficult to disprove.

But when it comes to politicians and people with power, I think it's even worse than all of that. It's kind of obvious what Mr Epstein was getting up to with regard to blackmail.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:28AM (#44872726)
> How do you even defend against planted digital evidence?

With your good name. In the end, it is not important what the politician had or did not have on the disk, but who the public will believe more, the secret services, who claim that there was something there, or the politician, who claims that he is being set up and groundlessly persecuted for the purpose of political pressure.

And as long as public opinion about the special services is what it is, politicians can safely stash CP on their disks without fear that they will be charged with anything even if they are found.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hopelite on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:39AM (#44874237)
You’re dismissing something way more complicated. Many people with good names have supposedly had CP hoards. How would you even go about checking out confirming that it even is CP? You can’t, and would you even want to look into that? No, of course not.

Frankly, it could even just be made up. How would you know? I’m sure in most cases it is true and correct, but with as much corruption in every and all aspects of policing and justice, there is absolutely zero chance that when it involves something with such huge and hidden levers as CP, that there would be zero corruption. Cops still plant drugs on people even though they know they are on body cam and they still shoot people to death for no reason and are simply absolved by the system that protects itself; you don’t think that the black box of CP accusation that no one wants to or can look into is not used for corrupt reasons?

The whole system is rotten and corrupt, why wouldn’t it be corrupt in this case where there is a huge lever and no one dares look into it?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by account42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:21AM (#44874456)
I bet you have never witnessed someone being accused of even a much less severe social taboo. They won't even be given the chance to defend themselves.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:21AM (#44872695)
I don't think it's blackmailing. Total surveillance by itself is just a great tool (when you have it in your hands). Why give it up?
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by john01dav on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:55PM (#44871505)
If these claims are accurate, then the solution is obvious: elected officials who are themselves domain experts in this. They can then explain to their colleagues why these arguments are bullshit.

But, I expect that that won't help because your claims don't tell the while story. Most representatives don't act in good faith and like the government that they're a part of having such power.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:18AM (#44872669)
Why do you think politicians are idiots?

Yes, many of them are really stupid people. But they are not idiots. I think 95 percent of them are perfectly aware of why the laws they pass are really needed. And they pass them EXACTLY FOR THIS, and not at all for protecting children and internet safety.

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by hopelite on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:57AM (#44874332)
There irony is that people who call politicians stupid are generally not very smart people themselves in my experience, regardless of various forms of advanced degrees they believe disproves that.

They may be puppets, they may be manipulators, they may be con-artists, they may be liars; but what does it say about oneself if an “idiot” managed to become one of a few hundred most powerful humans on this planet and in all of human history (in the case of an American politician) and you did not?

Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by imtringued on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:38AM (#44877729)
Considering the average age and net worth of American politicians. I certainly know that it is almost exclusive to rich old men.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by account42 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:22AM (#44874465)
Why do you think politicians look out for what is "really needed" rather than what is beneficial to themselves.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by Ray20 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:57AM (#44874677)
What do you mean "why"? They do not.
Re:Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act verif... by pyuser583 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:05AM (#44872933)
A big problem is private entities do so much spying, it becomes hard to argue against.

We collect tons of data on people to sell ads. Why not to save children?