News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grok3 Launch by angusturner on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:25AM (#43089813)
Credit to the engineers that built this, but it fills me with rage that Elon has this sort of unchecked power.

How long before this starts getting deployed in safety critical applications or government decision making processes?

With no oversight because Elon seems to have the power to dismiss the people responsible for investigating him.

Anyone not scared by this concentration of power needs to pick up a book.

Re:Grok3 Launch by ijustlovemath on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:01AM (#43090274)
What's remarkable to me about criticism like this is how quickly it's rebutted by people claiming "where did they say they would do this," as if these people don't make incredibly rushed and poorly planned decisions all the time. It's like an idea immune system that rejects any criticism or self reflection. It would be sociologically fascinating if it wasn't being combined with a dereliction of congressional power and an unchecked executive.
Re:Grok3 Launch by soheil on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:41AM (#43091817)
You do realize you and your OP are currently top comments in your respective threads both criticizing Elon and even preemptively criticize your imaginary criticizers
Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:29AM (#43090627)
I literally post for years the same thing about the need for open source alternatives to social platforms where 1 person controls the algorithm to prioritize what a billion people see. And the response is “meh”. No one even bothers to read past the first paragraph:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43036350

But if you really want to see the “immune system” shine, mention web3 and smart contracts, and watch the downvotes pour in. Any time one even mentions “decentralized byzantine fault tolerant” anything, an army rises up to repeat anodyne versions of “grift… no one needs it… banks are great…” etc.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43073421

But if you mention any concerns with AI, no matter who or what you cite, the same group goes the other way and always repeats “(insert problem here) has always been possible, there is nothing to see here, move on, AI is amazing, deregulate and let the industry develop faster”:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40900155

It’s groupthink at its most obvious, repeatable, always on, and I wonder how much of it is organic.

Re:Grok3 Launch by pjc50 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:18AM (#43091354)
Having been on the internet for a very long time, I can answer why open source alternatives to social platforms seldom get off the ground: the network effect is huge, and the community of users matters far more than any of the technology.

Don't bother telling people how it works. Show them who's using it and for what.

Oh, and for any kind of "normie" use it must have a decent moderation and anti-abuse system. Which inevitably clashes hard with "decentralized". Bluesky is succeeding because it lives in a contradiction of pretending to be decentralized, but what it really offers is the "pre Elon Twitter" experience. To basically the same people.

> the same group

While there's a certain amount of hivemind, it's rare that you see people directly contradict their own posts here; what you're seeing is different people.

Re:Grok3 Launch by sanity on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:59AM (#43091026)
This is the problem we're working on with https://freenet.org/ - a general purpose platform for building entirely decentralized services.

Our thesis is that the client-server architecture is a fundamental flaw in the world wide web's design, which inherently concentrates power in the hands of a few. Freenet aims to be a general purpose replacement for this in which all services are entirely decentralized.

The first non-trivial app we're building will be a group chat system called River[1].

[1] https://github.com/freenet/river

Re:Grok3 Launch by pjc50 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:24AM (#43091485)
Freenet is 25 years old. It never took off, what makes people think it will take off now?
Re:Grok3 Launch by sanity on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:19PM (#43092347)
The original Freenet had over 6m downloads over the years - and pioneered ideas like cryptographic contracts which later formed the basis for bitcoin, but it was always a very experimental project, while the new Freenet is designed for mass adoption.

They key differences between old and new Freenet are:

Functionality: The previous version was analogous to a decentralized hard drive, while the current version is analogous to a full decentralized computer.

Real-time Interaction: The current version allows users to subscribe to data and be notified immediately if it changes. This is essential for systems like instant messaging or group chat.

Programming Language: Unlike the previous version, which was developed in Java, the current Freenet is implemented in Rust. This allows for better efficiency and integration into a wide variety of platforms (Windows, Mac, Android, MacOS, etc).

Transparency: The current version is a drop-in replacement for the world wide web and is just as easy to use.

Anonymity: While the previous version was designed with a focus on anonymity, the current version does not offer built-in anonymity but allows for a choice of anonymizing systems to be layered on top.

Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @08:31PM (#43097502)
Can you drop me an email? Would like to have a conversation about our respective roadmaps and helping each other

http://qbix.com/about

Re:Grok3 Launch by sanity on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:01PM (#43097680)
Will do.
Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:01AM (#43091061)
I like the new Freenet! I interviewed your founder, Ian Clarke, 2 years ago on my channel — discussing the original freenet, probably the first truly decentralized content network in the world. Here is the 2-hour discussion:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JWrRqUkJpMQ&t=12m0s

Look around the 12 minute mark when I start to discuss how “the capitalist system” produces centralized monopoilies that extract rents for their shareholders.

Re:Grok3 Launch by eightysixfour on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:37AM (#43090736)
Or, people have different opinions about who should have power over social media, banking, and AI, for completely rational reasons…
Re:Grok3 Launch by namuol on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:56AM (#43092016)
> But if you really want to see the “immune system” shine, mention web3 and smart contracts, and watch the downvotes pour in.

Yeah that sounds like a feature, not a bug.

Re:Grok3 Launch by echelon on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:49AM (#43090891)
> But if you really want to see the “immune system” shine, mention web3 and smart contracts, and watch the downvotes pour in

I'm all for distributed / P2P social media, but crypto is full of some of the most scammy and downright shameful behavior I've ever seen in my life. Pump and dumps, rug pulls, money laundering. There is a real reason people hate crypto.

To tip it off, crypto is one of the least meritocratic things there is. The longer you've been in it, the more people you've scammed, the more you hype, the "wealthier" you are.

Crypto smells like a shit and vomit sandwich and people immediately turn their noses.

Build P2P social without the crypto angle and you have my attention. I've been wanting p2p (not federated) social media since the 200Xs and the decline of the indie web. Social and news should work like email and BitTorrent, not Facebook or "federated Twitter".

Re:Grok3 Launch by swalsh on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:11AM (#43091225)
> I'm all for distributed / P2P social media, but crypto is full of some of the most scammy and downright shameful behavior I've ever seen in my life. Pump and dumps, rug pulls, money laundering.

The SEC's answer no questions, sue first, approach to crypto in general made legitimate players afriad to operate, so the space became dominated by those that didn't care about the law.

Re:Grok3 Launch by pjc50 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:21AM (#43091420)
> The SEC's answer no questions, sue first

This isn't true, and last time someone tried to prove it was, they cited .. a huge PDF of all the questions the SEC had been asking crypto firms prior to action.

Besides, the rules are over now. The US President ran a pump and dump. Can't get more legitimacy than that.

Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:13AM (#43091254)
Many on HN don’t believe there ARE any legitimate uses of crypto in the first place.

Here are some:

https://intercoin.org/applications

But most comments I get are “I stopped reading 2 seconds in when I saw the word Web5.”

(We started using it when Jack who founded Twitter, started bluesky, promoted nostr started using it).

Here is a graphical presentation that can drive it home:

https://intercoin.app/investors.pdf

Re:Grok3 Launch by svara on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:21PM (#43093210)
I looked at your links and I still don't get it. I do want to understand. Where is the problem stated, clearly and concisely? What is the solution and why does it require crypto?

I say that as someone who read the Bitcoin paper in 2012 and was pretty excited back then.

Meanwhile online scams are a bigger industry than the illegal drug trade and bigger than the Australian economy. There are thousands of modern day slaves in call centers in Myanmar and the Philippines with fake social media profiles running pig butchering scams. That industry runs on crypto 100%. I guess that's one "problem" crypto solved.

You need some pretty convincing arguments at this point to convince me (and many others) that getting rid of this stuff wouldn't be a big win for humanity.

Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:26PM (#43095318)
The problem is relative to WHOM.

Here is the problem statement and solution for community leaders, the same class of decision makers who exited “AOL Keyword NYTimes” in favor of “nytimes.com” on this newfangled protocol called HTTP, with its servers and clients called browsers that people were downloading

intercoin.org/currencies.pdf

Re:Grok3 Launch by chefandy on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:53PM (#43098719)
When they asked for a clear and concise description of your problem and solution, they are probably looking for a problem statement: a focused, 1 or 2 sentence explanation of the problem you intend to solve. You then present your proposed solution in the same form.

Hypothetical example problem statement: We want to promote ycombinator to everyone that could benefit, but banner ads make us look chintzy, directly engaging in the feral discourse on Slashdot would inevitably look unprofessional, and engaging directly through dozens of purpose-built blogs and websites is too onerous.

Hypothetical example solution statement: We should create our own simple, well-designed news site built on user submissions, and include threaded discussion capability with moderation built in at both the community and company level to keep things relatively civil. Then our audience will come looking for us.

What you offered is not a problem statement. It is a sales deck offering a, frankly, convoluted explanation of how starting a currency will solve a largely unrelated problem backed up by an unsupported assertion about the least representative sample in the world— Donald Trump.

Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:47AM (#43098987)
Or, you could actually read the deck and it explains the problem.

At this point, I think this is just performative

Re:Grok3 Launch by svara on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:35AM (#43099623)
I read it all. It's apparently supposed to be a way for celebrities to extract money from their audience by having them buy into their currency.

If you're satisfied with calling that useful, okay, I guess - to me it's deeply alarming that this is presented as a good example of a useful application of crypto.

In the broader context of crypto demand being driven essentially by digital crime and gambling, there would need to be some seriously glowing example of something good that can be done with it to shift my judgment.

For example, in the early days of Ethereum, I thought it'd be possible at some point to build truly open source, decentralized SaaS, where the deployment happens to the blockchain, and that this in turn would enable open source projects to finance themselves.

I've yet to see an example of this where the crypto aspect isn't a figleaf.

I'm very concerned that people arguing for exciting applications of crypto are involuntarily legitimizing the online crime ecosystem. Crypto in practice seems to lead to a massive transfer of assets to criminals. To an extent where that may end up destabilizing whole countries, given the market cap trajectory.

Re:Grok3 Launch by chefandy on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @06:59AM (#43101128)
It doesn’t explain anything. It asserts a lot. Sorry I took the time to critique and give examples as a freelance business communication designer. Effective business communication requires frank feedback, and mine usually isn’t cheap, but if protecting your ego is the goal here, just keep assuming you’re doing everything right and it’s everybody else’s fault it’s not landing.
Re:Grok3 Launch by talldayo on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:28PM (#43094646)
> We started using it when Jack who founded Twitter, started bluesky, promoted nostr started using it

Jack Dorsey is certifiably insane. His obsession with cryptocurrency is a warning to anyone that throws away success to live as a crypto maxi. You will lose the only things that matter to you in life, your business will be taken away from you by shareholders if you own one. Your control will be hated by users that accuse you of trying to ruin the internet with NFT profile pictures and crypto tickers. Many users outright left as a consequence, others would leave after the takeover. But Dorsey set the stage for the enshittification of Twitter, and anyone that's forgotten that should face the music.

Web5, no matter who utters it, is a phrase that means nothing. A person walking on the street would not be able to define it for you. Me, a programmer, cannot define it for you or even explain what it looks like. It is a marketing term as applied to Free Software, which will alienate Free Software users and disgust/confuse common people. If you cannot find a better phrase to describe your philosophy then people will forever associate you with the myriad grifters that shared your "Web(n)" branding.

Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:28PM (#43095333)
I defined it very clearly

  Web2 (community) +
  Web3 (blockchain)
  
We need to combine the two. Web3 by itself is lame, Web2 by itself is blind.
Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:57AM (#43090996)
I have been building it, in fact.

https://qbix.com/ecosystem

Do I have your attention now?

Ten years and $1 million dollars later, it’s free to use, but we haven’t started promoting it yet, still testing with paying clients:

https://github.com/Qbix

Here are some ideas:

https://qbix.com/community.pdf

https://qbix.com/alumni.pdf

Re:Grok3 Launch by echelon on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:30PM (#43093304)
This is interesting, but it feels too platformy for my use. I'd really like to see something 100% like BitTorrent.

Instead of trying to build a "you.com" (as in your pdf example), I want a place we're all just a simple disposable signed hash address (that you can change, make public, keep pseudonymous, etc.) - easy and disposable if needed, but also possible to use as the building block of an online presence or brand if your hash becomes well known. Kind of like email, in that sense.

The platform doesn't need real time streaming video or video calls. Just text and images to start. P2P Reddit or Twitter.

It shouldn't be about building a platform where you attract others to your brand. That can come later. It should be about participating in a swarm and building up a mass of people. An exchange of ideas and information, but where it feels like being in public. Like BitTorrent. Once network effects kick in, you can find the nodes (people, topics, etc.) you care about and want to prioritize in your interest graph.

Re:Grok3 Launch by swalsh on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:07AM (#43091147)
It's remarkable to me how "Web3 is a grift" has seemingly become tribal consensus here, without any real basis in reality. I think the last administration's explicit efforts to block crypto legitimization played a big part in this. It's clear that if you tried to follow the law and operate as a legitimate player, you risked being debanked or legally targeted by the SEC—and they made little to no effort to answer questions or help you work within the law's constraints. They wanted to sue first. As a result, those who ignored the law ended up dominating the space. This reflects policy failures, not issues with the tech or its legitimacy. I'm hoping the Trump administration shifts this dynamic, but now there's a reputation problem that needs correcting as well.
Re:Grok3 Launch by lelandbatey on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:25AM (#43091501)
To quote Patio11, "It's not a conspiracy if they really are out to get you."

Crypto in general and Web3 as well, all have mostly delivered scams. To the tune of billions stolen from everyday folks. Everything (to within a rounding error) that hasn't been a scam has delivered nothing else but being a speculative asset at best. Everything else has been a barely working toy that's better served by non-distributed implementations of the same thing.

People shit on crypto. government, regulators, and the public, all dislike crypto because the only thing that ever happens to us with it and the only thing we ever hear about happening, is folks losing money to scams.

There's no mystery here. Crypto doesn't need a policy shift. Crypto needs to stop fucking over folks. Yes it's cool technology, yes it also seems to just be a way to part folks from their money.

Re:Grok3 Launch by EGreg on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:22PM (#43092404)
That's like saying the only thing that ever happens with AI is people losing their jobs to AI. And unlike Crypto, they didn't opt in and literally buy digital assets and send them voluntarily somewhere. They get negatively affected regardless of any choice they have made. "Get on board, or get rolled." People worldwide would lose a lot more money to AI growing than crypto growing, regardless of never opting in. It will just be a giant wealth transfer to the already-wealthy and corporations. What about that? Oh, crickets. Dismissal from the HN crowd.

If I am going to put my money at risk, I expect it to be at risk. I'm happy to have a regulatory framework around that from the SEC, for instance, and there are. For example, since the JOBS Act, the SEC has greatly expanded the opportunities to raise money in a regulated way. I even interviewed the actual authors of Regulation S at the SEC, where I go into depth for an hour about how to raise money legally:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ocrqgkJn4m0

FINCEN has also been putting out guidances to the crypto industry since 2013:

2013: https://www.fincen.gov/statutes_regs/guidance/pdf/FIN-2013-G...

2019: https://www.fincen.gov/sites/default/files/2019-05/FinCEN%20...

So the regulations are there.

And frankly, most true adherents of crypto have been yelling from the rooftops that Celsius and FTX and Binance are not actual DeFi. They are not decentralized, they simply tell you to do the very thing crypto was designed to avoid -- i.e. send them money and "trust them". This is the very thing Bitcoin and Blockchain were designed to avoid -- the middleman.

FileCoin and UniSwap and Aave Marketplace and so on are real crypto, and they have never had any scandals and billions of dollars, bits, etc. are entrusted to them every day. Ditto for most altcoins and networks, including Hedera Hashgraph, Polygon, COSMOS, Polkadot, etc.

Any shade thrown at, e.g. Telegram's TON or Ripple's XRP, is due to regulators. I can understand why Facebook's Libra was shut down. But it has to do with them becoming "too powerful" and "not subject to national oversight". Kind of like Facebook and Twitter and Google themselves.

Re:Grok3 Launch by lelandbatey on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:02PM (#43092981)
Everything that you just mentioned, as far as "what it's actually doing" is either speculation/speculation accessories or is a not-as-good-version of existing offerings. Where is the value?

UniSwap: a marketplace for speculation on arguably scam crypto products.

Aave Marketplace: a marketplace for speculation on arguably scam crypto products.

FileCoin: file storage at rates 50% higher than e.g. BackBlaze/DigitalOcean.

There's no actual value here other than as scam, speculation (nearly a scam), or products that are flimsy pretenses at not being scams (but which don't deliver a lot of value). Why should anybody care (other than transparent greed)?

Re:Grok3 Launch by InTheArena on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:12AM (#43090397)
Elon's unchecked power at building a model? Or at politics?

I always worry whenever I see people telling me how to feel - rage in this case. We are in a political system that is oriented more around getting people to feel rage and hatred as opposed to consensus and deliberation. Elon is the face of that, but it's a much longer and larger problem. Throw in the complete dismisal that anyone not scared of this is ignorant, shuts down discussion.

The problem I have with Elon is that they are wasting a once in a lifetime chance to actually address and fix systematic problems with the US government. Deploying LLMs in the government space doesn't fear me with dread. Continuing the senseless partisan drive of the 20 years does.

Re:Grok3 Launch by swalsh on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:29AM (#43091591)
> Continuing the senseless partisan drive of the 20 years does.

I think what the government is going through right now is wrapping up the last political system. The idea that Democrats and Republicans just need to learn how to work together is just wrong. The parties are being destroyed, and I think we should all cheer that. They were built to address the issues of the 20th century, and neither party in the current form is ready to address 21st century issues. I think AI, Climate change, world demographic changes around the world (ie: low birthrates) is going to seriously alter everything about our world from geopolitics, to economy, even social issues.

The democrats are stuck in supporting the new deal bureaucracy and the post ww2 order. That's over, it's crumbling right now, and i'm not going to try and defend any of it personally. It's just obsolete. The old Republican party your dad probably supported is dead too, that died a while ago. The new Republican party seems to be an alliance of people who just really want to cheer the crumbling of the old system (MAGA) and the first emergence of what politics in the 21st century is going to look like (the tech alliance).

Democrats would be smart to understand it's a new century we have new threats, new challenges, and need new institutions.... and this IS NOT a once in a lifetime opportunity to fix our government. This is the first draft of our new political system, and they have a choice to participate in shaping it, but they will need to get votes, and to get votes they need to stop stalking about obsolete ideas.

Re:Grok3 Launch by OvbiousError on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:05PM (#43092146)
Consolidating power in the hands of the few very rich is not something new, it's just the old come again.
Re:Grok3 Launch by mrtesthah on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:23PM (#43092413)
Is this new political system akin to a banana republic? Because that’s what happens when you replace non partisan workers with loyalists in order to eliminate all accountability and oversight. Turning the rule of law into a partisan issue is a receipt for endemic corruption.

And even if you think the rule of law is antiquated, you’re misanthropically cheering the destruction of the largest institution in the world that 330 million people depend on for survival.

Re:Grok3 Launch by bastardoperator on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:39PM (#43092662)
I might cheer if the replacements weren't objectively worse in every measurable way.
Re:Grok3 Launch by jrussino on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:57PM (#43092910)
>The democrats are stuck in supporting the new deal bureaucracy and the post ww2 order

> The new Republican party seems to be an alliance of people who just really want to cheer the crumbling of the old system

I agree, and I think this is a bizarre flipping of the "Democrat ~= progressive / Republican ~= conservative" dynamic that has been largely assumed throughout my lifetime.

We need both conservative and progressive forces in our society. Someone needs to be saying "here's what's wrong with our system; here's what needs to change", and someone else needs to balance that with "here's what we're doing right; here are the parts that are working well and that we should not get rid of".

It seems to me that now, instead of that tug-of-war discussion happening between the two parties, it is happening in parallel within them. Unfortunately, the sane and responsible version of that discussion is happening entirely within the boundary of the Democratic coalition, in a way that is completely ineffectual because (a) the internal conservative moderating force is relatively strong in a moment when the populace seems to want more progressive action, and (b) to they have so little ability to effectively wield political power.

Meanwhile, the Republicans are dominated by a bizarro "progressive" faction that wants to pull us all in an entirely different (IMHO regressive) direction. And that faction is completely unchecked by any internal "conservative" moderating force within its own party, so it is for the moment able to push us as hard and fast as possible in its preferred direction.

Re:Grok3 Launch by swalsh on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:48PM (#43095554)
> It seems to me that now, instead of that tug-of-war discussion happening between the two parties,

I'm REALLY looking forward to 2028, because I think that potentially will be the first election where we start to see what modern politics will look like. I wouldn't be surprised if there are multiple new parties, and multiples of them have a real chance. If it seems one sided right now, it's just because one side found their way to the start line first... but make no mistake, history shows that over time new political factions will form that offer resistance to bad ideas, and clear a path for the good ideas.

Given the rate of change with AI, We're going to have a real idea on what a world being disrupted by AGI (whether that is true AGI, or something close to it) looks like. At the same time Healthcare is only getting worse, and Trump is NOT going to fundumentally address it. China is going to be rising, and they're a real geopolitical threat. The war in Ukraine has completely changed what warfare looks like, and we're going to have to completely restructure our military (just like we have to restructure our healthcare). I also wouldn't be surprised if Trump's war with the cartel turns out to be far harder than expected because cheap autonomous drones allow a small military to compete against a large traditional military.

All of our prior assumptions on retirement are different too, retired boomers are not the same as the pensioneers from their day. They're not impoverished, instead they're flush with cash. I'm not sure in a world with an aging workforce you're going to be anti-immigrant... and all these benefits we give to retirees may not make sense in a world where retirees are wealthier than the regular workforce supporting them.

The general theme for the next decade is going to be throw out all the old books, 80% of our prior assumptions no longer apply.

Re:Grok3 Launch by spankalee on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:31AM (#43090652)
> actually address and fix systematic problems with the US government

I wonder if you could even name what some of these critical problems are? Or have you just been told that there are problems that justify this chaos?

Re:Grok3 Launch by InTheArena on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:42AM (#43090797)
I'm happy to, thought the end of your statement strongly suggestions that you have are not acting in honest faith by asking this question. 1) All positions have become partisan, which political ideology being as critical to promotion in high level positions. 2) Congress refuses to act as the constitution intends, and have delegated their budget making authority to the executive branch. 3) The government specific procurement system is almost as expensive as what is being procured. 4) Auditing the government is almost impossible. 5) The debt load on the government is becoming unsustainable. 6) The lack of "digital transformation" (what we called it in banking) means poor service. 7) The unfunded liabilities (mostly at a state level) will swamp budgets in a few years. 8) Most large contracts should be fixed contracts, not cost plus contracts. Companies can do bilk the government for things that are a order of magnitude cheaper to the outside world. 9) Medicare refuses to lower health care costs (by reducing rates) due to political pressure. 10) No rationalization of government spending or revenue has occured since the post world war 2 era.
Re:Grok3 Launch by dralley on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:06AM (#43091138)
All of your points can be summed up as "Congress refuses to do their job".

Breaking all the laws to bypass the government does not "actually address and fix systematic problems with the US government", that is an absurd position. Caesar did not fix the Roman Republic.

And opposition to DOGE is not on the basis that people don't care about government efficiency. It's on the basis that the shit they're doing has nothing to do with government efficiency. There's not even a pretense of trying to calculate the "benefit" part of the cost-benefit equation with the cuts they are doing, they are just slashing and burning without any concern for outcomes as a power play and messaging tool. Elon is famous for doing this at Tesla and Twitter and all evidence points to it being incredibly harmful.

This isn't efficient! https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2025/02/15/return-to...

And not everything is about efficiency. Laying off veteran's crisis hotline workers or refusing to pay for the USAID employees you've just abandoned to be extracted (or in one case, medevac'd after a medical emergency) from the places they were sent to is just cruel (and again, illegal).

Re:Grok3 Launch by mrtesthah on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:38PM (#43092643)
1. Making all positions partisan is a fascist tactic to challenge objective truth.

2. Congress as a whole isn’t a single entity —- one party refuses to compromise in any way while the other plays by the rules.

3. Doesn’t matter. Cost reform needs to go through existing legal routes.

4. What constitutes “auditing” the government? Because we had plenty of non partisan positions overseeing and auditing all parts of the government. DOGE fired those people.

5. Again, go through the legal route.

6. A lack of “digital transformation” is the vaguest most unconvincing point in this entire justification.

7. These budget issues need to be decided on through constitutional processes and with oversight, as before.

8. Ditto.

9. Medicare can lower health costs by other means, such as being available universally to all and setting limits on what they pay to providers based on procedure.

10. Do you watch CSPAN?

Re:Grok3 Launch by Tycho on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:38AM (#43091758)
But it is a partisan issue. All these people on fat NGO salaries, all these federal workers not pulling their weight, all the welfare abuse, all these aid payments - which party do you think is keen to keep the spigot flowing? Of course, it would be a shame if they didn’t audit the Pentagon as well, definitely massive graft happening there.
Re:Grok3 Launch by d0gsg0w00f on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:09PM (#43092210)
Allegedly, the Pentagon sees the writing on the wall and is trying to get a head start on DOGE

https://www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/doge-departme...

Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:54AM (#43091989)
It’s just wild to me that an attempt to tally up whats in the community grain store and where it’s allocated out to is even considered a bipartisan issue.
Re:Grok3 Launch by matwood on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:40PM (#43092678)
The problem is the person doing the tallying is doing it behind closed doors, has routinely been shown to lie to further his interests and has already been caught lying with the tallies he's released.

The GOP controls both houses and the POTUS. They could absolutely do a top to bottom audit with full transparency and make cuts where needed. But that's not what this is about.

Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:12PM (#43093101)
Is that totally true, though? Maybe they have pulled wool over my eyes, but it seems like we've seen more transparency in the last few weeks than the last 40 years.

Just poke around a bit: https://doge.gov/savings

And please even try to explain how this sort of thing is even remotely in America's best interest:

https://www.usaspending.gov/award/CONT_AWD_FA865018C7886_970...

> ACTIVE SOCIAL ENGINEERING DEFENSE (ASED) LARGE SCALE SOCIAL DECEPTION (LSD)

Then there's the basic accounting 101 things like improper categorization, 150 year old people getting social security, etc. Why should the US government be held to a lower standard than a publicly traded company?

Re:Grok3 Launch by matwood on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:01PM (#43093681)
Do you have a third party audit that this is true or have those datasets all been removed? Musk has shown himself unknowledgeable at best and purposely lying at worse so many DOGE findings are hard to take at face value.

https://apnews.com/article/usaid-funding-trump-musk-misinfor...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/conormurray/2025/02/10/elon-mus...

Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:54PM (#43094225)
Did you even read those articles? Full of BS excuses and justifications. None of them pass the sniff test by any honest person with above room temperature IQ.

People are just angry at Musk for turning their safe space into a free speech platform then switching sides. And that he’s now taking away their sides unlimited slush fund.

Re:Grok3 Launch by matwood on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:39AM (#43099973)
You clearly don't want to read anything outside of Twitter/Musk, but another error, fixed/hidden in order to keep showing incorrect data that looks better for DOGE.

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/18/upshot/doge-contracts-mus...

The DOGE website initially included a screenshot from the federal contracting database showing that the contract’s value was $8 million, even as the DOGE site listed $8 billion in savings. On Tuesday night, around the time this article was published, DOGE removed the screenshot that showed the mismatch, but continued to claim $8 billion in savings. It added a link to the original, outdated version of the contract worth $8 billion.

So much honesty and transparency out of this group.

Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:57PM (#43106731)
Man people can’t stand that Elon turned Twitter into a free speech platform. Anyways, I'm more of a long-form article, book, podcast and travel guy when it comes to informing my opinion.
Re:Grok3 Launch by Tycho on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:22PM (#43095281)
This ASED and LSD, aren’t they services to help the state counteract an information warfare attack? Just guessing, but it sounds like a legitimate thing where they’d want capacity to uncover/expose such activities, which I’m sure adversaries would consider.
Re:Grok3 Launch by deng on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:35PM (#43095408)
Yes, the contract was for researching defenses against deception, was first awarded under Trump and also on public record, visible for many years, not "revealed" by anyone, especially not those DOGE masterminds. But what's even the point now? I think we're past discussing any facts here, because OP has a "sniff test" instead (see answer below).
Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:43PM (#43095484)
Sure, sure. Pentagon money going to the western press, USAID (a literal terrorist organization) funding both sides of the narrative, what could go wrong?

There was a time liberals screamed at the top of their lungs over this type of threat to democracy, now they embrace and endorse it because they’ve fully merged with the primacy neocons.

Re:Grok3 Launch by deng on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:50PM (#43095573)
Yeah, thanks for proving my point. Have a nice day.
Re:Grok3 Launch by matwood on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:45AM (#43099301)
> USAID (a literal terrorist organization)

Maybe get your news from somewhere other than Twitter.

Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:06PM (#43106026)
Maybe you could recommend some western news sources that haven't been infected by USAIDS?
Re:Grok3 Launch by bloopernova on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:48PM (#43092792)
I don't know any voters who want fraud to continue, but most do accept that fraud is just a part of any system designed and implemented by humans.

I personally would like to see the end of the "find gravy train, keep that gravy flowing at all costs" methodology of capitalism, because it's primary focus is money instead of the service provided. Whether it's pentagon contractors, business subsidies, or the heinous medicare and medical insurance fraud. But I don't want to cut SNAP even if someone buys a goddamn coke once in a while.

The current method seems to be brain surgery with a monkey wrench. Slash and burn with little thought given to the effects upon humans, especially those who don't have other options. Kagi gave me a figure of between 9.2 to 15.2 percent of welfare being fraudulent. Yes that's too high, yes I'd like to fix that, but I want that change to be considered, studied, and planned with caution.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Tycho on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:32PM (#43095370)
Tbh I think “move fast and break things” is what’s needed. The government bureaucracy has ossified over many years, and any attempt to change it gets bogged down in “committees” and “inquiries”. The only thing that will work is shock and awe, and if something important does get broken, it’s east enough to fix when its criticality becomes evident.
Re:Grok3 Launch by KerrAvon on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:15AM (#43090442)
Has it occurred to you that the people who feel rage fundamentally understand the situation, and you may be undereducated in this area? What do you think are the root causes of that “senseless partisan drive”?

I’d suggest starting with Rick Perlman’s book “Nixonland” if you’re interested.

Re:Grok3 Launch by diggan on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:25AM (#43090574)
> Has it occurred to you that the people who feel rage fundamentally understand the situation, and you may be undereducated in this area?

Regardless of how justified the rage is or not, being very emotional about things usually have one of two effects on people A) people gets taken aback by someone's strong emotions or B) people get inspired/taking with the emotion, even feeling that emotion stronger themselves. Sometimes also C) they don't really care either way.

What probably isn't helpful, is calling someone is "undereducated" when they're clearly saying that they're person (A), and just because they may or may not agree with you (although parent didn't even clearly say they disagree, just that they're "taken aback" a bit).

Some people are calm regardless of what's going on around them, even if the world would be on fire, they'd try to describe what's going on around them with careful words and consideration. It isn't wrong or right, just like the people who feel rage and very emotional aren't wrong or right, it's just a showcase how we're different.

But we should aim to at least understand each other, not by trying to provoke, instigate or look down on others, but by asking questions to clarify and to better understand.

Re:Grok3 Launch by elorm on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:33AM (#43090677)
You're doing the exact same thing he is addressing in that statement above. He's not belittling anyone's rage, he's speaking about people who incite others to feel the rage with them. Now let's turn your question around.

Has it occurred to you that the people who feel rage fundamentally misunderstand the situation and are completely undereducated in this area, and are only fuelled by sensationalism and Media manipulation? And then I suggest you go read Dirty Politics by Kathleen Hall Jamieson if you're interested, because that's what people who want to sound more intelligent than the other half of the conversation always do.

How does it help anyone?

Re:Grok3 Launch by jtrn on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:37AM (#43090734)
Has it occurred to you that nothing is more powerful for coming up with intellectual arguments than a strong driving emotion?

Yes, rage might be the appropriate and response given the situation. But it’s often true that it starts with an emotion, and then people just argue from there. Even while being wrong. Just look at all the people with contradictory opinions in history, both with strong, emotional rage, and and equally certain of their connection. Throwing the fact that people actually has a tendency to want to be angry.

Re:Grok3 Launch by normalaccess on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:28AM (#43091545)
Rage is the fuel of the internet, but it’s fundamentally useless when it comes to seeking truth. Social media platforms are engineered to maximize engagement, and the most engaging emotion is anger. This isn’t accidental—outrage drives clicks, shares, and ad revenue. The internet has long been called a “hate machine,” and there’s plenty of truth to that.

This creates an environment where misinformation and emotional appeals spread faster than facts. When discussing complex, non-trivial topics, logic and reason are the only tools that can cut through the noise. But in a system designed to reward outrage, those tools are often drowned out.

I highly recommend Sam Vaknin's talk about Social Media toxicity.

Sources: Outrage is the most profitable emotion https://www.cityam.com/outrage-most-profitable-emotion-so-ad...

Sam Vaknin: The TRUE Toxicity of Social Media Revealed - Interview by Richard Grannon https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o58mFU004hg

Re:Grok3 Launch by concordDance on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:23AM (#43090540)
Given the two of you probably have different models of reality, perhaps you two can try and figure out which is correct by seeing which model gives better predictions?

So try to come up with some sort of future observation that can be made where you think the other person's model would give a different answer to yours about what you would be able to objectively observe.

What do you reckon?

Re:Grok3 Launch by vlovich123 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:33AM (#43090683)
Over what time scale, how do we agree on facts, and how do we evaluate things that require a common value system to determine whether the facts are good or bad?
Re:Grok3 Launch by concordDance on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:34AM (#43091682)
The idea would be that the two of them collaboratively agree on some observable prediction they differ on. E.g. level of officially reported government spending in 4 years time or gdp growth rate next year or number of plane crashes next year or what have you.

Just some observable metric.

If they literally can't come up with a single observable predictive difference then the predictive aspects of their models are actually equivalent and they are only narratively different and don't "really disagree". Like Copenhagen interpretation vs many worlds.

Re:Grok3 Launch by vlovich123 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:43PM (#43094110)
Many things don't have quantifiable metrics like that. For example, is USA still a democracy in 4 years? Are people more or less free?. You know, important questions that aren't just economic numbers. Even semi-quantifiable stuff like "are Americans better educated" is debatable on many topics if you can't agree on truth. Oh, and that GDP growth rate number? That relies on a lot of trust as to who's doing the reporting. For example, many people don't believe China's reported GDP numbers. What makes you think the USA doesn't devolve to such a distrust as well.
Re:Grok3 Launch by concordDance on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:29AM (#43099908)
If they affect your life they can be observed.

If "democracy" is just metaphysics then it's irrelevant. But if it has actual tangible effects such as "can you vote?", "can you protest the government?", "is the leader of the opposition arrested?", "do most people think they live in a democracy?", "how popular is new legislation compared to previous years?", etc...

Then you can make predictions about it and test them!

You can even do local predictions if both can agree, such as "will the combined incomes of my family be higher or lower in 4 years time?" as low coupling proxies for gdp. (Ideally one would use probabilities for loosely linked proxies like that and use the probability differences the two theories assign to give bits of evidence to one over the other, so you'd want many many such proxies, ideally uncorrelated ones)

Re:Grok3 Launch by vlovich123 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @08:57AM (#43102203)
> can you vote? can you protest the government? do most people think they live in a democracy?

Was Jan 6 a protest of the government or an insurrection? Can Russians vote or are elections a sham? Do the majority of Russians believe they live in a democracy if they’re afraid of whose conducting the polling (or the MAGA non response to polling)? Those are values question that require you to have an agreement on reality.

> You can even do local predictions if both can agree, such as "will the combined incomes of my family be higher or lower in 4 years time?" as low coupling proxies for gdp

Your personal income has absolutely no predictive value on gdp. It’s more predictive of whether you personally made successful bets or even if you’re better at sucking up to the current power structure. It tells you nothing about population level metrics if you have no way of conducting reliable population level surveys. For example Donald Trump’s personal net worth sky rocketed under Biden because he won the election while as the leader of the opposition to the democrats was looking at jail time and whether that was legitimate or not depends on which political lens you look through it.

> If they affect your life they can be observed.

Ah, but if either side distrusts the other about whether the observation made is truthfully reported, how do you solve that? It requires some amount of trust and right now there’s a very clear divide there.

Re:Grok3 Launch by concordDance on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:37PM (#43108048)
There are definitely tangible predictive differences in the case of, say, Russia vs USA. Things like "If you go to the capital with a bunch of friends carrying placards saying '$LEADER is corrupt and evil and should be replaced by $OPPOSITION' how many of you end up in a jail cell in the next day?".

If there is literally no tangible difference then it's just label games and metaphysics and doesn't matter.

> Your personal income has absolutely no predictive value on gdp.

It actually is correlated (admittedly in most day-to-day cases it's just a lagging indicator, but things like natural disasters hit both). It's not the strongest correlation but it would still be evidential. Definitely under 1.0 bits though... One would need a LOT of such observations and having them not screen each other off to start getting a convincing number of bits.

Probably not realistic to have humans manage these sorts of numerous tiny updates though...

/nitpicks

> Ah, but if either side distrusts the other about whether the observation made is truthfully reported, how do you solve that? It requires some amount of trust and right now there’s a very clear divide there.

Yeah, it gets much trickier like that. But I do think two reasonable people from the opposite political sides could agree on some sort of observable to the extent their disagreement is anything other than narrative.

Re:Grok3 Launch by vlovich123 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @10:46PM (#43110863)
> Things like "If you go to the capital with a bunch of friends carrying placards saying '$LEADER is corrupt and evil and should be replaced by $OPPOSITION' how many of you end up in a jail cell in the next day?".

If the other side calls it a violent riot does it still count as people getting put in jail? Cause the Jan 6 insurrection and BLM protests occurred at about the same time and are viewed very differently depending on which political lens you put on.

> If there is literally no tangible difference then it's just label games and metaphysics and doesn't matter.

You’re discounting feelings as if it doesn’t matter. But if people believe or feel like they live in a dictatorship, what quantitative data are you going to use to disprove that. Moreover, why aren’t feelings valid when talking about politics which is fundamentally an emotionally driven human activity and not a data driven one? By the way the left believes they live in an authoritarian dictatorship under Trump while the right believes they lived in an authoritarian dictatorship under Biden. And political power literally is the power to emotionally manipulate others because you individually can’t actually accomplish anything by yourself.

Re:Grok3 Launch by InTheArena on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:22AM (#43090523)
As a Historian (and a German historian in particular) - I've spent a reasonable amount of time educating myself on the nature of fascism and in particular the break down of democracies (Wiemar, France, and also the erosion of civil liberties during the great depression in the United States).

I have also been a delegate to both the RNC and the DNC at a state level.

This is not a appeal to authority, but rather a honest response to your request for my education level.

IMHO, The root cause of the "senseless partisan drive" is the fact that he founding fathers could not come up with a way to restrict parties (they called them "interests") and left them unchecked. This is a constant "sin" of the American political system, and is a key reason Slavery survived as long as it did, why separate but equal became the law of the land, why America shot itself in the foot several time with the Banks of America and why we are looking at the wrong side of history now.

The parties now act to destroy each other as their prime directive, rather then to better the country. I liken this to Wiemar Germany, where the increasing radicalization of both the Nazis and the Communists led to political instability and eventual violence that destroyed the government. That erosion of democratic norms, as well as the "other side must be destroyed for us to survive" messaging is the true threat, IMHO.

I would strongly suggest Richard Evan's three part history on Nazi history to understand Fascism. Don't worry, you can still hate and worry about Trump and think he is the next coming of Hitler afterwords - it will just be for better reasons.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Hasu on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:49PM (#43092803)
> I always worry whenever I see people telling me how to feel - rage in this case.

No one told you to feel rage.

> Throw in the complete dismisal that anyone not scared of this is ignorant, shuts down discussion.

Weird, there are a lot of comments doing discussion in reply to the parent comment. It hasn't been shut down at all! You read those words and disagreed with them, and wrote your own words in response. You're doing the discussion you're claiming is being shut down! What are you even talking about?

Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:32AM (#43089906)
I'm not sure how LLMs/AI couldn't consolidate power. By design, it will move power from the individual to those running the AI systems.
Re:Grok3 Launch by llm_trw on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:37AM (#43090738)
Because the difference between a model that costs 10 million to train and a model that costs 10 billion to train is 6 months.

Deepseek R1 is something that you can run in a garage on hardware that the average software engineer can buy with a months salary and when it came out last month it was better than _every_ other model.

Re:Grok3 Launch by cedws on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:55AM (#43090968)
What about third world programmers? They can’t necessarily afford a $5000 GPU. If it weren’t for the “generosity” of tech companies like GitHub granting free LLM usage, they might be locked out entirely. This would put them at a disadvantage, we can argue to what degree but it’s still a disadvantage.

Depending on the curve we’re on, LLMs may grow more resource hungry while becoming closer to human performance in software engineering tasks. It’s not unimaginable this would concentrate productivity in the upper class of software engineers that can afford the hardware and/or licenses.

Re:Grok3 Launch by llm_trw on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:59AM (#43091029)
$5000 monthly salary?

My heart goes out to all the oppressed programmers in the EU.

Re:Grok3 Launch by ben_w on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:59PM (#43095658)
EU isn't "third world".

Kenya is, and at current exchange rates the range in this citation is $558-$1876/month: https://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/kenya-software-engineer-s...

Re:Grok3 Launch by llm_trw on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:27PM (#43095912)
With salaries like that it's not first world either.

If op is trying to catch up to frontier models locally on a budget 1/5th of what you can get in the west then I can see why she would feel the way she does about Ai.

Re:Grok3 Launch by ben_w on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:05PM (#43096282)
What are you even talking about?

You said a month's salary; cedws said "third world" devs can't afford $5000 — and this is correct, third world devs can't afford that. cedws did not say EU, they said third world, at least not here. You said EU, not them.

When you reply to me with "With salaries like that it's not first world either", who is "they"? The country I said explicitly was third world? Because that's a tautology.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Fnoord on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:14AM (#43091274)
Deepseek R1 performs well on a 600 EUR Jetson, and a 700 EUR AMD GPU. Both bought during COVID crisis. It is that quick. However, don't ask it about certain sensitive topics.

You can bet your ass Musk is using his AI tools as propaganda tool for his advancement, just like he does with X. We already seen prompt leak of Grok, it wasn't neutral.

Re:Grok3 Launch by mrtesthah on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:46PM (#43092750)
This is exactly correct. Grok is already slandering specific journalistic outlets such as “The Information” that publish negative stories on Musk.
Re:Grok3 Launch by mwigdahl on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:24AM (#43091471)
No, it was not. It was not better than o1, nor o1-pro. Yes, it was _cheaper_ than those models, and superior in price/performance if the performance was acceptable. But in terms of raw performance it was behind them.
Re:Grok3 Launch by johnfn on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:56AM (#43092020)
Chatbot arena leaderboard[1] says otherwise. 4o is ahead now, but that version of 4o was released after r1. r1 was ahead of all version of 4o and o1 at the time of release.

https://huggingface.co/spaces/lmarena-ai/chatbot-arena-leade...

Re:Grok3 Launch by mwigdahl on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:38PM (#43098637)
Chatbot arena leaderboard is a good test for vibes and style of response, but not much else. R1's performance in objective benchmarks (coding, etc.) showed very good performance, granted, but inferior to the full o1 and o1-pro models.

It's still a very impressive feat, but it wasn't frontier-pushing.

Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:47PM (#43092779)
Is it your expectation that as models get cheaper we won't be developing much more powerful models at the higher price range?

Its already worth noting that we already ran into the self hosting at scale problem. People don't want to run a web server and instead accept all the problems that come along with the convenience of social media. Why would LLMs, or any future AI product, be different?

Re:Grok3 Launch by tartoran on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:44AM (#43090039)
I'm not sure people will just take it though. In the short term it looks like the situation is on a horrible course but eventually people will have had enough. I'm hoping it would take less time for that to happen and the damage will not be too great. Let's remember that we could use the same technology if not a better one to fight against all this.
Re:Grok3 Launch by xenodium on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:00AM (#43090254)
> but eventually people will have had enough

As a Venezuelan, I thought so too. 25 years on...

Re:Grok3 Launch by bloopernova on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:03AM (#43091087)
A lot of US citizens are living incredibly comfortable lives. If that is threatened, for instance by food shortages caused by lack of people willing to work on farms for very low wages, then protests may happen.

But the reality distortion field around the current administration is very powerful. Fox and CNN are owned by supporters of the republicans, NYTimes and Washington Post don't appear to be reporting certain aspects of the government restructuring. Multiple social media sites are owned and ran by people who support the current admin.

I am personally worried that we're going to see the gradual yet continual escalation of rhetoric, more actions that undermine rule of law, and continued lack of critical thinking in so many people. That path appears to lead to extremism.

I have a horrible feeling that whoever "wins" in a couple of decades or so will have no time to savour their utopia as the climate catastrophe really starts to bite hard.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Gothmog69 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:18AM (#43091347)
So you are a leftist who believes the economy can't operate without basically third world slaves working in your fields?
Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:50PM (#43092811)
We enslaved the planet with industrialization and we are about to enslave AI, if we haven't already. Humans aren't on the losing end of that, but if your concern is with slavery itself that wouldn't matter.
Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:47AM (#43090081)
When a potential power imbalance is created, those willing to use it for selfish means will almost always win in the end.

Anyone with morals driving their use of a new tech will be limited, and unless those people massively outnumber the few selfish ones they will lose eventually.

Re:Grok3 Launch by tartoran on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:10AM (#43090376)
Losing a battle is painful but no win is final until things fall into a balance and even that doesn't last forever or it even reverse. The worst case scenario is not going to matter for anyone in the grand scheme of things because there will not be anyone around.
Re:Grok3 Launch by ryandrake on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:19AM (#43091368)
I'm not sure I understand how a hallucinating plagiarism machine that people mostly just use to write their term papers translates into "power" (presumably political power? I don't understand what kind of power we're talking about either).
Re:Grok3 Launch by psb217 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:38AM (#43091763)
The ability to inject your preferred biases into the system that people use for finding or generating nearly all information they consume on a day-to-day basis is extremely powerful. Eg, if all "term papers" produced by this plagiarism machine are now 20% more favourable to the machine's owner than they would otherwise be, that can have significant, compounding long-term effects.

Of course, similar things could be said about controlling information flow through: social networks, newspapers, printed books, or whatever the town crier shouts in town square. But, each advancement in information dissemination tends to be power concentrating relative to the older tech, and I don't see any reason why this most recent advance won't follow that trend.

Re:Grok3 Launch by smeeger on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:42AM (#43090008)
bingo. and everyone is fine with it as long as the consolidation is benefiting their own tribe.
Re:Grok3 Launch by throwaway657656 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:25AM (#43090576)
Definitely not everyone. For many of us, checks and balances are a feature not a bug.
Re:Grok3 Launch by tartoran on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:46AM (#43090075)
A spark can start a fire, it doesn't seem wise to ignore history. Things can always get out of control even for the ones up there on top of the pyramid of power.
Re:Grok3 Launch by cwalv on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:30AM (#43090638)
That was fast. Perhaps we should imagine this has nothing to do with Musk to avoid completely derailing the conversation
Re:Grok3 Launch by SubiculumCode on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:47AM (#43090859)
It cannot. Musk is probably the most powerful person in the world now and intent on remaking the world to his vision.
Re:Grok3 Launch by Fnoord on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:19AM (#43091375)
Trump is the most powerful, he is immune and can commune sentences. If he wants to, he puts Musk in jail tomorrow, no question about that. His successor will be as powerful, whether that is his son or Vance is up in the air. It won't be an elected Democrat though.
Re:Grok3 Launch by dvngnt_ on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:29AM (#43091592)
> It won't be an elected Democrat though.

the pendulum swings back and forth. i don't see that changing

Re:Grok3 Launch by Fnoord on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:09PM (#43092204)
There won't be a fair election anymore after 2024. Trump in his own words: "we'll have it fixed so good". Right now, the USA is in a constitutional crisis, at the very least.

There a fantastic website here, following the status of Project 2025 [1], with references. Trump is following that document to the T.

[1] https://www.project2025.observer/

Re:Grok3 Launch by matwood on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:47PM (#43092771)
I, probably naively, hold out hope. But Trump/Musk dismantling the groups who work to keep elections fair and free is disturbing.

https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/02/07/trump...

https://www.npr.org/2025/02/11/nx-s1-5293521/foreign-influen...

Re:Grok3 Launch by throw16180339 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:52PM (#43098017)
It's an open question if elections will even be held. If they are, demographic changes also make it much harder for the Democrats to win after 2030 (https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/democrats-future-crisi...).
Re:Grok3 Launch by brabel on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:40PM (#43092681)
> If he wants to, he puts Musk in jail tomorrow,

Has America already become an authoritarian state where this sort of thing really happens?? I don't know, I haven't seen that sort of thing happen yet.

Re:Grok3 Launch by cheema33 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:28PM (#43093286)
> Has America already become an authoritarian state where this sort of thing really happens?

The conservative Supreme court recently ruled that the president has essentially unlimited power. During his campaign, Trump did promise that he will be a dictator for a day. Appears to be overdoing it.

Re:Grok3 Launch by pcthrowaway on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:13PM (#43093817)
You might be surprised to learn they could change their ruling if the court justices were to be incentivized differently, and that Musk has a lot of influence.
Re:Grok3 Launch by ben_w on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:07PM (#43095737)
Musk indeed has a lot of influence. Trump is a narcissist. Not saying this will happen, but it's definitely not impossible that Trump just orders Musk shot (as per opinion of what's now allowed in the dissenting opinion of Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor) — if such an order is followed, I wouldn't want to guess, but death has a way of significantly altering someone's influence.
Re:Grok3 Launch by pcthrowaway on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:12PM (#43093804)
There are different kinds of power, and I'm honestly not sure Trump can get Musk thrown in jail. On what basis would Trump even do that?

Similarly, Musk can potentially launch a campaign to sway the public to move for Trump to be impeached due to his felony convictions.

A battle between the two might be the shakeup the current empire needs.

Trump may be more powerful than Musk by some metrics, on a time-limited basis (unless he manages to change the term limits), but Musk is more powerful in many ways as well. Musk's wealth is greater than that of many entire countries.

Re:Grok3 Launch by actionfromafar on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:23PM (#43096425)
Basis? Since when is Trump looking for a basis? Musk could sway out a window. Russia / US relations are being normalized, maybe it could be a small gesture of goodwill to help a friend out if one wanted to keep the regular chain of command clean.
Re:Grok3 Launch by srid on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:41AM (#43090003)
I do not share your fear & anxiety. What concrete danger do you imagine will happen as a result of xAI? Try to be as concrete as possible.

Also, dang, is there anything we can do to keep the comments on this submission tech-focused? Perhaps the Elon-bashing political digression can be split into its own thread?

Re:Grok3 Launch by Arubis on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:44AM (#43090041)
Tech is the most powerful force in the modern economy. There is no making it not political. "Tech isn't political" _is a political statement_.
Re:Grok3 Launch by cbm-vic-20 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:18AM (#43090483)
The problem, as I see it, is that the results from AI systems will either be used to make decisions, even if those results are flawed. Or worse, those flawed results will be used to justify decisions that negatively impact peoples' lives.

This isn't something specific to xAI, but it turns out that the person who controls xAI also holds an unusually strong influence over the highest level government officials. These officials can use xAI as an excuse to implement harmful policy, "because the computer said this is the best course of action"- not unlike people who end up driving on train tracks or into large bodies of water because their GPS told them to go that way.

Re:Grok3 Launch by troyvit on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:43AM (#43090810)
I think this comment sums it up well. As soon as advanced LLMs started making a splash we all saw the writing on the wall. AI will start taking on large chunks of cognitive load across industry, government, etc. that humans formerly held (It has already been a strong driver in finance).

I for one was ready to welcome my AI overlords once they were mature and tested. It was an inevitability. Because of the relationship between this oligarch and the government though it looks like the time line has accelerated and we're going to see misplaced trust in tools that aren't ready for what we're about to hand them.

Re:Grok3 Launch by digdugdirk on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:01AM (#43090261)
The concrete danger isn't necessarily with xAI (the product) but with Elon being the one who is in control of it. LLMs are an interesting technology, and we should absolutely be investing in pushing our understanding of the technology forward. We should absolutely not be relying on them for the ongoing functioning of our government: https://www.axios.com/2025/02/05/musk-doge-ai-government-eff...

Unfortunately, Elon has made himself a spectacle. To separate him and his intentions out from the technology itself would be a disservice to the discourse as a whole.

Re:Grok3 Launch by srid on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:06AM (#43090319)
Hmm, I'm only too happy to rephrase my question, then.

What concrete danger do you imagine will happen as a result of xAI being controlled by Elon? Try to be as concrete as possible.

Re:Grok3 Launch by katbyte on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:01PM (#43093680)
he will bias it toward his views and favoured outcomes like he did twitter

and those are pretty terrible, anti-science, and petty

Re:Grok3 Launch by wezdog1 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:46AM (#43090065)
I do not share your fear & anxiety so please dont share yours.
Re:Grok3 Launch by spiderfarmer on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:02AM (#43090287)
How is this Elon-bashing? Address his concerns. Elon is not a king that shouldn't be questioned. Quite the contrary.
Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:53AM (#43090170)
> How long before this starts getting deployed in safety critical applications or government decision making processes

Hopefully sooner than later. I trust this more than the literal scammers and thieves who were previously running things.

Re:Grok3 Launch by spiderfarmer on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:00AM (#43090258)
This is exactly the sort of comment I would expect from a HN bot with Grok as a backend that did an extra round of training on X posts under Fox News articles.
Re:Grok3 Launch by jcpham2 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:16AM (#43090460)
Yeah unfortunately I've spent a good bit of time talking to Grok (v2 I guess) and I agree with you. The commenter asking people not be political would be the same commenter that seems the most dismissive of any criticism and coincidentally also the most political. Grok is generally dismissive of any criticism(s) against certain parties, even when presenting facts.
Re:Grok3 Launch by amazingamazing on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:31AM (#43090647)
I’m not really following what this has to do with grok. It’s his company, no?

It’s also annoying that the top comment engages in no way with the content of the OP…

It must be truly infuriating to work hard to push a release, and you see it featured on your favorite orange website, only for the top comment to have nothing to do with what was worked on.

Here's a test - if this post was about Starship, the same comment could apply! Neuralink, the same thing! Boring Company, same thing! Wow, could it be that such a comment is really applicable to so many different companies or projects, or is it just a generic one? You decide.

Re:Grok3 Launch by gyanchawdhary on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:46AM (#43090842)
The best comment on this thread !
Re:Grok3 Launch by finnthehuman on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:43AM (#43090020)
> it fills me with rage that Elon has this sort of unchecked power

I can empathize, but I can't feel indignant about it. Not any more.

For years and years I've watched people warn about the centralization of power by tech companies. They were shut down left and right. I'm not accusing you of being one doing the shutting down. I'm just annoyed that Elon is what it takes for people to start realizing the people arguing the principal might have been onto something.

And I expect to see them start getting their "I told you so" in. Watching this play out, I'm personally inclined to join team "you made your bed, now sleep in it."

Re:Grok3 Launch by tartoran on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:48AM (#43090094)
All it takes is some big fcukups and a political shift for these to be broken down to smithereens.
Re:Grok3 Launch by randomcarbloke on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:51AM (#43090138)
I just wish it was someone technical or otherwise genuinely intelligent that did this.
Re:Grok3 Launch by soheil on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:43AM (#43091841)
Never seen HN turned against someone so vehemently, it's as if a group of bots was set lose to criticize a certain individual.
Re:Grok3 Launch by hahamrfunnyguy on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:05PM (#43093010)
It's been a long time coming with Elon Musk, and he has been criticized A LOT on Hacker News.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27796948 (2021) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33622767 (2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11025852 (2016)

I would also argue he is not being singled out, here are some comments posted criticizing Steve Jobs:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28295688 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5578642

It really shouldn't come as a surprise that notable people related to a company or project are brought up when an article about it appears on HN.

Re:Grok3 Launch by katbyte on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:03PM (#43093713)
or just maybe, and i know its a crazy idea, a certain individual is objectively an awful person who has done great harm in the world and its subjective if its greater or lesser then the good (imho its far greater harms then any good done but i know that is my subjective view)

just because you disagree with a widespread view/opinion does not mean its bots

Re:Grok3 Launch by pton_xd on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:06PM (#43094372)
> done great harm in the world

Can someone enumerate the "great harm" that Elon is doing? I honestly don't see it.

Re:Grok3 Launch by dkjaudyeqooe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:09PM (#43094405)
"There are none so blind as those who will not see"
Re:Grok3 Launch by cynicalpeace on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:39AM (#43090760)
> it fills me with rage that Elon has this sort of unchecked power.

The check on this is the market. Don't understand your point other than "Elon bad"

Re:Grok3 Launch by dionian on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:06AM (#43090321)
It's nothing in comparison to NBC/CBS/ABC/NYT/etc. But still a fair point
Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:54AM (#43090172)
There is precisely zero mention of any plan to put xAI or any other LLM in any safety critical or decision making process. How long? Nobody knows because nobody is even considering it. Take your pointless fear mongering elsewhere.
Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:58AM (#43090226)
It's well documented that DOGE uses AI, and Musk has tweeted that SpaceX will be overhauling the FAA as well. It's pretty realistic to think they will (or already do) use xAI for critical processes.
Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:03AM (#43090294)
DOGE makes recommendations to the president, who has the final decision making authority.

The rest is pure speculation. “It is very reasonable to believe this thing that confirms all my biases so therefore it must be true”

Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:12AM (#43090400)
I would argue that developing those recommendations is a "safety critical" task. Especially given that just in the past few days they accidentally fired, then re-hired, a bunch of nuclear weapons safety workers.
Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:19AM (#43090494)
That is the MO. Elon has stated publicly that if you don’t have to put something back, you haven’t cut enough. That is the idea. You cut things and see what was necessary.
Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:54AM (#43090945)
That might work if you're slashing headcount at a social media company (though I would argue that it doesn't), but the stakes are a bit higher when you're responsible for things like feeding hungry people, curing disease, or keeping planes in the sky.
Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:07AM (#43091148)
Feeding hungry people: when I’m hungry I feed myself. Why can’t they?

Curing diseases: name a disease the US government cured.

Keeping planes in the sky: it’s easy when you hire people based on merit and not because they got handed the answers to a personality quiz.

Re:Grok3 Launch by lawlessone on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:19PM (#43093194)
>when I’m hungry I feed myself. Why can’t they?

you know exactly what you are doing here Gabe, its easy to say all this stuff when you're sitting pretty in Hong Kong.

Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:53PM (#43095614)
“Sitting pretty”, yes, that’s what I’m doing.

I’ll end this here since you don’t seem to have anything else relevant to say, and instead prefer to stalk my profile. Enjoy. It’s good reading if I do say so myself.

Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:47PM (#43093512)
>Curing diseases: name a disease the US government cured.

Smallpox?

Re:Grok3 Launch by herval on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:19AM (#43091372)
Worth noticing that it _doesn't even work at a social media company_. Twitter is a husk of its former self, with all the problems that were if not solved, at least mitigated, back in full force (child porn, bots, impersonators). It's just kept alive because it's a honeypot for right wing nutjobs now (which I'm sure can't read an SEC filing and will claim it's "operating better than before").

It'll be a disaster for the soon-to-be-previous most powerful country on earth...

Re:Grok3 Launch by katbyte on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:05PM (#43093734)
you can't do that in government and services people rely on to you know, live. people will die (and i wouldn't be surprised if some already have)

shows a total disregard for the wellbeing of others

Re:Grok3 Launch by herval on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:22AM (#43091436)
> DOGE makes recommendations to the president

Trump is so far gone in his dementia, he can't even make eye contact anymore. You see this in all the videos. He's basically King Théoden at this point. Not even Musk's kid respects him.

He's so disabled, he's sending his VP to do the job, and we all know how much of a paranoid child he is, from the past term (when he went into a Colonoscopy without anesthesia just to not have to give the nuclear codes to the VP).

Re:Grok3 Launch by cowpig on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:17AM (#43090471)
> DOGE makes recommendations to the president, who has the final decision making authority.

It's clearly being run by Elon Musk, but he has not been nominated or confirmed for any official position.

DOGE appears to have unprecedented access to systems that usually have safeguards in place. What do you think people should do in this situation if they are concerned about abuse of power?

Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:23AM (#43090532)
DOGE is a rebranding of USDS which was established under Obama. All their authority to access systems derives from that.

They have read-only access to systems and the “abuses” seem to be publicly posting what the government is spending money on.

Why do you think it’s a problem for the public to know where the government spends money?

Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:26AM (#43090584)
Government spending is mostly already public information. Ironically, it's DOGE itself which is trying it's best to act in secrecy.
Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:34AM (#43090695)
If they are cloaked in secrecy how do you know what you’re even mad about? The people who are tweeting everything they do are acting in secret?

If all they are doing is posting information that was already public then what exactly is your problem?

Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:38AM (#43090749)
> If they are cloaked in secrecy how do you know what you’re even mad about?

Do you hear yourself?

Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:54AM (#43090950)
Do you hear yourself?

Name a specific thing you would like to know about DOGE that is not publicly disclosed.

Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:03AM (#43091081)
I could go into details (What are they doing to ensure data privacy? Can/do they exfiltrate data and run it through external AI models? What kind of security clearances do the children of DOGE have?).

But just on the surface, Elon has accused a journalist who published the name of DOGE employees of breaking the law. If it were up to them, even that would be kept secret. This is not a transparent organization.

Re:Grok3 Launch by lawlessone on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:03AM (#43091086)
>Name a specific thing you would like to know about DOGE that is not publicly disclosed.

Why one of the guys working for it was running a dodgy image sharing website and has links to cycbercrime and CSAM?

and why Elon called the journos that revealed these links criminals?

Re:Grok3 Launch by amazingamazing on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:33AM (#43090687)
The details of said spending is very much not public, and even if it was (it’s not) - it’s not accessible. If it's not true, would love to see links where I can see everything easily.
Re:Grok3 Launch by cowpig on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:36AM (#43090725)
> DOGE is a rebranding of USDS which was established under Obama. All their authority to access systems derives from that.

OK I actually know what this is and no, it's absolutely nothing like the USDS, which builds tools to support government processes. What has DOGE built?

> Why do you think it’s a problem for the public to know where the government spends money?

I would very much like to see transparency, and if that were what DOGE was doing it would be great. But it looks to me like they're operating in secrecy and firing huge numbers of people before publishing any kind of analysis or study, without even providing reasoning for what they're doing.

Re:Grok3 Launch by moolcool on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:41AM (#43090785)
> What has DOGE built?

They built a portal to look at government spending, which is both worse than the existing visualizations, and did not put authentication in front of it's database. https://www.theverge.com/news/612865/doge-government-website...

Re:Grok3 Launch by lawlessone on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:13AM (#43090425)
>DOGE makes recommendations to the president,

Yeah but Elon is your president now.

Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:20AM (#43090505)
Grow up
Re:Grok3 Launch by lawlessone on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:24AM (#43090552)
>Grow up

Would you say i'm being more or less mature than your president ?

Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:32AM (#43090672)
Considerably less.
Re:Grok3 Launch by lawlessone on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:50AM (#43090898)
>Considerably less.

How so?

Re:Grok3 Launch by KronisLV on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:09AM (#43090367)
3rd party example: https://arstechnica.com/health/2023/11/ai-with-90-error-rate...

No comment about current US politics, but it’s probably a given that many will read “A computer can never be held accountable, therefore a computer must never make a management decision.” and drop the second part because the first is exactly what they want. Same as how you can’t get in touch with human support on many platforms nowadays, but instead just get useless bot responses.

Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:38AM (#43090755)
“It bolsters my argument to assume this thing is true so it’s a given that it’s true”. Cool. Good job.
Re:Grok3 Launch by pccole on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:33AM (#43090689)
This is a really bad take honestly. This guy sits next to the president. I have no doubt in my mind he will get another government contract and the government will be using Grok.
Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:35AM (#43090713)
Oh wow you imagined something will happen and you have no doubt it will happen. Amazing. Very convincing.
[dead]
Re:Grok3 Launch by herval on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:05AM (#43090317)
It's unbelievable how the US government is literally being dismantled in front of your eyes, and all you can see is this thought-terminating bullshit about "purple hair people". Half the American population completely lost the ability to think...
Re:Grok3 Launch by xedrac on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:18AM (#43090485)
The way I see it is our government is being rescued from the tyranny of unelected bureaucrats with near zero accountability. And now that Trump has appointed someone to take a close look at everything and make recommendations for improvement, people are losing it. Why? I'm outraged at how irresponsible our government has been with my tax dollars. Trump has been the most transparent president in history, and it has absolutely been a breath of fresh air.
Re:Grok3 Launch by cpursley on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:28AM (#43090604)
Yeah, exactly. It blows my mind that expecting accountability, transparency, and effectiveness out of public servants is even a partisan issue.
Re:Grok3 Launch by imgabe on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:32AM (#43090667)
Large parts of the government needed to be dismantled. I know this is a shock to the people whose solution to every problem is “give the government more money”, but amazingly, people who primarily take a job because it has a cushy pension and its impossible to get fired are not the most effective people in the world.
Re:Grok3 Launch by niceice on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:15AM (#43090443)
Ironically you should take your own advice and read more books. This is how power already worked and always works.

TLDR: The status quo elite that have been looting the USA with endless wars for decades is being replaced by the brain that runs SpaceX and is the most transparent elite we've ever seen. Why is that scarier?

It's only scarier if you're happy with the status quo. Most people in the real world are not happy with it.

We're better off and this hysteria will have been all for not. You should be excited more than scared, but I get why it would be a mix of the two. There will be, and have already been, mistakes along the way. Just understand that the algorithm that made SpaceX and Tesla both productive and safe In The Real World is replacing the corrupt and unresponsive bureaucracy.

We're headed to a golden age!

Re:Grok3 Launch by therouwboat on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:25AM (#43090563)
He also runs tesla, twitter, xai, boring company, that brain thing company, government agency and has like 10 kids. I'm scared.
Re:Grok3 Launch by pizzafeelsright on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:38AM (#43091756)
Would it be fair to say you have latched your mind onto something beyond your control which is leading to your fear?

If you got a phone call today about your pancreatic cancer that will kill you in six weeks, do you fear Elon or some political agency?

Re:Grok3 Launch by amazingamazing on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:30AM (#43090632)
Are you actually? Why?
Re:Grok3 Launch by niceice on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:00AM (#43091041)
Richard Dawkins: "I have a very favorable impression of Elon Musk and his concern for the welfare of the world.

I have sat with [Elon] on a transatlantic plane and had a very, very long conversation with him. He's undoubtedly highly intelligent and knowledgeable.

I've had lunch with him on two or three occasions, and so I know him a little bit.

I have formed a very favorable impression of his intelligence, his knowledge and his concern for the welfare of the world."

The Poetry of Reality, November 17, 2024

Re:Grok3 Launch by lonelyasacloud on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:31AM (#43091643)
Intelligence is not a guarantee against getting drawn in by evil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nazi_ideologues .
Re:Grok3 Launch by throw16180339 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:51PM (#43098012)
Elon screws his partners in business deals, cheated Twitter employees out of severance, and is currently destroying our government. All of this trumps a firsthand impression from Dawkins.
Re:Grok3 Launch by silentsanctuary on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:42AM (#43090800)
> TLDR: The status quo elite that have been looting the USA for decades is being replaced by the guy who runs SpaceX and is the most transparent elite we've ever seen. Why is that scarier?

The reason why it's scarier is that for those of us who've come to understand Elon, his actions, and his methods better, it's clear that:

- he IS "the status quo elite that have been looting the USA for decades"

- instead of being an incredibly smart polymath who turns things to gold, it's become obvious his main talent is actually just convincing other people that he's smart

- the successes of Tesla and SpaceX have had to come DESPITE Elon's management, and despite having huge budgets to hire some of the smartest people around, he's still an incredibly weighty anchor pulling them down

- rather than being transparent, he's playing at being a showman - and people who are only passively observing the situation are getting sucked into it

Re:Grok3 Launch by Fnoord on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:31AM (#43091629)
My conclusion from reading The PayPal Wars was exactly that. That PayPal succeeded despite Musk.

As for all that government efficiency BS; it is just to swap to oligarchy. I mean, the name DOGE gives it away. DOGE was the first memecoin, entirely and openly being bullshit, yet it succeeded despite of that.

Meanwhile: not good emotional connection with father like the rest of these so-called strongmen (Trump, Putin, ...), and from a rich position of influence as child. Ie. he never was white trash, with his father having been part of pro-apartheid movement (a fight lost but which is meaningful for a young Elon). Furthermore, I am not convinced his drugs usage, in the end, serves him.

Re:Grok3 Launch by niceice on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:45AM (#43090832)
Sorry, but that is mental gymnastics. You've already made your conclusion and are torturing reality to make it fit.
Re:Grok3 Launch by silentsanctuary on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:55AM (#43090969)
Actually, I used to like Elon and was almost about to buy a Tesla, before the overwhelming burden of evidence required me to change my mind about him.

What motivates your point of view? I'm genuinely very curious.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Gothmog69 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:21AM (#43091417)
How is he the status quo elite? What leads you to believe he's not intelligent? Like those 2 things alone you need massive cognitive dissonance to believe.
Re:Grok3 Launch by hersko on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:19AM (#43091381)
Because "looting the USA" is a ridiculous accusation agains someone who is became wealthy from creating genuinely great products. He spent everything he had on SpaceX and Tesla and came incredibly close to losing it all. He is not some robber baron or oligarch who is wealthy by hoarding natural resources.
Re:Grok3 Launch by platybubsy on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:22PM (#43092408)
>the successes of SpaceX have had to come DESPITE Elon's management

Can you elaborate on this? AFAIK all other rocket companies without Elon have not been as successful. Also Eric Berger and multiple employees at SpaceX seem to disagree with your statement.

Re:Grok3 Launch by pton_xd on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:09PM (#43094406)
> the successes of Tesla and SpaceX have had to come DESPITE Elon's management

Huh? Name some better leaders who run more successful EV and space companies. There aren't any! Twitter is as popular as ever, and now xAI appears to be highly competitive.

But yeah sure, Elon is the common problem among all these successes.

He does make outlandish promises and lots of mean tweets though.

Re:Grok3 Launch by thrance on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:29PM (#43094652)
Twitter is losing users for the first time in its existence and lost 75% of its valuation since takeover.

Tesla is loing steam as other nations start linking Musk with the fascist threat looming over the US.

SpaceX, like all his successful ventures, are carried by exceptional talent. Attributing it to Musk is an insult to them.

Tell me, with him twitting an average of 60+ times a day, reaching max level in Path Of Exile, and now spending a fair share of his time dismantling the government, where does he find the time to put any work in his many companies? Answer: he doesn't.

Re:Grok3 Launch by spacechild1 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:46AM (#43090847)
I honestly don't know if you are being sarcastic or not. I really hope for the former.
Re:Grok3 Launch by thrance on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:05AM (#43091110)
The brains that run SpaceX are anonymous engineers working long hours and passionately applying their expertise to a project they believe in. Elon is a man-child tweeting an average of 50 times a day (number not made up), pretending to reach max level in a popular video game and then bragging about it, constantly flying between Mar-a-Lago and the White House in his private jets. He has no time to actually manage "his" companies, of which he puts no work in whatsoever.

You have to finally break free of this myth of the billionaire self-made man, building his fortune at the sweat of his brows. At some point, you're simply so rich that however stupid you are, competent people will still manage your capital well and make you even richer. You can only fail upward.

Do not mistake the current events for anything but an acceleration of the theft of your country by billionaire oligarchs (or rather the people managing their wealth).

Re:Grok3 Launch by kurikuri on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:29AM (#43090624)
Ah yes, replacing the ‘elites’ with a single person, much less scary. And, to be clear, the ‘elites’ are still in power (because, in America, power tends to follow money). The only thing that seems to be happening is the rapid destruction of any system Elon deems ‘bad.’

We aren’t better off at the whims of this robber baron, and I don’t understand how you can think that.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Gothmog69 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:23AM (#43091450)
How is he a robber baron? You don't need to buy any of his products.
Re:Grok3 Launch by llm_trw on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:44AM (#43090819)
To quote Marx on the current churn in the US government:

>The bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionising the instruments of production, and thereby the relations of production, and with them the whole relations of society. Conservation of the old modes of production in unaltered form, was, on the contrary, the first condition of existence for all earlier industrial classes. Constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones. All fixed, fast-frozen relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions, are swept away, all new-formed ones become antiquated before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned, and man is at last compelled to face with sober senses his real conditions of life, and his relations with his kind.

LLM training—and the massive (potential) copyright infringement that everyone is engaging in to train these models—is the latest contradiction in capitalism. For the first time in my lifetime, this contradiction isn’t harming the workers but is instead affecting a segment of the capitalist class.

Not since the abolition of slavery has one class of capitalists required the destruction of another to modernize the means of production.

We are in for an interesting decade.

Re:Grok3 Launch by martin-t on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:30AM (#43091615)
LLMs are used to launder code under GPL and AGPL and strip its users of their rights.

When I publish something under those copyleft licenses, my users have the right to see and modify the code. They even have that right if somebody else builds on top of my work. With LLMs, proprietary products based on my copyleft code are being written and used right now and my users have no rights at all, in fact, they don't even have a way to find out they are my users.

Imagine I ~~stole~~ got my hands on code from the top 5 tech companies and then made an autocompleter that looks at function signatures the programmer writes and autocompletes the function by picking a matching function from that corpus. I'd get sued and rightfully so.

What LLM companies are doing is exactly the same, just a bit more capable and it mixes the code just a bit more thoroughly to mask the origin.

Re:Grok3 Launch by stronglikedan on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:44AM (#43090818)
Elon is only doing good with this not-unchecked power. Everything is on the up and up, despite what your favorite propagandists want you to think. Go Elon!
Re:Grok3 Launch by LMYahooTFY on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:30PM (#43092515)
He does not have the power to dismiss Judges and Congressional representatives.

Judges can only be removed by Congress.

Congressional representatives can only be removed by their peers.

Re:Grok3 Launch by conductr on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:57PM (#43092916)
Or he starts using NSA data to train it, seems he has unchecked power to get into national systems and he made a point of saying this is more than the internet worth of knowledge...