News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:32AM (#43089906)
I'm not sure how LLMs/AI couldn't consolidate power. By design, it will move power from the individual to those running the AI systems.
Re:Grok3 Launch by llm_trw on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:37AM (#43090738)
Because the difference between a model that costs 10 million to train and a model that costs 10 billion to train is 6 months.

Deepseek R1 is something that you can run in a garage on hardware that the average software engineer can buy with a months salary and when it came out last month it was better than _every_ other model.

Re:Grok3 Launch by cedws on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:55AM (#43090968)
What about third world programmers? They can’t necessarily afford a $5000 GPU. If it weren’t for the “generosity” of tech companies like GitHub granting free LLM usage, they might be locked out entirely. This would put them at a disadvantage, we can argue to what degree but it’s still a disadvantage.

Depending on the curve we’re on, LLMs may grow more resource hungry while becoming closer to human performance in software engineering tasks. It’s not unimaginable this would concentrate productivity in the upper class of software engineers that can afford the hardware and/or licenses.

Re:Grok3 Launch by llm_trw on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:59AM (#43091029)
$5000 monthly salary?

My heart goes out to all the oppressed programmers in the EU.

Re:Grok3 Launch by ben_w on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @04:59PM (#43095658)
EU isn't "third world".

Kenya is, and at current exchange rates the range in this citation is $558-$1876/month: https://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/kenya-software-engineer-s...

Re:Grok3 Launch by llm_trw on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @05:27PM (#43095912)
With salaries like that it's not first world either.

If op is trying to catch up to frontier models locally on a budget 1/5th of what you can get in the west then I can see why she would feel the way she does about Ai.

Re:Grok3 Launch by ben_w on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:05PM (#43096282)
What are you even talking about?

You said a month's salary; cedws said "third world" devs can't afford $5000 — and this is correct, third world devs can't afford that. cedws did not say EU, they said third world, at least not here. You said EU, not them.

When you reply to me with "With salaries like that it's not first world either", who is "they"? The country I said explicitly was third world? Because that's a tautology.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Fnoord on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:14AM (#43091274)
Deepseek R1 performs well on a 600 EUR Jetson, and a 700 EUR AMD GPU. Both bought during COVID crisis. It is that quick. However, don't ask it about certain sensitive topics.

You can bet your ass Musk is using his AI tools as propaganda tool for his advancement, just like he does with X. We already seen prompt leak of Grok, it wasn't neutral.

Re:Grok3 Launch by mrtesthah on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:46PM (#43092750)
This is exactly correct. Grok is already slandering specific journalistic outlets such as “The Information” that publish negative stories on Musk.
Re:Grok3 Launch by mwigdahl on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:24AM (#43091471)
No, it was not. It was not better than o1, nor o1-pro. Yes, it was _cheaper_ than those models, and superior in price/performance if the performance was acceptable. But in terms of raw performance it was behind them.
Re:Grok3 Launch by johnfn on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:56AM (#43092020)
Chatbot arena leaderboard[1] says otherwise. 4o is ahead now, but that version of 4o was released after r1. r1 was ahead of all version of 4o and o1 at the time of release.

https://huggingface.co/spaces/lmarena-ai/chatbot-arena-leade...

Re:Grok3 Launch by mwigdahl on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:38PM (#43098637)
Chatbot arena leaderboard is a good test for vibes and style of response, but not much else. R1's performance in objective benchmarks (coding, etc.) showed very good performance, granted, but inferior to the full o1 and o1-pro models.

It's still a very impressive feat, but it wasn't frontier-pushing.

Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:47PM (#43092779)
Is it your expectation that as models get cheaper we won't be developing much more powerful models at the higher price range?

Its already worth noting that we already ran into the self hosting at scale problem. People don't want to run a web server and instead accept all the problems that come along with the convenience of social media. Why would LLMs, or any future AI product, be different?

Re:Grok3 Launch by tartoran on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:44AM (#43090039)
I'm not sure people will just take it though. In the short term it looks like the situation is on a horrible course but eventually people will have had enough. I'm hoping it would take less time for that to happen and the damage will not be too great. Let's remember that we could use the same technology if not a better one to fight against all this.
Re:Grok3 Launch by xenodium on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:00AM (#43090254)
> but eventually people will have had enough

As a Venezuelan, I thought so too. 25 years on...

Re:Grok3 Launch by bloopernova on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:03AM (#43091087)
A lot of US citizens are living incredibly comfortable lives. If that is threatened, for instance by food shortages caused by lack of people willing to work on farms for very low wages, then protests may happen.

But the reality distortion field around the current administration is very powerful. Fox and CNN are owned by supporters of the republicans, NYTimes and Washington Post don't appear to be reporting certain aspects of the government restructuring. Multiple social media sites are owned and ran by people who support the current admin.

I am personally worried that we're going to see the gradual yet continual escalation of rhetoric, more actions that undermine rule of law, and continued lack of critical thinking in so many people. That path appears to lead to extremism.

I have a horrible feeling that whoever "wins" in a couple of decades or so will have no time to savour their utopia as the climate catastrophe really starts to bite hard.

Re:Grok3 Launch by Gothmog69 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:18AM (#43091347)
So you are a leftist who believes the economy can't operate without basically third world slaves working in your fields?
Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:50PM (#43092811)
We enslaved the planet with industrialization and we are about to enslave AI, if we haven't already. Humans aren't on the losing end of that, but if your concern is with slavery itself that wouldn't matter.
Re:Grok3 Launch by _heimdall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:47AM (#43090081)
When a potential power imbalance is created, those willing to use it for selfish means will almost always win in the end.

Anyone with morals driving their use of a new tech will be limited, and unless those people massively outnumber the few selfish ones they will lose eventually.

Re:Grok3 Launch by tartoran on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:10AM (#43090376)
Losing a battle is painful but no win is final until things fall into a balance and even that doesn't last forever or it even reverse. The worst case scenario is not going to matter for anyone in the grand scheme of things because there will not be anyone around.
Re:Grok3 Launch by ryandrake on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:19AM (#43091368)
I'm not sure I understand how a hallucinating plagiarism machine that people mostly just use to write their term papers translates into "power" (presumably political power? I don't understand what kind of power we're talking about either).
Re:Grok3 Launch by psb217 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:38AM (#43091763)
The ability to inject your preferred biases into the system that people use for finding or generating nearly all information they consume on a day-to-day basis is extremely powerful. Eg, if all "term papers" produced by this plagiarism machine are now 20% more favourable to the machine's owner than they would otherwise be, that can have significant, compounding long-term effects.

Of course, similar things could be said about controlling information flow through: social networks, newspapers, printed books, or whatever the town crier shouts in town square. But, each advancement in information dissemination tends to be power concentrating relative to the older tech, and I don't see any reason why this most recent advance won't follow that trend.

Re:Grok3 Launch by smeeger on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:42AM (#43090008)
bingo. and everyone is fine with it as long as the consolidation is benefiting their own tribe.
Re:Grok3 Launch by throwaway657656 on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:25AM (#43090576)
Definitely not everyone. For many of us, checks and balances are a feature not a bug.
Re:Grok3 Launch by tartoran on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:46AM (#43090075)
A spark can start a fire, it doesn't seem wise to ignore history. Things can always get out of control even for the ones up there on top of the pyramid of power.