My main point is if you think you might want to be a "founding engineer", just be a founder instead. As a good example, consider Nathan Blecharczyk, one of the 3 cofounders of AirBnB, and was its original CTO and coded its first website. He's now worth about $10 billion and according to Wikipedia is the 203rd richest person on the planet. If he instead took a job as "founding engineer" at AirBnB, and let Brian Chesky and Joe Gebbia instead take on the sole founder titles, he'd be worth orders of magnitude less (granted an order of magnitude less than $10 billion is still hundreds of million, but point being there is no reason he should be compensated less than his other cofounders).
I knew someone who was the lone engineer at a start up who got a call from the founders, all on the golf course who wanted to talk about a new feature. At first he thought it was a joke because it seemed absurd, no they were serious. He quit the next day. He figured they were non serious founders. Company just rand itself out of money not too long after.
Maybe not many people making $220 take these offers?
There has to be a fair number of start ups that really don't "need" a $220k engineer if their business is "uber...but for cleaning your windows".
It would be interesting to see the breakdown of who does take these roles.
Granted "founding engineer" implys a lot so I'm not disagreeing with the premise or article, but sometimes on HN the idea that an engineer costs $200k+ is just assumed where often I think that isn't the case.
I have taken a role like this before, but when I did so, I was making a lateral move from a compensation standpoint. This is without factoring in any expected value of equity (because there was none).
I'm willing to also bet that most people do not do a lot of opportunity costs math.
But as your example points out, like mine, maybe this whole idea of top paid engineers not getting paid, or even taking those jobs isn't a thing as much as we might imagine.
"Uber ... but for walking your cat" might offer far less than 220k, but they also don't need that guy might be offering more lateral move type people / money.
I get that the typical $220k dev probably has a different mindset than the one you'd look to when building a new company. That said, I've focused most of my career on being the 2-5th employee and helping guide startups to viability. I've been able to do that while still pulling in reasonable $$ and hours to make my lifestyle work.
Maybe this alternate model is gone now with the credit crunch, but it does seem like we're missing out on a workable yet oddly unpopular approach here.
So I've thought about saving up enough to comfortably retire, and then going to work in a more risky company for the chance to get a life changing amount of equity (something more than single digit millions). I don't know that I will though, because the odds are seriously bad.
You have to ask yourself this- how much is enough, and how hard are you willing to work/risk for it? On the low end, how much is the minimum, and what pros would make that acceptable, quality of life, risk, anxiety levels, etc.
Your way forward will be much clearer when you know what your parameters are, even though life may happen between now and the end date of your plans.
On the flip side, it's funny to think about what life would look like if I spent all my disposable income, but it's not really an experiment I want to run haha.
I think the most likely scenario is that I take some time off and decide to continue working similarly to now, but I think it'll be nice to have some confidence that I can have more freedom to choose what I want to do if I show myself that I could afford to retire. I largely like my job. I wish there was less stress and external pressure, but it seems difficult to keep the parts of my job that I like without those.
Also you are very likely to be laid off or pushed out before you get to the goals you think are so obvious.
Can you elaborate more on this? What would be a more optimal approach?
When you set your goals as a single young techie you are in for a surprise when real life hits
Back in 2008 when Yahoo was laying off people, joining Facebook was something people did out of desperation.
That was an 85k/year job with an expectation of "all work, no life".
It was not seen as a good option, but most of the time the only place that was hiring during the Great Recession.
A decade later, it was a completely different thing. Yahoo was dead, Google+ (Orkut) had failed & FB had Instagram & Whatsapp.
I took up an offer to work for 1/10th of my previous salary and half the working hours. Life is not all about money.
My risk is even higher than yours, coz at 1%, I'll have no say in anything important. And I'm breaking even only once we reach 10M valuation.
The problem is that there's no easy way to cash out with just a valuation and you need the $100k now to pay for whatever, not when the board says there can be a liquidity event (which may never even happen).
Having a tech career at all is an incredible luxury compared to pretty much any other way of making a living. It is easy to have a comfortable life without bothering to chase the high end of the market. One cannot ignore compensation, but neither need it be the focus of one's career decisions.
What is a "replacement level college-educated career"? That's not a phrase I have heard before.
Not really. They don't want you to give up anything or some do and you can just say no. The reality is that people want to find other people who want to work in startups to be their engineers. You really can't get top performance out of a guy who hates doing some work by paying him. You'd much rather get the guy who loves doing some work and pay him enough that he feels appreciated. Mercenary hires are useful in prop trading firms, but anywhere else the mercenary is better contracted than hired.
Besides, startup salaries are not $100k/year and you can get 2% as a founding engineer.
Taking more money to do a job you hate is a recipe for burnout.
There's nothing inherently wrong or illogical about making less than the maximum amount of money you can make.
I'll happily take substantially lower salaries for publicly funded healthcare and undergrad education.
This doesn’t even factor in general higher tax brackets abroad
The premiums don't cover everything and if you (heaven forbid) get a curable form of cancer you're gonna be paying quite a bit out of pocket past the quoted $43k, and it's not just about the money, but dealing with the whole system as well. Getting claims denied and having to contest it, having a mystery bill hanging over your head. If you break an ankle, it might just be less hassle to buy the things you need off Amazon than deal with insurance.
Meanwhile you can complain about eg long wait times in, say, Sweden, but the total deductible per year there is approximately $100 and then you don't pay more than that. Getting a curable cancer just doesn't have the same implication there.
There's also other intangibles. Things like time off, infrastructure, social safety net, dating pool, culture, human rights, cost of living. inequality (good or bad). What's it worth in dollars to you for your daughter to be able to afford to buy a house someday when it also turns out she wants to be a painter when she grows up?
I'm not making any argument for or against a particular county. What I'm saying is, live where you want to live. Money isn't everything so make sure to read past the numbers on a spreadsheet.
basically when I’m on the market at all the smaller companies move faster so I just take them
older mid size companies are the ones that compromise on base salary and take too long
I just don’t and won’t do the studying adequate for FAANG
When I joined, I was shocked how high the turnover was. And not anecdotally! there were stats you could slice and dice every which way, and...it was shocking.
How!? This was paradise.
After clearing enough years, and getting enough advice from people at 50+ who stayed at BigCo, once you got a pile o' money, it looks more like:
$170K/yr + $30K bonus + $100K/yr RSUs at Google - $150K/yr existential dread.
vs. startup:
$150K/yr + $15K bonus + $2.5K/yr (1% chance of $250K/year)
Increasing the money pile becomes not worth it once you've stacked Google RSUs, and the choking existential dread of what goes on inside BigCo is worth the pay difference.
I know that sounds nuts. Hell, when I was doing my big "Where do I go now that I've sold my startup?" interview rounds, I also interviewed for positions with a couple ex-Googlers who told me it'd be awful to join there.
I thought a lot about it and decided they were wrong, they didn't understand how little savings I had.
And they were wrong: it was totally worth building the money pile so I could move on like they did, to more productive areas where there's room to grow.
aside: I'm not sure anyone would get $220K/year base then only get $100K/year base. I usually see roughly the same base, frankly, its usually a bit higher than Google's.
another aside: stereotypes are stereotypes, from what you characterize startups vs. BigCo as, I think you'd be very surprised how many Googlers feel about workload
First thing I should say is none of what I'm going to say matters if you are the world's most well-adjusted person. i.e. you have 0 inherent desire to do anything other than A) get a paycheck B) do what boss says.
The ex-Googlers I interviewed with put is as "you can't get anything done", which I took as a challenge. And succeeded. Then failed. But not because that's not what leadership wanted, it was the opposite, they had been asking for years: because I was low enough on the totem pole, and in engineering, in a way people could screw around and have 0 consequences.
Hyperbole: every single job I've worked at was better managed than what Google had become at the end, including food service ones. There's a professionalism-as-don't-speak-up authoritarianism in play.
Another handwave I've used to describe it is "humans are humans, everywhere.",
This was the first time I was with a group of really, really smart people. Ivy Leaguers, etc. I dropped out from the #116 ranked university.
I expected that meant the level of shitty behavior would be lower, but, it was higher. Much higher. There's much more training data accumulated in smart people. Making it easier to construct internal narratives for why somethings a bad idea, but, this was usually lazy and slotting into some stereotype. One lesson I learned quickly is there's a parable for every possible decision.
Another problem was you had a ton of people who were just Ivy Leaguers who said "ehhh I guess finance is more evil?", ended up in tech, and really could not fundamentally understand at all why you'd do anything, or talk about anything, or think about anything, other than what someone in authority explicitly said to do and documented and had 0 ambiguity at all. This actually played well with the authoritarianism I mentioned, despite "thriving in ambiguity" being a catchphrase used in perf a lot.
Last thing I'll mention: there were two major decision points that ended up causes an exponential increase in issues:
#1 in...2018?...moving promotion review into the local team, instead of a panel of reviewers from throughout Google. Won't belabor the point too much, TL;DR: that's an excellent way to enable authoritarianism and adjacent issues, because no one can be good enough to just do an end-around.
#2 in late 2022, moving performance reviews from a variety of feedback from collaborators to your manager and whoever your manager bothered picking.
Anyone, if you've made it this far and are very curious, feel free to reach out to jp0hhhh@gmail for deeper conversation (replace the 0 with an o). I'm offering just to pay it forward, i.e. give what I didn't have before Google, someone with a direct sense of tradeoffs.
At the startup, there's not even the $150k to subtract out.
I'll try to reply with more specifics to the sibling
It's a different dread working for a startup, but really believing that you're helping its mission to save the world, or at least, not making it worse is it's own form of payment.
Some people work at a Fang only do after convincing themselves that to do so would be wrong, but the pay is just so good, and so they hate themselves for working there. They haven't drunk the Kool aid and have bought into a narrative that the company they're working for is eeeeevil. Other people just buy that BMW and provide a better life for their kids than they had, and the thought doesn't even register.
In effect, I'd be "investing" $180k/yr and putting in crazy hours for a 1% equity that gets diluted to nearly nothing in a few funding rounds. How does that make sense?
You can only invest your time and salary cut into a single company, while angel and VC investor can invest their time and money into many companies. They only need 1 of those investments to skyrocket. You need 100% of your investments (size 1) to skyrocket for it to make sense.
Sure, if you hit the jackpot and join Facebook, then you're set for life. But that's an extreme outlier, otherwise I wouldn't be using it as an example.