News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by legitster on Thursday December 19, 2024 @06:49PM (#42466978)
This article is fascinating. But what's on display here is less of a nefarious plan from Spotify to replace famous Katy Perry with AI - instead we get to see something much more specific: a behind-the-scenes of how those endless chill/lo-fi/ambient playlists get created.

Which is something I've always wondered! How does the Lofi Girl channel on Youtube always have so much new music from artists I have never heard from?

The answer is surprising: real people and real instruments! (At least at the time of writing). Third-party stock music ("muzak") companies hiring underemployed jazz musicians to crank out a few dozen derivative songs every day to hack the algorithm.

> “Honestly, for most of this stuff, I just write out charts while lying on my back on the couch,” he explained. “And then once we have a critical mass, they organize a session and we play them. And it’s usually just like, one take, one take, one take, one take. You knock out like fifteen in an hour or two.” With the jazz musician’s particular group, the session typically includes a pianist, a bassist, and a drummer. An engineer from the studio will be there, and usually someone from the PFC partner company will come along, too—acting as a producer, giving light feedback, at times inching the musicians in a more playlist-friendly direction.”

I think there's an easy and obvious thing we can do - stop listening to playlists! Seek out named jazz artists. Listen to your local jazz station. Go to jazz shows.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Gigachad on Thursday December 19, 2024 @08:09PM (#42467373)
I’m not even mad about it. It’s background music and clearly people are enjoying it. Just because they smashed out 15 tracks in a single session doesn’t make it unfit for purpose. That’s just how Jazz music is.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by wbl on Thursday December 19, 2024 @10:54PM (#42468134)
Kenny G might deserve your comment. But Charlie Parker, John Coltrane, Ornette Coleman, Charles Mingus...
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by orblivion on Thursday December 19, 2024 @11:31PM (#42468301)
I think some people may have a misunderstanding about what jazz is. I know one friend of mine did. Some jazz may be easy listening, but it's not made for easy listening, it's made to bend the boundaries of music theory. And also a lot of "easy listening" that sounds like jazz isn't really jazz.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by vasco on Friday December 20, 2024 @02:43AM (#42469078)
So what is jazz
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:14AM (#42469438)
The devils music.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by gvurrdon on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:31AM (#42469290)
The term covers a variety of styles, with old ones hanging around as new ground is broken. Perhaps it is a "meta-genre". There are various articles around explaining its history which might be worth looking at, if you're interested. I'd expect to hear some degree of improvisation in jazz, but not in easy listening.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by YagoTheFrood on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:34AM (#42469887)
"If you have to ask what jazz is, you'll never know." Apocryphal quote by Louis Armstrong.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by vasco on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:02AM (#42470064)
Ah, gatekeeping and elitist? Got it.

PS: Spent more hours than I should trying to learn jazz drums

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by technothrasher on Friday December 20, 2024 @08:34AM (#42470931)
The original quote is apocryphal, but he did respond to a question from a reporter asking about the quote saying, "Yeah, Daddy. Ya know how it is... jazz is something ya feel... ya live it, that's all." So he wasn't gatekeeping, he was saying the answer to "what is jazz?" was contained in the experience of jazz.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by kid64 on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:57AM (#42470038)
jazz != smooth jazz
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by browningstreet on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:53AM (#42471552)
JavaScript != Java

These are everywhere…

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by DonHopkins on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:44PM (#42474832)
New Age rhymes with Sewage
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by netdevphoenix on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:16AM (#42470153)
It is an approach to music (more than a genre) that relies on elaborate harmonic structures, freedom of interpretation of melody and personalising the harmony, interesting rhythms and time signatures and a general approach of trying to push the boundaries of music making. It is meant to be listened actively as opposed to having it as background music. The capitalisation of music has led us to the commoditisation of music and treating it as audio content as opposed to art.
[dead]
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by klez on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:21AM (#42471271)
That would be the distinction between "fine art" and "decorative art". Jazz as GP meant it is "fine art", the smooth jazz you hear in the elevator could be classified as decorative art.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by dijksterhuis on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:44AM (#42471469)
in my personal opinion, which is as valuable as the piece of paper i’m writing this on /s

art has no function except to be observed by an audience. if they enjoy it or not is immaterial. its purpose is to be observed.

the design of a box of cereal has a purpose - to sell you the box of cereal by making it attractive/stand out/fit the brand.

graphic design, when it has purposes beyond being observed, is not art — it’s a craft.

like engineering.

although graphic design/engineering can become art when it has no purpose except being observed.

edit — enjoyment is immaterial and the bits about graphic design can be art etc.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by bezkom on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:44AM (#42472065)
Most of the masterpieces you see in museums were used as decoration at some point.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by wbl on Friday December 20, 2024 @12:07PM (#42472783)
The Pope needed something for his ceiling.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by troupo on Friday December 20, 2024 @12:24PM (#42472954)
Most masterpieces where literally hanging in the background of some rich person's summer houses, and hunting lodges, and other properties. Thrown out and replaced on a whim.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by mr_toad on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:55PM (#42477184)
Or melted down to make spears and helmets.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Neonlicht on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:38AM (#42479085)
Art was used by the rich and famous to show off their wealth. In the 19th century countries got into the game (the idea that Dutch masters were ending up in American collections was a national embarrassment).
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by xanderlewis on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:46AM (#42472083)
I feel like there’s some kind of analogy between jazz cats and hackers.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by jdietrich on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:42AM (#42470302)
In short, a cultural tradition. At length:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=68zOvCLwcL8

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by shrikant on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:47AM (#42470315)
I found it easier to "get" when I started thinking of jazz as the beat poetry of music.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by mesofile on Friday December 20, 2024 @07:47AM (#42470652)
the ‘sound of surprise’
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by datadrivenangel on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:23AM (#42471290)
jazz is what you can get away with.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by kunalgupta on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:50AM (#42472113)
delightful mental pain, like a cold plunge
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Asooka on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:23PM (#42474652)
Normal people care about music theory as much as they care whether you use jemalloc vs tcmalloc. "Easy listening" is a much more useful everyday definition for them than whatever musicians may want it to be.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by briandear on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:06PM (#42475023)
Kind of Blue is far from “easy listening.”
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by maroonblazer on Friday December 20, 2024 @08:49PM (#42476877)
Compared to Anthony Braxton, "Kind of Blue" is elevator music.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by wbl on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:41PM (#42475336)
There's nothing easy about Cecil Taylor.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by orblivion on Sunday December 22, 2024 @12:55AM (#42484646)
Normal people who don't care about music at all, sure they can call it "easy listening" and I won't bother arguing. For anyone who cares about music or even history at least a little, it's worth knowing that jazz is very important to the history of music.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by beacon294 on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @12:11AM (#42506995)
It's possible to care only in some modes of your being.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by fuhsnn on Thursday December 19, 2024 @11:31PM (#42468302)
All jazz artists started as insignificant band members before they found their voice.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by petre on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:20AM (#42478479)
If I'd want to crash a party I'd totally play Ornette Coleman.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by couchand on Saturday December 21, 2024 @10:05AM (#42480086)
Interesting that your first counterexample is Charlie Parker. I've been listening to a lot of Phil Schaap's Bird Flight recently (https://www.philschaapjazz.com/sections/bird-flight). It's funny to see how many of the episodes are Phil describing a recording session more or less like this:

"The Bird showed up two hours late to a three and a half hour recording session. They recorded one take each of six tracks, but the recording engineer was surprised when they started so he missed the first half of the first track. And that's how we got the five tracks on <INSERT CRITICALLY-ACCLAIMED ALBUM HERE>."

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by dleink on Saturday December 21, 2024 @11:56AM (#42480705)
goes to show, lines of code doesn't equal quality.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by bee_rider on Friday December 20, 2024 @01:32AM (#42468791)
Yeah, this rules, why are we supposed to be angry? It is like WFH for music makers.

Although, I’m pretty sure there’s a ton of really complex and difficult jazz out there (IIRC it is one of the most advanced genres, whatever they means; I don’t do music). But that isn’t what we’re looking for on the chill whatever ambient music channels.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by oreilles on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:35AM (#42469894)
Did you guys not read the article ? The problem arises because of the way the music is distributed on Spotify and the way it is licensed. Spotify make deals with the companies producing this stock music so that it can fill its popular playlists with while paying close to zero royalties. The consequence is a decline both in music quality on the platform and in artists rights, revenue, and ability to be listened to overall.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by afro88 on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:12AM (#42470129)
Spotify isn't a monopoly, and if they want to fill their platform with stock music and presumably AI slop in the future, good luck to them. They're hollowing themselves out and making way for a new better service.

And in the end, the real money for musicians is syncs, shows and merch anyway. Spotify streaming revenue is tiny in comparison.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by oreilles on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:26AM (#42470212)
The discussion is not wether Spotify will benefit from this situation in the long run or not, it's wether the users of the platform (both the listeners and the artists) should be happy with it and the answer to that is, thanks this lengthy article, demonstrably no.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by gizmondo on Friday December 20, 2024 @02:52PM (#42474350)
I don't think the article showed that listeners are unhappy.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Wolfenstein98k on Saturday December 21, 2024 @07:34AM (#42479306)
Whether*

A wether is a castrated ram.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by edu on Friday December 20, 2024 @07:23AM (#42470512)
Yes, that’s’ why a switched to Apple Music
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by georgebcrawford on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:43PM (#42475360)
You don't think every platform will be doing the same within a year or two?
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by afro88 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @03:35AM (#42478266)
Same
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by wbl on Monday December 23, 2024 @05:02PM (#42497960)
Glenn Gould didn't tour past 31 and made money from recordings.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by danudey on Friday December 20, 2024 @12:14PM (#42472848)
100% guarantee that, once the technology is solid enough and the library is big enough, Spotify is going to train an AI off the tracks they own the rights to so they can mass-produce this music without paying anyone (except nvidia) a dime.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by bee_rider on Friday December 20, 2024 @01:41PM (#42473612)
Hopefully someone will release a music ML model to just generate it locally.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by RandallBrown on Friday December 20, 2024 @12:52PM (#42473189)
Those playlists become popular because of the music on them. If they decline in quality won't people will just listen to better playlists?

My Discover Weekly from Spotify used to be awesome. I found a bunch of new artists that I really liked and tons of great new songs. Recently it's been a bunch of old stuff that I've definitely heard of before. So I've mostly stopped listening to it.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Wolfenstein98k on Saturday December 21, 2024 @07:33AM (#42479302)
Big agree.

Discover Weekly went from something I was excited about every Monday morning on the train, to something I forget to check most weeks.

There's a handful of songs it puts on every few weeks, for literally years now, despite me skipping them every time and never once listening to the band or song by choice.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Cthulhu_ on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:31AM (#42470245)
I mean yeah, the music isn't the problem; a lot of music especially "back when" (in my idealised head, this may not be true) was just some guy or a small band noodling in the corner, instead of a well known artist giving a performance of their greatest hits.

"jazz improv" is probably just that, start with a generic beat / atmosphere and improvise and noodle on top of that. Sounds great to me, I wish there was more low barrier to entry live music like that. But I suppose there's no market for e.g. an in-house band working shifts for background entertainment, and they can't compete with jukebox software.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by ksymph on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:54AM (#42471558)
The issue is that the artists who make it are getting paid very little, with no attribution, on songs that get massive amounts of plays and exposure. The entire purpose of the program is for Spotify to pay artists less and cut out real independent musicians. The decline in quality is an (arguably) unfortunate side effect, but not really the main reason for people to be angry.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by lmz on Friday December 20, 2024 @07:01PM (#42476365)
It's not like they put in a lot of work into it either (as per the article).
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by bezkom on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:41AM (#42472041)
Miles Davis famously recorded 4 legendary albums in just 2 sessions, jazz you know...
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by insane_dreamer on Friday December 20, 2024 @01:14PM (#42473359)
You don't understand how Spotify distributes revenue to artists.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by alsetmusic on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:45AM (#42472073)
The point is that artists who have <1000 streams get zero pay. This is designed to help prevent payouts and increase profits. 'Deny,' 'defend', and 'depose'.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by jzb on Friday December 20, 2024 @11:07AM (#42472264)
It's designed to increase profits, for sure. I do not have a lot of love for Spotify, currently, but this particular practice does not bother me much.

Look: If you give a damn about what you're listening to, you can go over to Spotify and create your own playlists filled with music you care about (assuming they have the artists you like in their catalog). In that case, the artists will get paid accordingly.

But Spotify has realized that a lot of people use it for background noise and don't give two shits whether what they're listening to is a "real" band or music-like content squeezed out of sweatshop sessions in Sweden or whatever. I can't fault them overmuch for taking advantage of the actual listening preferences of its users. If you feel cheated by this, spend some time curating playlists on your own.

Tacking on the CEO-shooter's mantra to your message is shameful. This isn't healthcare. This isn't killing anyone. It's a fully optional service that happens to be popular. Trying to link it to anger over being denied healthcare is ridiculous.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by georgebcrawford on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:52PM (#42475425)
I 50/50 agree with you. My issue is the bait and switch feel it has to it, for both artist and audience. Spotify holds all the power. They already pay less for Discover Weekly streams, instead using that old music industry classic "exposure". If they really care about artists (like their marketing claims), perhaps they can add a filter for playlists that contain PFC vs not?

I'm just rambling without much explanation sorry, but I'm gonna hit the reply button anyway!

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by volkl48 on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:03PM (#42475515)
Yes and no.

They do not pay out per stream. They pay out a set % of their total revenue to rights holders. Spotify has to pay the exact same amount of money before and after that change.

The savings for Spotify is in not having the (not so insignificant) administrative overhead of trying to make hundreds of thousands of basically worthless payouts to different individuals that are worth <$5 or even <$1.

I think it's fairly reasonable to draw some sort of lower bound on the minimum you need to reach to get a payout, especially in a world where basically anyone can put music on their service.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by tuna74 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @11:16AM (#42480463)
Spotify seems to have special deals with these music producers that probably gives them less money per stream.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by flipthefrog on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:05PM (#42477234)
Kind of Blue was smashed out in two sessions. A Love Supreme in one
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by CocaKoala on Thursday December 19, 2024 @07:12PM (#42467115)
Ah, see, my experience is exactly the opposite of yours; I don't listen to the ChilledCow streams, but I do listen to the Chillhop playlists (and in fact purchase the seasonal essentials collections on vinyl) and one of the reasons I like them is because there's a lot of curation that goes into the playlist and they tend to feature artists that I end up liking - Blue Wednesday, Purple Cat, Joey Pecararo are all reliable artists in the genre for me.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by nicky0 on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:19AM (#42469225)
I like how you called it ChilledCow to show how OG you are.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by chrisweekly on Friday December 20, 2024 @12:29AM (#42468523)
Interesting take.

For my part, I'm grateful for Spotify's "exclude from taste profile" feature. This lets me leverage my personally-curated "Flowstate" playlist ^1 for hours at a time while I'm working -- tracks that I've hand-picked to facilitate a "getting things done" mindset / energized mood / creativity or go-time vibe, and can stand to listen to on repeat -- without "polluting" my regular music preferences. It's apples and oranges, mostly - there's music I want to listen and attend to (as a guitar player and lifelong avid music listener across many genres including "serious" jazz), and there's audio (which could as easily be programmatically generated / binaural beats, whatever -- eg brain.fm) that I use as a tool specifically to help shape my cognitive state for focus / productivity.

I think it's kind of funny how some people get confused about the fact that there are many reasons to listen to many kinds of music.

When it comes to music discovery on Spotify, the "go to radio" option from a given track or album is a reliable way to surface new-to-me things. I usually prefer this proactive seeking to the playlists spotify's algo generates for me. (shrug)

1. https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6UScdOAlqXqWTOmXFgQhFA?si=...

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by dmonitor on Friday December 20, 2024 @02:04PM (#42473840)
> For my part, I'm grateful for Spotify's "exclude from taste profile" feature

This is my first time being made aware of this. Fantastic option that more websites should adopt

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by klabetron on Saturday December 21, 2024 @03:37AM (#42478272)
Anyone know if YouTube has it? The number of times I switch the YouTube app to Incognito just to avoid whatever links my friends send from influencing my recommendations…
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by m5l on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:48PM (#42482966)
Removing videos from my watch history seems to work for this. The note on this page[1] seems to indicate that watch history is what's driving your recommendations (they disappear if you don't have enough history):

[1] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/95725

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by feoren on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:33PM (#42475271)
> I think it's kind of funny how some people get confused about the fact that there are many reasons to listen to many kinds of music.

It has always boggled my mind that this point seems to be lost on every music streaming service.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by aoanevdus on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:06AM (#42477667)
Spotify has been automatically generating 6 different “daily mix” podcasts for me, which cover different styles/moods.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by sitkack on Friday December 20, 2024 @12:30AM (#42468534)
> is less of a nefarious plan from Spotify to replace famous Katy Perry with AI

Has that been shown?

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by mort96 on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:28AM (#42469498)
It hasn't been shown that Spotify has no nefarious plan to replace Katy Perry with AI, but what's on display here, what this article is highlighting, is no such thing.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Balgair on Friday December 20, 2024 @01:36AM (#42468806)
Check out Chillhop ( https://chillhop.com/radio/). Great little lofi studio out of Rotterdam. Good to the artists, from what I can tell.

Psalm Trees, an artist with them, just put out an interesting little 'double'-ish album here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmL9LvTYjMQ

He produced a whole jazz album just so he could sample from it for a lofi album. Absolutely mental workload.

There's a lot of crap in lofi, but also some real 'bangers' too : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IU3yBo2szD8 (yes, really, 10 hours of great work, IMHO)

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by xrd on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:29PM (#42476187)
I want to know how you found this. Why do you say they are good to the artists? I would love to know how you cultivate your feed and from where you get your music information?
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by fakedang on Saturday December 21, 2024 @01:14AM (#42477846)
Psalm Trees is my jam! The song "Fever" got me into lofi music.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by eleveriven on Friday December 20, 2024 @02:29AM (#42469019)
It’s ironic, though, that what we love about playlists like Lofi Girl (endless streams of music that feel fresh yet familiar) is exactly what’s being exploited
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by fuhsnn on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:27AM (#42469491)
>feel fresh yet familiar

This probably applies to most mainstream entertainment.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by Cthulhu_ on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:33AM (#42470255)
In this particular context, it's for passive entertainment; things like blockbuster movies are intended for actively watching.

But that said, people massively underestimate the background entertainment market. Spotify Reddit is that for me a lot of the time, as is youtube. Netflix and co less so, if I'm watching something I want to enjoy it, not have it as background / comofort stuff.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by eleveriven on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:46AM (#42500345)
What’s interesting (and ironic) here is how that formula is being industrialized to an extreme in the case of platforms like Spotify
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by rich_sasha on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:57AM (#42470366)
I agree 100%.

I think the question is, what when inevitably someone uses that human music to train an AI generating the same ambient music? Especially when you acquired the music on the cheap using a monopoly position.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by lotsofpulp on Friday December 20, 2024 @07:04AM (#42470400)
I assumed that has already been happening. I see tons of all capital letter 5 or 6 letter “artists” in Apple Music infinite playlist.

There are also websites and apps like Suno that make whatever you want on the fly.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by yellow_lead on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:03AM (#42471641)
> Which is something I've always wondered! How does the Lofi Girl channel on Youtube always have so much new music from artists I have never heard from?

> The answer is surprising: real people and real instruments! (At least at the time of writing).

Sorry to break it to you, but there's actually tones of AI lofi music from Suno all over YouTube right now.

See this video for an explanation: https://youtu.be/_oxtFP2UUyM

And here are some examples of the content:

https://youtu.be/RJUvNVCqtpI https://youtu.be/iBt051Pq7_4

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by liminalsunset on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:47PM (#42475384)
The YouTube link that starts with RJUvNV, titled "(a). sip" IMO, the first track is a banger (I really like it), and it doesn't sound obviously AI.

The second track is more obviously AI, mostly due to the high frequency "dullness". Likewise, the second link iBT051 seems to have the same issue, it's low fidelity (but in a different way than the lo-fi style is).

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by insane_dreamer on Friday December 20, 2024 @01:13PM (#42473351)
> less of a nefarious plan from Spotify to replace famous Katy Perry with AI

actually, it's the same nefarious plan, just that AI wasn't yet up to the task. Now it is, and replacing those fake artists, who are still human beings as far as we know, with AI (and the same fake resumes) is the logical next step.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by motorest on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:35AM (#42479079)
> Now it is, and replacing those fake artists (...)

They aren't even artists. They release content bought from third-parties, and at most their role is limited to market it. These "artists" are at best brands that are carefully managed and curated.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by yojo on Saturday December 21, 2024 @10:16AM (#42480131)
To your point, the article even mentions that since the Muzak labels own the master on all these tracks, they are free to use them however they see fit. Which in this case probably means training their AI entirely on their own cleanly licensed music.

They are probably already doing it, slipping in a few AI-generated songs in with the gig-produced music to see how it’s performing.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by legohead on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:22PM (#42474647)
There is an incredible amount of unique music & artists on Soundcloud. Or at least there was some years ago. I got quite into it, to where it was taking up too much of my time and I stopped using it altogether. They kept making it more difficult to download music too so that was another thing that drove me away.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by onemoresoop on Saturday December 21, 2024 @07:38AM (#42479322)
I tried soundcloud recently and it’s filled with ads to the point of being an extremely disruptive experience.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by lubujackson on Saturday December 21, 2024 @01:29AM (#42477886)
Alternative take - this might not actually be the worst thing for musicians, to have a low effort, steady paying gig creating music. I am reminded of the documentary "Standing in the Shadows of Motown" about the "Funk Brothers", which was an amorphous group of jazz musicians who did all of the backing tracks for most of the 100s of Motown hits.

Obviously, making ambient tracks is not quite the same as writing "Please Mr. Postman" and hearing your songs on the radio, but in the documentary the band talked about how they'd pump out songs during the day then go to a jazz club at night to make the music they REALLY wanted to make.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by motorest on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:21AM (#42478995)
> Alternative take - this might not actually be the worst thing for musicians, to have a low effort, steady paying gig creating music.

I think this is a red herring to try to convince people that it's in their best interests to be force-fed content produced by major labels behind the brand {INSERT_ARTIST_NAME}.

Which incidentally it's the business model from major labels.

I mean, check any major labels artist. Each and every single hit song they release has countless writers and producers claiming a stake, not to mention the fact that some major labels artists don't even try to hide the fact they buy all their content from third-parties to slap their name over it.

Is this the state of affairs that's being defended?

Give me a procedurally-generated playlist that I can listen all day long, and skip the content I'm not interested in.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by tuna74 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @11:13AM (#42480447)
"I mean, check any major labels artist. Each and every single hit song they release has countless writers and producers claiming a stake, not to mention the fact that some major labels artists don't even try to hide the fact they buy all their content from third-parties to slap their name over it."

Do you think this is a bad thing?

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by jfengel on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:28PM (#42480931)
It's too bad that stardom still generally requires being promoted by one of a handful of corporations. It's not impossible to get there without them, but the result is that we still end up concentrating most of the wealth on a tiny number of artists, while a vast number of equal talents go under-used and under-compensated.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by motorest on Sunday December 22, 2024 @05:19AM (#42485494)
> Do you think this is a bad thing?

Yes obviously, if you're trying to complain about "ghost artists" by presenting these "artists" as the counterpoint when they are even faker.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by magic_hamster on Saturday December 21, 2024 @02:48AM (#42478120)
Only on your last sentence did I realize you were describing something you thought was actually bad. In my opinion it's a pretty good system where everybody wins: the audience gets real, fresh music, the players get paid for some practice sessions with low pressure (sounds like fun), and the producers make some money. This is a pretty good expression of music as a service in my opinion.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by chrz on Sunday December 22, 2024 @03:51AM (#42485173)
Oh look spotify is here. From article it wasnt "sounds like fun" but "horrible expierience"
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by kiba on Saturday December 21, 2024 @08:14AM (#42479458)
I think there's an easy and obvious thing we can do - stop listening to playlists! Seek out named jazz artists. Listen to your local jazz station. Go to jazz shows.

Not a musician myself, but I am a live performer. I think live performance will come back into stride for things people do.

Then again, people do livestreaming all the time, but it's a different sort of entertainment compared to people putting up a live show for you for a lack of better term.

I am hoping to do it next year.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by jfengel on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:25PM (#42480914)
I'm in theater, which is challenging because we do things comparable to TV and movies, but with significant physical constraints. And costs constraints, unless you're doing a Broadway musical for which ticket prices are well over $100.

Yet people still come to my shows. I have to charge more than I want to, simply as a matter of real estate. People do still want what we can bring them live. I could not conceivably make a living at it, but there is still value in doing the work and bringing it to people.

Maybe AI will demotivate people from screens. I haven't seen a flood yet, to be sure, but we'll see.

Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by bondarchuk on Saturday December 21, 2024 @11:35AM (#42480564)
I'm just pleasantly surprised that this stuff is played by humans at all. Maybe in 20 years we'll see some "best of mid-2020's streaming muzak" compilations pressed on expensive vinyl, like we got with the library music of yore not that long ago.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine by wsintra2022 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:10PM (#42480811)
If your looking for an early community that wants to press vinyl and create an online community, check out kushtybuckrecords, it’s a project me and my son are building, we have friends that own a vinyl press factory (Press On) and we are trying to build an online community that will help Artist create vinyl records