Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by vasco on Friday December 20, 2024 @02:43AM
(#42469078)
So what is jazz
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:14AM
(#42469438)
The devils music.
The term covers a variety of styles, with old ones hanging around as new ground is broken. Perhaps it is a "meta-genre". There are various articles around explaining its history which might be worth looking at, if you're interested.
I'd expect to hear some degree of improvisation in jazz, but not in easy listening.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by YagoTheFrood on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:34AM
(#42469887)
"If you have to ask what jazz is, you'll never know."
Apocryphal quote by Louis Armstrong.
Ah, gatekeeping and elitist? Got it.
PS: Spent more hours than I should trying to learn jazz drums
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by technothrasher on Friday December 20, 2024 @08:34AM
(#42470931)
The original quote is apocryphal, but he did respond to a question from a reporter asking about the quote saying, "Yeah, Daddy. Ya know how it is... jazz is something ya feel... ya live it, that's all." So he wasn't gatekeeping, he was saying the answer to "what is jazz?" was contained in the experience of jazz.
jazz != smooth jazz
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by browningstreet on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:53AM
(#42471552)
JavaScript != Java
These are everywhere…
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by DonHopkins on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:44PM
(#42474832)
New Age rhymes with Sewage
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by netdevphoenix on Friday December 20, 2024 @06:16AM
(#42470153)
It is an approach to music (more than a genre) that relies on elaborate harmonic structures, freedom of interpretation of melody and personalising the harmony, interesting rhythms and time signatures and a general approach of trying to push the boundaries of music making. It is meant to be listened actively as opposed to having it as background music. The capitalisation of music has led us to the commoditisation of music and treating it as audio content as opposed to art.
[dead]
That would be the distinction between "fine art" and "decorative art". Jazz as GP meant it is "fine art", the smooth jazz you hear in the elevator could be classified as decorative art.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by dijksterhuis on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:44AM
(#42471469)
in my personal opinion, which is as valuable as the piece of paper i’m writing this on /s
art has no function except to be observed by an audience. if they enjoy it or not is immaterial. its purpose is to be observed.
the design of a box of cereal has a purpose - to sell you the box of cereal by making it attractive/stand out/fit the brand.
graphic design, when it has purposes beyond being observed, is not art — it’s a craft.
like engineering.
although graphic design/engineering can become art when it has no purpose except being observed.
edit — enjoyment is immaterial and the bits about graphic design can be art etc.
Most of the masterpieces you see in museums were used as decoration at some point.
The Pope needed something for his ceiling.
Most masterpieces where literally hanging in the background of some rich person's summer houses, and hunting lodges, and other properties. Thrown out and replaced on a whim.
Or melted down to make spears and helmets.
Art was used by the rich and famous to show off their wealth.
In the 19th century countries got into the game (the idea that Dutch masters were ending up in American collections was a national embarrassment).
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by xanderlewis on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:46AM
(#42472083)
I feel like there’s some kind of analogy between jazz cats and hackers.
In short, a cultural tradition. At length:
I found it easier to "get" when I started thinking of jazz as the beat poetry of music.
the ‘sound of surprise’
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by datadrivenangel on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:23AM
(#42471290)
jazz is what you can get away with.
Re:The Ghosts in the Machine
by kunalgupta on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:50AM
(#42472113)
delightful mental pain, like a cold plunge