News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by a2128 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:14AM (#41189252)
This reads like a tragic story. Once you've collected enough data on every internet user out there to group them into different advertising cohorts, the remaining ungrouped users, by process of elimination (due to privacy or targeted advertising laws), are children; and now they can be targeted just as easily.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw12347825 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:21AM (#41189544)
A tragic story would be one where folks in positions of power in these organizations saw these crises coming from a million miles away, tried to avoid disaster, and failed.

I don't think this is a tragic story.

I think this is a rather boring and formulaic plot we're seeing over and over: the story of late-stage capitalism and the application of value-extraction to human social structures resulting in comically terrible outcomes.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:18AM (#41189873)
Well said!

Capitalism is structured in such a way that we are throwing all other values out in the (short term) pursuit of money.

Who needs nature, mental and physical health if you made a buck or two? The perverse incentives of capitalism will never create good social change, and we are seeing it now more and more in late stage capitalism.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by adamc on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:50AM (#41192150)
This is a problem that could be solved with serious penalties (say, 20 years in prison for executives involved) and serious enforcement.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ssklash on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:44AM (#41192761)
It's really not though. All that money goes somewhere, and not just in their pockets. Some goes to make sure that serious penalties and serious enforcement doesn't happen, because that too is another avenue of ensuring maximum profit.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:48PM (#41198421)
> Some goes to make sure that serious penalties and serious enforcement doesn't happen

Representatives aren't emotionless puppets that respond to money. They're people, and they can be good or bad. In this case, they're bad, and they're the ones to blame, because they're responsible for protecting consumers from bad companies.

> that too is another avenue of ensuring maximum profit

This is also insanely deluded and ignorant of reality. Every communist country in existence has power deals between bureaucrats in charge of the state, and bureaucrats in charge of producing things. This is a result of human nature, and capitalism doesn't come into it at all.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by toofy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:40PM (#41198593)
> and they're the ones to blame, because they're responsible for protecting consumers from bad companies.

in your example they’re both bad—both the original aggressor and the one refusing to enforce against that aggressor.

we need to mitigate against this desire to find The One thing to blame. By their very nature complicated situations will have many problems, rarely simply one. we need to remember this so we don’t accidentally stifle conversations by saying “No! It’s this other thing! Not what you said!” we need to recognize this when we find ourselves falling into this trap.

keep in mind, in your scenario, if the elected representative were to enforce against the aggressor, the aggressor would go to jail because their actions are bad—-this tells us that no, it isn’t only the elected person. Both of the parties in your scenario are actively making the situation worse.

it’s both. they both deserve our derision.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:27AM (#41201161)
if we want to point fingers then I certainly have my targets but what good will that do? you’ll piss off one side, promote the other, and increase the divide for both.

another solution, actually boycott immorality. morality was pushed from society not so long ago, at least in the US, and what you see is the result. why wouldn’t you follow the letter of the law and screw over large swaths of people if it’s legal?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by CRConrad on Monday August 19, 2024 @09:01AM (#41290681)
Sure, boycott immorality and promote morality.

As long as you don't fall into the common (epecially for the US) trap of mistaking morality for having anything to do with whom you are or are not allowed to fuck.

(Except of course kids and in general people who don't want you to; those we absolutely should proscribe. But ironically the kind of USians who screech "morality" the loudest when you want to do it with someone of the wrong sex or race are also often the ones who seem to have the least of a problem with that.)

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Monday August 19, 2024 @09:09PM (#41295908)
> mistaking morality for having anything to do with whom you are or are not allowed to fuck

> Except of course kids and in general people who don't want you to

There's no self-consistent system of morality (that does not involve religion) that simultaneously supports all of these positions. What religious morality are you using?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Sunday August 11, 2024 @01:25PM (#41217772)
Sorry, yes, I agree - both the evildoers, and figures of authority that enable their behavior, deserve scorn and derision. I didn't mean to say that entities actually doing bad things don't deserve shame.

The point that I'm trying to make is that, while evildoers will always exist, we don't have very much agency over their actions. You don't have very many options over the actions of a bad company (or person) - but you do have the ability to hold your representatives accountable and protest and vote against them if they don't make good laws and enforce them.

So, even though evil companies/people should be shunned, at the very least we know that there's always going to be some of them around - but our representatives are ostensibly acting in our bests interests, and have more responsibility, power, and accountability than the bad actors, so we should focus on them instead.

That is - the same amount of energy applied to our representatives will do far more good than applied to bad companies.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:51AM (#41200950)
Sure it doesn't ALL go in their pockets.

https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-pay-in-2022/

The average CEO nowadays is paid 344 times more than an average worker, while in 1978 this figure was "only" 21 times.

And indeed, lots of it goes to prevent serious penalties, like lawyering-up, lobbying, (deceitful) media campaigns, bribing "scientists" and "doctors", etc. Just look at Big Tobacco's playbook: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Frank_Statement and see it playing out with Big Oil and climate change, Big Chem (PFAS in our water), etc etc. And, let's not forget Big Tech, with companies like Twitter/X where fascism now thrives, and Instagram/TikTok/Whatever who mine our attention.

These companies have grown, much like tumors, to be overly powerful, overly protected, and overly influential. And they wreck havoc on our societies and planet. Their attempts of "self-regulation" are laughable, and so far also laughable have been our governments' attempts to reign them in.

My point is that the kind of corp feudalism we see now is a direct following of unrestrained capitalism/libertarianism. Unless we reign in the companies, break them down, make them pay fair wages and hold them responsible for their societal and environmental impact, we will drown in our own garbage.

And yes, it's capitalism to blame, a philosophy where you optimize only for profit, throwing all other values out the window, in the hope that the (non-existent) "invisible hand" of the market will somehow fix everything magically.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:29AM (#41201179)
> it's capitalism to blame

it doesn’t matter how many times this is said, rational people know the issue is with humans and not capitalism. we can’t keep giving human behavior a pass and blaming systems that literally cannot take any action on their own. we see this with guns as well, the problem is not the system nor the laws, the problem is people. i wish you luck in fixing people, as many have tried before you and failed.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Friday August 09, 2024 @11:07AM (#41202591)
The solution to guns is simple. Ban guns and make ownership hard.

It's the same reason you don't allow 10 year-olds to operate a vehicle, cause it can be a danger to society.

> it doesn’t matter how many times this is said, rational people know the issue is with humans and not capitalism.

This statement is the equivalent of hand waving. Capitalism is a system made by humans, it's not some divine order. We have toppled other flawed systems in the past, feudalism (kings and queens heads were rolling), slavery, and we can do the same with capitalism.

These large complex systems have a life on their own and are susceptible to laws that individuals within can't predict/influence, so it's not human nature. Humans are largely compassionate, cooperative creatures. But the system in which we are placed influences our behavior to a huge extent. In this case, the system is definitely the problem, because it has bugs and corner cases that make it collapse, one way or another, and behavior that we consider "bad" to flourish.

Capitalism, let's call it for what it is, has become money-based feudalism where the most ruthless and sociopathic people "succeed". How else would you call Big Tobacco's disinformation campaigns: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Frank_Statement#. This purposeful misinformation of the public is surely evil. How else would you call tobacco execs' behavior if not evil and sociopathic? The capitalistic system is basically cutthroat lying and stealing and extraction of value with a false veneer of fairness and law.

- Theoretically, we are all equal in front of the law. In practice, the rich can lawyer up and get away with things that a normal person wouldn't be able to

- Theoretically, all of us, through hard work and enterprise, can "succeed" in capitalism. In practice, it's much more important who your daddy is, where you were born, and where you studied (which is also influenced by money)

- Theoretically, the government system in which we participate has elected bodies which are supposed to protect us from harm (e.g pollution, climate change, etc). In practice, money has allowed large corporation to buy politicians, lobbyists, campaign time, influence public opinion, etc.

So, you see, in capitalism, the system is very very rigged, it promises one thing, but, behind the scenes, it's all about money. Everything is optimized for money, everything else is thrown out of the window (including people, nature, morals). There is only one option to defeat this rigged system, and that's not individual action, it's collective action.

Strikes work, greedy corps can't actually survive without their workers doing the work.

The pandemic made many people re-evaluate what's important, and we saw that it's the lower paid professions that were the "essential ones": nurses, delivery drivers, sanitation, etc. Why are they lower paid then?

Now we are back to pretending nothing ever happened and corporations really hard are trying to make it business as usual again, trying to put you back to the office, trying to raise their prices and blame it on inflation.

But guess what: with the fabrics of society unraveling together with the natural world, when there is no drinkable water and no food to eat, and fires are raging everywhere, you will realize that capitalism was the cancer causing all this. You'd be regretting you didn't band up with others and acted up sooner.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Sunday August 11, 2024 @09:09AM (#41215867)
> The solution to guns is simple. Ban guns and make ownership hard.

But then this is stepping on an enumerated right. If we remove or make it difficult the right to own guns, what’s next? Freedom of speech? That one was attacked recently as well. So no the solution is not to further limit rights due to the hoplophobia of a few, the solution is actually what you’re trying to stop. Prior to recent history, it was quite common for a child to have a gun. They didn’t go around shooting people then, so what’s different? (removing morality such that people are only scared of breaking laws, and nothing else).

The rest I didn’t read because this isn’t a blog and you tried to compare capitalism with feudalism.

I understand capitalism doesn’t allow you to be lazy and have no job, but that’s a feature not a bug.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Sunday August 11, 2024 @11:21AM (#41216827)
> But then this is stepping on an enumerated right.

So was the right to own slaves. So was the right of a samurai to kill a peasant. Or a man to beat his wife.

> If we remove or make it difficult the right to own guns, what’s next?

America wouldn't have a school shooting each week. I know it's hard for the American brain to comprehend, but schools are for studying, not for target practice.

> Freedom of speech? That one was attacked recently as well

Really? Who attacked it? You mean the right of the right-wing to incite for violence and do an insurrection? That's not free speech, that's incitement to violence and insurrection.

> So no the solution is not to further limit rights due to the hoplophobia of a few

Nah, the solution is to make gun ownership hard, much harder than it is now, like literally any other civilized country. And limit gun ownership for civilians to small firearms.

> Prior to recent history, it was quite common for a child to have a gun

Prior to recent history, it was also common for children to work in mines, people to own slaves, we had segregated toilets, and women couldn't open a bank account. Times are a'changin', it's high time for that to happen to guns.

Only in one country, the same country where all the time a toddler shoots their family members or themselves by accident. The same country where school shootings are happening each week and have their own wikipedia page. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_th...

- https://abc7.com/gun-safety-pregnant-woman-shot-norwalk-ohio...

- https://www.wcjb.com/2024/04/18/gpd-victims-family-covered-u...

- https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/after-a-toddler-acci...

> The rest I didn’t read because this isn’t a blog and you tried to compare capitalism with feudalism.

In capitalism you work for a boss so you can have a roof over your head, and in feudalism you work for a king. In both cases somebody has too much power over you, whether it's due to money or divine right, it's just a matter of detail.

> I understand capitalism doesn’t allow you to be lazy and have no job, but that’s a feature not a bug.

Ooh, somebody is getting spicy. I thought the promise of capitalism is that we are going to create so much wealth that we'd all be able to enjoy leisure, free time, and unprecedented economic growth. Why is that then people working two jobs can't afford rent and basic groceries?

- https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/nov/05/multiple-job...

- https://metro.co.uk/2023/12/02/work-two-jobs-afford-london-r...

Maybe your precious capitalism has some bugs after all, if the countries where its left running unchecked (e.g UK and the US) have lower life expectancy, lower life satisfaction and higher inequality, and less individual freedoms than countries that have social democracy (like Sweden, Netherlands, Norway)?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Monday August 12, 2024 @09:46AM (#41224321)
posts a long message that someone refuses to read (because you’re wasting my time) then posts another long message expecting people to read.

if your goal is to convince people of your perspective, I suggest reducing the word count to 10% of what’s here so busy people with jobs can read it.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Monday August 12, 2024 @12:49PM (#41226569)
> I suggest reducing the word count to 10% of what’s here so busy people with jobs can read it.

Fine, I will oblige :)

TLDR;

1. capitalism is bad, social democracies beat it in every index.

2. Google/Meta grew to the tumors they are nowadays due to capitalism.

> I suggest reducing the word count to 10% of what’s here so busy people with jobs can read i

No, I am not interested in editing my post to cater to people who don't have the mental capacity/space to read 300 words with attention and understanding (another symptom of capitalism, people are struggling to keep jobs that demand so much of them that they can't even read). I've heard Twitter is good for that though, maybe you should check it out.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Monday August 19, 2024 @10:42PM (#41296286)
> But then this is stepping on an enumerated right. If we remove or make it difficult the right to own guns, what’s next? Freedom of speech?

It may be enlightening to read some of the GP's other comments, e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41290361

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:11PM (#41206824)
GP is not rational, and they're not interested in debate, but in using emotional pleading to push an agenda. Suggest flagging and moving on.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:46PM (#41198413)
This is deluded. "Capitalism" is not "structured" in this way at all. This is a failure of regulation, and it's extremely easy to see why: because competent regulators would take anticompetitive action against large monopolies like Google and Meta, as well as enacting laws to prevent undesirable things like personal data being sold.

> The perverse incentives of capitalism will never create good social change

...and you just outed yourself as being extremely ignorant of basically all history, as the vast majority of socially beneficial inventions and rights of all time have come from capitalist countries.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:37PM (#41203372)
> This is deluded. "Capitalism" is not "structured" in this way at all. This is a failure of regulation

I do agree with you that this is a failure of regulation. However, in the stage of capitalism we are currently in, capitalism actively FIGHTS regulation.

Whether it's lobbyism, hiring "scientists" to challenge independent studies, outright tax evasion, or simply accepting fines for disaster after disaster (oil spills, bad plane design, data sales) because they can afford it. Hell, politicians now are deregulating our countries by privatising or de-funding branch after branch (see the NHS in the UK).

Capitalism at its current stage is just a giant fire-sale, and our governments are as deeply involved as the corporations, not out of maliciousness, but due to how the system naturally drags everybody and everything in, with its need for constant growth. You know what else constantly grows? Tumors.

Sure we do need powerful regulation and regulation enforcement, but we also need to think whether a system that produces statements like this: https://jacobin.com/2022/05/pete-buttigieg-free-market-hungr...

"Pete Buttigieg: Hungry Babies, Regrettably, Are Just the Price of the Free Market"

Is worth preserving.

I'd say not, and I will work my best to dismantle it and throw it in the past, where it belongs, along with slavery, feudalism, fascism and other obsolete and harmful human societal arrangements.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:07PM (#41206808)
> However, in the stage of capitalism we are currently in

This is, again, deeply deluded and detached from reality.

People always fight those who hold them back. This applies to employees fighting bosses, children fighting parents, companies fighting regulators, citizens fighting corrupt governments, and different bureaucrats fighting each other in socialist and communist systems.

It's blindingly obvious that this phenomenon isn't specific to capitalism, and outright false to claim that it wouldn't happen in any other economic system. (and, in fact, it would be much worse in command economies, as history clearly shows)

> Capitalism at its current stage is just a giant fire-sale

Again: there's no "at its current stage" - there is corruption in government that has allowed bad actors to run rampant. The fact that tens of thousands of companies are behaving reasonably trivially disproves your claim that this is a "stage". This is bad actors, which have always existed, and always will continue to exist, that are now less checked than usual because of regulatory failure.

> we also need to think whether a system that produces statements like this

...which proves decisively that you have no idea what you're talking about. This is not an argument - this is emotional pleading.

That describes a lot of your posts, actually - pleading. Because there are no logical points made, just a lot of emotionally manipulative, trivially-false statements.

> will work my best to dismantle it and throw it in the past

...and there's the activism, which comes with the typical lack of understanding of reality that is common to proponents for communism.

You should visit North Korea for yourself and see how alternative systems to capitalism actually work.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:48AM (#41207990)
> trivially-false statements.

You showed no arguments where my statements are false, so I assume this is (bad) trolling on your side.

> ...and there's the activism, which comes with the typical lack of understanding of reality that is common to proponents for communism. ...This is not an argument - this is emotional pleading.

I am not a proponent for communism, dunno where you got that from. Maybe try to understand other people's point before emotionally pleading against them yourself.

> Again: there's no "at its current stage"

Says who, you? The term for the stage of capitalism our societies right now is: "late capitalism", or "late stage capitalism". It's blatantly obvious you don't know or you don't want to know about this, but there are many of us who do. There is a link, educate yourself (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_capitalism)

It's obvious to anyone who pays attention to any statistics, that this capitalism comes with humongous wealth inequality (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_inequality_in_the_Unite...), increased corporation meddling in politics (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lobbying_in_the_United_States) and an ever increasing of destruction of natural habitat and poisoning of people and nature alike (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer_Alley, https://www.aamc.org/news/microplastics-are-inside-us-all-wh..., https://www.frontiersin.org/news/2024/07/25/pesticides-smoki..., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pollution_in_California).

These things didn't happen under some different order, they happened under capitalism. And what we experience today is vastly different than the capitalism on the past, and it all started to change from when Thatcher and Raegan started dismantling government guardrails on the market, unleashing the destructive form of capitalism that we have today. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcherism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics)

> You should visit North Korea for yourself and see how alternative systems to capitalism actually work.

I've seen and lived in enough countries to know that countries that are social democracies (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_democracy) with capitalism reigned in do far better in terms of population happiness, health, longevity, worker rights, and freedoms.

- Freedom: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_inequalit...

- Happiness + Life Satisfaction: https://ourworldindata.org/happiness-and-life-satisfaction

- Inequality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_inequalit...

- Life Expectancies https://www.worldometers.info/demographics/life-expectancy/

If capitalism is so good, why social democracies, where capitalism is put at its place outperform it in every possible human index: happiness, freedoms, inequality and life expectancy? Stop simping for capitalism, it isn't working, all data shows it for what it is: a harmful ideology destroying people and nature alike.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @10:53PM (#41242096)
> You showed no arguments where my statements are false

Yes, I did:

"> However, in the stage of capitalism we are currently in" was disproven by "this phenomenon isn't specific to capitalism, and outright false to claim that it wouldn't happen in any other economic system."

"> Capitalism at its current stage is just a giant fire-sale" was disproven by "there's no "at its current stage"" and "This is bad actors, which have always existed, and always will continue to exist, that are now less checked than usual because of regulatory failure."

> I am not a proponent for communism

So then what's the system you're going to replace "capitalism" with after you "dismantle it"? There's basically no other answer except communism. Socialism is a special case and explicitly a transitional stage used by communists to institute it.

> Maybe try to understand other people's point before emotionally pleading against them yourself.

You didn't provide any serious arguments or details to argue against. I countered all of your points to the level of fidelity possible given the lack of details and reason.

> The term for the stage of capitalism our societies right now is: "late capitalism", or "late stage capitalism". It's blatantly obvious you don't know or you don't want to know about this, but there are many of us who do. There is a link, educate yourself (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_capitalism)

This is simultaneously both extremely condescending and ignorant. Late capitalism does not exist. It is an activist term and fictional construct, invented by a Marxist and used by Marxists to advance a political agenda. There is no "education" to have, because you cannot "educate" yourself about an activist concept that has no concrete definition, scientific test, or acceptance in the boarder field that it claims to be a part of.

> capitalism comes with humongous wealth inequality

Yes, some amount of wealth inequality is expected and good. Excesses of it are clearly due to corruption in the government that does regulation. And, as I've stated earlier, this is not unique to capitalism. Wealth and power inequality happen in every economic system.

> increased corporation meddling in politics

Which is solely the fault of elected representatives that aren't being held to account by their constituents - and, as stated before, this is not unique to capitalism - this meddling happens in every economic system between different people and organizations in positions of power.

> an ever increasing of destruction of natural habitat and poisoning of people and nature alike

...and again, this is the fault of elected representatives part of whose jobs are to literally force individuals and corporations to account for externalities. This also isn't unique to corporations - individuals also take advantage of negative externalities. This also isn't unique to capitalism, and happens with every economic system.

You've spouted statistics that you don't understand, that aren't unique to capitalism, and that are exclusively limited to the US and/or CA and do not generalize to the rest of the world.

> These things didn't happen under some different order, they happened under capitalism

False. Wealth inequality, corruption and meddling between entities in power, and the destruction of the environment have happened, and are happening, in every country on earth. Your statement is objectively false.

> it all started to change from when Thatcher and Raegan started dismantling government guardrails on the market, unleashing the destructive form of capitalism that we have today

Citation needed. Wikipedia articles don't count. Also, you never provided a definition of "this form of capitalism". You are actively making it more difficult to have a productive discussion by avoiding providing definitions or details for anything you say.

> I've seen and lived in enough countries to know that countries that are social democracies

"Social democracies" - socialism - is a transitionary stage towards communism, one of the most evil ideologies known to man.

> population happiness, health, longevity, worker rights, and freedoms

(1) all of the countries at the top of the HDI report are tiny compared to the US, with radically different cultures and fiscal situations, rendering a comparison without controlling for those factors utterly irrelevant. People who travel are aware of these differences. (2) "worker rights" is incredibly subjective and impossible to measure objectively, especially when socialists are doing the measurement, (3) the US is, by most measures, far more free than most of these countries (4) "longevity" also has cultural and biological factors that are utterly unrelated to economic system.

> Stop simping for capitalism

I'm defending my arguments with reason, not the one simping for socialism by spraying Wikipedia links without any understanding of what they actually say or the (lack of) evidence that supports them.

I am well aware of the faults of the US's economic system (look, I can actually be precise with my terms, and avoid vague terms like "capitalism", that isn't so hard, is it?), and actively work to fix those, because I'm aware of the horrible atrocities that happen under communism.

> the tech giants have repeatedly broken regulation after regulation, have gotten fine after fine, but they continue so because they can afford to do so, and this all happened under capitalism, which allowed them to grow to the monstrosities that they are today

I've repeated this several times, and it continues to be true: this is not unique to capitalism, and happens under every economic system. This, objectively, is not unique to capitalism. This is a fact.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ath3nd on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @07:25PM (#41251664)
> Yes, I did:

No, you didn't. You just said everything I said is blatantly false, which I find laughable, considering you (again) provided no arguments to defend your position.

> False. Wealth inequality, corruption and meddling between entities in power, and the destruction of the environment have happened, and are happening, in every country on earth. Your statement is objectively false.

You are blatantly wrong. My statement that Google and Meta came to exist and became what they are under capitalism is 100% objectively true. Or do you claim the story of their existence is a success story of socialism?

> So then what's the system you're going to replace "capitalism" with after you "dismantle it"?

It's called socialism, it has many flavors, look it up. It also already exists.

> I've repeated this several times, and it continues to be true: this is not unique to capitalism, and happens under every economic system.

False. It happens at this scale only under capitalism.

> I am well aware of the faults of the US's economic system (look, I can actually be precise with my terms, and avoid vague terms like "capitalism", that isn't so hard, is it?)

The US economic system is a raging libertarianism-type capitalism, unrestrained by checks and balances, due to the line of policies introduced by Raegan. This has been a process that has progressed till today, hence the huge income and social inequality that we see in the US, much bigger than it was when Raegan become president. It's simply the predictable trajectory of all capitalist countries, they reach the boiling point of inequality and discontent, and then there is a revolution.

> "Social democracies" - socialism - is a transitionary stage towards communism, one of the most evil ideologies known to man.

You are thinking of capitalism, which IS the most evil ideology known to man, as it's all about growing mindlessly like a tumor, and destroying everything in its path. Luckily, it can't contain itself, as the people who actually do the work eventually get pissed off at the rich rent-seekers, and stop working for them, or worse.

> Which is solely the fault of elected representatives that aren't being held to account by their constituents - and, as stated before, this is not unique to capitalism - this meddling happens in every economic system between different people and organizations in positions of power

What IS unique to capitalism, is the disproportionate amount of influence money have on the politics and on power, and how much corporations meddle in politics, with lobbyism, with pressuring the EPA, and with throwing their support under presidential candidates, making pawns of our elected officials.

> Excesses of it are clearly due to corruption in the government that does regulation. And, as I've stated earlier, this is not unique to capitalism. Wealth and power inequality happen in every economic system.

Blatantly wrong. There is certainly corruption in the government, but the reason for the huge disparity in income is that the system of capitalism is structured like that. This is a known and predictable behavior of unchecked capitalism, and is described by Marx. This is a fact.

> This is simultaneously both extremely condescending and ignorant. Late capitalism does not exist. It is an activist term and fictional construct.

Don't get all Jordan Peterson-like, please. Arguments like: "what even is climate?" or "it's a model/theory and thus it can tell us nothing about the world" are laughable. We use words and constructs to describe things, and economists of the past thought how to describe the capitalism of the future, and called it "late capitalism".

It's similar to calling the Republicans "right-wing", another concept.

The GDP is also a fictional (and useless/harmful) construct but we use it all the time and pretend it matters.

An even more harmful made-up-construct is the "invisible hand of the market", a half-baked theory popularized by Adam Smith which economists base their growth fetishes and deregulation wet dreams on.

All those concepts are made by people to describe something or another. That's how words work.

Once again, here is the link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_capitalism describing how the stage of capitalism we are in atm is "late capitalism".

"Late Capitalism", that's the term that's used for what you experience now in the US and the UK: concentration of wealth in the 1%'s hands, and a growing discontent.

If you don't like the term, feel free to use other names for it, like neo-capitalism, but the rest of us know it for what it is and will continue calling it so. Beause that's how it's called (it even has a wiki page). And that's a fact.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Monday August 19, 2024 @09:04PM (#41295868)
> Don't get all Jordan Peterson-like, please.

> It's called socialism, it has many flavors, look it up

At this point, combined with other comments like:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41207990

> I am not a proponent for communism, dunno where you got that from. Maybe try to understand other people's point before emotionally pleading against them yourself.

> Says who, you?

> Stop simping for capitalism, it isn't working

...it's extremely clear that you're not interested in debate, but in pushing an ideology, using whatever fallacies and redefinitions you need to in order to convince people. I have no obligation to respond to you, nor will it be productive, as you cannot change the mind of someone holding onto an ideology religiously like this.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by CRConrad on Monday August 19, 2024 @09:23AM (#41290855)
> > You showed no arguments where my statements are false

> Yes, I did:

> "> However, in the stage of capitalism we are currently in" was disproven by "this phenomenon isn't specific to capitalism, and outright false to claim that it wouldn't happen in any other economic system."

> "> Capitalism at its current stage is just a giant fire-sale" was disproven by "there's no "at its current stage"" and "This is bad actors, which have always existed, and always will continue to exist, that are now less checked than usual because of regulatory failure."

Neither of those proved anything; they're just assertions.

Reading some of your other comments, it's hard to think you're unaware of the difference. So what's this? Doesn't look all that much like arguing in good faith.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by throw10920 on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:49PM (#41295782)
The fact that you got mad when I called you out in a response[1] and proceeded to stalk my other comment threads to personally attack me conclusively proves that you're not interested in debate or reason, just pushing your own ideological agenda. I have no responsibility to respond to you. Your opinions and arguments are invalid, because you're shown that you're willing to resort to stalking and personal attacks against those you do not like.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41295385

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by CRConrad on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:04AM (#41298825)
1) You've got your chronology and causality wrong[1]. No, I did not "stalk [your] other comment threads" after my other response to you.

2) And no, pointing out flawed logic in an argument is not a "personal attack".

3) My interests and motivations don't affect the validity of my arguments. I just said that assertions aren't proofs (here), and that working for a particular employer is a choice, not mandatory (elsewhere, at your link above). Hitler could say either of those, and it would still be correct. So could Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Emperor Bokassa, Donald Trump, Joe Biden, or Churchill. See how it has nothing to do with ideology?

4) What you claim are "proofs" are still just assertions, and working for a particular employer is still a choice. You were wrong, that is all.

___

[1]: I think I've replied to you exactly twice before, and you posted this exact same (apart from the link) response to both. Since what you're saying is either "you attacked me elsewhere, and then followed me here!" or "you attacked me here, and then followed me elsewhere!", it's confusing as Hell. Which is supposed to be "elsewhere", and which "here"? It even took me a while to realise both links were valid, and not some weird loop... (I was beginning to speculate whether Dan G had moved one sub-thread or both into some offshoot. That is, after I realised they are two separate sub-threads in the first place.)

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ToucanLoucan on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:11AM (#41191741)
The line has to go up, and the slack has to be taken out of every last source of revenue. Like that story that was here yesterday about insurance companies monitoring customer's insured assets with drones and AI. Every unexploited dollar left on the table is slack, and a perfect market leaves no dollar unexploited. Therefore a more perfect market can be built with more perfect machine-powered decisions to more perfectly screw you out of every nickel they can.

"Oops, sorry your brother cut his leg and you had to speed to the hospital, but you better get a second job if you wanna keep your car."

Fuck this shit. Fuck all of it. And fuck all the status quo warriors sitting on the sidelines bleating about "it's just the way it is" because the axe hasn't swung for them yet. You're safe now because the market has more vulnerable people to grind up first, but rest assured, as it churns through them, your time will come too.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by shadowgovt on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:22AM (#41192500)
And relatedly, I'm sorry that while you were speeding your brother to the hospital, you blew through a red light you couldn't stop for and caused a three-car pileup that killed an elderly woman.

There's a reason we have these rules, and the problem of better enforcement leading to more application of the rules isn't a late-stage-capitalism problem; it's a "rules require flexibility" problem (but it's not great if the nature of the flexibility is "you didn't get caught").

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ToucanLoucan on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:10PM (#41193834)
> And relatedly, I'm sorry that while you were speeding your brother to the hospital, you blew through a red light you couldn't stop for and caused a three-car pileup that killed an elderly woman.

Firstly, surveilling every person in the world at all times to ensure safety is a gross misapplicaiton of tech that flies in the face of personal freedom and privacy.

Secondly, we're not even talking about authorities surveilling you to prevent safety situations (which would, by itself, already be plenty vile enough). We're talking your insurance company checking on you to make sure your roof doesn't have moss on it, and jacking your price/nuking your policy if they feel your behavior is too "risky," according to a model you (and probably they) don't fully understand how it works.

There's so much wrong with this and if you don't think so I doubt a comment here is going to change your mind. If you place ANY value at all on personal autonomy and privacy, I don't believe it's possible to, at the same time, say your insurance company by virtue of insuring your car, has the right to surveil that car at a time and via a method of their choosing, with no notification, and with no oversight, solely for the purpose of jacking up your price and/or rewriting your contract on the fly. These relationships already heavily, heavily bias in the favor of the corporation. Do they really need YET MORE unearned, unchecked authority in our lives?!

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by shadowgovt on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:30PM (#41194096)
> surveilling every person in the world at all times to ensure safety is a gross misapplicaiton of tech that flies in the face of personal freedom and privacy

Not at all times, of course.

But if we built the technology to do it whenever someone is operating a multi-ton vehicle on a shared roadway (similar to how we require police to wear body-cams), I wouldn't actually be sad about it or feel unduly watched.

I do concur, however, that routing it through the insurance company is pretty sub-optimal; I'd much prefer a public authority that I could vote out if they screw up.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by getwiththeprog on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @07:39AM (#41244944)
Not at all times, just when they are driving 2 tons of deadly metal.

I look forward to police metadata monitors that identify speeding and dangerous driving.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by shadowgovt on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @11:23AM (#41247161)
Way back in high school, I remember learning the Mean Value Theorem in calculus, and I asked the teacher (little annoying asshole that I was) whether the consequence of the theorem that "for a continuous function, the mean of the values in the interval is one of the values in the interval" implies that you could track how long it took someone to get from point A to point B on the highway and conclude that even if you didn't see them speed, they must have sped.

He paused and responded "yes, but nobody will stand for getting tickets like that."

Fast-forward to the 2020s and I find there are actually plenty of people who would, in fact, stand for that.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:11PM (#41194536)
> Firstly, surveilling every person in the world at all times to ensure safety is a gross misapplicaiton of tech that flies in the face of personal freedom and privacy.

Are you referring to the opt-in system of surveillance which insurance companies use to monitor driving (install our app/plug our device into your OBD port)?

Or are they, these days, buying data on your driving from stuff like traffic cams (wouldn't be surprising, sorry if I'm giving them the idea now)?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by kelnos on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:07PM (#41195083)
> Are you referring to the opt-in system of surveillance which insurance companies use to monitor driving (install our app/plug our device into your OBD port)?

Not the person you're replying to, but yes, absolutely stuff like that. (I think GP was talking about drone surveillance and stuff like that, but sure, we can talk about this too.)

The problem is that people are being coerced into giving up their privacy and autonomy. In this particular case, the coercion is (as usual) money: you presumably get a discount for letting your insurance company spy on you. I expect, though, that ultimately the insurance companies use these things as justification to charge more on average. Let's face it: most people are not particularly good drivers. That's a problem, certainly, but not one that should or will be solved by a company with a profit motive. Some people will drive within whatever arbitrary, poorly-understood parameters that makes the insurance company's algorithms happy, but most probably will not, and will likely see their premiums go up, but not realize why.

And even if this did actually result in lower premiums on average (for the people who opt into this dystopia), it's still a problem, because the implication is that only rich people are allowed to have privacy.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by shadowgovt on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @11:24AM (#41247170)
> only rich people are allowed to have privacy.

We already live in a world where being wealthy can buy you more privacy. The question is only where we put the comfort slider on that fact, not whether it is a fact.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ToucanLoucan on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:13PM (#41194564)
In the thread I saw yesterday, can't spend the time to find it atm, the topic was specifically about an insurance company using drones and AI to ascertain that someone's roof had moss growing on it. The homeowner fully acknowledged that this was a lapse in his upkeep, but also, I am incredibly opposed to the notion that a company can surveil people as such simply because they buy insurance from them.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:29PM (#41195888)
Actually these days new cars have GPS tracking built in, and the manufacturers sell your location data, so it's much more fine-grained than traffic cams, and they didn't need your help getting the idea.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by markovs_gun on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:09AM (#41200672)
Does it really matter if it's opt-in when insurance companies are going to make the price without the "discounts" you get for opting in completely unaffordable for most people? When I shopped around for auto insurance most recently, I discovered that Liberty Mutual is already using this model. The quoted price is way higher than most, but convenient discounts are offered if you download an app that lets them spy on your driving habits. What happens when every insurer starts doing stuff like this because it becomes socially acceptable for them to do so? The issue, as usual, isn't from one or two firms offering a discount in exchange for data collection, it's when this data collection happens at scale and is practically unavoidable, especially for people who don't realize what they're really opting into.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:19AM (#41201099)
> Does it really matter if it's opt-in when insurance companies are going to make the price without the "discounts" you get for opting in completely unaffordable for most people?

let’s be accurate with statements yes? i was offered one of these devices, refused it, and my rates did not increase. you’re claiming the rates people have been paying are lower than after they refuse the device. This is incorrect.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by markovs_gun on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:34AM (#41201222)
That's not the mechanism by which this happens. It's likely illegal (or at the very least, a bad look PR wise) for them to increase your rates based on your refusal to be spied on, but the base price will likely increase as the adoption of technologies like this becomes more widespread, and the discounts will become a more important part of how people afford car insurance. It's not that your specific policy will go from $200/mo to $300/mo for not opting in, it's that over time the same policy for new customers will be $300/mo but with a $100/mo discount for letting them spy on you.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Sunday August 11, 2024 @09:12AM (#41215888)
Inflation will also do that. So are you mad at the current administration for increasing the prices of all policies?

in reality so long as there still competition and the gov keeps their regulatory noses out of it, then competition alone will take care of it.

Besides, the devices are embedded into cars now so this is entirely a nonissue going forward. Everybody already has one and your driving data is being sent to insurance companies without you even knowing.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by alfiedotwtf on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:06AM (#41192320)
You’re on a website run by venture capitalists who use this platform to increase the value of their portfolios… so unless you’re an agent provocateur, your comment needs to be read as ironic performance art because I hate to break it to you - you’re also part of the problem
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by harimau777 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:48AM (#41192825)
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by toomuchtodo on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:15AM (#41192413)
I operated under this mental model originally as well. But, based on all available information, while HN allows running ads for YC portfolio companies and uses it for other promo purposes (YC applications), I have come to the conclusion tha pg, dang, et el are running this place as part science project, part public good, funded by YC returns (which, while not exact, can be predicted with high confidence from public information wrt portfolio liquidity events).

Certainly, you need funding, look what happened to Reddit's quest to squeeze community for returns. HN runs lean (two servers in colo, a few mods) and small (less is more), so they can be more flexible in what they're optimizing for. I will argue there is something intangible that exists they are cultivating. More for another thread, but I would be cautious about saying "You cannot speak truth about capitalism failings because YC runs HN and YC is a VC fund." Simplicity is rare, and the evidence does not indicate this forum runs to maximize profit.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ToucanLoucan on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:18AM (#41192460)
If the problem you're referring to is capitalism, it is not possible to not participate in capitalism because capitalism operates every nation state and every portion of the planet.

If the problem you're referring to is venture capital, I don't work at a VC firm and have no intention to.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by kelnos on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:17PM (#41195184)
Kinda tired of hearing this over and over. By and large, most HN readers and commenters are just regular people. Certainly we are regular people of a certain demographic, but we're not all venture capitalists or startup executives or whatever. Not even close.

If you have evidence that the people who run and moderate HN are doing so with a heavy bias toward projecting some sort of venture-capitalist narrative, please present that evidence. My interactions with dang, at least (reading his comments here, and a few email interactions) suggest quite the opposite.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tacocataco on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:41AM (#41202328)
There is no ethical consumption while living a capitalist way of life.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by toomuchtodo on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:59AM (#41192240)
Someone on HN [1] recommended "Broken Code," [2] a book about the various people who tried to fix Facebook/Meta from the inside and noped out. Highly recommend having purchased and read. "Evil, I think, is the absence of empathy.” -- Captain G. M. Gilbert

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40969211

[2] https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/712678/broken-code-...

(keep those book recommendations coming)

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by rurp on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:12AM (#41192368)
I'm beyond being shocked by this kind of behavior but it is still striking to me how some of the most profitable companies in history will go out of their way to do shady deals for a slight short term increase in their record profits.

The resulting reputational damage and future risk to their monopoly revenue has got to make deals like this -EV for the company in the long run, but decision makers at these companies are paid more for short term profits and they know it.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by pseudocomposer on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:08PM (#41193811)
Reputational damage is pretty easy to limit for companies that can control what news a huge majority of people see.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mrguyorama on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:51PM (#41194308)
If the "Craftsman" brand of tools didn't go completely out of business despite removing the lifetime warranty and just slapping the brand name on cheap chinese tools, then "Reputational damage" does not exist.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by markovs_gun on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:02AM (#41200635)
Yep. Reputational damage is a thing of the past in a world where everyone is completely bombarded with useless and incorrect information 24/7. Maybe it was never a thing at all, and companies merely assumed it was as a theoretical. Either way, I have never seen any brand actually suffer long term because of their reputation.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mixmastamyk on Saturday August 10, 2024 @12:56PM (#41210722)
Tarnished brands change their name these days.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mewse on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:52AM (#41208411)
Pedantry: "Craftsman" was never a company and didn't "go out of business".

"Craftsman" was originally a store brand used by Sears, under which it sold tools that Sears contracted various third parties to produce.

In 2017, Stanley Black & Decker purchased the "Craftsman" trademark from Sears (Sears Holdings at the time), giving Sears a long-term royalty-free license to continue producing and selling tools under that trademark (I think that license lasts for about another decade at this point? And then there'd be a small royalty payment for using the trademark beyond that point.)

As a result, several different stores now each carry tools all called "Craftsman", they're generally not the same tools; different stores sell different tools produced in different places, and all sell their own versions of the tools under the same "Craftsman" brand name.

This undoubtedly causes absurd levels of consumer confusion. As you say, it's absolutely causing tremendous reputational value for the trademark.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:16AM (#41201082)
> the story of late-stage capitalism and the application of value-extraction to human social structures resulting in comically terrible outcomes

You mean the MBAs. Ban anything related to business administration degrees and fix the problem.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by cantrevealname on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:35AM (#41189631)
> the remaining ungrouped users, by process of elimination..."

This being hacker news, I can't help but appreciate the pure evil genius of this. It reminds me of some other cases cunning corporate ingenuity:

- Monsanto and their "terminator" seeds that prevents farmers from planting seeds they harvest, requiring them to purchase new seeds for every planting.[1]

- Volkswagen and how they programmed diesel engines to activate emissions controls only during laboratory emissions testing.[2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto#%22Terminator%22_seed...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by echoangle on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:48AM (#41190474)
> Monsanto and their "terminator" seeds that prevents farmers from planting seeds they harvest, requiring them to purchase new seeds for every planting.

Kind of misleading to just state it like this if your source points out that Monsanto never sold this, pledged 25 years ago they won’t do this, and according to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_use_restriction_tech... , they also didn’t invent it.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by HDThoreaun on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:09AM (#41192338)
Monsanto isn’t forcing anyone to buy their product. Farmers use it because they’re better than uncopyeighted seeds.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by harimau777 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:52AM (#41192867)
They are forced in the sense that it's a prisoner's dilemma type of thing: Farmers would be better off if none of them used exploitative seeds. However since they are competing with farmers who are using those seeds then have to do so as well in order to stay competitive.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by HDThoreaun on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:45PM (#41193528)
I dont see how that is the case. How does one farmer using monsanto seeds mean another needs to as well? Each farmers seed choice has no effect on others choices. If the monsanto seeds cost more than they were worth farmers wouldnt use them. In fact saying that you need to use their seeds to be competitive makes it clear that you understand that the seeds are worth it, you just wish they were free or cheaper. But in order to create these seeds monsanto needs to be paid.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by kelnos on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:28PM (#41195261)
My guess would be it's about pricing. Let's imagine a world where there are only two farms, mine and my neighbor's. We're both using regular seeds, and we do a decent job, but it's not wonderful, and some years our yield isn't so great.

Then Monsanto comes along and wants to sell us a product that gives us better, more consistent yields, even better than our best harvests with the regular seeds. The catch, of course, is that we have to buy new seed from them every year, and can't propagate seed from the prior year's crop.

So my neighbor decides to start buying Monsanto's seeds, but I don't like the terms of the deal, so I don't. My neighbor sees amazing yields, even to the point of surplus. He decides to undercut me by lowering his prices because he has so much to sell, and can still make out better than before, with those lower prices. Nothing's changed for me, so I can't lower my prices. My neighbor's entire inventory sells out, but because of his surplus, only half of my yield gets sold. Fortunately I have some savings to fall back on, so I burn my entire savings feeding my family for the rest of the year, and then grudgingly buy Monsanto seeds for next year.

I'm sure this exact scenario doesn't scale up to the global agricultural system, but I think it's more likely than your naive "no one forces anyone to buy anything; if they buy it, it's because it's worth it" view of economics... things are rarely that simple.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:40AM (#41201271)
You do realize that most farming is subsidized by the gov these days right? So in your scenario here, likely no farmer is making profit and the gov is paying the difference.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by vsensei on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:30AM (#41207931)
In your story nobody is forced to anything. The farmer that doesn't like the monsanto deal made their choice, effectively rendering their farm business less competitive (unable to lower prices like the other farmer). That was predictable, it's also why the other farmer took the deal. Yeah, forced by market to not ignore progress to be better at what you do, that may be, but can't see that as negative.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by harimau777 on Monday August 12, 2024 @09:17PM (#41231220)
They are forced in the sense that they don't have a viable choice other than taking a bad deal.

Note that the issue isn't ignoring progress. Neither farmer has an issue with using more sophisticated seeds. The issue is with the deal that goes along with the seeds.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Manabu-eo on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:29PM (#41195883)
If you neighbor uses monsanto seeds, he also sprays pesticides that might kill your crops or make them have too much pesticides to be edible. It's also basically impossible to do organic farming besides such a farm.

https://investigatemidwest.org/2020/12/04/buy-it-or-else-ins...

https://inthedirt.substack.com/p/when-the-neighbor-kills-you...

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:38AM (#41201255)
This is an interesting twist of the original urban legend around these seeds. The story was that if you didn’t pay for monsanto seeds, and your neighbor did and planted them, and one blew into your yard then you’d be targeted by a lawsuit.

in reality though, i’d like to see this farmland so close to another that they can’t accurately spray or sow. there’s fences and access roads between fields, sometimes trees as well.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by chrz on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:05PM (#41212206)
They were buying farms out and suing neighbour farmers for using monsato seeds blown by wind from their farms. Theyre pure evil. They have a deal with Bayer
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by HDThoreaun on Saturday August 10, 2024 @09:02PM (#41213294)
There are zero cases of monsanto suing farmers for seeds blown by the wind.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by chrz on Sunday August 11, 2024 @05:01AM (#41214918)
Hmm true, I was lied by internet it seems. But https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/feb/12/monsanto...
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by snowpid on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:47AM (#41189711)
" nce you've collected enough data on every internet user " I guess by legal I can force companies not to collect data from me. (I am not a kid). I just happen not to live in the US. But this article reads more like a US problem.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Zambyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:07AM (#41189823)
We could also make it illegal to advertise to children at all. Wouldn't that be funny if all of us started clicking "I am below 18" :D
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mattacular on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:48AM (#41190026)
Dream bigger? We could make it illegal to advertise period.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by hn72774 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:53AM (#41190052)
Tax ad revenue as a vice like at alcohol and tobacco levels, or higher.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by guerrilla on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:02AM (#41190116)
It's not an abused substance, it's violence.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by spunker540 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:54AM (#41190512)
You do a disservice to anyone actually exposed to real violence. I’m sure they’d prefer advertising to violence any day
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ssklash on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:48AM (#41192822)
Maybe not violence, but what word more accurately describes the non-consensual exploitation of human psychology for massive profit?
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Nasrudith on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:43PM (#41194838)
Fraud is closer but still a massive reach.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by kelnos on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:35PM (#41195338)
IMO advertising is worse than fraud. At least with fraud the impact is usually fairly clear, and not buried in our broken, manipulated, subconscious minds.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by johnnyanmac on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:10PM (#41197374)
We know so little about out subconscious that this simply seems alarmist. Maybe TV really does rot our brain, maybe it's better to answer kids's questions about everything and expose them to it rather than set age restrictions.

Until some substantial info of our brains occur, I can't say the ability to make people aware of products is worse than fraud.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ssklash on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:10AM (#41198937)
If all ads did was make you aware of products, we would not be having this discussion. They attempt to hijack deep-seated human urges and tenancies in order to get you to buy their crap. Watch any perfume or cologne commercial and tell me they are simply making you aware that the product exists.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by immibis on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:18AM (#41190235)
This is not the first time I'm hearing someone say free speech is violence, but it is the first time they actually meant it about free speech and weren't covering up something else by calling it that.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by hn72774 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:49AM (#41190477)
Not who shared that but there's a concept of non-violent communication that they may be referring to.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonviolent_Communication

Coercion -> force -> violence

Forcing ads onto kids = violence?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by codr7 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:50AM (#41190974)
From my experience, that concept is mostly used as weapon and shield by the worst kind of people, to let them get away with their manipulative bs.

Speaking clearly sometimes means saying things that are uncomfortable to hear.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by hn72774 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:22AM (#41191212)
That sounds more like gaslighting.

Non-violent communication isn't at all about manipulation. It's about discussing behaviors and their impact on the person vs attacking and defending in circles that go nowhere.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by codr7 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:27AM (#41191910)
Yeah, I get the potential, and I'm not saying it's a bad idea.

It's just that in practice I've only seen it used by morons to shut down discussions they don't feel like having.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by whythre on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:27AM (#41191913)
One can couch their words in the language of nonviolence and still be manipulative, cruel or discriminatory. It can and does act as a form of social camouflage, because humans are shitty and a method of communication will not safeguard against predators.

You can’t make people harmless, but you can force them to innovate different ways to harm others.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by codr7 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:17PM (#41195177)
Yeah, but that isn't it at all, I'm afraid.

It's much darker.

The fact is that exactly the same people who are pushing the idea, are the ones who we would need protection from. And they're not innovating much, it's the same bs over and over and over again.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by comfysocks on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:20PM (#41195783)
I don’t think the dynamic you are talking about has much to do with Rosenberg’s Nonviolent Communication.

Perhaps a slightly reductive view, but I see “NVC” as basically saying that when people argue, emotions can sometimes overrule logic.

When people get emotional, they sometimes plug their ears and start screaming into the void.

NVC is then basically a bunch of tactics to circumvent the emotional aspect so that the discussion can get back to logical facts.

It also tries to create a framework where the people arguing have to hear the other side’s arguments before making a counter argument.

I think the book has some very useful ideas mixed in with some amount of self-promotion. I think the name “Nonviolent Communication” (which might throw some people off) is part of that self-promotion. Don’t let the name fool you.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by codr7 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:08PM (#41196848)
I don't think eliminating emotions from human interaction is a very smart thing to do, and certainly not the only alternative to screaming into the void.

We're already at the point where we're almost not supposed to have emotions anymore, turning more into robots every day.

Every single aspect of being human is emotional, every single decision you make is emotional, no matter how hard you work to justify it mentally.

The idea is nice in theory, if it wasn't for all the humans involved it might actually work.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by guerrilla on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:33AM (#41191976)
Exactly this.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Y_Y on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:58AM (#41190542)
Why is free speech free? If you think people (and by extension business) should be allowed to express themselves that's one thing, but advertising is disgustingly district from that. It's protected speech in most of the anglosphere to say you don't like some person or group, but not to maliciously damage someone's reputation or incite hatred. I can imagine an analogous situation where you're free to express that you think your product is good, but not to incite irrational desire in consumers or try so place information about your product in places that are difficult to avoid, like public billboards.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by CuriousSkeptic on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:31AM (#41191963)
On free speech vs violent acts of speech (if we want to keep using that term)

A possible compromise that might work is to protect _good faith_ speech while working against bad faith speech.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by smcin on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:42AM (#41192072)
Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff have been attacking that trope as factually incorrect and unhelpful for almost a decade now:

"Why It's a Bad Idea to Tell Students Words Are Violence : A claim increasingly heard on campus will make them more anxious and more willing to justify physical harm." (2017)

https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/07/why-it...

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by snapcaster on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:42AM (#41191398)
I hate ads, but this is not a winning argument. Instead of winning people over to the sympathetic cause (nobody really LIKES ads besides google and meta employees) you alienate people
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:15AM (#41192423)
Ads can be likeable under the right conditions. Who doesn't want to learn about something that will actually improve their life? Which is also ideal for advertisers. Who wants to pay to advertise to an audience that doesn't want their product?

Google and Facebook, in the early days, thought they could use copious amounts of data to tailor the ads to the user such that they would only be subjected to those which are likeable, but then the audience got skittish about having that much information collected on them. And so we now just get whatever random ad happens to be in the queue – which, indeed, is statistically unlikely to be in line with what you actually need, and therefore unlikable.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by BriggyDwiggs42 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:22PM (#41193223)
There’s a subtle error in your beliefs about the motivations of FB and Google. They are incentivized not to give users useful ads, but effective ones. The goal isn’t to improve your life. For example, something you buy because its marketed very well, but then never use, is a success for FB or Google and a loss for you. You should frame them less positively as a consequence. I also want to point out that it’s not skittishness; skittishness implies animalistic irrationality. People are right to be afraid of the control that a powerful actor can exert over them if it knows everything they do.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:50PM (#41193589)
Even if it's something you want, if there is competition in the space, then since Internet ads work on a real-time auction system, you can expect that the winning bidder is the entity that has the most available margin to make. i.e. it is the worst possible deal for you the customer. So e.g. when you search for something on Amazon and see sponsored results, you can expect that those are the worst possible deal.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:46PM (#41193546)
Nobody would buy something without an understanding of it being beneficial.

I'll grant you that understandings can be faulty. One may learn that there was no benefit. But that's outside of the ad itself. Invalidating your hypotheseses is an important part of the scientific method.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:53PM (#41193619)
Explain sugar cereals, soda, cigarettes, alcohol, drugs, gambling, etc.

The advertisements create the misunderstanding. "Lucky Charms are part of a complete breakfast" etc. No normal person under normal circumstances would think that marshmallows or cookies are part of a healthy meal if you asked them directly to think about it.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:00PM (#41193719)
What's to explain? They feel good when consumed, and thus improve one's life, even if only for a fleeting moment.

Who is buying Lucky Charms because they find them disgusting, but somehow see them as being important? Let's be real: People only (continue to, at least – they may buy once just to try) buy Lucky Charms if they like consuming them.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by sebastiennight on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:22PM (#41194664)
> Who is buying Lucky Charms because they find them disgusting, but somehow see them as being important?

Have... you met a teenager?

I'm failing to see the point of this example, as I don't think I've never met a single person who found their first cigarette enjoyable. Is your experience that people buy their first and second pack out of enjoyment of the taste?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:36PM (#41194768)
I have never met a teenager who is concerned about eating a "whole" breakfast, no, especially if that "whole" breakfast requires eating something that is otherwise unpleasant. Even if this so-called whole breakfast was some scientific truth, proven to improve health outcomes, what teenager would care? Have... you met a teenager?

I don't really see the point of the example either, frankly, but it is what we were given. I expect the contextual parent was just desperately trying to come up with something in the absence of having something meaningful to say.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:12PM (#41195125)
The point of the example is that there are plenty of things that have no benefit at all, and in fact have obvious downsides that everyone knows about. However, there is an immense amount of marketing around those things to try to make them seem "cool" and minimize their perceived harm. People get addicted to these things, and struggle to stop consuming them even when they know they're literally dying from it.

No one in their right mind would ever give their kids Oreos for breakfast, but somehow advertisements make people feel comfortable giving them Oero O's. Any person of sound mind would say that giving that to your kids as a meal is neglect, but people do it, and it's "normal". This is the harm that marketing is capable of.

Cookies are, in fact, not a part of a complete breakfast. Evidently, you can convince people that they are by just repeating the message thousands of times to them. I don't see how the people who are involved in making those ads (or the products) can live with themselves. Convincing people to e.g. set their kids up for a life of obesity and early T2 diabetes from poor dietary habits is pure evil, and that's just one example of horrible (yet completely mundane for them) things marketers do.

Just imagine being a person who wakes up in the morning and thinks about how to best convince children to try ingesting poison[0]:

> Juul Labs, the vaping company that has long insisted it never marketed its products to teenagers, purchased ad space in its early days on numerous youth-focused websites, including those of Nickelodeon, the Cartoon Network, Seventeen magazine and educational sites for middle school and high school students, according to a lawsuit filed Wednesday by the Massachusetts attorney general.

Everyone involved in something like that should be put in prison.

[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/12/health/juul-vaping-lawsui...

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:31PM (#41195896)
> No one in their right mind would ever give their kids Oreos for breakfast

Assuming you are going to feed your children Oreos at some point, why not for breakfast?

> Cookies are, in fact, not a part of a complete breakfast.

They could be. If you are going to eat them anyway, why not at breakfast?

> Evidently, you can convince people that they are by just repeating the message thousands of times to them.

Evidently not. Remember, a "complete breakfast" refers to a specific culinary dish that consists of items like bacon, sausages, eggs, baked beans, tomatoes, mushrooms, etc.

Who eats a bowl of cookies in addition to all that? I've certainly never met such a person. I've known people who eat bowls of cookies for breakfast, indeed, but when they do that's approximately the only thing they eat, which violates what is told in the advertisement. The advertisement you point to is abundantly clear that these cookies are only to be eaten with all those other foods.

Evidently people don't pay attention to what is said and will go off and do their own thing.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:15PM (#41196375)
> Evidently people don't pay attention to what is said and will go off and do their own thing.

It's almost like that was the intention. It's weird how the ad doesn't prominently show the eggs, beans, etc. and talk about how great they are, and instead focuses on how you can totally eat cookies for breakfast!

Here's an example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YnvHUXssIAo

"Not Candy! Resees Puffs cereal!"

It is candy. Like 1/3 of the mass is added sugar, and the other 2/3 is more carbs. And what's the complete breakfast that goes with it? Two slices of white-bread toast, a glass of milk, and a glass of juice. Even the "complete" breakfast is garbage. The bowl almost certainly has more than the 1 cup serving as well.

The purpose of this commercial is not to inform you about how to use their product as part of a healthy diet (because it isn't a part of a healthy diet). It is to turn your brain off and get you to buy something that you intuitively know is not appropriate. People received the intended message.

Even if they did show their product as a small side (rather than a centerpiece) of an otherwise healthy breakfast, it's still ridiculous to suggest that you should be giving your kids candy with any regularity.

My oldest kid is 3, and I don't think she has had an Oreo. Will she before she's 18? Probably. Has she had some other treats? Sure. But it's not at all a regular thing. It's certainly not part of a daily diet.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:45PM (#41197190)
> The purpose of this commercial is not to inform you about how to use their product

Assuming we watched the same video, the purpose is to inform the offer of a solution to a problem: The problem of parents needing to rush off to work and the kids off to school, without time to prepare a proper healthy breakfast, with the kids crying "I'm hungry" yet turning their nose up at anything that might be even reasonably healthy.

Hell ya I've given my children candy for breakfast on occasion. We seem to both accept that the occasional treat is not the end of the world. Why not at breakfast? I certainly wouldn't want to make it a habit, but I can also say that from a point of relative privilege in time and resources to cater to other choices. While I think we can agree it is not ideal to turn it into a habit, I can empathize with the parent who is trying to cope with a hard situation by resorting to something that solves the immediate problem.

> ...as part of a healthy diet

While this ends up being true, does this caveat not imply that health is the only problem people face? Clearly that is not true.

> It is to turn your brain off and get you to buy something that you intuitively know is not appropriate.

Like you imply, I expect most parents have a pang of guilt when buying breakfast candy for their children, but I expect they also don't know what is a better alternative that fits within their life constraints. If you could market to them something that is at least as equally palatable to the picky child, at least as easy to prepare, and actually healthy, I bet you could destroy the cereal market overnight. But without consumers becoming aware of that better solution...

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:36PM (#41198376)
Again, this is a problem the advertisers create. My kid doesn't turn her nose up at healthy food; she asks for it. Want to know why? She doesn't know things like cereal exist. She wouldn't know to ever ask for it, much less demand it. In her mind, strawberries are a treat.

We don't eat candy for breakfast because candy is not food. Thus the issue of fighting to enforce good habits never arises. Without advertisements undermining us, the idea simply does not exist. If it ever occurred to her, it's easy to say "no, candy is not food" and we don't have a TV telling her otherwise.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:01PM (#41198467)
> My kid doesn't turn her nose up at healthy food; she asks for it.

Yeah, so did my kids at that age. In fact, if given the choice, they would choose the healthy food over the candy. Get back to us in a few years.

On that note, there is nothing to me that suggests the ad in question is even trying to convince you that your unruly 3 year old that you are rushing to get off to school is a problem. It clearly portrays older children. You appear to be the exact embodiment of the idea that ads are not likeable when they are not applicable.

What does seem applicable to your preferences is healthy food. Would you be this miffed if you were shown an ad in a similar vein about a new food product that tastes great and has proven to be healthy? Or would you be glad to learn about it?

> She doesn't know things like cereal exist.

Without some kind of advertising, she also wouldn't know anything exists – even healthy food. Seems you're trying to go down the same road as the parallel thread of "advertising is only bad if the product is bad".

Which is hard to deny on some kind of superficial level, sure, but seems to conflate a number of ideas that I'm not sure should be conflated.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by sebastiennight on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:30PM (#41198551)
I enjoyed reading your side of the argument but am less convinced with

> Without some kind of advertising, she also wouldn't know anything exists – even healthy food.

Do you actually believe that before the 1900s and the invention of advertising, nobody knew about food?

I don't see how you can make such a big claim without resorting to "well, daddy telling you to eat cucumber is a form of advertising".

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:46AM (#41198845)
> but am less convinced

Is there something we are supposed to convince you of?

> Do you actually believe that before the 1900s and the invention of advertising, nobody knew about food?

1900s? Even what is considered "modern" advertising dates back to the 17th century – i.e. the 1600s.

> I don't see how you can make such a big claim without resorting to "well, daddy telling you to eat cucumber is a form of advertising".

Okay, but unless "daddy" hales from Mesopotamia, then he didn't really stumble upon one in nature by happenstance. The rest of world only came to learn of the existence of cucumbers through advertising.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by sebastiennight on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:29PM (#41205526)
Alright, it's all good and dandy to play devil's advocate to everyone, but it would be nice if you didn't mind sharing your definition of "advertising" that dates back to the 1600s and includes "knowing about the existence of vegetables".

Just a definition would be nice. Thanks.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Monday August 12, 2024 @10:31AM (#41224816)
By the 1600s, people were letting it be known about wares they wish to sell and whatnot in newspapers; a practice that continues today. This is generally considered the birth of "modern" advertising.

If you want a definition, pick a definition – come up with something on the spot, even. It makes no difference to me.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:25PM (#41198541)
Of course she would know healthy food exists: her parents show her. That is fundamentally different from a paid message.

I don't see why you wouldn't tie those ideas. Sure, ads that remind you to do some push-ups and tell kids how cool it is to be strong would be great, but they don't exist. Talking about decent adverts might as well be talking about how "true" communism hasn't been tried. In the real world, the product generally is somewhere between unnecessary and outright bad. It's obtuse to ignore that.

One of us is talking about hypothetical ads for fantasy products. The other is talking about actual ads.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by defrost on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:34PM (#41198576)
Reading the two of you is surreal:

> Without some kind of advertising, she also wouldn't know anything exists – even healthy food.

Our family didn't see, hear, or read an advertising until myself and siblings were well into our teens .. we were all too far out from cities to get TV, the national broadcasting radio didn't carry ads, etc.

We all knew what healthy food was, the food we grew, raise, and caught. The bulk goods that were ordered.

> Sure, ads that remind you to do some push-ups would be great, but they don't exist.

Sure they do: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNjEge3Awl8 the first "ad" campaign series I saw. As a teenager.

Life without advertising is possible, even today - I principally use the internet and haven't seen an add their for decades thanks to sponser blocks and ad blocking.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:05AM (#41198678)
> The bulk goods that were ordered.

Wait. Ordered as in you shouted out into the wilderness: "Oh great vast expanse, give me rice!"

Or ordered as in, like, you contacted a business that supplies bulk goods and requested that they fulfill an order? I'm assuming this one, but how did you magically find out about this business without some kind of advertising letting its existence be known?

Hell, even if we believe the former, how did you come to learn that rice (or whatever good it is that you ordered) exists? You (or your parents, or their parents, whatever) were somehow magically born with that knowledge?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:53PM (#41198641)
> Of course she would know healthy food exists: her parents show her. That is fundamentally different from a paid message.

Advertising does not necessarily imply paid, but let's go down that road. How do you, and therefore your child, know how to obtain the food that your children eat?

In my case, I go to the grocery store. But I only know that there that grocery store to go to because they spend quite a lot of money to let it be known that they exist. And when in the grocery story, they spent quite a lot on marketing to let it be known what I can buy, healthy or otherwise.

It is advertising all the way down.

> Talking about decent adverts might as well be talking about how "true" communism hasn't been tried.

Well, of course it hasn't been tried. Communism is a work that imagines what life could be like if we achieve post-scarcity. Star-Trek is another adaptation of the same idea. Outside of science fiction, trying either at this juncture is fundamentally impossible. We have not yet succeeded in fulfilling the necessary preconditions that would allow trying.

Yes, indeed, there is hopeful progress towards that goal. We have, according to the UN, achieved post-scarcity in the area of food. It is quite possible that we will get all the way there some day. But not yet. Its time has not yet come.

So what purpose would a "Star-Trek hasn't been tried!" ad actually serve? Just to state the obvious? Perhaps you see it as some kind of gorilla marketing tactic to convince people to watch Star-Trek, or to what you really said, read about the imagined world of communism, because you find it to be entertaining and think others will too?

> One of us is talking about hypothetical ads for fantasy products. The other is talking about actual ads.

And then there is what the rest of us are talking about. What is not clear is who the second player is. Do you have a split personality, by chance?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by xigoi on Friday August 09, 2024 @02:36AM (#41199304)
> I only know that there that grocery store to go to because they spend quite a lot of money to let it be known that they exist. And when in the grocery story, they spent quite a lot on marketing to let it be known what I can buy, healthy or otherwise.

You know, there is this thing called a “map” that you can use to find places without having them advertize themselves to you. And of course grocery stores show you the food they sell, how else would they sell it?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:00AM (#41201416)
> You know, there is this thing called a “map” that you can use to find places without having them advertize themselves to you.

A blank map will reveal business destinations? Methinks you've not thought this through.

> And of course grocery stores show you the food they sell, how else would they sell it?

It is not unheard of to see counter service, with the food hidden away in the back. Presenting the food can be deferred until after the sale is made. Ordering online for pickup (or perhaps delivery, although that is less common around here) has also become quite popular, which definitely means you aren't seeing the food beforehand. Most grocery stores try to go for the wholesale experience nowadays because it is a great way to advertise the products, sure, but it is not a strict requirement. Methinks you've not thought this through.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by johnnyanmac on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:44PM (#41197562)
>Any person of sound mind would say that giving that to your kids as a meal is neglect,

it's grains either way, even if some grains have sugar on them (we have a lot of stuff with too much sugar/salt for taste or preservative purposes. Fresh food every day is sadly a luxury). This seems overly dramatic to the point of dismissing your whole point. Giving "bad breakfast cereal" is neglect? Really?

You're free to only give your kid soylent 3 times a day if you want to minmax health, but you seem to be missing a core point that humans also desire pleasurable senses.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ndriscoll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:13PM (#41198272)
I'm not sure what you mean by it's grains either way. My older kid usually asks for cottage cheese in the morning. She wouldn't know to demand cereal because we've never bought it or even gone into that aisle in the store. She's never heard of it, and advertisers don't have access to her to suggest it.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by bitbuilder on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:10PM (#41193836)
I don't think it's the random ads that bother me and others so much, those are easy to tune out. Nobody cares about billboards. Random junk ads on websites are annoying, but I don't think they're doing much societal harm.

On the contrary, it's the hyper targetting of ads, nested in content algorithmically maximixed for engagement, that I object to.

I've worked in the ad industry, so I've certainly heard and appreciate the whole "we're just educating consumers about products they might be interested in" angle. That's fine, academically speaking, if that's all advertising was. However, advertising more often than not attempts to pray on people's emotions to generate demand for a product. And when we know exactly who someone is, it's SO much easier to do that.

As a perfect example, I woke up last Saturday, started scrolling IG, and saw an ad with a photo of a miserable looking middle aged man lying in bed, asking "Are you tired of feeling like a horrible father because of your drinking problems? Try Reframe!" (No idea what the exact phrasing was, but close enough to that.)

Yes, I'd in fact had drinks with friends the night before. And yes, I'm a middle aged dad. I thought the targetting was pretty hilarious, so I laughed and shared it with my wife and friends. But also, Reframe is praying on my feelings of guilt and shame in an attempt to sell me their shitty app.

I can laugh it off, but I'm not so sure your typical teenager could.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:37PM (#41194175)
Let's assume, for the sake of discussion, that this Reframe is some miracle app that will truly do what you think it claims to. Would that not be an ideal way to get the solution into your hands if you have that problem?

You're not going to feel guilt or shame unless you already are under the understanding that you're not, in this case, being then parent you wish to become. Anyone who takes an interest in this ad will do so only because they actually want to make their life better by becoming a better parent and drinking less, and are seeking solutions to see that through.

It seems the only problem here is that the app is shitty.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by bitbuilder on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:39PM (#41194801)
That's a valid way to look at this, and I appreciate that perspective.

However, I think you may be missing the point that the advertisement is specifically meant to elicit, or create, those feelings of guilt or shame. Maybe I feel just fine about the amount I drink, but the wording of the ads subtely implied I should feel guilty about my drinking. If the question was "Do you feel like you could use help with your drinking? Then try Reframe.", then I'd agree with your point more.

But maybe a bad example, because in that case perhaps the end result of the targetted ad could in fact be a better outcome for everyone, as you point out. To pick a bit of a hyperbolic example, what if instead the ad had instead said "Tired of being the the ugliest girl in your class? Try BetterMakeup!" (with all the appropriate imagery the targetting provides). Is advertisement like that truly good for anyone but the seller?

As a bit of a side note, everyone knows ads are targetted now, so there's an implicit assumption on the viewers part that the seller must know something about them. And now advertisers are using that to their advantage.

I think the larger point though is that many of us simply do not think its ethical or healthy to give companies the tools to manipulate our emotions and tap into our insecurities in the pursuit of profit. The seller doesn't care about the buyer, they only care about convincing the buyer to buy their product, even if that means making them feel shitty about themselves.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:29PM (#41195268)
> I think you may be missing the point that the advertisement is specifically meant to elicit, or create, those feelings of guilt or shame.

I'm not sure that was missed, but, as before, you cannot elicit or create feelings where there isn't already an understanding of what the feelings reflect. The particular ad no doubt does elicit feelings in those who already see themselves as not being the parent they want to be. It's not going to elicit any particular feelings in someone who is childless, though. They lack the necessary understanding.

And if you do have concern about the way you are parenting, wouldn't you want to improve upon that?

> what if instead the ad had instead said "Tired of being the the ugliest girl in your class? Try BetterMakeup!" (with all the appropriate imagery the targetting provides). Is advertisement like that truly good for anyone but the seller?

Sure, it is also good for the person who has an understanding that they are ugly and no longer want to be, again, assuming the product works. We do again have the potential problem of where the product might not work as expected. Indeed, that can be a problem, but I'm not sure that's a problem with advertising in and of itself. We should be careful to not conflate different ideas.

On the assumption that "BetterMakeup" actually makes a person more beautiful, someone wants to become more beautiful, and the ad gave awareness to the person that there is a solution to their apparent problem, is that not a win for the consumer?

> I think the larger point though is that many of us simply do not think its ethical or healthy to give companies the tools to manipulate our emotions and tap into our insecurities in the pursuit of profit.

If all products magically solved the problems they purport to solve, would you still have the same concern? As before, trying to convince a childless person that they are a bad parent isn't going to work. This only works when you are presenting a solution to someone who already understands that they have a problem.

If the product is shitty, thereby not solving the problem, then I can definitely understand your overall concern. Although I am not sure you have made clear why advertising is to blame for shitty products. If we are imagining ways to change the world, why place product evaluation in the advertising band at all? Perhaps these shitty products don't need to be allowed on the market in the first place?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:29PM (#41195889)
> And if you do have concern about the way you are parenting, wouldn't you want to improve upon that?

> Let's assume, for the sake of discussion, that this Reframe is some miracle app that will truly do what you think it claims to.

Reading this discussion, I remain unconvinced. Unless I lost the plot somewhere along the way (admittedly, that's a possibility), it sounds like the context is that of someone advertising a product in a probably dishonest way and it's justified because people want the thing that's being advertised, even though it's not necessarily the thing that's being sold.

> Although I am not sure you have made clear why advertising is to blame for shitty products.

Put another way: what if the product in question was literally snake oil? Is that still justifiable as marketing because they're making a promise about it which someone wants to hear? Maybe it's more than just a shitty product.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:51PM (#41196112)
> I remain unconvinced.

Was there something we were supposed to convince you of?

> what if the product in question was literally snake oil? Is that still justifiable as marketing because they're making a promise about it which someone wants to hear?

The discussion is about advertising preying on insecurities, not marketing in general. If we assume snake oil were to be advertised, is there some reason to prefer: "Snake Oil: The miracle cure-all!" over "Your bad breath is scaring off the girl of your dreams. Cure it with Snake Oil!"?

If yes, why is the latter less preferable? Is it because it calls attention to a real problem someone might want to solve? Does that continue to hold if we assume snake oil truly is a miracle cure-all that eliminates bad breath?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:22PM (#41196442)
Because the advertisement inappropriately calls the product a solution to an unrelated problem. The manufacturer can demonstrate that it will eliminate my halitosis but not that it will get me laid. Using the initial example, I might be less addicted to alcohol but that doesn't necessarily make me a better parent; the advertisement sold me on being a better parent.

(I appreciate your questions. I had to think about that one.)

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:55PM (#41196752)
> Because the advertisement inappropriately calls the product a solution to an unrelated problem.

Yes, but that is true in both cases. A miracle cure-all, if there were such a thing, would, indeed, solve your halitosis and girl troubles.

If I am to infer something here, it is that you didn't realize what a "cure-all" can do. It took more precise language to get you thinking about specific problems and how to solve them.

So, let's assume for a minute that snake oil is well and truly a magical cure-all. It seems that by the first ad you wouldn't recognize that fact and would end up not being able to benefit from is miracle properties. Perhaps the second ad would actually be preferable?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:17PM (#41196946)
> Yes, but that is true in both cases.

I think I can see where you're coming from with this but it's still not how I read it. The second advertisement is telling me that the product will cure my bad breath and therefore my girl problems but my girl problems are not necessarily related to my bad breath. It's the same as the drinking father example; a person's parenting can be good or bad irrespective of their drinking habits. (Maybe it fixes my girl problems independently from curing my bad breath but the advertisement seems to be telling me that it will solve my girl problems by means of curing my bad breath. Same as the given drinking father real-world example.)

Can you think of a non-cure-all example for which this argument holds?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:15PM (#41197403)
> but it's still not how I read it.

Right. Which also demonstrates why the latter type of ad tends to be much more effective, even though both technically say the same thing.

So, it seems to me that we have two different discussions trying to compete here:

- The acceptability of false advertising.

- The acceptability of advertising that attempts to evoke emotions.

While you are not wrong in noticing that these examples also exhibit false advertising, that is staring to move away from the original discussion, which was about preying on insecurities.

> Can you think of a non-cure-all example for which this argument holds?

How about we turn to the ad that shows up on just about every HN page? It will be well-familiar to everyone here. Here are two variants on one of those ads (with a little paraphrasing on my part):

- "Rust: It will protect your memory!"

- "Still programming in C like it is 1972? The hackers are going to get you. Secure your programs with Rust!"

My understanding from earlier in the thread is that only the first example should be allowed according to the beliefs of those who participated. But, I must say, I'm far more compelled by the latter. It addresses problems I understand deep down when programming in C and then offers a solution. The "It will protect your memory" doesn't tell me much. Why do I need my memory protected? Next.

Assuming only the latter ad catches my attention, which I think is a decent assumption based on what we've seen in this very thread and around ad response behaviour in general, is it possible that the consumer actually benefits from the latter?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:33PM (#41197789)
The Rust example is categorically different from the drinking father example. The former evokes emotions around professional decisions while the latter evokes emotions around personal decisions.

The consumer may still ultimately benefit from this advertisement which evokes emotions in such a personal way, especially if we assume the efficacy of the product to be as advertised. The advertisement might also cause a mentally unhealthy individual to become worse as such. The negativity of the emotions might push someone into a worse spot or into learning self-harming or abusive behaviors.

As much as advertisers A/B test their advertisements, I don’t get the feeling they measure the effect they have on national suicide rates. Do you think they’d publish those numbers if they had them?

Admittedly, I dragged this away from OP’s point a bit but I think I brought it back. One person might laugh it off while another abuses their family. It’s really hard to say that the advertisement is not evil, even if it can be demonstrated to be a net good for some.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:52PM (#41197877)
> The former evokes emotions around professional decisions while the latter evokes emotions around personal decisions.

That there is a division between personal emotions and professional emotions is a new idea to me. What is the difference?

> It’s really hard to say that the advertisement is not evil, even if it can be demonstrated to be a net good for some.

If we assume that advertisements can be evil, how are we certain the type that doesn't go after insecurities aren't the evil ones? Like you say, there doesn't seem to be much data published to back up which and which ads aren't evil.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:55PM (#41198176)
> What is the difference?

The emotions are all personal but some topics evoke emotions of lesser or greater intensity than others; the topic of one’s parenting will likely be more emotionally intense than the topic of their tech stack at work. Most people in relevant situations will be far more invested in the former than the latter.

> If we assume that advertisements can be evil, how are we certain the type that doesn't go after insecurities aren't the evil ones? Like you say, there doesn't seem to be much data published to back up which and which ads aren't evil.

It’s a personal belief that this behavior is evil; indeed, that seems a necessary component of calling anything evil. I also wouldn’t distinguish between advertisements which play on emotions and those which don’t -- they all play on emotions. The important distinction for me is in the specific topic being exploited. (There was also the distraction I brought up of false advertising but I think that’s more uncontroversially “evil”.)

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by randomdata on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:33PM (#41198364)
> the topic of one’s parenting will likely be less emotionally intense than the topic of their tech stack at work. Most people in relevant situations will be far more invested in the former than the latter.

Where does "Are you tired of feeling like a horrible father because you are spending more time tracking down error cases you forgot to handle than with your children? Try Rust!" fall?

> I also wouldn’t distinguish between advertisements which play on emotions and those which don’t -- they all play on emotions.

You kind of have to distinguish between them in order to meaningfully participate in this discussion. That there is no difference follows my point made initially, so I can certainly appreciate your position in a vacuum, but we moved long past that to explore the idea that there is a difference. If you cannot speak to a difference then there is only nonsense.

Perhaps I misunderstand?

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by johnnyanmac on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:52PM (#41197602)
>Would that not be an ideal way to get the solution into your hands if you have that problem?

I think that's where the algorithm matters more than the ad. e.g. if it was some random traveling saelesman going door to door and they researched this neighborhood having 30 year old dads, it wouldn't feel that bad to happen upon a convinient solution.

When you know some company sold your data (with dubious consent) to a bidder who can then pay another company who has your data to say "yeah, give this ad to 30 year old dads", then start starts to feel overly invasive. Not because the product is bad per se, but because two different conglomerations exploited your data.

and for the absurd, "optimal" solution: if this company had government surveillance about your private life up to your recent daily activity, and used that to directly text your spouse or older kid about how your spouse/dad needs this to get over his drinking problem, that'd go way over the line.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by kelnos on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:38PM (#41195367)
> Who doesn't want to learn about something that will actually improve their life?

I don't, honestly. If I've decided I want something, I'll seek it out. If I've identified an area where I feel like my life is lacking, I might look for a product to help fix that. If I don't even know about something that I might want, I'm fine not having it.

The problem is that I don't really trust anyone else to determine what kind of ad passes the test of "will improve people's lives". There's really no objective way to approve or reject an ad based on this kind of criterion.

I'd rather we just ban all forms of advertising.

> Google and Facebook, in the early days, thought they could use copious amounts of data to tailor the ads to the user such that they would only be subjected to those which are likeable

No, they wanted to give people ads they thought would be effective. Google's plan was to make ads unobtrusive, mostly text-only, and thought that they would be likeable enough to be effective. But that's the key: they didn't do this because they were being nice and wanted to make the web a better place. They did it because they thought the ads would actually work better.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by johnnyanmac on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:24PM (#41197460)
>If I've decided I want something, I'll seek it out.

you dont know what you don't know. I wouldn't have even been aware of tech if I didn't randomly bumble into a robotics club in high school. Would I have been fine likely making much less in a field I'm less paasoinate about? Maybe, but that seems to be a big sacrifice just so your life is "ad-free" (an odd ideal, if possible at all).

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:48AM (#41201327)
the advertiser also doesn’t know what they don’t know.

if you hadn’t joined the robotics club, chances are very high you would tripped over robotics on your way off of the stage when graduating. it’s that prevalent these days. if not then you would’ve seen one of the many youtube videos convincing you to join some company. had you seen an ad for robot building school, most would consider it a scam and move on.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by sithlord on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:59AM (#41191604)
I would hazard a guess that no one likes ads except the likes of google and meta SHAREHOLDERS).
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by brigadier132 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:17AM (#41191800)
I was incredulous but many normal people actually enjoy ads.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ssklash on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:46AM (#41192791)
Many people have also never experienced a world where ads do not exist. I use so many layers of adblocking that whenever I use a vanilla VM or devices, I'm stunned at how shockingly bad the internet experience is for most people.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by dwayne_dibley on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:00AM (#41192254)
I mean they can often be useful.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ajsnigrutin on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:17AM (#41192439)
Limit advertising budgets to some percentage of reported (and taxed) income.

Solve multiple problems at once :)

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by briandear on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:18PM (#41193183)
So the big companies can spend more and the startups wouldn’t be able to advertise at all. That’s not solving anything.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by sham1 on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:16AM (#41199487)
Those sorts of taxes could be made progressive. And if one wanted to be really cheeky, the progression could be based on percentages of global revenue.

Ads really are a negative externality, and they should really be treated as such.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:43AM (#41201298)
take a complex solution that doesn’t actually solve the problem and make it more complex so then it solves it, yet still doesn’t.

a less complex solution, let companies like apple do what they do and allow ad blockers and develop an AI feature for removing them.

people still seeing ads these days are doing so by choice.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ajsnigrutin on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:33PM (#41206510)
> people still seeing ads these days are doing so by choice.

Hey, you might not know, but there exists this place called "the outside", where there are no adblockers, no AI, but A LOT of ads.

Severly limiting ads would solve that too. Adblocks wouldn't.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by tekknik on Sunday August 11, 2024 @08:59AM (#41215831)
nobody is forcing you to look at anything. unless you’re in Asia, the rest of the world has what, a billboard occasionally?
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by FridayoLeary on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:29AM (#41191926)
That is overly simplistic. Advertising is a great way to make people aware of things they may find useful. Without a good method to spread the news no one could sell their innovations.

But i do agree that most ads are annoying.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by briandear on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:18PM (#41193173)
A ridiculous concept — the only people that win in that are the incumbent producers.

“I make a better widget at a lower price than BigCorp” — yet nobody will ever find out about it because advertising that fact would be illegal. Journalists would become supremely powerful and (more) supremely corrupt. Just like radio DJs in the 20th century determined what music sold (and were often bribed accordingly,) the same thing will happen for literally everything. Journalism would become even more like advertising but people wouldn’t be able to tell the difference. I don’t want the equivalent of radio DJs determining what products and services win.

Many professional sports would disappear, Motorsports, soccer, many olympic sports would cease to exist at the highest level. The Olympics themselves would no longer be broadcast (who would pay for it?) Kid’s little league teams would lose local business sponsors. Everything would be pay-per-view assuming the economics worked at all. Newspapers would all shut down. TV stations would disappear. Radio would be limited to small amateur stations — if that because the moment the host mentions a product, service, song, they’d be sued (wrongly or rightly) for potentially advertising. New restaurants would never survive (how will anyone know you exist: Signage and logos are all advertising.)

Basically it would be North Korea with people shopping for inferior state-produced goods at inferior state run supermarkets reading state-approved messages about the greatness of the Dear Leader and his progeny.

Even word of mouth referrals would be subject to lawsuits “can you prove you didn’t get a free cookie in exchange for saying something to your friends about this bakery?”

An absolutely dystopian nightmare.

And if there were an advertising ban, you can bet politicians would exempt themselves from such a ban.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Terr_ on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:38PM (#41194183)
There may be some more-creative options out there too.

For example, in Washington State there isn't a blanket prohibition on signs advertising to people on the highway, but anything advertised must be available for purchase on the property. So far, that's been enough to curb companies from lining the highways with walls of giant billboards.

So--just spitballing here--imagine if people had a legal right to use and sell software that blocks ads or objectionable material from their view or on devices they own, and how that could lead to ad-ecosystem changes.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mrguyorama on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:01PM (#41194428)
Or you can do like a few different states have done and just fucking ban billboards, and the world doesn't end, and the economy doesn't crash, and the world is an explicitly better place.

So much stupid nonsense just to not make the world a better place and I don't understand it. You don't need to be creative.

Speaking of which, at this point it's only a matter of time before some big name attempts to put a satellite in orbit that is also a billboard, so you can ALWAYS see their advertising in the nights sky, because it is not currently being used for advertising so, you know, they want to fix that. If we don't ban it now, we WILL have our night sky blocked out by advertising at some point. Companies already use big drone displays to do this.

And I guarantee you people will insist "It's not a big deal, we need advertising, we don't need to block all of it"

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Terr_ on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:07PM (#41198239)
> Or you can [...] just fucking ban billboards

I feel this "just do X" formula is doing an awful lot of heavy lifting. Will you force most gas stations dismantle their price-signs? Will "garage sale here" signs become illegal? What zones are or aren't covered?

Vehemence is unfortunately not a substitute for planning or clear rules.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mrguyorama on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:47PM (#41203922)
And yet several states have done "just" that! You don't even have to figure anything out yourself, you can just copy their frameworks!

Why are you so insistent on this? We figured it out decades ago! Don't make up BS reasons to avoid reality, just go read the existing rules.

https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/23/title23sec1908.htm... Click the buttons at the top of the page to navigate this section of law.

Maine has had this all on the internet since the 90s. It's a solved problem.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by kelnos on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:32PM (#41195307)
That really is my dream. Advertising is a blight on humanity.

Of course, this would break capitalism. We live in a society where the foundation of the economy requires that people keep buying things, even things they don't really need and don't really want.

I happen to think breaking capitalism a bit could be a good thing, but it would likely also cause a period of economic instability that would crush people who are marginal financially.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mhx1138 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:04AM (#41191080)
We could make it illegal for minors to use the internet at all. It is too dangerous. Similar to driving. That would solve so many current problems.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Zambyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:31AM (#41191289)
I think it's more interesting when you scope it to mass media system. I think kids using the internet to communicate directly with their peers and family makes a lot of sense. Kids consuming an infinite amount of media and trying to broadcast themselves to the whole world is very often unhealthy.

I think this is also true if adults, but I think kids are particularly susceptible to unhealthy habits / addictions around mass media systems.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by cacois on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:21AM (#41191836)
Respectfully disagree - their peers often make an unhealthy environment on the internet. Kids need in-person communication and interactions, its necessary for healthy development. The internet looks like it provides social interaction, but it actually does not provide what kids need. They should interact with their peers elsewhere, synchronously.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by fwip on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:22AM (#41192499)
I feel like interacting with a moderate-sized set of real peers is workable - like chat rooms on AIM with the kids you know from school. Kids have always had unsupervised time with their peers.

Where it breaks down, is when you get a whole ecosystem populated entirely by kids and those trying to make money off of them.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by mrguyorama on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:09PM (#41194513)
No, most of the problem with internet interaction is how the human brain considers the username saying things to you on AIM is NOT the same as the dude you hang out with every day in real life, and more importantly, the usernames you don't know in real life are just vague spirits your brain is much more willing to demonize. This exact same effect is the main cause of roadrage and why everyone is such an asshole when you put them in steel boxes and have them interact on the road.

It is NOT SOCIALIZATION to talk to people on the internet. Your brain simply does not treat it the same way.

Kids are fine interacting in person at school and other public places. They don't need this social media bullshit, and even private messaging systems like AIM or MSN aren't really that great.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by cacois on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @01:50PM (#41248709)
I agree that AIM was fine. Not as good as in-person interaction, and no real substitute for it, but as an augmentation it caused no real harm. Chatrooms could be in the same boat, but had more problems.

However, social media ever since feeds and the "like" button are an entirely different beast which is addicting, dehumanizing, and antisocial - preventing kids from developing socially.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Nasrudith on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:48PM (#41194880)
Are you joking? Peer communication is the most toxic, Lord Of The Flies things there is. Notice how much office politics is high school bullshit? That is what happens when you have norms set by an isolated incestuous prison-mimicking subset of society cut off from experience and wisdom.

Consuming an infinite amount of media is positively wholesome by comparison.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by Zambyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:59PM (#41194987)
Your high school and work experience sounds completely different from mine. I grew up in a very rural area. My options outside of school and sports (both not accounting for the whole year for me) were to talk to my friends on the internet, talk to strangers on the internet, consume infinite media from the internet, or isolating myself. I spend a very large portion of my free time either talking to my friends, or talking to strangers and my friends at the same time. I don't think you'll be able to convince me that I would have been better off choosing any other options.

As for work, I have had a hard time leaving jobs, because to me that also means leaving the people I work with. I guess my office life is similar to my high school life in the sense that I actually like(d) the people around me.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by brightlancer on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:29AM (#41192588)
In the US, minors can get a driver's license at 16 in most places, and at 15 in a few I've seen.

And a person of any age can drive a car on private property.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by novia on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:56PM (#41194958)
People at age 12, maybe even age 10, are ready to use the internet.

This might be an unpopular take, but I remember being that age and having to jump through so many hoops to access the sites I wanted to access, and I swore to myself I would defend children's right to exist online. I'm 35 now. My opinion hasn't changed.

The regulations ask websites not to target advertising to children. Websites don't like that because advertising is their main means of profiting or breaking even, so they try to pull their site offline for minors, and limit their ability to communicate with others. COPPA doesn't require that you limit the ability for minors to communicate with others, but websites err on the side of caution because of the very real threat of pedophiles.

Children age 12-ish are bored out of their minds, and a lot of them are really smart and would contribute to the internet in a positive way. See the story of Aaron Swartz. He contributed so much to open software before he was even 16.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by the1thatgb on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:20AM (#41191830)
There should be operating systems just for minkrs that are devoid of tracking and using software for kids like the kiddle search engine and social media for kids (not the one we all know of)
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by rolph on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:32AM (#41192624)
the number of websites that would complain such OS and browser is unsupported, is skyrocketing. thats a blight that requires mitigation any time soon.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by maeil on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:03AM (#41192282)
This is already the case for e.g. gambling ads in certain countries. Recently I saw the first website that was basically begging the user to "please be honest" on the age popup, indicating a good number of people have caught on to just clicking "under 21". Of course I still clicked "under 21".
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by quotemstr on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:56AM (#41191567)
Heaven forbid someone being shown ads for things that interest him. All this hand-wringing about privacy seems to me to be producing a lot of noise for minimal practical benefit. I don't see harms in ad targeting.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by consteval on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:06AM (#41191694)
The harms, in my opinion, is that hyper-consumerism is an addiction. These methods are intended as a way to get impressionable and vulnerable groups hooked on various products, for the benefit of the manufacturer.

Children cannot make good decisions (generally) and they often have poor impulse control. Building the habit of spending money on random sparkly shit they don't need ensure that, as adults, they will be good consumers. And by that I mean materialistic and poorer than they have to be.

It's no surprise that these ads play into the most intrinsic human emotions for manipulation. They target social status, perception of self, pleasure. I see it as no different than sparkling lights on a slot machine. A way to manipulate the mind and build a money-burning addiction.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by burningChrome on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:52AM (#41192170)
This sounds eerily familiar with how big tobacco targeted underage kids to get them hooked on their products in the 60's and 70's.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by supertofu on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:07AM (#41192325)
You don't even have to go that far back. Remember Juul in the 2010s?
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by radicaldreamer on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:54PM (#41194328)
Juul sent representatives to schools who told kids that Juuls weren’t addictive.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/25/health/juul-teens-vaping....

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:50PM (#41195477)
> sent representatives to schools

This seems like something that should need to be positively justified by the organization which wants to send salespeo^W representatives to schools, in a way that is publicly auditable.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by burningChrome on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:27PM (#41195858)
I remember a ton of vaping threads extoling the idea vaping was totally safe on Reddit. When people brought up the possible negative side effects of vaping they were routinely downvoted into oblivion. Nobody wanted to believe vaping was dangerous are could have harmful side effects.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by 325125 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:57PM (#41198185)
What are the harmful side effects if you don't have a preexisting health condition?
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by drekk on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:29AM (#41199019)
Besides a crippling nicotine addiction?
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by carlmr on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:18AM (#41199498)
We don't know yet. But besides the nicotine addiction, there are other components in the vapor which we have no long-term data on, because it's just so new. But we know that there are components in the vapor that are harmful to your health, and nicotine itself is cardiotoxic, so there's that [1].

We do however have studies showing that vaping can be implicated in lung cancer [2].

[1] https://www.moffitt.org/cancers/lung-cancer/faqs/lung-cancer... [2] https://www.news-medical.net/news/20240520/Study-reveals-inc...

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by supertofu on Friday August 09, 2024 @11:00AM (#41202516)
I can only answer anecdotally from my personal experience but: frequent coughing while not vaping, chest pain, very obviously reduced cardiovascular capacity and increased fatigue during my workouts.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by valianteffort on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:31PM (#41211669)
Your body has no mechanism for purging oil residue from your lungs. The frequency at which vape users would be flooding their lungs with those vaporized oils was akin to someone starting out as a pack a day heavy smoker.

Tar as I understand it does break down very slowly over time but many smoke at a greater rate than it can be broken down and smoke itself is a worse irritant than oil vapor.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by TremendousJudge on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:25AM (#41192535)
Tobacco companies have always targeted kids. In the early 20th century most baseball cards were produced by sweets and tobacco manufacturers
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by bryan_w on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:33PM (#41197501)
Howso? This seems like a separate situation than the one you mentioned.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by ProllyInfamous on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:26PM (#41203284)
I remember from my 80's/90's childhood candy cigarettes [essentially sugar compressed into long cylinders]... just the other day, at a Southern US sporting goods store, I saw "Big Chew Gum," which had a baseball player with a wad of tobacco ("gum") in his mouth.

Thought this was strange, as chewing tobacco is probably more addictive than cigarettes, and the gum's packaging was clearly set at child-height.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by belter on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:37PM (#41193424)
Looking at the stories here in the last two days, lots in HN are more worried with the location of Twitter headquarters...( Will never mention that letter...)
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by johnnyanmac on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:52PM (#41194315)
Don't want to go too off topic, but I legitmately don't understand the fuss. It went from California to California. If there's any forced moves to SoCal, my condolances, but I didn't get that vibe from that thread that there were a bunch of disgruntled workers.

Are people still that interested in trying to join Twitter c. 2024? I'm desperate enough in terms of money to accept if I was just handed an offer, but I sure as hell am not doing anything more than 2 interviews before my interest nosedives.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by fragmede on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:30PM (#41194720)
For all the speculation about the move, the reason is simple. Twitter is going to launch a payments system, San Francisco has a tax on gross receipts, which is so unfair to payments processing companies that several others - square, stripe, and block - moved out of SF to avoid paying that tax, and Twitter is simply following suite. it's too inside baseball for the average reader to follow, so we're left with baseless speculation and conspiracy theories on why they're moving HQ when it's a subplot business decision that has made made by others already.
Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:19PM (#41196419)
> we're left with baseless speculation and conspiracy theories on why they're moving

Sounds like Elon, so it's on-brand.

Re:Google and Meta struck secret ads deal to target teenagers by choppaface on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:17PM (#41194603)
Google has yet to experience significant penalties due to their Jedi Blue price-fixing scheme ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jedi_Blue ). Perhaps this story covers some other set of claims that will be broken out of the larger Jedi Blue case.

Edit: this is actually a recent campaign, the story says 2023 but some other outlets said it executed this year in 2024.

After all, Google fought very hard and farted out a cashier's check to the US Gov to avoid a jury trial in one of their ad monopoly cases https://apnews.com/article/google-antitrust-ad-tech-virginia...