No, you didn't. You just said everything I said is blatantly false, which I find laughable, considering you (again) provided no arguments to defend your position.
> False. Wealth inequality, corruption and meddling between entities in power, and the destruction of the environment have happened, and are happening, in every country on earth. Your statement is objectively false.
You are blatantly wrong. My statement that Google and Meta came to exist and became what they are under capitalism is 100% objectively true. Or do you claim the story of their existence is a success story of socialism?
> So then what's the system you're going to replace "capitalism" with after you "dismantle it"?
It's called socialism, it has many flavors, look it up. It also already exists.
> I've repeated this several times, and it continues to be true: this is not unique to capitalism, and happens under every economic system.
False. It happens at this scale only under capitalism.
> I am well aware of the faults of the US's economic system (look, I can actually be precise with my terms, and avoid vague terms like "capitalism", that isn't so hard, is it?)
The US economic system is a raging libertarianism-type capitalism, unrestrained by checks and balances, due to the line of policies introduced by Raegan. This has been a process that has progressed till today, hence the huge income and social inequality that we see in the US, much bigger than it was when Raegan become president. It's simply the predictable trajectory of all capitalist countries, they reach the boiling point of inequality and discontent, and then there is a revolution.
> "Social democracies" - socialism - is a transitionary stage towards communism, one of the most evil ideologies known to man.
You are thinking of capitalism, which IS the most evil ideology known to man, as it's all about growing mindlessly like a tumor, and destroying everything in its path. Luckily, it can't contain itself, as the people who actually do the work eventually get pissed off at the rich rent-seekers, and stop working for them, or worse.
> Which is solely the fault of elected representatives that aren't being held to account by their constituents - and, as stated before, this is not unique to capitalism - this meddling happens in every economic system between different people and organizations in positions of power
What IS unique to capitalism, is the disproportionate amount of influence money have on the politics and on power, and how much corporations meddle in politics, with lobbyism, with pressuring the EPA, and with throwing their support under presidential candidates, making pawns of our elected officials.
> Excesses of it are clearly due to corruption in the government that does regulation. And, as I've stated earlier, this is not unique to capitalism. Wealth and power inequality happen in every economic system.
Blatantly wrong. There is certainly corruption in the government, but the reason for the huge disparity in income is that the system of capitalism is structured like that. This is a known and predictable behavior of unchecked capitalism, and is described by Marx. This is a fact.
> This is simultaneously both extremely condescending and ignorant. Late capitalism does not exist. It is an activist term and fictional construct.
Don't get all Jordan Peterson-like, please. Arguments like: "what even is climate?" or "it's a model/theory and thus it can tell us nothing about the world" are laughable. We use words and constructs to describe things, and economists of the past thought how to describe the capitalism of the future, and called it "late capitalism".
It's similar to calling the Republicans "right-wing", another concept.
The GDP is also a fictional (and useless/harmful) construct but we use it all the time and pretend it matters.
An even more harmful made-up-construct is the "invisible hand of the market", a half-baked theory popularized by Adam Smith which economists base their growth fetishes and deregulation wet dreams on.
All those concepts are made by people to describe something or another. That's how words work.
Once again, here is the link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_capitalism describing how the stage of capitalism we are in atm is "late capitalism".
"Late Capitalism", that's the term that's used for what you experience now in the US and the UK: concentration of wealth in the 1%'s hands, and a growing discontent.
If you don't like the term, feel free to use other names for it, like neo-capitalism, but the rest of us know it for what it is and will continue calling it so. Beause that's how it's called (it even has a wiki page). And that's a fact.
> It's called socialism, it has many flavors, look it up
At this point, combined with other comments like:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41207990
> I am not a proponent for communism, dunno where you got that from. Maybe try to understand other people's point before emotionally pleading against them yourself.
> Says who, you?
> Stop simping for capitalism, it isn't working
...it's extremely clear that you're not interested in debate, but in pushing an ideology, using whatever fallacies and redefinitions you need to in order to convince people. I have no obligation to respond to you, nor will it be productive, as you cannot change the mind of someone holding onto an ideology religiously like this.
> Yes, I did:
> "> However, in the stage of capitalism we are currently in" was disproven by "this phenomenon isn't specific to capitalism, and outright false to claim that it wouldn't happen in any other economic system."
> "> Capitalism at its current stage is just a giant fire-sale" was disproven by "there's no "at its current stage"" and "This is bad actors, which have always existed, and always will continue to exist, that are now less checked than usual because of regulatory failure."
Neither of those proved anything; they're just assertions.
Reading some of your other comments, it's hard to think you're unaware of the difference. So what's this? Doesn't look all that much like arguing in good faith.
2) And no, pointing out flawed logic in an argument is not a "personal attack".
3) My interests and motivations don't affect the validity of my arguments. I just said that assertions aren't proofs (here), and that working for a particular employer is a choice, not mandatory (elsewhere, at your link above). Hitler could say either of those, and it would still be correct. So could Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Emperor Bokassa, Donald Trump, Joe Biden, or Churchill. See how it has nothing to do with ideology?
4) What you claim are "proofs" are still just assertions, and working for a particular employer is still a choice. You were wrong, that is all.
___
[1]: I think I've replied to you exactly twice before, and you posted this exact same (apart from the link) response to both. Since what you're saying is either "you attacked me elsewhere, and then followed me here!" or "you attacked me here, and then followed me elsewhere!", it's confusing as Hell. Which is supposed to be "elsewhere", and which "here"? It even took me a while to realise both links were valid, and not some weird loop... (I was beginning to speculate whether Dan G had moved one sub-thread or both into some offshoot. That is, after I realised they are two separate sub-threads in the first place.)
Yes, I did:
"> However, in the stage of capitalism we are currently in" was disproven by "this phenomenon isn't specific to capitalism, and outright false to claim that it wouldn't happen in any other economic system."
"> Capitalism at its current stage is just a giant fire-sale" was disproven by "there's no "at its current stage"" and "This is bad actors, which have always existed, and always will continue to exist, that are now less checked than usual because of regulatory failure."
> I am not a proponent for communism
So then what's the system you're going to replace "capitalism" with after you "dismantle it"? There's basically no other answer except communism. Socialism is a special case and explicitly a transitional stage used by communists to institute it.
> Maybe try to understand other people's point before emotionally pleading against them yourself.
You didn't provide any serious arguments or details to argue against. I countered all of your points to the level of fidelity possible given the lack of details and reason.
> The term for the stage of capitalism our societies right now is: "late capitalism", or "late stage capitalism". It's blatantly obvious you don't know or you don't want to know about this, but there are many of us who do. There is a link, educate yourself (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_capitalism)
This is simultaneously both extremely condescending and ignorant. Late capitalism does not exist. It is an activist term and fictional construct, invented by a Marxist and used by Marxists to advance a political agenda. There is no "education" to have, because you cannot "educate" yourself about an activist concept that has no concrete definition, scientific test, or acceptance in the boarder field that it claims to be a part of.
> capitalism comes with humongous wealth inequality
Yes, some amount of wealth inequality is expected and good. Excesses of it are clearly due to corruption in the government that does regulation. And, as I've stated earlier, this is not unique to capitalism. Wealth and power inequality happen in every economic system.
> increased corporation meddling in politics
Which is solely the fault of elected representatives that aren't being held to account by their constituents - and, as stated before, this is not unique to capitalism - this meddling happens in every economic system between different people and organizations in positions of power.
> an ever increasing of destruction of natural habitat and poisoning of people and nature alike
...and again, this is the fault of elected representatives part of whose jobs are to literally force individuals and corporations to account for externalities. This also isn't unique to corporations - individuals also take advantage of negative externalities. This also isn't unique to capitalism, and happens with every economic system.
You've spouted statistics that you don't understand, that aren't unique to capitalism, and that are exclusively limited to the US and/or CA and do not generalize to the rest of the world.
> These things didn't happen under some different order, they happened under capitalism
False. Wealth inequality, corruption and meddling between entities in power, and the destruction of the environment have happened, and are happening, in every country on earth. Your statement is objectively false.
> it all started to change from when Thatcher and Raegan started dismantling government guardrails on the market, unleashing the destructive form of capitalism that we have today
Citation needed. Wikipedia articles don't count. Also, you never provided a definition of "this form of capitalism". You are actively making it more difficult to have a productive discussion by avoiding providing definitions or details for anything you say.
> I've seen and lived in enough countries to know that countries that are social democracies
"Social democracies" - socialism - is a transitionary stage towards communism, one of the most evil ideologies known to man.
> population happiness, health, longevity, worker rights, and freedoms
(1) all of the countries at the top of the HDI report are tiny compared to the US, with radically different cultures and fiscal situations, rendering a comparison without controlling for those factors utterly irrelevant. People who travel are aware of these differences. (2) "worker rights" is incredibly subjective and impossible to measure objectively, especially when socialists are doing the measurement, (3) the US is, by most measures, far more free than most of these countries (4) "longevity" also has cultural and biological factors that are utterly unrelated to economic system.
> Stop simping for capitalism
I'm defending my arguments with reason, not the one simping for socialism by spraying Wikipedia links without any understanding of what they actually say or the (lack of) evidence that supports them.
I am well aware of the faults of the US's economic system (look, I can actually be precise with my terms, and avoid vague terms like "capitalism", that isn't so hard, is it?), and actively work to fix those, because I'm aware of the horrible atrocities that happen under communism.
> the tech giants have repeatedly broken regulation after regulation, have gotten fine after fine, but they continue so because they can afford to do so, and this all happened under capitalism, which allowed them to grow to the monstrosities that they are today
I've repeated this several times, and it continues to be true: this is not unique to capitalism, and happens under every economic system. This, objectively, is not unique to capitalism. This is a fact.