Calling it 'The Problem' like climate change or the national debt gives it too much power. Just use something else. People use group chats for real relationships now anyway.
So in practice you have to make choices, or you'll end up running the new 4chan and being sad about your life. As happened to the guy who ran the old 4chan: https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/4chans...
The ideal, platonic version of this would be that moderators only see an "identity scrambled" version of each tweet/post when they make their moderation decision. Like a screen that blinds orchestra musicians when they audition, the human would see a statement like "I hate New Yorkers" and not know if the original message said "I hate New Yorkers" or "I hate Floridians." So they would have to make a decision based on the general principle of whether a statement of this form is allowable.
Anywhere you want to draw the line is fine with me, as long as you draw it consistently.
Take the use of reclaimed slurs, for example. When used against the discriminated group by a dominant group, their intention is often to cause harm. When used within the group, the intention is to reappropriate the term: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reappropriation
Similarly, harassers will use terms in ways that are plausibly read different ways depending on who they're talking to. So something that might sound innocuous or just odd when directed at me will be correctly read as a racist attack when directed at somebody else.
And that's not even counting when they'll just come up with new terms so they can be awful in ways that are novel enough that automated filters or out-of-date moderators won't catch. E.g.: https://www.vice.com/en/article/bv88a5/white-supremacists-ha...
In short, because there's a great deal of identity-based hate in the world, identity-blind moderation ends up being an aid to the identity haters out there.
That this moderation strategy would prevent the use of all slurs (even reappropriated ones) sounds like a feature to me, not a bug.
You're proposing erring on the side of censorship to avoid some gray areas. While this is a reasonable position, it doesn't satisfy some ideal of neutrality and won't really avoid the gray areas, and so still would require subjective judgement.
In practice, almost any nominally "neutral" position ends up allowing an enormous amount of abuse. Which is why you'll see most platforms that start with a free-speech maximalism approach coming up with a lot of nuance and exceptions over time. And those that don't turn into cesspools.
Most people are pretty great, but moderation has to be built for the worst-case attacker.
Which is ultimately what I object to.
Moderation is full of gray areas, and they are unavoidable.
What we have now is a system where, on many platforms, moderators often put their thumbs on the scale and decide that certain groups need more protection than others. Generalizing about or disparaging certain groups is ok, but the sensitivities of other groups are considered sacrosanct and must be deferred to.
Like I said, draw the line anywhere you like. If it applies to everyone equally, I am happy. I am fine with things that require subjective judgment, as long as that subjective judgment is behind a screen that conceals identity.
If the end result is politically unbiased, it's due to their conscious decisions, not some magic algorithm.
As opposed to centralized moderation (twitter, FB, IG, etc.)
See here for more: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39471973
Congrats on launching! Excited to see what y'all do next.
We're thinking about Bluesky as both a product and a protocol (informing each other's design), and you're 100% right that for the end user, the product itself is what matters. Because we've taken on the decentralization constraint, we take longer to "catch up" to features that centralized platforms tend to have from the start, but it's definitely going to be a major area of focus for us going forward. (Ofc Mastodon isn't centralized, but note that it's had a few years of head start on feature development. We'll get there.)
For a decentralized protocol doing things right is much more important than doing things fast, it is very difficult (and in a lot of cases impossible) to break backwards compatibility.
If Signal releases a malicious update (and they don't provide reproducible builds), it is very much possible for you to know about it, as everything is on your device. Even if the binaries are different from the source code, decompilers, analyzing network traffic, etc. gives the community a good chance at catching malicious updates. Mastodon admins can simply pull up your plaintext DMs on their servers and no one will ever know.
Well then I guess it's pointless because it doesn't accomplish that.
(The actual point, FYI, is that you don't have to trust all of: them, their hosting providers, your ISP, the ISPs between, the government, and their mom.)
> it is very much possible for you to know about it
"Possible" != "done"
> analyzing network traffic
How are you gonna do that? Surely if they wanted to sniff it would still just look like any other encrypted data
> gives the community a good chance at catching malicious updates
Sure, when the same application is used by everyone, which is not true in either the Mastodon world or the new Bluesky-small-instances world
And the linked privacy policy goes into further detail (at least on my instance, mstdn.io):
> Please keep in mind that the _operators of the server and any receiving server may view such messages_, and that recipients may screenshot, copy or otherwise re-share them. Do not share any sensitive information over Mastodon.
Overall, I think it's safe for most chit-chat, and for anything more serious you can add link to Matrix or your email and PGP key in your profile.
As a sidenote, I'd also like to point out that a lot of serious communication nowadays still happens over unencrypted email. You can consider it whataboutism, but it's still worth remembering IMO. (And of course, like others pointed out, DMs on Twitter aren't encrypted, too, so it's the status quo here.)
If the protocol is not open, you have to rely in the clients provided by the vendor, and you can slip a backdoor throigh easily.
When did you last audit your Signal client? Where is “the commjnity” organizing this effort and publishing the results?
Debian shipped an entropy lowering in house patch despite the “many eyeballs” fos years (for OpenSSL). Don’t lure yourself into false feeling of security bevause of the “community” might be doing something. Only count on defenses surely in place, with traceable operation and output history, with responsibles who are allocated resources for the work and having stakes at its outcomes.
Videos might be more of a resource issue. Hardly a good time to launch videos almost at the same timeframe as they spike their user base by going public.
As it is, og-embeds do work for video and audio from a few different providers.
Never going to be taken seriously by the public.
If you want to be Twitter, you'll end up being Twitter. We already have one of those, it sucks, and we don't need another one.
Social networks go to crap above a certain scale. If everyone can see your posts, you'll write posts to be seen by everyone. Which, as it turns out, ends up benefiting no one. The magic comes when there is a community, where you give a shit about the people you're sending messages to, and they give a shit about you. If the community is too small, then nobody bothers with it and it dies. If the community is too large, then it ends up being old men screaming at clouds, and (see above) we already have one of those. So a platform that is good enough to use, but limits the number of disaffected members, is the only thing worth creating.
If something I'm saying requires a video, then I can always link to one. If something someone else is saying requires a video, and it requires the video to be immediately visible while I'm reading whatever they're saying, then there's a good chance I'm better off not seeing it anyway, even if I think I want to.
(Ironically, in this post I am an old man screaming at clouds...)
A size limit affects both equally.
> even relatively good ones like Cloudflare have particular payment shenanigans around video
That's only for the web service. Workers and R2 let you do video just fine. And small videos don't need any fancy logic, just toss them over http.
> Size uploads could help in that situation, but it's a bandaid on a bullet wound when the video still gets played a million times, y'know?
No, I legitimately don't know. Why is it different from an image that gets a million views?
It's not a good way to do it, though, and it's worse for Bluesky because it implies that in order to move your PDS (one of the best features of the design), you'd have to pick up the freight for video that already exists. If PDS mobility is important, attaching large economic strings to that is a big disincentive.
I mean that's the whole point of the Fediverse, a federated network of independent nodes. Of course the nodes take care of the functionality.
GIF support: https://github.com/bluesky-social/social-app/issues/1047
Audio/video support: https://github.com/bluesky-social/social-app/issues/1052
Still though, I get like Matt Gaetz' tweets recommended to me. Does anyone like that dude? How is this happening? Why on earth would I want that? I feel like all this conservative stuff is surfaced by the application to me.
[Proof](https://ibb.co/ypHS8fN)
I got notifications, on my dang phone, for the dumbest fucking takes. I don't get them for liberal people. Possible I am just in the demographic of people they think would swing conservative so they target me.
I use Twitter for tech, but my feed is now conservative politics, gore video, & tech tweets intermingled.
It’s absolutely conservative cesspool. Nazis can are literally posting 14 words propaganda all day long and there are no consequences.
In the face of current events though, that can be overlooked as it is not a narrative that serves western interest.
But to give an anecdote about an alternative, I rarely see any bigotry on Mastodon. Instances which allow that or don't moderate it correctly get block listed by instances I like. These instances may defederate into their own bubble in which they can still exist but cause no harm to the general timeline. Yet everyone still remains the freedom to express themselves. I like this because it's just a natural way of how to solve this problem for the end user.
Musk is grandstanding about "free speech", but what Twitter actually does now is fold and cave to demands for censorship from any authoritarian government that asks [4][5].
[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/twitter-leaked-internal-mess...
[2] https://theintercept.com/2022/12/20/elon-musk-twitter-banned...
[3] https://www.thedailybeast.com/elon-musk-suspends-insiders-li...
[4] https://restofworld.org/2023/elon-musk-twitter-government-or...
[5] https://www.techdirt.com/2023/05/15/once-again-free-speech-a...
Putin is a fascist dictator and Navalny wanted democratic rule.
That.. that is the exact opposite of the problem with Twitter. As Jeremy Clarkson put it years ago: "Twitter is where left wing people go to share their increasingly left wing views". The worst of them jumped ship for Mastodon (and it's why I'll never, ever use Mastodon) but it's still very far from some kind of conservative haven.
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/05/01/after-mus...
Soooo.. Right and left are objective bars in the sand and my options are perfectly formed and happen to be exactly just on the correct side of all issues.
I guess "absolute" is the wrong word. Lean isn't really a measurable thing, which is sorta my point. The GP claimed that there was, my claim was that all we have are people's feelings, and people don't feel in absolute terms, they just notice when there's a change so the linked data on peoples feelings probably doesn't support the claim.
Every time I open BlueSky it's like 50% Liberal rage-bait and like 40% people posting mostly about their sexual and gender identities.
If the GP's social circle leaned more conservative than them, it may just be bad predictions. And I can see how that would degrade user experience.
I often hear things like X service skews left/right and find it odd that people can have such differing experiences. Hence my belief that the feed algos are primarily the issue. People do like confirmation of biases.
The antidote is Linkedinification: “Thanks for bringing up this point it’s really smart and I fully agree!”
Or your point stands and helps to describe why the non conservative GGP was of the belief that X is conservative leaning.
You think Twitter doesn't still "put its boot on the neck of anyone they disagreed with"? Actually now it's "anyone they or Musk disagree with", so I guess you're kinda right.
Meanwhile he brought back people who were banned for committing crimes on it while banning people for posting entirely legal content like jack sweeney.
He's not a free speech absolutist, he's a me speech absolutist.
But sure, nobody was chased off by Musk.
If anything, my experience of Bluesky has been the inoffensive vapid thought leadering of peak Twitter alongside the playful air-headed liberal self-help that is also fairly reminiscent of peak Twitter. In one word: bland. Being able to paint over the offensive things like nazis and porn by sweeping them under your personal rug rather than blocking or banning them only adds to this impression for me.
Twitter, your breath of fresh air, on the other hand is overrun by ChatGPT spam bots and shovelware drop shipping ads worse than the crypto "giveaway" scams and paid tweets of the immediate pre-Musk days and every even moderately left-leaning political tweet is filled with replies describing the violent acts they want to do to that person in excessive detail by accounts that openly post literal neo-nazi propaganda videos of Adolf Hitler denouncing "degenerate art" as a Jewish plot to weaken the German volk and national spirit and going "I don't agree with everything he did but he had a point". Political discussions about the Middle East in turn are split evenly between right wing calls for genocide of all adults and children in Palestine and right wing defenses of Palestinians for being victims of the international Jewish conspiracy to exterminate the white race through mixed breeding with brown refugees.
We used to always call Twitter "the bad place", "hellsite" or "cesspool" before Musk but it certainly deserves those names now more than ever, arguably rivaling 4chan in its political takes although the depictions of gore are mostly limited to uncensored war footage and the porn is decidedly more tame.
The reason Twitter is called a "right-wing cesspool" is not because it's full of right-wing people (that would just make it a "pool"), it's because of the vicious explicit threats of violence and celebration of human suffering propagated by those people. For all its faults, the bland libs on Bluesky don't do much of that.
Granted, my experience of Twitter might be tainted by the fact most people I used to follow in the old days have either left or are no longer active and any time I visit the algorithmic timeline hits me at full blast. And a lot of the edgier posts (not replies) by right wing folks the avalanche of drama RTs throw my way are clearly created to farm engagement in the hope of striking it big if the bluecheck authors make the payout lottery.
Interesting. I see it as the de-facto journalist platform, which to me (as a non american) make it very left leaning. But then again, I don't use X.
The same is true about most so-called "left-wing" journalism. Some journalists may be true believers but the platforms exist to make money, not to be any threat to the systems those ideologies explicitly oppose.
Heck, this even goes for political parties like the Democrats: the Texas governor literally rejected the authority of the federal government and legislative system by deploying his military at the border and the Democrat president's response was to propose a bill that would have created a legal avenue for what the treasonous governor was trying to make happen. Decorum is used as an excuse to keep intentionally ceding ground to the supposed political enemy.
But more importantly, a bit rich for someone still caught up in the left-right dichotomy to be telling others to wise up.
I think the reason my friends did not join Bluesky despite me inviting them is that it just isn't as good of a product as Twitter. You can't post videos or DM.
I am not a tech executive and have no idea about corporate strategy, but it seems like Bluesky should focus less on technical differentiators and more on building killer features that have mass appeal and a community that people want to join.
IMHO this milestone, while cool, means absolutely nothing to people outside of the hacker news crowd.
I'm rooting for Bluesky, but it seems to me it will die without a critical mass of users.
Again, I'm kinda dumb, so this may all be wrong.