News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @10:54AM (#36878718)
> the quality has absolutely cratered

You just got old. It happens to everyone, and every generation says the same thing: The music I enjoyed when I was young and impressionable was great, but all the stuff they make nowadays is crap.

People were whining about how Beatles destroyed music, how rock’n’roll was just monkey noise, how crooners like Sinatra wasn’t real singing.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by the_only_law on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @10:56AM (#36878742)
It’s also a sign you aren’t looking. Yeah, music is going to be trash if you’re just looking at what’s popular on the radio/TikTok/charts. Spend some time on bandcamp going through what’s been posted in your preferred genres.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by Night_Thastus on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:47AM (#36879706)
Yes! One of the many joys of the internet and cheap computers is that anyone can produce music with very little upfront cost compared to before.

If you trawl around through youtube videos with 100 views, obscure bandcamp, audiophile forums, etc, niche discord and subreddits, you can find all sorts of absolutely fantastic music.

It obviously takes some work, but it's a lot of fun to discover as well!

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by the_only_law on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:59AM (#36879927)
Oh yeah, I forgot about YouTube, some of the best stuff I’ve found in recent years have been on channels that curate/promote music in particular genre. I have one for all sorts of punk genres, as well as one for doom metal and its related genres. They’re great, because they have all sorts of stuff, old and new, and help cut down on the cruft.

My only complaint about bandcamp is the mobile app. As far as I can tell, there’s no way to change the sorting when you’re looking through a genre, so it’s usually filled with albums and artists I already heard years ago, but their website is much better.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nick-of-time on Thursday July 27, 2023 @04:48PM (#36899951)
Basically all of the music I've bought in the last 5ish years I found through the channel Years of Silence. That person apparently has a very similar taste to me. Rujnuj has remained my favorite album for several years, especially since I found translations of the lyrics last year.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mbn404 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:51AM (#36879775)
Aslo go to rateyourmusic (RYM).
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by sixothree on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:04PM (#36880032)
On top of that there is vastly more selection than just 20 years ago.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by dmonitor on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:07PM (#36881079)
“what’s popular on the radio /TikTok/charts” being gutter tier hogwash is exactly what they’re talking about. Humans didn’t lose the ability to create good interesting music, and nobody legitimately thinks that. The publishing industry prevents independent artists from reaching any kind of mainstream popularity. Indie artists need money and the publishers that decide the winners/losers by controlling all the traditional distribution networks have no incentive to signal boost independents.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by Spivak on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:31PM (#36881520)
You have TikTok completely backwards. It's giving a platform and virality to independent artists at a scale that was simply not possible before.

If your only association with TikTok music culture is "TikTok charts" then you're just falling for the same Billboard top 40s but with a new coat of paint.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mmcdermott on Thursday July 27, 2023 @10:13AM (#36893865)
> Indie artists need money and the publishers that decide the winners/losers by controlling all the traditional distribution networks have no incentive to signal boost independents.

A publisher may wish to control distribution, but the cost to distribute any media (music, text, video, software) is nearly zero. The internet allows all of us to have a slush pile, to delve as deep for raw ore as we want. Some people want to go mining. Most don't and the traditional distribution networks ultimately market to such a person - and one way or another, we can't all delve through every slush pile. If you spend hours on SoundCloud or Bandcamp looking for music, you have less time to crawl for independent films or writing.

Any attempt to narrow the slush pile has the effect of marginalizing less mainstream efforts. If you read reviews or blogs to find things that seem worthy, then you are seeing what made it through someone else's slush pile. If you let the YouTube algorithm do it through recommendations, you are allowing Google to work through the slush pile.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by JeremyNT on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:38PM (#36882722)
> It’s also a sign you aren’t looking. Yeah, music is going to be trash if you’re just looking at what’s popular on the radio/TikTok/charts. Spend some time on bandcamp going through what’s been posted in your preferred genres.

There's more recorded music than ever, and I don't care what your tastes are there are - new and interesting artists are out there to discover.

... which is also, in its own way, a new difficulty. There's so much to sift through, finding what you think is "good" is going to be difficult. This is doubly so for people who grew up listening to the radio or watching MTV, where these decisions were made for them.

The best advice I could give anybody is to find an actual radio station that plays what they consider to be good new music. This probably doesn't look like a commercial station, and you may not even have any in broadcast range of you, but there are plenty out there that stream online. I'm partial to my local NPR music station, but maybe you'd have better luck with college radio or a local low powered station instead.

DJs may be a rare breed these days, but try to find some you like and just let them do the work for you. The algorithms aren't going to cut it.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:03AM (#36878863)
No it's objectively worse. The average complexity is at all time lows.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by lwelyk on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:12AM (#36879041)
I wasn't aware there was an objective 1-to-1 correlation between the complexity of music to its quality.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:18AM (#36879173)
There's not but it's a good heuristic. In pop music the average entropy is much lower, not only because the songs are simpler, but because they are more alike.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by TremendousJudge on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:24AM (#36879284)
Are you quoting that "Measuring the Evolution of Contemporary Western Popular Music" paper? Anybody who knows about music disagrees with its methods. Here's a good rundown by a classical composer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VfNdps0daF8
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nradov on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:54AM (#36879824)
Since you're not required to listen to pop music, the average entropy is utterly irrelevant. If you prefer more complex music there is a huge amount out there, probably more than you can listen to.

Average artwork has always been garbage throughout human history. But I still found a few good paintings to hang on my walls. As long as you can get what you want it doesn't really matter what else is out there.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ctoth on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:19PM (#36880243)
> Since you're not required to listen to pop music,

Is there a trick I'm missing to avoid this in {Ubers, grocery stores, bars, ...}? If so I'd love to know about it! Note: am blind, so can't constantly wear earplugs.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by colpabar on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:19PM (#36880246)
Okay, but you know that "good" and "worse" and subjective, relative terms? Just because you have your own reasons for something doesn't make them "objective", you just don't like modern pop music.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by stale2002 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:34PM (#36881565)
Ok, so since it is all "subjective" then you have to concede that a song which is just 1 hour of a single note being played is equally good.

Or maybe, instead of devolving into absurdity we can just say that there are come qualities of being better or worse that most people can agree on.

Of course, you can simply bite the bullet and say "yep. The song with 1 note in it is subjectively just as good".

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @04:08AM (#36890436)
> there are come qualities of being better or worse that most people can agree on

Maybe, but enough people like modern day pop music, so by that criteria it is good.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by empath-nirvana on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:39PM (#36881667)
The only heuristic that matters the quality of pop music is "do people like it" and it's almost a tautology that pop music in any given time period passes it.

If people preferred more complicated music, then more complicated music would be popular and more of it would get made.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by some-guy on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:15AM (#36879102)
What does “complexity” even mean here? Is modern music any less complex than “I Want to Hold Your Hand”?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:28AM (#36879363)
There are different ways to measure complexity: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.0067... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4281146/

Modern music is less harmonically complex than even early Beatles, who used more chords (and more chord progressions) than are used today. Music today is highly repetitive.

Timbre is also less complex thanks in part to the use of virtual instruments and sample packs. Synthesized sounds and samples are intrinsically less complex than sounds recorded in a room. Any two hits of, say, a hi-hat will yield different waveforms and our brains pick up on these micro variations.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by whycome on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:42AM (#36879612)
We're running out of chords. They've all been mined. We can't make new ones.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by TremendousJudge on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:33AM (#36879433)
I notice that the authors of that paper are two physicists and a data scientist. I wonder if they even consulted a musicologist or a composer with a background in research before publishing this paper. What would you think about a paper on programming that featured no computer scientists?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by yunwal on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:06PM (#36881059)
> Modern music is less harmonically complex than even early Beatles

The most popular genre in America (the world?) isn’t sung and doesn’t focus on tone, so this is hardly surprising. I bet if you measured rhythmic complexity or lyrical complexity it’d show the opposite.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by empath-nirvana on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:42PM (#36881716)
> Timbre is also less complex thanks in part to the use of virtual instruments and sample packs. Synthesized sounds and samples are intrinsically less complex than sounds recorded in a room. Any two hits of, say, a hi-hat will yield different waveforms and our brains pick up on these micro variations.

You should see how much time EDM producers spend tweaking the waveforms of individual percussion hits. The idea that timbre in modern music is _less_ complex than in the past is just mind boggling to me, given the level of control that people have in sculpting waveforms and samples. There are entire EDM tracks that are basically just atonal explorations of timbre.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by cmgbhm on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:02PM (#36882099)
I think it goes both ways. Some do spend insane amounts of time on individual hits or compositing sounds to various functional points.

You can also get the same thing looped 4x that has no variation. Hard to fault either side. Musicians have to get work out rapidly and then occasionally something gets legs.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by agumonkey on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:23PM (#36882471)
Vocal harmonies for one
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by retrac on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:58PM (#36883067)
Maybe an example of really complicated would help: https://youtu.be/uDhwFTw4VnI?t=300 (Steve Reich's Drumming)

I'm not the best at music theory but what I hear there, the subjective rhythm, what you want to sway to, arises from small permutations of the underlying repeating static phrase of each part. Which leads to a slowly constantly changing emotional/feel to the music. Sort of a rhythmic equivalent to counterpoint. Try and listen to any single part; it's almost impossible to follow without repeat listening. It produces an emergent effect. It's complicated.

I don't particularly enjoy it to be honest (Reich doesn't always compose for aesthetics -- intentionally experimental). I suppose it is musically and intellectually stimulating.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by math_dandy on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:13AM (#36879043)
You’re right about the average, but that single summary statistic is too coarse. There’s probably much more great music being produced now than ever before, but there’s much much much more crappy music. And recommendation algorithms aren’t optimizing for quality.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:16AM (#36879117)
Specifically I mean pop music. What you find on the radio, what is most heavily promoted, what gets the most streams + sales.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by starlevel003 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:46AM (#36879701)
> The average complexity is at all time lows.

there's more than enough breakcore out there if you measure music quality like that. theree's definitely more than in the 20th century.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by booleandilemma on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:53AM (#36879813)
What an HN comment.

"Is this song good?"

"One sec, let me check how complex it is"

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by seabass-labrax on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:10PM (#36886440)
"500 notes per second! Irish dance is the winner!"
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by dmonitor on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:08PM (#36881107)
Look up King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard if you want complex music. Polygondwanaland especially if you want something really out there.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ROTMetro on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:17PM (#36881252)
Complexity left to right may have gone down, but top to bottom has gone up. In a DAW people add way more tracks than ever and add all kinds of detail/texture/layers the weren't possible before so yeah, people search out the new and novel to experiment/have fun with. That happens all the time in music. No one used distorted electric guitars in music then all of the sudden music was over saturated in it. Just because you might not understand/recognize the current complexity doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by vunderba on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:40PM (#36886710)
If you're gonna make that argument than music peaked during the contrapuntal period and anything post-baroque is simply romantic drivel.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:03PM (#36880007)
That’s a real thing but it’s also real that investment in artist development cratered along with the market for CDs in the 2000s.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by pessimizer on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:14PM (#36880164)
> You just got old. It happens to everyone, and every generation says the same thing

I hate how people decide something is an inevitable eternal cycle that started in the 20th century. Recorded music hasn't been around long enough to think that platitudes like this actually have any meaningful content.

I'm here whining about how you're using a Beatles example because your argument is literally a teenage Baby Boomer argument. I've got board games older than your eternal generational war over the consumption of recorded music.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nkozyra on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:45PM (#36880696)
> I hate how people decide something is an inevitable eternal cycle that started in the 20th century. Recorded music hasn't been around long enough to think that platitudes like this actually have any meaningful content.

Maybe, but doesn't the same complaint exist about other media, too? 'Kids these days and their [books|music|art|clothes|dance styles]'

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by empath-nirvana on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:58PM (#36880921)
> I hate how people decide something is an inevitable eternal cycle that started in the 20th century.

People were complaining about the loudness war in _classical music_ in the early 19th century, unfavorably comparing Beethoven to his predecessors, and how his imitators were ruining music. Human nature doesn't change, and the phenomenon of people having their taste in music frozen in their teens and twenties is not something that was invented with the phonograph.

“It is not surprising that Beethoven should, occasionally, have entertained blasé notions of his art; that he should have mistaken noise for grandeur, extravagance for originality, and have supposed that the interest of his compositions would be in proportion to their duration. That he gave little time to reflection, is proved most clearly in the extraordinary length of some movements in his later symphonies… His great qualities are frequently alloyed by a morbid desire for novelty; by extravagance, and by a disdain of rule… The effect which the writings of Beethoven have had on the art must, I fear, be considered as injurious. Led away by the force of his genius and dazzled by his creations, a crowd of imitators has arisen, who have displayed as much harshness, as much extravagance, and as much obscurity, with little or none of his beauty and grandeur. Thus music is no longer intended to sooth, to delight, to ‘wrap the sense in Elysium’; it is absorbed in one principle—to astonish.” Letter to the Editor in the Quarterly Musical Magazine and Review, London, 1827

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ideamotor on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:30PM (#36881483)
It’s my lunch break, but all of you need to get back to work. None of any of this proves a damn thing.

Do some coding where your words actually have meaning and impact. But stop assuming the real world works that way.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mschuster91 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:18PM (#36880232)
> You just got old. It happens to everyone, and every generation says the same thing: The music I enjoyed when I was young and impressionable was great, but all the stuff they make nowadays is crap.

Thing is, there are objective metrics about quality. One aspect is "loudness war" aka compression, where subjective loudness gets increased at the cost of dynamic range [1], another (in)famous aspect is the increasing use of auto-tune (both the software itself as well as the general principle after which it was named). Artists and especially producers love that shit because similar to standardization in fast-food it provides a "consistent" performance even in live productions - which is seen as "cheating" in music by older people, and I think for good reason.

On top of that there's an increasing tendency of producers to push for "bland" personalities as well instead of also taking risks, and it's not just music - it's movies as well: most movies aren't original productions any more, a lot of them is based off of prior IP (Harry Potter, MCU) or endless continuations (Star Wars, Star Trek) to recoup ever growing production and marketing costs.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nkozyra on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:40PM (#36880613)
> One aspect is "loudness war" aka compression, where subjective loudness gets increased at the cost of dynamic range

The interesting thing about streaming services is they really put a cap on this (often a hard one measured by LUFS) and we really don't have as much wall-of-sound compression like we did from the 90s through the mid 00s.

https://hyperbits.com/ultimate-guide-to-the-loudness-war/

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by taeric on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:28PM (#36880403)
There really aren't objective metrics. There are quantifiable metrics, but turning something into a number doesn't make it fully objective.

And nothing pushes for bland personalities near as much as people pining for the past.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by wizofaus on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:00PM (#36884038)
That last statement might hold for "recent past" (last 10 or 15 years, say), but the one recent top 40 hit that stood out for me has a 50s type vibe (Until I Found You, Stephen Sanchez). I'm not particularly a fan of that style (well before my time!) but it's surely not "bland".
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by taeric on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:34PM (#36884572)
There are nuances there. I am not claiming that older things are bland. I'm saying that the people that are constantly pining on the past are. Really, it is more that they often make choices that lead to bland results.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by lenzm on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:49PM (#36880783)
I don't like the results of the loudness war either but it isn't objectively worse. Lots of people are listening to music on cheap speakers over the sound of road noise while driving or with generic earbuds on a train or any number of situations not conducive to high dynamic ranges. To these people in these situations, the highly compressed music sounds better.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by DropInIn on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @06:03PM (#36885791)
Imo musicians need to make it a norm to release two 'correct' verions:

The highly compressed versions for radio play/commoners

And

A 'hi-fi' version for audiophiles

They need to be the same except for levels etc, and neither more official than the other

If your song can't be enjoyed in both ways, then either your music is 'specialty' music catering to audiophiles and musicophiles (?) Or it's just garbage and shouldn't be released regardless.

But that opinion may be a major cause for myself never releasing anything....

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by l72 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:26PM (#36897071)
Why don’t we have an audio format that has different profiles with different mixes?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by DropInIn on Thursday July 27, 2023 @11:26PM (#36902845)
In a world of limitless storage that makes sense but for users who have music locally on thier phone not so much...

The actual use cases for each form undermine consolidation into one file.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by volkl48 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:54PM (#36880861)
Movies + Music aren't the same medium, though.

Music doesn't have ever-increasing production costs, and if anything it's easier than ever to get something out there on the primary distribution mechanisms used by the public to consume media.

It certainly has it's own business problems but I don't see any lack of interesting, risk-taking music out there. Even as a fan of genres largely far out of the mainstream I often feel like there's so much great new stuff that I can't keep up with it all.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mschuster91 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:00PM (#36880965)
> Music doesn't have ever-increasing production costs

It actually has. Venues are getting more and more expensive, and the effort to run shows has also increased - Rammstein is far from the only one requiring dozens of trucks to move their equipment around. On top of that you have Ticketmaster and their ilk on a brutal rent-seeking ride at the expense of both artists and fans.

> It certainly has it's own business problems but I don't see any lack of interesting, risk-taking music out there. Even as a fan of genres largely far out of the mainstream I often feel like there's so much great new stuff that I can't keep up with it all.

Yeah, indie stuff still works out fine these days, if not easier as Soundcloud has replaced physical tapes, but to achieve major recognition still takes an absurd amount of money, connections and luck. Or all three of them.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by filoleg on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:21PM (#36881316)
Venues and their increasing costs have nothing to do with production costs. Production costs refer to what it costs to actually produce a track and release it out there to the public.

Not even talking about insane amounts of good educational material available online for free these days, the capable equipment required to produce a studio-quality track fell down in price significantly, and most older equipment is still fully functional and compatible with newer offerings (thanks, MIDI and XLR). And newer equipment is still significantly cheaper than almost anything comparable from 20 years ago (if it was even available back then).

Back then, you wouldn't be able to produce anything that could compete in quality with studios from your bedroom, and not on a reasonable budget. And even if you somehow were so rich you were able to finance a pro studio in your house, and you produced a decent track, now the question is how would you even distribute it to the public and get heard.

These days? Thanks to affordability of what it takes to produce a track and the ease of getting your material released to the public, you can go from a nobody to someone with a hit track overnight. All for the price of a laptop, some decent speakers/headphones, and a midi-controller. And even that list is optional, as there are people who produce great stuff with less than this or even something entirely different.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mschuster91 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:30PM (#36882585)
> These days? Thanks to affordability of what it takes to produce a track and the ease of getting your material released to the public, you can go from a nobody to someone with a hit track overnight. All for the price of a laptop, some decent speakers/headphones, and a midi-controller. And even that list is optional, as there are people who produce great stuff with less than this or even something entirely different.

But how many actually manage to pull off that feat? You can probably count them on two hands. One-hit wonders yes, there have been a fair few of these that managed to hit the zeitgeist thanks to social media (Wellerman!), but a sustained career after that, from scratch and with no prior experience? I couldn't name one.

Everyone has the chance to strike a lottery jackpot, but only one person will.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by belthesar on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:50PM (#36884819)
Skrillex, Billie Eilish and Soulja Boy immediately come to mind, and they're not even on the list of these artists on this ad-riddled collection compiled 3 years ago - https://www.technowize.com/12-musicians-who-were-discovered-...

Are they everywhere? Nah, music is a capitalist endeavor, and the market wouldn't support that. But there are a surprising number of artists that have gained success with their first endeavors produced out of their homes.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by filoleg on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:11PM (#36896765)
> But how many actually manage to pull off that feat?

Quite a few, but that's not the point. Increasing opportunities for everyone does not mean that there will be the same levels of increase in top tier outlier outcomes. Just like if you suddenly gave access to MIT education to everyone, I think the success metric median (whether it is income or achievements) for MIT students will decrease, but the absolute number of successful people due to MIT education being available to everyone will increase.

Off the top of my head in terms of examples: Brockhampton, Skrillex, Billie Eilish, Porter Robinson, Steve Lacy (who produced hit tracks for artists like Mac Miller, J.Cole, and Kendrick Lamar), Flume, etc. The list can keep going on and on, and I listed only the very top tier artists in terms of popularity and lasting presence so far.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:57PM (#36883045)
> Music doesn't have ever-increasing production costs

“How much does it cost to make a hit song”

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/07/05/137530847/how-...

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mjr00 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:00PM (#36880962)
Firstly, the loudness war largely died with Spotify. LUFS normalization means that pushing beyond -14 is an artistic choice and not necessary to compete with other tracks on loudness alone.

Secondly, more compressed (less dynamic range) doesn't mean worse, or better. It means more compressed. In some genres, tons of compression is desirable; in others, less so. Is an orchestral Hans Zimmer piece that maxes at -10 momentary LUFS better than a Skrillex song that hits -4 during a drop? You could argue either song is better, but I don't think your argument would have anything to do with its LUFS measurement.

Compression is similar to distortion. Too much distortion is generally seen as bad. But if distortion were always bad, people would use acoustic guitars and clean electrics and never run things through a distortion pedal. Same idea with compression. Too much compression will kill a mix, but not enough will reduce the impact the song has on the listener.

In other words, trying to say that LUFS is an "objective metric of quality" is complete nonsense. To me that's like saying that lines of code written is an objective metric of quality of a software developer.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by aqfamnzc on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:41PM (#36881710)
I generally agree, but I don't think your comparison between distortion and compression makes sense. Distortion (guitar pedals, etc.) is something the artist intentionally adds to the song, in a specific way, intensity, and time. Compression is something added after the fact, for transit and storage. The artist doesn't really have control over what sort of artifacts lossy compression is going to add, so I don't see how "not enough [compression] will reduce the impact the song has on the listener."
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by biorach on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:48PM (#36881859)
> Compression is something added after the fact, for transit and storage. The artist doesn't really have control over what sort of artifacts lossy compression is going to add, so I don't see how "not enough [compression] will reduce the impact the song has on the listener."

This conversation isn't about file compression, it's about dynamic range compression. Very different.

https://www.izotope.com/en/learn/what-is-audio-compression.h...

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mjr00 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:47PM (#36881823)
I'm talking about dynamic range compression[0] in this context, not audio compression (e.g. MP3).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_range_compression

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by Slow_Hand on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:32PM (#36881527)
Agreed. LUFS as an "objective metric of quality" is nonsensical. I work as the assistant to a world class mastering engineer and we never discuss LUFS or aim to hit a target loudness. Such metrics (while well understood) are never a consideration.

All we do is listen. Often the goal is to get the record to feel as loud as it can be, but the moment our choices start to degrade the feel of the record we back off. We're doing very little in the way of actual limiting for loudness. We have ways of making the record feel louder, and they don't always involve dynamics processing.

Quite often no limiting is necessary because the mixes that we receive are mixed hot, which leads me to my next point:

Where I'll push back a little - for the sake of conversation - is the assertion that the loudness war died with streaming services. I consider their automatic level compensation features to be a big plus for audio fidelity. For artists and mixers who are sensitive to this issue it relieves them of the pressure of feeling that they need to deliver super hot mixes. The record can simply be what it needs to be and not conform to a certain loudness standard. It's a positive step.

Where my objection comes in is the reality that artists and mixers (who are well aware of the dilemma) nonetheless deliver us mixes that have been crafted for maximum perceived loudness. And they're really good at it. Even world class producers and mixers are sending us records that are squashed to hell, but very often they still sound good! The craft of mixing is evolving and people have become very adept at making an objectively loud record (-3 LUFS, etc) still work. HOW they do that is far too big of a topic to broach here.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mjr00 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:57PM (#36882011)
Yeah it's true that people are still trying to make loud stuff. But as you say, people are so good at making it work now that's not really a "I'm making this -3 because I need to be competitive with other songs," it's "I'm making this -3 because it's a heavy bass record and I want this to melt people's goddamn faces when they listen to it." In other words, an artistic decision, rather than a business one.

I think most modern EDM-pop now is at about -7 or so. These are world-class engineers doing the mixing, they could absolutely push it to -5 or -3 if they wanted, there's just no need thanks to LUFS normalization.

Like when people think about the real victims of the loudness war, it's albums like Californication or What's the Story (Morning Glory), which really didn't need to be that loud except for sounding better (in the louder = better sense) on the radio. Something like Death Magnetic you could argue is both intentionally loud + a victim of the loudness war, but it's also just really poorly mixed/mastered in general.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by radicaldreamer on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:23PM (#36882468)
Stadium Arcadium was a victim of this until the LP corrected the levels and is now considered the definitive version of the album.

I'm not sure if the high-res audio version on Apple Music has corrected this sin of the original CDs.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ROTMetro on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:10PM (#36881144)
I too agree that music was ruined once loud orchestra's were formed. The only good music was chamber music. Orchestras anonymized the musician and were basically the end of musicianship.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by Slow_Hand on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:12PM (#36881172)
While the Loudness War is indeed a race to the bottom for the dynamic quality of audio, it would have occurred sooner if the medium for recorded music had allowed for it. Vinyl records simply cannot go as loud as today's modern records because of physical limitations in the medium.

Nevertheless, for 70+ years producers, record executives, and artists have been using every sonic trick at their disposal to make their record "pop" and stand out from the competition. The advent of digital audio simply opened up more headroom with which to push the record.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by WalterBright on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:27PM (#36882548)
It's hard to find a popular recording these days that hasn't had the vocal electronically altered. Autotune is just one of the effects applied.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by mhh__ on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @05:04PM (#36884998)
You're saying Daft Punk don't sing like that in real life?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by jjulius on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @06:00PM (#36885743)
>... popular recording...

At the risk of being reductive, dig a little bit deeper, beyond popular music, and you'll find large swathes of fantastic music where this isn't the case.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by shagymoe on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:00PM (#36883081)
Nothing about the "quality" of art, including music, is objective. These sound waves are better than those sound waves? No. Beauty and the quality of art is in the eye (or ear) of the beholder.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by msla on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:00PM (#36883083)
> another (in)famous aspect is the increasing use of auto-tune (both the software itself as well as the general principle after which it was named)

This is mostly subjective, not objective.

(Is it being used more? Objective. Is that relevant to quality? Subjective.)

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by jjulius on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @05:55PM (#36885672)
>Thing is, there are objective metrics about quality. One aspect is "loudness war" aka compression...

Eeeeehhhhh. I've heard plenty of beautifully-mastered tracks that were otherwise just crap pieces of music, just as I've heard plenty of music that was so good I was willing to overlook the fact that it might be taking part in the loudness war.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by vunderba on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:34PM (#36886656)
Eh. You can make the same argument for synthesizers, samplers, drum machines or anything that allows you to use midi to control instruments. At that point, you're not having to play it, so isn't that technically cheating?

Note I'm not making a point for or against either way, just pointing out that this argument taken to its logical end covers a pretty broad domain of the music industry.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by version_five on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:34PM (#36880496)
I'm not sure. Music goes in cycles, like the 80s generated a lot of crap and then gave way to the explosion of the alternative music scene.

For an actual semi-objective measure, think about how often you hear songs from the 60s and 70s, and from the 90s (and early 2000s for hip hop). And then think of all the crap that's gone by that has no staying power. I'm sure it's partially my bubble, but there were bands in the decades I mention that are going to be widely listened to for a long time, while in between there's a ton of throwaway. Basically you get original, defining music as new genres emerge then runs of derivative crap between them, it's not constant.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nemo44x on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:35PM (#36880529)
Yup. Getting old is a tough pill to swallow. An early sign is when you don’t care about new music.

Face it, popular music exists for teenagers to claim their spot. Their unique identity from previous generations. The new and fresh - it’s about today and they are today.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by deepspace on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:15PM (#36883337)
> The new and fresh

But that's just the point. New music all sounds the same. Half-spoken, mumbled lyrics- check. Autotuned to death- check. Forgettable tunes- check.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by jabroni_salad on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:32PM (#36884546)
That's weird, the stuff I'm listening to has good clarity and writing and inventiveness. I'm listening to people like cory wong, theo katzman, ariel posen, big wild, chris thile's various groups, john grant, louis cole.

Maybe whatever you're using to find new music just sucks? blink twice if it's a clearchannel playlist.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by samstave on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:48PM (#36880747)
Sure, but one cant deny the music of the late 60s and 70s changed a lot of human culture.

But we dont have revolutionary music such as led zepplin, pink floyd, etc in the current crop.

none of the above sought facade public images as much as every single 'influencing' pop-stars today.

Their influence was organic. Today's music trends are forced.

Aside from some EDM style folks, such as ZHU - great music but hes not out there trying to push 'lifestyle' bs, as much as others.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bigbillheck on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:54PM (#36881967)
> Their influence was organic. Today's music trends are forced.

This is 100% purestrain revisionism.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by samstave on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @05:53PM (#36885648)
Uh, I had to goog this...

but this doesnt map. So explain thyself ;;

" this involve a significant revision of fundamental Marxist theories and premises, and usually involve making an alliance with the bourgeois class "

-

uh... explain me... to me?

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bigbillheck on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @08:23PM (#36887106)
Your understanding of the music industry of the 60s and 70s is at the 'not even wrong' level.

Let's start with this to set the context: > But we dont have revolutionary music such as led zepplin, pink floyd, etc in the current crop.

And then when it comes to Led Zeppelin and this: > none of the above sought facade public images as much as every single 'influencing' pop-stars today.

I'm not sure what 'facade' is doing there, maybe you meant to use a different word, but I'm also not sure how you can look at Led Zeppelin after the early 70s and say they weren't seeking a public image.

Then there's Pink Floyd and this: > Their influence was organic. Today's music trends are forced.

From which I'm going to guess that you've never actually listened to the lyrics to 'Have a Cigar'.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by samstave on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @09:55PM (#36887882)
im open to hearing ypour thoughts
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by vondur on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:52PM (#36880830)
I do think that the quality of the current Top 40 hits is certainly worse than in the past. However, there are good bands out there you just have to look for them on Bandcamp/Youtube or forums/sites dedicated to the genre of music you enjoy.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by scelerat on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:10PM (#36881138)
Ehh. I was in high school and college throughout the '90s and still think pop music quality peaked sometime between 1966 and 1986. It's not necessarily an age thing. I mean, I remember thinking that at the time too.

There are still tons of great musicians and bands making new music today, but the stuff that most people are familiar with is dreck compared to what most people were familiar with fifty years ago.

Among other things is that popular attention, once focused by a handful of local radio stations and three national broadcast networks (in the US), has been atomized by a billion channels. The stuff that gets shoved down the big expensive earball-rich pipes is pablum for broad but weak appeal, processed by self-affirming accountants and algorithms, to a degree it simply was not a generation or two ago. It's simply not the same.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nemo44x on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:30PM (#36881484)
> I was in high school and college throughout the '90s and still think pop music quality peaked sometime between 1966 and 1986.

Pop music or rock music in particular? Rock is a type of pop music and it's arguable that it is past its prime and was better when it was newer.

> the stuff that most people are familiar with is dreck compared to what most people were familiar with fifty years ago.

Likely some survival bias here. There was tons of awful music that was quickly forgotten about back in the day too. I will grant that the cost of recording and distributing music is much lower today so there very well is a lower barrier to entry which means there's probably more garbage than ever.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by Spivak on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:27PM (#36881438)
You weren't around for the garbage. You're getting the benefit of listening to only the best of the best music from an entire generation with ears untainted by it being overplayed. If I pushed you twenty years in the future, made you completely forget all music from 2010 on and played only the very best hearing it for the first time you would be convinced that it was a renaissance.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by agumonkey on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:21PM (#36882429)
I think what changed is

The place of music in society. Availability doesn't mean wide impact. It often created smaller sub cultures.

The place of music in people, there are more things capturing your mind now.

The place of the industry, in the past access was granted through a tree of labels and record companies, it also had a weight in the inertia of styles and art. You went through more skilled eyes, it gives you a different legitimity.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by JambalayaJim on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:35PM (#36883619)
>Ehh. I was in high school and college throughout the '90s and still think pop music quality peaked sometime between 1966 and 1986

How much of that was influence from baby-boomer controlled music media?

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @10:06AM (#36893741)
> but the stuff that most people are familiar with is dreck compared to what most people were familiar with fifty years ago

Maybe you have just forgotten about all the dreck that was popular 50 years ago and only remember the classics?

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by stcroixx on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:18PM (#36881278)
I like various music from the past 100 years or so, not just from when I was young, and agree quality of current pop is pretty low compared to that time period.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nemo44x on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:34PM (#36881572)
I'd give way to say that the music from your teens and before. It's much easier to appreciate music from before your time than after your time for some reason. I'd guess nostalgia in part and because when you first heard the old music it was new to you and part of your nostalgia. So you don't experience it the same way that teenagers did when it was released but you have a relationship with it that is meaningful none the less.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by chiefalchemist on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:38PM (#36881640)
Yes and no. The problem current artists run into is coming up with something new. Disco, Hip Hop, Punk and even post-Punk were fresh and new then...but those sounds live on to this day in "new" artists. It's entertaining, but it's hardly something to get excited about.

It's not a matter of getting old per se. It's a matter of having more context, more perspective. Yes, there's a lot of good music today. However, so much of it relies on what we've heard before, it rarely qualifies as great. Or, at best, great is relative to the current, which often is average at best.

Do I want to listen to (e.g.) New Order, or a knock-off of New Order?

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ok123456 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:39PM (#36881654)
> Beatles destroyed music, how rock’n’roll was just monkey noise, how crooners like Sinatra wasn’t real singing.

Agree.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by LanceH on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:47PM (#36881818)
Where are the ugly singers? Music is represented my a disproportionately high number of hot women (and less so men) with no room for others. There is obviously a standard other than musical quality in play.

Today, it's mostly true that everything is available. The music that reaches the masses, though, is defined by production over musical quality.

Would we even see or hear from Cass Elliot, Janis Joplin, or Patsy Cline today? Producers would choose someone other than Patsy Cline for Crazy and twist Willie Nelson's arm to make him a ghostwriter on the song so the hot, autotuned, woman could claim she wrote it herself.

There is more to it than just getting older.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by sspiff on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:52PM (#36881930)
This is nothing new though, this has been true since the rise of TV and things like top of the pops. Because guess what? People prefer pretty people.

Once artists became visible, this was inevitable. The pretty people were going to become popular regardless of whether the music industry got involved or not.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by agumonkey on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:17PM (#36882373)
A french singer contest saw a normal/chubby girl winning by a wide margin. The tour after te tv show bombed horribly.

There's a reflex in crowds to seek for some traits and physical "beauty" seems one of them. The rest seems the exception (and those singers have either very special skills or a super solid persona)

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by blowski on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:53PM (#36881946)
Lewis Capaldi, Adele, Meghan Trainor, Jay Z, Drake. I don’t believe any of them made it because of their looks.

On the other hand, the Beatles, The Stones, The Monkees, Stevie Nicks, Olivia Newton John - their looks were very much part of their appeal.

Same as it ever was. Face it - you’re old.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by jurimasa on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:16PM (#36884304)
So, being old = opinion invalid?

Nice ageism you have there, kid.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by DropInIn on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:09PM (#36886421)
"Exceptions that prove the rule"

You've heard the phrase before right?

Why could you pick those names so readily? Because they're the exceptions...

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by blowski on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @09:56PM (#36887894)
That seems rather “One True Scotsman” logic.

“Where are the Elton Johns of today?”

“Here and here and here”

“Ah yes, but those are exceptions that prove the rule”

By that easy logic, I can say Elton John was also an exception.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by DropInIn on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @10:38PM (#36888226)
... you think he wasn't?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by rz2k on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:02PM (#36883125)
I don't agree at all. I've found the YouTube algorithms as good for discovering new singer-songwriters as when I used to see live music a few times a week in New York decades ago. Many, or even most, of the women that come up in my feed are no more conventionally beautiful than the people you cite.

How mainstream was someone like Janis Joplin? She was on the radio, but she was also somewhat counter culture. The women (who don't deserve to be written about as evidence of success without beauty) have hundreds of thousands of subscribers just on youtube, many millions of listens, and I hear their music in stores, commercials and coffee shops.

In addition to there being many more avenues for reaching a large audience outside of record labels, there are also quite a few mainstream performers who aren't conventionally attractive who became famous through pseudo-grassroot paths like television contests.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by DropInIn on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:07PM (#36886401)
Take a look at which artists get traction on YouTube.... It's extremely biased by beauty, as the algorithm rewards engagement and if nothing else all the creeps wanking while watching on repeat drive the ladies up the figurative charts....

Really.... how have you not noticed?

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by rz2k on Thursday July 27, 2023 @02:35AM (#36889764)
I'm sure that has something to do with the music industry. People who work in things like professional modelling or professional sports makes many times more than they made decades ago. Even well-known musicians who made their mark decades ago remain not that rich.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by libraryatnight on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:30PM (#36884510)
They'd have a youtube channel and 8 million followers, whether or not you'd hear about them is debatable.

Mac Demarco is not a handsome man. Lady Gaga isn't winning any pageants, Adele was mocked for her weight,and then her weight loss, Lizzo's whole thing is self love because she gets harassed for her weight.

There will always be beautiful people produced and controlled for sale, and there will always be the talented, the weird, the outrageous that rise to public conscious - and some from all camps that do not.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by DropInIn on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:10PM (#36886442)
"Lady Gaga isn't winning any pageants"

How does she look in her breakout hit? (Poker face)

Yea... that's right, she definitely looks "good".

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by amalcon on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:59PM (#36884932)
Milli Vanilli was 30 years ago now. That act literally replaced the singers with better looking people for marketing reasons.

A baby born the day The Monkees formed would be retiring now. That wildly popular band was literally created for a TV show.

This problem has been going on for a long time.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Saturday July 29, 2023 @05:41AM (#36918508)
Nothing new though - Elvis never wrote a song either, but he had the look.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by adamc on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:47PM (#36882879)
I've liked significant portions of most eras, but it's true that today's music is different and seems more limited. The average song is being driven down toward 2 minutes by the realities of streaming, songs use a lot more sampling (because musicians cost more), there is much less modulation than there once was, etc.

Objectively, it seems like less sophisticated music, in part because there isn't the same kind of money there once was in the system to pay for studio musicians, producers, etc.

Is it possible to create great songs despite that? Yes, but it involves a lot of "skating uphill".

You can see that older music is still getting a LOT of plays -- I think too many to make sense, unless we accept that the current industry is not healthy.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by tracerbulletx on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:00PM (#36883088)
Yeah, there's an insane amount of amazing music of so many different styles being produced. The nature of finding it, the gate keepers, what's cool, and everything else has changed though and if you haven't been keeping up with it, it might be somewhat invisible to you. Refusing to use streaming services out of principal definitely just sounds like being old and refusing to adapt though, you can always buy physical media to support an artist once you discover them.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by msla on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:06PM (#36883190)
Plus, The Winnowing: We don't listen to most music from decades ago. We don't listen to most hits from decades ago. The Winnowing removes most works, in every medium, from the popular consciousness, leaving only the consensus favorites, also known as the canon.

Here's an example: "The Ballad Of The Green Berets" by SSG Barry Sadler was number one for five weeks in 1966, tied with "California Dreamin'" by The Mamas And The Papas. That song is effectively gone now. It's no longer remembered. It didn't make the canon, because The Winnowing got to it, so now it isn't part of The Sixties as a consensus mass memory. "California Dreamin'" which was objectively just as popular by the metric of the charts, however, is pretty well remembered and is, therefore, part of the canon.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ballad_of_the_Green_Berets

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8kj9qv6rmG8

Newer music hasn't gone through The Winnowing. More of the chaff is still remembered. Therefore, it all looks worse.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by dredmorbius on Thursday July 27, 2023 @12:34AM (#36888963)
I agree with you in part, but feel there's something to the criticism as well. You can look at the top hits --- number ones, top 10s, Billboard top 40, etc., going back through time. And whilst the most popular song of any given year or decade often is reasonably banal, it often isn't, and as you go back through the list, there are dark-horse pieces which do appear.

Another factor is that far more music is published or streamed now, which makes sorting through the mix much more challenging.

Popular taste and memory are both fickle, and one thing that makes going through back-catalogues and earlier periods so interesting is that the sounds of forgotten hits are often fresh to modern ears, while at the same time being tinged with nostalgia based on style, composition, performance characteristics, etc.

If you look at popular hits going back about 150--200 years (say to the 1820s -- 1870s onward), one characteristic that becomes overwhelmingly apparent is the role of technology in popular music. Earlier pieces are often meant to be played or sung by the masses themselves, and tend to instrumentation that would have been available (fiddle, flute, piano). The first recorded formats were player-piano pieces distributed on rolls (and with a distinctly mechanical sound). By the early 20th century, amplification starts to emerge, allowing smaller acts, then electrification (the 3--4 piece rock group emerges), synthesizers (1- and 2-person acts), rap DJs, and over the past decade or so the ability for either a single person to play multiple tracks or for artists in remote locations to be able to collaborate on a single piece.

This may give rise to either original pieces, or simply amazing covers of classics. Leonid & Friends cover of Chicago's "25 or 6 to 4", for example, seems to me better than and at the same time more faithful to the original. It is technically fantastic, while at the same time having its own honest spirit and vivaciousness:

<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=9_torOTK5qc>

Other notable covers:

- Pomplamoose, e.g., "In the Air Tonight": <https://pipe.kavin.rocks/watch?v=9_torOTK5qc>

- Disturbed's "Sounds of Silence": <https://piped.kavin.rocks/watch?v=u9Dg-g7t2l4>

I still think that songs such as "Gangnam Style" and "Someone That I Used to Know" are both truly good recent (post-2000, for me) songs. Both in originals and covers such as Walk Off the Earth's: <https://piped.kavin.rocks/watch?v=p4hIzgqA9io>. (Not to mention the parodies of the original and cover versions...).

That said ...

... I listen to very little contemporary music, largely preferring classical and jazz / blues / folk traditions. Terrestrial broadcast radio is all but completely dead to me. And I don't use streaming services, so that's not really there either.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by deepspace on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:12PM (#36883284)
Watch this video, and tell me that there is no objective difference in quality between pre-2000 and post-2000 songs.

With a few exceptions, modern music is autotuned-to-death, boring, indistinguishable crap.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7uMW2XsMx8Q

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by jacquesm on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:14PM (#36884279)
Very interesting.

After 1990 it drops right off a cliff for me with a few exceptions.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by allturtles on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:29PM (#36884504)
I have the same gut feeling that there has been a decline in quality, but I'm not sure that video makes the case.

In the previous 10 years (2013-2022) years the songs that clearly fit your description are "Closer" (2016), "Sunflower" (2018), "Stay" (2021). I'd probably say "Old Town Road" (2019) is pretty bad also, with a very boring, repetitive bass track. And "Despacito" (2017) is catchy but has the same cliche beat as a million other songs in the genre.

"Happy" (2013) is a fun song that could be compared to Bobby McFerrin's 1988 hit, "Uptown Funk" (2014) is a 70s throwback, "Hello" (2015) is a vocal fireworks show, "Blinding Lights" (2020) and "As It Was" (2022) are 80s throwbacks.

On the other hand is "Never Gonna Give You Up" (1987) actually a good song? Is "U Can't Touch This" (1990)? Is "Wannabe" (1996)? No, they are fun but none of these are really good songs.

I'm not sure just comparing the most recognizable song of each year gets you very far.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by DropInIn on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @09:39PM (#36887776)
To so many on that list of "bad" and the reasons for it I can't help but think of James Brown and "I feel good" or a song like "Twist and Shout" which have had pretty damn good saying power and few would say are actually bad. A lot of Amy winehouses music too, as well as many "punk" songs.. repetition is not a hallmark of quality nor lack thereof.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by jacquesm on Thursday July 27, 2023 @06:41PM (#36901097)
Amy Winehouse could have sung the phonebook and it would have sounded great.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by yCombLinks on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:24PM (#36883466)
This is the most banal argument. It's never possible something is worse than it was before?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:23PM (#36913543)
Note that a lot of people can agree that newer music is crap but wildly disagree about when the good music was made. Just in this thread you can see some claim good music was made until 1985, some say it was until the 90’s some say it was until the last decade. There is no consensus at all, which indicate it is not an objective change in quality.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by yCombLinks on Friday July 28, 2023 @10:48PM (#36916316)
100% agree it's not objective, but if you took a poll for which time period had better music 1965-1969 vs 1980-1985 you'd have a heavy vote for 65-69
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by libraryatnight on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @04:24PM (#36884422)
I agree. People will tell you they have objective ways of proving the quality of music, it's emotional reactionary BS. It's an art that moves with culture and technology; the length of the song, the instruments, complexity - people are going to make what they feel and listen to what they like (and there will always be people making some version of something even if it's not popular - one of my friends is committed to metrical verse). With so many people making music (and art in general) now, writing off a generation's output based on what sold or showed up in commercial media is short sighted. "Music" is so much more than what's irritating the taste-keepers.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by benreesman on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @05:55PM (#36885676)
I’m knocking on 40 and the absolute best shit is on SoundCloud done by some teenager or 20-something on like a pirated copy of Ableton in a basement. There are like 2 things you can do as the technology goes to infinity: make way more diverse awesome stuff, or just make the music one tiny part of the well-oiled Taylor Swift Corporation.

There’s more amazing music being made than ever, and the stuff with big money behind it is worse than ever.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by rkok on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:08AM (#36889162)
Care to share a few links? Always nice to discover a bit of new music. Don't worry, I won't judge.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by pallas_athena on Thursday July 27, 2023 @02:30AM (#36889723)
> and every generation says the same thing

Juvenoia: "The fear or hostility directed by an older generation toward a younger one, or toward youth culture in general."

See also: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD0x7ho_IYc

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ttjjtt on Thursday July 27, 2023 @09:35AM (#36893259)
Honestly this popular rebuttal actually appears more inaccurate and quaint to me than the opinion it’s dismissing.

My teenage kid strongly feels that modern pop music is trash quality compared to previous decades, thinks that new “underground” music is poorly mimicking previous decades, and bemoans the lack of current scenes that she can participate in. It’s a bit sad watching her sift through 90s/00s music rather than dig into new music of her generation, but I can hear the problem when she plays me both the underground and pop stuff her friends are listening to. It’s tame.

There have been profound infrastructural changes to cultural production and distribution, lead by SV and VCs. These have served to massively boost stock valuations of centralising digital platforms. The music they produce is affected by these changes. The faux meta genre “hyperpop” even exploits this (boringly imo). It’s reassuring to believe the kids are alright but the problem is not the kids.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by itsanaccount on Thursday July 27, 2023 @09:44AM (#36893378)
I want to summarize because I feel like it cant be repeated enough on this site:

The endless march of optimizing profits by investors who control an ever lopsided share of wealth destroys everything.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @09:54AM (#36893534)
What you describe is pretty common - a segement of younger people preferring older music, typically the music of their parents generation. This is nothing new either, not every young person liked Elvis either.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ttjjtt on Thursday July 27, 2023 @10:02AM (#36893672)
I know. but what’s atypical is the tame-ness, the lack of energy and lack of community participation and shared experience in new music, and its sharp decline of perceived cultural value by the younger generation. I think the changing valuation and changing qualities are not wholly unrelated.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @10:25AM (#36894060)
Was Gilbert O’Sullivan really that much better than Kenrick Lamar?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ttjjtt on Thursday July 27, 2023 @10:35AM (#36894260)
Not much to chew on there tbh

I have a lot of friends in the music industry since I used to work there until recently, both back end eg A&Rs and agents as well as artists. The common sentiment is that nothing new has happened in the last decade, everyone’s wondering why, and increasingly exasperated.

So okay, hip hop.. US trap has been largely in stasis since 2008/2010 (lex lugar era). Uk drill has been in stasis since 2017. Does 2023 Kendrick really sound much different to 2012 kendrick? Compare 2002 rap to 1992 rap.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by zirgs on Thursday July 27, 2023 @11:04AM (#36894700)
As I said before - we have reached the end of history of music.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by kansface on Thursday July 27, 2023 @06:02PM (#36900743)
Surely some generation is actually correct? Do you think all music is equally good and all trends are universally good as well?