News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:03AM (#36878863)
No it's objectively worse. The average complexity is at all time lows.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by lwelyk on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:12AM (#36879041)
I wasn't aware there was an objective 1-to-1 correlation between the complexity of music to its quality.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:18AM (#36879173)
There's not but it's a good heuristic. In pop music the average entropy is much lower, not only because the songs are simpler, but because they are more alike.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by TremendousJudge on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:24AM (#36879284)
Are you quoting that "Measuring the Evolution of Contemporary Western Popular Music" paper? Anybody who knows about music disagrees with its methods. Here's a good rundown by a classical composer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VfNdps0daF8
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by nradov on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:54AM (#36879824)
Since you're not required to listen to pop music, the average entropy is utterly irrelevant. If you prefer more complex music there is a huge amount out there, probably more than you can listen to.

Average artwork has always been garbage throughout human history. But I still found a few good paintings to hang on my walls. As long as you can get what you want it doesn't really matter what else is out there.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ctoth on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:19PM (#36880243)
> Since you're not required to listen to pop music,

Is there a trick I'm missing to avoid this in {Ubers, grocery stores, bars, ...}? If so I'd love to know about it! Note: am blind, so can't constantly wear earplugs.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by colpabar on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:19PM (#36880246)
Okay, but you know that "good" and "worse" and subjective, relative terms? Just because you have your own reasons for something doesn't make them "objective", you just don't like modern pop music.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by stale2002 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:34PM (#36881565)
Ok, so since it is all "subjective" then you have to concede that a song which is just 1 hour of a single note being played is equally good.

Or maybe, instead of devolving into absurdity we can just say that there are come qualities of being better or worse that most people can agree on.

Of course, you can simply bite the bullet and say "yep. The song with 1 note in it is subjectively just as good".

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by bazoom42 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @04:08AM (#36890436)
> there are come qualities of being better or worse that most people can agree on

Maybe, but enough people like modern day pop music, so by that criteria it is good.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by empath-nirvana on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:39PM (#36881667)
The only heuristic that matters the quality of pop music is "do people like it" and it's almost a tautology that pop music in any given time period passes it.

If people preferred more complicated music, then more complicated music would be popular and more of it would get made.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by some-guy on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:15AM (#36879102)
What does “complexity” even mean here? Is modern music any less complex than “I Want to Hold Your Hand”?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:28AM (#36879363)
There are different ways to measure complexity: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.0067... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4281146/

Modern music is less harmonically complex than even early Beatles, who used more chords (and more chord progressions) than are used today. Music today is highly repetitive.

Timbre is also less complex thanks in part to the use of virtual instruments and sample packs. Synthesized sounds and samples are intrinsically less complex than sounds recorded in a room. Any two hits of, say, a hi-hat will yield different waveforms and our brains pick up on these micro variations.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by whycome on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:42AM (#36879612)
We're running out of chords. They've all been mined. We can't make new ones.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by TremendousJudge on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:33AM (#36879433)
I notice that the authors of that paper are two physicists and a data scientist. I wonder if they even consulted a musicologist or a composer with a background in research before publishing this paper. What would you think about a paper on programming that featured no computer scientists?
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by yunwal on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:06PM (#36881059)
> Modern music is less harmonically complex than even early Beatles

The most popular genre in America (the world?) isn’t sung and doesn’t focus on tone, so this is hardly surprising. I bet if you measured rhythmic complexity or lyrical complexity it’d show the opposite.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by empath-nirvana on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:42PM (#36881716)
> Timbre is also less complex thanks in part to the use of virtual instruments and sample packs. Synthesized sounds and samples are intrinsically less complex than sounds recorded in a room. Any two hits of, say, a hi-hat will yield different waveforms and our brains pick up on these micro variations.

You should see how much time EDM producers spend tweaking the waveforms of individual percussion hits. The idea that timbre in modern music is _less_ complex than in the past is just mind boggling to me, given the level of control that people have in sculpting waveforms and samples. There are entire EDM tracks that are basically just atonal explorations of timbre.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by cmgbhm on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:02PM (#36882099)
I think it goes both ways. Some do spend insane amounts of time on individual hits or compositing sounds to various functional points.

You can also get the same thing looped 4x that has no variation. Hard to fault either side. Musicians have to get work out rapidly and then occasionally something gets legs.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by agumonkey on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:23PM (#36882471)
Vocal harmonies for one
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by retrac on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:58PM (#36883067)
Maybe an example of really complicated would help: https://youtu.be/uDhwFTw4VnI?t=300 (Steve Reich's Drumming)

I'm not the best at music theory but what I hear there, the subjective rhythm, what you want to sway to, arises from small permutations of the underlying repeating static phrase of each part. Which leads to a slowly constantly changing emotional/feel to the music. Sort of a rhythmic equivalent to counterpoint. Try and listen to any single part; it's almost impossible to follow without repeat listening. It produces an emergent effect. It's complicated.

I don't particularly enjoy it to be honest (Reich doesn't always compose for aesthetics -- intentionally experimental). I suppose it is musically and intellectually stimulating.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by math_dandy on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:13AM (#36879043)
You’re right about the average, but that single summary statistic is too coarse. There’s probably much more great music being produced now than ever before, but there’s much much much more crappy music. And recommendation algorithms aren’t optimizing for quality.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by intalentive on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:16AM (#36879117)
Specifically I mean pop music. What you find on the radio, what is most heavily promoted, what gets the most streams + sales.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by starlevel003 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:46AM (#36879701)
> The average complexity is at all time lows.

there's more than enough breakcore out there if you measure music quality like that. theree's definitely more than in the 20th century.

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by booleandilemma on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:53AM (#36879813)
What an HN comment.

"Is this song good?"

"One sec, let me check how complex it is"

Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by seabass-labrax on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:10PM (#36886440)
"500 notes per second! Irish dance is the winner!"
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by dmonitor on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:08PM (#36881107)
Look up King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard if you want complex music. Polygondwanaland especially if you want something really out there.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by ROTMetro on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:17PM (#36881252)
Complexity left to right may have gone down, but top to bottom has gone up. In a DAW people add way more tracks than ever and add all kinds of detail/texture/layers the weren't possible before so yeah, people search out the new and novel to experiment/have fun with. That happens all the time in music. No one used distorted electric guitars in music then all of the sudden music was over saturated in it. Just because you might not understand/recognize the current complexity doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du... by vunderba on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:40PM (#36886710)
If you're gonna make that argument than music peaked during the contrapuntal period and anything post-baroque is simply romantic drivel.