Once artists became visible, this was inevitable. The pretty people were going to become popular regardless of whether the music industry got involved or not.
There's a reflex in crowds to seek for some traits and physical "beauty" seems one of them. The rest seems the exception (and those singers have either very special skills or a super solid persona)
On the other hand, the Beatles, The Stones, The Monkees, Stevie Nicks, Olivia Newton John - their looks were very much part of their appeal.
Same as it ever was. Face it - you’re old.
Nice ageism you have there, kid.
You've heard the phrase before right?
Why could you pick those names so readily? Because they're the exceptions...
“Where are the Elton Johns of today?”
“Here and here and here”
“Ah yes, but those are exceptions that prove the rule”
By that easy logic, I can say Elton John was also an exception.
How mainstream was someone like Janis Joplin? She was on the radio, but she was also somewhat counter culture. The women (who don't deserve to be written about as evidence of success without beauty) have hundreds of thousands of subscribers just on youtube, many millions of listens, and I hear their music in stores, commercials and coffee shops.
In addition to there being many more avenues for reaching a large audience outside of record labels, there are also quite a few mainstream performers who aren't conventionally attractive who became famous through pseudo-grassroot paths like television contests.
Really.... how have you not noticed?
Mac Demarco is not a handsome man. Lady Gaga isn't winning any pageants, Adele was mocked for her weight,and then her weight loss, Lizzo's whole thing is self love because she gets harassed for her weight.
There will always be beautiful people produced and controlled for sale, and there will always be the talented, the weird, the outrageous that rise to public conscious - and some from all camps that do not.
How does she look in her breakout hit? (Poker face)
Yea... that's right, she definitely looks "good".
A baby born the day The Monkees formed would be retiring now. That wildly popular band was literally created for a TV show.
This problem has been going on for a long time.
Today, it's mostly true that everything is available. The music that reaches the masses, though, is defined by production over musical quality.
Would we even see or hear from Cass Elliot, Janis Joplin, or Patsy Cline today? Producers would choose someone other than Patsy Cline for Crazy and twist Willie Nelson's arm to make him a ghostwriter on the song so the hot, autotuned, woman could claim she wrote it herself.
There is more to it than just getting older.