1. Tesla already opened up the NACS connector for others to use. We don't know the detail yet but the license fee is probably minimal if Ford and GM agree to join.
2. the CSS1 connector is monstrous compare to NACS, with design deficiencies that are more or less not fixable.
3. Your USB example would be more like manufacturers sticking with Serial port (with manual configuration and payment done by the user) vs plug-and-play USB 1.0 (still a pain but it's a huge improvement.)
4. Tesla has a larger and better charging infrastructure than EA etc. What's wrong with giving infrastructure subsidies to companies who proved they have a superior product? Or do you think that everyone deserves a piece of the pie, regardless of their technical competency?
Any licensing fee paid to a single company is unacceptable for what is described as an "open standard."
> the CSS1 connector is monstrous compare to NACS
Sure, it's bigger, but how is that a problem? It's not like you carry it with you. Nobody I know has ever had an issue physically working with it, including people 70+ years old.
> Tesla has a larger and better charging infrastructure than EA etc. What's wrong with giving infrastructure subsidies to companies who proved they have a superior product? Or do you think that everyone deserves a piece of the pie, regardless of their technical competency?
I have a big problem with companies getting infrastructure subsidies that they then use to rent-seek in the market and force other companies to pay them fees for access to publicly-funded infrastructure, yes.
I'm not saying subsidies have to be given equally, but subsidies should absolutely not be given to companies that limit the product of that subsidy (charging) based on licensing for profit.
https://www.tesla.com/blog/opening-north-american-charging-s...
I do agree that the connector needs to be a public standard and the licensing fee needs to be kept to a minimal.
(I am against free solely to cover the cost of standard validation similar to WiFi. As we see from USB-C, having 1000 companies of various quality developing charging cable is a disaster, but now it's 400V 500Amp connector.)
I assume they changed facetime to not infringe the patent (which was later found invalid anyway) in response so couldn't they just have opened up the changed version?
If that lawsuit affected their ability to go forward with facetime, facetime surely wouldn't exist at all so I don't understand why it explains facetime continuing to exist but not being open.
The latest event: https://www.reuters.com/legal/apple-wins-reversal-502-mln-vi...
It's since exploded into things beyond just FaceTime. The FaceTime one though, Apple ultimately lost their appeal in 2019 and paid out $440M for FaceTime infringement (so, yes, legally speaking, VirnetX won). It's now over VPN patents which had some patents cancelled.
With FaceTime being legally infringing... hard to make an open standard. Plus, why would they now? Not only would it primarily benefit the competition; but it would also undermine FaceTime's security. The beauty of FaceTime is that it is very much tied to physical devices, making it very expensive and difficult to spam call without detection. An open standard would likely lose that ability, causing spam video calls everywhere.
Noone has to pay Tesla to build vehicles that support this.
They might have to pay to get the level of app integration that they want, but that is a different thing.
> Network operators already have plans in motion to incorporate NACS at their chargers, so Tesla owners can look forward to charging at other networks without adapters.
And Tesla has already opened up charging to all EVs on some superchargers via the Magic Dock, but the situation isn't amazing, especially with many new cars using an 800 volt architecture and thus not charging super fast on Tesla's 400 volt superchargers. https://youtu.be/pUYqDNCIFD8
Combine this with how many charge port doors aren't on the back left or front right, and you have a really messy charging situation with blocked spots and slow charging cars.
The partnership most likely means:
- The cars will be 400 volt architecture (or otherwise 800v and upcoming V4 superchargers will support up to 1000 volts)
- The charging port door will be either on the front right quarter of the car, or back left quarter.
Also, in the original announcement, I wonder if ford meant they'll give CCS to Tesla adapters[0] so that you can plug in on existing infra.
It’s all bad software, poor maintenance, and bullshit silicon valley social networking stuff.
For instance, EA’s and evgo’s tap to pay terminals will fail to work regardless of whether you’re trying to charge with a tesla cord or a ccs cord.
And who is/are the "relevant standards bodies"? SAE? IEC? Other?
See also: HD Radio. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_radio#United_States
HD Radio on the other hand is just something of little interest to me personally. By the time I had a tuner with that feature, it also came with bluetooth which meant my device was doing the work and the radio was just a legacy thing that came with the device.
... do you understand how out of touch this is? Every single recent "public standard" will absolutely require paying license fees to some company, or often a whole pool of companies. This is simply how things are done, designing things cost money and that money is recouped through licensing. The key part is that the licenses are FRAND, or Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminating.
If the fee is to one company, it is usually an industry non-profit (HDMI, Bluetooth) that doesn't itself have a stake in the outcome. If it's a pool of companies they also have to hash things out amongst themselves and no one company will have control over another.
Neither of these situations apply to Tesla and 'NACS'.
If Tesla wants to give up control of 'NACS' to SAE or IEC, then we can talk.
I don't get audio when I use my DVR on Plex because of that.
There is no such thing as ATSC 3 audio. ATSC is the transmission standard, either ATSC 1 (basically everywhere, 1080p) or ATSC 3 in some cities ("Next-Gen TV", 4K). ATSC 1 uses Dolby Digital AC-3, ATSC 3 uses Dolby AC-4 which is otherwise quite rare.
Also, that's a very light example. Look into the patent situation for H.264 / AVC, H.265 / HEVC. They are Open Standards (you can download the documentation right now), but they are patent minefields to implement, with dozens of companies and hundreds, if not thousands of patents.
Also, to reply to the comment above you:
> If the fee is to one company, it is usually an industry non-profit (HDMI, Bluetooth) that doesn't itself have a stake in the outcome. If it's a pool of companies they also have to hash things out amongst themselves and no one company will have control over another.
What? HDMI is not an open standard - you need to pay to get the documentation, pass certification, and pay a royalty fee per device (about 5-15 cents per connector). You also need to license the logo because HDMI is actually a brand. Sure, anyone can get HDMI, but it sure ain't open. And if it's a TV or a monitor, better license HDCP separately. Also, as for Bluetooth... that was a patent minefield for decades.
Part of what makes Tesla so successful is that they can make EVs cheaply. Using NACS instead of CCS seems to be one factor in keeping costs down:
because the charge door is smaller, they can make it part of the trim instead of having to match it to the body
The plumbing from the charge door to the battery also seems more cost effective
Watt for watt, dropping weight makes a small but real improvement in EV range
The latch setup also seems better, on Plugshare I see a decent # of chargers that are out of commissions because of how CCS puts the latch on the EVSE
Shaving a few ounces isn't going to make a difference in range. With EVs, even adding a hundred pounds or two isn't changing the range that much. You get a ton of it back in regen so the vast majority of energy usage is rolling resistance (which a few pounds isn't changing) and aero drag (no weight difference at all).
All doors and bumpers on a car is attached to the body during the paint process, then the whole thing is painted, disassembled, and re-mated later to the same chassis, for better color matching.
That's maybe 12lbs of extra stuff. On a 4,500lb car. 12/4500. 0.2% difference in mass in a car with regen braking. You think that's enough for a difference in range?
I routinely get groceries weighing more than that. There's no effective difference in my range. I don't even have a noticeable hit in range with just a solo driver or four total people with bags, a difference of probably 600lbs or so.
The Lightning range estimates don't really change much with several hundred pounds of stuff in the bed. You really only start seeing range hits towing, and that's mostly because you're adding a lot of drag and extra rolling resistance with more tires.
I don't think the charge port is making that much of an impact on the range. Motor design and placement, aero drag, suspension, tires, battery size, inverter efficiency. These things will affect range, but not 12 extra pounds.
So the three wires would weigh 1-3 pounds total for six feet of cable.
The NACS latch is entirely driven by the car, which is fine for the owner of the car — assuming the car is working as it ought to, the owner can disconnect a charger. But there is no intelligent logic for when someone (owner or otherwise) ought to be able to disconnect the charger without the owner’s help. In many cases, it would make sense to be able to disconnect someone else’s car once it’s fully charged, and disconnecting or connecting a charger in the owner’s garage should not require unlocking the car.
The J1772 latch is substantially more complex, and I’ve seen it get stuck. This is quite nasty when it happens.
This seems like a bad idea for something designed by for use in public with no direct supervision. I would absolutely prefer that no one disconnect my car over having the ability to disconnect someone else's car. I can understand having some override that requires a little mechanical effort in the case of malfunction, repossession, or something like that. However, I wouldn't want any random person to be able to disconnect my car at their discretion. That is a recipe for chaos at charging stations. Plus the caveat of "once its fully charged", already means you need to let the car have at least partial control over the unlocking mechanism anyway.
I've got bad news for you regarding USB, DisplayPort and HDMI. All those connectors require paying license fees to their respective companies.
The plug is huge, the cables are heavy.. there is a poorly implemented locking mechanism that frequently breaks.. some people end up propping up the cable to support it so it doesn't trip that failure mode.
The CCS network companies in US are a joke, they are more than 5 year behind Tesla and building out slower than Tesla's current expansion.
On the east coast they are in less convenient locations, with fewer overall stations, with fewer stalls per station, with way higher failure rates, with much longer repair times.. and if you do happen to use it, the interface to activate charging is slower, error prone, and sometimes requires calling them.
I can go on and on.
CCS in US, lead by EA, has truly and utterly failed. I am less happy with them continuing to be propped up by government subsidies and carmaker bulk purchases, than I am to see Tesla get a little more money to support their incredible charging network.
I am an EV proponent and would never pressure any family member to buy a non-Tesla because I do not want to be responsible for their CCS experience. I say this, again, as a non-Tesla EV owner who is happier with my car than with my old Tesla.
There is no successful EV transition in the US in which we rely on the likes of the Electrify America, EVGo and Chargepoint.
i have a non tesla ev and it’s totally fine.
For EA, there’s also a 10% chance it’ll flip my car’s “oh my god you are trying to make me explode with bad voltage, abort! abort!” alarm/circuit breaker.
At home, there is no problem. For a given evgo charger, there is no problem (so I know it isn’t my car).
Also, the flaky data connection stuff from above is documented in the ea UI (and only seems to apply to them… they really suck).
I’ll begrudgingly admit that chargepoint generally works, but screw them for having an app (and they’re mostly only level 2 anyway).
Also, there are a half dozen smaller networks, each of which is also a fractal snowflake of bullshit like this.
It really isn’t. Driving my Leaf or i3 beyond 70 miles round trip is absolute Russian roulette. Will the charger be in service? Will it accept payment? Will it accept payment and then, for unknowable reasons, just not initiate charging?
Contrast that with driving 2000 miles round trip in a Tesla. There’s not going to be any trouble charging, ever.
It actually does cause reliability issues. A common troubleshooting tip for a CCS (Type 1) charge failing to start is to lift up and push in on the handle while the charge is starting to make sure the data pins make good contact for the initial handshake.
I'm sure Ford and GM have some real world reliability metrics around this at this point.
My understanding is this is unique to CCS Type 1 used in North America, which uses an external lever at the top of the connector to latch it to the vehicle. CCS Type 2 used in Europe and elsewhere uses internal latch points where the vehicle locks the connector to the port during charging and doesn't seem to have the same issue.
So if I want to purchase a NACS charger for my house, besides Tesla, what are my options?
> 2. the CSS1 connector is monstrous compare to NACS, with design deficiencies that are more or less not fixable.
Besides size apparently, what are these "design deficiencies" that you speak of?
It’s kind of the chicken and egg problem, but should work itself out since they seem adamant about making it a free, open standard.
You'll forgive me if I don't believe them, considering their last PR release pre-2021 about it being an "open standard" included the fine print of Tesla gaining permanent access to all of your IP if you used it.
https://www.tesla.com/blog/opening-north-american-charging-s...
What does this mean? Who is doing the ratification? SAE? IEC? Other?
This plastic locking mechanism on a CCS handle can break if it's abused, leaving it in an unsafe state to use
The locking mechanism can also break on the car. Its way more challenging to fix. Also, I'd prefer to always be able to quickly and easily manually unlatch it, which isn't true on a Tesla. On most models the manual release is tucked pretty deep in the car.
It has to capture the CCS latch and is often a little flipper near the top of the car's inlet.
Tesla's larger network is just classic first mover advantage and output setting. Not an indication their (charging) product is "technically superior".
Open standards with nominal fees are pretty standard.
You mean the organizations/standards that are run by non-profits where multiple competitors get together and hash things out so that no one company has a leg up on another?
Home theater receivers use HDMI because the vast majority of things a home user is going to use with it also uses HDMI.
Legacy and network effects: home A/V has HDMI because HDMI is on all home A/V equipment.
At this point you can probably have either/both and things would work fine.
Then it was "it's not really free if they charge a fee", but that's common enough to be standard practice.
Now it's "But their org structure".
Not only is this a moving goalpost, I wonder if we're asymptomatically approaching "I just think Elon is a tool". Even if not, the news on TFA is good, because Tesla chargers are now more open.
They aren’t entitled to gouge but please explain why they shouldn’t be allowed to profit from being a huge first mover?
Sure seems like there are seeing as how finding a dispenser with both CCS and Tesla is like finding a unicorn. You'd think someone would have been rolling them out years ago alongside Tesla.
Also, they did it in the most EVGo way possible. There was a high traffic route near me with no superchargers. EVGo had a location, but no adapter. But EVGo would put units like that in the same parking lot as supercharger. :facepalm
More recently, a lot of manufacturers want to do it, but there's a different constraint. High quality cable and connector manufacturers are not yet making Tesla connectors in volume. Tesla doesn't sell their own cables and connectors to third parties. I'm hearing that this will all change by next year, though.
At least one charger company (Freewire, IIRC) has committed to using them.
If there were third party natively Tesla compatible chargers (including payment negotiation), are you really saying you'd never use them? Like, if your hotel had a third party one, or there was the Tesla one off the highway a few miles away, you'd go.out of your way to go to the Tesla one? What if the third party ones were cheaper?
I totally get most Tesla owners ignoring CCS chargers currently. Most owners don't have adapters, many chargers would require some app for a subpar billing experience, people don't like the connector, etc. But I wouldn't understand people choosing Tesla ones over similarly equipped ones. It'd be like driving well out of your way to always use Shell stations while you pass up an Exxon, a Phillips, a Wawa, etc.
I also have the CCS adapter, but I've rarely used it. It does help when the CCS station is more convenient. I've had that happen a couple of times, but it is remarkably rare.
The opposite situation, CCS but no Tesla Supercharger access would be a lot less pleasant.
Having a few DCFC plugs would encourage people to rotate through more. Plug in when you first get there, get checked in and settled, then move the car. Bonus points for valet service doing it.
That or have a lot of L2 plugs.
67% of EVs shipped in North American in Q3 2022 supported NACS. While that % may have gone down in subsequent quarters, it goes up historically. That means the majority of EVs in North America already support NACS.
It's far easier for other manufacturers to adopt NACS than it is for Tesla to adopt CCS Combo 1.
What adapters are you talking about here? I can't figure out if this is real.
Edit: Oh, you're talking about the proposed adapter as part of this deal.
> As a purely electrical and mechanical interface agnostic to use case and communication protocol, NACS is straightforward to adopt. The design and specification files are available for download, and we are actively working with relevant standards bodies to codify Tesla’s charging connector as a public standard. Enjoy.
https://www.tesla.com/blog/opening-north-american-charging-s...
Is there any evidence of the license fee you mention?
CSIRO (Australia's science and technology research agency) developed WiFi and made the design "public". However, they also held a patent for that technology.
After other companies adopted WiFi as the standard, CSIRO went to the biggest users (BroadCom, AT&T, Lenovo, etc) and sued them for patent infringement. [1]
There are a few things that Tesla could do here. If they are building all of the charging infrastructure, and other manufacturers use the Tesla proprietary plug, does that mean other chargers can automatically use it as well? If not, that removes those players from the market - but as I understand it, Tesla chargers are way better anyway.
I'm sure Ford and GM lawyers are all over the potential implications of this in the future, but I think it's best not to consider public and proprietary as completely orthogonal.
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/04/how-the-aussie-g...
Earlier today, I was hearing about the marketing benefit Tesla will get from everyone going to their chargers. It has 2 benefits.
How would Apple have benefitted if everyone who owned a PC had to go to an Apple store to buy a USB cable?
Also, Tesla will now build more of their charging network, putting their brand in more places.
So, just in the marketing alone, it's a huge win for Tesla.
Which one? Thunderbolt/USB4 (which pretty much still requires intel only solutions/chips)
How about HDMI? ;)
doesnt it require licensing patents from Qualcomm to implement?
CCS is not fit for purpose, even more so the CCS chargers.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fq0RAjJ1PKQ
They are absolute garbage hardware with a clunky, fragile connector.
And the only company deploying them at scale is doing so because they (VW) were forced to when settling Dieselgate.
The NACS standard is public, and any auto or charger manufacturer is free to equip them, or make as many as they'd like.
Then there's the separate issue of whether or not a given car will communicate with a charger -- that is using the CCS standard, which is managed by a standards group.
So you have a free connector design, the ability to anybody and their dog to make adapters (although you probably shouldn't use a dog-designed adaptor), and the important part (the charging protocol) being controlled by the consortium you seem enamored by.
Tesla has already said their charging network will become EV-agnostic, making that an open standard.
You have to be strangely self-centered to proclaim that you can't understand why people are excited, and somewhat unwilling to read.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_facto_standard
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Format_war
I also think about other standards that went the proprietary way, like DirectX over OpenGL.
that said, tesla has done a really GOOD job. Their superchargers are everywhere, they have a many stalls at each location and they charge quickly.
It's why non Tesla chargers are such a compatibility mess. There are a few emerging standards like plug & charge and a mess of ISO and other specifications. So, things are slowly improving but there are still lots of issues with cars and chargers not being compatible with each other, weird payment processes and complexity, enormous testing overhead to deal with all the silly hacks, workarounds, bugs, etc. CCS is a bit of a train wreck as a standard and it's a bit user hostile. And very much a work in progress.
The Tesla ecosystem predates all of that and is un-apologetically a Tesla ecosystem that has been running smoothly for many years that has none of those issues. While other vendors insisted EVs were a fad, Tesla actually invested in lots of chargers which is why they dominate the market.
The Tesla charging experience is best in class in this industry. It is a standard in its own right as well. Tesla positions NACS as an alternative to CCS. And like CCS, you can license it in order to use it and it is well specified. Ford and GM just chose to license NACS in addition to CCS to enable a better charging experience for their users. Nothing wrong with that. I'd say, more vendors will probably do this and that would effectively make it an industry standard just like CCS is. All an industry standard is is different companies agreeing on some specifications and signing licensing agreements with each other.
I think instead of governments dictating half broken specifications as standards or endorsing this or that consortium, it's better to just let the industry sort things out by itself.
I genuinely don't know why people are excited to replace an open standard with a proprietary one. Imagine if all USB development were hamstrung and required to go through an Apple approval process, and every device you bought had to pay the Apple tax for a lightning port?
In addition, it seems that in the way the way the language is worded, Tesla's connector now qualifies for infrastructure subsidies because it can charge multiple makes of vehicles, even though it's limited to only those makes that have paid them the tax*. That's appalling.
* this is made clear by their discussion of the Tesla to CCS adapters, which are vendor locked to only charge GM and Ford vehicles. Everyone with a different brand of car is left out. "Open standard"? I don't think so.