News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TheCaptain4815 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:14PM (#36077011)
Elons point on cars being worth 5x as much with self driving shouldn’t be dismissed. If a car that costs $25,000 to manufacture all of a sudden can be driven 40-50 hours a week automatically, how much is that car now worth?

So I totally disagree on that end, as do most investors given teslas enormous valuation.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by rurp on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:28PM (#36077192)
Elon doesn't actually believe that Tesla cars are about to quintuple in value now, any more than he did 7+ years ago when he first started saying it; that's just marketing BS.

> So I totally disagree on that end, as do most investors given teslas enormous valuation.

Yes, and most Gamestop investors think the company is going to be the next Amazon. Buying a popular meme stock doesn't make their predictions right.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TheCaptain4815 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:04PM (#36077573)
And he’s admitted self driving was way more difficult than anyone realized, so his dream is gonna be delayed 5-10 years like most of his other major ones.

It’s now 2013, want to see a video of Starship taking off?

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by JumpinJack_Cash on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:24PM (#36077742)
> > And he’s admitted self driving was way more difficult than anyone realized,

Sure and the guy is getting paid right now in cold hard cash, while all the synchopants keep ranting about hopes and dreams.

> > It’s now 2013, want to see a video of Starship taking off?

Want to see a sample of what Microsoft's ChatGPT can do?? It's amazing! But that has nothing to do with Microsoft giving Apple a run for its money in the smartphone market like Ballmer predicted back in 2012

There is no correlation between the 2 things just like there is no correlation between rockets and self driving cars, and it's laughable that synchopants think they are correlated just because thought leader and cult of personality enthusiast Elon Musk is both the founder of SpaceX and the petty individual who sued for the right to be called the founder of Tesla

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by austhrow743 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:33PM (#36077821)
Elon is paid in stock not cash.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by JumpinJack_Cash on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:33PM (#36077828)
that he regularly sells.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by philippejara on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:01PM (#36078064)
And is bought by people that think the company is valuable enough to give the stock said value. You can argue that those people are wrong, sure, but I don't get what point you're trying to make. He isn't taking money away from someone else or being given "underserved" rewards, when the people that are keeping the value of what he receives believes it to be of such value.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by JumpinJack_Cash on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:10PM (#36078131)
Point is that you first sign off the effing self-driving car, then you get your effing money.

That is what we used to do in America, since the days of JD Rockefeller, Henry Ford...but also Steve Jobs and Bill Gates and Larry Ellison. I mean I used Windows before Gates became richest man in the world and so did hundreds of millions of people.

Musk got to #1 by selling go karts to a handful of rich people and promises of future selfdriving and total domination of the EV sector which is not even sure to be the winner in the decarbonization of cars

The vast majority of Americans have never even set foot in a Tesla.

You seem to condone the poker game that Wall St. has become, I don't agree with that because entrepreneurship shouldn't be about bluffing and then offloading your hand to a bigger fool. We do that in Vegas, like men where at least you have to look in the eyes the dude you are screwing over.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by dmix on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:31PM (#36078289)
How do you expect self driving cars, or any extremely hard technology, to come about then without long term risk capital via public/private investment? Just pure R&D working out of universities and gov labs? Let them perfect it and only then try to raise capital? Go back to the Rockefeller days before there was venture capital and mature public markets?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TylerE on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:03PM (#36078885)
> The vast majority of Americans have never even set foot in a Tesla.

Not so sure about that. Model 3s seem to rapidly replacing Civics as the Uber car of choice.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by philippejara on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:15AM (#36079824)
so what do you propose is to be done? you simply stop people from buying tesla stock so that the price doesn't go up and he doesn't get as much money? Seriously i'm really struggling to understand what you are proposing here.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by badpun on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:14AM (#36082221)
You stop the fed from printing so much money. I mean, right now it's too late, but for the future, it would be a good policy.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by freejazz on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:05PM (#36086866)
> And is bought by people that think the company is valuable enough to give the stock said value.

They say a sucker is born every minute

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TheCaptain4815 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:54PM (#36077998)
My point was Elon has an incredible track record of success which follows a formula of overhype, delays, and eventual achievement if not overachievement.

You seem to have a more personal vendetta against him, I’m just looking at his insane success and envying hype/ management style

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:28PM (#36078267)
> My point was Elon has an incredible track record of success which follows a formula of overhype, delays, and eventual achievement if not overachievement.

His biggest success is the rocket industry. Let's examine top competitors - corrupt ULA which flies rockets on 50 year old engines and does cost+ contracts, his other competitor was Russia, a corrupt kleptocracy that stopped innovating when USSR fell apart. Russia would sell engines physically made in USSR to ULA. This market literally had no competition and no innovation for like 40 years.

So yes, his great achievement is that he could march finance into an industry that no-one would consider for investment. But results in other industries were not so great.

Tesla had a head start on electric, but they could not take advantage of this. Once other manufacturers woke up to the threat, it became clear Tesla has nothing on them, and car industry is fiercely competitive. His leadership was not good enough to take advantage of the head start he had and extremely high level of finance that he had.

Where is cybertruck? Other automakers are already selling electric trucks. VW and even Chinese automakers are eating Tesla's lunch.

Elon's boring company is an abject failure, as is hyperloop.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by mensetmanusman on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:53PM (#36078450)
Cybertruck is delayed because people are still buying other high margin vehicles.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by pmorici on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:56PM (#36078472)
“ Tesla had a head start on electric, but they could not take advantage of this. Once other manufacturers woke up to the threat, it became clear Tesla has nothing on them, and car industry is fiercely competitive.”

Is there any other car company in the world selling electric vehicles at a profit besides Tesla? Everyone else is losing money on their EVs most are losing a lot of money. Not only is Tesla profitable but they have better margins than many companies have on their gas cars.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by what-the-grump on Thursday May 25, 2023 @11:00PM (#36079263)
If you are looking to buy a car in 2023 and you are not looking at a model y or a model 3…

Tesla is the only car to drop prices in 2023, and the only car that doesn’t feel like you are paying 50% more for whatever you got 3 years ago.

Anything else at the 40-50k usd range is simply a joke compared to model y, and Tesla is simply eating the market right now.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by throw9away6 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @11:30PM (#36079472)
Nah Tesla is just goosing the government subsidies hard. The ioniq5 is a great car just doesn’t qualify for inflation increase act subsidies
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by shushpanchik on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:54AM (#36082494)
If that's the case, why Tesla easily beats any other opponent overseas as well? Here, in Australia, they do not get any subsidies. Model 3 and Y sales are leaving all others, including Ioniq, far behind.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by throw9away6 on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:14PM (#36090908)
Other manufacturers haven’t had time to scale up production. Also the direct you consumer model has been a real winner in preventing dealer price gouging due to shortages
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by throwawayadvsec on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:58PM (#36078489)
If someone built a dozen companies, and like a third of them succeeded and made him one of (if not the) richest man in the world, I think you could say that that person "has an incredible track record of success"

and I don't even like this guy, but this is just dishonest from you

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:32PM (#36078675)
What was successful after Tesla and SpaceX?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by dizhn on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:18AM (#36079846)
Parent might be including PayPal too. Though it's not clear what Musk's involvement in their success was.

By the way, if you or I owned either one of the companies you mentioned it would be considered a great success. Your question itself is putting Musk in a league of his own. I don't care that he's an asshole. If someone asked the three of us to eject into space a car that we built, only he could comply.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by fakedang on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:38AM (#36080792)
I would say that PayPal was a success because of the mafia (which mostly consists of Thiel and Levchin's team by the way). I would argue that Musk actually hampered PayPal in many ways (pushing Windows as the dev environment, as one example, when the rest of the team wanted Linux).

That being said, SpaceX and Tesla are successful, even if they took government subsidies to get started. There are many more companies which took a lot of government money yet managed to return nothing except fat bonuses for their executives. Or the number of large companies which have stopped innovating now (IBM and Intel for instance).

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by dotancohen on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:32AM (#36080759)

  > What was successful after Tesla and SpaceX?
Is Tesla and SpaceX not enough of a track record? Seriously, if that is not a track record of success, what is a track record of success by your measure?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by fakedang on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:39AM (#36080798)
2 successful billion dollar companies is more than what most people can boast of.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by abletonlive on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:39PM (#36078718)
Your bias against elon is showing and it's not a good look. You're not being very rational.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:27PM (#36079029)
I used to be a fan, then he showed up to the cave rescue operation with half a submarine, and in responce to crtiticism he called rescue divers pedoes.

So I started wondering, can he be a good leader when he can't take criticism? How does he retain best pepple if his ego is this fragile?

I am quite happy to see more people reassess him as he demonstrates capricious and callous behavioir, for exanple the Twitter aquisition whoch he first wanted then tried to get out of.

I think you will come around when he targets something yoi carw about.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by abletonlive on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:23AM (#36079882)
No, I won't, because I don't think he's a faultless person. In fact, I think he's quite an asshole, but I can rationally separate who he is from his long list of accomplishments.

Just because you want him to be a failure or a con-artist or whatever doesn't mean he actually is.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by birdyrooster on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:52AM (#36080509)
Elon's biggest accomplishment is how he optimizes for capital growth by any means necessary and is willing to throw norms to the wind and think very big. Elon never had to be a good people person to succeed here. It is why successful companies allow brilliant jerks... they are so brilliant it makes up for their asshole nature. Elon is this, as much as it pains me to say it.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TylerE on Friday May 26, 2023 @03:29PM (#36088571)
Jerk is not a synonym for bigoted asshole.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by freejazz on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:04PM (#36086848)
Why do people emphasis rationality when reasonability is much more important?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by abletonlive on Monday May 29, 2023 @03:20PM (#36117051)
Why do people make semantic arguments disguised as philosophy instead of making a concrete point and furthering the discussion? Seems like a cop out to me. It's tempting to respond to everything online and hit enter but sometimes you don't have to if you don't have anything meaningful to say.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by freejazz on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @12:41PM (#36127048)
It's not remotely philosophical. What's the point of emphasizing what is rational, when the likely answer is within a much smaller subset (what is reasonable). You overemphasize rationality to the point you aren't reasonable. You sit here and talk about what is rational, but you aren't reasonable and therefore it's not a good argument. We aren't dealing in the abstract world of mathematics, we are dealing with human relationships.

"It's tempting to respond to everything online and hit enter but sometimes you don't have to if you don't have anything meaningful to say."

What a projection

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by abletonlive on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:53PM (#36144877)
There is nothing reasonable about pretending like Elon isn't accomplished because you don't like him.

Happy?

It's not reasonable to pretend like Tesla/spacex is not a smashing success story.

You're not dealing with human relationships. What are you talking about. The parent of my original comment is spinning a narrative about Elon's accomplishments because of his personality quirks.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by freejazz on Thursday June 01, 2023 @01:14AM (#36147795)
Well Tesla has significantly devalued as of late, is facing tremendous regulatory scrutiny, just recently suffered a massive recall, and is likely never going to deliver on its key promise of achieving practicable self-driving car, and by all estimates from anyone else in the industry, is being completely unreasonable in going about it predominantly via computer-vision.

so as an initial, I don't think your argument is reasonable at all. it goes against so of the most basic and recent facts about tesla. I can understand feeling different because you like him and he makes you feel fuzzy or something like that. but hard to say you are being reasonable - when you don't offer reasons!

> The parent of my original comment is spinning a narrative about Elon's accomplishments because of his personality quirks.

This is absolutely the boundaries of human relationships and is not better defined in the space of mathematics or physics, or even game theory, to the point you boil things down to being rational/un-rational. rational is basically the lowest boundary here, it means possible, it doesn't mean likely.

>There is nothing reasonable about pretending like Elon isn't accomplished because you don't like him.

I guess it depends on what you think accomplished is. I certainly think he's achieved a certain kind of status in society, I'm not sure if it's an accomplishment, but the amount of money that belongs to him is certainly very large and something anyone else would like to have.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by abletonlive on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @08:49PM (#36235722)
>Well Tesla has significantly devalued as of late,

So have a lot of companies? Tesla is down 7% in the last year. Up 12% from 2 years ago. Another example of unreasonable hyperbole.

> is facing tremendous regulatory scrutiny, just recently suffered a massive recall,

A massive recall fixed by over the air updates? Be real. Yet another example of hyperbole.

> and is likely never going to deliver on its key promise of achieving practicable self-driving car,

Okay this is speculation. What can I really say about this?

> and by all estimates from anyone else in the industry, is being completely unreasonable in going about it predominantly via computer-vision.

what does this have to do with elon's success? He's not allowed to fail sometimes?

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by DennisP on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:57PM (#36078839)
> Tesla had a head start on electric, but they could not take advantage of this.

The Model Y is currently the world's best-selling car. I think that counts as Tesla taking advantage.

https://www.motor1.com/news/669135/tesla-model-y-worlds-best...

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by firecall on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:20PM (#36078987)
Agreed on some points.

Although I do think Tesla did take advantage of their head start. But it’s clear that the pandemic and issues with China and supply chains are hampering them globally.

And sure, Tesla launched successful Electric cars and woke the market up when they realised consumers actually really would switch.

But it’s not like other manufacturers couldn’t do it, they just chose not to.

The biggest thing Tesla did was actually making it happen with vehicles that were significantly differentiated and looked like the future!

In a market where companies stopped selling sedans in favour of SUVs, Teslas came along with the model 3 and then model Y, and showed people will choose electric tech over SUV form factor.

People weren’t buying ICE sedans because they were largely garbage!

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by dotancohen on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:34AM (#36080766)

  > The biggest thing Tesla did was actually making it happen with vehicles that were significantly differentiated and looked like the future!
Tesla also invested in charging infrastructure - taking care of both the chicken and the egg.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by sssilver on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:58AM (#36080931)
I think it would be fair to state that every single electric car on the market today would have been radically different if Tesla didn’t exist.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by JumpinJack_Cash on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:29PM (#36078271)
Success is measured by hypothetical subtraction.

If you disappeared Tesla, SpaceX, Boring, Twitter and even Mr.Musk overnight, the world would look exactly the same the following morning.

Try and disappear Apple, Microsoft, Cisco, Boeing, JPMorgan, BankofAmerica, Exxon, Royal Dutch Shell overnight.

You'll have chaos and civil unrest within a week. That's where your quality of life comes from, sure it's not as exciting aas drinking the kool-aid of future Mars colonies and self driving cars and 100% domination in the EV cars sector, but at least it's real

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by mensetmanusman on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:53PM (#36078454)
Actually, Ukraine said they would have lost already without starlink.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:54PM (#36079214)
Hardly, Starlink has had some impact on Ukraine but not nearly that much. They have called it “critical” but they call a great many things critical, the actual use of Starlink still isn’t that common.

The important bit for Ukrainian is Starlink is subsidized by other countries and it reduces the incentives for Russia to destroy communication infrastructure. Unfortunately because Russia is focusing less on communication infrastructure they get to focus more on other targets.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by mensetmanusman on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:57PM (#36079233)
People following this closely disagree.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Thursday May 25, 2023 @11:21PM (#36079407)
A few of those people do, but it’s a minority opinion.

People say same seriously crazy shit about the Ukraine war, but the ground truth is fairly pedestrian as far as recent wars go.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by re-thc on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:20PM (#36078983)
> If you disappeared Tesla, SpaceX, Boring, Twitter and even Mr.Musk overnight, the world would look exactly the same the following morning.

No it won't. Where would the Twitter trolls go? They'd flood the streets. If Twitter had disappeared no 1 can announce for president anymore!

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by eimrine on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:33AM (#36080764)
> Where would the Twitter trolls go? They'd flood the streets.

Compare this argumentation with typical argumentation about violenceful computer games players which are also going to flood the streets for some different reasons but with similar unwanted outcomes.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by rsynnott on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:48AM (#36083348)
I assume the person you're replying to wasn't being entirely serious :)
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by re-thc on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:48AM (#36093093)
> wasn't being entirely serious :)

Thanks for understanding.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by notmypenguin on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:13PM (#36078150)
Easy there, cowboy, he’s had incredible success whipping his fans into frothing frenzies of self congratulatory adulation that would make a seesaw get dizzy. No other boss person since the mighty Steve has had this effect on the mass psyche, and Elon has arguably done a lot less. I claim teslas success is in spite of him, not because of him. Facts matter, and the SEC case was where I first realized his lack of leadership skill, and boasting about tanking his own stock price was not impressive. He’s not impressive, rather dull and low imagination if you ask me, which you didn’t, as you were busy falling over yourself to worship Elon Musk, who sounds like a cheap cologne
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ironSkillet on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:46PM (#36079144)
...this...has to be a troll right? The guy helped bring space flight out of a stagnant era into commercial viability and put electric cars into the world's popular psyche.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:41PM (#36079114)
SpaceX has been quite successful, though it also came really close to failing.

Solar city actually failed as an independent company.

Boring company is floundering.

Twitter is having massive issues.

I think he’s done more harm to Tesla after taking it over from the original founders than been a benefit. It’s unclear but he definitely took massive risks which were unnecessary and has many serious failures such as how long their truck has slipped.

All together not a bad track record, but also not nearly as impressive as many people seem to think. I don’t want to suggest it’s luck, but many companies that might have been successful which came that close to failure simply failed. We look back on people who happened to have passed those thresholds because they go past them not necessarily because they had a better approach.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by chii on Thursday May 25, 2023 @11:50PM (#36079620)
> has many serious failures such as how long their truck has slipped.

i wouldn't call the cybertruck a true failure, since it's effectively free marketing, and they don't have a real obligation to make a sale.

Tesla's massive competitive moat is their battery making capacity. I do not believe the incumbent car manufacturers are able to catch up any time soon.

It would be the chinese manufacturers of electric cars that pose the biggest threat to tesla, not the US/western incumbents.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:27AM (#36079916)
Tesla is down to 54% of US EV sales (it’s much worse globally) and it’s been falling very quickly. So, their battery moat is basically gone, and the need for the recent price drop amid such rapidly expanding EV sales is a really bad sign.

A significant part of that is they lack of a truck option considering how popular the Ford Lightning, Rivian, etc are. Alongside that is the general perception of stagnation among car buyers, the yoke was seen as a gimmick not the refresh the model S is in serious need of.

They just keep fumbling. Consider the amount of bad press they got around the undersized breaks on the Plaid or their 1 foot rollout numbers. What could have been a real halo product did almost as much harm as it helped.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by biaachmonkie on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:48AM (#36080861)
This is such a silly criticism, of course Tesla's share of the "EV Car" market is going to shrink as more companies sell EV cars. DUH! But that is a silly way to view things, Toyota was never compared on their share of the "Hybrid Car Market", because that is not a real thing, just as the "EV Car" market isn't really a thing, people buy cars and to the extent they cross shop they generally do so across drive trains.

Tesla's share of the overall Automotive market is growing and that is what matters.

The Model S is a tiny and irrelevant portion of Tesla's sales.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:43AM (#36085639)
The Halo effect / most premium products do drive sales. This is graphics card manufacturers care about the speed crown for a product launch even if their most expensive products are a trivial number of sales.

The perception of the plaid being unsafe unconditionally extends to people viewing all their cars as unsafe irrespective of actual crash statistics etc. The same thing happened with self diving car fatalities it’s a trivial number of accidents but still impacted people’s perception of the brand.

> Tesla's share of the overall Automotive market is growing and that is what matters.

The company’s stock price is based on the assumption they can ride the wave of exponentially increasing EV sales and take a large share of the global car market. Having largely squandered that opportunity the company’s prospects are far less favorable.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by pfannkuchen on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:05AM (#36079754)
> I think he’s done more harm to Tesla after taking it over from the original founders than been a benefit.

Didn't every single product launch happen after the takeover? We probably would have never heard of the company otherwise, why would we assume a similar trajectory with different leadership? It's like saying Jobs did more harm than good after returning to Apple.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:38AM (#36079998)
No.

Tesla was founded in 2003, Musk invested in 2004, Roadster unveiled in 2006 and entered production in 2008. October 2008, Musk took over as CEO of the company which went public in 2010. The model S entered production in 2012 and they discontinued the roadster.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by youngtaff on Friday May 26, 2023 @03:56AM (#36081322)
The boring company was always hype… we’ve known how to use TBMs to drill tunnels for years
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:02PM (#36085938)
I mean we’ve known how to use rockets for decades, but SpaceX was a good idea.

TBMs are just slightly too expensive right now. At 1/2 the price per mile a huge number of projects suddenly become very attractive. Which then opens the door for more economies of scale, further efficiencies, and in theory a very valuable company.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by youngtaff on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:35PM (#36087281)
There are plenty of lower cost TBM options, low enough cost for my local water company to be using a mini one to dig a 12 mile sewer near where I live
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Retric on Friday May 26, 2023 @09:22PM (#36091229)
Lower cost, but not cheaper because you can’t use them for the same things. Aka a toy car costs less than a real one but isn’t a cheaper transportation option.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by youngtaff on Sunday May 28, 2023 @05:23AM (#36102449)
But you can’t use the Boring Company’s TBM to drill ‘real’ tunnels - it’s build for tiny Tesla car sized tunnels (which aren’t actually that much larger than the local sewer being bored)

Trains i.e. proper mass transit, require wide bore tunnels and cost increases with the diameter of the bore

A lot of the costs with tunnels isn’t the tunnel but things like the portals that need to dissipate pressure waves as trains enter and leave at high speed

The boring company produced a smallish bore TBM and then ‘oh look it’s cheaper than a large one’, there is no innovation there

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by freejazz on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:02PM (#36086818)
> My point was Elon has an incredible track record of success

Um what? He has a rocket company where he basically has absolutely no involvement at all...

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by gumby on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:16PM (#36078174)
> …while all the synchopants keep ranting…

We definitely now live in a world that needs this word. I am now adopting it myself. Thanks!

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Prickle on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:21PM (#36078207)
> no correlation between rockets and self driving cars,

This is actually false. Automation of vehicle controls has a surprisingly large overlap between air/space and land.

The main difference is the amount of traffic and lack of vibration dampening.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by tsuujin on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:37PM (#36078701)
Do you mean “sycophants” or is “synchopants” a new word I’m not trendy enough to know yet?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by swader999 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:37PM (#36078332)
"It’s now 2013, want to see a video of Starship taking off?" Can they even build a strong enough launch pad to handle starship?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by DennisP on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:51PM (#36078807)
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by swader999 on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:59AM (#36082522)
That is awesome!
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by SecretDreams on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:20AM (#36082679)
If his dream involves people dying using FSD along the way, it's a nightmare.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by pnt12 on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:55AM (#36082924)
> that anyone realized

Not to be pedantic, but lots of people "realized" (or predicted) this, myself included.

He promised something, charged for it, and had little to show for. To me that's a big mistake, not little "ooopsie shit happens".

And it's not clear this will be fixed 10 years from now. Experimental research often fails in some stage between research and production.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Nextgrid on Friday May 26, 2023 @09:49AM (#36084087)
Rocketry and self-driving are completely different domains of difficulty. Rocketry is a solved problem - the basic math works, we've done it before, the challenge now is building upon that knowledge, refining it and increasing efficiency, but the basics have been figured out and proven since we've launched the first satellites in orbit. SpaceX is successfully doing this.

Unsupervised self-driving in an unconstrained environment is a completely different game. The reason humans can drive is that they have millions of years of evolution in both low-level image processing, reasoning, etc, diverse knowledge of the world that an individual obtains during the course of their life which can be blended in various ways to make driving-related decisions, as well as a sense of self-preservation that generally forces them to err on the side of caution. Short of a major AGI breakthrough, safe self-driving on existing road infrastructure is impossible.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by 4gotunameagain on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:11AM (#36084412)
> Rocketry is a solved problem - the basic math works, we've done it before, the challenge now is building upon that knowledge

This is not true. The only thing that enabled the reusability of SpaceX rockets was the convexification of the soft landing problem, a novelty by Lars Blackmore.

Sure, you could argue the the model predictive control scaffolding was pre-existing, but so was linear algebra for self driving.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by sidcool on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:22PM (#36087847)
Countries have failed at rocketry. It's not a solved problem.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by throwawayadvsec on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:54PM (#36078459)
Personally I believe it, I'm not sure about the year, but someone is going to make a fully autonomous car in the next few years.

If you look at just CLIP, Dino, GPT-4, given the current pace of progress, it's pretty obvious that it's going to happen.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by polishdude20 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:56PM (#36078834)
So it happens, then people realize they can earn money with it, then tesla realizes they can sell it now for 4 times more. In the end, you're not going to earn 4 times more because Tesla or whoever makes the car will take that into account and skim off that top.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by fennecfoxy on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:36AM (#36082369)
As with everything, competitors will prevent a single offering from being priced too high.

I personally don't think Tesla will ever develop the FSD architecture that ends up used by everyone else.

Whilst I agree with Elon that _technically_ FSD could be done only with cameras, because that's how humans do it, humans only drive "fine" and not "perfectly". We need cameras, LIDAR and whatever other sensors we can fuse in.

The software that runs the thing will not be developed by a car company, because car companies (yes, even Tesla) are absolute dogshit at software. All of them. Every single one. They can't even make a proper entertainment system that isn't laggy, let alone all of the legwork & research required to piece together enough models in the right way for FSD that meets the lofty standards of the public (ie a perfect 0 fatalities, vs angry evolution-driven hormonal monkeys in multi-tonne hunks of steel powered by explosions whose fatality count grows every day at 3700 deaths/day, 8th leading cause of death globally).

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by brewtide on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:15PM (#36078950)
>Yes, and most Gamestop investors think the company is going to be the next Amazon. Buying a popular meme stock doesn't make their predictions right.

Unrelated but GameStop should combine combine games plus what RadioShack used to be for 'us', for modern times / tech / electronics

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by andsoitis on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:17AM (#36079838)
> Buying a popular meme stock

I don’t know that I would connote “meme stock” and “Tesla”

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by 93po on Friday May 26, 2023 @05:25PM (#36089691)
> Elon doesn't actually believe

What's your evidence of this?

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Finnucane on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:18PM (#36077076)
Is there a big market for $125,000 cars? Who needs a car 40 hours a week?
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by HDThoreaun on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:23PM (#36077137)
Uber
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by capableweb on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:34PM (#36077260)
How many cars does Uber own? I thought they offloaded all of that pesky "ownership" stuff to their custome.. I mean drivers / coworkers / employees / collaborating business owners / freelancers.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by manquer on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:52PM (#36077481)
The point being they could eliminate the human drivers and take the whole revenue instead of sharing it.

From ridesharing company PoV right now they are only taking 30%-50% of the revenue, and they have gaps in meeting demand due to resourcing challenges.

The business model is pretty solid if self driving taxis work even if its only in urban and suburbs

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by kibwen on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:15PM (#36077682)
Except that currently all the drivers also manage the inventory of physical cars, and all maintenance, and all legal liability. The parent's question is a good one. Owning and operating a fleet of cars is the core competency of a rental agency, not a ride-hailing app.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:38PM (#36078343)
> and all legal liability.

People really do not understand that the Companies like Uber, Airbnb and Deliveroo make a huge amount of money from offloading liability - it's suddenly not Deliveroo's fault that the guy delivering your pizza in London does this on illegal, unroadworthy e-bikewith no insurance, and in case of a crash he is liable. Airbnb routinely rents out apartments in blocks that have this forbidden in the leave / rental agreement.

If the human is gone, then liability offloading is impossible. You have noone to blame. That liability off-load is worth more to deliveroo than is the pittance they pay him.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by manquer on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:10PM (#36078918)
Self-driving won't make a difference to this structure though ?

The pitch Tesla (if you believe them) keeps making is we could rent out our cars when we don't use it to the rental networks. We still own the car ( and the liability ) and unlock RoI.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by manquer on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:07PM (#36078908)
Just a ride sharing app cannot reach the scale and revenue to justify the investments they have attracted. It is not realistic to raise $25+ Billion[1] just to be a pure SaaS startup.

Both Uber and Lyft[2] run rental businesses already, the model works where you can rent a car on a weekly basis just to drive on their apps, they cover maintenance and other services.

Uber will have to find a way to maintain their growth, and Lyft probably will be acquired by a rental network. The result is the same vertical integration.

[1] Uber's equity investment so far. SaaS startups can be valued lot more even $100s of billions, but pure tech companies do not raise that kind of cash. Stripe for example despite its delayed IPOs and ESOP issues has only raised $8B.

[2] They own some of the inventory and rest are from partners I believe.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by kklisura on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:15PM (#36077678)
> The point being they could eliminate the human drivers and take the whole revenue instead of sharing it.

Why would then Tesla even sell such cars if they can just compete and outcompete Uber?

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:02PM (#36078876)
Musk has already stated that Tesla will start a ride sharing service that FSD Tesla owners can participate in. It will also supposedly be exclusive (not allowed to do ride sharing for other services using FSD).

Google self driving car division has an agreement with Uber now.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by tyre on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:36PM (#36077855)
I don’t know about Uber but Lyft has a car rental service. Drivers can rent cars from Lyft to drive with Lyft. If the infrastructure is already there, going from “driver turns on an app to accept/reject a ride” to “we accept that automatically” is quite simple.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Gunnerhead on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:40PM (#36086500)
I don’t believe Lyft owns the cars, they just partner with the traditional car rental agencies. Uber also has a car rental service.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by CydeWeys on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:17PM (#36078182)
Which Waymo and possibly Cruise are on track to make cars for. Tesla though, nope. Their approach is fundamentally unsound and unworkable (just like Uber's internal effort was).
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by contravariant on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:34PM (#36077258)
5 people.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by kibwen on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:11PM (#36077642)
> If a car that costs $25,000 to manufacture all of a sudden can be driven 40-50 hours a week automatically, how much is that car now worth?

Cars depreciate based on distance driven, not on age. A car will need to be serviced every X miles and replaced every Y miles, and these numbers are independent of whether the car is driven one hour a week or forty. In no universe does driving more hours per week increase the value of a car.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by SECProto on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:36PM (#36077852)
You clearly don't drive in a location that heavily salts roads! Here, a 15 year old car with 50,000 km is only marginally better than a 15 year old car with 200,000km - and it's mostly because the lower mileage car has probably been driven less in the winter.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by xattt on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:22PM (#36077732)
Ultra-high mileage vehicles driven over short timeframes where rust doesn’t get a chance to set would probably get into wear-and-tear of structural welds. Something like how airframes are rated for x number of decompression cycles.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TylerE on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:04PM (#36141539)
Highly unlikely. Aluminum has a finite fatigue lifetime. Steel, as long as you stay below a (fairly high) threshold, lasts forever.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by highwaylights on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:23PM (#36077736)
Even if that reasoning were true, the valuation for Tesla doesn’t make much sense, given they’re not remotely close to a self-driving car in the way that the average customer would understand it.

They’re not delayed by a few years. The problem is intractable, unless you can limit the journey to a controlled scope.

I drive over multiple pathways and grassy lanes a week that aren’t mapped and have no markings. A self-driving car can’t arbitrarily account for something like that any time soon.

Waymo is able to operate a limited route in Phoenix because they restrict to best-case routes.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by jliptzin on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:57PM (#36078030)
FSD is a very small component of Tesla' current stock price. Some dumbasses are certainly buying Tesla because they think FSD is right around the corner, but dumbasses tend to not have a lot of money.

For any Tesla price estimate, you've got to pick a number, how many million vehicles the company will ship in say 2025.

Then pick an Average Selling Price, profit margin, and P/E multiple.

Divide by 3 billion to get the price per share of your estimate.

Considering Tesla is on track to deliver 1.8M vehicles this year and the delivery growth trajectory it's been on, 4M is a good target goal for 2025, $45k ASP, 10% profit margin, 30 P/E . . . from that I get $180, so today's price is fair as a base case for 2025.

$400 was a nice top in 2022 and I think we'll see it before 2025 as Tesla Energy starts contributing to the bottom line, each $1B of profit from energy is worth $10 on the share price (30 P/E, 3B shares).

If you think $180 for Tesla is way too high you have to account for that in the model...either 2025 deliveries will be a lot less than 4 million, or 10% profit margin will come way down, or P/E will come way down below 30 (it's currently 51).

https://www.reddit.com/r/teslainvestorsclub/comments/13obftu...

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by blake1 on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:47PM (#36078405)
This is not the way I would do stock valuation. PE is the ratio of future earnings will all its growth to current earnings, discounted. In the future, some of that growth will be in the past, and the PE will be expected to come down. This being Tesla, you could imagine some new fancy product, and not value it strictly as a car company.

Edit: I see that you actually addressed the PE roll down. Missed that on the first read.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ohgodplsno on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:57AM (#36080535)
>dumbasses tend to not have a lot of money.

If wealth made people smart or gave them taste, we'd know. Dumbasses do tend to have a lot of cash, that's why they can happen to be dumbasses repeatedly.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by jliptzin on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:46PM (#36088115)
Some dumbasses do, most don’t.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by badpun on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:24AM (#36082285)
> Considering Tesla is on track to deliver 1.8M vehicles this year and the delivery growth trajectory it's been on, 4M is a good target goal for 2025, $45k ASP, 10% profit margin, 30 P/E . . . from that I get $180, so today's price is fair as a base case for 2025.

That's a lot of assumptions. Why not wait 3 years till all those projections materialize, and buy it then for $180 (if the price is still there)? Currently, if you buy at $180, you're discounting all the uncertainty and risk included in your calculations. Not to mention, even if you're right, the stock will be worth $180 in 3 years from now, which means your money will be idling for 3 years if you buy now.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by highwaylights on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:54AM (#36085816)
This. It’s being priced as if the best possible case has already happened and can be taken for granted with 100% certainty, which if that’s the case, still means you’d be better somewhere else for the interim.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by jliptzin on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:41PM (#36088060)
Not really, since you’re getting everything else the company is working on essentially for free at this price, including energy, FSD, the robot, the AI hardware, etc.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by taneq on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:39PM (#36077877)
> If a car that costs $25,000 to manufacture all of a sudden can be driven 40-50 hours a week automatically, how much is that car now worth?

It’s worth what an Uber driver’s take-home pay would be for the same week after maintenance and depreciation costs.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by Gustomaximus on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:46PM (#36077929)
Less as that cost component is removed and replaced with an ROI on the cars costs.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by CydeWeys on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:16PM (#36078173)
Many people don't want to use their car as a robotic rideshare for hire. The inside is gonna get pretty not nice in a hurry.

At least when there's a human driver in a car, they can tell misbehaving people to knock it off. Not so when the car is unattended and robotic.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by freejazz on Thursday May 25, 2023 @07:46PM (#36077928)
Cars aren't suddenly going to cost more because of that...
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by ineedasername on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:22PM (#36078213)
The physical capabilities of the car do not increase with the # of hours it is driven. If you work a car 5x as hard, it will require a similar increase in maintenance and an overall shorter lifetime. (Lifespan. As measured in calendar years, not miles driven)

I’m not saying you’re completely wrong on the general concept, but the relationship between value increase and drivable time per week (or whatever unit of time) is not 1:1. There’s going to be some loss in there.

Also not all cars would see drive time increases. Those used as Ubers or similar certainly will, but that won’t displace the vast majority of car owners who will continue to own a car and drive it at similar rates for the convenience of having it immediately on hand, at all times, ready to go. If it self drives too then that’s great, the claw back some personal time during a commute etc.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by bryanlarsen on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:11PM (#36090118)
Good point. You're likely to get 200,000 - 300,000 miles out of a Tesla. That might take 5 years if used as a robotaxi or 20 years without, but the cost per mile and thus the value of the car will be comparable either way.

That might be different with an LFP Tesla, which have what should be 750,000 mile batteries.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by rootusrootus on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:31PM (#36078291)
First Tesla would have to make a car with plausible hardware for self driving. Not decade+ old cameras trying to do everything. Can't even reliably wipe the windshield at the right time. The idea of robotaxis is just a fantasy.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by HyperSane on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:32PM (#36078292)
Elon Musk is a modern day P. T. Barnum and Tesla will never have full self driving cars on the market.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by blabberwocky on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:16PM (#36078588)
For a brief moment, that car becomes worth a lot more. But as other manufacturers put FSD-capable vehicles on the road, values might in fact fall as overall capacity skyrockets. What is certain is that the cost of a ride will drop.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by yumraj on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:47PM (#36078775)
>Elons point on cars being worth 5x as much .... all of a sudden can be driven 40-50 hours a week ...

Look at it this way, assume humans drive, or need to be driven/travel, X miles per year.

Today, assuming a car drives Y miles per year, the market needs X/Y cars.

Given your argument, with self driving, a car runs nY miles per year, the demand for car will drop to X/nY, basically 1/n of before or maybe a little more, since after all the humans won't suddenly need to drive/travel nX miles per year.

So, if a car were to become worth 5x more, but we need 1/5x cars, the total market would remain the same.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TylerE on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:05PM (#36078897)
Self driving will increase demand, not decrease, as it will displace other less popular modes of transit. Why call an Uber or taxi after a night at the bar when you can just have your EV drive you home?

Why make a medium-distance flight, when you can just sleep in the back of your EV as it cruises down the highway overnight? (This will pare well with lay flat front seats what would allow turning the car into something like one of those airline sleep pods).

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by tremon on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:22PM (#36086194)
Self driving will increase demand, not decrease, as it will displace other less popular modes of transit

Are you sure? How many people right now own a car that they use mostly a few times per week? Car ownership right now is the only way to guarantee personal long-range transport. But if self-driving cars can replace taxis and even some form of public transport, car usage might go up but it's not clear to me that car ownership will go up along with it.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by TylerE on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:42PM (#36087370)
> How many people right now own a car that they use mostly a few times per week?

A lot fewer than the average SF/NYC bubbler probably thinks. It is the only viable means of transportation for probably 90% of americans.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:56PM (#36078833)
If cars drive themselves, you can let them out as Ubers when you don’t need to drive it. That could definitely mean less cars if they are priced aggressively. Peak is still a problem, but public transit can focus on peak rather than non peak (assuming Robo taxis are price efficient).

Even if we need 1/5 cars (and EVs do last longer, so without self driving, this will happen anyways), as long as the lost cars come from your competitors, it’s fine.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by yumraj on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:47PM (#36079153)
> as long as the lost cars come from your competitors, it’s fine.

It’s a rather arrogant, and unrealistic assumption, (on Tesla’s part if they are making it) that they will capture the entire market. It ain’t gonna happen.

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by haspok on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:24AM (#36082286)
> If cars drive themselves, you can let them out as Ubers when you don’t need to drive it.

This does not require self driving btw, but a more important question is: would you really? Would you let strangers in your private car? Would you want to clean it afterwards? Would you accept damages other people do to you car? Would it still be your car if strangers use it far more than you do? And at this point we have arrived at car sharing, which already exists today...

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by MisterBastahrd on Thursday May 25, 2023 @09:56PM (#36078832)
Not a much more than I'm already paying for it, because the technology will become ubiquitous and the cost should drop appropriately.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by olliej on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:00PM (#36078861)
Why does self driving impact this at all?

You can already lend out your car for other people to drive, and there are numerous companies that do exactly that as their entire business model.

So this is a serious question, in what way does self driving cars mean your personal car is going to be used more?

The only people for whom self-driving cars represent an actual real world monetary win are people and companies that transport people and things. So public transport, trucking companies, uber, etc - for them self driving would mean no longer having to pay for drivers.

For every other group self driving has no financial impact on the value of the car (except possibly tremendously devaluing any existing cars where a component of their value is current generation "self driving").

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by firecall on Thursday May 25, 2023 @10:13PM (#36078938)
It’s not worth 5x!

Cars driven commercially like that are worth less money.

Take a hybrid Toyota Camry that’s driven as Taxi almost 25 hours a day.

Are they worth more? Do they command a premium?

No, they do not. And at the end of they short useful lives their value goes to zero.

You could argue that self driving cars don’t need drivers, and so can be driven 24/7 at less cost of labour.

Even that eventuates, and we get a world where car ownership is significantly on the decline, it just means they sell less cars.

As we’ve seen with most technology commodity products, price tends to be forced downwards.

So maybe Elon is right, and a self driving car is worth 5x. But it’s not obvious to me, and I’m wary of people like Elon talking up his own book. He is a proven loser and fantasist, but also a very successful billionaire. :-/

Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by lepus on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:28AM (#36080746)
Five+ years ago when more of us believed that false promise that it was happening any day now it made more sense to have discussions about these kinds of hypothetical situations.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by bjornasm on Friday May 26, 2023 @05:44AM (#36082049)
I mean it would be worth 10x as much if its also made you breakfast but it don't and it won't.
Re:Whistleblower Drops 100 GB of Tesla Secrets to German New... by cableshaft on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:33AM (#36083209)
I'm not whoring my car out to Uber to let people make a mess in my car when I'm not driving it, sorry. So to me this means nothing. I'll still be in it as much as I would otherwise. Maybe a few less trips driving my wife to errands (as she doesn't feel comfortable driving, despite having a license), but otherwise it shouldn't make much difference.

The only thing I can think of is maybe it would make some trips not need my presence at all. Like I could see placing a Wal-mart grocery order, and sending my car to go to Wal-mart without me in it, they load it up, and then it comes back, and I can unload it.

Which is nice, but I'm not paying 5x the already expensive car prices in order to save a few minutes here and there.