News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by neom on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @08:50PM (#36052652)
I still think out of all the...unique... things Elon has said... work from home is morally wrong has to take the cake. I try to spend time looking at things as radically as I can. I think it's helpful to accept folks views as widely as possible, but I'm still trying to wrap my head around work from home being morally wrong.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5OHFt8QyiU

I was on a bicycle ride listening to this interview when he said it and I literally pulled my bike over and sat for a half hour or so thinking about what I think about the idea, I'm still not sure what I think. (Intellectual dishonesty or a valid view point?)

At least he got me thinking I suppose, heh.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by LapsangGuzzler on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @08:59PM (#36052711)
Pure speculation, but my guess is that he’s invested in the commercial real estate market and hoping for a turnaround. I don’t think it’s some profound or insane ideology he has, I think he’s just trying to prop up CRE like he does with crypto.

He’s famous for buying distressed commercial properties and for gaslighting, it just makes sense and the whole moral argument was a great way to get people talking about it.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by adverbly on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:15PM (#36052836)
I don't think its a CRE angle. He has multiple companies built around transportation.

Remote work => less demand for transportation.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by LapsangGuzzler on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:21PM (#36052883)
There’s no way that someone as wealthy as he doesn’t own at least some commercial property. Even if not himself, Tesla alone owns billions in CRE, not to mention his other companies.

Commercial properties are some of the most valuable assets a company owns, of course the guy wants to keep CRE values up. Just because he owns some transportation companies doesn’t mean he’s allergic to CRE, that’s kinda naive.

That’s like arguing guys at his level don’t donate to both political parties when they clearly do. Because by doing that, you get to own the whole system, not just a piece.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by otterley on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:49PM (#36053103)
Counterpoint: Berkshire Hathaway owns practically no commercial real estate assets.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by LapsangGuzzler on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:00PM (#36053179)
But they definitely own a ton of stock in companies that own real estate. 10 percent of their portfolio is in Bank of America, which has a huge commercial real estate lending portfolio. Berkshire doesn’t need to own CRE directly when they own companies that do CRE.

Commercial real estate is foundational in corporate finance. I guess I just don’t this argument that these huge companies aren’t somehow exposed. I guarantee you that if the CRE market tanks, Berkshire is gonna feel it too.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ydlr on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:19PM (#36053303)
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by otterley on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @03:32PM (#36062907)
That's a brokerage, not a holding company.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by JustLurking2022 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:29PM (#36052944)
Less commuting = fewer miles on your car = less frequent need to buy a new one.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by InitialLastName on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:10PM (#36053245)
It also edges your car mileage from the circumstance where electric cars excel (daily medium distance trips ending at home every day to charge) towards less advantageous use (long multi-day trips).
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by 908B64B197 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:02PM (#36052735)
He's hedging his bets by not paying rent for Twitter's offices.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by the_only_law on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:05PM (#36052760)
Maybe someone can help me understand this.

If I were to refuse to pay my rent. My landlord would post an eviction notice and if I refused to comply, I would likely be arrested or forcibly removed.

Why can’t the landlord “evict” twitter? Does the process look significantly different for commercial real estate? Does twitter provide value to the landlord in some form other than rent? Maybe they’re afraid of bad PR?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by LapsangGuzzler on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:08PM (#36052781)
It would probably cost a lot more to evict Twitter and find a new commercial tenant than it does to compel them to pay rent.

The reason this wouldn’t apply to you is that residential real estate vacancies are usually easy to fill, especially nowadays.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:14PM (#36052826)
> The reason this wouldn’t apply to you

That remains to be established. People often have no idea what renter protections are like. If he's in California, he might find that he can't be evicted without the landlord going through a multi-year process.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by seattle_spring on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:33PM (#36052965)
Take years, or even a year, is very much hyperbole, even for SF. Particularly when dealing with non-paying tenants. This may have been different during eviction moratoriums at the height of the pandemic.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by sjburt on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:04PM (#36053206)
The eviction moratorium is still active in SF, Oakland and Berkeley.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ballenf on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:56PM (#36053152)
Having run a small business for some years, refusal to pay an uncontested debt is (very unfortunately) a routine part of business and negotiation. It's a very ugly part, but creates a bit of a prisoner's dilemma where you wonder if you're the only sucker paying debts on time and in full.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by CamperBob2 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:36AM (#36054138)
It's just another instance of the old saying about banks. If you owe your landlord $1000, you have a problem. If you owe your landlord $10,000,000...
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ed25519FUUU on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:02PM (#36053193)
Also he’s welcome to have his opinions.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by operatingthetan on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:08PM (#36053235)
>Pure speculation, but my guess is that he’s invested in the commercial real estate market and hoping for a turnaround. I don’t think it’s some profound or insane ideology he has, I think he’s just trying to prop up CRE like he does with crypto.

We should assume any public statements on morality from powerful people out of the blue are motivated by a secondary factor.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by plagiarist on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:17PM (#36053295)
You don't even need that rule of thumb here. I believe Elon's very public tantrums on and regarding Twitter have shown that he lacks even basic integrity. The gall that he would discuss what is or is not moral from that position.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by operatingthetan on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:20PM (#36053312)
It must be some form of gaslighting for an obviously amoral person to make public announcements of moral platitudes. Why people agree with them is beyond me, is there perverse pleasure in being deeply wrong?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by coliveira on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:08AM (#36053985)
Being a billionaire in America transforms the person in some kind of super hero. People are mentally incapable to disagree with them, even on basic topics that everyone knows are wrong. The media exploits this every day.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by wombatpm on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:27PM (#36053725)
Elon has shown us all how to make a small fortune in social media. It’s not his fault that we don’t have 40 billion to burn buying a 20 billion business with a 13 billion mortgage
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by opmelogy on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:08PM (#36053236)
> He’s famous...for gaslighting

This is an excellent way to put it and a great observation. I was never able to put my finger on it even though the BS meter was off the charts. Here it is. Thanks.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ted_bunny on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:25PM (#36053348)
What makes it gaslighting as opposed to garden variety bullshit?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:00PM (#36053554)
By adding "morally" it enforces questioning one's own principles in support of the thing.

Without "morally" it's dismissable nonsense (ie. bullshit). With "morally" it requires pulling at strands that make up our world-view.

It's not necessarily a bad thing to question one's world-view on occasion, but causing that level of fundamental questioning, for a comment that would otherwise be easily dismissable, is gaslighting.

(by my opinion of the definition)

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by opmelogy on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:39PM (#36053799)
Good answer.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by dcow on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:37AM (#36054141)
Personally I think the repeated part of the gaslighting definition is really important (and the implication that the repetition is conducted abusively). Otherwise you'd argue that any dialog that causes one to question one's world-view is gaslighting, and that's simply not true under the colloquial use of the term.

If I make a statement that killing is not justifiable even in self defense, and that causes you, who believes that killing is justified as a measure of self defense, to question your worldview, I'm not gaslighting you into believing me, I'm simply sharing a viewpoint.

I actually think it's dangerous to throw gaslighting as a term around so casually. Gaslighting, very specifically, means to repeatedly question someone's worldview, while ignoring their anecdotal experience, in order to emotionally abuse them into submission or indoctrination. It's pretty serious and ugly. I know it's fun on HN to throw the term around, but Elon (regardless of how much you dislike him, and how many people follow him) arguing that WFH is morally wrong, is not an instance of Musk gaslighting the public at large.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by dcow on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:52AM (#36054213)
Preemptive corollary: to repeatedly espouse one's viewpoint, even if it pertains to the mental health of a class or group of people, is also not to gaslight, though that is more recently how the term has been used and how we bridge from a serious topic to a rhetorical device used as a Kafka trap. Gaslighting is targeted at an individual, with the specific goal of essentially brainwash. It's not espousing a political belief that may negatively impact a group of people, even if the result would be oppression of the faction's liberty. That's just politics, and politics in the west is all about choosing which factions to oppress and at what cost to the majority.

For example, repeatedly arguing that you think the idea of unchecked ownership of assault weapons is a stretch too liberal of an interpretation of the 2nd amendment, and that it's crazy to think it's okay for anybody to own one without training, and that you think it'd be a good idea to limit gun ownership and require mental health checks and registered firearms lists of trained individuals, and even that you think it's immoral to allow such easy access to acquire devices that make killing trivial, because it puts too much responsibility in the hands of civilian organizations to protect people from maniacs, which they clearly can't do at scale, and even to go so far as to argue they're insane to think otherwise, is not an instance of gaslighting gun owners or rights advocates into thinking their worldview is broken and in need of an update. But by the casual interpretation, it is, since you're arguing to oppress the liberty of some group of people on practical and/or moral (designation doesn't matter, anything that causes them to question their worldview) grounds.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by quicklime on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:29PM (#36053379)
But he's not the only business leader using heavy-handed techniques to get workers back in the office. I think it's likely that he genuinely believes that working from the office is better - he's not playing 4d chess.

The morality argument is just him rationalizing what he already believes. This isn't the "first principles" thinking that he demands from others.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by smeej on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:07PM (#36053594)
My brother calls return-to-office policies "panicking, in Boomer."

Tech company profits are declining. Management (especially Boomer management) needs to be seen as "doing something" or they're the ones on the chopping block. So they force everybody back into the office so they can be seen to be managing.

God forbid the cause of declining profits be things like national monetary policy or years of short-term decision-making that propped profits up to unsustainable highs.

No. It must be that Andy works from home. Better bring everybody in to keep an eye on them (to read their faces and find out for sure just how much shit they'll take from you before they quit).

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by danjac on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:25AM (#36054395)
I doubt there are that many Boomers left in tech management - almost all that age cohort are in retirement or semi-retired, they're enjoying their Saga cruises and golf courses (or if they're unlucky, their Walmart greeter jobs).

I suspect there are managers panicking about losing relevance in a post-office world, but those will be middle-managers, not CEOs. Much of the panic is from owners of commercial real estate and their flying monkeys in the media who are seeing empty office blocks and declining property values and rents.

As for Musk, who knows. He's in his own very weird bubble of long-terminism or cosmism or whatever it is he believes in. Maybe he thinks if everyone works from home it will lead to a drop in birth rates or decline in Western society or something.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by smeej on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @06:16AM (#36055998)
I'm specifically talking about the middle managers. They're the ones who need to be seen "doing things," so when it's time to surface any ideas for how to fix the problem, especially when it's their butts on the line, this is what comes out.

But I also refer to the boards and investors. We'd love to think it's all a young person's VC game, but behind all that money is still, more often than not, someone who panics in Boomer.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by shard on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:28AM (#36059460)
Baby Boomer generation is 1946-1964, which would make them 59-77. I expect only the younger range is likely to still be middle managers.

Maybe it's just me, but I feel like the use of "boomer" as a derogative to be reductionist and ageist, not to mention most of the time incorrect, as I've seen it applied all the way to Millennials.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by smeej on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:43PM (#36060697)
They've been criticizing my generation for receiving the "participation trophies" they gave us as kids, as well as screwing over our entire economy with shortsighted self-protectionism, so I definitely mean it in a derogatory way against people their age.

To be fair, I criticize them for the shit they did when they were my age too, so I'm criticizing them as a cohort, not because of their current age.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by shard on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @05:51PM (#36064323)
> They've been criticizing my generation for receiving the "participation trophies" they gave us as kids

Are you sure that the people doing the criticizing are the same people giving out the trophies?

> so I definitely mean it in a derogatory way against people their age

The way you had used it, as commentary on middle managers, seem to include people from Baby Boomers all the way to Millennials.

> I'm criticizing them as a cohort, not because of their current age

In which case it sounds like using the age identifier would be incorrect.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by smeej on Thursday May 25, 2023 @01:32PM (#36073595)
Yes, 100%, Boomers are the parent generation of Millennials. They spent our whole childhoods giving us participation trophies, and our whole young adulthood criticizing us for having received them.

I criticize them as a generational cohort for being the most entitled, wasteful, short-sighted generation that has ever lived, and has done more to screw up the entire world they are handing on to their children than anyone in history.

They have done this at every stage of their lives, but especially once they were old enough to be having children.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by shard on Friday June 02, 2023 @01:09PM (#36167869)
> Yes, 100%, Boomers are the parent generation of Millennials. They spent our whole childhoods giving us participation trophies, and our whole young adulthood criticizing us for having received them.

I don't mean as a cohort, I mean as individuals. I have my doubts that the exact same person who has given out participation trophies is the one who criticized. I think you are mixing two separate groups into one, by using their birth years as a commonality.

Also, I suspect that participation trophies is a Western creation, perhaps even an American phenomenon, and the Boomers who are not part of those cultures did not participate in those actitivities.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by danjac on Thursday May 25, 2023 @01:17AM (#36067261)
Most middle managers I know are in their thirties and forties. So Millennial or maybe Gen-X but definitely not "Boomer".

To quote the Princess Bride, "you keep using that word, I do not think it means what you think it means".

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by smeej on Thursday May 25, 2023 @01:36PM (#36073639)
I'd say this of low- or first-level managers, but not the middle layers.

Those are filled with people who are clinging to their roles well past their usefulness, because even though they're ruining social supports like Medicare and Social Security by pulling out multiples more funds than they ever contributed, they also failed to save anything of their own or are otherwise refusing to retire and leave the workforce (even though they've already started receiving "retirement" benefits).

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jjav on Friday May 26, 2023 @03:34AM (#36081182)
> they're ruining social supports like Medicare and Social Security by pulling out multiples more funds than they ever contributed

FYI, people don't get to "pull out" funds from social security. You get paid what the government computes you'll get.

> they also failed to save anything of their own or are otherwise refusing to retire and leave the workforce

So which is it? They failed to save therefore they can't retire, or they could retire but are "refusing to"?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by nyc_data_geek1 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:38AM (#36054144)
He probably has money in commercial real estate, like Jamie Dimon and so many others.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jredwards on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:15PM (#36053645)
I don't think you have to get that creative.

The man sells cars. He's invested in people commuting.

[dead]
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by p1esk on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:33PM (#36053755)
Asshole - yes, ignorant- no.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by notyourwork on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:32AM (#36057785)
This type of stuff would suggest otherwise.

https://www.dailyo.in/technology/elon-musk-fired-a-twitter-e...

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by nkozyra on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:44PM (#36053821)
Cars are used for more than commuting.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jredwards on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:15AM (#36054032)
But they are used for commuting.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kqr on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:50AM (#36054541)
They are, but at least in my city, comparing traffic at rush hour (a.k.a. commuting hour) to other times of the day makes it fairly clear commuting is one of the primary use cases.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ryanbrunner on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:13AM (#36054676)
If a couple (particularly in a city) doesn't commute, they are way way more likely to consider owning one car vs. two.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by geodel on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:33AM (#36054124)
> He’s famous for buying distressed commercial properties and for gaslighting

In his case, it could be solar lighting or else he is not about renewables as he claim to be :)

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by stuaxo on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:40PM (#36053026)
He owns a car company and wants people to use cars.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by marricks on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:21PM (#36053316)
That is such an incredibly obvious take I somehow never thought of. Thanks!

Not to mention, his main consumer would be exactly that white collar worker who'd rather not drive to the office.

It's a sort of sick inversion of Henry Ford's

> "I want my employees to be able to buy my car"

to...

> "I want all employees to be forced to own one"

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Rebelgecko on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @03:20AM (#36055056)
And for traffic to be so bad that they buy autopilot
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by zaptheimpaler on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:41PM (#36053038)
Taking the argument seriously is exactly what he wants - debating the position makes it a valid position. There is really no argument there, just self-interest. If its immoral to have more or different privileges than someone else, thats literally communism. He should give up all his wealth in that case.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by whitemary on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:29PM (#36053383)
>If its immoral to have more or different privileges than someone else, thats literally communism

This is not quite the Marxist definition of communism, but it is a lot closer than I would expect to find on HN. I am surprised.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by voisin on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @08:56PM (#36052693)
It’s really no different than other forms of wealth inequality. Some people get to work in palaces and others have to work in the salt mines, and most of us are somewhere in the middle, mostly (not totally) due to our status at birth. It isn’t moral or immoral in and of itself - it is a direct consequence of our economic and social system. I don’t think there is any value inherent to it at all.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by throwaway675309 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @08:54PM (#36052684)
His argument also boils down to the idea that since other jobs such as manufacturing require employees to be on site, that all jobs should have the same requirement. Smh...

Also the idea of a ruthless capitalistic multibillionaire invoking morality as a defense is just kafkaesque.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by vkou on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @08:56PM (#36052697)
I like his argument, and I would like to extend it to something like 'Since some people get through life on a salary of $7.75/hr (Or less), we should take away Elon's billions of dollars.' It'd only be fair - he can, after all, do well without all the comforts and power that his wealth affords him.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by bcrosby95 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:21PM (#36052878)
But that would be unfair because it harms Elon.

What happens to us doesn't matter, remember? We're all just NPCs.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kcplate on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:56PM (#36053153)
I think it would also be a reasonable accommodation to just cut the SWE’s salaries down to 10% below the lowest end salary of the manufacturing workers who have to be in person to do their job and let the SWEs do their job remote.

But I expect that may not be a popular opinion here on HN, though.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by drewcoo on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:17PM (#36052852)
Harrison Bergeron

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron

full text: https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=sites&srcid=ZGVmYXVsd...

That used to be standard reading in my high school. Elon is full of deepity. And high school reading.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by lettergram on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:16PM (#36052840)
I have a farm and work remotely. I'm awake 18 hrs a day, spend 6 with my family & 12 working -- 8 for tech job, 4 for farm. I do this 6 days a week. I'm insanely productive by most metrics (many many launched products, side gigs, work 1.5 jobs, etc). I schedule my day down to 15 min increments (though obviously, adjustments are always made).

Remote work affords me that opportunity and I work as hard as anyone. It's fun to wear the blue and white collar at the same time to be honest. I have survivalist friends, guys who work on cars, tech folks where wee discuss AI, etc.

I think Musk is wrong here, but do agree people need to roll up their sleeves and do legit work. You should always be contributing to your community, family, etc.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by NegativeK on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:37PM (#36052994)
I'm a bit confused. Are you saying that, morally, we should all be working like you do?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by mwint on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:43PM (#36053046)
What does your planning process look like? I’d like to get more structure in my workday, maybe not that much… but how do you deal with the Stuff that inevitably Comes Up?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by lettergram on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:08PM (#36053234)
If you can, you push it to the next day and schedule accordingly. If you can, obviously plans changed lol. 99% of what we have going on can be pushed to tomorrow
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by moneywoes on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:56PM (#36053159)
How do you do this 15 minute scheduling, google calendar?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by lettergram on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:06PM (#36053215)
Most calendars you can break down to w.e. interval you want, I share a calendar with my family and we put our stuff up. Then for each bucket, I break it down individually as the day comes up. Takes like 10 min at night to put it all in, so maybe an hour a week of planning. That may seem like a lot, but worth the effort IMO.

As an example, every day my basic schedule: 6-8am with family, 8am-12pm [farm] work, 12pm-4pm [collaborative] work, 4-7pm chores & family, 7-9pm [emails / focus work] work, 9-10pm family, 10-12pm [focus] work.

Then the day before, I will break out individual events. There are times, for instance, I have to take a kid to the doctor so I'll block that out, put in all my meetings and adjust the 4-7pm family time to say 5-7pm (take an hr from work & family time).

It's all about being disciplined and trying to ensure you are organized and maximize time for me. Gotta keep focused

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by astronads on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:53PM (#36053512)
As an early retired person who is most definitely capitalizing on “taking it easy”, this lifestyle sounds positively exhausting and hellish to me.

I find it mostly interesting how different successful people can be with wildly varied takes on what works for them lifestyle-wise as well as what they value in life. Not to mention how we prioritize (and focus) our limited time on earth.

Kudos to you for making your life work well. We’re wired differently, and that’s okay.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by malthaus on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:42AM (#36054496)
i'm fascinated by your schedule as well - is your life (during the work week at least) really just work & family and all fully scheduled in advance?

what about hobbies? alone time? being lazy & purposefully wasting time? culture & entertainment? sports? etc. where exactly is your "me" fitting in here?

my european free spirited mind boggles

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Ancalagon on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:23PM (#36053327)
Your work ethic is very impressive, but what do you mean by 'legit work'? Are you implying remote work is not legitimate? I'm confused because you even state that you spend your days working remotely - are you are obviously very productive at it. Is that not legit work, and only the blue collar is legit?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jjnoakes on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:30PM (#36053393)
Not the author of the comment, but it is pretty clear to me that they are saying you can work from home and coast, or you can work from home and be productive, and they suggest that everyone who works from home should do the latter.

I agree with them. To me it isn't about the color of one's collar or the location they work from. It is about being productive. Productive workers should have flexibility, where possible. Unproductive ones shouldn't.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ipaddr on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:45PM (#36053469)
It's easier to coast at the office and look productive. Much easier. Attending every social fuction, social visits, adhoc meetings can kill half a week easy.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jjnoakes on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:04AM (#36053960)
No disagreement here. I think office workers should be productive too.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Eisenstein on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:44AM (#36054865)
Honest question: why?

Why should people work so hard all the time? In the US, we are already insanely productive compared to almost every other worker in every other country and even compared to ourselves a few decades ago.

We work hard to bring value to our employer who wouldn't waste a minute for sympathy when they lay us off to increase their margins for a quarter, but you feel that we have to be productive all the time or else, what? We are immoral?

I contend that the worker owes nothing but fulfilling their job description. If you don't have work to do, then why find it?

There is no need to 'be productive' every working hour of every day if you don't have to be. To do so is insanity in my opinion. Go be with your family. Kids grow up way too fast and you are missing it.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jjnoakes on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @08:21PM (#36065707)
I think if productivity is high enough then there should just be fewer working hours.

Edit: I also want to be clear that I don't really think about productivity as an instantaneous measure, but more of an average over time. Someone (at home or at work) who is "coasting" in my opinion is someone who is rarely, if ever, productive. Someone who is productive is someone who gets good work done every week or month or whatever unit of time is relevant to the job at hand. What you do with this 5 minutes or that hour isn't really as important, IMO.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Frondo on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:00AM (#36054601)
> people need to roll up their sleeves and do legit work.

I don't like this kind of Calvinist attitude toward work. Increasing productivity via technological advancement should free us all up to do more of what we want.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by colordrops on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:07PM (#36052767)
Elon's argument makes no sense on multiple levels:

1. Every job has different requirements, and you can't arbitrarily apply the same standards to every one. It's no different from saying that "Cooks have to de-grease the grill, so desk workers have to de-grease their desks at the end of the day as well." You'd think that someone so ruthlessly focused on productivity and efficiency would acknowledge this.

2. He speaks as if the current hierarchical capitalist structure with all its particular corporate idiosyncrasies is a fundamental aspect of reality rather than a very specific and arbitrary social construct. We should be fighting to move away from it rather than submit to it further.

3. He does not apply these standards to himself, flying around in his corporate jet and rarely "in the office" himself. So apparently he does believe some roles are not bound by the same rules and requirements, which is inconsistent.

Realistically he likely understands all this, but just can't say the truth directly because it's not so palatable.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by favorited on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:20PM (#36052871)
It makes a lot of sense when you consider how much of his wealth is invested in a car company.

Even in a hybrid work environment, the vast majority of the miles I put on my car are commuting to and from the office. And if a household as 2 adults who need to commute, they're more likely to want 2 fuel-efficient vehicles.

[dead]
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by taftster on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:57PM (#36053171)
I'm not even following this, "Unnatural" ...

Work from Home - Throughout the ages of man, I would tend to believe that more work has been done at home than at any notion of modern workplace. Farming, milling, iron working, etc. have all historically been performed by small tradesmen working out of their homes. "Go to Joe's house if you want your horses shoed."

Home School - Again, I would argue that far more children throughout history are being school at home than in a western notion of traditional school. I would wager that even today, more kids are currently "at home" schooling across the globe than in a modern school.

Interest Rates - Maybe this one is a reasonable notion of "unnatural". But again, throughout all time, bartering has dominated merchant exchanges and simple currency exchanges (through precious metals). There has probably always been a notion of interest rates in all this, but what you're describing is more about the federal reserve's interest rates and fractional banking, which is quite a modern invention.

In all, I don't think anything about work from home, home schooling or making transactions with neighbors is unnatural. If anything, it's the most natural way that society has worked and existed throughout history.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by pishpash on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:35PM (#36053423)
Parent is what might be called "well socialized".
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jgalt212 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:05PM (#36061888)
> Farming, milling, iron working, etc. have all historically been performed by small tradesmen working out of their homes. "Go to Joe's house if you want your horses shoed."

All of this has significant IRL contact with the wider world. Modern knowledge worker WFH does not.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Freedom2 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:54PM (#36053144)
Working in a separate place than your home is a recent concept - humanity has worked from home far longer than in offices or workplaces. Consider farming, or craftspeople working their trade, as well as nomadic cultures.

In what way is WFH 'unnatural'?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jgalt212 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:03PM (#36061847)
because IRL you're avoiding contact with the wider world.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Freedom2 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:30PM (#36062200)
Define contact. I talk to my coworkers regularly, I am able to visit and support my local community businesses where I live (rather than a large, faceless city), I am able to socialize with my local community as well.

I would avoid extrapolating your own WFH experience to others.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jgalt212 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @07:45PM (#36065396)
able to, but not forced to.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:52PM (#36053128)
I generally like feeling spouting off in the reflection that comes from it. I wouldn't want to put words, but I can see some individuals claiming a human right to work from home as an example of moral hypocrisy. That's sad, of course I don't work from home as a mutual agreement between consenting adults has any moral questions
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by rossjudson on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:09PM (#36053241)
Farhad Manjoo wrote: "Office Workers Don’t Hate the Office. They Hate the Commute."

That's true for a decent number of people...but definitely not all.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/19/opinion/elon-musk-remote-...

And another thing -- the "morally wrong" is remarkably selective. Musk is clearly saying that it's "morally wrong" for white collar workers to be remote while insisting that blue collar workers be fully present.

In a CNBC interview this week, speaking about service and manufacturing workers, Musk said “it's messed up to assume that, yes, they have to go to work, but you don't. It's not just a productivity thing, I think it's morally wrong,” suggesting “the laptop class is living in la-la land.”

What if the headline was "CEO phones in 20 hours/week from Hawaii while threatening to fire workers who clock < 60 hours/week"?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kitsunesoba on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:19PM (#36053305)
The commute and the open office layout. If getting to the office doesn’t take a big bite out of my day and salary and I’m given an environment that makes me more productive than I am at home, I’m happy to go to the office.

That’s unusual, though. Usually getting to/from work takes at minimum of an hour (30m both ways), either due to traffic or from being pushed out way from where the office is located in order to be able to afford the rent/mortgage. You’re also usually stuck with an open office where maintaining focus for any period of time is impossible, as opposed to cubicles or private offices.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ghaff on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:31PM (#36053400)
I think it's mostly true. Yes, people have gotten used to the flexibility and maybe their very particular setups at home. But, if people could walk 10 minutes to their office and people they knew would be there I'm pretty sure you'd see a lot less pushback--especially for coming in a few days a week.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by plagiarist on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:26PM (#36053351)
If Elon finds it morally distasteful that blue collar workers' commutes are unpaid, he could simply pay them for their time, or have them work fewer hours for the same pay and benefits.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:09PM (#36053609)
Couple of interesting implications:

1. Fewer people commuting would make commuting faster / more bearable

2. Employee's who's work requires physical presence at a specific place could / should demand higher pay because of the new convenience differential

(#2 is fraught with assumptions and state / country based situational sensitivities)

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by itronitron on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:11AM (#36054314)
Furthermore, if fewer people are commuting then employees whose work requires physical presence will have shorter commute times, and better parking spots.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ulfw on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:28PM (#36053730)
I hate the office. Shitty equipment, loud distracting environment, uncomfortable, need to keep appearances up, notion of ass-in-seat rather than creating output that matters.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by deeg on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:28PM (#36053732)
> Musk is clearly saying that it's "morally wrong" for white collar workers to be remote while insisting that blue collar workers be fully present.

If that is his justification then it's just as silly. Does Musk think it's morally wrong that white collar workers live in bigger homes than blue collar workers? That they send more of their kids to private school? Has Musk gone full communist?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by grensley on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:12PM (#36053258)
I think it's that he doesn't feel enough power over remote workers.

Also Elon Musk accusing anyone of being in "La La Land" is hilarious.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kryogen1c on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:20PM (#36053313)
> but I'm still trying to wrap my head around work from home being morally wrong.

Are you? Have you tried seriously considering his position instead of watching 1 second sound bites OBVIOUSLY taken out of context?

> I was on a bicycle ride listening to this interview when he said it and I literally pulled my bike over and sat for a half hour or so thinking about what I think about the idea

Oh? This musk interview was the first time you learned about unfairness in the world? I'm glad he "got you thinking". Heh.

It is not some extreme, radical position that shutting down your company by staging a strike because you _deserve_ to work from the comfort of your own home is morally tenuous. You can disagree, but acting like musk is a raving lunatic for sympathizing with minimum wage workers who bus to work is nothing short of supreme stupidity.

Honestly the anti musk sentiment around here is so braindead and reactionary its beginning to feel like an astroturfed psyop.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by campbel on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:29PM (#36053380)
> It is not some extreme, radical position that shutting down your company by staging a strike because you _deserve_ to work from the comfort of your own home is morally tenuous.

Why? This is just a negotiation. Striking is one bargaining chip that labor has that they can play. Striking isn't morally tenuous.

> You can disagree, but acting like musk is a raving lunatic for sympathizing with minimum wage workers who bus to work is nothing short of supreme stupidity.

How is Musk sympathizing with minimum wage workers? Did the minimum wage workers ask for the "laptop class" to comeback to the office? Do they even care? What about people in other lines of work where remote isn't an option? Do they care? It seems more likely that Musk is just using this false comparison as a way to pit labor classes against each other.

> Honestly the anti musk sentiment around here is so braindead and reactionary its beginning to feel like an astroturfed psyop.

Come on...

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kaibee on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:45PM (#36053472)
> How is Musk sympathizing with minimum wage workers? Did the minimum wage workers ask for the "laptop class" to comeback to the office? Do they even care? What about people in other lines of work where remote isn't an option? Do they care? It seems more likely that Musk is just using this false comparison as a way to pit labor classes against each other.

Capital class tries to pit working class against itself, part N

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by mediasavvy on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:23PM (#36053333)
> acting like musk is a raving lunatic for sympathizing with minimum wage workers who bus to work is nothing short of supreme stupidity

It’s called concern trolling

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jpeg_hero on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:23PM (#36053329)
I read it as a direct opposition to the moralizing here oh HN about how it’s morally wrong to not let people work from home. (the “noise” argument, the “I’m individually more productive” arguments and all that)
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by w_for_wumbo on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:23PM (#36053334)
If I had to try and think of an angle, I guess it could be around the protection of intellectual data. In the office, it's a controlled environment. Whereas working from home is essentially taking corporate assets into an uncontrolled environment.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kbos87 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:24PM (#36053341)
I think a lot of the speculation about his motivations and just how long of a game he is playing give him too much credit. The past 12 months have been a complete backslide in his credibility. I chalk it up to the fact that he has literally become an attention seeking soundbite machine.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by throwawaylinux on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:25PM (#36053342)
Hard to judge from the truncated context provided there. Was he just saying anybody who wants to work from home is morally wrong? It actually sounded like the conversation was about people who thought they had a right to work from home. If they expected others not to, I can see that as being somewhat hypocritical.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by judge2020 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:29PM (#36053385)
Eh, the more mindshare these people think they have the more crazy they become. Pre-2018 Elon was more focused on the companies, although he still made mistakes (Taking TSLA private tweet, borderline self-dealing with the SolarCity acquisition). The cave rescue fiasco and how he was sleeping on the floor of the factory during the 2018 Model 3 Ramp[0] (which also supposedly had Tesla a month away from bankruptcy[0]) must have triggered something, perhaps he'd already done the hard work and wanted to celebrate by increasing his fame/clout and by eventually purchasing his favorite social media platform.

0: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/11/elon-musk-says-he-is-sleepin...

1: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/03/musk-tesla-was-about-a-month...

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by sottol on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:46PM (#36053480)
It does sound good on the surface. Equality for all. Right? Only selectively. But nice touch invoking immorality.

Is it moral to fly around the US and the world while the guy that's hiring the chef that cooks your food stays grounded?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by nonethewiser on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:47PM (#36053482)
> There are some exceptions, but I think that the whole notion of work from home is a bit like the fake Marie Antoinette quote, ’Let them eat cake,'″ Musk told CNBC.

> "It's like, really, you’re going to work from home and you're going to make everyone else who made your car come work in the factory? You're going to make the people who make your food… that they can't work from home? The people that fix your house — they can't work from home? But, you can? Does that seem morally right?" the billionaire asked. "That's messed up."

https://www.foxbusiness.com/lifestyle/elon-musk-working-from...

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jxramos on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:48PM (#36053490)
Interesting, haven’t seen this exchange till now. He’s basically talking about what is increasingly becoming identified as the “laptop class” who can do the whole virtual life, live in lockdowns indefinitely, carry on with delivery stuff, etc etc. He’s building a set of claims about the morality of that set of arrangements for our subpopulation who are members of the laptop class. I’ll have to think about that one, that’s a novel claim to view those affordances critically in terms of special treatment and how that all intersects in the morality angle.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by dataflow on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @10:56PM (#36053529)
Of all the people in the position to claim people are morally obligated to commute to work, a rich billionaire focused on minimizing carbon emissions isn't one.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by 8note on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:08AM (#36053986)
He's certainly not focused on minimizing carbon emissions - otherwise he wouldn't be making a luxury car company

He exploited tax incentives intended to reduce carbon emissions, sure, but that's not the same thing as focussing on reducing carbon emissions

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by GiorgioG on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:02PM (#36053565)
I deactivated my twitter account over it. It’s just complete nonsense.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by hanniabu on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:09PM (#36053610)
> I'm still trying to wrap my head around work from home being morally wrong.

By being a selfish individual and wanting to work remotely you are devaluing a wealthy investor's commercial real estate all because you didn't want to waste a tenth of your day pointlessly commuting to the office to do something that could have been done at home

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by WesternWind on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:14PM (#36053633)
Hasn't work from home been shown to improve worker efficiency and happiness too?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by missedthecue on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:53PM (#36053885)
I think it's been shown to increase isolation. The number of young people going days without seeing another human being should startle and upset.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by 8note on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:10AM (#36053996)
Young people all have 6 roommates with somebody turning the living room into an extra bedroom because rents are too high.

The isolation of being at home is countered by how many people are at home

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Kbelicius on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @03:28AM (#36055105)
> The number of young people going days without seeing another human being should startle and upset.

That number has little to do with WHF. WHF might have increased it but it certainly isn't the root cause or even a major driver of the rise.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by rirze on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:17AM (#36058422)
It's hard to decouple this phenomenon from the aftereffects of COVID restrictions. We'll be able to figure the isolation from WFH in the next few years.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by thybag on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @06:20AM (#36056039)
It does seem like most studies show WFH workers being happier/healthier/more productive. Wouldn't necessarily take that as conclusive, but i've certainly not found much evidence beyond random anecdotes saying the opposite.

e.g.https://www.forbes.com/sites/bryanrobinson/2022/02/04/3-new-...

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Timon3 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:50AM (#36058937)
There is no way Elon doesn't know about this. I think for him, poor people should feel unhappy. He feels it immoral for poor people to be happy and content.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by notyourwork on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:18PM (#36053667)
> At least he got me thinking I suppose, heh.

Wealth doesn't automatically give credence to valuable perspective. Further, I tend to just disregard Elon for what he is.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Thorentis on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:25PM (#36053718)
> when he said it and I literally pulled my bike over and sat for a half hour or so thinking

Meta comment, but seriously? A comment from Elon made you pause your commute for 30 minutes? I can't imagine ever being this affected by a podcast.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:35PM (#36053774)
Your response is interesting in its own right.

Half the fun of this life is exploring and questioning new ideas and podcasts are a great way to do that.

I don't think I pulled over, I've definitely spent some time sitting and thinking once I get to my destination

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by neom on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:10AM (#36053994)
Yeah seriously! I was riding beside a river (for fun) listening to the interview and it came to that section, he said it and I laughed out loud... thought what a weird perspective. I'd never considered that before and there was a bench over looking the river a ways down so I pulled over, sat on the bench and debated it with myself for a while... let myself agree in one direction... see how I feel, let myself agree in the other direction, see how I feel. Just think it back and forth with myself for a while. As the other reply to this comment said, it's a great deal of fun to do this and I enjoy it a lot!
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:31PM (#36053744)
My two cents on this is that he is saying "working from home is morally wrong" - for his companies... but he left out the for his companies part.

He owns a car company and a space ship company - both of which have assembly lines with tons of workers. A majority of his employees will need to be working in a factory or with physical equipment/prototypes. Therefore they must be at the office or at the plant.

In that environment - allowing a small percentage of people to have the flexibility to work from home all the time, actually can seem amoral as that will create two classes of workers - the in-office class and the laptop WFH class within the same company.

Friction could be generated if for instance. the laptop class is making decisions from the comfort of their PJs which impacts the production line class. Its much easier to just make that 8% laptop class of the company RTO and experience the impact of their decisions.

Similar issues would be apparent at Amazon (distribution center workers versus AWS staff) and possibly Apple (i.e. HW Apple engineers have to be in office, but iCloud workers can WFH).

I think it'd be hard/impossible that a small cloud first company or small remote only startup like GitLabs would be amoral for being WFH.

Twitter could probably be WFH, but in order to make statement that would not possibly be construed as hypocritical he unfortunately can't make such a distinction.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by hamburglar on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:55PM (#36053898)
> allowing a small percentage of people to have the flexibility to work from home all the time, actually can seem amoral as that will create two classes of workers

This is kind of absurd, though, since they are already two classes of workers. Information workers and factory workers are different.

But also, the deciding factor on whether you can work from home should be: can you do your job from home? Look at nurses. They have to be in a hospital, walking into rooms and tending to patients, right? Not phone nurses and poison control center nurses. They work from home nowadays.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:08AM (#36053987)
I agree from a technological/logical standpoint but from a human/emotional standpoint I think there are issues. People love to complain/go to press about HR decisions. The press would love to portray Musk as hypocritical about treating production line workers as second class denizens. The headline writes itself.

I tthink the way you overcome it is by paying a premium to in office staff. In your scenario - onsite nurses likely get paid a very significant premium to the salary of a remote, phone nurse.

But in the "Elon" case its going to hard to show how your are paying a premium for onsite factory techs when the design engineers are making $$$ plus RSUs.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by hackerlight on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:15AM (#36054034)
> from a human/emotional standpoint I think there are issues

From an emotional standpoint, sure, but not from a moral standpoint, which is what your previous post was saying. There is no moral case for punishing an advantaged class if that punishment does nothing to help the other class.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:28AM (#36054095)
I think that's a fair point - especially if one prescribes to most economically efficient == most moral - which not all subscribe to (although perhaps of all people Musk would subscribe to this theory).

That said I could for see cases where the laptop class could be isolated from pain when a separate class has to do the physical work. Imagine a scenario where the laptop class engineer does some sloppy work in order to pick up the kids for soccer. The goof up requires 100 production line people to redo step 8 of 30 steps for 3 additional hours.

That goof up will be less visible there than at a company that has outsourced production line work. At the outsourced production company the goof up will show up as the additional change order which will have a directly mappable line item on the quarterly accounting that the responsible engineer will need to answer for.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ethbr0 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:04AM (#36053962)
> Information workers and factory workers are different.

Should they be, in terms of work-life balance?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by zarzavat on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:14AM (#36054030)
Yes. The alternative is absurd. Should it be mandatory for everybody to work shifts just because some people have to work shifts?

I’ve never met a factory worker who resents the existence of cushy WFH jobs. On the contrary, many aspire to have such a job.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kqr on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:36AM (#36054466)
There are also many people in non-desk jobs who could never imagine doing one. The recent example I have in mind are the woodland firefighters described by Desmond. It's hard, grueling, dirty, long work, but for many of them, it beats sitting still stuck at home attempting to look busy for some guy in a suit.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by joeblubaugh on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:13AM (#36054020)
The answer is to improve the lot of factory workers, not worsen that of the others.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:41AM (#36054158)
That would cost Elon money though...
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by int_19h on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @05:47PM (#36064283)
It seems unavoidable without artificially making life worse for some. But it should also be properly compensated.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by hamburglar on Thursday May 25, 2023 @01:34AM (#36067348)
Zero opinion on the work-life balance question, because it's irrelevant here (this is not fundamentally a work-life balance issue, and people who work remotely have their own work-life balance problems). This is about whether or not you have to physically be in a particular place to actually perform your job duties. For a factory worker, yes you do. For an awful lot of information workers, you absolutely don't.

Park rangers get to perform their jobs out amongst the majestic beauty of nature. Should we make it "fair" by forcing them to go sit in a cubicle under fluorescent lights too?

100% remote work was a thing before the pandemic and it will continue to be a thing in the future. Companies that don't learn how to adapt to this will be at a disadvantage on this point. This cuts both ways, of course. If I can do my job "anywhere" and I live in an expensive place like Seattle, I should worry that I have to compete with people in very low CoL places, and that likely pushes my own market value down. That's life. But pretending we need information worker's butts in seats downtown to operate servers thousands of miles away from them is not going to fix the problem.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by 8note on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:58PM (#36053918)
It seems weird that the office workers are working from the office and not in the production line too, no? Do your meetings while assembling a car, I'd you're worried about the people assembling cars feeling bad
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:04AM (#36053961)
I think that is the preference/ideal scenario that Musk has in his head. Take a morning standup with your coworkers about supply chain/scrum, head to the factory floor to show the technicians how to flash the latest firmware to the infotainment system, do some heads down work, go home, eat dinner and then take a phone conference late at night with your Tesla China/Berlin counterpart.

Probably impressions matter on the factory floor and when you scale up operations. You don't want a situation where the people on the factory floor just refer to the design team as "corporate" (i.e. "corporate" wants us to do this, guys we have to redo X over again because "dude in corporate" thinks its not going to work otherwise).

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:37AM (#36054827)
I think this is probably where the motivation comes from. You don't want the people who get their hands dirty viewing the people that make decisions for them as some floating heads somewhere off in the ether. If they dont come around ever that's what's going to happen. It creates resentment, destroys morale, and you have to balance that with the morale impact of making the information workers show their faces often enough.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jen20 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @08:33AM (#36057113)
Given that Tesla have been producing cars where the steering “yoke” literally falls off on the highway after a few miles, I wouldn’t be so sure this hasn’t been implemented already!
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by rover0 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:17AM (#36054048)
Why stop here?

Some workers have shifts, some have to work outside in the rain.

It's only fair that everyone works outside in the rain in shifts?

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:39AM (#36054153)
I would say usually this is deftly handled at other tech companies (MSFT, AAPL, Netflix, Facebook, Google) by outsourcing all meal preparation, cleaning services, security, low level IT, contract manufacturing to other companies. That way there is not a separate class within the same company. This works most of the time to not create a press $*$!storm.

The challenge for Elon (and Amazon) is that his two of his companies rely on physical labor and can't outsource the physical part but still need tech talent that could WFH.

I don't envy him...

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by rover0 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:58AM (#36054243)
The jobmarket is "unfair", we all have different conditions and earn a different wages. Suddenly when Musk hates WFH he cares about fairness?
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:05AM (#36054274)
I think its important to realize that Elon's smart enough to realize that part of his job is performative - for his primary investors/faithful (i.e. Cathie Wood, Tesla Daily, Hyperchange, Ross Gerber).

They want Tesla to maintain that original "Elon sleeping under desks", all hands on deck, Tesla hunger of yore. To them - they probably were concerned about the design teams getting to soft from WFH and getting uppity.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by marcus_holmes on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:19AM (#36054361)
Also a symptom of that management style is measuring input not outcomes.

A star worker for them is someone who works 16 hours a day, adds 10K lines of code and sleeps under their desk. Not someone who goes for a long walk in the park while thinking deeply about the problem, and then spends half an hour at the keyboard refactoring to remove 1000 lines of code and clear a major performance bottleneck.

Elon may be performing for his shareholders, but if he was actually smart he'd be informing them. It's notable how many of the actually-smart rockstar CEO's didn't seem to care what their shareholders thought.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by saagarjha on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:03AM (#36054259)
Contractors are treated pretty poorly at those companies
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by somethoughts on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:21AM (#36054373)
Agree - definitely is still an issue - mostly noticing that introducing outsourcing and badge levels/colors seems to make it less press-worthy.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by kqr on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:29AM (#36054422)
Classic bureaucrat response.

"People are getting annoyed by these implicit class differences in our organisation, what do we do?"

"Let's encode them explicitly in the contracts. Then we can blame it on the contracts and pretend it's out of our control!"

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Kbelicius on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:54AM (#36054913)
> That way there is not a separate class within the same company.

No, you've now created an even "lower" class within the company.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by dools on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:29AM (#36054101)
Agreed.

There are people whose jobs involve abseiling from the side of a building.

Therefore it's only fair that we should all be doing our jobs while abseiling from the side of a building.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by prasadjoglekar on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:15AM (#36054339)
No, but it's fair for a company to mandate some minimum level of behavior that reflects a baseline of values. A cable company I worked for had fewer holidays than most other companies, even for their corporate employees. The rationale was that if the line cable installer or phone rep was schlepping in to work, then so should the marketing guy.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Turskarama on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:28AM (#36054417)
This is ridiculous, we already have a way of making up for differing work conditions, it's called pay.

If you think it's "unfair" that some people have to commute into work then pay them accordingly.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by andyfos on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:58PM (#36062542)
It seems, however, that the idea of a pay rise is often the last resort for employers, no matter the circumstance.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by UncleMeat on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @07:45AM (#36056648)
And nobody looked at that and said "wait... why not just give holidays to these folks too?"
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by ryanisnan on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:05AM (#36054632)
Because it fits his mental model.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by scott_w on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:37AM (#36054476)
But those aren’t moral issues, they’re productivity issues. My younger brother used to do his computer job from the office because it was attached to the factory. It meant he could talk directly with the people manufacturing the steel frames he specified in the building dressing to get the right thing built quickly. This was a USP of the company vs other design shops.

This could be true for Tesla, there’s no morality to this. The fact Musk brings morality in suggests he’s talking out his arse.

Twitter is a different company. If he doesn’t bring morality into it, he doesn’t have to be a hypocrite. He could easily say “working on site is necessary for Tesla, not for Twitter.” Being dogmatic is not good business.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by andsoitis on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:29AM (#36057749)
> But those aren’t moral issues

According to the dictionary, morality is simply “ principles concerning the distinction between right and wrong or good and bad behavior.”

> they’re productivity issues

Some would say that choosing being unproductive when you could be productive IS immoral. Not only does Benjamin Franklin jump to mind, but the entire Protestant-informed culture of “the West”. Japan’s culture is also infused with a productivity mindset.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by scott_w on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:20AM (#36058479)
> According to the dictionary, morality is simply “ principles concerning the distinction between right and wrong or good and bad behavior.”

Right/wrong in this case are meant in the sense of "it's wrong to murder people" as opposed to "saying 2 + 2 = 5 is wrong." The former is a statement of morality, the latter is a statement of correctness. This does not link productivity / morality.

> Some would say that choosing being unproductive when you could be productive IS immoral.

Therefore it's not an axiom. Most people would only consider it immoral if you chose to be unproductive for the sake of being unproductive. For example, refusing to do your job while expecting to be paid is something many people would consider immoral.

This is different from choosing a path you prefer, that happens to be less productive. For example, doing something more slowly but more safely may be less productive but also something many would not consider immoral.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by andsoitis on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:26AM (#36058581)
> This is different from choosing a path you prefer, that happens to be less productive.

In the context of one's life, I agree fully. However, once you choose to work in a collective, choosing to be less productive without a positive tradeoff to the system, harms the ones around you.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by shard on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:12AM (#36059253)
The positive tradeoff to the system is that the employee who prefers to WFH is happier and less stressed, which leads to increased productivity and retention. Now whether this offsets the decreased productivity from not being there in person, that's what's being argued over.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by scott_w on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:53PM (#36061721)
Nothing you said here sufficiently answers the specific points I raised.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:47PM (#36061640)
> those aren’t moral issues

I think you may have missed the issues they intended to bring up. The moral issues I see could be that you might have one class of worker ("knowledge worker") who is able to work from home and another class of worker who is unable to work from home. It's along the lines of the difference between paid catering for the executive suite but not the rest of the office.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by scott_w on Thursday May 25, 2023 @12:54AM (#36067163)
No they’re not even remotely related. One type of work can’t be done from home, one can. That’s not a moral discussion, that’s just a description of reality.

Paid catering isn’t an intrinsic part of the work, so it has absolutely nothing to do with this discussion.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday May 25, 2023 @08:26AM (#36069884)
The exclusive paid catering I gave as an example is something that might foster resentment towards executives from the rest of the office staff. Work from home, regardless of circumstances around the work which allow for it, can be seen as a similar privilege which might draw resentment from one worker group to another. I think something like that is what was being suggested.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by dhx on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:53AM (#36054566)
"But role XYZ can't work from home therefore no one should work from home" is the silliest of all arguments. It's similar to "Back in my day, we didn't have parental leave and it was very hard, so why is it fair that young people should not have to go through the hardest experience too!".

Here's just some of the benefits to on-site workers in role XYZ of other workers being able to WFH:

* Quicker commutes (less congestion from people needlessly traveling) and thus more free time.

* If a partner is WFH, they haven't wasted time commuting and thus have more time and energy to assist with the household.

* Higher salaries as the jobs requiring a commute become less desirable vs. WFH jobs.

* Higher salaries as the business wastes less money on having unnecessary office facilities and (theoretically at least) workers could demand these savings be reflected in their salaries.

* Improved health from reduction in pollution caused by commuting.

* Reduced cost of living from less wasted land used for offices that are only used 30% of a week.

* Lower taxes or improved government services as less money needs to be wasted on infrastructure that is overwhelmingly built to cater for the 12% per week that it is used to needlessly shuffle everyone around.

* Increased productivity from reduction in illnesses transferred on public transport and within office facilities.

* Improved happiness and productivity resulting from workers being able to setup a workspace/home office that is most productive for their needs. Fresh air, lighting, seating, etc are all controllable by the worker at home.

* Households could switch to having a single car.

If one were to debate against WFH, more sensible arguments would be things like:

* Greater heating / cooling efficiency to cram more people in a single cramped building than to have those same people heat / cool their homes individually. Passive houses largely solve this.

* More efficient access to some services such as getting a haircut, buying goods from a specialist retailer, etc if they're all centralised in a CBD as opposed to requiring individuals to travel all across a city. Increased deliveries to home negates this.

* Forced exercise (on average) due to workers needing to walk between transport options and an office building, whereas at home they don't have to walk anywhere unless they are motivated to do so.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by jensgk on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @10:34AM (#36058719)
Also:

* Larger population to recruit from, because distance to office does not matter.

* More diverse workforce, because people with some physical and/or mental disabilities, will be able to work remote.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by nimblegorilla on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @08:18AM (#36056974)
> My two cents on this is that he is saying "working from home is morally wrong" - for his companies... but he left out the for his companies part.

If you watch his interview you see him say WFH is morally wrong for almost everyone in the "laptop class" and not just his companies.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/elon-musk-work-from-home-morall... "You're going to make people who make your food that gets delivered [that] can't work from home; the people that come fix your house, they cant work from home, but you can?"

"Does that seem morally right? That's messed up," Musk said.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by alienicecream on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:20AM (#36057629)
There are 12 year olds working in Cobalt mines, I wonder if Musk is going to send his children to work in those. Some people have to live on the street, maybe we all should, otherwise it's "messed up".
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by lumb63 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:51AM (#36058066)
I saw this first-hand at a defense contractor. A lot of the work is classified, so it needs to be done in-office. The group of in-office workers definitely harbored a lot of anger toward the out-of-office “no-work-from-home” workers. It doesn’t help that it was mostly true (there) that the work-from-homers were doing nothing; I know because I was one of them, at one point.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by lIIllIIllIIllII on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:32PM (#36053748)
It's pretty textbook behaviour for narcissistic manipulators.

Harm the victim in some way, when victim complains about it, turn it around so as to frame it as the victim doing the wrong thing all along, and the victim should feel like a bad person.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by langsoul-com on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:12AM (#36054012)
Makes sense given his position. He has a vested interest in his workers coming in.

He, unlike others, can afford to be extremely close to the office. There's all benefits and no detriments for his statements.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by george-in-sd on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:48AM (#36054193)
Upper class is fighting for a perk that the working class will never have. Maybe not morally wrong but working class is treated pretty badly in a place like SF.
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by davidw on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @12:50AM (#36054204)
I think all the casting doubt about some recent mass shooter being a nazi has a viable claim in terms of cake taking.

I used to think he was eccentric but did some cool stuff too.

I now have a very negative opinion of him as a person.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by mouzogu on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:13AM (#36054331)
Musk presenting wfh as a moral argument frustrates me, and comparing office workers with manual workers strikes me a false dichotomy.

Everyone is different, and flexibility should be a recognition of that.

If anything the arbitrary denial of flexibility is much more of a moral argument.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by xwowsersx on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @01:34AM (#36054451)
That was a real head scratcher for me too. I really think it was some kind of a virtue signal. He framed it in a way that evokes a kind of righteous indignation from people...like calling out the privilege of people who work from home when there are nurses who have no choice but to be at their workplace. I too tried to see the argument, but I just don't get it. I _can_ work from home and some people can't...therefore I ought to travel to some arbitrary place...for what exactly? As a show of solidarity with people who don't have a choice? I just don't get it...
Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:30AM (#36054789)
Take it to it's absurd conclusion... Is it morally wrong for you to have a job sitting at a desk while someone else digs ditches all day?

It's obviously not. The fundamental differentiator is what is the nature of the job? What are the needs to accomplish the work being performed? If it's typing on a computer and talking to people, it can be done from home. It's not morally wrong to do it that way.

As someone who generally likes what Musk has to say, this one threw me for a loop. He's smarter than that and I don't think for one second he truly believes that. I think it's a public position he is taking on the subject, moralizing to dismiss criticism, he has other motivations. I don't think they're "his ego" but I don't think he genuinely believes it's morally wrong to sit down while typing.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by Mizoguchi on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @06:12AM (#36055965)
How about people with dangerous jobs? police officers, firefighters, miners and ironworkers, pilots, soldiers, drivers...

Would that make having a desktop job morally wrong?

I get Elon's point that manufacturing often requires some people to report to site, particularly in a company like Tesla.

But generalizing and saying that all positions require to report to office because of moral and ethical reasons is ridiculous.

How about incentives for commuting to work? Not flashy offices with free snacks and meditation rooms, how about money?

Companies usually reallocate to remote suburban areas to pay less taxes, and they expect people to spent over 40 hours per month, a full week of additional work, for free, to commute to the office.

That's morally wrong from all angles.

Re:Amazon corporate workers plan walkout next week over retu... by pragmatic on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:11AM (#36057513)
He owns a car company. He needs people to need cars. Commuting in many places requires a car.

Cui bono?