[1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?hl=en&id=com.denp...
/s that’s probably the problem with an unsafe OS by default.
Many of these so called "antiviruses" are malware themselves.
Considering how absolutely dreadful iOS has been when it comes to CVEs allowing arbitrary code executions with kernel level privileges, I don't really think anyone gets to talk about iOS being "secure" by default. Secure for your grandfather maybe. There's a reason Zerodium values iOS zero days less than Android ones too [0], which is quite telling of the amount of them they already have in stock. See also Pegasus, which literally had multiple no-interaction RCEs for iPhones through iMessage (because Apple keeps parsing files through horribly vulnerable parsers). [1]
Apple gets to pretend that iOS is secure because they control the app store, which is the only official point of entry, and iOS is closed source.
[0] https://zerodium.com/program.html
[1] https://citizenlab.ca/2021/09/forcedentry-nso-group-imessage...
You could be right, but I don't think it's a given that the latter follows the former. The reason that Zerodium values iOS zero-days less than Androids is more likely because the US and European governments that purchase these exploits from Zerodium value iOS less than Android, which itself could be attributed to there simply being more Android phones used by adversarial countries than iOS.
iirc it was the other way around for some time
Why did you need to download anything besides Uber? You said that was the only thing he needed a smartphone for.
It really doesn't matter to the point of the story though.
I prefer firefox with a few addons because I generally know what I want, but opera and brave have good defaults out of the box from what I hear.
The article also mentions that the problem is not with Android, but with some unknown phone brands.
The Apple App Store does have shady apps (see for example the recent ChatGPT clones) but the problem there is much less severe. Whether it stays that way with alternative app stores proposed in the EU is an interesting prospect, and a separate question though.
Bad actors have exploited vulnerabilities and because of that there has been a bigger emphasis on security, even down to the hardware level.
One could argue that the sandbox model used in iOS and other operating systems is a response to that era of malware. And we’re more secure because of it.
But a lot of people including myself think of them more as consoles or appliances.
And so it makes perfectly logical sense that we want the flexibility and freedom on our Mac but not on our phones.
It's possible malware somehow found its way to the phone, but the more likely scenario is that the phone was infected out of the factory.
The bottom of the barrel Android phones (no name brands, often phones <$200) feature system level adware that downloads and installs more crap as time goes on. It's one of the reasons these phones can be sold for that cheap.
I have to wonder what brand phone you got him. I've never seen this happen on brand phones, it's always the AliExpress/Amazon crap that's full of ads in seconds. Spend the same amount of money you'd spend on an iPhone SE and I highly doubt you'll get the same result.
This is not correct. In fact the permissions paradigm for both systems is basically identical.
I hasn't been like this for at least 5 years (maybe more), your knowledge is out of date.
Android permissions are asked whenever needed, granular and regularly expire automatically.
Worst is I’ve ever used. Absolute dog poop
Honestly, my Windows machine needs no more attention than my Mac OSX machine. Technically, more, but I do a lot more heavy lifting on my Mac (so I need to reboot more often to free up memory and such).
EDIT: Rather ; can anyone help everyone with a write-up for locking MSFT ads out and keeping normal function?
Anyone 'wireshark' this bitch?
I've had this problem out of nowhere one day (computer would not stop crashing randomly) and it turned out to be a defective memory stick. All good after replacing it.
Windows doesn't overcommit and in GPU-accelerated apps these days the driver commits never-used main memory to back GPU memory.
Result is some users will have tabs and apps crash from out of memory even with 16 GiB of main memory if swap is disabled or very small.
Hint, there's likely a problem with your hardware.
That’s wild. Self replicating bloatware. How could this even be legislated against? I can’t figure out how to legally qualify something as “bloatware” vs something the user would want to automatically download/update.
The problem is that nobody will go after the FWUWGFISA brand of phone on Amazon. They disappear next week and reappear as FUFWEIW. Either Amazon needs to get their crap together (I doubt that'll ever happen) or consumers need to make better purchasing decisions than "let's sort by price and pick the first one in the list".
I don't think there's a good way to solve this problem without massively impacting businesses that do deserve the benefit of the doubt. The driving force behind this crap is consumers preferring the slightly cheaper Amazon rates despite all the news about scams. Perhaps some public education campaign about the problems with resellers can help, and maybe some legislation forcing platforms to show the branding of the actual seller instead of their own, but I don't think placing the responsibility directly on the platform is a good solution to this problem.
I personally stopped trusting Oneplus a while ago. They once were the champions of open source Android phones with affordable models and clean ROMs, but they seem to have changed lanes to become your average Chinese smartphone manufacturer a while back, with expensive phones, questionable business practices, lacking update guarantees and support, and so on.
I've never trusted a carrier branded phone, that basically adds a layer of crap and problematic customization that I don't need. Carriers and ISPs are notoriously shit at providing useful services, that's why Apple become popular for refusing customized phones, and their incompetent and malicious layers on top of already mediocre Android implementations are just a recipe for disaster.
I realize these types of phones are much more common over in the USA, but there's a reason they're cheaper than when you buy the phone from a normal store and it's not because your carrier sympathizes with your financial situation and decides you deserve to save some money.
Xiaomi is the worst, selling top spec phones for dirt cheap by subsidizing them with ads, but even they never ruin your battery life by spamming ads all over the place. Plus, you can turn them off during setup, but most people just hit next to get the annoying setup screens to disappear it seems.
The default choices for settings were terrible. Some components aren't even configurable at all - lots of Samsung's apps and default Android stuff can send notifications, sit in background all the time or report location if its enabled.
Even with this permission, you still need to manually verify every app you install. Background installation is reserved for apps part of the system image (i.e. Google Play, Samsung Store, Huawei Whatevertheycallit, etc.).
These apps don't just appear, they need to be confirmed every single time. For a dropper to get installed into the system and successfully install another app, you need to confirm four different security prompts. That also assumes Play Protect doesn't immediately get rid of the dropper; antivirus scanning, even for apps not part of the Play Store, has been built into Android system images for this reason.
I completely believe their story, I've seen these ad ridden crapdroids with my own eyes. But every single time they have come with malware preinstalled by some shady AliExpress/Amazon reseller.
The current status quo actually stifles competition, because the only way to reasonably avoid these products is to limit yourself to an oligopoly of established (and expensive) brands. Between the two extremes of reputable and adware-subsidized devices, no-name manufacturers that just want to compete on price with shitty hardware and limited support/updates have no real shot.
there are plenty of perfectly respectable phones available for less than 200 USD. At least they are in Norway, for instance, Moto, Nokia, Xiaomi. My Moto G30 (>6 inch display, 128 GB storage, 64 MP main camera) from Lenovo was only 120 USD a couple of years ago.
Can't imagine why anyone would buy a no name mobile at the same price.
If I need an inexpensive phone, I usually buy a refurbished or used phone from a good brand, like Sony or Samsung or Google.
Nothing new, this has been going on since the early days of android / ios. Good hygiene: deactivate/uninstall any/all apps you can at first boot, reboot, then install anew all the apps you really use. Takes a few minutes/hours, worth it most of the time. YMMV.
After 9 months of using the tablets, they all would have an ad pop-up on the lock screen. I'm guessing that they came with malware that activated after X months of use.
Anyway, we wiped the tablets and reinstalled our app from scratch. It wasn't too hard because the tablets were single-purpose, but if those tablets were personal tablets with all of my favorite things, it would suck.
Those things are the bane of my existence. I support / develop some tablet / phone business apps. Some customers cheap out up front on tablets and then I have listen to them complain that leopards ate their face (the tablets come with pre-installed garbage, one of them demands you log in to at least 3 different services on every reboot, strangely slow / unpredictable OS response times to simple API calls...).
It's horrible, I own a couple of the customer's tablets to provide better support and +90% of the time the issue is "you cheaped out and bought a crappy tablet".
These folks save sub $10K or even way less than that up front and then these crappy tablets and their crap-ware eats up their productivity endlessly. Sometimes they have compliance issues with their own people because they tried rebooting and it takes FOREVER for the cheap tablet to actually be usable so their employees don't do the thing with the app at all...
I just tell them all they should have bought iPads / we recommend buying an iPad.
At this point I'm quietly lobbying that we stop supporting Android "unofficially" and push anyone new to use iPads. Android support will be there for the sake of saying we support it... but only as an alternative / best effort just because the ecosystem is full of such bad products / eats up our time with "not the application" / "your people didn't do the thing because they hate their tablet / it didn't work" issues.
What brand?
Haven't been following much (since I'm not interested in paying close to $1k for a phone) but from what I gather the Pixels are still excellent devices.
I can't speak to bloatware on their latest versions, because I switched to a Pixel due to the update policy.
I would assert that the iPhone SE is the best smartphone bang for the buck, especially for users in your family with a tendency to shoot themselves in the foot and need your assistance.
The $399 iPhone SE from 2016 got six years of OS updates and just got another security update last month. That's about $57 per supported year.
As an Android user, I think I'm on-board with this sentiment. Anecdotally, most of the people I know with Android phones are in IT; specifically software engineers.
I once had to transfer files that were downloaded on my phone to a work laptop that couldn't access the external internet and no access to external storage. I installed Termux on my Android phone, dropped to the linux terminal, installed http-server and spun up a server on the local network. I was then able to download the files I needed off of my phone.
Quirky scenarios like the one I mentioned where I can "MacGyver" my Android phone is why I really like the platform. And then there's F-Droid so I don't have to deal with those pesky apps from the Google Play store.
I don't get it, why didn't you plug in a USB cable?
I wish Android devices instead worked like iPods, which had a partition that mounted as a plain old USB/Firewire disk when plugged into a computer.
maybe i have been spoiled by the real computer in my pocket experience of custom rom's.
Frankly, the problem is the ubiquity of native apps. You don't need a native app to get the weather. It shouldn't have any permissions. This is the whole premise of the web. The web has its own problems, but it can't ruin a device like poorly-considered native apps can.
So at least on iOS, the impact of native junkware is limited to notification spam and can't run battery life into the ground as badly. It's not much worse than PWAs can do with webworkers and push notification permissions (and if someone has been granting every app push permissions, you can be sure they'll do the same for PWA push permissions).
Apps are a remininent of the personal computer experience of installing software. but for better or worse that ecosystem does not really exist on phones. apps exist in a sandbox environment with a fine grain permission for device access. really they should just transparently install and run and uninstall. It should behave like a web page with a saner execution environment. the main reason the app ecosystem exists the way it does is so the os manufacturer can seek rent on the device.
This is why I am so thankful the internet and the web were developed in an academic environment rather than a commercial environment. centralized rent seeking was not a design goal of the internet.
I have a somewhat increasingly constrain opinion on HN. May be Steve Jobs's original model was right / better. Only First Party and extremely selected third party Native Apps. And everything else being Web / HTML 5 Apps.
I pretty much forced her to go to iOS and she's been happen ever since. She really resisted me, though, and complained for a few months, but now agrees it's better.
I switched in Jan 2020. I got so sick of having to upgrade phones every 2 years to get updates. I understand that's changed now (Pixel phones gets updates for 3 or 4 years?), but for more than a decade I bought a new phone every 2 years. I've had the same iPhone (11) since 1/20 and I will keep it for as long as it has updates and/or the battery lasts. So far, it feels like the day I got it.
I completely agree with your last sentence. The protected garden Apple creates is a blessing for most tech illiterate users.
Fast forward 2 weeks and he’s complaining the battery only lasts a couple hours.
The Lock Screen was littered with gambling ads, there were all kinds of apps installed, and the phone was basically unusable.
He claimed to have no idea how it happened. I assumed he was just clicking on any/every pop up. Maybe he really downloaded 1 bad app which then self installed the rest of this crap?
Anyway, I went back to the store and bought him an iPhone SE. That was years ago now and haven’t heard a single complaint since.
I think android phones aren’t for the tech illiterate. It’s way too easy to screw them up.