News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jeroenhd on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:23AM (#36021147)
Apps can't just install other apps. You need system level permissions for something like that to happen.

It's possible malware somehow found its way to the phone, but the more likely scenario is that the phone was infected out of the factory.

The bottom of the barrel Android phones (no name brands, often phones <$200) feature system level adware that downloads and installs more crap as time goes on. It's one of the reasons these phones can be sold for that cheap.

I have to wonder what brand phone you got him. I've never seen this happen on brand phones, it's always the AliExpress/Amazon crap that's full of ads in seconds. Spend the same amount of money you'd spend on an iPhone SE and I highly doubt you'll get the same result.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by yardie on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:38AM (#36021342)
It's' been a few years since I used an Android phone daily. But one of the nice things about iOS is the granularity of permissions. For Android app permissions are asked once during install and you take it or leave it. iOS is constantly renewing requests for location permissions and other things. And it reinforces that you are in control of your device. If you don't want an app or site to have location data you don't have to give it.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by tsimionescu on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:57AM (#36021619)
The same is true on Android today. You are asked for permissions the first time the app needs them, not at installation time. And various things require various permissions, you don't get asked in bulk.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by Xorlev on Sunday May 21, 2023 @10:57AM (#36021620)
Android also reaps permissions that either haven't been used recently. In the case of location, Android prompts for renewal.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by ajross on Sunday May 21, 2023 @11:16AM (#36021822)
> For Android app permissions are asked once during install and you take it or leave it.

This is not correct. In fact the permissions paradigm for both systems is basically identical.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by josephcsible on Sunday May 21, 2023 @12:09PM (#36022333)
Are you comparing the permission system iOS has today with the one Android had a decade ago?
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by realusername on Sunday May 21, 2023 @12:33PM (#36022548)
> For Android app permissions are asked once during install and you take it or leave it

I hasn't been like this for at least 5 years (maybe more), your knowledge is out of date.

Android permissions are asked whenever needed, granular and regularly expire automatically.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by samstave on Sunday May 21, 2023 @11:40AM (#36022045)
Kind of like windows 11

Worst is I’ve ever used. Absolute dog poop

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by RHSeeger on Sunday May 21, 2023 @12:42PM (#36022621)
Weird. I'm running Windows 11, and I reboot every week or two, if that. I have no problems with performance whatsoever. Mind you, I'm not a big fan of 11, but I certainly haven't seen the issues you're describing.

Honestly, my Windows machine needs no more attention than my Mac OSX machine. Technically, more, but I do a lot more heavy lifting on my Mac (so I need to reboot more often to free up memory and such).

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by samstave on Monday May 22, 2023 @03:36PM (#36035689)
Do you have a FW rule for blocking any and all ads/whatever connections whereby MSFT is slurping ads/news from?

EDIT: Rather ; can anyone help everyone with a write-up for locking MSFT ads out and keeping normal function?

Anyone 'wireshark' this bitch?

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by secondcoming on Sunday May 21, 2023 @12:47PM (#36022663)
Strange. Check your RAM maybe. I can't remember the last time Windows crashed on me.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by samstave on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:12PM (#36022905)
When you say "check your ram" do you mean consumption, or quality?
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by zuminator on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:22PM (#36022985)
Sometimes bad quality ram chips, or set with the wrong timing in UEFI, or just not properly seated ram, can cause problems similar to what you've described. Anecdotally I have W11 installed on 5 different machines and none of them have the issues you're describing.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by andersa on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:50PM (#36023221)
Run the memory test that comes with windows. It takes like an hour or something, and will tell you if the memory is malfunctioning - that would explain all the mysterious crashes.

I've had this problem out of nowhere one day (computer would not stop crashing randomly) and it turned out to be a defective memory stick. All good after replacing it.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by bsdetector on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:37PM (#36023598)
More likely not enough swap space.

Windows doesn't overcommit and in GPU-accelerated apps these days the driver commits never-used main memory to back GPU memory.

Result is some users will have tabs and apps crash from out of memory even with 16 GiB of main memory if swap is disabled or very small.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by samstave on Monday May 22, 2023 @10:16AM (#36031729)
I think this may be the answer... Ill investigate.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by stevenhuang on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:27PM (#36023506)
When something ubiquitously used breaks that often you should stop to consider if maybe your experience is not normal, and so seek to find what's wrong with it.

Hint, there's likely a problem with your hardware.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jeroenhd on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:50PM (#36023709)
That's not normal at all. I have a healthy amount of hatred for Windows 11 myself, with its awful push to Microsoft accounts and the preinstalled crapware, but full system crashes are very rare in my experience. That sounds like a hardware issue (bad RAM?) or a broken driver to me. Gaming mode being triggered by browsing tabs does make it sound like some preinstalled tool by the laptop vendor is messing up.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by Our_Benefactors on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:05PM (#36022830)
> downloads and installs more crap as time goes on

That’s wild. Self replicating bloatware. How could this even be legislated against? I can’t figure out how to legally qualify something as “bloatware” vs something the user would want to automatically download/update.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jeroenhd on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:49PM (#36023209)
With the amount of data this crapware collects, basic privacy regulations should do the job. Trojans and adware are already on the boundary between legal and illegal at best in many countries.

The problem is that nobody will go after the FWUWGFISA brand of phone on Amazon. They disappear next week and reappear as FUFWEIW. Either Amazon needs to get their crap together (I doubt that'll ever happen) or consumers need to make better purchasing decisions than "let's sort by price and pick the first one in the list".

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by aembleton on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:07PM (#36023336)
Or the regulation could target amazon for selling sub par goods.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by LadyCailin on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:01PM (#36023294)
Easy on that one too: make the seller partly responsible for the shit they sell. Amazon is profiting from the situation, so make them responsible as well.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jeroenhd on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:47PM (#36023686)
That'd be ideal, but that would also end sites like eBay and other points of sale for second hand items for good. You could make an exception for second hand sales, but then every shady foreign reseller will just list their item as refurbished.

I don't think there's a good way to solve this problem without massively impacting businesses that do deserve the benefit of the doubt. The driving force behind this crap is consumers preferring the slightly cheaper Amazon rates despite all the news about scams. Perhaps some public education campaign about the problems with resellers can help, and maybe some legislation forcing platforms to show the branding of the actual seller instead of their own, but I don't think placing the responsibility directly on the platform is a good solution to this problem.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by 13of40 on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:12PM (#36022902)
I've owned several OnePlus phones, all bought straight from the company except the most recent one, which is T-Mobile branded and bought from the T-Mobile store. Unlike the previous ones, this one has strange behavior around app alerting permissions: I block all alerts from Starbucks or Prime Video, for example, and they're quiet for several days/weeks, then start alerting again. I thought I was misremembering at first, so I started taking a screenshot every time I turned off all alerts for an app and confirmed it's real behavior. I'm sure it's just a bug or something, but the conspiracy nut in me wonders if companies like those can slip T-Mobile some money under the table and get them to "fix" people's alerting preferences.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jeroenhd on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:59PM (#36023282)
Android will retract permissions automatically if you haven't used apps for a while. It's possible that this mechanism is implemented wrong (i.e. they just reset the permissions regardless of whether they've been denied before).

I personally stopped trusting Oneplus a while ago. They once were the champions of open source Android phones with affordable models and clean ROMs, but they seem to have changed lanes to become your average Chinese smartphone manufacturer a while back, with expensive phones, questionable business practices, lacking update guarantees and support, and so on.

I've never trusted a carrier branded phone, that basically adds a layer of crap and problematic customization that I don't need. Carriers and ISPs are notoriously shit at providing useful services, that's why Apple become popular for refusing customized phones, and their incompetent and malicious layers on top of already mediocre Android implementations are just a recipe for disaster.

I realize these types of phones are much more common over in the USA, but there's a reason they're cheaper than when you buy the phone from a normal store and it's not because your carrier sympathizes with your financial situation and decides you deserve to save some money.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by senectus1 on Sunday May 21, 2023 @07:02PM (#36025416)
thats a fairly recent development.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by sizzle on Sunday May 21, 2023 @04:27PM (#36024405)
This behavior drove me crazy enough to get an iPhone and I’ve never looked back. Respect my settings google.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by supriyo-biswas on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:13PM (#36022913)
Or an OTA was pushed out with adware. Samsung and Xiaomi phones do this a lot.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jeroenhd on Sunday May 21, 2023 @01:50PM (#36023223)
I've never seen anything as aggressive as what the parent describes on either Samsung or Xiaomi.

Xiaomi is the worst, selling top spec phones for dirt cheap by subsidizing them with ads, but even they never ruin your battery life by spamming ads all over the place. Plus, you can turn them off during setup, but most people just hit next to get the annoying setup screens to disappear it seems.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by pndy on Sunday May 21, 2023 @06:57PM (#36025387)
I've bought used Samsung A50 few days ago as a spare phone. I had Windows Phones, iPhones previously but never got Android device for myself and I never saw anywhere (even in case of my mother's obscure low-end Android device) so many vendor apps being installed in such short time after enabling WiFi password.

The default choices for settings were terrible. Some components aren't even configurable at all - lots of Samsung's apps and default Android stuff can send notifications, sit in background all the time or report location if its enabled.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by Zircom on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:28PM (#36023522)
On Android when installing from an unknown/unverified source, the installer can literally prompt you with a link to the correct settings page where you can enable installing from other sources, and once you click it opens the correct page, scrolls to the right toggle switch, and highlights it for you. So I totally believe OPs story.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jeroenhd on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:42PM (#36023644)
If you enable that setting, your browser can install other apps. The app you're installing can't. There used to be a global toggle, but that's been removed for years. Sure, the app you've installed can prompt for installer permissions, but that's a second prompt you need to go through.

Even with this permission, you still need to manually verify every app you install. Background installation is reserved for apps part of the system image (i.e. Google Play, Samsung Store, Huawei Whatevertheycallit, etc.).

These apps don't just appear, they need to be confirmed every single time. For a dropper to get installed into the system and successfully install another app, you need to confirm four different security prompts. That also assumes Play Protect doesn't immediately get rid of the dropper; antivirus scanning, even for apps not part of the Play Store, has been built into Android system images for this reason.

I completely believe their story, I've seen these ad ridden crapdroids with my own eyes. But every single time they have come with malware preinstalled by some shady AliExpress/Amazon reseller.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by flangola7 on Sunday May 21, 2023 @03:11PM (#36023852)
Background installation for 3rd party apps was added in Android 12. You only have to complete the manual approval the first time
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by buu700 on Sunday May 21, 2023 @02:52PM (#36023721)
I can't help but think that some sort of regulation here is overdue. You shouldn't need above average technical literacy just to avoid buying a product that actively and intentionally harms you.

The current status quo actually stifles competition, because the only way to reasonably avoid these products is to limit yourself to an oligopoly of established (and expensive) brands. Between the two extremes of reputable and adware-subsidized devices, no-name manufacturers that just want to compete on price with shitty hardware and limited support/updates have no real shot.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by jaynate on Sunday May 21, 2023 @06:15PM (#36025144)
You either pay for the product or you are the product. No different than “free” software. Want a smart phone you’re going to pay for it one way or the other.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by buu700 on Monday May 22, 2023 @01:38AM (#36027817)
Not really sure what you're getting at. The devices we're discussing are cheap, not free.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by kwhitefoot on Sunday May 21, 2023 @06:10PM (#36025107)
> no name brands, often phones <$200

there are plenty of perfectly respectable phones available for less than 200 USD. At least they are in Norway, for instance, Moto, Nokia, Xiaomi. My Moto G30 (>6 inch display, 128 GB storage, 64 MP main camera) from Lenovo was only 120 USD a couple of years ago.

Can't imagine why anyone would buy a no name mobile at the same price.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by nine_k on Sunday May 21, 2023 @07:03PM (#36025430)
Xiaomi have great hardware, but I can't trust their software one bit :(

If I need an inexpensive phone, I usually buy a refurbished or used phone from a good brand, like Sony or Samsung or Google.

Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by unaindz on Sunday May 21, 2023 @07:14PM (#36025504)
Xiaomi makes it very easy to unlock the bootloader and install a custom ROM. Of course you should trust the ROM makers and learning how to flash every device takes a little bit of time but I think is worth it.
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by Crespyl on Sunday May 21, 2023 @09:49PM (#36026513)
Do they still require you to make an account with them and wait a few weeks, or am I thinking of a different manufacturer?
Re:Potentially millions of Android TVs and phones come with ... by cute_boi on Monday May 22, 2023 @07:11PM (#36037882)
Actually thats a protection. Many frauds were found to custom unlock the phone and sell those phone with malware, so they decided to make unlocking process hard. Phone are unlocked by bad people, too, but I agree thats quite annoying.