Google Brain was formed in 2011. If that's not coherent investment in a long term strategy I don't know what would qualify.
When you have all you need theoretically in house but your moves are rushed and come only as a reaction to the competition you are the very example I was trying to make, of milking your cash cow and waiting too long. Google had to change the strategy [0], reorganize [1], and struggle to launch your product in an emergency as a response to competition. This is the very definition of not having a well thought out long term strategy, isn't it?
Google owned Brain and DeepMind as rival divisions since before OpenAI existed. They didn't cooperate, didn't launch any revolutionary product, and didn't compete in any way with Google's main offering. They were left to their own devices like side projects until the competition dashed in front and hit Google's most sensitive area and dictated their strategy.
I don't know if Bard is a good or bad product. But we may have different definitions of a coherent investment in a long term strategy to make a better product. None of the above shouts "coherent", "long term strategy", or even necessarily "better product".
[0] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/01/feari...
[1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/04/googles-ai-panic-for...
Google Voice Search cannibalized search since forever, without being monetizable. Google realized the importance of ML/AI early, and has had a coherent AI strategy that predates most AI companies - I would argue Google's strategy precipitated the existence of those companies by performing and publishing foundational research in the field.
Pixel phones are a masterclass of applied ML in a very humane way one might expect from Apple- e.g. call screening with realtime transcription.
bart is only being made public because openai did a thing
This is exactly the opposite of what was meant
I disagree on this. The iPhone was a potential iPod replacement when it launched, but the choice was selling $200 iPods or $500 iPhones. The iPhone felt like a leap of several generations, but the hardware and business model were still similar.
Where Apple actually cannibalized something was Apple Music and the iTunes store, but they drug their feet on it.
I don't think we are in disagreement. But the fact is very few companies do this regardless. When it comes to the product that's their bread and butter they tend to put it on a pedestal never to be touched until it falls into irrelevance.
Apple didn't launch an improved iPod and retire the old. They didn't try to sell a phone and a music player by artificially differentiating them, or by sabotaging one of them. They didn't try to make $250 off the iPod and another $250 from a phone that "shouldn't compete too well". They launched 2 product lines made by different parts of the company, knowing that the iPhone may undermine the iPod userbase and then still fail, possibly souring those customers.
Again to give the Google example, when they tried to have competing lines (Google/Nest) they managed to fail at both and lose the customers completely.
They’re gradually bridging them (Catalyst, and adding cursor support to iPadOS), and speaking as a fan of both product lines I’m glad they’re trying to make them each more powerful without just slapping them into a single UI.
Could they do a better job of supporting external devices on iPad? I imagine so, but there’s such a long road from the extremely-protective/simplistic/sandboxed iOS 1.0 to a full-fledged workstation operating system I have to think it’s not all that easy.
[0]: https://www.cultofmac.com/325034/apples-music-streaming-nego...
[1]: https://variety.com/2018/biz/news/spotify-at-days-close-what...
The iPod Classic got relatively little updates toward the end of the iPod line because while it had a dedicated fan base due to its ability to store truly massive music libraries, it just wasn't selling much.
This was also the first time we really saw the scale Tim Cook could push for - competitors had difficulty going up against Apple because they hadn't just bought out all the available flash in the channel - they had funded building new factories for building denser/cheaper flash, in return for their entire initial production.
I think the most recent apple golden age was around 2007 when they switched to intel. This allowed folks to use apple hardware and macos, but also run windows on their systems. mac os was more open. The mac pro embraced the PC ecosystem, hard drives, pcie cards and more.
Nowadays the pendulum is swinging the other way and though it might be good for apple's bottom line, I don't think it's better for customers (or apple long term)
The M1 MacBook Pro is the best laptop I’ve ever used.
But I also think the abusive, controlling behaviour they exhibit when it comes to their hardware is shockingly bad. (See: any of Louis Rossman's videos).
I also think its awful how controlling Apple is over the software that runs on iPhones. For example, apparently the city of SF needs to pay Apple millions of dollars a year to allow iphones to be used as clipper tickets. Why is apple paid money for this? Users have already bought the NFC chips in their phones from Apple. Installing themselves as an unaccountable, monopolistic middleman is disgusting behaviour.
Apple is the the only big tech company which at least nominally cares about user privacy. Google, culturally, doesn't really make any products which don't depend on their cloud services. Last time I owned an android phone, I tried saying no to most of the modals google throws up asking permission to upload my personal data. Some features broke in horrible ways - presumably the devs didn't actually test what happens when people refuse consent dialogs. And lots of features become flat out unavailable. For example, their AI assistant. Despite all that, they still ended up storing more data on me than I'm comfortable with. I think android is only a viable OS if you let google track everything you do. I don't want that, either.
On the computer side, the framework laptops look lovely. I've moved to linux for my desktop workstation and my next laptop might be a framework laptop. But there are absolutely compromises. Battery life isn't as good. Linux isn't as cohesive as macos - keyboard shortcuts are all over the place. I tried to configure linux to feel like macos but some apps won't let you use the meta key as a modifier key. Linux doesn't integrate with an iphone at all. Being able to copy+paste from laptop to phone is an absolutely killer feature. Or take a photo and airdrop it across. Or stop my phone alarm by talking to a siri smart speaker elsewhere in my house.
There are no options for everyday computing that I'm entirely happy with. For now, like it or not, Apple has my business.
Systems using your NFC chip like clipper don’t work through Apple Pay. My understanding is organisations building apps using the iPhone nfc chip like that have to pay apple millions for the privilege. On android the equivalent api is free and open.
My understanding is whenever you make a payment a myriad of companies get paid. I would assume Google is one of those?
That doesn't change wether or not NFC is open of course.
I'm 3 years in and have never needed servicing. If I do, I'm fine having to go back to Apple. It's not a good fit for everyone. But it is for my niche. (Also, Apple stand out in having long first-party support runways for their products.)
otoh i hope to be burried with my m1 airbook (for home use) -- i hope never to buy another notebook class device, and just keep replacing the battery every 5 yrs.
It's not bad to want to pull apart and service your own laptop, but for me it's a tool to get a job done and if it breaks I'll send it to Apple to fix
My previous Intel Retina MBP lasted from 2012 to 2020, and now my dad uses it because it still works fine. My younger brother uses my ~2008 17" MacBook Pro (it only runs on wall power, though). Repairability has just never been much of a concern in my use of Apple stuff
I never had a laptop for that long before. And just had to replace the battery once, by an after market one. The keys on the keyboard disappearing is the only notable aging symptom.
Maybe an outlier, but based on that, I'm confident the M1 may last long too.
Another way to look at this is - if Apple is so confident that their setup is absolutely incredibly good - why not make exiting with the data super easy? After all, if it is so good, people just won't leave even with those options available, right?
MacOS doesn't take your data hostage, you can exfilrate everything to anywhere you want .
Hell, all macs have a special boot mode that turn them into usb hard drives so you can access everything from another computer.
The iOS is a walled garden but you were misinformed if you think macos locks you into its app store or locks your data away.
Even if you feel like that might change one day, it doesn't justify lying about the present.
Assume a positve intent, was a valuable lesson for me.
I can still say, the new Apple Silicon Macs are one of the best computing devices I've ever used.
Note that back when macos first launched, if a program crashed wanted to send information to apple, you would get a popup, see what would be sent and decide whether to send it or not. Nowadays all kinds of things are just sent, like every time you create an account, even a local one or one for work, it phones home.
> quality of the physical device
Agreed. I really like their hardware but I still want to be in control and running my own software on it.
> lack of spyware
Doubt it.
> They aren’t looking to run windows or Linux or anything like that.
Asahi Linux compatibility will absolutely be a major factor in my willingness to purchase Apple hardware. I just purchased a phone because GrapheneOS recommended it. This stuff matters.
Unlike Microsoft, it’s not been reported anywhere that Apple has spyware built in. Props to Apple’s PR team if they’re so competent they can pull the wool over everyone’s eyes for years.
The number of people who want to sysadmin their phones is effectively zero.
I don't see myself running it for years, until it becomes the only way to get security updates to continue to use the hardware.
Apple has virtualization and paravirtualization built into the OS to run Linux and Windows as ARM VMs. They even have support to let ARM Linux use Rosetta 2 to run x86_64 ELF binaries.
I can already run Linux in a supported manner. I don't see a reason to run boot linux until my current hypervisor is no longer getting support.
M1 is a big improvement over that even without the upgrade flexibility early intel years offered.
M1 can run windows in parallels and it works well enough for most cases
The iPod was subsumed by the iPhone, not cannibalised. Parents were obligated to buy their kids a device with tracking/communication capabilities, so iPods became irrelevant. Now everyone buys the 2x more expensive device.
Now, if Apple were to merge the iPad and Macbook, I would agree with you readily.
but if you're going to carry a phone anyway, like digital handheld cameras, you don't need an extra device on top of your phone
I agree, a full phone was annoying large and hard to carry (tried forearm straps at one point) and often ran without one. Though I know people who still ran with a phone anyways.
- They waited years longer than the competition to switch to larger screens. They only really got to it with the iPhone 6.
- They completely slept on OLED and stuck to LCD until the iPhone X, when all mid to high range Android phones had already used OLED for years. Their iPads still use LCDs for apparently no good reason (lower price presumably), around ten years after Samsung sold their first OLED tablets.
- They slept on the screen-to-body ratio. They were years behind their Android competition when they finally changed their course with the iPhone X.
But if you prefer a system that just gets out of your way so you don’t need to think about it, and just use it as a tool to do something else then Apple is nearly unbeatable.
And I say this as a recent Apple convert. I reluctantly started using their tech a few years ago when a Macbook was the laptop given to me at a new job. But since embracing the idea of “meh I’ll just use the defaults and let the system get out of my way”, I feel like I get to spend more time on things where I add value.
I switched to an iPhone for the first time in 2020 with the SE, and it is still running fine today with no problems, on the latest software update. I don’t care about the screen-to-body ratio, I just want it to work well as a tool
The point that I was trying to make is that a general Apple consumer doesn’t really care about those things, but does like consistency. So Apple waits until they are pretty sure that something is actually valuable to customers, before releasing it.
Regarding of tablets: I have a 2017 Galaxy Tab S3, very heavily used. The screen is still basically flawless. Physical wear is only visible when the whole screen shows a very dark grey uniform image, which happens approximately never.
The brightness isn't an issue either, in my experience. LCD does use less power on average, particularly on websites (which are typically bright) or PDFs, but smartphones have rather small screens anyway and tablets have a quite large battery.
There was a reason for OLED. The first Android phones with OLED looked hideous. The saturation was all wrong and they used pentile subpixel arrangements. Further more I remember seeing pictures of burn-in on some (cheaper/off brand?) OLED phones.
Apple has their priorities. And display quality is one of them. Look at professional reviews of their monitors and other displays like the iPhones and iPads. Whatever people think of the cost/features they tend to be be impressed with the display accuracy out of the box.
They waited until they could get enough OLED screens to handle their demand. But they also wanted certain levels of color accuracy, I assume non-pentile, and something that could handle avoiding burn in for the expected lifetime of the phone.
That must have taken time.
Screen to body: I suspect they knew they were getting close on the iPhone X design and wanted it to really stand out, so they stuck with the forehead/chin longer than others. Total guess though.
There's a lot of people upset they switched to larger screens! I suspect that Steve Jobs really wanted the phone to continue to fit in his jeans watch pocket.
Android phones generally had to be larger for engineering reasons. But larger phones sell well.
> They completely slept on OLED and stuck to LCD until the iPhone X, when all mid to high range Android phones had already used OLED for years.
The iPhone has always had great screens. A lot of the early OLED screens were simply not good enough, cheap enough, and/or available at high enough production.
The iPhone X was more expensive and meant to be a smaller run compared to the main consumer line. It needed a screen with a concave cutout. It makes a lot of sense that this was their first OLED iPhone screen.
IIRC correctly, the iPhone X had much higher demand than Apple anticipated, and there were shortages due to the OLED screen.
Generally, android phones compare favorably because people will pick and choose the winning premium features and the lowest price from a set of Android phones, to compare against the single flagship iPhone. It's rigged.
Eventually people will be talking about how late Apple was to get into folding phones, when nearly all Android phones sold are still non-folding phones today, years after the first folder launched - and folders typically sell at over $1k premium.
> They slept on the screen-to-body ratio. They were years behind their Android competition when they finally changed their course with the iPhone X.
Is replacing hardware buttons with an always-displayed button bar really changing the screen-to-body ratio?
I see literally more ads on my iphone than I see on my Google Pixel, and it is one of Apple's fastest growing sources of revenue.
I've had multiple relatives with broken/stolen phones who lost very important photos because they were no longer being backed up.
You can always turn iCloud backup off if you think notices that the feature is failing are annoying, but the notices themselves are hardly misleading.
Perhaps instead of this being about Apple vs. Google (or others), it's about companies investing in their core competencies and areas where they have a business interest.
The other thing which they are very slow to support is new codecs on the video tag. Presumably this is because they want to keep their "video playback" power metrics. the WebKit team is incredibly metrics-driven, which is one reason for their performance and power-efficiency.
They’ve definitely made some significant missteps over the last few years, mostly around breaking storage APIs and being slow to fix it due to being part of the macOS release cadence.
Apple doesn't want other browsers because they don't want runtimes. They don't want a way for someone else to build a marketplace on top of iPhone or to escape Apple's stringent review process and deploy on their own timelines.
Last time I tried, Safari was a no-go. The web without an ad blocker is incredibly bad.
1) I don’t understand why it’s relevant. Parent commented about the lack of ad blocking and I simply shared a possible solution.
2) I don’t understand why complexity has to be factored in when it comes to pricing.
Should something be free just because it’s simple? Someone has to work and maintain that software.
You can also add quotes to "100%", as anything else in Safari, it was quite buggy and you had to use workarounds sometimes.
They both had to, f was dominant.
Not Android because it has a direct competition that is arguably doing much better ( More user switching to Apple than Android ) and is forced to improve in other to compete.
A whitebox iOS could be downgraded enough that they could still service the snob market, but maybe undercut Google completely. I mean, how much does it even have to cost per unit when each sold drives traffic to their own app store?
And that’s a huge part of the problem. Any move like that would tarnish iOS in everyone’s eyes. Apple wants you to buy a real iPhone, even if it’s the model from 2 years ago, instead.
If BMW started selling a ton of $18,000 cars do you think that would help or hurt sales of the M3 and the 5 Series?
That bit then with the clones. The competition undercut them. You know what that high Apple price does? Help pay to develop iOS.
They would have to charge enough to make up for the money they would lose on the list phone sales. And seriously risk their reputation in the process.
Apple has been through a lot in their 40 years. They have an atavistic reaction at this point against anything that prevents them from controlling their own destiny. It’s hurt them too many times.
I suspect that’s why they’re doing this. They don’t want to be beholden to Samsung, LG, or anyone else for displays.
Much the same thing as happened to Apple when they licensed their OS in the 90s, I imagine.
Google News took over and they gave up. Gmail got huge and they stopped doing much other than adding ads. Maps slowed down, other than adding ads. Google search keeps getting worse, they can’t seem to fix the SEO/spam problem. But they can add more ads.
Left to their own devices, Google seems happy to collect rent.
Apple, historically, makes their money by selling new hardware, and that requires improving things enough people want to buy it.
Such changes are usually also not newsworthy, unless one has to do leaps to catch up with a competitor (looking at you, Apple Maps)...
Google only has a few consumer products, but they made quite a few leaps in the past years for similar reasons (Pixel Phone has to catch up with Samsung, Pixel Watch has to catch up with Apple Watch), while Google/Nest Home is competing mainly with Amazon in an ecosystem war I'd say.
One could argue that the iPhone is not moving forward much in user-experience for a few years now, it's mainly iterating to achieve further cost-reduction/profit and enhance additional revenue streams of Apple.
- Apple Watch is mainly getting enhanced to create additional (healthcare/insurance/services) business for Apple.
- The iPad is under no stress to evolve other than cost-reduction in HW/SW development by harmonization with the iPhone, main strategy seems to be to push customers towards more expensive variants.
- The Macbook was indeed revolutionized, by applying the same supply-chain practice of the iPhone. Lots of leaps forward here in terms of tech, something only Apple could do. But Apple was also not leading this segment and is under strong competition, so they were forced to do something or dissolve into oblivion.
- The Desktop-Mac trajectory seems to be to become a MacBook without battery.
There's an easy explanation for that UX stagnation in iOS: iOS-products are actually not classical "products" anymore, but equipment for consuming services. The devices come bundled with a few free services from Apple and encouage you to consume other services from affiliates. Apple's main incentive is then not to sell new hardware, but to rollout new enabler-HW for selling additional services.
And they are in an increasing struggle to keep consumers "entertained" to pay for new enabler-HW, so apart from keeping control over their supply-chain they now need to become more exclusive in HW-components to lock-out competitors. Of course that can all be beneficial to the consumer, but would Apple move forward if they weren't forced by their business model?
I like the advice Steve Jobs gave the Harvard graduates: "Stay hungry, stay foolish."
The main difference between iOS and Android is that you have no choice but to use many of these first-party adware apps on iOS.
Oh the mighty power ipad with M2 chip and 5G modem but a crippling ipadOS that prevents one from making good use of the CPU power would like a word to argue with you :-)
I cannot think of any reason for Apple to not allow ipadOS to get proper multi-tasking than "oh this will start eating into our profits from the MacBook Air/Macbook Pro lines". I'm not advocating for MacOS on a touchscreen mode. I would have chosen the ipad Pro in a heatbeat if it could have real multi-tasking with a keyboard and a touchpad plugged in. I mean the chip is already there twiddling its thumbs..
Pretty much every company on planet earth other than Apple. There are actually Three key points here, long term, correct strategy and better. Most company would do pretty well if they even have just one of the three.
One could argue Intel didn't have any of the three for about 5 - 8 years.
One thing I really appreciate when it comes to Apple is that despite all their shortcomings they don't "sleep on the job". Over the years they never hesitated to cannibalize their own product lines (iPod), or go through several tough technological transitions (68K/PPC/x86/ARM) if it meant building a better product. And bigger profits of course.
For example I'm sure Google would just rather stuff your phone to the gills with ads in order to drive revenue than actually bother with a coherent investment in a long term strategy to make a better product. And bigger profits of course.