News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by z_open on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:10AM (#35578057)
I wish steam didn't have an effective monopoly on PC video game distribution. It was basically forced on us when CS 1.6 required it. But people will choose the option even slightly more convenient for them against ethical costs.

I frequently see people here justifying chrome over Firefox due to a really small feature relative to maintaining a healthier web.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by pjmlp on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:40AM (#35578211)
There is always the Windows Store and XBox games, or plain old physical boxes.

I never used Steam, nor plan to.

There isn't time to play everything.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by iforgotpassword on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:49AM (#35578249)
> or plain old physical boxes

Not anymore. Or hardly anymore. Often these contain a barely working game if at all, but might even just contain a download code for steam, origin etc.

And then there are a lot of games that release exclusively on steam. Oxygen not included comes to mind.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by pjmlp on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:11AM (#35578365)
Depends on the game, additionally there are plenty of 2nd hand fun games to chose from.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by flohofwoe on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:19AM (#35579229)
Did they finally fix the problem on Windows Store that large game downloads simply don't work? I actually thought they just gave up when the Microsoft 1st party games started showing up on Steam.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ttoinou on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:39AM (#35578200)

   It was basically forced on us when CS 1.6 required it.

Huh, they're the one who developed this video game in the first place
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ownagefool on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:51AM (#35578831)
CS was a half life mod that valve bought, so it's half-true.

Reality is almost everyone abandoned PC gaming for a decade+ in favour of consoles.

Valve and steam were the only real player, which is why they're in the position they're in.

I took an shining to GOG, but the the Linux situation just reaffirmed how I buy my games.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by jimbob45 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:41AM (#35578213)
Is your history off or was I always misguided? I thought Steam effectively launched such HL2 which included the release of CSS. CSS is what required it rather than 1.6, no?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by twostorytower on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:51AM (#35578262)
CS 1.6 definitely required it. 1.5 was the last version of CS on WON. It was the flagship game to have Steam for until Half-Life 2. And yes, CS:S also required it.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by skhr0680 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:57AM (#35578595)
CS 1.6 required Steam and was released together with Steam 1.0. You could say that it was a soft launch to get Steam ready for HL2 one year later.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by FredPret on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:17AM (#35578090)
Devil’s advocate:

Is it always unethical to buy something supplied by a monopoly?

Is convenience an ethical good, especially convenience delivered on a mass scale?

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by akira2501 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:36AM (#35578182)
> Is it always unethical to buy something supplied by a monopoly?

Never, it's just unethical to operate one.

> Is convenience an ethical good

I feel like this could only be true if your life was in actual danger when lacking that convenience. This is possibly the wrong question anyways, I'd ask if the externalized costs of that convenience are small enough to justify the imputed good of the service.

Which is why we can tolerate natural monopolies where collective safety is involved, such as electrical distribution, but shouldn't where it isn't, such as video game distribution.

> especially convenience delivered on a mass scale?

What special ethical properties does this provide?

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by wvenable on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:11AM (#35578367)
> Never, it's just unethical to operate one.

Is it? If you simply have no competition, you're running a monopoly. That doesn't seem like an unethical situation.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by diffeomorphism on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:19AM (#35579568)
That seems like frictionless spherical cows. Having a monopoly might happen for a very short time by being first, keeping one....
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by shagie on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:34AM (#35580969)
The issue isn't having a monopoly (which Steam doesn't) but rather doing anti-competitive things to maintain the monopoly.

Having a good product that people want and prefer to buy isn't anti-competitive. Establishing exclusive contracts with publishers and preventing something from being sold somewhere else for less is anti-competitive.

I don't find it reasonable to claim that Steam is a monopoly in the PC gaming space (there might be an argument for it if one were to try to limit it to "games distribution platforms that run on Linux"). And even assuming that they did have a monopoly, they aren't using anti-competitive techniques to maintain it.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by diffeomorphism on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:14AM (#35581352)
Correct and nobody claimed that.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by shagie on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:44PM (#35582774)
There is a statement further up in the comment tree that states ".. it's just unethical to operate [a monopoly]."

I'm trying to clarify that it's not unethical to have a monopoly, nor even maintain one - it is only unethical to maintain one in ways that are anticompetitive (and making the best product isn't anticompetitive).

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by FredPret on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:12AM (#35578377)
Convenience is an ethical good because it saves either time, energy, or thought, all of which are limited resources.

If a monopoly makes something more convenient for hundreds of millions of people, think of the species-wide savings.

Add up all conveniences, and you get real progress. For instance, many women in Africa are in charge of providing water and clean laundry for their households - not agreeing, just stating the facts. These two things are almost a full-time job if done by hand.

If things ever progressed to the point where African countries have mass-scale running water and washing machines, think of how hundreds of millions of adults suddenly have time and energy to do something else.

Now that's an extreme example, but the point stands. Making things convenient for others requires hard work upfront building systems and is to be encouraged.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by EtienneK on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:50AM (#35578259)
Once the ActiBlizz Microsoft sale goes through, then there will be a huge reason to switch to the Xbox / MS store: Gamepass.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Hamuko on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:19AM (#35578705)
I don't like renting my games. One of the nicest things about Steam is that I can still download and play the games I bought 17 years ago.

Also, if I need to choose my monopoly, I'll take Valve over Microsoft.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by olejorgenb on Sunday April 16, 2023 @06:41AM (#35588833)
I kinda get it, but what is the practical difference between that and re-renting the game 17 years later? In both scenarios you depend on the game still being available. (the buy model make it easier to keep the game around on some disk for 17 years ofc.)
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by poopooracoocoo on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:12AM (#35579192)
Why does the acquisition need to go through for Activision-Blizzard's titles to be on Xbox Game Pass?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by EtienneK on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:23AM (#35579973)
Because it goes from a hope to a rule. No need to hope that Diablo IV will be free on Gamepass, day 1 (and let's be serious, if ActiBlizz stays independent there is no hope in hell for this to happen) - but if the sale goes through then this will be reality.

Imagine Diablo IV or each of the Call of Duties... free... day 1. That is huge value. Something Steam can't compete with.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ThunderSizzle on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:10AM (#35580317)
Accounting and exclusivity. MS can try to make GamePass a gate for all future purchases, and the interchange cost is just moving money around inside MS at that point.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by mrfinn on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:02AM (#35578312)
GOG is the way to go. Enough with the DRM BS. Is not only about ethical costs, all that people that invested thousands creating a huge library better pray Valve doesn't get into any trouble... or they get into any trouble with Valve. Buying and in the end, not owning anything doesn't look like buying at all!.

PS. I'm not angry with Valve because they use DRM in their platform, I'm angry with Valve because they don't give publishers the option to distribute their games using an offline, DRM free installer.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Hamuko on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:22AM (#35578722)
I thought that it was possible to have DRM-free games on Steam?

https://www.pcgamingwiki.com/wiki/The_big_list_of_DRM-free_g...

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by pseudo0 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:43AM (#35578792)
It is. Allowing DRM seems to be a concession to publishers, since there is no real benefit for Valve. If anything it's a significant hindrance that is obstructing their effort to get as much Steam Deck support as possible. Windows-only DRM and anticheat are some of the worst offenders for breaking Proton compatibility.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by SXX on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:44AM (#35578795)
The point is that Steam itself is DRM. Even if game itself can work standalone you can't install or update it without Steam client. This is the difference between Steam and GOG.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by agentgumshoe on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:59AM (#35578882)
What is the Steam client doing that makes it a problem?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by SXX on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:09AM (#35578926)
Like making me login again into Steam at random for whatever reason Valve come up with? I guess there was bug on older macOS where it asked me for password every single time I restarted Steam. Now this is fixed though. There is offline mode, but it's unreliable.

I know that some games might run without Steam, but it's not comfortable at all.

And yeah It's not a problem. It's just a difference between Steam and DRM-free platforms like GOG.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by autoexec on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:19AM (#35579570)
> There is offline mode, but it's unreliable.

Even when it's working, eventually it stops working and you'll be forced to connect to the internet. I learned this the hard way once. When you're already dealing with the fact that you don't have internet access, having your access to your single player offline games taken from you is just cruel!

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by t0bia_s on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:14AM (#35578952)
It's like man in middle that doesn't have to be there.

I'm buying games exclusively on GoG because DRM free policy.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by thaumasiotes on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:21AM (#35578983)
GoG doesn't have a DRM-free policy. DRM is allowed. Has been for quite a while.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by t0bia_s on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:27AM (#35579003)
GoG galaxy is not must like Steam.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by thaumasiotes on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:00AM (#35579132)
That depends what you're trying to do.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by debugnik on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:02AM (#35579142)
Galaxy also has an SDK that devs can choose to require for their game; if they don't it's for lack of adoption.

Their docs do admittedly ask devs to make integration optional for the user, but their definition of optional includes "no multiplayer" as well.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:42AM (#35581645)
> but their definition of optional includes "no multiplayer" as well.

I don't think this is ideal by any means, but I do think it's a reasonable compromise.

For better or worse, many/most modern multiplayer games are architected to use a centralized, company-run software. The server software is not built to be deployed by end-users, and getting it to that state would involve very significant engineering effort. It's just not a reasonable ask.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by flohofwoe on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:27AM (#35579281)
Steam also allows DRM free games, it's probably just not very popular with game developers.

One advantage of GoG is that they seem to actually care that old games on their store are actually working on new Windows versions, while on Steam it's more or less a gamble (at least you can return broken games though).

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by depressedpanda on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:29AM (#35579638)
In some ways I think we've reached a point where it's easier to run old Windows games on Linux via Wine/Proton, than on the latest version of Windows.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bentley on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:28AM (#35579286)
When I hear this complaint it usually refers to games that provide certain features, multiplayer, rewards like skins, etc., only through the use of an online account.

I’m not saying those things aren’t worth complaining about, but frankly, they aren’t what come to mind when I think of problematic DRM in video games. What comes to mind is the inability to install and play a game without an internet connection. GOG still provides real installers, and remains the most prominent platform committed to it.

To get a sense of what people are referring to as DRM on GOG, I reference this thread: https://www.gog.com/forum/general/drm_on_gog_list_of_singlep...

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by thaumasiotes on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:00AM (#35579452)
You don't think multiplayer counts as playing the game?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bentley on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:16AM (#35579548)
I think having an online account for multiplayer is a categorically different kind of requirement than having an online account for single player.

Until there’s a storefront that only sells games that include multiplayer servers that can be self‐hosted on your LAN, I think GOG’s explicit policy of no‐DRM installers is worth praising.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by thaumasiotes on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:31AM (#35579646)
They didn't have a problem releasing Northgard without the ability to play single-player offline.

There was enough complaining about that that it got fixed, I believe, but that's how they released it.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bentley on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:43AM (#35579709)
Yes, that was mentioned in the thread I linked. According to the thread, both GOG and the game developer claimed it was a bug, and fixed it. This does not convince me of your statement that GOG has de facto eliminated its no‐DRM policy. A more plausible explanation is that GOG, not rolling in money like Steam, is subject to a certain amount of jank including high‐impact bugs that take longer than they should to get fixed. And GOG’s jankiness is a common complaint throughout these HN comments. I don’t think anyone contests that Valve provides a generally slick experience in comparison to its competitors.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by badsectoracula on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:31AM (#35580034)
> Until there’s a storefront that only sells games that include multiplayer servers that can be self‐hosted on your LAN

IIRC from a discussion in their official Discord (by one of the people who work there) that is basically Zoom Platform[0]'s approach - if a game has a multiplayer component it has to allow you to run your own server.

[0] https://www.zoom-platform.com/

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Dylan16807 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:05PM (#35582431)
> GOG still provides real installers, and remains the most prominent platform committed to it.

Is steam's backup/restore game files option much different in practice?

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bentley on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:50PM (#35584908)
My understanding is those are DRMed: you can’t play a restored game without connecting online to your Steam account at least once.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by maccard on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:16AM (#35579207)
It provides a storefront, authentication, distribution and an updater, at least. That is valuable to a lot of games.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by t0bia_s on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#35581409)
That is service. Not DRM.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by IIsi50MHz on Sunday April 16, 2023 @05:11PM (#35594310)
I think Steam requires that the Steam client connect to Steamservers at least once every two weeks, to validate your licenses.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by DRW_ on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:15AM (#35579538)
How is it different than having to use GOG's website to install a purchase you made or download an updated version?

Developers on Steam can ship their own update mechanism separate from Steam if they want to.

I feel like people don't actually know the policies of Steam and how it mostly just leaves it up to the developer, for better or worse.

If Steam decided to block developers from being able to do DRM, it wouldn't mean all the games would go DRM free, it'd mean the games wouldn't go on Steam, like they don't go on GOG - they'd go to their own launchers.

As much as people like to believe Steam has a monopoly, publishers have been able to bring out their own launchers reasonably successfully. People will go to their launchers if that's the only way to get anticipated games. Some of the most successful games started and remained outside of Steam.

The industry would look significantly different if Steam had an actual monopoly.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by johnfonesca on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:32AM (#35579653)
>How is it different than having to use GOG's website to install a purchase you made or download an updated version?

You buy game on GOG, dowload the installers, move it to a external HDD and you can install that game forever. This is the only thing that is actually DRM free.

Needless to say, you can't to that with ANY other store (be it Steam, Epic etc). All of them requires you to install their crap to access your bought games and they don't give you full offline installers.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by badsectoracula on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:25AM (#35579989)
> Needless to say, you can't to that with ANY other store (be it Steam, Epic etc). All of them requires you to install their crap to access your bought games and they don't give you full offline installers.

You don't get an installer but many games are DRM-free on Steam so you can just zip up the directory under steamapps/common and you're good to go. I have ~180 games on my storage HDD from Steam.

I always try to have an offline copy of every game i buy (and i try to buy them from "proper" DRM-free stores than Steam where possible) and while it'd be nice if there was an offline installer, it isn't really much of an issue in practice. The biggest issue with Steam is that you don't know if a game is DRM-free or not before buying it and trying to figure out yourself (which is why i prefer other stores like Zoom Platform and GOG in the first place).

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by worldsayshi on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:46AM (#35579079)
> because they don't give publishers the option to distribute their games using an offline, DRM free installer.

What does this mean? You can still publish your game through other channels if you publish through steam right? I mean there are games that are on Steam and other platforms.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bombcar on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:52AM (#35579408)
I think he means that you can't have the thing you get when you buy from steam be an offline installer (though actually I think some older games are just this, or you can copy the installed files around afterwards; think running Morrowind with OpenMW).
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by mrfinn on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:44PM (#35583378)
Exactly. I don't get why people keep repeating the "but not all games are DRM" mantra. Everyone with a minimal experience in PC gaming knows that without a proper installer most of the time you'll be in trouble just by doing a game folder backup and restore afterwards. Not to mention as well that the DRM free games lists aren't supported in any way by Valve itself (Information about that in the game profile? A filter in the search page?), as they are simply a community effort.

Have to say I'm not anti-Valve at all, I appreciate their commitment to the PC platform and their contribution to the free source cause. I'm just very critical about lack of proper support of DRM-free options AND allowing people to not to depend on a working account after some product is supposedly purchased. DRM is the wrong answer to the wrong question aka how to stop people from doing something that current technology makes incredibly easy to do, instead of properly thinking about the real issue, how we keep fairly paying authors.

PS. Also I think that people should be a bit more concerned about data harvesting through the launcher.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Avamander on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:55AM (#35579110)
The platform that didn't/doesn't bother with a Linux client? Why should I bother?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bentley on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:17AM (#35579218)
Well, because it provides offline, DRM‐free installers for your games, often including Linux installers.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by depressedpanda on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:24AM (#35579597)
Steam does it much, much better.

GoG ostensibly cared about Linux in the beginning, but by now it's very clear that they don't.

It's their choice of course, and among all the alternatives to Steam I guess they're the best choice.

But they obviously don't want me as a customer, so I largely ignore them and don't recommend them to anyone.

In almost every single aspect, Steam is just the superior product.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Avamander on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:56AM (#35580234)
So does Steam for games that want it. In the end GOG can't override publishers' wishes either.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:50AM (#35581726)
It works completely fine in a browser though
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Avamander on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:25PM (#35583203)
One of the rare cases where I want a native application, something that can update and launch my games.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by DRW_ on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:13AM (#35579529)
>I'm angry with Valve because they don't give publishers the option to distribute their games using an offline, DRM free installer.

Yes they do. There are plenty of DRM free games on Steam. DRM is optional on Steam.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:46AM (#35580591)
This is just false. As sibling comment mentioned Valve doesn't do third party exclusivity, but also the Steam DRM is completely optional and there are many games for which Steam just acts as a downloader and automatic update system. You can just copy these games' folder to another PC and run them without issue.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bogwog on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:10PM (#35581932)
This seems like an extreme niche. What is the benefit of offline installers? Doomsday prepping? Because it’s certainly not more convenient than what Steam does, and Steam doesn’t require an internet connection to play games.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by mehlmao on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:40PM (#35582733)
Steam is dropping support for Windows 7 and 8. If you don't switch OS, you'll lose the ability to install (and for most games with DRM, to play) the games you already purchased.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by pezezin on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:06PM (#35585926)
Windows 7 reached EOL three years ago. Do you expect them to support a dead OS forever?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by mehlmao on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:32PM (#35609290)
I expect them to let me access the things I purchased. Not a problem with offline installers from GoG.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by mehlmao on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:38PM (#35582719)
GOG used to be my first choice for buying games, but I stopped making purchases from them after they delisted a Taiwanese game dev for making a joke about Xi Jinping: https://www.pcgamer.com/devotion-returns-almost-two-years-af...
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by kzrdude on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:03AM (#35578316)
Then steam is the most well behaved monopoly I know. They care about Linux.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by asmor on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:34AM (#35578480)
They care about whatever Valve employees are interested in / is perceived as creating most value (not always the same as creating most value). Valve has a system of weighted peer feedback (impacting salary and sometimes continued employment) that encourages follow-the-leader mentality despite their supposedly open culture.

People Make Games made an enlightening documentary on the Valve model and where it fails: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9aCwCKgkLo

Though if you need an example: Steam still doesn't have M1 binaries. Steam uses about 15 variants of UI framework, and some of it simply doesn't work on some platforms. Steam also took record time shipping an x86_64 (over x86) binary back in the day. Everything that's not the shiny current thing receives life support at most.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by TazeTSchnitzel on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:29AM (#35578747)
When 32-bit binaries on macOS died, all the old Source games went with them, and Valve has seemingly never fixed it. :(
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by SXX on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:58AM (#35578876)
There a lot of Mac software that been abandoned at some point in time due to API breakage on MacOS updates, driver API changes, etc. Supporting OS that breaks compatibility all the time is expansive even for less complex software and fixing games created on custom engines likely way to expensive.

After all you can install it in Parallels and play Windows versions just fine.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by SXX on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:52AM (#35578839)
On M1 support. Apple been actively hostile to game developers. Apple has not maintained OpenGL support well, dropped 32-bit binaries, have no Vulkan support and break their APIs and compatibility all the time. No surprise Valve is not enthusiastic about supporting their platform.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by sgtnoodle on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:05AM (#35578909)
I'm not sure I understand your example. What actual value would M1/aarch64 compiled steam binaries be? Practically all games available on their platform are made for x86 or x86-64. That doesn't seem like something Valve can change. The only reason gaming on Linux is becoming practical is because Vulkan support is maturing and Valve doubled down on getting windows binary compatibility.

I suppose Proton could probably be ported to OSX with enough work. Apple isn't making it easy by refusing to natively implement Vulkan, though. DirectX to Vulkan to Metal conversion on top of x86-64 emulation is just a lot going on. It seems like no one's interested in doing the work to convert DirectX directly to Metal.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by tstrimple on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:20AM (#35578980)
> That doesn't seem like something Valve can change.

This is where I'd disagree with you. Valve has all sorts of levers they could pull to encourage ARM builds. One example, they could offer a lower commission rate on games which have ARM builds available. This would incentivize developers to target the platform.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by wheybags on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:04AM (#35579151)
Given the tiny percentage that osx represents, why would they bother? It's just not worth investing too much effort in apple platforms.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by BirAdam on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:01AM (#35579460)
Linux was less until SteamDeck.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by depressedpanda on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:33AM (#35579662)
Irrelevant given the potential Linux brings to the table.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by usrusr on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:26AM (#35579996)
Linux support was (is) a hedge against an OS vendor using their power to force themselves into the lucrative middle man position. MacOS support is not.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by smoldesu on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:10PM (#35581938)
Linux doesn't depreciate major graphics APIs or CPU features willy-nilly.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by sokoloff on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:17AM (#35579212)
If 70% of the sales price isn’t enough profit incentive, I kind of doubt that making that 80% would tip the scales to it being desirable to the game studio.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by andrepd on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:39AM (#35579347)
So if they have to subsidise your favourite platform, which apparently even Apple does not care about, or else they aren't "supporting" the platform, is that right?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by usrusr on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:24AM (#35579979)
Why would Valve want to throw money at a platform that is as close to locking out third party app stores as Apple is?

Offering their client on Mac to those of their producers and consumers who are inherently motivated to use it but, otherwise keeping a low profile there seems like just the right call to me.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by BirAdam on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:04AM (#35579475)
MoltenVK exists so that would take of Vulkan. Rosetta2 is super efficient, so I don’t see that as an impediment. The truth is, I don’t think Valve cares much about Macintosh. Blizzard doesn’t lately either. Oddly, the trend lines here are weird. MacOS is becoming the “get stuff done” platform, and Linux is becoming a gaming platform, both of which were previously Microsoft’s domain.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by smoldesu on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:08PM (#35581923)
And what would provide 32-bit Wine runtime? Presumably not MacOS, if you're using any version past Mojave.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by tadfisher on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:23PM (#35583188)
WoW64 support was added recently, so you shouldn't need a 32-bit Wine in the near future. This is because some Linux distros are also ditching multilib support on x86.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by asmor on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:00AM (#35580254)
There are several games I play that are actually natively compiled for M1 (The Long Dark, Disco Elysium). Steam is a very noticeable resource hog on an M1, and I'd presume that's a mix of their UI framework mixing (CEF, VGUI) and lack of Apple Silicon binaries.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by philistine on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:12AM (#35580785)
Valve's insane corporate structure means its strategic moves are plain as day. They initially went on OSX because it made sense to leave no room for a competing game market to start on Mac and move to Windows.

They've invested massively on Linux and have attacked the problem from two angles in the last ten years because they need to diversify. They can't single-handedly rely on Microsoft for their continued existence. Hence the VR headsets, the Steam Machines, and now the Steam Deck.

They've put zero effort on macOS on Apple Silicon because they would gain nothing strategically, and the percentage of Mac users using Steam is small. The hardcore gamer on a Mac does not exist. We have consoles.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by smoldesu on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:06PM (#35581896)
It's not insane for them to be transparent. When Valve depreciated Steam Play for MacOS, they had engineers very clearly spell out the reason: the MacOS runtime is not stable enough for games. They also called this out when depreciating SteamVR for MacOS, it seems less like a "strategic move" and more like a platform limitation.

There's definitely something for Valve to gain by porting Steam to MacOS, after all they did support MacOS with Proton originally. The work required to fix it for modern MacOS is monumental though, and unless Apple sponsors it I see no reason why it would happen. Once they axed 32-bit execution support on Mac, there was effectively no reason to keep supporting the platform anymore gaming-wise. OpenGL depreciations were the icing on the disappointment cake, very clearly Valve was being told to pound sand by Apple.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by dbeley on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:55AM (#35579114)
They supported linux in order to have their own platform outside of Microsoft's reach (first through the Steam Machines, now the Steam Deck).

Indeed the Mac support is lackluster, but it's yet another proprietary platform and Apple makes it difficult to work on.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Dylan16807 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:11PM (#35582494)
> Steam also took record time shipping an x86_64 (over x86) binary back in the day.

Steam doesn't need more than 2/4GB so it doesn't seem like that matters.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by iaml on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:55AM (#35578583)
They care about linux because they fear(ed) ms pulling the plug on their platform.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by DANmode on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:09AM (#35578661)
The enemy of my enemy...is still my enemy because he won't release 3!
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:58AM (#35578596)
>They care about Linux.

They care about making money. Their investments in Linxu are to take away control from Microsoft. It's a business decision, not a benevolent one.

Not knocking them but it's good to keep in mind the truth.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ahartmetz on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:20AM (#35578981)
Long-term self-interest is often indistinguishable from altruism. It is refreshing to see a company at least capable of that. That is as far as my blind worship goes ;)
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:42AM (#35579065)
By that logic Microsoft is also incredibly altruistic ;)
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:13AM (#35581337)
(Shrug) They brought cheap commodity PCs of incredible power to the mass market. Do you think that would have happened in a world dominated by Apple?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Dylan16807 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:13PM (#35582508)
The logic that says it's possible for them to be the same?

Microsoft has that in certain areas, like Typescript. Not so much anything related to Windows.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by depressedpanda on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:05AM (#35579478)
Sure, but Valve has done a lot for the Linux gaming ecosystem.

It also goes deeper than just Linux, and the Steam Deck is a perfect example of this. It's a real PC, and they allow you to use the device you bought as you wish.

Our incentives are aligned and due to how they operate it's likely that it'll stay that way for a long time.

As long as this is the case I will keep giving Valve my money and recommending their products to others.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:52AM (#35579764)
Of course they let you have full ownership of the stream deck, since you don't have the ownership of your games.

They don't care what devices you use to play the games you bought on Steam since you're still tied to their platform.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by usrusr on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:42AM (#35580119)
Almost makes me happy that I have this (otherwise rather bad for, well, life) gaming habit, for allowing me to experience this rare case of capitalism working out rather nice (for two decades and counting).
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by flippinburgers on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:27AM (#35581472)
Their interests align with my values. Being picky about the "why" of their interests especially when it is "they want to survive the crushing hand of Microsoft" is a rather rich criticism on your part.

Yeah companies want to survive economically. If they don't exist the products they make would be completely unavailable. It is a rather uninteresting angle to take.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by sireat on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:55AM (#35578857)
Linux is a complement to Valve:

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/

"Commoditize your complements."

In general you open source / lower price (to free if possible) your complements.

Pretty much all companies do this.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by paoda on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:14PM (#35582520)
While I can appreciate their dedication to Linux, I find their application process arbitrary and random, if not confusingly prejudiced towards certain types of games.

It's honestly a dice roll whether a visual novel will be accepted or rejected from Steam. Whatever reason used will weirdly not apply for titles already released and even titles that will apply after you. It doesn't matter if youre an indie game dev or Square Enix publishing a game set in the same universe as the widely loved Steins;Gate. You're still subject for a ban and for what really? Square Enix at least has the ability to talk behind the scenes to have the game approved.

This all matters so much because visual novels are already a niche. If you want to turn a profit you must sell on steam. This means that in response to an imprecise, contradictory policy it's in your best interest to self-censor as much as you can because you can not afford to have your game rejected.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by tadfisher on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:20PM (#35583150)
I thought they got rid of any game content policies a couple years ago. The line was, "everything is allowed except malware and obvious trolling".
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by paoda on Sunday April 16, 2023 @03:00AM (#35587898)
If that's their policy, they genuinely make zero effort to follow it.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by optionalsquid on Sunday April 16, 2023 @06:59AM (#35588930)
Their actual content policies are described on the SteamWorks page and they include quite a lot more exceptions than malware and trolling:

https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/gettingstarted/onboarding...

Visual novels and similar games with young (looking) characters tend to get rejected for sexualizing those characters (rule 8). But there are also plenty of examples of tame games getting rejected, while similar but much more risque games were permitted, so it's hard to figure out exactly what Valve objects to.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ScoobleDoodle on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:10AM (#35578355)
Steam doesn’t have a strict monopoly, but it is the most known and used.

Steam takes a 30% cut of all sales. If a game sells over $10 million then the cut is reduced to 25%

There is Epic Game Store: maker of Fortnite and Unreal Engine which also gives away 1 or 2 free games a week. It takes a 12% cut from developers selling through their store. Tencent, which has close ties to CCP, owns ~40% of Epic.

GOG “good old gamestore”owned by CD Projekt Red, the developers of the Witcher and Cyberpunk 2077. Takes a 30% cut from sales. Also advocates for games without DRM.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Ralfp on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:43AM (#35578529)
GOG and Red are sister subsidiaries of CD Projekt company which itself does game publishing, distribution and localization.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by SXX on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:39AM (#35578776)
EGS also dont have any proper user reviews to begin with. Its by design since Epic Games dont want even give players option to affect game sales. For instance compare how terrible broken The Last of Us Part 1 looks on Steam and EGS:

> https://store.steampowered.com/app/1888930/The_Last_of_Us_Pa...

Reviews are mixed above and a lot of negative reviews from players below.

> https://store.epicgames.com/en-US/p/the-last-of-us-part-1

Some 3.8 star rating above and tons of praise from press below.

PS: As game developer I think competition is good. But as gamer I personally not gonna use Tencent/CCP Game Store since it's intentionally customer-hostile. This is not Steam competitor I want to support.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by tstrimple on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:17AM (#35578964)
I used to care about this shit, but I don't any more. The experience with Steam is just that much more superior. Cloud saves that allow me to pick up my PC gaming session on my Steam Deck or MBP is something no other platform offers on the scale that Steam does. If I could buy a game on GOG or Steam, I will choose Steam every single time because of the platform benefits unless the GOG game allows a Steam redemption. To me this is the same argument as streaming video content. Steam offers enough content that I don't need to seek other services to supplement my gaming needs. This is very different from the video streaming services where content is so siloed into proprietary buckets.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ivanmontillam on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:12AM (#35578373)
> But people will choose the option even slightly more convenient for them against ethical costs.

Such is human nature. It actually takes mental effort/mind wrestling to justify for ourselves the healthier, less attractive choice.

Same is for our bodies and healthy foods, against something like a chocolate cake or pizza.

> I wish steam didn't have an effective monopoly on PC video game distribution.

Back on topic, any other dominant actor in the market could have been the one affected by this moderation misjudgement. Let's suppose Origin was this dominant actor and this faux pas happened to them. This post would have been about Origin.

Note: I chose to say "dominant actor" instead of "effective monopolist" because other market actors are present, even if much less powerful.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by pipes on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:28AM (#35578456)
I use gog.com, come to think of it it's the only thing I have any sort of brand loyalty for. They seem to genuinely care. I use steam if it's not on gog though.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by spockz on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:38AM (#35578498)
But why? All the other launchers I have used are worse. Especially the EA launcher. It has been rewritten multiple times. When patching games it somehow requires a huge amount of extra disk space on top of installed game + 2*patch size.

So if they are the best, why shouldn’t have the largest market share?

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by snickerbockers on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:44AM (#35578797)
Steam isn't anywhere near a monopoly lol.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by WastingMyTime89 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:10AM (#35578932)
Effective monopoly on PC game distribution?

They are competing with Epic, CD Project, Microsoft, Apple on macOS plus all the editors store and physical media. They are dominant but very far from being a monopoly.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Ekaros on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:51AM (#35579102)
Steam is possibly one of the least worse monopolies that have existed. It doesn't block the products from being sold on other platforms, takes care of quite a lot for those who use it.

I think it is lesser evil compared to having dozens of stores and accounts to manage with some of them dying and taking the products down with them. If you were to play range of titles you could possibly end up with quite many clients running in background, just for that having single big player is positive.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by em-bee on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:25AM (#35579603)
Steam is possibly one of the least worse monopolies that have existed

and it invests into wine development to make windows games run on linux.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ryandrake on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:24AM (#35580422)
Their acceptance and willingness to distribute anti-cheat malware is really the only black mark I can think of on their otherwise very good reputation.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:43AM (#35580575)
There's also the whole skins thing, but yeah generally speaking Valve has a very good record and I'm always a bit sus about people claiming it is an awful thing for gaming. Apparently they don't remember what PC gaming was like before Steam.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:09AM (#35581310)
What choice do they have?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ryandrake on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#35581399)
Steam at this point has massive market power as a distributor. They must already have some sort of anti-malware policy they hold their suppliers to. If they wanted to, they could extend that policy to include intrusive anti-cheat malware, and the industry would change its ways overnight. Only the most powerful game companies could afford to forego Steam distribution. Steam 100% has the choice, and they choose to distribute this software.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:12PM (#35581969)
I don't game much these days, but my understanding from those who do is that multiplayer gaming could not exist without aggressive anti-cheat measures. Are you aware of less intrusive ways to keep the majority of players honest?
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ryandrake on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:17PM (#35582004)
I'm not a game programmer, but I'd bet you could go far with better game technical design and architecture. My bank doesn't require me to run ring-0 spyware to prevent cheat software from changing my balance or viewing other people's balances. They correctly don't trust the client and don't send the client any more information than necessary.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:56PM (#35582341)
But your bank also doesn't reward you for your situational-awareness skills, or give you a way to make even more money if you could somehow develop inhuman reflexes.

At least mine doesn't.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by em-bee on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:58PM (#35584460)
to be fair...

not really, because you'd legally have to return that money anyways. your argument still holds.

a better counterargument would be that some banks don't allow their app to run on rooted phones, which is equivalent to anti-cheat measures (since windows is rooted by default)

to protect against what though?

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by CamperBob2 on Sunday April 16, 2023 @02:11PM (#35592659)
to protect against what though?

Keyloggers (touchloggers?), I imagine.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by tomatotomato37 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:54PM (#35582878)
The thing is they also happen to distribute their own multiplayer games that have been being hammered lately due to an influx of bots and cheaters. So on one side you have people arguing for the sanctity of their systems, and on the other side you have players who would like to enter at least one match where there isn't six snipers spinning around like washing machines
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by bogwog on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:49AM (#35581714)
> Steam is possibly one of the least worse monopolies that have existed. It doesn't block the products from being sold on other platforms, takes care of quite a lot for those who use it.

They do require that the price of your game on Steam be equivalent or lower than the price outside of it. That’s very anticompetitive, and IMO should be illegal as it doesn’t do anything but harm consumers.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by WastingMyTime89 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:19PM (#35583715)
> They do require that the price of your game on Steam be equivalent or lower than the price outside of it.

No, they don’t. As far as I know, there is nothing in the Distribution Agreement saying that and you can in fact regularly see games sold for less on GOG than Steam.

The only thing Valve disallows selling outside of Steam for less than on Steam are Steam keys.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Bran_son on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:37PM (#35583869)
> lesser evil compared to having dozens of stores

Realistically, the alternative without Steam would not be dozens of stores, but (eventually) 2-3 stores, that would all behave much worse than Steam.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Ekaros on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:28PM (#35584721)
I actually doubt it would be just 2-3. Already adding up the attempts of publishers comes to more than that. EA, Ubisoft, Bethesda, Activision-Blizzard, Microsoft, Take Two...

And then I remember the third party tries... All the MMORPGs. Pretty much everyone would have their own launcher and then there would bunch of smaller stores with their own platforms.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Avamander on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:57AM (#35579120)
It doesn't. There are so many launchers and ways of distribution and I loathe it. I don't want all this bloatware to get what I paid for.

Plus unlike Electronic Arts, Valve doesn't delete games I've bought from my library.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by flohofwoe on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:12AM (#35579188)
> didn't have an effective monopoly on PC video game distribution

And yet the PC is the only platform left where the user even has a choice in the matter.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by matheusmoreira on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:19AM (#35579566)
Monopolies and DRM is always bad but I still appreciate the fact Steam is the least bad implementation of such evil I've ever seen. Other DRM platforms are infinitely worse.

Also, Steam provides a good service. There's a reason people don't remember the old days where you had to download and apply several 500 MB incremental patches on unreliable connections just to play an online game.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by LegitShady on Saturday April 15, 2023 @08:51AM (#35580187)
steam doesn't have a monopoly on pc video game distribution. There are many other services - GoG, epic, microsoft, etc. Steam is just the best of those services, by a long shot, and was far earlier and is better in almost all respects.
Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by still_grokking on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:24AM (#35580420)
To be honest Steam was one of the best working monopolies out of the perspective of end-users.

All you needed once to play games on Linux was Steam.

Now we have a few more relevant competing game stores and you need a whole bunch of awful launchers.

I'm not saying the monopoly was a great thing for publishers though! That's a completely different story.

But for end-users it was "the one and only app store for games you ever need". This was even better than mostly everything else regarding Linux software. Steam was once like Napster. You've just got everything there. No we have the same situation like with the dozens of movie streaming providers: If you want access to everything you need accounts everywhere. That's a clear step backwards for the consumers.

If only something like Steam or movie streaming could be one globally distributed open service… Than such a "monopoly" would be the greatest thing for customers since Napster.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by jeroenhd on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:30AM (#35580939)
Steam can do with some competition but all their competition is terrible. Chrome's competitors at least work similarly and well enough. Google would have a browser monopoly if all of their competition were as laggy and featureless as Steam's main competitors are.

GOG comes closest to being good but I find their launcher to be quite buggy and slow. Origin, uPlay, Epic Games, those are all terrible in comparison to Steam. The Steam UI is far from amazing, but it's leagues ahead of the competition in terms of usability in my experience.

If you don't like Steam, you can buy your games elsewhere. GOG and Epic exist and together they have most games that aren't Steam exclusives. Xbox Game Pass has some pretty good deals on games too (which includes some PC titles). There are thousands of games to be played without ever having to download Steam if you choose to.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by Aeolun on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#35582036)
> But people will choose the option even slightly more convenient for them against ethical costs.

I have few, if any, problems with Steam.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ChoGGi on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:01PM (#35582394)
> It was basically forced on us when CS 1.6 required it.

That'd be CSS, not 1.6.

Re:Valve Restricts Accounts of 2500 Users Who Marked a Negat... by ThatPlayer on Saturday April 15, 2023 @04:48PM (#35584377)
CS 1.6 required it when Valve shutdown the WON servers.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Opponent_Network