News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Nifty3929 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:42AM (#35411716)
The main problem with government poverty programs is that they usually focus on spending money instead of giving money to people who need it. That is, the government spends money on things, but this is a very inefficient or even counterproductive way to help. And a lot of the time it just means that the money is going to whoever is politically connected.

A much more efficient way to help people is just to give them money directly, and then people can spend it on whatever they think they need.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by snapplebobapple on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:10PM (#35412084)
That's the same problem with pretty much all government programs. A recent example that has affected me is the childcare subsidy brought in by the federal government here in Canada. It was supposed to be an extra 300-900 a month to make childcare cost 10 dollars a day. Instead it has became a large bureaucracy directly ruining an ok private system that existed previously by driving up costs substantially everywhere and making the experience much worse for my kids via spurious regulation. Specifically my day home now charges 70 dollars more a month to cover the onerous additional paperwork and filing requirements of the program (I don't blame them, given the extra work I would have expected more of a cost increase), my day home had to remove perfectly fine play equipment from the backyard because it was 1800 dollar Costco play equipment rather than the multi hundred thousand dollar professional public park grade stuff, and there are a substantial number of additional bureaucrats employed by my government making more and more busy work for everyone, which may ruin the much better day home style care system in favor of large institutional day cares (up to six kids, one care giver that stays constant vs 20+ kids and a string of day care workers that can and does change regularly). If they had just given the money to the parents and kept the existing regulatory regime things would have been better, instead the government made it worse.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by zapdrive on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:53PM (#35412533)
Everything Trudeau touches turns into shit.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by snapplebobapple on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:25PM (#35412905)
Yah, it's kind of embarrassing that the second half of the 20th century was a story of electing and then recovering from electing a trudeau and we were dumb enough to do it all again making that the main theme of the first half of the 21st century as well.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by soperj on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:29PM (#35413618)
He gets less than a 1/3 of the actual voters. Way less than a 1/3 of people who are eligible to vote, and less of the popular vote of the conservatives in the last election. The voting system is flawed. He knew that and actually ran on changing it, and then !!surprise!! didn't change a thing.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Teever on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:24PM (#35414145)
Dude, this is /r/canada tier shit, not HN.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by soperj on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:25PM (#35415920)
meh. I say that as someone who doesn't vote conservative. The voting system is dumb. Most of the votes are just thrown out.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by darrylb42 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:48PM (#35413807)
The daycare my kids go to reduced rates. Maybe it is big enough that the paper work is not a big deal. The new subsidized daycare made things cheaper for everyone I know.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by snapplebobapple on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:28PM (#35415944)
overall my rate is technically reduced because I get 300 subsidy but pay 70 more. The quality of service has gone down too because of the removal of perfectly good amenities.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by rhaway84773 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @09:02PM (#35417257)
The quality of service in North America has gone down across nearly every service, whether wholly governmental, or wholly private, since the pandemic.

It’s very likely the quality of service is heavily affected by the same general forces.

In addition to that, any effort which greatly increases access to services to a broader spectrum of people will usually lead to a short term reduction of quality as the supply catches up with the new demand. A logical solution to this would be to phase in the demand, but unfortunately it’s not politically viable at all (politicians of all stripes want to be credited for the changes they make, and phasing it in over a period of time means the costs impact the budget almost immediately, but the benefits take time to filter through, which will likely be a political disaster).

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by xen2xen1 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @07:18PM (#35447149)
Everyone, everywhere is new.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Spooky23 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:35PM (#35412365)
That’s how the critics of these programs spiked the programs. “Welfare Queens” were supposedly driving around with Cadillacs, so controls had to be in place.

I spent several years working on social services IT. The biggest welfare beneficiaries are companies like IBM, CSC, Accenture, Unisys, Northrup Grumman, etc and their employees.

That’s why some politicians were so terrified of the COVID relief programs. The government efficiently provided direct cash aid to millions of people with minimal fraud while the complex controlled systems like unemployment insurance were just raided by fraudsters. We made people’s lives measurably better, saved the economy from collapse, etc, and then took it all away.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by vinyl7 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:18PM (#35412808)
Less than 35% of the $800 billion in PPP loans actually went to workers, say economists

https://www.fastcompany.com/90713747/workers-800-billion-ppp...

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by pnutjam on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:01PM (#35413311)
Sure, now do the tax credits to parents and the pandemic EBT. These are what we're talking about. PPP was a giveaway to moneyed interests because god forbid we pay it directly to workers.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by red-iron-pine on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:38PM (#35428040)
Jesus, $800 billion?
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by orzig on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:19PM (#35412825)
> Minimal fraud

You’re going to have to be more specific or offer some evidence, because a cursory search suggests there was massive fraud.

To take the least sensationalized source: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-takes-acti...

They’re estimating more than half a billion dollars and are just getting started.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by flaviut on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:41PM (#35413075)
I believe they're referring specifically to the Economic Impact Payments, since those had zero controls from most peoples' perspective. Money just showed up in your bank account.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Spooky23 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:31PM (#35412965)
I was. The government efficiently gave cash to almost everyone. That was pretty close to UBI. The biggest issue with direct payments were due to the way separated couples claim dependents.

UI, which I specifically mentioned, was a fraud carnival.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by orzig on Sunday April 02, 2023 @08:36PM (#35417057)
Got it, I stand corrected (and better informed). Thank you, too few internet conversations are this constructive.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Spooky23 on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:52PM (#35427189)
No worries! I lived closer to some this stuff and could have been more clear.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by araes on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:52PM (#35413850)
This. From https://www.govexec.com/management/2023/03/coronavirus-round...

$247 billion in improper payments in fiscal 2022

"At least" $35 billion in pandemic relief money - $29 billion was in the Pandemic Protection Program - $6.9 billion was in the Economic Injury Disaster Loan program

IRS has 975 tax and money laundering cases related to pandemic fraud with a total of $3.2 billion in alleged fraud. 236 already sentenced for avg. 37 months in prison. ~100% conviction rate.

From: https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-105523.pdf "the lower bound of this fraud rate (7.6 percent) extrapolated to total spending across all Unemployment Insurance (UI) programs ... suggest over $60 billion in fraudulent UI payments." - Cases of Proven Fraud: "currently $4.3 billion dollars of fraud based on formal determinations"

From: https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-22-104397 and https://www.asas.org/taking-stock/blog-post/taking-stock/202... - Coronavirus Food Assistance Program (CFAP) provided producers $31.0 billion for various commodities ... half of the producers that GAO reviewed did not provide full support for their payments. The payments are therefore potentially improper. - USDA’s Business Center 2021 payment integrity review for CFAP estimated that CFAP had a significant improper payment rate for the fiscal year 2020 ... estimated that that $450M were improper.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by gfdsgfsdgfs on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:39PM (#35413056)
What did you expect when there were government mandates to shut down companies?
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Nifty3929 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:48AM (#35411793)
Just replying to myself to make what I hope is an obvious point: Yet, giving money does not in itself create any new stuff to buy. It pushed prices up, and (at least temporarily) profits for those businesses providing the stuff. Nevertheless, it does even things out, and the higher profits will spur more competition in those industries that produce the things poor people are buying (if allowed), which ultimately achieves the desired result.

But any which way you look at it, and even if not perfect, giving money is the best way to help of the available options.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by bigtex88 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:57AM (#35411908)
UBI will always be the best answer. MLK advocated for it as the best way to alleviate poverty. Even Milton Friedman believed in a pseudo-UBI through his Negative Income Tax.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by skeeter2020 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:26PM (#35412251)
The biggest problem is that NIT or even UBI is supported by many on the right as an alternative to the "government knows best" spending programs and as an addition by many on the left. For someone like me who ends up paying the majority of any social program, the former is a good idea and the latter a non-starter, but politically you'll never find an elected (or even electable) politician who will advocate for replacing existing, entrenched programs with direct cash payments.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by peanuty1 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:51PM (#35412515)
Why should we care what MLK thought about UBI?
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by jobs_throwaway on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:48PM (#35413157)
His great moral standing and wisdom
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by glhaynes on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:42PM (#35413766)
MLK is largely seen as a virtuous, wise person. A lot of moral sentiment enters into people's opinions on social economics. Also, people look to group sentiment to calibrate whether a proposal is more extreme than they want to think of themselves/be thought of.

MLK having expressed a favorable opinion about it makes UBI less susceptible to "that's evil, naive communism"-style attacks.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by rhaway84773 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @09:09PM (#35417302)
It also helps fight against the reverse, a knee jerk “that’s evil, hyper capitalism in disguise” sentiments.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by TigeriusKirk on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:04PM (#35413968)
Because he thought a lot about poverty and how to relieve it, as well as having practical working knowledge of the problems.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by rolenthedeep on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:53PM (#35416151)
Other than championing human and civil rights for all, equality, the end of government sanctioned and funded inequality and suppression or minorities, non-violent protest, and overall social reform?

Can't think of a single reason.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by bigtex88 on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:08PM (#35426267)
I was trying to show that people on both the "left" (MLK) and the "right" (Friedman) advocate for UBI. But thank you for revealing your thoughts on MLK through your question.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by claytongulick on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:12PM (#35412747)
Cost living expenses before UBI = x.

Cost of living expenses after UBI = x + UBI.

The price of goods will always rise to what the market will bear.

If you inject money into a market with schemes like UBI, all you do is creating a forcing function for inflation.

Fundamentally, money represents a debt that society owes based on creation/consumption of goods and services.

If you create money (debt symbols) without the corresponding good or service, you devalue the debt. So, an apple that was worth $1 now becomes worth $2 because your symbols that represent debt have been artificially modified.

Then, first order thinking drives yet another "UBI+" solution to give more money, and the cycle continues until an apple is "one billion dollars". World history has many examples of this, but you don't really need to look harder than covid related inflation.

The best solution to human poverty and suffering that we've ever created is economic opportunity. When given the chance, humans will thrive and succeed.

The best way to create economic opportunity is to reduce barriers to success (like onerous income taxation, and excessive regulation) and to invest in infrastructure that enhances and supports economic activity.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by spaceguillotine on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:44PM (#35413116)
Answer: Regulation. Your theory is only viable in unrestricted hedonistic capitalism. Cap prices.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by jazzyjackson on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:30PM (#35413639)
By capping prices you're capping production.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by claytongulick on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:51PM (#35413202)
That's certainly the solution that first-order thinking would suggest.

Command economies have never worked in history, though lots of folks have tried [1].

It's good to learn from past mistakes.

It's also sort of a fun thought experiment. When you grant this power to the government, the sorts of things they can do. There's lot of obvious things like "make eggs cheaper!!", but the more fun thought experiment is with something esoteric like the sex industry.

Let's conceive of the correct pricing for a lap dance.

That's a bit complex, it's certainly not fair to charge the same amount for everyone - an attractive, skilled dancer would be forced to charge the same as someone who is unattractive and disinterested. We're going to need a rate table.

Hygiene, attractiveness, skill, friendliness. What else? Age? The body politic has decided that you're not allowed to factor age into a lap dance or to discriminate on what dancer you chose based on age. So we can exclude that from our rate table.

Going to need to create a bureaucracy to develop fair standards for all of those things.

Also, as a footnote, let's create another agency to advertise exotic dancing to the elderly as an excellent career opportunity.

Of course, we'd need to add more regulation that would require the dancers to register their weight and attractiveness with a government agency, and we'd need inspectors to verify that. We'd also probably need to watchers to watch the watchers because the inspectors may be tempted by some "extra services" to inflate their scoring, allowing a dancer to charge more. Probably also going to need to add some undercover officers to make sure that unenlightened customers aren't expressing an opinion on what age of dancer they receive.

Of course, all lap dances aren't created equal - so rates may vary based on how many people are involved, whether the patron is allowed to touch the dancer, and if so the minimum necessary security involved. We'll probably need some secret shoppers to go out and verify that the rates are being charged properly and in-line with dictates.

This would all be pretty costly though, so we'll have to increase taxes on the dancers to pay for it all. But we can't allow them to raise their rates, that would defeat the purpose.

Now we'll need a way to confront the unpatriotic, unwilling masses who have for completely selfish reasons decided that a non-lucrative career in exotic dancing doesn't seem very fun.

Regulation is the answer! Like the Soviet Union, let's decide what profession folks would go into at a young age. Perfect!

Hmm, quality is suffering. Strangely, forcing folks into a profession to meet the needs of our dictated economic constraints resulted in a sub-par experience. There aren't any customers anymore. Fine, mark the whole thing as a loss and outlaw it, certainly can't have an underground economy operating on market forces undermining what our enlightened leaders have decided for us.

(Psst. there's a reason why command economies fail, and freedom matters. Even China understands this.)

[1] https://helpfulprofessor.com/command-economy-examples/

(edited to try to make it more funny)

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by 818ikdhh on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:16PM (#35414078)
Regulation is usually part of the problem, not the part of solution.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by mjevans on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:12PM (#35413425)
It's probably (IMO is) better to spend additional money on Infrastructure. Lots of the obvious stuff, but even things that seem like a stretch. Is healthcare infrastructure? Is childcare? How about work benefits management (days off, stock options, etc), pretty much HR, as a centralized national entity? (Not the funding of those benefits, companies would pay their costs into the program and then not need to worry about it anymore.)

The economically desirable things that UBI or any other handout are spent on, should fall into two categories. Things the government pays for itself because it's going to be the only buyer or a major buyer. Things the government has limited debit card systems for (E.G. food stamps) because there's already a market and they won't be a major buyer.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by jamilton on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:23PM (#35413545)
Why are you presuming that UBI will be funded through creating more money, instead of redirecting money and/or increasing taxes? Does that change your conclusion?

Reducing taxes will not meaningfully increase economic opportunity for people in poverty, because they are not the causes of most people's poverty. Reducing regulation may help, but only because "regulation" is broad and includes things like onerous means-testing that makes it harder for people in need to get resources. Jobs help, and AFAIK there's not much regulation making it harder to get a job.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by claytongulick on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:16PM (#35414694)
> Why are you presuming that UBI will be funded through creating more money, instead of redirecting money and/or increasing taxes?

Those are the same thing.

Increasing taxes = raised prices.

Raised prices = inflationary pressure.

Inflationary pressure = higher UBI.

Rinse, repeat.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by htfu on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:04PM (#35415748)
No. The basic version goes lowering taxes = more money in pockets but same output = inflationary. It's not necessarily that simple but in any case you have it completely backwards.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by claytongulick on Sunday April 02, 2023 @10:51PM (#35417969)
Let's apply the ole reductio absurdum and see how it shakes out.

Bloat an already obese government by cranking taxes up to 100%, society collapses.

Put the government on the fasting cure, starve the beast, and most folks end up with more in their pocket and happier.

How about I add $100 tax to each apple sale? What happens to apple prices? I'd be forced to finally develop a taste for cherry pie.

How much and who to tax have been arm wrestled over since humans figured out that houses are nicer than caves.

Cities need both taxes and sewers to survive, but too much of either will stink enough to drive off anyone who can.

Take a peek at That Which is Seen and That Which is Not Seen [1]. Bastiat had his head screwed on straight for a Frenchman, and had it figured out in 1850.

[1] http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by htfu on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @03:03PM (#35444424)
Sure. Or starve an already cash-strapped government by lowering taxes to 0%, society collapses. What is your point exactly?

Other notable things: America's historic tax rates (pre-Reagan), social democratic leaning countries. Higher happiness, somehow. Top marginal rate doesn't affect the vast majority of people, should go without saying.

But you changed the subject. We were discussing what relative tax changes may or may not do to inflation, not your libertarian dreams.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by pharmakom on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:45PM (#35413789)
1. there is a very monetarist account of inflation that not everyone agrees with

2. UBI can (and should imo) be funded through redistribution (taxation)

You seem to believe in markets. UBI allows us to have most of the benefits of a dynamic market system whilst avoiding the worst aspects - crushing poverty for those whose market value of labour is extremely low.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by imtringued on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:10PM (#35414010)
>If you inject money into a market with schemes like UBI, all you do is creating a forcing function for inflation.

That isn't how negative income taxes work at all. Come on educate yourself on the topic before writing a comment like that. In a negative income tax system a break even point is set where you pay exactly as much as you are getting. For the average person this means nothing changes for them. It is only at the high end where people pay significantly more in than they get and at the bottom end where people get out more than they pay in.

The funding problem for UBI has been solved a long time ago. There is no inflation problem. Yes, the UBI will be small but who exactly expects a large UBI? It's not like you get generous welfare payments today.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by dyno12345 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:33PM (#35415982)
the pandemic was a UBI experiment and inflation was a clear result
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by jerojero on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:51PM (#35416136)
Is it?

Surely you're not just waving out the supply chain issues and reduced productive capacity of the whole world due to lockdowns.

Was inflation in the USA higher than inflation in countries that didn't do direct deposits to people? As far as I know, it wasn't. That seems like a more fair starting point on studying effects of direct deposits.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by rolenthedeep on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:59PM (#35416223)
Consider how much money was given to the people and how much money was removed from circulation by corporations and billionaires taking unchecked ludicrous profits and evading taxes on it.

Clearly giving people two $500 checks over the span of two years is the problem

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by zackmorris on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:19PM (#35414108)
If you create money (debt symbols) without the corresponding good or service, you devalue the debt.

This is the central logical fallacy in your argument: you're equating UBI with inflation. UBI is different because it's funded through taxation, which holds the money supply constant.

The best solution to human poverty and suffering that we've ever created is economic opportunity. When given the chance, humans will thrive and succeed.

This is the central emotional fallacy in your argument: that a person's fate is decided by their actions. You're applying your own belief system, rather than using systems-level thinking to do the work of root cause analysis, meta analysis, epidemiological analysis around the psychological effects of wealth inequality, etc. That's why you feel very strongly about your solution, without having evidence to support it, and why people like me who have a different life experience don't subscribe to it.

If we study history, we see that technology was available after the Green Revolution, post WWII, to feed everyone in the world by the late 1960s. We see that so many measures of poverty like infant mortality are unnecessary symptoms, because modern medicine made birth control pills available and pregnancy safe, again by the late 60s. Same with basic measures of equality like the percentage of the workforce who are women, which was rising substantially by the 60s, but close to parity in the western world by the 1980s.

What's really going on is that a luddite backlash occurs every time that humankind overcomes adversity. For example, Nixon started the War on Drugs as a pretense to put US leftists in prison, by making the plant medicines they use to expand consciousness illegal. The Vietnam War, Oil Embargo, trickle-down economics, loss of unions, Savings and Loan Scandal, first Gulf War, Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act, Dot Com Bubble popping, 9/11, Second Gulf War, Who Killed the Electric Car, outsourcing, Housing Bubble popping, 2016 election, 30% tariff on imported solar panels, and even the COVID-19 pandemic (I could go on forever) are a direct result of that fear-mongering and othering dividing us along ideological lines. Which all stemmed from Nixon's and Goldwater's Southern Strategy to enforce segregation.

Reports like this begin to make sense when one understands the sabotage and corruption that create wealth inequality:

https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-inequality/a-guide...

And we see that if we cut taxes on the wealthy further, then wealth inequality increases. One person's definition of opportunity becomes another's definition of subjugation. If we continue on the path we're on, then the National Debt will succeed in finally taking away all self-determination and agency from US workers, forcing them to stay underemployed to survive. Taking away the very opportunity and choice which you so advocate.

With the arrival of AI and sustainable solutions to preserve the environment, we're again at one of these crossroads. We can embrace solutions like UBI and free humanity from forced labor, or we can double down on the failed solutions of the past century and move further into dystopia.

I hope that some of these breadcrumbs help you on your journey of discovery. If your first instinct is to outright reject what I'm suggesting, then I hope you take some time to think upon the events in your life which obfuscated the things I've said. I'll do the same, because your truth is valid to me and if we would listen more, I think that we could solve these longstanding problems and transition to a 21st century economy which works for everyone.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by bigtex88 on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:44PM (#35427008)
That's not how any of this works. You're assuming that every single person will spend their UBI payment in exactly the same fashion, and thus that all prices will go up in unison. That is an extremely basic model of the economy (i.e. it's not a good model). It doesn't take into account people saving, people paying off debt (another form of savings), or any sort of second-order effects (how will this effect how people operate in the labor market if they know they can leave a crappy job and not become homeless)?

"First order thinking" is not a euphemism for "I'm right because I said so".

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by claytongulick on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:55PM (#35429402)
First order thinking means exactly what I intended: a simple model of cause and effect without thinking through consequences entirely.

Society needs that sometimes. It can be paralyzed by Nth order thinking to the point where gross injustice is allowed to survive for much too long.

A response like "just add more regulation and price caps" as a solution to dealing with runaway inflation is definitely first order thinking, as is (in my opinion) "the solution to poverty is to just give people money (UBI)".

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by whitemary on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:52AM (#35411843)
Close, but the most efficient way to help people is to provide the services they need without depending on the private sector to deliver them. For example, if cash benefits are universally increased by $500, low-end rents will also increase by approximately that same amount, like clock work. UBI would be a catastrophe for many reasons, but this is the most straightforward of them.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by snapplebobapple on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:28PM (#35412279)
I don't think you understand what the word efficient means because what you said about it is certainly untrue. The private sector will almost always deliver a better result as long as you mitigate market power abuse. You are basically saying it is more efficient to deliver services through a public system because said public system failed at mitigating market power. In the rent example a lot of that market power is even self inflicted by said public sector via onerous zoning and permitting regulations that make development only plausible via large, oligopolistic systems.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by hd95489 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:39PM (#35412410)
You assume a free market economy that does not exist. Rent is a good example because regulation is driving it small land lords in favor of a few large corporate land lords that collude on rent using common algorithmic models.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by the_optimist on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:10PM (#35412711)
Similarly, you assume a public sector ability to identify, create, operate, and obsolete services that does not exist.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by throwaway173738 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:19PM (#35412827)
Mostly the issue with being a small landlord lies in how the landlord-tenant laws are written to treat you like a large corporate landlord. You have the same legal obligation to go through very lengthy eviction processes and to be very verbose about criteria but you can’t amortize the risk of a bad tenant over even tens of units like a corporation can. If you get one bad tenant they can cost you more than you get from them in rent, and they can destroy the rental house before you get to the eviction hearing.

I’ve had more than one conversation with my wife about just keeping the house empty instead while we’re gone, but I still think I have a moral obligation to rent to someone if I can.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by hd95489 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:11PM (#35415816)
I think short term rental lowers that risk by having more renters but none under contract. Air b&b is a terrible thing but also the local maximum for individuals
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by snapplebobapple on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:31PM (#35412966)
No, I assume the free market that does exist, i.e. the one where the outcome of competition is monopoly/oligopoly. On the way to oligopoly you get all these sweet, sweet benefits from competition, so one of the major goals of government has to be breaking up the ologipolists/monopolists or at least regulating them in such a way that they can't exercise market power (i.e. mitigating market power) so we can keep competition fierce and keep benefiting from said fierce competition. Doing the above has mostly been an utter failure in America and Canada since roughly the 1970's.

It's interesting that I said government self inflicted a lot of this in the rent space by over-regulating and you seem to think this is an example of the free market not working rather than the government breaking the market.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by userabchn on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:00PM (#35413295)
In my country there used to be a government-owned airline with a monopoly. Tickets were so expensive that only the wealthy could afford them (yet somehow the airline still lost money). Then the market was thankfully deregulated. Competition substantially lowered the prices, and gave people the freedom to choose which airline to fly on.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by laurencerowe on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:10PM (#35414631)
The bigger problem seems to be private homeowners colluding to increase their house prices by voting to prevent development in their neighborhoods.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by narwally on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:43PM (#35412454)
> The private sector will almost always deliver a better result as you mitigate market power abuse.

Yeah, and feathers fall at the same speed as baseballs if you mitigate friction.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by sologoub on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:05PM (#35412018)
That argument about UBI may be true ceteris paribus (all else being equal), though even then it may not. The assumption seems to be that all other money flows and incomes remain the same and demand grows while supply remains the same. UBI (there are many proposals/variants) would likely require taxes that will make it basically zero beyond a certain level of income and negative further up (increase in tax on upper brackets). UBI will also incentivize some people to stop working and rely on UBI, so net effects won’t be a uniform increase in buying power. Rents are not uniform geographically and area usually related to how desirable a place is and how much work there is in the areas. With UBI consumers can choose to move away from jobs centers.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by HPsquared on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:14PM (#35412120)
Sounds like a recipe for increase in demand for goods/services, coupled with a simultaneous reduction in productivity. Won't this just make the country as a whole poorer?
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by sologoub on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:14PM (#35412769)
This redistribution already happens with progressive income tax brackets and tax refunds that don’t depend on amounts paid in. This is US tax code today. Might as well have a better safety net in case things go south.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by mxkopy on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:44PM (#35414335)
> simultaneous reduction in productivity

Hasn't productivity been on the rise the past X years? Shouldn't we have a little slack by this point?

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by specialist on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:56PM (#35414481)
And maybe some profit sharing too.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by wutbrodo on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:15PM (#35414687)
First-order, yes: Redistributive policies don't have the sum of the country's wealth as their primary optimization objective. Arguably, their goal is closer (but not quite) to the sum of national utility, which follows from diminishing marginal utility.

That being said, there are also claimed and real second-order effects of policies whose first-order economic effect is deadweight-loss. The entirety of government fits this description! To use the most trite and least controversial example, confiscating resources to build roads is redistribution from heavier taxpayers to heavier road users (incl downstream beneficiaries), but the second-order effects of a functional transportation are enough that we don't consider it to "make the country as a whole poorer"

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by whitemary on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:26PM (#35412256)
Like I said, this is only the most straightforward problem with UBI. The most damning problem with UBI is that it's still capitalism, i.e. the capitalists will remain in control. As a result, UBI recipients, like the poor in developed countries today, will remain what Karl Marx called a "reserve army of labor." The UBI will always fall short of what is necessary for a healthy or dignified existence. This instrumentalized suffering, just like the permanent unemployed class in the US today, is a crucial component of industrial capitalism. Effectively, under UBI, nothing will fundamentally change.

I do support UBI because it will probably prevent some number of deaths of despair, but capitalists will never let UBI happen for this reason. The reserve army of labor must be trimmed and maintained to prevent a worker uprising, which is the primary function of the opioid crisis.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by sologoub on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:20PM (#35412854)
Sadly, communism worked out even worse. When communists realized that NEP worked too well and peasants started to get out of poverty, they instituted terror to “prune” the population and “remind them why they need” those said communists (a reference to V for Vendetta movie line). Just the best known example, there were also 1920s razkulachivanie and such, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Purge
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by mjevans on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:54PM (#35413871)
Communism != Socialism

Greed, seemingly fundamental human nature, causes corruption and suffering. I don't think we've yet developed a society or tool that is immune from such issues, though competition among providers does seem to help.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by whitemary on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:51PM (#35414407)
Your narration is so nonsensical and unserious that even the link you yourself shared undermines it, and of course it does. Wikipedia is a well-known liberal anti-communist institution, but at least they do some diligence.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Dig1t on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:57AM (#35411901)
I’ve always thought this same thing about UBI. Like that episode of Futurama where every citizen gets a $300 bill from the government and in the background of the scene right after they announce it, you see the 99 cent store sign being changed to the $299.99 store.

https://youtu.be/X_HyY-8dQJA

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by lotsofpulp on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:31PM (#35412325)
This ignores the effects of increasing marginal income or marginal sales taxes, which can be adjusted to the desired level of wealth redistribution.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by whitemary on Sunday April 02, 2023 @05:24PM (#35415388)
Income tax and sales tax are both regressive taxes. In other words, they both promote inequality by favoring the capitalist class.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by lotsofpulp on Sunday April 02, 2023 @08:55PM (#35417201)
Marginal income and marginal sales taxes are not regressive, they are progressive.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Nifty3929 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:01PM (#35411957)
For your housing example, we just need to produce more housing - but so many people are opposed to it. It's not that the private sector doesn't want to, obviously, they just aren't allowed to. You're making a good argument that we should allow for more housing to be built, but I don't see from your argument why it's better for that to be the government.

I can't think of many examples where the government does a better job producing things than the private sector. Even in countries with, for example, socialized medicine, and assuming you think that works well, the services (I think) are still provided by private companies. Maybe the VA Hospitals in the US - though I'm not sure that's an example of the government doing better or not.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by whitemary on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:02PM (#35414540)
> For your housing example, we just need to produce more housing

Existing property capital owners have a vested interest in not building more housing. Building more housing will negatively impact their profits. Existing property capital owners also have far more power than the petty bourgeoise investors seeking to "build more." This conflict of "NIMBYs vs YIMBYs" exemplifies a core contradiction of capitalism that Karl Marx articulated 150 years ago, except "NIMBYs" are not individual homeowners; they are rather the idols of the petty bourgeoise "YIMBYs." See: contradiction.

Objectively, the working class has no place in this conflict and will not profit from building more housing. Of course we should build more and better housing for working people, but that is not what the petty bourgeoise investors actually want; they want to build more housing for profit. Big difference.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by dantheman on Sunday April 02, 2023 @05:42PM (#35415560)
No they have incentive for others not to build, but for them to build.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by ISL on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:55AM (#35411882)
If low-end rents double, building housing looks a lot more attractive.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by polygamous_bat on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:02PM (#35411977)
Except current landlords have local governments in a stranglehold and you can't build any new housing at all.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by sologoub on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:16PM (#35412137)
That’s not the entire picture -Builder’s Remedy apperently is working: “ For example, after Santa Monica failed to pass a compliant housing development plan, developers employed the builder's remedy to move forward with the construction of approximately 4,000 new housing units spread across 12 new development sites.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Builder%27s_remedy

That’s nearly an 8.8% increase from the current 45,487 units total (including all houses) https://scag.ca.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/santa-...

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by catiopatio on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:44PM (#35413123)
It’s “working” insofar as it represents a giveaway to value-extracting development interests, nearly all of which seek to grow the permanent renter class.

It remains to be seen whether that will reduce housing costs.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by sologoub on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:25PM (#35413575)
Santa Monica is one of the most desirable areas in greater Los Angeles. I doubt the demand for it is that shallow. However, this helps more people (who are likely well off) to afford it and reduce pressures elsewhere.

If your goal is a paid off place to live, SM isn’t the best choice unless you are either high income already or are set to receive a windfall somehow.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Spooky23 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:15PM (#35412781)
Low end rents are already really high and subsidies set a price floor.

A two bedroom hovel in my city nets about $1200 section 8 voucher. A two bedroom in a nice development in the burbs is about $1300, and includes parking, pool and gym.

Landlords are like oil people, it’s all about extractive value. You want to pump the most cash possible with the minimum overhead possible. Building housing gets attractive only when the government subsidizes construction through low rates and rapid tax depreciation. A relative was the lead on development of a $18M hotel. He probably has $750k in. Most of the money is made with accelerated depreciation. The hotel itself is an afterthought, you couldn’t build it without the backend tax subsidy.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by analog31 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:42PM (#35413089)
From what I've read, low income housing is actually more profitable for landlords.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by ruined on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:03PM (#35411988)
"too much material wealth is captured by rent-seeking middlemen controlling access to location" is a problem with your property regime.

yeah, by extension, it is a problem with any action you take under that property regime. but don't let that prevent you from talking about what the solutions to other problems must be.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by skeeter2020 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:28PM (#35412285)
this is only true if everybody needs the same services, thus everyone uses UBI for the same thing. In the case of rent this would point to a systemic issue for which cash payments is not going to correct it, but there are a lot of varied needs for which UBI far more efficient than a government program addressing it directly.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Glyptodon on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:50PM (#35412510)
It's not so much UBI as a supply issue with housing at play regardless of UBI.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by ams92 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:21PM (#35412199)
Yep, the cost to run these programs is more than it would be to have a 20k UBI given how to each person living in poverty.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by tootie on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:32PM (#35412333)
Is it? SNAP, TANF and EITC are very much giving people money. The biggest missing piece by far is universal healthcare followed closely by housing scarcity.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:56PM (#35413882)
Yeah... Add in HUD and SSI.

This is the majority of spending on poverty, and it's literally direct transfers.

So I'm really confused by this comment.

The reason we spend money on special programs is because things like job training and drug addiction would never be taken care of by just handing out free money.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by dfxm12 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:36PM (#35414255)
You really don't understand snap if you think it's "giving people money", between the restrictions on what you can buy with it and all confusing red tape to sign up.

Based on the criticism I read about it, I think these clearing up these misconceptions is important if the USA is going to have a working welfare system.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by tootie on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:37PM (#35414920)
I didn't say they were perfect and fair, only that they were payments.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by salawat on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:10PM (#35412080)
>A much more efficient way to help people is just to give them money directly, and then people can spend it on whatever they think they need.

Capital tends to accrete capital. If you aren't actively hostile to passive capital accretion, eventually you'll end up with a handful of people making most of the capital allocation decisions.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by mordae on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:33PM (#35413670)
I don't believe it works like that when everyone has their needs met, specifically with UBI. Possible losses from breaking the law and getting caught would drive the price of white-collar crime up non-linearly. It would also be easier to unionize, which would help combat inequality.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by imtringued on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:39PM (#35414283)
What he means is that in a system with exponential growth, people who reinvest will eventually become a much bigger part of the economy than those who don't (for whatever reason). People with a disproportionate amount of power may use that power to get rid of UBI.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by ModernMech on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:04PM (#35413969)
> making most of the capital allocation decisions.

Unfortunately "making the most" sometimes (usually) means manufacturing fidget spinners for direct landfill deposit, instead of allocating resources for housing, healthcare, food, and education.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by salawat on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:22PM (#35414772)
...or creating transaction opportunities by inserting transaction processing medium where none previously existed.

See the bloody scooter rental people, printer companies trying to funnel people to ink by subscription, Keurig/Juicero. Practically every fintech ever.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by cptskippy on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:45AM (#35411752)
This stems from the fundamental conservative beliefs that the system is fair and your station in life is a result of your actions or efforts. Thus a fundamental opposition to actually charity and instead dangling opportunities for people to help themselves.

Running those programs is of course non trivial so the capitalist naturally offer to run them for the government at a modest fee.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by PragmaticPulp on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:04PM (#35412004)
> This stems from the fundamental conservative beliefs that the system is fair and your station in life is a result of your actions or efforts.

I don’t think I’ve ever heard a conservative say that life is fair. It’s more common to hear talk about “life isn’t fair” and how people shouldn’t expect every unfair thing to be corrected for them by someone else.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by plokiju on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:15PM (#35412125)
There’s definitely still some who believe in the American dream idea, where anyone who comes to America and works hard can pull themselves up by their bootstraps and become successful.

That often leads to the idea that if you’re poorer than me, you’re probably not working as hard as I am. And giving you handouts is unfair and offensive, because you just need to work for it

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by PragmaticPulp on Sunday April 02, 2023 @12:51PM (#35412520)
> There’s definitely still some who believe in the American dream idea

America is objectively and statistically one of the better places to succeed in this way, despite the shortcomings. If you believe that nobody or very few people think the “American Dream” is real, you’re probably in a bubble. This kind of out of touch cynicism is only really rampant on social media.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Timon3 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:53PM (#35413229)
Objectively and statistically speaking, it's really not. The Global Social Mobility Index 2020 places it at 27th place. Considering its economic place in the world that's pretty bad. At best you could say it's slightly above-average.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by ThrowawayR2 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:13PM (#35412758)
> "There’s definitely still some who believe in the American dream idea, where anyone who comes to America and works hard can pull themselves up by their bootstraps and become successful."

Which, in the case of immigrants coming to the United States, is often exactly what happens, proving that it is still mostly true.

Americans don't appreciate how good they have it.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by brodouevencode on Sunday April 02, 2023 @11:53AM (#35411857)
That’s not a conservative take per se, meritocracy was a notion whose popularity came directly from the Enlightenment.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by cptskippy on Thursday April 06, 2023 @11:50AM (#35470098)
No one said that it was a creation of conservatives, just that it was a belief. People's beliefs are usually impressed upon them by externalities like the community that raised them or traumas they endured.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by softjobs on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:15PM (#35415853)
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by arenaninja on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:03PM (#35412634)
I disagree to an extent. I know people on WIC, TANF, etc. who get subsidized internet, discounted property taxes, etc. Almost all of the ones I know game the system to their advantage one way or another.

I see people stop working because they'd rather not deal with others when they already have their needs met - I have no problem with this.

I see people who continuously pop more kids to keep the gravy train running - this is an issue.

I have seen people sell the products (a lot of it is food) they get for free and people who sell the vouchers because they already have too much; this to me is an issue too.

I see people who lie all of the time to get benefits they wouldn't qualify for otherwise; literally millionaires lying to get free stuff from the government.

I don't have a big social circle but it seems everyone I come into contact with is on the take and sucking hard on the government teat.

I think the approach needs to be more holistic and consider all of the different programs people qualify for - between WIC/TANF most people will get more food than they can consume. I think they should be nontransferable (maybe it already is, I don't understand how people end up selling them) and I don't think they should be progressive. Means-testing should be ended and everybody should qualify for these programs.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by lthornberry on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:10PM (#35412712)
I also support a shift to UBI, but your description of TANF/WIC is not grounded in reality. TANF has a 5 year lifetime, and many states actually have lower limits food stamps do not come close to covering the costs of feeding a family People do sell food stamps sometimes, not because they have more than they need, but because they are desperate for cash to pay for other necessities such as utilities.

The idea that people are getting by for years and years based on these as sources of income is a myth.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Aloha on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:38PM (#35413042)
We also make staying on benefits functionally a full time job too. The programs are too complex, they also don't cover all basic needs.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by arenaninja on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:24PM (#35414788)
Thanks, to clarify I don't begrudge TANF/WIC but those two are a short list of benefits that are available. Rent assistance ($), daycare assistance ($), free healthcare that's better than what I can get on the market regardless of $$$$, etc. I explained in other comments how a lot of it works, and I think rather than means testing I would like to see a different form of enforcement for these programs.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by michaelmrose on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:31PM (#35412974)
> I see people stop working because they'd rather not deal with others when they already have their needs met.

While some folks do get benefits when they could be working many more are denied anything despite obviously being disabled and the money that is paid is a relative pittance that few would choose given any alternative.

> I see people who continuously pop more kids to keep the gravy train running - this is an issue.

This is basically a myth. There are TANF in most states has a lifetime limit of 5 years or less and we are talking about $283 per month for a single parent single child household and it doesn't scale linearly. The next child nets you an additional $44 for instance. Exact figures vary by state.

People effectively sell vouchers or food benefits because they are desperately poor and need other things. As the refrain goes "food stamps don't buy diapers". In the case of WIC the vouchers may be for things that they literally don't need can't eat which will expire and thereby be lost.

This is an example of the inefficiency of buying things for people instead of letting them buy their own things.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by pnutjam on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:09PM (#35413393)
Thanks, the popping out babies is such a garbage take. It's not designed to argue in good faith, it's just a moron talking point.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by arenaninja on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:56PM (#35414480)
Just because a plurality or even majority of people aren't doing it doesn't mean it doesn't happen. As I've stated, I'm recounting these scenarios from my experience which isn't vast but it tracks in every state/city I have lived in (and I have lived in several).

It's a miserable living experience for their children. Welfare queens do exist even if they don't look like the media portrays them.

As I stated, I'm not against social programs, but I think there's substantial waste and program goals need to be realigned. It needs to be reimagined, and not from ivory towers like the techno-elite that gathers here on HN.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by pnutjam on Sunday April 02, 2023 @06:40PM (#35416032)
It's just a silly scenario. Nobody gets more in assistance then it costs to raise a child.

People might scam the system because they can't afford the kids they have, but nobody is having more kids just to scam the system.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by phil21 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @10:49PM (#35417954)
> Nobody gets more in assistance then it costs to raise a child.

Absolutely utterly false. Witnessed it personally.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by michaelmrose on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:50AM (#35419022)
Please give an example case in a real place based on actual benefit programs that exactly exist with links to information on said programs.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by pnutjam on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:44AM (#35421310)
The 100% truth is that you had no idea of any of the detail about whatever you saw. Unless someone has a massive trust with a procreation requirement, there is no free ride for children in America.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by phil21 on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:41PM (#35426950)
I had direct 100% access to every single aspect of one individuals life. Talked directly about the subject dozens to hundreds of times.

I absolutely know both the financial details as well as personal motivations. Others in that sphere I do not have as much intimate knowledge of but they follow the same pattern and social circles.

This topic is something HN (or rather the demographics that tend to post on HN) simply has a giant blind spot on.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by pnutjam on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:52PM (#35428339)
You've just modified your previous statement. I absolutely believe someone might have a child to get child support or even qualify for benefits. I don't believe anyone is popping out multiple kids to rake in extra benefits. There is no situation where multiple kids make life easier for the poor in America.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by phil21 on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:02PM (#35434451)
I'm not sure where the disconnect is. You pop out multiple kids so you extend the clock, not so you get multiples on any sort of payments (aside from perhaps child support, but that's a different topic). This is what OP meant by "extend the gravy train". Much subsidized housing is only practically available to women with dependent children.

As stated, I have personally witnessed this exact behavior. The common belief in certain circles seems to be this is unheard of and uncommon but I absolutely do not believe the mainstream statistics on the matter.

It's not just kids. It's a whole way of life. Usually SSDI is involved among other such shenanigans as well. It goes deep - to the point of ensuring your teenage kids show up to school exactly the minimum number of days to not get dinged on benefits.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by michaelmrose on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:11PM (#35459022)
Having one kids gives one a dependant child for at least 18 years which is virtually all of a woman's child rearing years. There is no clock to reset.

" not just kids. It's a whole way of life. Usually SSDI is involved among other such shenanigans as well. It goes deep - to the point of ensuring your teenage kids show up to school exactly the minimum number of days to not get dinged on benefits."

Adding details isn't making this more plausible. Nobody is denying YOUR life experience just your third hand misunderstanding of other people's.

Now you have them living on child support, fraudulent disability, and neglecting their kids.

Have you considered that maybe you have skeevy family and this is not normal.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by arenaninja on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:50PM (#35414405)
> This is basically a myth. There are TANF in most states has a lifetime limit of 5 years or less ....

Because you can't imagine it or haven't seen it that doesn't mean it's a myth. I have known women who continuously have more kids from different fathers. I think many people ignore the fact that people can also qualify for getting their rent paid, free healthcare for the kids, etc. I have seen it in several different states, lived in the same apartments as them and now know about them from their family members who are my acquaintances.

But I agree with you on inefficiency. As I said, I think we need a holistic approach that looks at the overall needs and gets rid of some of the programs and just hands out cash as you said maybe.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by phil21 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @10:46PM (#35417939)
> This is basically a myth.

It's very interesting to me that so many people these days are telling me what I've personally witnessed is not real.

Amazing how my personal bubble growing up apparently are the only ones committing such acts and literally no one else if you go by the stats.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by michaelmrose on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:41AM (#35418635)
If 2+2=4 it doesn't matter if you "witnessed" it being 3. Anyone who has actually interacted with poverty in the past 30 years would know that benefits are miserly, sparse, and limited.

Notable virtually no cash money which is basically required to live and work requirements for other benefits.

Welfare is what poor people rely on in addition to working not what they do instead of working.

This is why virtually everyone on food stamps is either temporarily between jobs, working, retired, disabled.

You can't just keep having kids and actually live indoors because the government will give you more food stamps but not more money.

What part of tanif being a few hundred a month and having a lifetime maximum of 5 years isn't getting through?

More kids = more poverty. The only angle to work is child support not welfare which is obviously the disconnect here.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by arenaninja on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:14PM (#35458301)
I don't think I have seen something as disingenuous on HN as trying to negate somebody else's life experience by saying "2+2=4". I won't be engaging the contents of a bad faith argument.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by afpx on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:13PM (#35413439)
I don't know what it's like now, but in the 1980s, we received aid, and you certainly couldn't live on it. It was a horrible existence. Yeah, we'd sometimes game the system. For instance, we knew if we bought something for $4.01, we'd get the $0.99 change back as cash. We'd trade vouchers for cash sometimes (to, say, put kerosene in the heater) But, we're only talking about gaining a few hundred dollars a year. If people in your social circle are living large, I'd love to know their trick.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by arenaninja on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:06PM (#35414582)
Yeah as I said in another comment, it's a mostly miserable experience on the kids and yet some garbage humans do decide to live strictly off of it. I'm not sure how we could disincentivize that, but I do think means testing should go.

The people I have seen who really milk the system work for cash, live with their boyfriend/SO and remain unmarried to keep the benefits coming (and just lie saying that the father isn't in the picture). So the burden of healthcare/food/rent is on the state and all of the income is fun money. Trucks/SUVs, jewelry, trips, rental houses, etc. follow. The kids only benefit as far as not starving, but they get free food at school/day care most of the year anyway so most stamps get sold. There's some who do very well and just stop caring about TANF anyway because it's overall pretty low value.

Another I've seen is just lying on the application so they get their benefits (I imagine similar to the others they say their husband/SO isn't in the picture) while they have a steady income stream from renting out their house.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by anovikov on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:08PM (#35412690)
I strongly believe the opposite. Fighting poverty should focus on things intended to prevent people from becoming poor, including in the next generation, not helping those already poor - more often than not, they have their life choices already made and they are impossible or incredibly difficult to alter, that's not a good allocation of resources.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by throwaway173738 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:24PM (#35412902)
I really don’t believe it’s impossible. And providing a way out of poverty for someone’s parents also necessarily lifts that child out of poverty. Even a thousand dollars is a life-changing amount, and we shouldn’t overlook the impact that extra resources can have on someone’s life. Buying breathing room to make different choices is one of the most powerful things we can do to lift people out of poverty.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by winstonprivacy on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:10PM (#35412719)
Ugh, I completely disagree with this. The government should NOT be handing out money to anyone. I also believe that they should be spending far, far less on public programs (though I do think that public healthcare is worthy of consideration).

Promoting affluence and the individual pursuit of happiness are two essential core values of the USA.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by User23 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:38PM (#35413715)
> The government should NOT be handing out money to anyone

Well, then we better get rid of our entire banking, payments, and public debt financing system.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by 818ikdhh on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:23PM (#35414133)
Banking and payments existed before governments, not sure what you mean :)

Public debt as a concept is evil, we should get rid of it.

>Postulate that the productive side of our economy is running considerably below capacity and then increasing demand via monthly helicopter drops isn’t crazy

Well, it is as crazy as it gets. Economy is driven by the supply side, not demand side, as evidenced by recent COVID induced inflation. No amount of money will buy you a loaf of bread if there's zero fertile land available to grow crops on.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by compsciphd on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:15PM (#35412777)
I'd argue that is the same reason we should simply have vouchers for education, instead of pouring money into a public school system, simply enable the people to spend money on education in how they think is best for their children.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Nifty3929 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:22PM (#35414765)
Typically vouchers have the money going to the school, and therefore becoming a price floor. And once again looks like govt spending instead of giving.

Much better would be to give everybody $1000 (or pick your number) per month directly, when they attend a private school. Regardless of how much that school costs. This preserves everybody’s full agency, as well as healthy competition.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by PontifexMinimus on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:17PM (#35412791)
Indeed. If someone's problem is lack of money, money will fix that problem.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by logicalmonster on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:18PM (#35412811)
> they usually focus on spending money instead of giving money to people who need it

From my perspective, the issue is that a lot of politicians operate as goal-oriented rather than systems-oriented problem solvers.

Many government programs generally operate as "give a man food" rather than "teach that man to fish".

It's no wonder that many problems are far further from being solved despite decades of cash pumped into them.

Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by analog31 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:20PM (#35412845)
Perhaps overly simplistic, but my suggestion is to spend money where there are true economies of scale, or services that individuals can't manage on their own such as education and health care. And in all other cases, just give money. For instance the food industry is already scaled up.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by Consultant32452 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:34PM (#35412994)
The government, advocacy groups, etc. need the problem of poverty more than they need the solutions to poverty. This is consistently true for every societal problem: racism, sexism, immigration, etc.
Re:‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than al... by dfxm12 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @03:19PM (#35414102)
I don't know if you can identify just one main problem. Another big issue is the all the means testing and second order effects of work requirements, etc. These make it hard to get aid to the people who need it and to allow people to find or train for better jobs.

It's totally systemic. America has socialism for the rich and rugged individualism for everyone else.