News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by sonofhans on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:22AM (#34805991)
One things this means is that cars are going to become as disposable as cell phones and laptops. As cars get assembled from larger components, damage to one area of the car will have larger effects. This will increase repair costs, more often pushing them over the limit to declare the car a total loss.

I can’t quickly find the numbers, but I know that car repair costs are going up and repair rates are going down, and have been for decades. The reason is obvious: the benefits of a modern car come at a cost. E.g., cars are much safer now, partly thanks to airbags; those are expensive to replace. My car has 11 airbags, and if they all popped off at once that alone would probably total it.

Years ago I was in a collision which bent that frame of my car. That’s usually game-ending, but this car has a modular frame, so they just bolted on a new frame component. Now, Mercedes have always (until lately, perhaps) been known as highly-repairable; it’s one reason they last so long.

So it’s good that the right-to-repair movement is getting traction. We’re going to need to point it at cars soon, and for mechanical reasons.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by bryanlarsen on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:50AM (#34806654)
The reason that your Mercedes was worth repairing was because it was so expensive. Most cars get written off with $15,000 worth of damage simply because most cars aren't worth $15,000.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by sonofhans on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:01PM (#34807898)
Actually, I got it used for about that amount, and many years before the collision. You may not know -- forgive me if I'm wrong -- but damage to a car frame totals the car. Frames have crumple zones, the activation of which destroys that part of the frame. No insurance company will sanction repair of it.

This only worked because the frame was modular to begin with, a rarity, so they could replace only the damaged part. IOW the car was built to be repairable. This increased its final cost, but means that it's still on the road today, rather than in a scrapyard.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dylan604 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:37PM (#34808505)
>You may not know -- forgive me if I'm wrong -- but damage to a car frame totals the car.

This is a pretty safe general rule, but it is not absolute. I had a brand new truck < 6 months old where I was hit from behind in stop-n-go traffic. The insurance company did not want to total it because the repair could be made for less than the value of the total. I asked how a frame could be repaired, and they just said it can be done. My counter was that the vehicle would now show frame repair and would have no value for trade-in nor would someone other than less than reputable dealers offer a car with repaired frame damage.

So, depending on the insurance company (Progressive was pushing for the repair. I hate Flo), some will argue against frame damage being an automatic total.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by YeahNO on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:21PM (#34809157)
I've had a car in a crash that should've been totaled. I was rear-ended by a truck while stopped about two months after my previous car was totaled (t-boned by an drunk driver). The insurance company balked at a 2nd total in that time period and demanded it be repaired. The total repair cost came to almost $5,000 over the KBB value. The rear end had been accordioned and the repair company straightened it out (you can indeed straighten frames with the proper alignment tooling) having to replace all the panels past the doors. They claimed it was back to spec, but it never tracked correctly in turns after the repair job. I sold it shortly after for about what I paid.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by joering2 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:00PM (#34809761)
> I sold it shortly after for about what I paid.

How did you manage to do that? Was that in USA? I presume damage was on record with CarFax, etc. Did you tell new owner what happened to the car?

Finally - if you were able to show the car does not track correctly, wouldn't that be enough to re-open the claim and go back to your insurance company to properly fix it (most likely replace it at this point?)

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by bombcar on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:10PM (#34812298)
Once cars hit a certain price people know they’re all sorts of messed up but don’t care.

You can find things on salvage titles that are literally two or three cars welded together.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dylan604 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:27PM (#34813712)
I'm kind of in the market for that kind of car myself. I need a car to just run errands in. I don't need it for commuting to working and back. I don't want a monthly car payment either for that kind of car.

The only thing that keeps me from doing that is not know what to do with that car when I do finally want to get a better car. It will have no value as a trade in, and I wouldn't want to have 2 insurance payments. Are they even worth anything as a donation?

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by bombcar on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:24PM (#34814592)
You can always get rid of a working vehicle.

But to answer the question, yes, even a dead vehicle will have some residual donation value (or you can sell it to a junkyard for $200-500 scrap value).

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by YeahNO on Monday February 20, 2023 @08:56AM (#34868087)
Yes, USA. Damage and behavior was disclosed. I was told by my insurance company that the problem was "in my head" as the vehicle's body and alignment were within specifications and their road test found no issues. This was a sports car and the behavior evidenced itself on more "spirited" turns.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by mauvehaus on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:18PM (#34810714)
Frame is a very different concept between a pickup truck and a Benz. Nearly all pickups are built as body-on-frame, where there's a separate chassis that mounts all the mechanical bits, and then the body goes on that. Nearly all sedans, wagons, and things that most people would consider "not trucks" are unibody. The body and frame are one and the same. The Benz in question likely had a detachable subframe at the front or rear where the mechanical bits are attached. It's pretty common to have bolt-on frame members (cross members especially), a fully detachable subframe forward of the firewall is less commmon.

All that to say, they can sometimes straighten a body on frame vehicle. Whether this is a good idea or not obviously depends on the severity of the damage. If a frame rail is bent into a banana shape, probably not. If there's been some light shearing or twisting movement of one rail to the other, they can probably do it safely within limits. Remaining imperfections get taken up in the suspension (it's adjustable). If you wonder how they put race cars back on the track so fast, it's because they'll tolerate a lot of frame geometry out of spec if they can make it up in the suspension without otherwise compromising safety and handling.

All that said, all of your points about the reduced value of the truck are certainly true.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by kjksf on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:56AM (#34806781)
Munroe addressed this complaint and his point was: if the collision is bad enough that it damages that cast, it would total a non-cast car as well.

Plus you have to reason on the level of systems, not components.

Single-piece rear casting replaces 70+ parts.

Those parts have to be welded together by robots.

Each weld is a potential failure point.

Casting produces more reliable car with less variances which ends up lowering repair costs on global (system) level.

https://twitter.com/Tesla/status/1513886756923445254

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by hef19898 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:59AM (#34806840)
Someone has not that much knowledge about casting nor welding it seems.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by Loughla on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:45PM (#34807614)
Expand on that comment, please.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by djbusby on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:45PM (#34807618)
Which one? I can't tell cause i don't have experience.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by numtel on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:10PM (#34808974)
Probably because welds are usually stronger than the materials they are binding.

As far as casting, I would imagine that would result in more brittle components that would snap instead of bend in a crash.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by galangalalgol on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:00PM (#34809767)
That depends on the metal and if it is post treated. Welded aluminum isn't as strong as the cast/extruded and heat treated pieces. Welding on 4130 steel can easily produce weaker joints if those joints are then treated. If they have an economical way to heat treat an entire cast piece, that might make it stronger than welded bits.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by hef19898 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:46PM (#34810331)
Heat treatment of modern, stabdardized alloys is a scirnce. Doing so with complex formed parts is still a bitch so. Especially big parts. Personally, I think induction hardening might work.

Well, welded structural parts, even produced in high vilumes, are a rather well understood problem so.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by adolph on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:22PM (#34810003)
The most common type of forging equipment is the hammer and anvil. Principles behind the hammer and anvil are still used today in drop-hammer equipment.

A forging press, often just called a press, is used for press forging. There are two main types: mechanical and hydraulic presses.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forging#Equipment

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by ketralnis on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:47PM (#34813340)
This is least useful way to express what you're trying to say
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by ketralnis on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:47PM (#34813342)
This is least useful way to express what you're trying to say. It just says "I'm smarter than you" while adding nothing.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by causi on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:34PM (#34808449)
Munroe addressed this complaint and his point was: if the collision is bad enough that it damages that cast, it would total a non-cast car as well.

I don't see how that's possible. Grain structure and alignment make forged parts much stronger than cast for a given weight.

http://www.expansion-parts.com.tw/upload/web/MetalPowderPart...

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by interstice on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:44PM (#34808616)
Should this not be a comparison to stamped /welded metal since that’s what car manufacturing generally uses?
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by sliken on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:59PM (#34808816)
The structural part of cars, at least any in the under $100k range, are not made of forged parts.

Sure various high stress suspension pieces are forged, but those aren't the ones being replaced by die cast assemblies.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by A_D_E_P_T on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:53PM (#34810417)
That's not at all true. Critical structural parts, such as B-pillars, are almost always made of forged or hot-stamped high-strength steels. And this is true even in cheap vehicles like the 2007 Dodge Caliber. See, e.g.: https://i.imgur.com/N399WLV.png

I think that the casting technique mentioned in the article is primarily, or entirely, for non-structural parts that would otherwise be made of something akin to mild steel.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by Robotbeat on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:42PM (#34811012)
No, the aluminum injection castings are structural. Using high pressure injection helps keep the voids low or non-existent compared to atmospheric pressure sand casting, for instance, which significantly improves performance (improving strength and toughness).
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by MichaelZuo on Thursday February 16, 2023 @12:10AM (#34815307)
No part of significant size will be forged in a sub $100k car. As another user mentioned, even the cheapest forged wheels are >>$1k each.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by pengaru on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:09PM (#34808959)
Very few parts of any automobile are forged. Even then it's usually high performance variants of ICE vehicles, limited to the engine internals, and transmission/differential internals.

Having said that though, the sheet metal used in unibody construction is far more ductile than usually brittle castings. If they've developed new alloys making the large castings more ductile than previous castings, it might not be a problem.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by bagels on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:17PM (#34810702)
It's mostly going to be internal engine/gearbox parts that are forged, and possibly wheels.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by rad_gruchalski on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:20PM (#34812414)
Forged wheels. Pretty damn expensive. Posh race cars use them. A cheapest set I was looking at some years ago was €6.5k.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by pengaru on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:53PM (#34824832)
IIRC RAYS / Volk Racing produced forged alloy aftermarket wheels at an affordable price. The TE-37 was a model back when I was modding RX7s and MX5s...
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by midoridensha on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:56AM (#34816534)
No one uses forged wheels for regular production cars, unless they're extremely high-end. All those alloy wheels you see on sub-$50k cars are all cast.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dsfyu404ed on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:00AM (#34817608)
All those Alcoa style rims Ford used in the 80s and 90s were forged. It has only gotten more prevalent since.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by theluketaylor on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:52AM (#34820256)
Forged suspension arms are uncommon but not unheard of. They are becoming more common as cars get bigger and heavier, though most manufacturers are going to extruded aluminum since it keeps costs down.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by abc_lisper on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:13PM (#34809900)
Can one align the grains by magnetizing the cast (aluminum is para magnetic)
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:18PM (#34809098)
>if the collision is bad enough that it damages that cast, it would total a non-cast car as well.

This is just lunacy.

It's absolutely possible to locally damage a cast item in a manner in which a welded/bolted steel assembly would also be locally damaged. And the cast is going to be harder to repair.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by lallysingh on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:13PM (#34809892)
Who's going to do that weld and then take liability for the safety of the car after?
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by linuxftw on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:55PM (#34810437)
Lots of older cars are rolling around with suspect welds today, often times performed by amateur welders. Everyone understands a repaired car might be be exactly same as new.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @05:38PM (#34811833)
The people performing their work and their insurer, just like literally every other case where skilled labor is bought.

Contrary to internet screeching welding the kind of cast alloys used on cars isn't really a big deal especially the aluminum ones (iron is harder). If the business case materializes I'm it will become common just like aluminum body repair.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by skellington on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:46PM (#34814733)
But almost nobody does it and insurance companies just total cars that have this kind of damage. Yes, in theory, it can be repaired but it's too expensive and because it's hard to guarantee the correctness of the repair, insurance companies don't do it and most consumers wouldn't stand for it.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dsfyu404ed on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:50AM (#34817539)
It's the labor cost that makes it non-viable in most cases. If it penciled out economically then all the people who are outsourcing their thinking to their insurance company would automatically become fine with it.

There is nothing about it harder to guarantee than anything else in the autobody business. How do you know they're applying panel bonding adhesive properly? You don't.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by rad_gruchalski on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:18PM (#34812383)
It’s pretty funny seeing a post from Tesla right after a line about „less variances“. It’s a common knowledge by now, posted many times here, that Tesla build quality and parts passing depend on the phase of the Moon and the menu at the factory.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jollyllama on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:08PM (#34807001)
All of the comparisons involved will probably be for unibody / monocoque vehicles, but comparisons to body on frame (Crown Vic) would be interesting.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by post_break on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:17PM (#34807148)
My Honda accord was $35,000. If the front is damaged just the headlights are $900 a piece. Ignoring structural issues with the unibody, the damage multiplier for new cars isn't the frame, but everything else. Headlights, fog, lights, sensors for adaptive cruise, calibrating the new sensor, bumper, paint, etc.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by function_seven on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:27PM (#34807340)
It’s insane. One of the stories about Chevrolet—when they were first designing the C5 Corvette—was that they took input from the insurance industry regarding repair costs.

One example of this is the hood. The previous generation had a beautiful clamshell hood that wrapped down around the sides. Opening the hood made the front end almost look like an open-wheel car. But it was expensive to make in one piece, and the entire piece had to be replaced if any part of it was damaged.

The C5 has a more conventional hood, with seams running along between the fenders and the hood panel. Not as pretty, but substantially cheaper to repair.

So, $900 for a headlight? We need to strengthen (or better align) the incentives for carmakers to reduce component costs.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jcampbell1 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:52PM (#34807735)
There is a huge incentive misalignment. The customer pays monthly for “insurance” and the moral hazard, the insurance company then pays a repair company, who then pays the OEM for the headlight.

The games all go away when the manufacturer sells the insurance, estimates how safe the driver is with data, and then handles the repairs.

Tesla understands this and sees it as a way to beat the competition on total operating cost for the customer.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by kube-system on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:10PM (#34808056)
I don't understand why more people don't check insurance rates before buying a car.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by coredog64 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:35PM (#34809390)
Insurance rates will eventually be reflected in the way the market prices the car. It would be more efficient if people checked, but the current process is close enough.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:00PM (#34809770)
Because the difference from model to model is a) not that high when cross-shopping models of the same form factor b) outweighed by demographic correlation factors.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by kube-system on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:39PM (#34810241)
People do cross shop different classes of vehicle, but even within a particular vehicle class, the differences can be easily be more than enough to be an important factor in purchasing. If you're comparing two vehicles, and one is $1000 cheaper to purchase, but costs 20% more on insurance... it likely isn't cheaper by the time your loan is paid off.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by rootusrootus on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:13PM (#34813580)
Tesla wants more to insure my Model 3 than USAA does, and that’s with lower coverage limits. Perfect safety score.

That’s without getting into how much better USAA’s service is compared to Tesla.

And if you have other non-Tesla cars you probably will benefit from having them on the same policy.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jcampbell1 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:08AM (#34820489)
Must I explain why people who serve in the US military are much better drivers on average? I’m going to go out on a limb and guess in addition to your perfect driving score, your Tesla is clean as well. I bet you probably agree with a statement like “there is no such thing as an accident”.

Enjoy your cheap car insurance. :)

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by notJim on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:51PM (#34808707)
Do we though? What percentage of cars are ever in an accident? If the choice is between better functioning while working versus lower repair costs, it's not obvious why we would prioritize lower repair costs. People on here always have this idea that repair must be prioritized above all without considering the tradeoffs.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by coredog64 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:34PM (#34809363)
This was Saturn’s big value proposition: GM used plastic for external body panels as they were more resilient to light damage and were pre-finished for cheaper replacement.

Expensive insurance will also kill cars, so insurance companies are definitely consulted stakeholders in vehicle manufacturing.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by bryanlarsen on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:53PM (#34810415)
Tesla sells insurance, so has a direct incentive to make its cars easier and faster to repair. Previously Tesla is notorious for how long it takes to get parts, but that is improving, partly because of the insurance incentive.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by njarboe on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @05:12PM (#34811452)
Elon Musk has mentioned one reason Tesla started doing insurance was to get more insight into repair costs and processes to help improve both vehicle design and the repair experience.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by mauvehaus on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:20PM (#34810732)
The first-gen Dodge Viper was notoriously expensive to repair for the same reason: the clamshell hood.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by Wistar on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:45PM (#34807622)
On a BMW 760i (V12) the driver’s side LED/laserlight headlight lens was badly fogged. These are sealed units and not repairable. Cost to replace? $9,600. It was covered under factory warranty but… whoa.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by DaveExeter on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:55PM (#34808752)
That's just BMW cheating customers. Or you might argue that they are cheating insurance companies, since most crunched headlights are replaced under insurance.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by BizarroLand on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:48PM (#34809588)
Yep. You may not be able to get it to Brand New Out of the box OEM shine but I bet there are a dozen acetone/sandpaper/lacquer/toothpaste/hydrogen peroxide something or anothers that could get you to 99% of new quality for less than $20.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by LeonM on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:47PM (#34810336)
Headlights are considered safety critical. None of the manufacturers will (and should!) allow a certified mechanic to rejuvenate and reseal a headlight unit under factory warranty. A manufacturer will always replace the unit, just to be able to warrant the repair.

You can DIY it of course, but no BMW 760i owner is ever expected to do that.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by BizarroLand on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:11PM (#34810639)
Under warranty? Sure, let the manufacturer handle it.

Outside of warranty? Don't give a company 10 grand for 74 cents worth of plastic and chrome.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by Wistar on Thursday February 16, 2023 @12:08AM (#34815293)
I wouldn’t go that far. Their light output and the steerability of their output is fairly stunning. They can’t be very cheap to make, but not $9k either.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:28PM (#34809287)
> These are sealed units and not repairable

Not repairable by a minimum effort flat rate tech in the US...

There's probably some guy in Latvia that has a Youtube instructional on how to re-seal it or something. $9600 is a hell of a motive to figure out how to repair it.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by elif on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:58PM (#34807857)
If you bend a frame rail in a composite structure, you have x new welds you have to perform, y rivets, z bolts, w plastic pins and spacers.

Some of those attachments were not designed to be removed and performed again, so you're looking at removing and replacing otherwise okay parts and then probably realizing that some other piece is slightly out of alignment and can't safely be reused...

If you bend a a unibody casting, firstly there is a larger chance that it is non-critical since there is so much added mass and structure. It is not a series of dominos like in a composite.

Secondly, all the attachment points are cast into the part. Replacement of one large piece is a significant reduction in effort, and results in more confidence in the ultimate repair.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by winrid on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:03PM (#34807937)
That "one large peice" is literally the entire unibody. You going to re-shell a street car like a racecar?
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:26PM (#34809241)
>Some of those attachments were not designed to be removed and performed again

Just because the OEM didn't bother to figure it out doesn't mean nobody can. There's all sorts of trick specialty repair parts and procedures in the aftermarket autobody industry to fill the gaps the OEM couldn't be bothered to.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by SECProto on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:02PM (#34807919)
> I know that car repair costs are going up and repair rates are going down, and have been for decades. The reason is obvious:

Have you taken a car in for repair recently? I agree that the reason is obvious - parts labour costs make it no longer make sense. Just a brake job nowadays costs a thousand dollars or more (depending on car model etc), i.e. 3% of a brand new vehicle purchase price. There's no anti-features causing this, it's just labour charges increasing.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by sonofhans on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:34PM (#34812569)
Yeah, but why is that? Consider: I can repair a 1980 Mercedes with one box of tools I can carry. Spend a couple years with your dad working on old cars and you could, too.

For a 2024 Mercedes I don’t think I’m even allowed to know what’s wrong with it. Hardly anything in modern cars is user-serviceable. Can I replace the airbags? Change their timing or velocity? Alter parameters of the antilock brakes, or emissions control? No way, never. Many of those systems have to be replaced wholesale by people specially trained.

The same argument holds, and for similar reasons, with phones. Anyone with a screwdriver could service an old Bell phone. Today it’s almost impossible to take most of them apart at all without destroying them, and the majority of their function is completely invisible and untouchable anyway (software).

We’ve added a huge amount of technology not just to vehicles, but to the tools we use to maintain them. Of course labor will be more expensive as it gets more specialized. Of course parts will be more expensive as they get more capable and more complex.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by SECProto on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:40PM (#34813286)
None of that gets to the question of why a brake job specifically costs so much, which is why I used it as an example. Brakes are no harder to do than 3 decades ago (at least for my car). They cost a lot because of the cost of labour, primarily. Other work has different costs.

The primary basis of your argument falls flat for me though. You don't need to repair new cars as much as you did 40 years ago. You never need to mess with your carburetor, spark plugs last a decade+, other stuff tends not to fail at nearly the rate it used to. My current car has 11 years and 250000 km on it, and I can count on one hand the number of times I've had to do any service aside from oil changes. (aside: why would I ever want to adjust airbag timing? And yes, if I somehow need to replace an airbag, I'll happily pay someone certified to do it. And if I buy a secondhand car, I'd really like to know that the person before me couldn't change airbag timing or velocity)

I do feel a sense of foreboding when it comes to choosing my next vehicle though. I want a BEV, but they all have so much electronic junk in that I fiind to be actively detrimental. I recently drove a friend's (2017) Toyota for a weekend, some ice built up on the sensor (in the badge on the front bumper). The following day, when roads were clear, it wouldn't let me use regular cruise control because the sensor was still iced over. A different toyota wouldn't let me cross the lane lines to avoid a pothole. They'll both slow me well below the speed limit on the highway based on the car ahead of me, with no notification. I would pay more for a car with these "features" removed.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by patwolf on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:50PM (#34808697)
I read an article, probably a decade or more ago, about how bad it would be for NYC cab companies that Ford was discontinuing the Crown Vic. The reasoning was that repair costs would increase because it was the last vehicle where individual body panels were easily replaceable. It was also the last body-on-frame sedan, so you could feasibly swap out an entire chassis.

I'd be curious what the long-term impact was, or whether Uber made all that irrelevant.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by Scoundreller on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:30PM (#34810853)
Probably still cheaper to operate a Corolla, especially when everyone on the planet knows how to fix them.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by pengaru on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:18PM (#34809091)
One could make the same argument about batteries in EVs making cars more disposable. The insurers are going to total any vehicle having the slightest damage to its battery module between the high risk of assessing its safety wrong and high cost of replacement...
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by nradov on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:24PM (#34810035)
Repairability for collision damage is a lost cause. Let's focus on collision prevention instead. The latest generation of Advanced Driver Assistance Systems are already bringing collision rates down for newer cars and there is much room for improvement.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by eternityforest on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:00PM (#34810491)
Most cars don't seem to fail because of structural damage. How relevant is repairability?

Is the expected material use and expected cost to the consumer more or less for repairable vs gigapress?

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by mauvehaus on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:09PM (#34810601)
I was talking to a body shop about unibody construction in the context of some rust repair several years ago. Basically, for a lot of cars, if it isn't a bolt on part, it's already supplied as one big piece from the manufacturer. Like, the whole side of the car sized piece. Whether that's one stamping or several welded together (or bonded), it's a cut and weld job for a collision repair. A small enough rust repair can be made up from sheet metal, but not a serious collision.

Also: paint. It's never one panel. They usually have to feather in the color on the adjacent panels because getting a perfect match is tough despite computers, etc. You need one panel painted, and you're pretty quickly looking at getting 3 or 4 painted (or at least attended to). Even discounting airbags, it doesn't take much to total out even a five to seven year old car these days.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by bombcar on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:09PM (#34812276)
Also totalling is “back to how it was” - a single hail storm totaled my wife’s car because that many dents can’t be undented.

So we took that and bought the totaled car back and still use it.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by tomcam on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:07PM (#34814029)
Username checks out
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by fiftyfifty on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:56PM (#34811208)
If you look at the breakdown of the Model Y with the casted front end and back end by Munroe on Youtube it's fairly modular, with a front end cast and back end cast both bolted to the battery pack in the middle, and the top of the car lowered onto the base. If one of these casts were damaged in an accident but the rest of the car was OK, it might make more sense to just replace the entire front end or back end cast with a new one.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by barney54 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:18PM (#34813048)
The average price of a new car in the US is now $50k. That’s not a disposable purchase.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by RugnirViking on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:39AM (#34817090)
I originally thought that too, but neither are laptops or mobile phones. However, it seems the OP is talking about disposable in the sense that they cannot be repaired, so must be disposed/replaced if they incur any damage.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by prawn on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:29PM (#34813170)
Is it the William Gibson book where future cars are described as having a cardboard exterior?
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by emmelaich on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:23PM (#34813678)
The same issue happened when they moved from chassis + wagon to monocoque.

It's still an improvement.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jacquesm on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:28PM (#34813725)
The main reason why MB lasts so long is due to a single component in the engine, they still use a chain rather than a timing belt. This one little change has so much impact on the rest of the engine design that they tend to last very long compared to cars that have timing belts. Suddenly a whole pile of stuff is happening inside the engine enclosure instead of outside of it reducing the number of seals and in general reducing complexity outside of the engine core. It also reduces the need for complex service.

It's a bit old fashioned, timing belts result in an engine that runs a little bit more quiet and they make for a lighter package. So it's easy to see why many manufacturers would choose that option. But MB got that bit right (they also got plenty wrong, their software for instance absolutely sucks).

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by ptmcc on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:27PM (#34814621)
You are right that chains are superior to belts, but MB is hardly the only manufacturer using timing chains. Chains are actually becoming more popular, not less popular, especially as interference engines have also become more common.

My 2021 Mazda uses a timing chain. My 2004 BMW uses a timing chain. My old 1990 BMW had a chain. My folks' 2019 Lexus and 2016 Toyota both use chains.

Honda was a notorious holdout that still mostly used belts for a long time, but even they are coming around and some new models use chains now.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jacquesm on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:37PM (#34814683)
Interesting! So there is a kind of resurgence in this. Nice to see that other manufacturers take the longevity and service of their engines serious. There was a point in time where MB seemed to be the lone holdout and the only other manufacturers that used chains were mostly making trucks (and Porsche). To me it's a no brainer, especially with an engine where the pistons don't clear the valves when they are active. The kind of engine damage that a broken timing belt results in is usually enough to completely scrap the engine.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by ptmcc on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:57AM (#34815860)
> I wonder if those other manufacturers chains are also rated for the life of the engine or rather not.

Mostly yes they are, which is wonderful compared to timing belts. It rubs my engineer brain intensely wrong to have such a critical engine component be designed as a wear item, especially when its failure can cause engine rebuild levels of damage.

However not all manufacturers' quality lives up to the intended design. VW/Audi have a spotty record with various well-known timing chain problems ranging from bad chain tensioners that fail and cause the chain to jump timing to plastic chain guides that break and wreak general havoc.

But for most cars a timing chain will last the life of the engine.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by classichasclass on Thursday February 16, 2023 @12:03AM (#34815269)
My '08 Civic Si had a timing chain, one of the few models that did at the time. Used to startle the service techs who weren't expecting it.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by bsagdiyev on Thursday February 16, 2023 @12:49AM (#34815538)
Yep, the N54 out of my 335i had timing chains. Replacing that during the engine build wasn't fun, but it was still solid at 130k.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by analog31 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:46PM (#34814735)
As an amusing aside, my 1995 Saturn station wagon had a timing chain. Thanks to a combination of design flaws, at around 70k miles, the chain skipped a tooth and the engine disintegrated.

But it wasn't just a matter of the chain. All Saturns burned oil from the git-go, and as a bonus, a low oil level would cause the timing chain to lose lubrication, thus causing it to wear out. People who religiously topped off their oil, every time they re-fueled, kept their Saturns for a long time. I was not one of those people.

My next car was a Toyota, which I still drive. The Toyota engine is designed to make it easy to service the timing belt at the prescribed interval, and the car consumes no oil.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jacquesm on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:47PM (#34814748)
Keeping the oil topped up isn't really a luxury! That must have been quite the thing when it happened. Were you in traffic?
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by analog31 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:20PM (#34814970)
I was at a stoplight. It just started making a grinding noise (probably the cylinders slapping the valves). I was not far from my regular repair shop, and drove it there. Later on, I returned to gather my belongings from the car, and the shop made it go away.

I'm definitely more careful with my newer cars.

My first car didn't burn oil, but dripped. I'd just top off the oil whenever I started hearing the tappets clicking. It was quite a forgiving engine, a 1975 Dodge.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jacquesm on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:35PM (#34815072)
The Mini I had was very much like your Dodge. There is a joke in Mini owner circles: "How do you know your Mini is out of oil?" -> "There is no puddle under it when you drive off".
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by inferiorhuman on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:28PM (#34815023)

  The main reason why MB lasts so long is due to a single component in the engine,
  they still use a chain rather than a timing belt. This one little change has so
  much impact on the rest of the engine design that they tend to last very long
  compared to cars that have timing belts. 
No.

Timing chain vs gear vs belt has little-to-no bearing on the longevity of an engine. You can, for instance, build an engine with a timing chain that's prone prone to catastrophic failure of the timing components. Mercedes has done it twice so far with the M116 and the M272/M273.

  Suddenly a whole pile of stuff is happening inside the engine enclosure
  instead of outside of it reducing the number of seals and in general reducing
  complexity outside of the engine core. It also reduces the need for complex
  service.
Tell that to anyone who's had a Ford with the Duratec or EcoBoost and an internal water pump.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jacquesm on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:36PM (#34815079)
So 'yes' except for some exceptions that prove the rule.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by inferiorhuman on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:44PM (#34815133)
So, no. GM's put out a fair number of stinkers including the Ecotec and the High Feature V6. Chrysler actually recalled their late 00s Hemi engines over timing chain problems. The previous owner of my E39 had to tear the whole engine apart because the timing chain guides failed (as they pretty much all do). BMW's later N20, N47, and N57(N) engines are also well known for timing chain problems. VW/Audi had plenty of timing chain issues with both the 1.8T and 2.0T. Let's not forget Audi's famous rear mounted V8 monstrosity. Jaguar's AJ8 was legendary for timing chain problems in its first few years. Nissan's had trouble over the years with the chains on both the V6 and 4 bangers…

Meanwhile people put hundreds of thousands of miles on Volvo's old four cylinder with a… timing belt which takes all of thirty minutes to replace.

Chains vs gears vs belts has no bearing on longevity. The big difference is that chains are smaller and when you need to work on a chain it's generally far, far more complex than a belt drive. Don't forget that engines like the Ecotec, EcoBoost, M272, N20, and 2.0T are basically the bread and butter of those companies. They are high volume mass market engines.

Mercedes tend to last a long time because they're expensive, people pay to repair and maintain them, and nearly any Mercedes part for any Mercedes car can still be purchased new.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by jacquesm on Thursday February 16, 2023 @12:25AM (#34815388)
You're welcome to your opinion, of course. Volvo has an excellent reputation. BMW not so much regardless of how they are constructed, Chrysler (at least the ones that I've had when I was in Canada) never impressed me from a technological point of view and it was in the shop quite frequently. And MB fields cars year-after-year that clock up 300K+ to the point that it isn't even something exceptional and as a rule with the original engine.

As for repair and maintenance: that's a nice bit of circular reasoning, the reason those parts can still be bought new is because there is still demand for them: the cars are still running.

When you start looking for cars that are 15 years and older (which is my bracket in NL) there really are only two brands that stand out: Volvo and MB. The rest are lucky accidents and this is reflected in the state of the rest of the cars as well. But as a rule car engines will fail well before the body does and with MB (and Volvo) it tends to be the other way around.

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by tomcam on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:04PM (#34814007)
Hasn't this been true since unibody construction prevailed?
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by andreareina on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:53PM (#34815199)
Right to repair has nothing to do with how easy it is, only that access to parts, manuals etc isn't restricted and that the repair doesn't require authorisation.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by squishy47 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:54AM (#34817175)
lots of people talking about repair costs. Mat Armstrong's channel (https://www.youtube.com/@MatArmstrongbmx) is good for this. Pretty interesting to see him repair crashed cars on his drive and the prices of the parts. especially the newer lambo series. (edit - Englishing better)
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by kjellsbells on Thursday February 16, 2023 @12:44PM (#34822227)
Also interesting to consider the third or fourth act of cars. There are a lot of beaten up mercedes 190s and toyotas in poorer countries that people run for decades. Many of them were once used in richer countries before being shipped overseas. I wonder what happens when such vehicles cannot be economically repaired, since that is a key part of the value prop?