Seeing how thoroughly he convinced people that he had political influence, and given his general lack of awareness, I’m willing to give merit to his believing he was immune. Similar to how people outside securities think insider trading is more rampant than it is, insider trade in the most obnoxiously obvious way, and then promptly get caught.
We’ve gotten tot he point where we’ve gone way too far off the deep end when it comes to this narrative around political influence. the collective imagination seems to have risen to comic book level proportions.
All people saw was SBF gave a bunch of money and thought, “he must have a ton of influence”. Meanwhile, in my state, he gave $11 million to a democratic candidate who lost in the primary and was transparently an absolute joke of a candidate.
If it's how it is in my weird African country (Nigeria), I'll wager that most of the money is spent on advertisements and clueless campaign managers and staff enjoying the grift. But then, I understand; the U.S. is a really rich country with a high percentage of politically-active citizens, so they put their money where their mouth is.
1- https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/03/2022-midterm-election-spendi...
You don't even have to give $5800 in most cases. $1k is plenty to get the attention of junior congressmen and even some less well known senators.
Just to put all this in perspective, it's actually possible to get meetings with these people without giving them money, especially if you're a constituent. But the more money you give, the higher you move up in the priority queue, and it doesn't take much to move to the front of the line.
Here's an easy one: "He was only arrested because he was going to reveal damning truth in today's Congressional hearing."
Even if the DOJ, Congress, and SBF all swear until they are black and blue that it wasn't the reason for the timing of the arrest, the theory can change to "Of course they would say that, they are all in on the deep state conspiracy."
The beautiful thing about the world is that there is an unlimited number of unconfirmable and unrefutable possibilities and could-have-beens that can be used to support any idea - sensible, or silly.
Axios wrote that he spent $37 million on the midterms:
https://www.axios.com/2022/11/15/ftz-crypto-bankman-fried-de...
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/nov/30/ftx-billi...
I also think the 1 billion figure is inaccurate. In May, SBF said that he could spend a billion between now and 2024. However, he backed away from that quote in October:
https://www.cnbc.com/2022/10/14/sam-bankman-fried-backtracks...
Elon Musk later said that SBF “probably” donated over 1 billion, without providing any supporting evidence. I can’t prove that he’s thinking of the May statement but it seems plausible if not certain. Either way, Elon Musk’s guesses are not proof of anything.
I’m glad you asked for sources. It’s always important to provide them.
Seriously. If I had a nickel for every time someone had posted on HN "SBF is immune because he donated a lot of money to Democrats" I'd have… well, a lot of nickels.
Madoff donated a lot of money to Democrats too and it didn't help him one bit.
There were numerous posts on this forum who were adamant that nothing would happen to SBF because they were certain that he had the Democratic Party bought and paid for. It’s the certainty that I’m calling out here (“comic book level), not the skepticism.
If he hadn't gotten indicted in, like, a couple of years, then sure. But people were assuming he wouldn't be indicted days after FTX collapsed.
Interestingly, if we take SBF at his word that he donated equally to Republicans in dark money, he would be the fifth largest donor to Republican candidates.
https://thehill.com/business-a-lobbying/3720141-here-are-the...
What's particularly stupid is most of the time that people are going off about how some company or person gave a bunch of money and that is obviously why Congress passed the bill that company or person supported, the companies or people that opposed the bill also gave a ton of money to the same members of Congress that the first company or person did.
Also, often those companies on both sides of the bill donated a lot to the members of Congress that supported the bill and those that opposed the bill.
Musk on stage with Chapelle last night, Elizabeth Holmes, or SBF’s whole schtick, who are the ones who have kept their feet on the ground?
What are the attributes of these others who don’t lose themselves in fawning attention and (sometimes short-lived) mountains of capital?
The person who built a liquor store and grew into 20 stores across the city. People who started consulting companies. That immigrant family who scraped and scraped for decades while living above their restaurant. The list is endless, especially compared to the much shorter list of crypto criminals who are drunk on their illusory power and fame, which seems to always disappear overnight.
Any fool can make a fortune; it takes a person of brains to hold onto it.
Ross Perot was a billionaire from consulting, before being a billionaire was a thing. Plus he was a genuinely good person.
Both my perception and my experience from knowing several extremely wealthy 'self-made' people is that the vast majority are fairly quiet, prudent, bright and hard-working people who've managed to make (mostly) good long-term decisions and continue doing so consistently over time. I suspect the "crazy, playboy billionaire" stereotype is based more on high-visibility outliers rather than the majority. Outlandish, eccentric and/or entitled behavior makes for good stories and click fodder while typical long-term value-building behaviors are pretty boring.
Although I get the impression a large part of Buffet's normalcy is because he's chosen to spend his time making money for other people.
If you're ridiculously rich... you could do worse than thinking of common people as your boss, for perspective.
You are only pointing to the very few who couldn't handle it or are drawn to attention.
Power is hard to measure, but in this context it seems reasonable to include lots of founders in the list. The Collison brothers, sama, and Brian Armstrong, to name a few. They’re all in charge of fortunes that normal people can only dream of.
I don’t think any of them have made critical errors. And it’s arguable whether Musk has, but time will tell.
I have no clue who these people are:
Hank & Doug Meijer
Tom & Judy Love
Stewart & Lynda Resnick
Andrew & Peggy Cherng
In fact the list of ones I recognize is tiny compared to the whole list.
Some of them don't even have pictures, but they're all billionaires. And yes, I consider even a single billion to be a great, real fortune. Most people will never crack a million.
By saying yes, she was, in effect, Amazon's first investor, and worked there in the early days. The value of positive support from family cannot be underestimated (see also Jeff Bezos' parents' early investment in the company).
You realize that he's not asking to go on the show, people are asking him to come on the show. Your questions should be directed at Dave Chappele.
There are actual lawyers on HN. I don't think proximity to lawyers makes one as knowledgeable as an actual one.
The answer is simple, through a lack of knowledge. Knowledge of the law is not genetically inherited.
So if you believe he's committed crimes, then it doesn't become far fetched to imagine that he'd continue to not listen to his parents on matters of criminal defense.
Lawyers and judges break the law, sometimes intentionally out of arrogance derived from how adeptly they believe they can skirt it because of their knowledge and position.
Well, he’s not a lawyer, for one…
Not everyone brings work home with them, or forces their kids down that path.
Any time SBF ran into trouble, he could just raise another round of financing, or borrow against artificial valuations, or "smooth things over" with the right people.
Once that happens enough, I imagine a lot of people would start to feel some cosmic entitlement to it, like that's just how it is, the FTT tokens must be worth $24 each, it's only a matter of "getting liquidity"[1], you can always raise more money, you can always call in a favor, you can always borrow against what you think the assets are worth, there's no reason to hold customer assets in their original form.
Heck, even to the very last days, when his attorneys and CFO were telling him he had to declare bankruptcy, he adamantly insisted that new funding was just about to come through -- and even that he got the offer moments after declaring -- but, of course, he can't say who, or under what terms, even why they would invest. [2]
Personally, I always try to maintain a frame of "these good times don't have to last, they can go away at any moment, so make sure you're ready for if/when that happens". But maybe I'd falter too, in the same position.
[1] A frame even informed observers buy into! Earlier comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33539326
[2] ctrl-f for "Mr. Bankman-Fried was also frustrated.": https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/29/technology/sam-bankman-fr...
obligatory “don’t talk to the police” link.
The friendliest police officer in the world is not your friend
edit: Saw that the professor, James Duane [0], has his own Wikipedia page, almost entirely on the popularity of the Youtube lecture. Even more surprising, his Talk page seems to be free of debate over Duane's notability. Pretty impressive for a single videoed lecture!
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/School-to-prison_pipeline
"Don't Talk to the Police Part 2" - https://youtu.be/tIt-l2YmH8M
The police aren't your friend. They're also not your enemy.
Talking to the police as part of an investigation doesn't make you a suspect. Seriously, how do people think criminal investigations are done? Talking to witnesses is a huge part of investigating. People very rarely finger themselves as potential suspects; it's almost always the other witnesses who identify them as suspects.
If you're worried that you've done something wrong, talk to a lawyer first. 99.9% of the time, they'll tell you it's fine. Of course, if you tell the police you need to talk to your lawyer first, they'll want to know why you think you need a lawyer; if I were your lawyer, that's the first thing I'd wonder too. And if you weren't considered a potential suspect before you definitely will be on their short list after.
If cops were obligated to be honest in more respects I would be more willing to open up, but of course they don't want any restrictions in that area. Cops in the US want to be able to lie whenever it's convenient and also have everyone trust them, but that's not a very fair bargain for the general public.
And if the police say something seemingly benign that causes you grief, you can look forward to a large-ish settlement to make up for your troubles.
People on HN rarely interact with the police and it seems they have an unrealistic, media-driven perception of how cops actually act. For point of reference, it's the same as how non-techies assume that every tech employee can hack their way into a bank account or rig together a go-kart from spare parts.
Cops are not as bad as people think they are. Cops behaving badly (in the U.S.) is news because it is the exception and not the norm.
https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/Pages/detailli...
30% These convictions aren't the result of people talking to the police and then getting screwed over. The overwhelming majority of them are the result of cross-racial witness identifications.
To put it bluntly: most wrongful convictions are due to racism on the part of prosecution witnesses.
Is it really unfortunate? There is simply an implicit assumption that humans avoid incriminating themselves when possible but are very quick to offer excuses. That seems to align pretty well with my experience. Therefore, we assume that if someone says something contrary to their own interest is is more likely to be true.
Yes; the system should not be biased towards guilt.
But it's unlikely the Police officer actually "witnessed" anything that'll help you.
If you tell police officer you did something bad, it's essentially a confession and reported as such.
If you tell police officer you did something good, it's hearsay - you told it to officer who told it to judge & jury.
Then there's jurisdictional details as to their role and rules of evidence etc that will vary from country to country.
But it's a shocking revelation to most people that Police cannot effectively help you in court. That's not their role.
-----------------------
Edit: Found it - federal rule of evidence 801(d)(2)(a) - Opposing Party Statement
https://www.uscourts.gov/sites/default/files/federal_rules_o...
Police have a responsibility to testify truthfully under oath, within the constraints of the rules on hearsay. But that doesn’t mean they are forbidden from saying anything in your favor, no matter what.
Witnessing things is a completely different matter.
I have a friend who is a federal criminal investigator and his advice when/if the feds show up is to say nothing other than "Do you have a business card? Someone will be in touch." and get a lawyer ASAP.
[0] - https://www.iannfriedman.com/blog/2019/april/federal-charges...
[1] - https://www.pallegarlawfirm.com/obstructing-justice-in-flori...
This is because the people who wrote the evidence rules believe nobody would admit to a crime unless they are guilty. So it's a hearsay exception.
The exception isn't meant to be a sinister trick to treat you unfairly, it's meant to lead to the right people going to jail and the right people not going to jail.
During Mirandized interrogation:
Doe: "I grabbed her wrists after she picked up a knife to attack me."
In court:
Prosecutor: "What, if anything, did you learn from questioning Mr. Doe?"
Officer: "He said he grabbed her wrists."
Defense attorney on cross-examination: "In what context did Mr. Doe grab her wrists?"
Officer: "After she picked up a kni--"
Prosecutor: "Objection! Hearsay!"
Judge: "Sustained. Jury will disregard anything about the accuser picking up a knife. Wrist grabbing stuff is fine."
^Not remotely how it works, at all, but what you might falsely believe from being told "your words are admissible against you, not for you".
In other words, if you try to introduce an out-of-court statement that supports your case, it's hearsay; if the statement is against your interest, it's allowable.
Of course there are other exceptions and nuances, but this is the jist of it.
Fact is that there is a huge paper trail of SBF's malfeasance, nevermind the fact that his co-conspirators appear to be turning against him. If anything, his interviews seemed to be his attempt to argue for negligence over malice in his case.
Yes, SBF is going to prison for a long time. No, I don't think anyone has made a viable argument that his interviews over the past few weeks are likely to make his sentence worse.
As an unrelated aside, note that this is also a way of punishing lower classes of people more severely. If you shoplift, prosecutors don't have to prove you meant to do that rather than just accidentally failing to pay. Generally laws for intent are for people that legislators can identify with, and there is no intent requirement for people legislators don't personally identify with.
Do you have examples of what you are referring to? As you say, intent matters here. The vast majority of quotes I've seen from his interviews are along the lines of "I suck at accounting", but that he didn't intend to steal funds.
But again, the other reason I don't think it matters is that there were plenty of other recorded examples that do show intent, e.g. cases where SBF was lying on Twitter specifically to try to cover his tracks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33632472
>Shoplifting is defined as entering a commercial establishment with an intent to commit larceny while it's open during regular business hours and the value of the property taken, or intended to be taken, is $950 or less. Any other entry into a commercial business with intent to commit larceny is burglary.
So - on basically every account - he would've been far, far better off to STFU.
1. Prosecutors don't operate independently of the court of public opinion. They can throw the book at you (e.g. the George Floyd officers) or let you off easy (e.g. other officers who historically did similar things but did not face the same charges).
2. The current perception is that he committed fraud (like Madoff), and if convicted for that would likely go to prison for the rest of his life.
3. He's clearly not innocent of wrongdoing, and there's too many people involved who are cooperating with authorities, so just being quiet doesn't help him as much (in contrast to being found at a crime scene with no witnesses).
4. If he can get a conviction only of criminal negligence then perhaps he can get out of prison faster.
5. Thus perhaps if he can loudly admit to being a bumbling idiot and super negligent, it might sway the public opinion to criminal negligence instead of outright fraud.
By comparison, Do Kwon has been relatively quiet but that didn't stop him from South Korea putting out an arrest warrant on him in September. But it seems he's still "free" b/c he spent his time hiding his whereabouts.
* (at least in the SEC civil lawsuit)
Even if he was under a delusion that the rules wouldn’t apply to him, we can assume his parents would do everything in their power to reign him in if this was not some sort of strategy.
From what I understand of the interviews, he carefully avoided going into details, and instead used the opportunity to present himself as an “aw, shucks” borderline simpleton with a heart of gold who just got in over his head. He was going to be arrested either way, so how do you see this as not a carefully-planned attempt to improve his public image?
My experience has been that working with family or very close friends often nullifies or severally weakens professional sensibilities. It would be very understandable and almost expected if his parents are too closely involved emotionally and financially to be objective in this situation, and even if they were, the parent-child relationship also affects how one takes advice.
I would never rely on a close family member for important legal services, it seems almost as bad an idea as relying on yourself for legal services.
He may be, but going for the Lauri Love defense as your 'hail mary' may have been his only move left; they'll likely claim that this will be clear indication of his mental state in order to to get a lighter sentence or end up in a white-collar prison rather than a stint in Chino.
Or are they usually put into the same place?
[0] https://protos.com/sam-bankman-fried-caught-deleting-more-tw...
[1] https://fortune.com/crypto/2022/11/14/sam-bankman-fried-cryp...
[2] https://old.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/ywz4j8/sam_...
Some other recent examples of this include the lawyer Michael Avenatti going to jail for decades for stealing from his clients, and everything that has ever happened to Donald Trump.
(In my experience as a white person it is mostly other white people who think this, but I don't want to generalize.)
How to casually stereotype without stereotyping?
Seems he really cannot shut up...
This whole FTX thing is very suspicious on all kinds of levels internally and externally. So many things about FTX don't make sense as presented.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_man_%28political_science%2...
I just don't follow my own advice I give to criminals like SBF.
The Senate trial is the equivalent of conviction; the House impeachment trial is more the equivalent of a grand jury indictment (although a very politicized one). No US President has ever been convicted in the Senate trial, Trump included.
That was obvious, but some of us who have seen some version of this before have been saying he was going to end up in prison when he entered US political donating/purchasing influence since the beginning of 2022; it was clear where this was all going and the hope was that it would take down all the alt scams, but somehow despite not having any BTC it has taken down the entire cryptocurrency market for no discernible reason.
Its the epitome of contagion effect in practice; and while hindsight is 20/20 I fear that the greatest take away here will be missed because of the ire that has been fomented in the media: insiders will use anything to achieve their largess, that regulation is a loosely held panacea when said insiders use influence and resources to grift.
I think he will get a light sentence, relative to the amount of money that has been lost, like Elizabeth Holmes as he scammed a lot of big players/rich people but it will not be the 2 life sentences that Ross Ulbricht, and that is the real point: we have a multi-tiered judicial system with a very clearly established selective application of the Law.
He has another angle. Maybe he was trying to taint the jury pool. He was up to something, but what?
"The FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried’s mother and father, who teach at Stanford Law School, are under scrutiny for their connections to their son’s crypto business." - https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/12/technology/sbf-parents-ft...
You may not owe ex-billionaire fraud defendants better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
A word to the unwise: If you have done something, anything, that you have a credible reason to believe the United States government thinks is illegal, shut up. Do not do any of the following:
* Go on a podcast and talk about it
* Go on a Twitter livestream and talk about it
* Tweet about it
* Answer questions from those you committed the crime against about it
* Speak to journalists about it
Instead, shut up. Shut up shut up shut up shut up. Your defense attorneys and your ankle will thank you.
It does not matter whether it was an honest mistake or not. It does not matter whether you agree, philosophically, that it ought to be illegal. It does not matter whether Congress wants to talk to you about it first. It doesn't matter whether you've lived a life so sheltered and privileged that you cannot conceive of the idea that anyone from the government might be out to get you.
Imagine the US Justice Department as an extremely patient, extremely hungry predator, and yourself as a delicious, plump prey animal with two broken legs hiding behind a rock. Anything you do or say to anybody except your lawyer will be used against you. So shut up.