And while there is certainly division of labour as you describe it, it does not necessarily imply that these are distinct social classes (even today, we have different job roles in a single social class).
Such hunter gatherer band was much worse dystopia village. You were dependent with your life on the band and if you disagreed with others, you could not just switch bands as easily as you can switch employers today.
If you said we have greater material comforts today, I couldn't disagree with you. If you said we're happier? I'm not so sure. There is something so damned compelling about a tight knit family and tribe.
The problem is that in most cases you can't do that. You might have been the person who made the last push to make the revenue possible, but you were building on the work of everyone else who was working for that company and you were leveraging someone else's resources to make it happen.
We have to have some way to agree what portion of that profit can reasonably be attributed to you. To avoid complicated math and guesswork every quarter, most of us agree to a fixed salary as a reasonable estimate for a fair share of the value we're creating.
I want it to be an equal equity corp basically every hour invested earns you shares based on your senior and tenure.... Sr dev multiplier x 2 years with company for example.
Then we'd earmark like 30 percent of revenue to go into profit sharing and each state gets a reward.
The shares also calculate your voting threshold.
Senior team will be given an edge so there's an ethical dictator but not an insurmountable thing.
It might take 10 people to out vote the execs but you can't buy shares it's all earned by actions and time investment etc...
I also want to build an ERP system that can actually run a co-op like this with multiple streams of income, multiple point pools to reward employees or even customers etc....
It'd also network with other co-ops to build symmetry like Amazon marketplace does for sellers, everyone would be invested in every other syndicated companies success.
Sales people often can get up to or more than 50% of the profits (after all expenses) as commission. I've seen up to 80 or 90 percent for companies with extreme growth focus.
Programmers don't generate value directly the same way, but often you can attribute value to products they create and compensate them fairly.
The bargain I've made instead is that I get a very good base salary and call it a day. When the company grows because of my contributions, I negotiate a higher salary, but I don't have to think about it from month to month.
I'm just saying, if I have an employee and he makes me $1m a year, I'm going to pay him well - I'll pay that employee what is fair in the context of what value we enable him to generate for us.
That usually means the employee is worth at least 50% of that in compensation, btw.
This is why if you bring a deal to a company as a sales person commissions are around that number (50% of profit).
Which is to say that cost/value proposition is never simple. I've been at companies where people were paid simply not to jump to competitors.
Fixing the problem would mean that instead of the 'owner' hiring an 'employee,' they instead form an equal partnership as co-owners. Because the business serves the interest of the owners, it will seek to maximize their compensation as the ultimate goal, rather than to minimize their salary as a way of reducing expenses.
They could perhaps give the worker a minimum wage and the rest pay in dividends, but mind that dividends need to be distributed among all the shareholders equally, so you can't say you would pay $100,000 unless you allocate shares so that when dividend pay out is decided, worker's shares will yield that exact amount.
1. Debt is built into your existence (student, medical, housing, etc);
2. The system is designed to extract (exploit) value from labor; and
3. There is no value without labor.
[1]: https://www.antislavery.org/what-we-do/past-projects/india-d...
My Assumption here is that the common usage of profit is, "Money after all expenses paid", which employee compensation is clearly outside of that definition.
Money is fungible and what we identify as "expenses" versus "profit shared" is arbitrary. Economic value is created by the enterprise, and that value is then split between the owner, the employees, the suppliers, and the customers.
We can argue about whether the distribution is fair, but complaining about the specific accounting method by which the value is distributed is myopic. Either you're getting a fair share of the economic value or you aren't—whether your share comes of the pre- or post-tax portion of the pie is the government's concern, not yours.
Workers: "We should see more of the profits the company makes and we are making the case that collectively we produce a larger portion of the value we're asking for"
Poster: "Your pay is part of the profit, the more money you make the less that goes to the owner"
You're right. I shouldn't assume a framing is misleading just because its unorthodox, I'm attempting to make a case for the framing being misleading with supporting statements.
At best the parent comment isn't saying anything of substance at all (in response to ITS parent comment), and in my view, at worst its an attempt to redirect the concept of 'profit' to make the argument seem less credible.
ceronman's thought experiment was "if you have employees, you have to share your profits ... If [they] don't produce any value, easy, fire them all, you get everything."
jerrre's response, which I think is fair, is that we're already running this experiment. If businesses did not think employees produce value, they would not pay them wages or salaries, because every dollar paid to an employee is a dollar less of profit for the company. Companies already acknowledge the value that employees create value by the very fact that they pay them anything.
In other words, what's actually at stake isn't whether employees create value but how much, and ceronman's comment doesn't contribute anything to that discussion.
I believe they were making the case that Employees need the company as much as the company needs the employees. The experiment is to split the profits evenly amongst those who created the value in the first place - The people that work inside the company. If they can't produce the value, get rid of them (And if that's the case there's more profit for everyone right?)
They could also mean that the profits are distributed amongst the employees based on individual contribution when they conclude that there wouldn't be any self-made billionaires because no single individual produces that much value.
I still disagree with the conflation of wages/cost of business and profits, even though more mages means less profit - Profit is still surplus after all has been paid. The distinction is important for more than just the scope of this conversation.
I think the allure of being a billionaire is it's "one and done". As in, once you achieve it, you can live the craziest life possible filled with lots of grandeur and not need to run any kind of business whatsoever after.
It's mainly a fantasy for people who are tired, overworked, underpaid, under-appreciated (which is like 85% of America I'm guessing).
"Wouldn't it be nice..."
I feel like this accelerates class segregation. like, going from talking about the new condo in a nice neighborhood changes from "must be nice" to "my friend lives there and says the Tesla charging stations are broken but I'll talk to the leasing office about it tomorrow", just immediately more depth that some groups of people can't contribute to and are dismissive about.
Hell, one can support the median household income at a reasonable SWR on ~ 2M.
Underlying all of this seems to be paulg's assertion that billionaire founders 'deserve' their wealth and therefore our inequality and their relatively small contribution to the public purse is justified.
I have no problem with founders being rich, but once you're earning 1%er income? You should be paying a hefty amount of taxes to support social spending. Think ~ 2/3rds, like it used to be before the regans and thatchers of the world gutted the social contract in the 80s.
$10M does get you a nice time, and you would never have to say no to any reasonable expense, but it's also definitely possible to overspend. There's some higher threshold where you really can be 'wild and crazy' and the only way to run out of money would be through bad investments.
There's a difference between always flying first class, always flying on a jetshare, and always having your plane fueled up and ready to go. Also, between driving yourself to the airport, taking a car service, having your driver take you, or having your helicopter pick you up.
I think maybe you're missing the perspectives of ...almost everyone outside of a very select few in VHCOL locations.
Tech workers in SF don’t.
While I wouldn't mind being very well off, I have a visceral gut reaction to any of the sort of flashy spending that draws attention to myself. I also find that it isolates you from the experience of the common man, and life is lonely enough as it is.
After I hit my 'retirement number', if I can find a job that will give me the flexibility I want in retirement, I plan on continuing to work 2-3 days a week and donating half my salary to charity.
God knows local charities can use my money far more than they can use me as a volunteer. I like coding, and if I get paid and do good in the world, so much the better.
for anybody not familiar
safe-withdrawl rate
typically 1% of portfolio value a quarter = 4% a year i am guessing?
theory is if your portfolio is invested in funds (mutual or ETF) tracking a broad-market index (S&P500) aka equities, and these equities go up 8-10% a year (return before inflation) on average over the long term
and if you have a $2m portfolio basically 100% in equities
sell off 4% = $80k/yr worth pre-tax (only taxes would be... long-term capital gains?)
because your portfolio is appreciating 8-10% a year, it'll stay at $2m despite you sell off $80k/year because it's tracking the US stock market/"economy" which is supposed to be growing 8-10% a year and they "offset each other"
with $10m this becomes $10m * 0.04 = $400k/yr pre-tax
i too would like to have $10m so that I could live off $400k/yr and not need to work :)
heck, i might even settle for $5m!
Of course you can always spend more money. However I have known rich people who decided their mansion was too large and so they downsized (their master bedroom after the downsize was the size of my whole house!) Eventually what you need is time to enjoy what you have not more luxury. Fly coach or have a private jet on call - end the end you get there, and the jet only saves you a bit of time at the airport.
-> https://www.ycombinator.com/
->
> Y Combinator created a new model for funding early stage startups.
> Twice a year we invest $500,000 per company in a large number of startups.
> We work intensively with the companies for three months, to get them into the best possible shape and refine their pitch to investors. Each cycle culminates in Demo Day, when the startups present their companies to a carefully selected, invite-only audience.
-> https://www.ycombinator.com/topcompanies/public
Sometimes I guess we just forget where we are :-)
So I guess yes, it's the wannabes.
I'm sure I'm years behind the curve on that idea, though.
Worth noting: Not all companies can or should target this trajectory -- which just means VC might not be the right funding source.
That money is needed for your business to survive in the environment where a bigger company can bully and destroy small companies.
This seems to be the trend in "Western" societies, and the middle class enthusiastically votes for those who pursue that agenda.
I guess that could be the vision for the US to: a developing country style society, with utral-nice fenced areas for the rich, a supporting 10-20% class, and "skid-row lite" welfare land for the rest, with crumbling infrastructure...
And if things end up worse, the rich have already bought houses in New Zealand and elsewhere anyway...
How much of the profit do I share with the employees? What does the society deem fair in the case where founder comes up with the product, identifies the problem and works with the customer to configure the product? Do I get to take 5 salaries or 1 salary?
You wrote 80% of the code (who wrote the rest?) and you got it deployed. You're making a decent living on 15.000 users. "Scaling" guy comes in and "scales" you to 150.000 users. Do they get an order of magnitude more profit than you?
I'm not placing any value on "scaling", I'm asking what it should be valued at.
> Who wrote the rest
For argument's sake, let's say there's 10 devs who wrote the rest.
Let's say that in span of 12 months, after paying yearly gross salary of $150 000 to each person in equation (10 devs, 1 scaling/devops guy, 1 founder), $2 800 000 is left and we're dividing it.
How much goes to each of the 12 people in the equation?
Economy isn’t so hot anymore, folks with obligations will absolutely settle and take it on the chin. You have all the power here.
The "boss bad, worker good" is getting really boring and disgusting, just like not all bosses are evil - not all workers are good. I presented a scenario where there's no investors and where the founder did majority of the work.
> if you have employees, you have to share your profits with your employees
Needless to say, this already happens via equity and options. There's a reasonable debate to be had over what constitutes "fair" profit-sharing. But the market clears where it clears, and individual tech employees definitely have meaningful leverage even under current macro conditions.
This equivalence doesn't make much sense unless there's a widespread phenomenon of businesses "firing" owners in favor of other capital-providers who will accept lower returns.
Startups share equity with employees. The earlier you are there, the more you get, in part because of the inherent risk.
This is why founders get the most equity and the most upside if it succeeds. They took on the most risk and it wouldn't otherwise exist.
If the company ends up being valued at 100B dollars, guess what, the founder and maybe some early employees are billionaires or hundred millionaires.
It would be one thing for a founder to have 3x the equity of an early hire, but it is commonly more like 60x or 300x. Instead of a dozen people being able to cash out and support their families for the rest of their lives, one or maybe two people get to have many multiples of that and the rest barely make progress towards retirement.
Why would anyone ever be an early employee when they can be a founder instead?
Is this always true though? I've worked with a grand total of one company where, if the company went bust, it would mean the end of the founders' life savings. Every other startup/company I've seen, the founder was already very well off. Yes, they put a big chunk of capital and/or time into the start-up. Yes, they were highly motivated to make it succeed. But if it failed, they would... be sad, fall back to family money for a while, and then later do another start-up (or go back to their previous career in Investment Banking). I think this idea that the founder must be singularly taking a huge amount of "risk" is a romantic, stereotypical take, not always true.
Start-up employees, however are shouldering risk. They are by and large not already wealthy so if the start-up fails, there goes their livelihood until they line up another job. I think we should stop thinking that "risk" is exactly the same as "how much of the company's raw dollar equity did you contribute".
However, I don’t see the way out unless the social safety net is strengthened (not gonna happen) or we just ban rich people from starting companies (lol, lmao even)
Edit: maybe there shouldn’t be a way out. Maybe the solution is just to educate and make transparent that rich founders have better odds and less to lose and bust conceptions around successful at business == higher quality individual.
You need to create value continously or fall back to UBI.
Just something to play around with. :)
Basically we’ll end up in a totalitarian society governed by an AI.
That train of thought escalated quickly.
This risk exists with any employment arrangement. So arguably the risk is merely the greater likelihood of the startup failing vs big corp laying you off.
So someone with 10 million dollars who puts up 1 million has put more capital at risk than someone who puts up 100,000 even if that is everything they own.
And paying out on personal risk doesn't make sense. Imagine doing a seed round and the share of equity each investor gets is not related to how much they invest but what % of their networth they invest.
Also in every startup I've worked for(3) the founders were not rich before starting the company.
Unless the providers of said ability have to compete for business on price. One should not underestimate how hard it is to replace them.
While that's true, I think it also pushes the profile of the ideal founder much more to the technical side than where it is now.
Creating and maintaining automations is inherently difficult-to-impossible to fully automate, and will likely always require some degree of engineering skill.
Conversely, many of the most important skills a "business founder" brings to the table are ripe for automation. Marketing, sales, administrative tasks, slides for investor pitches, support, accounting: all have the potential to be automated to a large degree by AI.
- Writing cold emails and responding to questions asked in replies
- Writing a script for sales calls
- Writing a pitch deck
- Writing marketing page copy
- Writing ad copy
- Responding to customer support requests
- Writing promotional social media posts
I have more confidence in its ability to do these tasks given its current level of sophistication than to meaningfully contribute to engineering tasks (though it can certainly help there too).
I wouldn't trust it with accounting or administrative tasks yet, but it doesn't seem far off.
Probably there will be AI tools to de-AI messages, like reverse semantic companders[1], coming soon.
It can already write better HR-friendly pap than I ever could, and it can churn it out by the thousands of words.
I'm very impressed by the power of "mere statistics" to construct dead-eyed language like the aliens in Blindsight. But, more than that, I'm grateful that I'm not employed to write such text in the first place. While there's an incoming boon for slackers who can just fire off a prompt email with a little bit of proofreading, there's a long run pinch on people who are employed just to talk nothings all day. Those who remain will have to watch over hundreds of thousands of words spraying out per day.
How do you determine how much profit an employed CTO makes versus a customer service rep? What's fair there? My estimated guess: you have no idea.
It seems like he definitely believes founders create a lot of value, but I don't think he is making the second claim that employees don't create value. Just making the argument that the outsized return to founders is fair because they are creating far more value as evidenced by automation.
I expect $1B solo founder startups to become normal pretty soon
https://twitter.com/amasad/status/1600143003607105537
(I honestly don't know -- not my area of expertise, just putting it up for discussion)
Very Musk-y of you
Satoshi Nakamoto is (most probably) a solo billionaire
And obviously, even if they were a billionare, their ultimate goal was not to develop a business where they become one, but they were probably supporting their idea by being an early miner.
Which is exactly why Marx makes his “vapid” argument: cleaners and other menial jobs contribute as much to society as any geniuses (evidently, as societies without those menial jobs got outcompeted). And the way society currently evaluate those values seems to be incorrect.
The issue with Marxist is that the solution he proposed is troublesome, not that the problem doesn’t exist. And until the next genius figures out a different solution, we should at least try to limit the problem as much as possible
Scarcity is clearly an important component of value. This is essentially the "why is gold more valuable than water when I need water to live." question. I don't see the point in rehashing this stuff as if it's new.
I agree that Paul is severely overstating his case here (as is his wont), but only the first half of your summary is true to his tweet. He's saying that founders create a lot of (even most of) the value in a company, but he is not saying that employees create no value.
His argument is essentially this: If employee jobs can in theory all be automated away while a company still produces value, that means the startup founder's role must produce a huge amount of the value in any company.
This is a pretty fragile argument that has a lot wrong with it (that a job can be automated today doesn't mean it wasn't extremely valuable yesterday), so there isn't really a need to erect a straw man.
They have some interesting properties and I wonder how they would stack up against a top-down structure like in a corporation or university. Specifically I wonder if they would be able to resist bureaucratic bloat and the growth of the managerial class that plagues mature companies and organizations.
As a small company, I have hired and fired few people over the years. When I made the wrong hire, it cost a lot not just in terms of money but the overhead, mental anguish and loss in productivity. Sometimes I got lucky and hired some exceptional people. They have made life 2x better and yes they do get rewarded accordingly at least in my company.
Not all employees produce equal (even if same job title and experience on paper) and it is a fact.
The claim he says is false is "their employees created all the value".
Replacing "all" with "also" produces almost the opposite statement. I don't mean to be pedantic but that's an extreme misinterpretation.
If that's true, then what about a social experiment: If you are a solo founder, you get all your profits for yourself. But if you have employees, you have to share your profits with your employees. If employees don't produce any value, easy, fire them all, you get everything. But if they do, share your profits fairly.
I'm curious to see how many solo billionaires will appear. My estimated guess: zero.