It would be one thing for a founder to have 3x the equity of an early hire, but it is commonly more like 60x or 300x. Instead of a dozen people being able to cash out and support their families for the rest of their lives, one or maybe two people get to have many multiples of that and the rest barely make progress towards retirement.
Why would anyone ever be an early employee when they can be a founder instead?
Is this always true though? I've worked with a grand total of one company where, if the company went bust, it would mean the end of the founders' life savings. Every other startup/company I've seen, the founder was already very well off. Yes, they put a big chunk of capital and/or time into the start-up. Yes, they were highly motivated to make it succeed. But if it failed, they would... be sad, fall back to family money for a while, and then later do another start-up (or go back to their previous career in Investment Banking). I think this idea that the founder must be singularly taking a huge amount of "risk" is a romantic, stereotypical take, not always true.
Start-up employees, however are shouldering risk. They are by and large not already wealthy so if the start-up fails, there goes their livelihood until they line up another job. I think we should stop thinking that "risk" is exactly the same as "how much of the company's raw dollar equity did you contribute".
However, I don’t see the way out unless the social safety net is strengthened (not gonna happen) or we just ban rich people from starting companies (lol, lmao even)
Edit: maybe there shouldn’t be a way out. Maybe the solution is just to educate and make transparent that rich founders have better odds and less to lose and bust conceptions around successful at business == higher quality individual.
You need to create value continously or fall back to UBI.
Just something to play around with. :)
Basically we’ll end up in a totalitarian society governed by an AI.
That train of thought escalated quickly.
This risk exists with any employment arrangement. So arguably the risk is merely the greater likelihood of the startup failing vs big corp laying you off.
So someone with 10 million dollars who puts up 1 million has put more capital at risk than someone who puts up 100,000 even if that is everything they own.
And paying out on personal risk doesn't make sense. Imagine doing a seed round and the share of equity each investor gets is not related to how much they invest but what % of their networth they invest.
Also in every startup I've worked for(3) the founders were not rich before starting the company.
Startups share equity with employees. The earlier you are there, the more you get, in part because of the inherent risk.
This is why founders get the most equity and the most upside if it succeeds. They took on the most risk and it wouldn't otherwise exist.
If the company ends up being valued at 100B dollars, guess what, the founder and maybe some early employees are billionaires or hundred millionaires.