News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by jerrre on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:45AM (#33880725)
Paying a wage = sharing your profits, just not on a % base, but a fixed amount. But in the end it's still: less profits for the founder, and more profit for the employee.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by vasco on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:49AM (#33880806)
Also this is not about a dystopian village with one single employer that exploits workers that cannot move. Startup employees agree with free choice to work somewhere for the agreed upon profit share, be that % based or fixed, or mixed.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by VictorPath on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:04AM (#33881108)
It certainly is a dystopia village - in the US a hunter gatherer band a century and a half ago provides for their own needs, with no social classes. Now the descendants of those natives must sell their labor power in order to live. That they have a supposed choice from who in an oligarchic cartel they can do it with means little.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by judge2020 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:24AM (#33881486)
Hunter-gatherer bands don't exactly survive without families to continue the cycle of reproduction, someone to take care of the children, someone to tend to the wounded and sick, someone to build the houses while the hunter-gatherers are out hunting, someone to grow crops when it's cold and food is harder to hunt for, someone to track how much food everyone is getting...
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by necovek on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:01PM (#33883320)
I did not read the original reply to mean that "hunter-gatherer band" only consists of hunters and gatherers.

And while there is certainly division of labour as you describe it, it does not necessarily imply that these are distinct social classes (even today, we have different job roles in a single social class).

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by judge2020 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:26PM (#33890314)
But it only takes one spark of someone thinking they "put more effort in than everyone else" to demand more food, and suddenly you have societal classes that drift further apart over time.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by zajio1am on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:33AM (#33881662)
> in the US a hunter gatherer band a century and a half ago provides for their own needs

Such hunter gatherer band was much worse dystopia village. You were dependent with your life on the band and if you disagreed with others, you could not just switch bands as easily as you can switch employers today.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by wing-_-nuts on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:37AM (#33882817)
Such bands had very flat hierarchies. Your opinion was weighted on merit (i.e. the best hunter's word was trusted in that activity and the best farmer on theirs). Different bands absolutely exchanged people. Young people heading out to find their way and tribe was practically a right of passage.

If you said we have greater material comforts today, I couldn't disagree with you. If you said we're happier? I'm not so sure. There is something so damned compelling about a tight knit family and tribe.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by Brigand on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:17AM (#33881367)
I am pretty sure among hunters there was a very strict pecking order and I am glad to live in the system we have today.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by achenet on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:27AM (#33881544)
any proof of that statement? from reading description of native american societies in Dawn of Everything, the opposite seems to be the case.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by wing-_-nuts on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:39AM (#33882856)
They really didn't. Hunter gatherer societies were the most democratic and egalitarian that we've ever had. Graeber's work on this is fantastic.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by roflyear on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:09AM (#33881201)
No not really. If I generate $1m of value for a company and they pay me $90k a year that isn't really sharing profit.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by lolinder on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:21AM (#33881432)
If you can convincingly demonstrate that you singlehandedly generate $1m revenue for a company, then I'm confident that you have the negotiating power to demand a share.

The problem is that in most cases you can't do that. You might have been the person who made the last push to make the revenue possible, but you were building on the work of everyone else who was working for that company and you were leveraging someone else's resources to make it happen.

We have to have some way to agree what portion of that profit can reasonably be attributed to you. To avoid complicated math and guesswork every quarter, most of us agree to a fixed salary as a reasonable estimate for a fair share of the value we're creating.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by gremlinsinc on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:36AM (#33881729)
I want to start an agency that does everything digital, but also some mrr micro SaaS projects.

I want it to be an equal equity corp basically every hour invested earns you shares based on your senior and tenure.... Sr dev multiplier x 2 years with company for example.

Then we'd earmark like 30 percent of revenue to go into profit sharing and each state gets a reward.

The shares also calculate your voting threshold.

Senior team will be given an edge so there's an ethical dictator but not an insurmountable thing.

It might take 10 people to out vote the execs but you can't buy shares it's all earned by actions and time investment etc...

I also want to build an ERP system that can actually run a co-op like this with multiple streams of income, multiple point pools to reward employees or even customers etc....

It'd also network with other co-ops to build symmetry like Amazon marketplace does for sellers, everyone would be invested in every other syndicated companies success.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by roflyear on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:41AM (#33882895)
Well, sure. But people are not programmed like that.

Sales people often can get up to or more than 50% of the profits (after all expenses) as commission. I've seen up to 80 or 90 percent for companies with extreme growth focus.

Programmers don't generate value directly the same way, but often you can attribute value to products they create and compensate them fairly.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by lolinder on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:13PM (#33883515)
Personally, I don't envy the salespeople their commission-based compensation. Having my compensation directly tied to demonstrable value created would be overly stressful for me.

The bargain I've made instead is that I get a very good base salary and call it a day. When the company grows because of my contributions, I negotiate a higher salary, but I don't have to think about it from month to month.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by ren_engineer on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:40AM (#33881801)
in that case you should bet on yourself and start your own company. It comes down to risk and reward
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by roflyear on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:38AM (#33882839)
I'm not implying that companies don't bring value by their nature. They absolutely do. I'm also not implying that I could generate this value on my own, though I have before.

I'm just saying, if I have an employee and he makes me $1m a year, I'm going to pay him well - I'll pay that employee what is fair in the context of what value we enable him to generate for us.

That usually means the employee is worth at least 50% of that in compensation, btw.

This is why if you bring a deal to a company as a sales person commissions are around that number (50% of profit).

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by ricksunny on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:20AM (#33881412)
Not disagreeing; but for clarity you'd want to refer to generating surplus value rather than value, i.e. net of costs. i.e. if my work can be construed as having created $1M of revenue, but $990,000 of cost (say some low-commission dropship affiliate sales structure, or online payments with a small transaction fee), I've only created $10,000 of surplus value, out of which I can make a case for a different distribution scheme based on an update (read: agitation) of normative values.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by roflyear on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:36AM (#33882798)
Sure, yeah. Agreed.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by jstanley on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:20AM (#33881402)
But if you cost the company $1m you still get your $90k.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by WitCanStain on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:36AM (#33882804)
More likely you get fired.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by roflyear on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:39AM (#33882849)
Hopefully you do not have many employees that are costing you $1m a year...
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by necovek on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:21PM (#33884664)
Look at the cost of Zuckerberg's metaverse push to Meta, and Musk's work to Twitter: sure, that's currently sitting at a lot more than that, but they are hoping to turn that around in a number of years.

Which is to say that cost/value proposition is never simple. I've been at companies where people were paid simply not to jump to competitors.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by dotnet00 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:59PM (#33885230)
It isn't even limited to high profile cases like those. Same goes for a lot of hiring (in junior positions especially), it often takes some time for the employee to learn the ropes, during which time their cost (both in terms of direct costs like salary, benefits and equipment and indirect costs like the time of the people bringing them up to speed) is almost definitely higher than the value they're bringing to the business.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by necovek on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @02:47PM (#33885975)
Definitely: I was just putting out obvious extreme cases to illustrate the point.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by VictorPath on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:59AM (#33880993)
The argument he is arguing against is that the workers create the wealth, and profit is that unpaid surplus labor time that the LPs/VCs/founders expropriate from the workers creating wealth. You can't "share" profits with workers when workers are creating all the wealth, the LPs/VCs etc. expropriate profits from workers.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by HideousKojima on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:04AM (#33881093)
So if the people providing the funding weren't there, where would the salary for the workers who are currently getting their surplus labor expropriated come from? If these workers are getting unjustly exploited, then what's to keep them from starting a co-op together where they share all profits? Plenty of co-ops exist in modern day capitalist societies, including several successful ones like WinCo in the US and Mondragon Corporation in Spain. No one is forcing these employees to give up their "surplus labor" to investors.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by varispeed on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:48AM (#33880791)
Wage is a cost and profit comes after costs. If owner want's to share profit, they need to give company shares to the employees and pay dividends.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by HideousKojima on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:54AM (#33880892)
A cost that cuts into what would otherwise be profits. It's all fungible so you're quibbling about an accounting issue here. If an owner made a contract with an employee that they will pay them a $0 salary but will pay them a fixed annual dividend of $100,000 (broken up into convenient bi-weekly payments) would that fix your concern? I'm getting the impression that it wouldn't.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by sidlls on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:52AM (#33882028)
This is disingenuous. Money is fungible but the flow of money is not. My buying weekly groceries is not the same as my putting a down payment on a new car: they're two different activities that use the same fungible source as a medium of exchange. Likewise, if I run a business, paying a fixed wage to an employee is not the same as distributing profit in the form of dividends to shareholders: the fungible medium of exchange is weighted differently, comes from different sources, and is used for different purposes.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by welshwelsh on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:59AM (#33882158)
You're right, that wouldn't fix it.

Fixing the problem would mean that instead of the 'owner' hiring an 'employee,' they instead form an equal partnership as co-owners. Because the business serves the interest of the owners, it will seek to maximize their compensation as the ultimate goal, rather than to minimize their salary as a way of reducing expenses.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by varispeed on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @04:30PM (#33887336)
That would be illegal in my country. Dividend is considered an unearned income and is taxed differently as well.

They could perhaps give the worker a minimum wage and the rest pay in dividends, but mind that dividends need to be distributed among all the shareholders equally, so you can't say you would pay $100,000 unless you allocate shares so that when dividend pay out is decided, worker's shares will yield that exact amount.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by jmyeet on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:14AM (#33881300)
Are you familiar with "debt bondage"? Technically, the brick kiln workers of India and Pakistan are paid a wage [1]. Closer to home, Amazin warehouse workers probably wouldn't consider themselves as sharing in Amazon's profits. Let me summarize:

1. Debt is built into your existence (student, medical, housing, etc);

2. The system is designed to extract (exploit) value from labor; and

3. There is no value without labor.

[1]: https://www.antislavery.org/what-we-do/past-projects/india-d...

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by judge2020 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:21AM (#33881423)
What is your point? OP's comment was about how revenue - (other employees wages) = profit, not the actual details surrounding working for a wage.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by jmyeet on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:59AM (#33882166)
And that revenue wouldn’t exist without labor. That’s the point. So offering to “share” that in the form of mostly fixed wages both betrays a presumption of ownership and gives a false appearance of charity or benevolence.
Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by shadowfoxx on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:52AM (#33882021)
This is a fun semantic game but Profits are not the cost of doing business. When you have an employee sign a contract for $X dollars per year, that's a cost. Conflating Revenue and Profit for the sake of an argument is bad faith.

My Assumption here is that the common usage of profit is, "Money after all expenses paid", which employee compensation is clearly outside of that definition.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by lolinder on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:58AM (#33883252)
Don't assume bad faith: that their framing is unorthodox doesn't make it misleading.

Money is fungible and what we identify as "expenses" versus "profit shared" is arbitrary. Economic value is created by the enterprise, and that value is then split between the owner, the employees, the suppliers, and the customers.

We can argue about whether the distribution is fair, but complaining about the specific accounting method by which the value is distributed is myopic. Either you're getting a fair share of the economic value or you aren't—whether your share comes of the pre- or post-tax portion of the pie is the government's concern, not yours.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by shadowfoxx on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @02:16PM (#33885481)
I think people are largely arguing over whether or not the share of economic value is proportional to contributions and when they talk about that share they typically refer to profits. I think redefining/reframing what profit means in this conversation is intentionally misunderstanding/redirecting the argument.

Workers: "We should see more of the profits the company makes and we are making the case that collectively we produce a larger portion of the value we're asking for"

Poster: "Your pay is part of the profit, the more money you make the less that goes to the owner"

You're right. I shouldn't assume a framing is misleading just because its unorthodox, I'm attempting to make a case for the framing being misleading with supporting statements.

At best the parent comment isn't saying anything of substance at all (in response to ITS parent comment), and in my view, at worst its an attempt to redirect the concept of 'profit' to make the argument seem less credible.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by lolinder on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @02:44PM (#33885908)
I don't agree that jerrre isn't saying anything of substance. It could have been fleshed out better, but what they say is a reasonable counter to their parent's argument.

ceronman's thought experiment was "if you have employees, you have to share your profits ... If [they] don't produce any value, easy, fire them all, you get everything."

jerrre's response, which I think is fair, is that we're already running this experiment. If businesses did not think employees produce value, they would not pay them wages or salaries, because every dollar paid to an employee is a dollar less of profit for the company. Companies already acknowledge the value that employees create value by the very fact that they pay them anything.

In other words, what's actually at stake isn't whether employees create value but how much, and ceronman's comment doesn't contribute anything to that discussion.

Re:Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer ... by shadowfoxx on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @03:36PM (#33886651)
I disagree with your interpretation of ceronman's experiment and the premise that we're already conducting it.

I believe they were making the case that Employees need the company as much as the company needs the employees. The experiment is to split the profits evenly amongst those who created the value in the first place - The people that work inside the company. If they can't produce the value, get rid of them (And if that's the case there's more profit for everyone right?)

They could also mean that the profits are distributed amongst the employees based on individual contribution when they conclude that there wouldn't be any self-made billionaires because no single individual produces that much value.

I still disagree with the conflation of wages/cost of business and profits, even though more mages means less profit - Profit is still surplus after all has been paid. The distinction is important for more than just the scope of this conversation.