News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by sixtyfourbits on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:07PM (#33461558)
Fortunately someone had the foresight to make a backup:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32972923

Z-library were in it for commercial gain (you could access a certain number of books but to get more you had to pay for a subscription). They started out as a fork of library genesis, whose mission has always been strictly non-commercial and about providing free access to everyone without limits.

Hopefully this will encourage more people to go back to the original libgen. I suspect Z-library's popularity was because of a better interface and larger collection, but I think lots of people didn't realize libgen offers all its books/papers for free without limits.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by braingenious on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:31PM (#33461770)
Well damn, I guess I’ve gotta figure out how to get 30+TB of storage. Does anybody have any suggestions for doing that as cheaply as possible?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by tttttt5ts on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:35PM (#33461810)
Buy 3x 16 or 18 TB external harddrives on black Friday and shuck them. It is still going to run you $400-$500. Can't do it cheaper as far as I know.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by bl4ckneon on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:39PM (#33461840)
Yep I have done that before to make a 6 bay NAS. Gotta tape over a couple connectors on the sata connector but works great. Datahorders on reddit is a great sub for that sort of stuff. Guides as well as people posting when the deals happen for WD elements (external hdds)
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by mister_tee on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:30AM (#33462214)
not an argument but just an FYI for people reading about that idea for the first time: some NAS enclosures (QNAP, Synology?) and some power supplies can use the drives directly without disabling that 3.3V pin.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by zaarn on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:12AM (#33462799)
Most enterprise level stuff can (ie, anything that'll go into a rack, the expensive QNAPs/Synos, any supermicro I've encountered, etc.) handle the 3V3 pin issue just fine, in my experience.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by flaviut on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:39PM (#33461841)
Black Friday isn't always the best time: https://camelcamelcamel.com/product/B08KTRBHP1

But great advice and the route I've personally taken :)

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by tttttt5ts on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:44PM (#33461877)
Yep, just predictably has some deals. eBay can be a reasonable option too.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by flutas on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:03AM (#33463381)
Best source I've found is BestBuy with Easystore drives.

In fact they have 14TBs for $199.99 right now ($14.28/TB)

https://www.bestbuy.com/site/wd-easystore-14tb-external-usb-...

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by tuco86 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:42PM (#33461857)
big HDDs are getting cheap. just checked, 16 tb is only 260E by now
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 1ark on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:39PM (#33461837)
4-5 Bay hard drive enclosure (with RAID)?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by boardwaalk on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:44PM (#33461878)
RAID isn’t cool anymore. Maybe ZFS.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by fanick on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:57PM (#33462010)
With obvious limitations you could use backblaze. Back of the napkin calculation this will cost you only $150 per month in storage fees.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by crumpled on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:03AM (#33462047)
If you can't seed the whole collection, just seed a random portion. You can still cherry pick what you like.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by snvzz on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:36AM (#33462243)
IPFS would be a start.

Actually, aren't they already using that?

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by OmarAssadi on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:40AM (#33462275)
It'll depend on where you live and what your goals are. If you have free-time to tinker and enjoy that kind of thing, you can build something very fast and reliable and prevent e-waste by building your own storage server with used parts on the cheap.

If you're in the United States, electricity is cheap enough that you can pick up much older SAS drives for really low $/TB cost and have it be worthwhile.

For example, I bought a used Supermicro CSE-836 [1], which is like a 3U server chassis with 16 hot-swappable drive bays and a backplane of some sort.

The backplanes vary, but mine came with the BPN-SAS2-836EL1. I paid $300 in total for the chassis itself, backplane, dual power supplies, heatsinks, etc, along with a Supermicro X9DRi-LN4F+ [2] and two Xeon E5 2660 V2s as a bundle from someone in the 'ServeTheHome' classifieds section [3]. From there, I picked up a load of HGST 3TB 7200rpm SAS2 drives on eBay for about $10 each from a recycling company. And then 192GB of DDR3 ECC memory from the same place for about $80.

I also grabbed a couple less-than-production-ready 3.84TB U.2 NVMe drives on eBay for a little over $100 each.

I think if I were to do it again, I'd have gotten slightly larger, newer drives. These are all totally fine, but I started seeing ~6TB drives for about 3x the cost per terabyte, which would pay itself off quickly with the energy reduction. The other reason is that I ended up going a little overboard; I have about 56x3TB drives right now, which is a lot more than 16, so I needed to get a couple of JBOD expansions to put them in, each of which were like $250 -- if I had gotten fewer, larger drives, I'd have had another $500 to work with & be saving on energy.

Another thing I'd have done differently is get fewer but larger sticks of memory. I have a really nice amount of RAM right now, but the energy consumption with 24x8GB isn't worth the upfront savings compared to getting 16 or 32GB DIMMs.

All the storage is in OpenZFS on Linux. The 56x3TB drives are configured as 7 RAIDZ2 vdevs, so 2 drives each are for redundancy, and 6 for actual usable storage. This leaves me with a bit over 100TB of usable space. And the 3.84TB U.2 drives are mirrored and act as a "special" device (lol, literally what they are called) [4] to automatically store small blocks and ZFS metadata.

I am sure I could have done a bunch better, but, so far, everything has been lightning fast and reliable.

I am using ZFSBootMenu [5] as my bootloader. It's cool since it is basically a tiny Linux distro that lives in your EFI and comes with a recent version of ZFS, so you can store your entire OS, including your actual kernel and such in ZFS, and you can enable all sorts of ZFS features that GRUB doesn't support, etc.

This is nice because, since the entire OS is living in ZFS, when I take snapshots, it is always of a bootable, working state, and ZFSBootMenu lets me roll-back to a selected snapshot from within the bootloader.

The Supermicro board has a slot for a SATA DOM [6], which is sort of like the form fact of an SD card. I picked up the smallest, cheapest one I could on eBay for like $15 and use that to store my bootloader. I did this so that my tiny 128GB SSDs that I use for my OS could be given to ZFS directly for simplicity instead of having to carve out a small boot partition, etc.

All in all, I'm probably out about $1750 for >100TB usable, redundant, fast storage, and a decent bit of power for virtualization and whatever else. It costs me like $50ish a month in electricity because of all the drives and DIMMs. But I was already paying 65 euros a month for a 4x8TB server from LeaseWeb to use as a seedbox, and ran out of space, so it's been worth it, even with my dumb decision to use 3TB drives.

[1]: <https://www.supermicro.com/en/products/chassis/3u/836/sc836b...>

[2]: <https://www.supermicro.com/products/archive/motherboard/x9dr...>

[3]: <https://forums.servethehome.com/index.php?forums/for-sale-fo...>

[4]: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QI4SnKAP6cQ>

[5]: <https://zfsbootmenu.org>

[6]: <https://www.supermicro.com/products/nfo/SATADOM.cfm>

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:19AM (#33462514)
Can I ask what you pay per kWh?

Have you put a power meter on that setup? I've always wanted to do something like this but electricity here is AU$0.27/kWh, and my house is poorly oriented for solar panels unfortunately.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by OmarAssadi on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:42AM (#33462644)
It's a little under $0.12 per kWh here. I haven't gotten around to putting up a meter on it since fully completing it, but in the past, with a bit over half the drives + all of the ram and everything else, it was peaking a bit over 400w -- I'd guess like +- 700ish right now?

So, give or take, with a stupid build like mine, here, it's like .7 * 720 * $0.118 = ~$60.

Another thing to note is that mine stay spinning instead of idling for much lower energy consumption, cause I've always read that the stop-start cycle is what really tends to kill the drives.

I think it could be a lot more affordable/justifiable with:

- fewer, larger drives (6-8TB each?)

- fewer, larger DIMMs (16-32GB each?)

- perhaps slower, more energy-efficient drives (5400rpm?)

Also, I have seen some of the Atom C2750/C2758 boards for fairly cheap here.

If you don't need an absurd amount of RAM/PCIe/CPU, that could be a good option to save another bit of power.

> and my house is poorly oriented for solar panels unfortunately.

And yeah, same, unfortunately. Ironically, despite being in Florida, I barely get any sun; my entire neighborhood is filled with massive trees, lol.

I'd still like to look into solar at some point when I've got more time & money, though. It's been awful the past couple of hurricane seasons because of the trees -- something always seems to fall and cause a bunch of damage, so I'd like to cut down a few of the scary ones anyway (I am sorry trees!)

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by jvdvegt on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:50AM (#33465095)
0.772012=6000kWh for a whole year. My household of four uses 4000kWh...
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by E39M5S62 on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:02AM (#33462742)
I'm one of the two ZFSBootMenu authors - it's great seeing people using it in the wild.

I'm not sure if this is something you're doing already, but don't forget that if you zfs send a snapshot to your storage pool, you can boot from that snapshot in a pinch.

We also (this past week) added a modifier to zbm.prefer - !!. If you specify zbm.prefer=zroot!! on the KCL, it'll only import the zroot pool. This might help your boot times by skipping importing your 56 drive storage pool.

We should have a new release out in the next few weeks, otherwise that feature is in the master branch if you build your own EFI executable.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by OmarAssadi on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:58AM (#33463052)
Oh, interesting, cool! I appreciate the advice -- I am definitely not making use of all of the features.

And thanks for the software! I've been using it on all of my non-Apple devices for a while now. And my mom has been using it on their computer for a fair bit as well. It's been a total lifesaver on a couple of occasions and streamlined a lot.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by jrumbut on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:11AM (#33462792)
I really like your writeup and I like how you shared some lessons learned and other stuff that didn't quite work out. Buying hardware can be a real adventure and it's a skill that for some of us is underdeveloped.

I'd encourage you to write more of this technical content!

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by OmarAssadi on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:00AM (#33463062)
Thank you, really! Maybe I am just in a weird mood, but that made my day, as strange as it might sound.

I don't think people, in general, are anywhere near as vocal and explicit about the things they appreciate compared to the things they actively hate or that frustrate them. And I think this applies even more so in careers and hobbies like tech where people don't seem to think of the things you make as consumable or creative in the same way they do with others (e.g., movies, videos, music, and other art); my personal experience has been that if someone is reaching out, it's—more often than not—to let you know about an issue or complaint.

So, thanks, it felt nice! And thanks for the reminder; I should let others know the same more often too.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pdimitar on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:29AM (#33467299)
> And the 3.84TB U.2 drives are mirrored and act as a "special" device (lol, literally what they are called) [4] to automatically store small blocks and ZFS metadata.

Man, even enterprise servers, sold directly to data centers, max out these devices at 64 gigabytes. Many are offered with a pair of 32GB SLC old-school SSDs (for the extra durability).

Using 3.84TB for this is an enormous waste unless you host half the GitHub yourself and have specified "all files under this or that size go to the special devices".

Better make a torrent or book or comics mirror or something on this pair of huge SSDs. I use a pair of 32GB extra-durable (SLC) USB pen drives for special/metadata on a fairly decent ZFS dataset (~9TB) and they have something like 4MB of taken space...

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pilimi_anna on Thursday November 03, 2022 @11:48PM (#33461925)
Holy shit! Did not see this coming, but glad we saved this collection just in time. (I'm Anna, the one who made the backup).

We are working on hosting this collection, as well as saving other large collections. Please consider supporting us, donation details at http://pilimi.org (we'll set up a patreon-like system soon)

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by voldacar on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:41AM (#33462276)
How do you actually host something like this without being shut down, arrested, etc? Do you pay your server provider in bitcoin or something?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by eru on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:44AM (#33462651)
You could host your stuff via tor? And have people do most of the downloading via bittorent?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by harias on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:45AM (#33465640)
Yes and you host out of someplace like Russia where the US publishers can't get you.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pilimi_anna on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:04AM (#33462056)
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:28AM (#33462202)
Those domains are up, but downloading doesn't work right now, possibly because their CDN uses non-onion domain names. They're timing out.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by renonce on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:54AM (#33463024)
You can use z-lib for the index and download the files on libgen
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by terrycody on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:11PM (#33477458)
Z-lib has much more books than libgen, sadly
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by Normille on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:32AM (#33482418)
If you use Telegram, you can use the Zlib bot to search for and get books sent to you over Telegram:

https://t.me/firstlibrarybot

[Max size <50MB]

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:11PM (#33470216)
A work around for PDFs it to select "Open in Browser" from the download popup menu.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by SalimoS on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:58AM (#33482075)
Download is working for me
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by luiseduaguil on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:15AM (#33462129)
Paul
[dead]
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:57PM (#33469966)
Can confirm, but has a 20MB (per book) limit.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by terrycody on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:12PM (#33477466)
Sorry can you direct the how to method to us?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by lgoex11 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:12AM (#33464174)
They stopped being active.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:56PM (#33469949)
Still working for me.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pilimi_anna on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:09AM (#33462091)
The Library Genesis forum is also down, but more likely because of overwhelming interest right now? https://forum.mhut.org/
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by ijkxyz on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:38AM (#33462618)
Do you backup user accounts and bookmarks too?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pilimi_anna on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:47AM (#33462989)
Sadly not yet.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by MVf4l on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:05AM (#33462763)
Hi Anna, could you please confirm that your server and yourself are not under US jurisdiction?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pilimi_anna on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:47AM (#33462986)
I will make no claims about my identity one way or another. If you are worried for me, don't be. If you are worried for yourself, then please take actions in line with your risk tolerance.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by psychphysic on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:46AM (#33463304)
More likely they are worried about throwing their money away if the US now has a taste for takedowns.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by vanderZwan on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:48AM (#33464004)
Anna deserves/needs the support just as much if they have to deal with US takedowns though
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by psychphysic on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:55AM (#33481509)
I disagree the community should get behind the most viable mechanisms to achieve its goal.

Hosting in the US, by someone in the US is foolish if your goal is breaking US copyright laws.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by beanjuiceII on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:59AM (#33465837)
thats good because i've already forwarded this to my superiors
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by wholinator2 on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:00PM (#33470036)
Maybe a naive question but assuming this isn't a troll, I'm curious why?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by beanjuiceII on Monday November 07, 2022 @05:10PM (#33513268)
its not a troll, just my job, is your question why am i doing my job?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by areoform on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:19AM (#33462830)
Thank you so much for your efforts!

I have steadily become convinced that we should make a multi-billion year backup of all of humanity's knowledge. All of it.

Something that,

  - is resilient (can survive a nuclear explosion)

  - requires no power

  - doesn't require software to read/reboot from

  - (theoretically) lasts for at least 1 billion years
Copying from the Long Now Foundation's projects, I think we can achieve these goals by miniaturizing pages and etching them on some metallic surface (a titanium alloy), depositing a layer of some resilient transparent material onto this surface, and creating multiple copies.

A few copies for Earth. 2 or 3 for the Moon. And a few sent out of the solar system on probes like Voyager.

Some simple math, if the pages could fit inside of a 10mm x 10mm, then for a plate that's about the size of an average coffee table at 2' x 4', we could fit 7,432 pages.

Assuming that we have 50 billion pages, we'd need about 6.7 million such plates to fit all of human knowledge, so far.

It sounds crazy, but assuming we could get net costs per plate down to $500, each copy would be about $35M. Or, ~0.14% of an Uber. Alternatively, 0.002% of the F-35 program.

That's doable!

-

6.7 million plates will probably weigh a lot. So off-world copies might need to use an alternative encoding scheme.

Another problem is likely to be organization of the plates/copies. The hardest part might be putting it all together in a way that can be trivially decoded by human descendants, even if they don't speak our language or share our subspecies.

(apologies for any typos, it's very late at my end)

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by gilded-lilly on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:26AM (#33462864)
Why not encode them microscopically, using some kind of easily decipherable code?

The main issue would be loss of language. You’d end up with a gigantic Rosetta Stone of indecipherable gibberish.

Better would be to convert all literature into hieroglyphics, or graphic novels (or both), and then etch them microscopically.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by areoform on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:37AM (#33462936)
This size will have microscopic features! There is probably a balance between ease of scanning/technological sophistication required to see the pages, cost of etching, and the number of plates overall.

The Long Now Foundation has extensively studied the language loss problem and arrived at a fairly elegant set of solutions.

https://longnow.org/ideas/02022/01/20/linguistic-data-in-the...

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 6510 on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:08PM (#33470171)
Encode in dna and do roaches with random pages on their back.
[dead]
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by burnished on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:40AM (#33465578)
You'd want to select it special to be non-reactive, and even then limit or eliminate exposure to UV, oxygen, and temperature changes. Stone is also a changing material on this time scale and I think storage preference would largely be the same. I think one of the more salient differences is feature size; easier to make very small yet still legible images in metal than in stone.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by anyfoo on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:43AM (#33462967)
I think what you consider the hardest part, putting it together so that someone who does not speak any human language today deciphers it, is actually one of the least of your problems. Unless you deliberately encrypt the information (which you wouldn’t), I have a feeling that even Wikipedia alone might be sufficient for a motivated civilization to figure it out. Linguists and archeologists in our time have to do with far, far less, and they have reasonable success. Add in a few things like dictionaries, textbook, novels, and I have little doubt that it’s a big obstacle.

Rather I think you vastly underestimate what a billion years can do. The earth itself, and all that was on it, was formed a “few” billion years ago.

Our rivers alone have carved entire valleys into mountain ranges in much, much less time. I doubt a titanium alloy and some unspecified sort of super epoxy stand a chance.

And constant custody with regular restoration cannot be guaranteed for billions of years either.

That’s a massive problem for one plate (and its many copies) alone, more so for millions of unique plates…

The Long Now Foundation is only shooting for 10000 years, as far as I know.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by prox on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:46AM (#33463300)
Off world would help, no atmosphere on the moon for instance makes for less deterioration, and a cave system would shield it from radiation.

On earth clay tablets have done a great job : we have tablets 6000 years old, so we know that works. That’s 60% of 10k already. Titanium seems expensive and might be melted down in time of need, like bronze has been often in the past. Clay tablets survived partly because it’s a ‘worthless’ material.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by wikfwikf on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:37AM (#33463928)
It is 60% of 10k, and 0.0006% of a billion years.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by hanniabu on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:52AM (#33464036)
> On earth clay tablets have done a great job

The ones that survived

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by prox on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:13AM (#33465302)
Yeah, but they didn’t even try preserving it! Lots were found in average storerooms and so on.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by hanniabu on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:41PM (#33469624)
When there's a lot of things to start with, there's bound to be a lot of things to survive by chance even without preserving. A lot of the stuff that survived was accidentally preserved by nature.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by prox on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:52PM (#33471003)
You could say that, but I would point out to its resilience and suitability as a medium for long term information containment. Literally thousands upon thousands have been found. Imagine if one were to try make it last longer :)
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dredmorbius on Sunday November 06, 2022 @10:32AM (#33493649)
With some irony, tablets subjected to the usual destroyer of documents, fire, survive even better as they're vitrified.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by Kuinox on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:46AM (#33464518)
You need to bury it on the moon. There is a reason the moon is full of holes.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by GTP on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:49AM (#33465701)
But can you engrave them with the precision required for miniaturization?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by GTP on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:48AM (#33465679)
As for normal backups, maybe it is better to have a chain of medium term solutions for storage rather than aiming for a single long term one.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by perihelions on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:18AM (#33463152)
The nice part about this it's robust against humans too. Even if the whole world gets caught up in a zeitgeist about destroying books, they'll still be safely out of reach on silent probes floating in the outer solar system. Stagger the orbits so that one returns once a generation or so, and you've ensured that eventually civilization will regain its books, after the anti-book mania passes.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by adhesive_wombat on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:51AM (#33463321)
6.5 million plates at $500 each is 3 billion, not 35 million.

Just don't make them look gold (even if they're not solid gold), or they'll get looted and melted.

Though it would be fun if a murderous warlord ended up with a gotten crown made of the Wikipedia article for toilet paper orientation. [1]

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toilet_paper_orientation

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by wengo314 on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:34AM (#33463533)
i think it's a brave assumption that gold will forever be as valuable as now.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by hanniabu on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:54AM (#33464059)
Gold is a really useful material
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by sokoloff on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:31AM (#33464942)
It’s not that it would need to be as valuable forever but rather the opposite: that it be forever not looted.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by GTP on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:58AM (#33465832)
Indeed, it is a reasonable assumption that it will get more valuable over time, as it is a scarce resource.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by literalAardvark on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:57AM (#33467810)
Gold is extremely common in the solar system.

In the next few hundred years it's pretty likely that gold price will be marginal, as asteroid miners looking for less useless materials such as nickel, cobalt and platinum mine an excess.

So no, unless for some hidden reason asteroid mining doesn't work out, which is pretty unlikely given how badly the developed world needs that material.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by GTP on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:44AM (#33468573)
But wouldn't use such miners make the extraction cost higher?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by code_duck on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:45AM (#33468588)
Gold is quite useful as a corrosion-resistant conductor. If it wasn’t, cheaper metals would be used in its place in electronics.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by mixmastamyk on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:56AM (#33468760)
This thread reminds me of a Twilight Zone episode.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rip_Van_Winkle_Caper

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by areoform on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:31AM (#33466368)
Oops! I did a rough calc in my head but forgot to add in the two zeros. But it's still fairly "cheap." 0.14 Ubers (14%), or 0.002 Pentagon Monetary Black Holes (0.2% of the F-35 program)
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pmontra on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:27AM (#33463497)
> 6.7 million plates will probably weigh a lot. So off-world copies might need to use an alternative encoding scheme.

For the Moon and Mars, carve them into stone there. You'll have to defend against meteor strikes so they'll be carved and stored deep underground. No idea about seismic activity on those bodies.

For outer space, maybe it's pointless because finding, boarding, unloading an interstellar probe and sending the cargo back home is not easy unless you have very advanced interstellar ships. An orbit around the sun could be an easier place to spot. The Library of Ceres or the Library of the Troians?

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by akie on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:39AM (#33463950)
Not sure if serious or sarcasm.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by burnished on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:37AM (#33465555)
What about that seemed sarcastic? It read as a practical solution to an unlikely problem.

Orbiting the sun seems like a pretty stellar solution to the whole "keep something close and visible but safe without maintenance" problem.

Plus, think of how exciting it would be for a future civilization to discover that an object orbiting the sun was not a lump of rock!

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by krisoft on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:30AM (#33466346)
> they'll be carved and stored deep underground.

But of course you need some marker then on the ground so people know where to look for it later if they want to read the data. Maybe some artwork? A giant monolith perhaps?

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by ASalazarMX on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:01PM (#33468880)
A giant pyramid, they can last thousands of years even in our aggressive environment, much more in the weak Martian weather.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by krisoft on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:02PM (#33473713)
I love that. Should we dig in the Cydonia region on Mars? :)

Perhaps at the D&M pyramid?

https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/images/pia04745-the-cydonia-dm-pyra...

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by ASalazarMX on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:06PM (#33477005)
I'd start with the pyramid, but there's a risk of trying to dig up a regular mountain, which would be very wasteful. Maybe we should dig instead the Face of Mars after all, but who knows what other alien faces are there that we can't recognize? Let's dig everywhere!
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by askiiart on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:11AM (#33465277)
To be useful after such a long period of time, we'd also need to include materials on learning the languages.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by survirtual on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:53AM (#33465743)
Just use this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5D_optical_data_storage

5d is a bit dramatic but it is a femtosecond laser writing of quartz crystal that should, in theory, be stable for billions of years and can hold hundreds of terabytes.

Seems to be just what is needed.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by jl6 on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:05AM (#33466879)
Sadly it appears to be early-stage R&D vaporware.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by xerox13ster on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:21AM (#33467133)
It was early stage R&D vaproware in 2013 when I read about it the first time.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/data-saved-quartz...

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by survirtual on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:29AM (#33467294)
That’s a shame. I saw it earlier on Reddit and read the wikipedia article, seemed promising.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by literalAardvark on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:59AM (#33467846)
Microsoft's "Project Silica" is in early production.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by OOPMan on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:02AM (#33465892)
A multi-billion year backup is probably pointless.

The earth will be uninhabitable in that time frame due to changes in the atmosphere and beyond that the sun itself will complete it's lifecycle.

I know there's a big fad to "just believe" in a SF future that spans space and time but physical realities in this area are pretty rough.

I think the best thing people could do is realise that, eventually, everything ends and believing otherwise when it comes to the human race is much like believing in an afterlife.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by areoform on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:46AM (#33466603)
Our survival is not the point. It is an act of hope and the manifestation of our goodwill to the rest of the universe. There is nothing more valuable that we can offer to the Universe than our culture, history, knowledge, and the Earth's biological data.

Imagine if you were an alien species who somehow comes across this capsule hundreds of millions or billions of years from now. It's proof of sentient life elsewhere! But then you date the U-238 and realize that they're probably all dead...

But, they've left all of their civilization, culture, heritage, and knowledge behind. And you get to experience that, even recreate a tiny simulacrum of their world. And it gives you something, it's a tangible form of communication and cooperation across aeons.

-

In the short term, the backup is probably useful to have. Imagine if a collection is lost to fire or some other catastrophe, and one of the closer ones could be used to bring it back. Case in point, the fire at Notre-Dame. In 2015, Dr. Andrew Tallon, an art historian, painstakingly scanned all of Notre Dame, https://www.forbes.com/sites/trevornace/2019/04/16/we-have-b...

I think it's important to be honest. Would you have flagged his work as pointless in 2015? After all, the Cathedral has stood for centuries, been photographed so many times, what's the point of a 3D scan?

After 2019's fire, those scans became important (unsure to what degree) to the restoration effort. At some level, by capturing and preserving history, Andrew Tallon helped save history. And now it becomes a part of the story.

That's the goal. To engage in an act of optimism for the betterment of us and all of humanity.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by literalAardvark on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:40AM (#33467493)
An alien civilization knowing us just by an archived version of Horizon Worlds feels like a fate worse than death.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by knaekhoved on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:09PM (#33469030)
Doomer fatalism is nearly as dumb as sci-fi optimism. It's 100% physically plausible, using technology we have today, to make humanity star-faring. The costs would be exorbitant at this point, but within the reach of human productive capacity (assuming we're willing to ditch the partial nuclear test ban).
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by TheOtherHobbes on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:16PM (#33469149)
The costs are not the problem.

We can barely get to the Moon and have no realistic prospect of making a self-sustaining Mars colony any time soon.

How is it credible to claim we can build starships that can cross lightyears without technological or sociopolitical problems?

The engines - which we're nowhere close to creating - are the easy part.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by loup-vaillant on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:41PM (#33469617)
Getting to the moon only takes another JFK. We have the tech, we have the people, all we lack is the budget and a 5-10 year deadline. Also, another hard part is getting there safely enough. A 5% chance of dying out there is probably not acceptable nowadays. We probably need to go below 0.1% to attempt it again, and that's not trivial, especially with the possibility of solar flares beyond the magnetic protection of the Earth.

The real question is, is it worth making it a priority?

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by petre on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:38PM (#33470725)
> is it worth making it a priority

It will follow by itself once space mining kicks off. I'm sure Jeff Bezos would like to mine some asteroids.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by knaekhoved on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:33PM (#33469472)
I was responding to "physical realities in this area are pretty rough" - obviously there are other blockers
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 411111111111111 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:31AM (#33480794)
> It's 100% physically plausible, using technology we have today, to make humanity star-faring.

That kind of claim needs an actual source, because it's not.

The distances are so many orders of magnitude too high for any of today's technologies, making this a pure daydream.

The best we could plausibly do is travel within Sol, and that's not starfaring.

It would have to be a multi generational journey in which any refueling/restocking is impossible and any slip up would cause a full wipeout.

Starfaring is far beyond us... and that's unlikely to ever change for humans with a biological body.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by knaekhoved on Sunday November 06, 2022 @02:31PM (#33496153)
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:52PM (#33469858)
> The earth will be uninhabitable in that time frame due to changes in the atmosphere and beyond that the sun itself will complete its lifecycle.

At that point someone can just put it on a thumb drive and take it with.

It's not beyond the realm of possibility that people ultimately inhabit a spaceship that wanders the universe looking for a new home.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dniculescu on Monday November 07, 2022 @06:52AM (#33504666)
"It's not beyond the realm of possibility that people ultimately inhabit a spaceship that wanders the universe looking for a new home."

We are doing that right now.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by hacknewslogin on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:20AM (#33466190)
Instead of metal plates with a clear coat, maybe laser etching diamonds? a 5cm square of diamond can store 25 exabytes of data. They will weight less then metal as well. https://newatlas.com/electronics/2-inch-diamond-wafers-quant...
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pdimitar on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:06AM (#33466898)
Holy shit, this reminds me of the Jedi / Sith holocrons.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by Shared404 on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:39AM (#33467468)
Wouldn't that fail this requirement though?

> The hardest part might be putting it all together in a way that can be trivially decoded by human descendants, even if they don't speak our language or share our subspecies.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dredmorbius on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:29PM (#33469404)
Diamond can burn.

Though other crystals should be highly stable. Quartz seems geologically and chemically stable, plain old glass ain't bad. Something reasonably cheap is probably preferable, both from the cost basis (an expensive-to-create archive is a challenge) and the repurposing challenge (a diamond-etched bibliographic archive might have other appeals to those who chance across it).

Even parchment proved sufficiently valuable that works were often repurposed (and lost) through palimpsests.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by fsckboy on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:08PM (#33471303)
> a 5cm square of diamond can store 25 exabytes of data

isn't the same idea viable if applied to silicon crystals (which we already grow lots of)?

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 0xbadcafebee on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:57AM (#33467791)
> I have steadily become convinced that we should make a multi-billion year backup of all of humanity's knowledge. All of it.

And I'm over here hoping humanity extinguishes itself ASAP so the rest of life can thrive before we kill it all.

Intelligent life seems highly overrated.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pilimi_anna on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:18PM (#33474691)
https://archmission.org is doing something like this. It's a super cool project, and they work with the Long Now Foundation, the Internet Archive, etc.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by mvkg on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:33AM (#33462913)
You mirror Z-Library but don't support TLS on any of your sites. This seems like an odd choice. What is your threat model?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by primax on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:36AM (#33463255)
Probably 'I want to archive books'. Not 'I want end to end privacy for anyone clicking on my plain text site with a few torrent links.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by chaxor on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:51AM (#33466669)
TLS doesn't matter / isn't needed here right? The IP address is still in the header from what I understand. So the only thing https can hide is the content, such as a credit card or password that you enter into the site. The fact that it's a plaintext website that doesn't change means that the exact same information is encoded in simply giving the IP address as there is in knowing that someone looked around the site - because there's nothing else to do? I would like to learn more about how I am wrong, if I am wrong.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by cesarb on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:58AM (#33468820)
> So the only thing https can hide is the content, such as a credit card or password that you enter into the site.

TLS is not only for hiding the content, it's also for authentication: it ensures that no malicious middle party can modify the content, for instance to inject malicious Javascript (for an example of this happening, read about the "Great Cannon" attack on GitHub).

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by candreasen on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:52PM (#33486789)
It also hides what URLs you visited. Depending how the hosting is implemented, just being able to see the IP, or even the domain name, wouldn't show what you were doing, but if it's in plaintext, they can see exactly what pages were visited and files downloaded
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by elashri on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:53AM (#33463017)
Care to add HTTPS support also?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by IceWreck on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:01AM (#33463372)
Hey, why not push the collection (the extra books) back to libgen
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by giancarlostoro on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:08AM (#33464742)
This was my first question honestly and involves a lot less effort.

Additionally working on a UI for libgen that is far better as an open source project might be worthwhile.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by DoItToMe81 on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:08AM (#33467997)
If you're asking why Zlibrary didn't, it's because they got greedy and wanted to soak up donations that might go to Libgen by piggybacking off of their servers and having individual uploads for their own.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by joshxyz on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:09AM (#33463410)
thank you for your work
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by __jambo on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:41AM (#33465031)
thankyou!
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pelasaco on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:58AM (#33466769)
thank you for your work!

> Z-library were in it for commercial gain (you could access a certain number of books but to get more you had to pay for a subscription). They started out as a fork of library genesis, whose mission has always been strictly non-commercial and about providing free access to everyone without limits.

What is the difference between what "z-library" was doing, which was "you download a lot for free, but if you need more, just pay us, because no internet bandwith is for free" from donations? I always understood the subscription at z-library as support, not different than patreon...

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by pilimi_anna on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:42PM (#33471708)
The Author's Guild and the Association of American Publishers made some handy lists for people who need Z-Library alternatives!

https://www.regulations.gov/comment/USTR-2022-0010-0024 https://www.regulations.gov/comment/USTR-2022-0010-0015

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by terrycody on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:10PM (#33477450)
good job anna!
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by xwowsersx on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:28PM (#33486003)
Forgive me, but I'm unclear on how I access the collection. I can just go to the torrent files as listed here: http://pilimi.org/zlib-downloads.html ? Is there a mirror where I can search for a particular book?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by zozbot234 on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:31AM (#33462221)
I wonder if there's any worthwhile public domain content in that backup? E.g. stuff published prior to 1925, that's not otherwise findable on the usual services (Gutenberg, IA etc.)
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by robertwt7 on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:46AM (#33462309)
when I go to libgen though, link number 2/3 always point to zlib though.. am I on the right libgen? are they connected?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by bawolff on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:53AM (#33462365)
> Z-library were in it for commercial gain (you could access a certain number of books but to get more you had to pay for a subscription). They started out as a fork of library genesis, whose mission has always been strictly non-commercial and about providing free access to everyone without limits.

Ick.

I'm sympathetic to piracy, but the moment people start to make money off of pirated works it starts to feel much more wrong.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 1dry on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:55AM (#33462716)
Why are you sympathetic to piracy?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by wardedVibe on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:14AM (#33462812)
I just want a copy of the thing I paid for that I can use on whatever machine in whatever way I want without a bunch of bullshit hoops
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 1dry on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:33AM (#33462911)
Have you considered the implications that such a (minor) convenience to you, at scale has on the author/artist/musician being able to eek out a living from their work?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by wardedVibe on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:43AM (#33462968)
Oh I also buy a physical copy, especially if they're relatively obscure. I'm the kind of yahoo who also donates to artists patreons.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by primax on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:37AM (#33463259)
I don't accept that I need to purchase the same work several times for them to be able to eke out a living. Especially given the price of many books.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by joshxyz on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:13AM (#33463427)
i pirated mp3 files back then, is ed sheeran living under a bridge now?

if youre worried about artists and authors, you got no idea how much cut publishing houses and music labels take from them.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by rndgermandude on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:14AM (#33463784)
Artists - just like inventors etc - should be compensated for their work, but in my humble opinion not in what has become now essentially perpetuity.

So, an artist eeking out a living on something they worked hard on and released a month ago or two years ago gets sympathy from me. An artist who released a thing 20 years ago and still wants to eek out a living off that, such an artist doesn't really have my sympathy. The great-grandchildren who want to get paid for something an ancestor released 120 years ago[0]? Hell no, go do something yourself to make money.

If you're Lars Ulrich in 2000 and sue Napster over songs you released 10-20 years ago, while sitting on a net worth of maybe around 100-200M USD (now 350M), then my sympathy is with the pirates.

This doesn't touch the issue of how a lot of artists are not making much money, not because of pirates but because of predatory music labels and publishing houses.

It also ignores the problems with the "lost sales" theory. A lot of the pirates would have never paid for stuff they downloaded in the first place. And a lot of pirates started paying after pirating some stuff. E.g. I remember discovering a lot of artists from songs I illegally copied on LAN parties back in the day[1], usually artists too small to be on a lot of rotation on radio and MTV (yes, MTV used to have music, crazy) which I probably would have never known about otherwise. And I gave lots of money to these artists, buying their CDs, going to their concerts when possible, and so on. In the same vein, I discovered artists on whatcd and similar pirate places later on.

And doesn't touch on the "please take my money" issue... There are a lot of things that are out of print, etc, that you cannot pay for. E.g. large companies holding licenses to content may even take works out of print deliberately in tax avoiding schemes - I am not a Hollywood accountant, but from my limited understanding they can declare a loss when doing so which is worth a lot more in tax reduction than keeping a title in print.

And it also doesn't even touch humanity's need to preserve important cultural artifacts for the future.

[0] Remember, up to artists death + 70 years copyright term. While this exact scenario has probably not happened yet, as these rules are too new, you get a glimpse of what will happen in the future when you look about all the legal fighting still happening over Sherlock Holmes - a figure and body of worked created mostly before copyright law even existed.

[1] Yes, I am old. If you have no idea what a LAN party is, it's basically a bunch of people actually meeting in some venue with their computers, wire everything together into a temporary LAN, to play games and swap files, which back in the day really was the only sane way to do mulitplayer and filesharing stuff as internet speeds were so limited, and internet was usually very expensive, often still paying by the minute.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by christophilus on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:41AM (#33464464)
I only pirate things that I've already purchased. I generally purchase used things, so the artists don't see my dollars either way in that case. Furthermore, artists only see a small fraction of the dollars of any purchase you make. It'd be nice if all media was available inexpensively and without DRM for all to consume as they pleased, and if anything over the hosting costs went straight to the authors rather than through a byzantine old publishing apparatus. But we don't live in that world, so I do what I do.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by bheadmaster on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:31AM (#33462901)
Because digital copyright is artificial scarcity.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 1dry on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:39AM (#33462954)
What is wrong with that, especially as it facilitates the creator's being able to earn income from their irreplaceable work?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by bheadmaster on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:13AM (#33463121)
One could argue that the whole purpose of society is to get rid of scarcity.

Creators being unable to earn income is a problem - but artificial scarcity is not a good solution, as it benefits the few at the expense of many. Imagine if everyone was prohibited from sharing news over internet because "free distribution of news harms the journalists who rely on newspaper sales" - that'd be absurd, wouldn't it?

Old-school copyright relied on the natural scarcity of paper and other distribution resources - digital age has lowered the distribution cost to zero, so the old model does not work anymore. Another model of rewarding authors is needed, one that does not rely on restriction of distribution.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by psychphysic on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:45AM (#33463293)
> One could argue that the whole purpose of society is to get rid of scarcity.

BAM you just blew my mind at quarter to 8 on a Friday.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by noduerme on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:26AM (#33463486)
> One could argue that the whole purpose of society is to get rid of scarcity.

Scarcity of resources has nothing to do with scarcity of artistic works. Literature isn't fungible like a commodity, and can't be grown or mined as needed. It's also not a professional service or a form of labor. You can't put a gun to a farmer's head and make them write something brilliant, the way you can make them farm potatoes.

One could just as easily argue that society exists to organize labor in a way that increases specialization and efficiency. The reduction of scarcity is just a side effect. Specialization breeds scarcity in every new speciality until it becomes universally reproducible. Art is the forwardmost outcropping of specialization - it exists in advance of what it describes being known or understood - and by definition it is always the most scarce speciality. The artifice in making distribution of it remain difficult is therefore an extension of the natural place of scarce ideas in a world of abundant things.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by bheadmaster on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:38AM (#33463945)
> One could just as easily argue that society exists to organize labor in a way that increases specialization and efficiency. The reduction of scarcity is just a side effect.

If so, then what is the purpose of specialization and efficiency, if not for the reduction of scarcity, in terms of individual access to resources? If cooperation wasn't beneficial for the individual, nobody would cooperate (unless forced to do so, but I personally wouldn't want to live in such a society).

> The artifice in making distribution of it remain difficult is therefore an extension of the natural place of scarce ideas in a world of abundant things.

The whole idea of monetizing ideas the same way we monetize material things comes from their representation in scarce material things, such as paper. There's nothing "naturally scarce" about ideas - I'd argue the opposite, the ideas can be multiplied and shared at zero cost to the original author of the idea. The only cost comes from the way in which ideas are distributed. The golden age of music industry happened when the only way to distribute sound was either to perform a show (which was unscalable) or to buy a record (which was scalable) - producing a record was costly, but since there was no other way to listen to music at home, people paid. Companies charged more than production cost, and they made profit.

My whole argument is that treating manifestation of ideas as scarce things is an outdated view - in the digital age, all it takes to share an idea is a few button clicks. Trying to force scarcity will never work, and we need another way to reward the authors.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by noduerme on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:40PM (#33471682)
You're talking about distribution cost and ignoring the cost in time (and lost opportunity to do something else) to the writers or musicians.

The price of a record was never just the cost of pressing the record. CDs cost pennies to burn; paper and digital printing by the late 20th century were extremely cheap. The wholesale and retail prices always included pay for the artist (along with a raft of agents and corporations along for the ride). Spotify itself imposes artificial costs to distributing music, in the form of limits, prohibiting downloads, subscriptions and advertising. They do this to make money for themselves, but also to pay the artists.

As you say, distribution is now essentially free from a technical standpoint. There's no philosophical difference between Spotify charging 100x what it costs them to stream a song, and a record company charging 20x what it cost to press a CD. Free distribution would mean zero money for artists. We started by talking about piracy. By definition, with piracy the artist gets nothing.

Since no one can sustain an artistic career and produce writing or music over a long period without some sort of income, this means either all artists will have to be from the wealthy classes, have other means of support, and simply want to make art as a hobby, or else there has to be a distribution channel with an imposed toll of some kind that ultimately funnels them payment for their work. Whether subscription-based, or charging per-device for copy protected media, that will never be a perfect system, will never be free of piracy, and will always appear to the end consumer as an arbitrary restriction on free information.

I don't think scarcity of paper has been the limiting factor on price since at least the 18th Century. Since there is no scarcity of electrons, I don't view scarcity as a useful paradigm. The prices of locked downloads are simply representing the actual cost and market value of the work, which should be the same whether on the paper or in the aether.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by bheadmaster on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:48PM (#33475769)
Distribution costs are the reason why record labels earned so much money - it provided friction to piracy, since copying a vinyl was as expensive (if not more) than buying a new one. That friction is no longer there, and such a model cannot work anymore. Perhaps the age of "rock stars" collecting rent for years is simply over. Why should artists be rewarded indefinitely for just one piece of work? Perhaps the very expectations are inflated due to the previous golden age.

Artists should be rewarded for their work - but artificially limiting everyone's ability to share information is not the right way to do it. It would have severe consequences for the free society.

Another way must be found. I don't have any ideas, but I know that restriction of sharing information is not a good one.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by hdjjhhvvhga on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:00AM (#33462736)
Personally, I use libgen to check if I actually want a given book, and if I do, I buy it (a physical copy, if possible). So, for me, it's a kind of a virtual bookshop.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by 1dry on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:36AM (#33462924)
That's great of you to buy the book as well, major kudos. I would bet most are not as altruistic as you.

Do not traditional libraries and their ebook lending systems, however inconvenient, provide the same service? All one needs to do is be patient until the book you are interested in becomes available. In the meantime, maybe you can check out a different book that is available that you might not have discovered otherwise!

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by zolland on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:12AM (#33463118)
What is the difference between me waiting for a single book at my library to be passed between 5 people, and me just reading it online?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by beermonster on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:26AM (#33463205)
Presumably the library paid for their copy?

[Edit]

Also check out OverDrive / Libby

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by bheadmaster on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:58PM (#33475881)
The library would've paid for the copy regardless of whether or not the person actually borrowed the book - the act of borrowing itself makes no difference.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by nihilius on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:32AM (#33463521)
I do the same, i live in germany and wanted a book from UK, sadly it has 4-5 weeks delivery time but our vacation was a week away. So i downloaded the book, read it on our vacation and had the physical copy a few weeks later deliverd. Later i bought the book a second time when the german version released. With another book i bought for my wife and wanted to read at the same time, i downloaded it and we could both read it and talk about it simultaneously. Some other time i wanted to read a book at home with a physical copy and on my kindle during some time when i was outside in the garden. Cause in a hammock the kindle is easier to hold. Every time i had purchased the physical copy and the illegal download was just for convenience. No harm done.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dghlsakjg on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:16AM (#33462815)
The download limit was per day per ip address, and they would remove limits for active community members. I have a hard time believing they were doing anything more than paying for hosting bills.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by flyingsky on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:34AM (#33462918)
> [...] but the moment people start to make money off of pirated works it starts to feel much more wrong.

"Piracy" is expensive! Most people do not donate to support these things it's understandable if they decide to charge a few cents or bucks to keep the light on.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by acomjean on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:18AM (#33466161)
Are you suggesting people who pirate don’t want to pay?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dghlsakjg on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:13AM (#33462806)
I'm not so sure there was commercial intent.

Their policy was basically around discouraging datahoarders and scrapers as far as I could tell. If I recall correctly, the limit was something like 10 e-books per day per ip address. Not really a huge limit when you consider that there was no limit on file size for things like graphic novels. They never required accounts, and the only thing locked behind a required donation was compute intense tasks like conversion, and send-to-kindle.

The kind of bandwidth/storage that they had to be consuming is quite expensive and I don't blame the organizers for soliciting donations.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by yencabulator on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:31PM (#33474854)
> 10 e-books per day per ip address

That's a silly policy in a world of shared VPN endpoints and Tor exit nodes.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by meltedcapacitor on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:52PM (#33475815)
They used various dark pattern marketing techniques to try and convince people to pay and make the site look like a legit library, so clearly some commercial intent even if it was always possible to download for free (maybe to provide some deniability?).
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dghlsakjg on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:13PM (#33476049)
I disagree.

The only thing approaching a dark pattern is asking you to sign in for advanced features. A free account gets you a bunch of those features.

The main page has a single 'donate' link in the upper right corner. A contribution as low $1usd was enough to unlock all features except higher daily download limits.

What dark patterns did you see?

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by meltedcapacitor on Monday November 07, 2022 @06:50AM (#33504649)
- Making the service look like a legit library instead of clearly saying it's a repository of stolen books. Was confused myself for a while when I first stumbled on it, had to infer from it being too good to be true and doing some due diligence search.

- Various tricks to get the user to give an email (even if not necessary, similar to cookie boxes making "accept everything" very much easier than "only essentials".)

- After some time (download count or delay?) spam emails to try and get some payments out of the punter, again under false pretence.

Not saying it was bad value for money. Possibly not much worse than tricks average legal businesses employ. The point is someone sat down and devised that part of the UX with no other purpose than extract more money from users, by lying to them.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by dghlsakjg on Monday November 07, 2022 @10:35PM (#33515626)
Fair enough.

It never occurred to me that people wouldn’t realize that it was a piracy site, and not a “library”. I guess I’m just too tuned into the internet. Haha

I see your point now. It’s sort of disappointing that I'm so used to even worse dark patterns on legit sites that I don’t really see this as dark.

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by lgoex11 on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:57AM (#33464081)
Z-library has books that Libgen doesn't have... I tested them.
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by roel_v on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:04AM (#33464126)
0 seeders on the few torrents I checked though. I mean, can't blame people for not seeding 350GB+ torrents, but still - if there aren't any seeders, what good are the torrents?
Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by golem14 on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:02PM (#33472008)
[this is not legal advice]

Practically speaking, if you are in the US, you could download stuff from zlib and get away with it - I believe that's not illegal. Hosting on the other hand is.

Using torrents to download is legally also hosting, albeit some random parts of what you are downloading yourself. So to stay legal in the US, you can't really use torrents.

Maybe some enterprising person in Russia or China can become a reseller of hard drives and preload them with chunks of libgen ?

I mean, it's sad that the greatest country on earth has a sneakernet gap with Cuba [1]! ;)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Paquete_Semanal

Re:ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Po... by nephanth on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:58AM (#33478406)
I thought only the domain name was seized though ? Couldn't one make a backup now bu connecting using ip address, or an alternatie DNS server