It’s also important to remember that rent stabilization is not rent control - landlords are free to raise the rent by an amount set annually by a board of landlord and tenant representatives. As a practical matter, that means that the rent increases track closely to inflation and consumer prices.
What it protects isn’t rising rent, it protects tenants from landlords jacking up the rent to kick them out, and then lowering it back again to get tenants of a different age or ethnicity, or saddling tenants with the risk that if they advocate for their rights as tenants that their lease may not be renewed next year.
It’s easy to say “price controls don’t work” while ignoring that the landlord / tenant relationship is so skewed from a power dynamic that there needs to be some sort of protection from abuse.
Landlords abusing tenants is totally irrelevant because rent control doesn't address that problem at all, it just shifts that abuse to new tenants for the benefit of long term residents, since the entire policy is a wealth transfer to people who never move from where they live.
As both the article and the GP pointed out, rent stabilization does allow for rents to increase.
Are you trying to say they aren't allowed to increase enough, or are you under the impression they don't rise at all?
In any case, the exact same economic phenomena has been observed regardless of if you fix rent increases to inflation or never allow for rents to increase, because the two approaches are just incredibly similar variants of price controls.
Without rent stabilization, landlords can and do raise rents arbitrarily to drive our particular renters and then offer better rents to preferred renters. Or equally likely drive out a family to subdivide an apartment into multiple rooms to rent.
If you pass laws that say, for example, you have to offer a renewal to an existing tenant, that doesn’t help, they’ll just play the same game with the rent. Mandate that the same rent has to be offered to new and existing? Well now we are in the realm of price controls.
The power dynamic is so massive between landlords and tenants, especially for people who aren’t fortunate enough to have disposable income, that there needs to be some sort of protection.
This is positing that landlords engage in complicated schemes to lower the rent they are paid. I speak with supreme confidence, the median landlord is not going to do that unless these 'preferred renters' are measurably better than the people getting kicked out, in ways that make objective sense. Frankly, if a landlord is engaging in this practice then they probably aren't a 'landlord', they've just taken the property out of the rental market so their kids can live there or something.
> ...drive out a family to subdivide an apartment into multiple rooms to rent.
A landlord is much more likely to do that, but the complaint here is that there are people willing to value the m2 of the apartment higher than the family. There is no way to block that from happening without price controls and, eventually, shortages emerging.
The landlords in the article are greedy, they don't want their apartments to be empty. They want to be renting them out for whatever the most willing renter is going to give them. But they also aren't stupid, and they aren't going to rent them out anticipating that they will make losses.
That’s all well and good but that isn’t the issue. Part of the contract for renting an apartment in NYC is that you must offer renewals. A lease is a contract that, unless there’s an eviction, only the tenant can end. And allowing landlords to violate the spirit of the law by saying “we didn’t kick them out we only raised the rent to $10k/mo” defeats the whole purpose of it which is to not rip housing out from underneath people.
But it is going to be mighty difficult to take people who take up the landlord side of that deal. And things like, say, 60k rent controlled apartments sitting empty seems like a reasonable outcome - y'know, might have to be an idiot to rent out an apartment for a deal that bad. It sounds ruinous. Sounds like a bad law, really.
I'll also point out that despite the fact that rent stabilization isn't required for new rental construction, there are a few areas in nyc where the city offered incentives in the form of property tax abatements in exchange for the landlords agreeing to rent stabilization - what do you think happened? Almost all of the new construction in those areas agreed to being rent stabilized. If it was so bad, so ruinous, why would they agree to that?
The story here isn't "rent stabilization is bad", it's "landlords are having a hissy fit that they can't exploit their tenants as much as before, so they're keeping apartments off the market on the off chance they win a court case"
And no-one is getting tricked here, it seems pretty obvious what is going on.
> The story here isn't "rent stabilization is bad", it's "landlords are having a hissy fit that they can't exploit their tenants as much as before, so they're keeping apartments off the market on the off chance they win a court case"
What do you think the symptoms would be if rent stabilisation was bad?
Bad for whom? Tenants? Landlords?
If landlords of rent stabilized buildings were declaring bankruptcy and the city had to take over and operate the buildings, that would be a clear sign that the economics of rent stabilization made it impossible for the free market to work.
Except that hasn’t happened, in fact, being a landlord is still so lucrative that they can afford to keep units off the market in the event of the small chance that the laws get changed in the next year.
I can guarantee you that once the court case is settled, those units will gradually come back on the market and everything will go back to the way it was.
I can imagine other creative ways to achieve the goal. However, I'm having difficulty wraping my head around your scenario.
The landlord decides they want an 18 year old Liliputian, but accidentally rents it to an 85 year old Belfuscian instead? Later, they realize their error, and temporarily jack the price up to kick out the Belfuscian they were totally fine renting it to earlier?
Isn't it more likely that, instead of suddenly becoming racist/ageist, the landlord is trying to get rid of them for some reason that became apparent after they signed the lease (late payments, noise, illegal activity, etc...)?
There are a few scenarios:
- landlord rents to belfuscian because that’s the market. Then a Lilliputian makes a popular tv show that depicts the neighborhood as cool and affordable. Landlord starts getting interest, so they force out the belfuscian so they can get the Lilliputians.
- landlord just wants to run a building and make a living. They get an offer too good to pass up and sell the building. New owner plans to make the money back by forcing our existing tenants and jacking the rent.
- the tenant believes that they have a right to an apartment without roaches and mice. The landlord feels like that’s not reasonable because it’s NYC, and there are roaches and mice. The landlord decides to get rid of these tenants and hope to raise the rent.
And yes, sure, there are bad tenants who landlords want to kick out. But let’s talk about who is more likely to end up in a bad situation- the low income tenant trying to get by, or the landlord who owns a building they want to maximize revenue from?
Around here, most bigger buildings are corporate-owned (equally good or terrible to all), or small enough where loopholes allow everyone to be evicted at sale.
The landlord is the property owner. Yes, they can kick renters out of their house after the lease, a contractual agreement to temporarily live in it, has expired. As long as the renter signed the contract, understood the terms, and wasn’t under duress that should be the end of it.
When someone otherwise takes something that doesn’t belong to them (In this case, someone’s house) that’s called stealing. When the government enables people to steal you get a bunch of weird market dynamics that reduce the supply of affordable housing.
You cannot end run around the law by trying to be “clever” and technically offering a lease renewal of 10 billion dollars a month. The world doesn’t work by programmer logic.
It’s not rent control, but someone else is, ah, controlling how much I can charge for the building I paid for.
?
Stabilization requires control.
Forcing X to do Y against their will requires control.
Argue for rent control if you want but your pissing on my leg and telling me it's raining.
“Rent control” in NYC is a specific term that applies to a separate set of regulations and laws that govern a particular set of rental properties. Tenants who live in these properties are effectively immune from rent increases for as long as they or their families live in the apartment.
Of course rent stabilization is a form of rent control, but it is not the same as Rent Control in NYC. In online discussions about NYC rental law, the two things often get conflated, as they have at several points in this thread.
Rent control is where both the initial rent price, and the increases are controlled.
We're in a technical forum, so it's reasonable to actually differentiate terms we're discussing.
> Few things have been proven as resoundingly as "price controls don't work", or more accurately "are very net negative".
I don't see how this follows. NYC has had rent stabilization for over 50 years, and the story here is: "the number of rent-stabilized homes reported vacant on annual apartment registrations rose to over 61,000 in 2021 — nearly doubling from less than 34,000 in just a year as the city emerged from COVID lockdown."
In other words, a very recent problem.
If price controls don't work, then wouldn't they have failed in the year 1971 rather than the year 2021?
Only Black Swan data applies.
> Altogether, the state numbers show a loss of over 95,000 stabilized apartments for rent after 2019 — the year a major overhaul in Albany of the state’s rent laws blocked landlords from significantly jacking up rents on vacant units when letting them to new tenants.
Artificially lowering prices is a good way to lower supply of housing, if that's what you're going for. Since people generally aren't interesting in lowering supply of housing and making the market less efficient, it's not a good approach.
The other thing rent control specifically does is give you are larger incentive to live where you've already been living, so if everybody did it, everybody would figure out it was irrational to ever move from the first home they ever rented. This doesn't actually stop "gentrification", it merely slows it, by simply making it hard to move to a new home in general. It also makes the existing residents more wealthy than newcomers, and the existing residents don't consider themselves the "Gentry" no matter how valuable the NY real estate they sit on is.
I feel there is a huge mismatch between what rent control actually does and what people are trying to accomplish by implementing it.
Real world free markets consistently fail to reflect the cost of externalities such as the effect of only rich people being able to afford housing in a wide area.
Rent controlling privately owned real estate does not work and has never worked. It literally just doesn't do what is claimed. It mostly repeatedly crops up generally because of how politics is structured means long term residents have a lot of clout to propose policies that benefit themselves while spinning BS about how rent control ends homelessness.
If you want the right to live in a specific area with specific amenities, well you can't always get what you want. The reality of resource scarcity and power differentials always crops up somewhere.
There's a lot of vilifying of landlords here. I was a landlord for a while because I wasn't ready to move. That got me my two first and only legal cases (one settled, one won but never collected $10k owed because the con artist skipped country). The insane level of stress got me out of that and I was lucky because only months later, all landlords got left holding the bag with the covid non-eviction mandate which meant renters could just stop paying rent. I'll never ever rent anything out again.
If people could build a house to rent out at a reasonable profit (and if the planning commission let them do so), then they'd build new housing. It's not like there's a capital shortage in NYC or SF, or new houses are some magic unproven technology.
The increased supply of modern units would create a downward pressure on old unit pricing, and therefore the rents paid by blue collar workers. This would decrease the price of construction to something vaguely approaching national norms.
Rent control (and, at least in California, insane codes) breaks this loop, so we have a situation where there is a shortage of housing, housing is completely unaffordable, and building new housing is unprofitable. (Also, the cost of construction has been completely decoupled from the price of materials. In most places, material costs are most of the budget!)
If landlords are being abusive, we should update regulations to suitably punish them for that abuse.
If landlords are keeping rentals empty, we should add an onerous tax on empty housing
A. Evil landlords meet at their secret underground fortress and collectively agree to charge too much for rent
B. Evil rich people / foreigners (pick whichever you find more objectionable) have bought up all the housing and are keeping the units vacant to spite everyone
Supply and demand doesn't apply to housing, of course. If we build more housing that will just drive prices up! Somehow!
I've certainly been told by a corporate landlord "we checked nearby rentals, and decided that we should match their rent increases" so I guess A is the proper option?
The article says B is also true, and the evil landlords are aiming to coerce policy change by making people homeless
There's your "somehow". Being intentionally obtuse just makes you look stupid at best.
There's no more choice in using roads than there is to live somewhere.
Well, induced demand is a popular theory in other areas, so... maybe?
Building lots and lots of housing will never induce more per capita housing use in the same way that better roads induce longer per capital commutes.
Because the fundamental concept of induced demand doesn’t really track with the concept of having a place to live. You need a place to live, you don’t start using more “place to live” because there are more of them.
It can only happen at the fringes — fewer shared leases, more people with 2nd homes. The vast majority will still have one place to live for their family.
Population mobility to desirable neighborhoods is also not “induced demand”.
Likewise, when we (Americans at least) talk about housing shortages, we don’t mean the USA as a whole, it’s just a few cities that everyone wants to live in, not say small towns in the Midwest or Deep South. So a lot of demand and is already suppressed because not everyone can live in those few hot places.
Whether these actions work or not, it is not immoral to attempt them.
There is no 'human right to profit at the expense of others'.
It takes quite distorted incentives for the obvious course of action to be (1) build a house => (2) leave it empty. For that to make economic sense for more than maybe 12 months, the government has to have really come in swinging with crazy policies.
The discomfort you experience of having to let your bought-for-the-purposes-of-renting properties is less important to me than the discomfort of the person you're evicting.
You want to be a landlord? Comply with tenant laws. If you don't like it, you won't be missed, it's not like you can leave and take that apartment with you.
In China, rental returns are so paltry compared to purchase prices that many property speculators simply don’t rent out their properties (renovating a property reduces its value in that market, so leaving it unfinished is a winning strategy). That has nothing to do with regulation and everything to do with an out of control property bubble, but the same principle applies. Here in Seattle, being a landlord is an increasingly untenable position, especially for private individuals. They are instead in it just for the appreciation (property bubble again) and so it makes sense for them to just leave the house vacant and keep squatters away.
When that happens, you don't give up trying to regulate - you regulate them further.
Clearly they need a LVT or tax on empty living space to make them play ball.
Rent controls are essentially the only thing that has ever worked for cheaper rent.
Yeah we need to send Vinny and Sal over there to get those assholes to play ball. Whose city do they think this is! /s
The mafia and the government operate on the same concepts. Coercion and violence to take your property.
> Consider the following hypothetical example:
>> Trespass: George is walking across a field when David jumps out from behind a bush, grabs him, and gently but forcefully removes him from the area.
> In this example, it certainly looks as though David is the one committing an act of aggression against George. After all, George is simply walking along, minding his own business, when David comes from out of nowhere, physically lays hands on him, and drags him off the field.
> But suppose that the field in this example is David’s property, and that George is knowingly trespassing across it. In that case it is clear that most libertarians would say that it is actually George who has committed aggression. David’s violence, they would say, is simply an appropriate response to George’s impermissible intrusion upon his land.
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/social-philosophy-an...
Libertarians oppose expropriation and eminent domain because the government is the one initiating the aggression against the property owner by forcible seizure. (Although libertarians support limiting the power of the state, it is not the same thing as eliminating the state entirely. That would be anarchism, not libertarianism.)
The state works because they have a monopoly on violence and imprisonment. As long as they operate for general good and operate via a strict system of laws which prevents abuses and maintains rights, then that is a good thing.
Making my neighbor stop dumping waste into my drinking water (which I don't own at the point they are dumping in) by having to come up with enough money to buy them out and shut them down is not viable.
If they own that part of the river, they are dumping it on their property. This is the definition of an externality.
When you said:
> The state works because they have a monopoly on violence and imprisonment. As long as they operate for general good and operate via a strict system of laws which prevents abuses and maintains rights, then that is a good thing.
did you think that most libertarians would disagree? The status quo is that the state has a role in protecting human and property rights, and in regulating public and common goods. No pragmatic libertarian would suggest removing the state from these roles without finding a suitable replacement.
If you believe that a state should exist and should protect human rights, even so far as to use their monopoly on violence to shut down a private property holder who is causing damage to property owners no where near them based on economic externalities such as providing markets for endangered species parts, then what is the difference between a 'statist' and a 'pragmatic libertarian'?
Because most libertarians are not anarchists, and because statism encompasses all sizes of governments, statism can be compatible with libertarianism. However, people who want to abolish government altogether cannot be statists, and people who support government expansion to an excessive and unnecessary extent cannot be libertarians.
The problems I have with libertarianism are around these issues and your handwaving of them, and this is compounded by the fact that you haven't defined what libertarianism actually is, besides that it is 'not anarchy'.
Have you really thought about these things, or do you just find the idea of self-sufficiency and absolute personal freedom enticing?
Since the status quo is that public lands are regulated by the state, the state will sue people who illegally poach endangered species within its jurisdiction. However, if another state allows the poaching of the same endangered species within its jurisdiction, a libertarian approach in the first state would allow for animal parts to be imported from the second state and sold within the first state.
A comprehensive definition from Wikipedia:
> Libertarians seek to maximize autonomy and political freedom, and minimize the state's encroachment on and violations of individual liberties; emphasizing pluralism, cosmopolitanism, cooperation, civil and political rights, bodily autonomy, free association, free trade, freedom of expression, freedom of choice, freedom of movement, individualism and voluntary association. Libertarians are often skeptical of or opposed to authority, state power, warfare, militarism and nationalism, but some libertarians diverge on the scope of their opposition to existing economic and political systems.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarianism
You seem to be painting all libertarians as a homogeneous extremist bloc, which is just as fallacious as ascribing minority hardline stances to "all liberals" or "all conservatives". The above describes general concepts that libertarians support, and absolutes such as "absolute personal freedom" are ideologies that pragmatists recognize as infeasible.
No, libertarians are not like 'liberals' or 'conservatives', they are libertarians, and they believe in an absolutely minimal amount of state intervention. Have you talked to any before? It seems like you read a few books and have some notion of some kind of libertarianism which is not at all what is advocated for by real life 'libertarians'. There is a 'Libertarian' party in the USA and they have candidates and an agenda. You may believe one thing, and call other people's views 'fallacious' but those views are based very much on Libertarianism as represented by Libertarians.
Here are some candidates for the Libertarian party.
Since the first-past-the-post voting system used in most U.S. states makes it difficult for third parties to gain traction, most politicians who prioritize winning elections run under one of the two major parties. A libertarian candidate who focuses on reducing taxes is more likely to become elected on the Republican ticket than the Libertarian ticket. A libertarian candidate who prioritizes legalizing marijuana will stand a better chance on the Democratic ticket than the Libertarian ticket. The goal is to push for changes that would advance the libertarian agenda on specific issues while maintaining the status quo party line on other issues, since it is easier to enact targeted changes than to fight on all fronts. Political candidates who choose to be affiliated with the Libertarian Party need to be sufficiently radical to reject the two dominant platforms that are much more likely to win them elections.
Voters know that third parties including the Libertarian Party are disadvantaged in U.S. elections, and in races that Libertarian Party candidates are certain to lose or do not participate in, many libertarian voters select the candidate from one of the two major parties that they believe would do the best job advancing or preserving the parts of the libertarian philosophy that they prioritize. This is the most effective short-term voting strategy when voter prefers one of the major party candidates more than the others. In the long term, libertarians in the U.S. support ranked choice voting and other reforms that would empower third parties like the Libertarian Party. If the Libertarian Party does manage to gain traction, its platform would adapt to become more moderate, mainstream, and pluralistic to accommodate its larger voter base and encompass more of the libertarian philosophy.
There aren't many surveys that focus on libertarians, but this 2014 one from the Pew Research Center shows that self-described libertarians tend to be more diverse and less radical than you perceive them to be:
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/08/25/in-search-o...
> Self-described libertarians tend to be modestly more supportive of some libertarian positions, but few of them hold consistent libertarian opinions on the role of government, foreign policy and social issues.
...
> None of the seven groups identified by the 2014 political typology closely resembled libertarians, and, in fact, self-described libertarians can be found in all seven. Their largest representation is among the group we call Business Conservatives...However, they are also supportive of an activist foreign policy and do not have a libertarian profile on issues of civil liberties.
Libertarian's as described in that survey (and as you probably are as well) are 'Republicans who like smoking weed and don't have a problem with homosexuals'.
Your perception of what libertarians believe in is more closely attuned to anarcho-capitalism, which is a radical subset of libertarianism. Most libertarians are not anarcho-capitalists. I described your comments as fallacious because you are attacking libertarianism using arguments directed at anarcho-capitalism (straw man).
I have never described my political affiliation here, so please don't make assumptions. The Pew Research survey says that 12% of Republicans, 6% of Democrats, and 14% of independents describe themselves as libertarians, so it is not reasonable to label all libertarians in that survey as Republicans.
At this point in time it is clear you are not going to change your mind on this -- and as long as you continue to claimn that I am wrong and fallacious for making assumptions about libertarian political ideas based on my direct experience with people espousing them, then I am afraid we are at an impasse.
Radicals tend to be louder than moderates, but judging an entire demographic based on the opinions of its most radical subset is not going to yield a realistic picture of the demographic. If you only consider people libertarians if they pass a purity test that requires them to subscribe to radical beliefs such as the complete abolition of the state, then the resulting group of people will be radical and non-representative of libertarians as a whole.
> convincing people how reasonable you can be instead of distancing yourself from the crazies
Again, I did not express any political ideology. When I saw you making comments conflating libertarianism with anarcho-capitalism, I explained the difference and brought in evidence to show that self-described libertarians generally do not hold the radical views that you believe they do. Equating libertarianism to anarcho-capitalism makes as much sense as conservatives equating progressivism to antifa and warning of a far-left takeover.
It doesn't account for massive differences in power, there's nothing in libertarian philosophy which takes into account that a multi-trillion dollar corporation will, always, have absurdly more power than any citizen or small collection of citizens.
Suing someone/something is not a magic bullet, in your utopian libertarian world you'd have to pay lawyers for that. You'd require lawyers that want to work with you instead of large corporations, corporations which would be free to blacklist any lawyer working against them to work for them. Not taking into account that these corporations can just slowly dial up the inconvenience to communities they'd like to push out, are you gonna sue them multiple times? What exactly do you expect that your powerless minimal government be able to do if you win a trial against such actors, to fine them? If they can just pay the fine, over and over, and they calculate those fines are just a cost of business that will be paid off by ROI, is that ok? Or do you expect the government to take action and shutdown a company that's constantly breaking the law?
I simply cannot understand why you really believe that suing a massively more overpowering force in a libertarian world is achievable, not only achievable but required to keep a balance of... Power.
It's absurd.
Libertarian world = no control of the government over any aspect of the economy, no public ownership, only private property is a right, everything is negotiated through contracts between private parties in society.
Authoritarian = almost total to total control of society by the government. Economy, customs, culture, speech. No dissent to the official government line of policies is tolerated, the people are completely controlled and submissive to the whims of the leadership. Decision-making is reserved to the political elites and the people have no voice in the process of it.
One is an economic-political philosophy, the other is a political system of control, not sure why you want to compare both.
When people say things such as "Libertarians don't account for externalities" and use a caricature of a "libertarian utopia" to attack libertarianism at large, it pigeonholes libertarians as extremists, and does not paint a realistic picture of how libertarianism actually influences politics every day.
I'm aware that Libertarianism as a philosophy has much broader branches of it, that it includes by definition concepts of freedoms and autonomy. Unfortunately most of the interactions I have with self-identified libertarians (both in Sweden and in Brazil) go towards extremism. As much as most of the philosophies under the umbrella of Libertarianism aren't that extreme that's what I see in public discourse, it's a caricature.
Libertarian thinking is also responsible for inspiring trickle-down economics, free market privatisations across the board and so on. These policies have been, at least, a mixed bag of results with plenty of it being failures (e.g trickle-down and privatisation of healthcare/education). We know, empirically, what the consequences of purely libertarian policies such as the ones brought by neoliberalism can be: monopoly/monopsony formations (i.e corporations mergers), empowerment of elites, diminished power of labour and so on.
Libertarianism defers too much power to private individuals, without much regard to the power imbalances that will arise from its philosophy, just trusting that certain mechanisms will balance it all out. That's my main reservation with the philosophy as a whole.
Is it your contention that people are misrepresenting libertarianism as extremist out of ignorance or malice?
Do you think that is unreasonable to view libertarianism as extreme because people who are 'real' libertarians are forced to run as Republicans, and because in the future the libertarian party is going to become more moderate and reasonable?
I am trying to understand why you expect people to have a nuanced view of a political group that does not present itself as such, because you feel that it should or will be something else.
In the U.S., self-described libertarians as a whole do not hold the views that you assume they hold. When 11% of people in the U.S. describe themselves as libertarians and correctly identify the term per Pew Research's definition ("someone whose political views emphasize individual freedom by limiting the role of government"), yet only 1.2% of U.S. voters chose the Libertarian Party ticket in the 2020 U.S. presidential election despite a 66.8% turnout rate,* you are not accounting for most libertarians in the U.S. when you limit your awareness of libertarianism to what is presented in the Libertarian Party platform.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_United_States_presidentia...
Money is the property of the state that prints it. Land likewise. You're leasing at best.
Real estate, as far as markets go, is exceptionally prone to profiteering via reduced supply. It’s unlikely that these 60k units would be unprofitable for their owners; the owners have simply determined that they’re not profitable enough.
Applying this to healthcare, does it hold? Socialised healthcare appears to be less expensive.
I might be missing your point though…
> Suppliers and owners will not simply accept lower prices, even if you really wish they did.
This isn’t always true. It probably devolves into a discussion on monopsony behaviour which become relevant at a certain point.
And to a lesser extent, I bet it can be marginally cheaper because of a reduction in redundant administration costs across multiple providers. But that, and all other of those facets are dwarfed by the single payer negotiating.
A surgery enthusiast startup for cardiac surgery or a garage side hustle pharmaceutical dispensary do not sound like a good idea.
Yes, regulation costs, and a lot of that is reasonable.
I want trained staff, calibrated machinery, audited processes and tested drugs.
https://www.amazon.com/Forty-Centuries-Wage-Price-Controls/d...
It is a solution - "Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable."
The colonists certainly didn't pay the natives for their land, and the revolutionaries sure didn't pay Britain to take ownership
When land isn't being used effectively, it's moved to another owner with limited to no compensation
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Edit: it looks like you've been posting unsubstantive and/or flamewar comments repeatedly. Would you please stop? We ban that sort of account. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for.
If the government is forcing rents to remain under inflation, eventually something will break.
I regularly see these takes hn and I don't get what's so assholeish about my situation. I know that my tenant is on a temporary visa. Are we arguing that ethically he should have bought my property?
Developer buys land. Spends all their money to build a house.
Investor comes along and buys the house to rent it out.
Developer now has money to build another house (and other developers notice that they can build houses and get paid to do so).
Without the investor money, developers build a lot fewer houses.Like, literally, if there were no landlords, by definition there would be no rental properties. So people who couldn't afford to buy a house outright would have nowhere to live. That can't be what you're advocating?
Are you really so ideologically brainwashed that you're incapable of imagining any other system that doesn't inherently exploit poor people and concentrates cash at the top???
Secondarily, since tradespeople tend to like food with their meals, landlords paying tradespeople is an important motivation for them to do that work.
I have just given up trying to be nice about this, despite HN's capitalist slant
That argument can literally be applied to any product or service, yet here we are.
There is a peculiar correlation I have noticed with these views - it tends to be (white) upper middle class suburban upbringing Americans that profess them. Principal agent problem of sorts, I guess.
Markets for food work pretty well. And for loans.
Markets are pretty efficient. That doesn’t mean you don’t regulate them.
Please look up how much subsidy is given to the American farmers. It's probably more than you think it is.
> And for loans.
Might have agreed more with you, but then 2008 happened.
It kind of reminds me of the argument that philanthropy is bad because individual rich people shouldn't get to choose who is helped; governments should tax the rich more and use it to help people. Well yeah, I agree, they should. But if they don't, it certainly doesn't make someone a bad person for choosing to voluntarily donate to charity.
The sad thing is that people don’t bother digging much into it and take simple answers like “greed” instead of figuring out exactly where the monies are going.
Own 10 houses, all vacant, then you can either sell or rent out. Having people hoard these properties does no good for society.
It's perfectly fine to complain about a system, without being a perfect citizen yourself. I can complain about oil companies, and still be dependent on a car.
That’s not a complaint. It is a naked authoritarian call to steal from people who legally do things you disapprove of.
Do you give permission to people who dislike your policy positions to take away your livelihood?
I think it is based on a mathematical theorem or something, but i have long since forgotten.
With price controls, there is a limit to how much you can invest in a property to fix it up to attract new tenants.
There are building permits with harsh rules. The reasons of these permits and rules is to keep the city livable, beautiful and functional.
Since you cannot build freely if left unchecked the prices would go to the sky. And you don't want that because functional city needs working class people, you need nurses, shop attendants, janitors, etc...
Maybe you think city planning and urbanism are bad ideas and that we should let the free market magically solve all the problems.
Few things have been proven as resoundingly as "price controls don't work", or more accurately "are very net negative".
This gets forgotten every time someone really wants them to work.
This applies to rent control as much as any other price.
When you want the price of something to be lower, subsidising demand increases prices rather than lowering them.
Suppliers and owners will not simply accept lower prices, even if you really wish they did.
The Great Forgetting - price controls don't work.