I've certainly been told by a corporate landlord "we checked nearby rentals, and decided that we should match their rent increases" so I guess A is the proper option?
The article says B is also true, and the evil landlords are aiming to coerce policy change by making people homeless
There's your "somehow". Being intentionally obtuse just makes you look stupid at best.
There's no more choice in using roads than there is to live somewhere.
Well, induced demand is a popular theory in other areas, so... maybe?
Building lots and lots of housing will never induce more per capita housing use in the same way that better roads induce longer per capital commutes.
Because the fundamental concept of induced demand doesn’t really track with the concept of having a place to live. You need a place to live, you don’t start using more “place to live” because there are more of them.
It can only happen at the fringes — fewer shared leases, more people with 2nd homes. The vast majority will still have one place to live for their family.
Population mobility to desirable neighborhoods is also not “induced demand”.
Likewise, when we (Americans at least) talk about housing shortages, we don’t mean the USA as a whole, it’s just a few cities that everyone wants to live in, not say small towns in the Midwest or Deep South. So a lot of demand and is already suppressed because not everyone can live in those few hot places.
Whether these actions work or not, it is not immoral to attempt them.
There is no 'human right to profit at the expense of others'.
It takes quite distorted incentives for the obvious course of action to be (1) build a house => (2) leave it empty. For that to make economic sense for more than maybe 12 months, the government has to have really come in swinging with crazy policies.
The discomfort you experience of having to let your bought-for-the-purposes-of-renting properties is less important to me than the discomfort of the person you're evicting.
You want to be a landlord? Comply with tenant laws. If you don't like it, you won't be missed, it's not like you can leave and take that apartment with you.
In China, rental returns are so paltry compared to purchase prices that many property speculators simply don’t rent out their properties (renovating a property reduces its value in that market, so leaving it unfinished is a winning strategy). That has nothing to do with regulation and everything to do with an out of control property bubble, but the same principle applies. Here in Seattle, being a landlord is an increasingly untenable position, especially for private individuals. They are instead in it just for the appreciation (property bubble again) and so it makes sense for them to just leave the house vacant and keep squatters away.
A. Evil landlords meet at their secret underground fortress and collectively agree to charge too much for rent
B. Evil rich people / foreigners (pick whichever you find more objectionable) have bought up all the housing and are keeping the units vacant to spite everyone
Supply and demand doesn't apply to housing, of course. If we build more housing that will just drive prices up! Somehow!