News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:41PM (#33086491)
History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money with no backing.

For a historical example, the Confederacy had high inflation. The printing press was in Richmond. When Richmond was threatened with a siege, the Confederacy hustled the printing press out to get it to a new, safer location.

Confederate inflation paused during the move.

The reason is pretty simple - the Law of Supply & Demand. The more currency there is flooding the economy, the less value that currency has.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:47PM (#33086569)
This is a very simplistic viewpoint. One could also argue that Inflation happens when people don't trust that their government will pay back all the money borrowed.

The US govt has been on a spending spree as of late, but hasn't yet bothered to mention how they are going to pay for it.

In 2008/2009, the US govt was also on a spending spree, but did promise to pay the bill eventually. Inflation didn't spike in 2008/2009.

The bottom line is, nobody really KNOWS, we just have guesses. My guess currently fits all the facts, where yours does not, but that doesn't mean my guess is right, but perhaps it's more correct than your version.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:18PM (#33087075)
> perhaps it's more correct than your version.

My version has lots and lots and LOTS of history backing it up.

Did you know that the US had inflation when on the gold standard during the California and Yukon gold rushes?

Did you know that Spain experienced massive inflation during the period when they were shipping the silver in S. America across the Atlantic?

I could go on and on.

> One could also argue that Inflation happens when people don't trust that their government will pay back all the money borrowed.

This sort of thing happens with private banknotes, which would trade at a discount based on the level of trust. But that is a one-time discount, not a cumulative process.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:03PM (#33088343)
I agree that there is lots of data that shows your version has some merit, but that doesn't mean it's 100% correct. I know of at least one instance where your version was incorrect(2008/2009). Again, I'm not arguing my version is correct, and I'm not even arguing that your version is completely wrong, because we literally do not know.

Read some John Cochrane[0] if you want a more academic defence of my version(which is where I got it from, I'm certainly not smart enough to have come up with it myself).

0: https://www.justicenewsflash.com/2022/01/03/the-grumpy-econo...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:56PM (#33089549)
> I know of at least one instance where your version was incorrect(2008/2009).

One one hand, we have thousands of years of history with what causes inflation.

On the other hand, we have one instance.

I'd say one has to examine the one counterexample for something missed. (Your cite makes no mention of 2008/2009.) Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Recall my other post here about how making loans creates money, and paying the loans back destroys it. Bankruptcy destroys money. I wonder if all the bankruptcies, defaults, haircuts and writedowns removed a vast amount of money from circulation, and the deficit spending simply filled that hole rather than creating more inflation.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:10AM (#33092665)
>One one hand, we have thousands of years of history with what causes inflation.

Yeah we know that inflation is caused by an insufficient internalisation of liquidity costs on the beneficiaries of liquidity.

This makes them destroy the supply of money that is available for transactions which then forces people to create new transaction available money to replace the loss.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:43AM (#33095481)
Thousands of years of pre Adam smith history where the concept of macroeconomics did not exist. Obviously a naive implementation of monetary expansion causes price inflation, that doesn’t mean a well implemented monetary expansion does though.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:22PM (#33099278)
The Law of Supply & Demand is there whether it is recognized or not.

> that doesn’t mean a well implemented monetary expansion does though

Then none of them are well implemented, because all examples of fiat money exhibit endemic inflation. The reason is straightforward - the whole point of a fiat money system is to inflate it.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:44PM (#33099627)
The decade following 08 had exactly the goal inflation even though there was unprecedented monetary expansion.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:12PM (#33090220)
> (Your cite makes no mention of 2008/2009.)

Incorrect: "One may look to politicians’ statements. Even in the Obama-era “stimulus” spending, the administration emphasized promises of eventual debt reduction. " And I have more to say on it later.

My cite is from a world-class economist, not from some random person on the Internet.

> One one hand, we have thousands of years of history with what causes inflation. > On the other hand, we have one instance.

Again, you are assuming facts not in evidence, you assume your version of reality is correct, likely because that is what economics text books taught you, because they also assumed it to be the case, these assumptions do not make it true.

Perhaps those thousands of years of history actually agree with my version also. We don't know what people were thinking across those thousands of years of inflation history, it's possible they were thinking our governments(such as they were) were not trusted to pay it back, as generally speaking, governments that go on large spending sprees tend to not pay it back very well. It's hard to be disciplined with money when there is very little incentive to politicians while in office.

There is no rigorous proof of what causes inflation. There are many well-educated guesses and your perspective was the common wisdom for a long time. That doesn't make it true, no matter how much you want it to be.

I'm pretty sure my version is also wrong, but it's at least an interesting perspective rather than "money printers go brrr inflation then always happens".

> Recall my other post here about how making loans creates money, and paying the loans back destroys it.

I don't agree with the second part of this sentence. I completely agree that the banks create money out of thin air when they decide to loan you $100k. But if you pay it back, more money is created as part of the interest payments on that $100k. If you don't pay it back:

> Bankruptcy destroys money.

True.

> I wonder if all the bankruptcies, defaults, haircuts and writedowns removed a vast amount of money from circulation, and the deficit spending simply filled that hole rather than creating more inflation.

The US government made money on it[0]. I'm almost positive there is essentially a zero percent chance of making any of the trillions we spent in 2020 back. We have to pay all that borrowing off somehow, either we raise taxes or we inflate it away. It seems like we are on the inflation train version for now at least.

Though perhaps your comment is also partially true, there was some bankruptcies(one might argue not enough). A quick web search didn't turn up any good data on the amount(s) though and I'm to lazy to do more research on it, but if you have done some, I'd be interested.

0: https://money.usnews.com/investing/articles/2017-01-19/finan...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:11PM (#33090659)
> There is no rigorous proof of what causes inflation.

There's no rigorous proof that smoking causes cancer, either. All we have is a lot of correlation.

The historical evidence of printing non-collateralized money corresponding with inflation is overwhelming. It corresponds with gold rushes, and silver rushes. It corresponds with debasing coins by mixing in cheap metals.

Me, I'm going where the evidence leads.

> I completely agree that the banks create money out of thin air when they decide to loan you $100k. But if you pay it back,

It is the inverse operation - destroying it. But of course, the bank creates it again for the next loan.

> more money is created as part of the interest payments on that $100k.

No, it does not. I wish I could create money to pay the interest on my loans, but I can't (at least not legally!). I use existing money to pay them.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by chubs on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:17AM (#33093090)
Always fantastic to see someone standing up for basic economics here!

My favourite tech-communicable way to consider it is this: Money is like 'points' for prioritising the way people/resources are allocated in the world, somewhat like agile/scrum planning poker. If you give everyone cards with larger points values, you'll still get the same amount of work done in a given sprint, it's just that you'll get an inflated 'sprint velocity' (eg story points implemented in a fortnight).

Apologies if i've explained this poorly!

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Thursday October 06, 2022 @11:19AM (#33109351)
> No, it does not. I wish I could create money to pay the interest on my loans, but I can't (at least not legally!). I use existing money to pay them.

LOL, wrong perspective, think of it from the banks point of view. They make money from you for creating money and letting you use some of it.

Again, this whole "creating money" thing is very simplistic perspective, they have limits on how much of this they can do, etc.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Izkata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:00AM (#33095674)
Looks like 2008 was a deflationary recession [0], so sounds like that money printing caused enough inflation to counter it and hold ~steady.

[0] https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/040715/were-there-a...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:08AM (#33092653)
>But that is a one-time discount, not a cumulative process.

Providing liquidity is a cumulative process.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by W3cUYxYwmXb5c on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:51PM (#33087536)
Monetary inflation is the increase in the money supply. Price inflation is one of the potential symptoms of monetary inflation. Too often people look at just one symptom to gauge the occurrence of the cause. Currently we are experiencing both, but people seem to want to ignore the inflation of the money supply, and scratch our heads over every other variable that affects prices.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:07AM (#33092649)
Ok, now introduce negative interest rates on cash.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jnwatson on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:00PM (#33086801)
We have very educated guesses.

The primary difference between 2008 and now with respect to monetary policy is money velocity. Increasing money supply is a necessary but insufficient condition for inflation.

In 2008, much of that money sat uninvested, so it didn’t impact the price of goods. In 2020, most of it got used to buy and invest.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:21PM (#33088544)
We do have educated guesses, The OP and my comment are 2 of them. There are more of them for sure.

It wasn't un-invested, it just didn't much make it out to buy consumer goods(at least not as directly as in 2020).

Like all things the devil is in the details, which get stupidly complicated.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by dasil003 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:58PM (#33086761)
There’s also a tipping point where inflation is self propelled because everyone is used to it so they just proactively raise prices on a regular basis. I experienced this growing up in Brazil in the 80s and 90s. It’s hard for Americans to relate, but essentially the mentality is spend/invest every penny you get before it loses value. Took some creative policy to break the cycle: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plano_Real
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:22PM (#33087129)
> There’s also a tipping point where inflation is self propelled because everyone is used to it so they just proactively raise prices on a regular basis.

This is called cost-push inflation. Unfortunately, that theory doesn't explain where the extra dollars come from.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by dasil003 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:33PM (#33087302)
Why would you expect there to be some unifying theory of inflation? It's an emergent phenomenon resulting from the actions of many individual actors. I'm quite sure the people raising the prices every week had no idea how much cash was in circulation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:52PM (#33087551)
Fiat money (or anything that increases the supply of money, like gold rushes) is the common factor with all instances of inflation. There are thousands of years of examples of this.

You're right on one point, the Law of Supply & Demand. It is an emergent property of many individual actions, though each might be completely ignorant of the big picture.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by lottin on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:59AM (#33091455)
Another common factor in all cases of inflation was the moon orbiting the Earth, so clearly the moon is causing inflation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:24PM (#33099315)
Your theory doesn't explain deflation. Mine does.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:35AM (#33092823)
Egyptians used grain money which spoils over time and the grain banks charged the depositors a fee for the liquidity they provide. If you want a stable banking system you are going to have to make depositors pay for the costs they impose onto other people.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:25PM (#33099334)
I suggest reading up on how banks make money from fractional reserve banking. No need for depositors to pay, and in fact lending money is so lucrative banks will pay the depositors.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Izkata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:06AM (#33095750)
One of the reasons to raise price is to discourage people from buying when you have limited stock. Sellers can tell where their supply is coming from, compare it to how much stock they have left, and compare that to normal times. So yeah, they do have such a signal, though it is secondary to the actual reason for the price increase.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by sidewndr46 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:23PM (#33090769)
All you've done here is dress up the "it's really complicated, you wouldn't understand it" dismissal in nicer terms.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mypalmike on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:06AM (#33091497)
Economists working for oil companies certainly don't ignore money supply.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Calavar on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:50AM (#33092528)
Why would there need to be any extra dollars? If inflation is a matter of supply and demand of currency, as you say, then shouldn't we expect that a demand-side shift could lead to inflation without any change in the money supply?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by hnick on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:55AM (#33093332)
Makes sense to me, the thing that matters is not total money but active money. Prices go up because there is the same amount of money, but sellers expect more, and buyers are used to paying more. This can continue by having their proportion of earnings/wealth spent increased which increases total liquid money supply, until they are at capacity (i.e. spending their whole income, selling off assets, etc).

Basically the inverse of people being averse to spending and instead hoarding cash, leading to deflation as prices are lowered to tempt them into spending again.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by wahern on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:11PM (#33087789)
AFAIU from reading about the Plano Real and some other cases, the extra dollars come from the central bank being stuck between a rock and a hard place. If they don't print the extra money, then inflation accelerates--a scarcer dollar increases in real value, but non-intuitively this doesn't produce deflation unless you're prepared to hold your ground while the economy and society incinerates in the chaos.

EDIT: I think this is one of the primary phenomenons creating the dilemma for the central bank and government: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_inflation But IIRC from the Brazil case, informal expectations and pricing strategies in the supply chain (from factory to corner store) were at least as important as contracts.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mixmastamyk on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:36PM (#33090863)
Not really, it happened in the US in the 70s and early 80s. Not as high as in some countries, but enough to make a difference in behavior.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by roenxi on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:27AM (#33092772)
There is no reason to believe the situation is complex. The value of money is changing because the authority that controls money is changing it.

Nobody understands the economy. But we can be pretty sure that it isn't the economy destroying the value of the dollar, because there is no reason for consistent annual inflation to be happening. If anything, in the absence of money creation, we should be seeing deflation because of technological improvements. Short term wobbles, sure, maybe even sometimes a few straight years of inflation due to exceptional conditions. But that isn't what is happening.

The only thing that can have caused the dollar to lose value consistently is creating new money. Otherwise we'd see it regularly snapping back to normal value with deflation. Which, in my lifetime, I think may have literally never happened.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by foobarian on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:45PM (#33086547)
> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money.

Of course, that is almost a tautology. The devil is in the details. No inflation is bad because the economy stops. High inflation is bad because of erosion of purchasing power and negative impact on nearly every participant in the economy. So what do you do to get that sweet spot of about 1-2% inflation? I'd say raising interest rates was a pretty good start, if a bit late in the game.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:30PM (#33087259)
> Of course, that is almost a tautology

Inflation lags the money printing, so it isn't a tautology.

> So what do you do to get that sweet spot of about 1-2% inflation?

I'm amazed that propaganda of a sweet spot gets so heavily embedded into the popular wisdom.

If there is a sweet spot for inflation, it's 0%.

Note that the US had net 0% inflation from 1800-1914, while growing from subsistence farming to superpower.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by woodruffw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:01AM (#33091057)
> Note that the US had net 0% inflation from 1800-1914, while growing from subsistence farming to superpower.

This is grossly ahistorical: in 1914, 2/3rds of the US lived in abject poverty[1]. Individual farming, including subsistence farming, didn't peak until the 1930s[2]. The US's ascent to superpower status can be traced, at the earliest, to lending programs begun during WWI (and repeated, to fantastic effect, during WWII).

The US's phenomenal ascent in international status and power is directly tied to its monetary policy, a policy that has more or less kept inflation around 2% since 1935[3].

[1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20150720050803/https://www.irp.w...

[2]: https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistic...

[3]: https://www.thebalancemoney.com/u-s-inflation-rate-history-b...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:35PM (#33099495)
> in 1914, 2/3rds of the US lived in abject poverty[1]

Your cite doesn't support that. Besides, during the 19th century average height increased enormously (a sign of good and consistent nutrition), mortality rates dropped dramatically, life expectancy increased, and the growth of the middle class was spectacular.

When the US entered WW1, the German soldiers were shocked by how tall they were, and how well fed and well supplied they were.

I.e. your claim is completely false.

> The US's phenomenal ascent in international status and power is directly tied to its monetary policy

None of your cites support that, either.

See "Historical Statistics of the United States Colonial Times To 1970, volumes 1 and 2". I think you can download it from archive.org. It's a gold mine.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by woodruffw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:49PM (#33099710)
> Besides, during the 19th century average height increased enormously (a sign of good and consistent nutrition), mortality rates dropped dramatically, life expectancy increased, and the growth of the middle class was spectacular.

Growth is good, but it's a delta: it doesn't mean that the average life was particularly nice by modern standards. The fact that things improved over time is not evidence that they were good at any instant (and indeed, nobody questions that things improved: they clearly had to in order to get to where we are now).

In 1914, the average male life expectancy was 52[1]. That's over 20 years shorter than our current life expectancies.

> When the US entered WW1, the German soldiers were shocked by how tall they were, and how well fed and well supplied they were.

This is a comparative error: the US's military population didn't need to be well fed by objective standards; they only needed to be better fed than the peasants who were press-ganged into the German army.

Nobody is saying that the US was uniquely impoverished by contemporaneous metrics; the claim is that the US was impoverished on an absolute and modern scale, and that said impoverishment declined as the US established domestic and international policies that are inextricably linked to its monetary policy.

[1]: https://u.demog.berkeley.edu/~andrew/1918/figure2.html

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:47AM (#33095530)
0% inflation is incredibly dangerous. Deflation is just about the worst possible thing that can happen to an economy. It instantly kills money market liquidity as real interest rates rise as they hit the lower bond for nominal rates. People stop spending as much as they can since their money will be worth more in the future. So the question is how can we guarantee no deflation. And the only answer is target 1-2% inflation.

By the way the us was in a recession for practically the entirety of the second half of the 19th century, mostly because of absolutely garbage monetary policy.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:39PM (#33099536)
> 0% inflation is incredibly dangerous.

Oh rubbish.

> By the way the us was in a recession for practically the entirety of the second half of the 19th century

Completely false. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/files/docs/meltzer/cenlon66.pd...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:43AM (#33092891)
>I'm amazed that propaganda of a sweet spot gets so heavily embedded into the popular wisdom.

Because that sweet spot is very similar to the benefits liquidity confers to the holder of liquidity. Come on grandpa, please don't tell me all the people "bringing their wares to the market" are doing so at no cost and that the holders of liquidity aren't benefitting from stores optimistically stocking goods.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by stopping on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:01AM (#33092603)
Dismissing a contrary position as "propaganda" only stifles debate, and you haven't presented an argument against "sweet spots". It's a good mental model for many situations. What makes you think there doesn't exist an optimal inflation rate?

0% inflation is generally not a safe target. In an economy you want to avoid deflation at all costs. If consumers expect future price drops, demand can dip significantly and induce further drops in price (deflationary spiral). Businesses need consistent, predictable demand, else they enact shortsighted, over-reactive responses (e.g. layoffs) which can further exacerbate an economic downturn. See the Japanese financial crisis. Even a small fluctuation into deflationary territory can have long-lasting effects on consumer perception. It's safer (read: insurance policy) to maintain a slightly positive inflation rate so that consumers are encouraged to make purchase decisions promptly when needs arise versus indefinite speculative postponement.

Of course, the "optimal" inflation rate is context-dependent. Your unique economic situation will dictate which inflation trade-offs you end up selecting.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:45PM (#33099642)
This is all unsupported by any evidence. The "deflationary spiral" theory is as wrong as its sister, the "inflationary spiral".

Inflation benefits borrowers, hurts lenders. Deflation hurts borrowers, benefits lenders.

The sweet spot is 0.

The reason everybody believes that inflation is good for you is because of persistent government propaganda to sell that idea, because what inflation really is is a tax on your money. That's right, a tax.

Now, if you want to argue that the inflation tax is a reasonable way for the government to raise revenue, ok, but be realistic as to what it is. Inflation isn't good for you any more than taxing you is good for you.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by stopping on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:24PM (#33100155)
Nothing of what you said is an argument against the points I made. Where is the error in my reasoning? I literally gave an example of my argument applying to a real life, well studied scenario.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:27PM (#33100198)
The "deflationary spiral" has empirical evidence from a fair number of financial crises in the 19th and early 20th centuries. It happened. A lot. And it was really destructive when it did.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:31PM (#33102938)
Too late to edit, so replying to myself: There also is plenty of evidence for the "inflationary spiral". See Zimbabwe for a recent example.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by rightbyte on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:26AM (#33092758)
> If consumers expect future price drops, demand can dip significantly and induce further drops in price

Sounds awesome? Saves resources. People save money for a rainy day. Lending goes down.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:52AM (#33092944)
Money is necessary to conduct transactions. If people are incapable of transacting because some people play a hoarding game like with Bitcoin then real people's real basic needs like food or housing won't be met. You will get wholly pointless homelessness.

How do we make sure that money cannot be abused to doom the rest of the economy into an inability to transact? You make people pay for the benefits they receive by holding onto money. People hate free markets, they are against paying for the costs they cause.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by randomdata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:40AM (#33095441)
> Money is necessary to conduct transactions.

Not necessarily. Money is little more than a distributed IOU held from providing past benefit to someone else to be used in exchange for future benefit from someone else. Money records that I did work for you now and in return you will do work for me later, except given that the IOU is recognized in a distributed fashion the work later can also come from other people.

IOUs bring a lot of benefit, but aren't strictly necessary to conduct a transaction. I could work for you now and at the same time you could work for me to provide equal value. Since there is no delay between services rendered there is no need to record that the other party promises to provide a future benefit. The transaction is already complete in the moment.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by KptMarchewa on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:19AM (#33093094)
And you get fired from your job because demand for it disappears. Amazing.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by autoexec on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @06:58AM (#33093786)
Demand doesn't disappear. People still want the things they want. They just might not be wiling to pay as much as others would like them to. Lower the prices, and suddenly those people can justify (or even simply afford) satisfing the demand that never went away. People spending leads to more jobs.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by KptMarchewa on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:21AM (#33095917)
>Lower the prices, and suddenly those people can justify (or even simply afford) satisfing the demand that never went away.

Or they can wait more to buy cheaper. Sure, they won't do that if you sell carrots, but they will do if you sell cars.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by autoexec on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:51PM (#33099741)
As if prices are going to come down. If the companies who have been making record profits refuse to accept making a little less profit and won't lower prices how long will you have to wait to buy something cheaper.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by stopping on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:37AM (#33092843)
Not at all. The issue of rampant consumerism is mostly orthogonal to issues of overall economic stability. Deflation will certainly reduce consumption, but at the cost of massive societal upheaval by way of extreme unemployment and all of its ill effects.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by randomdata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:24AM (#33094509)
> If consumers expect future price drops

Which they do. The only time in US history where a significant inflationary spike was not followed by deflation was in the long run up (already making it an outlier) in the 1970s through 1980s, and inflation in that period transpired primarily due to wage inflation. As wages are the stickiest of all, you don't get downward movement on price when the tide shifts, you simply see unemployment shoot through the roof.

When fertilizer availability is no longer the most pressing concern facing humanity, something we are unlikely to not be able to resolve in due time, there won't be much reason for prices to persist. There is little to no stickiness here and it tumbles from there.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by foobarian on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:44PM (#33088149)
I don’t know, the concept just makes sense to me intuitively. There are enough weird effects in systems and math when things are at zero that I just can’t tell what would happen. Example, in queueing theory when input rate is equal to output rate under reasonable randomness you get large backlogs. When everything drains at just a few percent over zero it just seems like a better system.

The US also had a civil war during that period. And then repeated brutal boom and bust cycles until Breton Woods.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:20PM (#33089812)
We still have boom and bust cycles, but with persistent inflation.

As for the Civil War, the US government printed fiat money during it.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mixmastamyk on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:39PM (#33090890)
^Became a superpower in the 1940s gearing up for WWII and then the only country left standing with brand new factories.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by sidewndr46 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:26PM (#33090792)
I've never heard anyone tell me they were going to quit working because the US government wasn't printing money fast enough.

I have heard people tell me they weren't making enough money to cover their expenses on a month-to-month basis as a result of cost increases. These happen to correlate with inflation.

There is no way an economy would stop just because there was no inflation. Would Microsoft suddenly decree that if the US government won't print US dollars, it won't sell you a Windows license key? Even in the case of extreme deflation, it only becomes an issue when you have people trying to do weird things with physical currency like cut a penny into 1/4s and use it to buy different goods.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:49AM (#33095551)
The people who couldn’t afford their expenses due to rising costs likely would have lost their job in the recession that was averted due to inflation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by sidewndr46 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:01AM (#33095691)
I really don't think we can call something "averted" if people can no longer actually afford to live.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:05AM (#33095743)
The recession was averted. The outcome was still bad, but it would’ve been much worse.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by virissimo on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:22PM (#33087141)
> No inflation is bad because the economy stops.

How much net inflation was there in Europe between the Napoleonic Wars and the start of WWI? Do you think "the economy stops" is a fair description of this time period?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by ryanisnan on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:00PM (#33086789)
I'm not very versed in economics, but can you explain "No inflation is bad because the economy stops."?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Aunche on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:56AM (#33091810)
Zero inflation is fine, but a small hiccup would cause it to spiral into deflation. Deflation sounds good in a micro-scale because money gets more valuable. However, this is actually a terrible thing because the only way this can happen is when money gets destroyed through defaults, which is why you only see deflation during a financial crisis.

When technology increases increases productivity and society has a fixed supply of paper money, you'd think you'd see deflation because there are more goods and the same amount of money. However, actually during those periods of times, banks lend out money, which increases the money supply. This is a good thing because they're enabling economic activity that otherwise wouldn't have happened like a loan to start a new business. However, this system is fragile because if depositors lose faith in the bank, everyone will try to withdrawal their money, which is called a bank run. The bank doesn't have enough money because they leant some of it out, so they default and depositors that aren't quick money lose their money. One of the purposes of central banks is to ensure that this doesn't happen.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:56AM (#33092972)
There is also the problem that if you pay off your debts at a faster rate than people spend off their savings your debt will shrink at the rate others are spending their money, not at the rate you are paying it off. If we expect people to be personally responsible why do we treat them as if they aren't when they do the right thing?

This is why we can't have nice things.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by foobarian on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:12PM (#33086978)
There are some other comments that probably described it better, but as an example: let's say inflation is negative. That means it is good to keep cash. What happens is everyone starts hoarding cash under their mattresses and there is no liquidity around to help exchange goods, and everything slows down.

With a small inflation, there is no incentive to hoard cash, and there is enough liquidity to make sure goods get exchanged without too much delay. At the end of the day that is what an economy is, exchanging goods.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by ephbit on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:33PM (#33088033)
> ... and everything slows down.

Agree.

And ... this is exactly what the ecosphere needs right now.

People continuing to consume all the usual necessities as they always have and always will. And consuming less of all the extra wasteful unnecessary stuff that gets pumped out of factories because of a destructive culture of "increasing GDP is good".

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by foobarian on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:48PM (#33088195)
Yes this is a great point. I wonder if to achieve that, a back pressure is required in the system that we are just not willing to put up with. Example, cruel warlords keeping the serfs in misery, or hunter gatherer tribes annihilating each other. Or more modern, some central authority allocating resources.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by ephbit on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:50PM (#33111534)
> I wonder if to achieve that, a back pressure is required in the system that we are just not willing to put up with.

By back pressure you mean some kind of negative feedback, I assume.

I think, more precisely, the problem is not that negative feedback is completely missing. The problem is, that technology and societies have implemented (mostly involuntarily so) lots of systems that effectively distribute the entirety of the negative feedback very widely across the members of society.

Like in a shared living situation where some people take great care to clean up after themselves and others do not. As a whole it somehow "works", without cleanliness getting out of hand, but only because some people are doing more than others. This way, those who do not clean up their own dirt, never even learn their real impact on the whole, because it's continuously remedied by others. Their negative feedback is effectively missing, so they get the impression that everything is fine.

On the worldwide scale it's an analogous situation.

Widespread governmental subsidies for energy are one of the biggest issues I see there. They redistribute a big part of production costs across all tax payers and eliminate a big part of negative feedback.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by IncRnd on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:27PM (#33087208)
But, the economy doesn't stop when there is no inflation or deflation. Well, I suppose that depends on your meaning of the word economy.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by foobarian on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:34PM (#33088043)
Certainly I was wrong if you take those words literally. You got me. At the end of the day hopefully you got positive insight out of it. :-)
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by rolisz on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:59AM (#33091456)
No, I didn't get it either. People will still need food, electricity, gas, clothing. Buildings will need maintenance. Are you saying people will decide to not eat because deflation? Or not fix their broken windows?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mypalmike on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:50AM (#33091768)
In deflation, prices are going down. So I know it will cost me less next week to fix that broken window than doing it today. So I wait a week. But the logic doesn't change - when next week comes, I'll wait another week to get a better price. Apply this across the board, and people mostly just buy what they need. Producers of goods stop producing. R&D disappears. Etc.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by JamesianP on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:08AM (#33092214)
Seems more like a good thing you've turned upside down. As long as some R&D has an average payoff that outperforms the rate of deflation, people will be motivated to take the risk. Deflation would disproportionately hurt risky investments, whereas inflation causes worse and worse choices to become increasingly attractive. I'd say we already got way more stupid investments than we needed in the last few decades of low inflation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:51AM (#33095574)
Deflation forces real interest rates up which kills investment and immediately lowers gdp. It is unequivocally an awful thing that leads to massive unemployment.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by JamesianP on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:24PM (#33099323)
Lowering prices is a good thing for consumers and businesses who need to buy those things. There's nothing "unequivocal" about the argument here. Including the value of speculative investments (good investments will still pay better than real interest rates) or the position of economists as you surely are aware. And by the way those historic periods of massive unemployment had other causes with deflation as a side effect, not the cause. Other times in history had deflation during periods of growth.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:06AM (#33093028)
They will decide to not eat because the medium of exchange is scarce. Some rich people see their big bank accounts go up in value and keep it there but poor people will keep spending until they have no money. Because the medium of exchange is blocked they can't sell their labor to obtain a medium of exchange which they can then use to buy food.

Deflation is like turning off the internet and no longer being able to pay with your credit card but it also affects paper money. The problem isn't a lack of productivity or a lack of capable workers.

If the medium of exchange didn't act as a gatekeeper people would keep trading in some beautiful purely theoretical economic model via barter.

How do we keep money flowing without inflation?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by IncRnd on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:40PM (#33090903)
I didn't "get you". What is your non-literal definition of economy?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by kelseyfrog on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:56PM (#33086727)
Why are interests rates as a money sink preferable to the more direct approach of simply sinking money out of supply via tax? They seem to amount to the same thing at the end of the day - siphoning dollars out.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by merely-unlikely on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:03PM (#33086848)
That is also a valid approach but I'm not sure it is more direct. Tax policy is generally only set once a year and only affects tax payers. Interest rates can be tweaked more frequently and (I think) directly impact a larger subset of economic players. That and the Fed doesn't determine tax rates.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by atq2119 on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:34AM (#33117790)
Your point about how tax rates are set compared to interest rates is true, but could be changed.

I don't follow the second part though: pretty much everybody pays a significant amount of taxes, if only the likes of sales tax. Far fewer (though of course still many) players have substantial interest income or expenses.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by bombcar on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:00PM (#33086794)
Because you don't have to subject it to a vote. People vote against taxes, they kinda ignore moderate interest/inflation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by em500 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:52AM (#33093309)
The Federal Reserves implements interest rate increases by selling the bonds that they own (bought in the past) in the market in exchange for cash ("Open Market Operations"). This takes cash out of the hand of the public (in exchange for cash that can be spent in the future). That's about as direct as it gets.

Removing cash in the public's hand via taxation has several drawbacks, as mentioned by other posters. It's a very slow legislative process, because it has much more direct distributional effects (who is going to be taxed?). Additionally, most academic economists believe more taxation reduces real, as opposed to nominal, economic activity ("distortionary effects of taxation").

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by marcosdumay on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:27PM (#33087199)
Why governments don't do monetary policy by fiscal means? Well, because the central bank is the authority on monetary matters, and the congress the authority on fiscal matters. They don't even usually agree on what direction to go. (Things are this way on every democracy.)

But that specific question, nobody would take money out of the economy by fiscal means, even if they could. You would need huge fiscal changes to have the same effect of a small monetary restriction. And you don't do huge fiscal changes, ever.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by badpun on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:21AM (#33092727)
This way, you'd only be vacuuming dollars held by US entities (citizens, companies), while USD is a global currency held by everyone in the world. This policy would greatly benefit non-US entities, at the cost of US entities.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by kelseyfrog on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:54PM (#33111587)
Interesting. It isn't obvious to me how the Fed(a US org) setting interest rates necessarily affects non-US entities. Could you explain the causal chain?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by atq2119 on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:30AM (#33117769)
Do non-US entities tend to have more assets in USD or more debts? I'd assume the former, which means that a US interest rate increase is actually net beneficial to non-US entities.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Consultant32452 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:02AM (#33091067)
Have you ever noticed you get raises roughly based on last year's inflation and not an estimation of next year's inflation? When the money printers print the people who touch the new money first get to buy assets before the price inflation occurs. Then, once the new money eventually circulates to the peasants, they get to use it to buy goods and services at the new, higher prices.

Inflation is a wealth transfer from the poor to the wealthy. It is not, by any means, necessary.

https://mises.org/wire/inflation-its-wealth-redistribution-s...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:27AM (#33093142)
Isn't it amazing that Austrian economists completely ignore that providing liquidity creates costs for the providers of liquidity?

Businesses give money value by offering products and services, meanwhile the holder of money expects the business to keep providing this costly service at no cost. In other words, there is a constant flow of free liquidity provisioning services toward the holders of money which makes the providers of liquidity poorer and the holders of liquidity richer if they market that liquidity. After all, money is worth more than the purchasing power it represents, it can buy anything available in the payments network. Money that buys bananas and apples is more valuable than money that only buys apples even if both have the same amount of purchasing power. Since liquidity is paid for by the general enterprising public, the holders who have none of the costs can just loan out and market their liquidity for a price and they get to pretend that they are providing a service, even though they haven't done anything for it in any way.

People who still have a need to transact must now pay the costs of liquidity to someone who doesn't provide it when they borrow money.

The person who borrows money is now stuck with the costs of liquidity even if they spend it. When they spend it, they no longer benefit from liquidity but they must still pay for the liquidity that someone else owns. That person then can lend his liquidity out without paying for it. The end result is that liquidity costs must be paid twice.

This is an endlessly compounding system. Like a pyramid scheme. Money acts like a perpetuity where the yield is paid out in liquidity which can through borrowing be turned into money. Previous perpetuities are paid by creating new perpetuities.

Very interesting scheme and Austrian economists are even denying the above so they are complicit.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:52PM (#33086659)
You keep claiming this, but it is fairly obvious that prices can be forced up by factors that have nothing to do with the money supply - most notably, constrained supply in basic raw materials (especially oil and its derivatives) can force virtually all prices up, regardless of the amount of currency available.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:03PM (#33086855)
Since you know all the obvious answers, try these on:

1. Where does all the money come from to pay for increased gas prices?

2. When gas prices go down (and they often do go down by multiples), why doesn't deflation happen?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:24AM (#33091970)
1. There's no extra money - poorer people just consume less.

2. Because companies just take all of the difference as extra revenue, and prefer to increase salaries (if not just keep everything as profit) rather than reducing prices.

Note that I'm not claiming that increased money supply doesn't cause inflation. It obviously does. I'm claiming it's not the only cause of inflation. It's sufficient, but not necessary for inflation to happen.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:53PM (#33099759)
When people consume less, prices drop. Again, it's the Law of Supply & Demand.

In physics, when momentum is not conserved, I don't have to work through the math to show it is wrong. I know it is wrong. When conservation of energy is denied, I know it is wrong. When someone claims a perpetual motion machine, I know it is wrong.

Analogously, when a theory requires denial of the Law of Supply & Demand, I know it's wrong.

This thread is chock full of weird economic theories of every description. The LoS&D is a wonderful tool to easily diagnose false economic theories.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:13PM (#33100722)
> When people consume less, prices drop. Again, it's the Law of Supply & Demand.

No, they don't: not if supply is inelastic.

The law of supply and demand says that the price of a good will tend to the price at which supply meets demand. If supply has a maximum, so does demand: any change in theoretical demand above that max will do nothing to affect the price.

If the entire economy produces 10 gallons of oil per day, the fact that today 100 people wanted 1 gallon each, while yesterday 1000 people wanted 1 gallon each, will do nothing to affect the price: I'm still only going to sell to the 10 highest bidders. Of course, if suddenly only 9 people are left using oil, I will indeed be forced to lower my price - but until then, lower demand will have no impact.

You seem to be basing your opinions on some other "Law" of Supply and Demand that somehow claims that Supply will always rise to meet Demand. That "Law" is simply false, and you should discard it.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by JamesianP on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:45AM (#33092494)
It's not so simple though since there's indirect effects that immediately follow.

1. Everyone consume less. Even rich people have to buy less of something else to pay for the higher-priced gas. So demand goes down elsewhere driving down other prices.

2. If margins or salaries increase then it increases the incentive for competition to enter the market and compete on price.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by magicalhippo on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:11AM (#33092670)
> So demand goes down elsewhere driving down other prices.

Right, but given that those other things were non-essentials, it surely don't matter as much?

I mean, you need food. You don't need a lap dance. So you stop spending money on lap dances, using it on food instead. Prices on lap dances go down.

But you still need food, not lap dances, so the reduction in price for a lap dance doesn't make you suddenly start buying lap dances.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by JamesianP on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:28AM (#33092780)
Strippers need to eat too though. Maybe I missing your argument. Isn't the point of lowering one's lap dance prices to get more customers to buy them?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by magicalhippo on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:57AM (#33092976)
> Isn't the point of lowering one's lap dance prices to get more customers to buy them?

Of course, that's why they lower prices. But you spent all your money on food, so you don't have any left for a lap dance.

edit: My point is that not all goods are equal. In normal times, if the price of a lap dance is too high I'll find some other entertainment with a price I find reasonable. But when food gets expensive, I still need some.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:44AM (#33092896)
That's the hope, but it doesn't mean it will happen. There is no law that says you'll find a price point that keeps your business afloat: changing economic conditions can just tank your business; the less critical the good or service is, the more likely it is to happen.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by JamesianP on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:59AM (#33092987)
Ok. Now the stripper can't afford to buy food and there's less demand for essentials after all. I'm still not getting how this helps?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:14AM (#33093076)
Just because the stripper can no longer afford food doesn't mean that food sellers will be able to lower their price. Supply issues can't be solved by price changes.

Taken to the extreme, people will die of starvation until the population adjusts, so still in the long run demand and supply will meet at the price point.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by JamesianP on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:39AM (#33093220)
But the people who were pocketing those higher profits and salaries back when gas prices went down, now do have room to cut prices though and still make money. It can't go both ways.

Anyway starving people still have labor to sell, which they will sell as cheaply as they have to, driving everyone's costs down and allowing them to cut prices after all.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:09AM (#33094352)
The price of labor isn't the problem, and anyway it has a floor. No one will work for 1 dollar a day, even if it's theoretically still better than 0 (not if bread costs 2 dollars at least - of course there are countries with such low wages).
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:58AM (#33092577)
1. Rich people already have much more income than they consume, they would likely only reduce investments/savings.

2. It takes a very long time to create a new manufacturing business, and it's hard to know how gas prices will evolve in 2-5 years time (which is a decent conservative estimate on when you would be able to start selling your products if you start today).

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:00PM (#33099842)
Reducing investment/savings reduces demand, as they are the source of funds for businesses to spend. Reduced demand reduces prices.

Any economic theory that denies the Law of Supply & Demand is false.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:15PM (#33100763)
Again, reducing demand only reduces prices if there is enough supply. If the demand already exceeded supply, then changes in demand don't do anything to price unless and until demand once again drops below supply.

Not to mention, if you think companies use all their funds every year, you're again using a very bizarre economic model. Companies often accrue money as cash savings to be used at later dates, taking it out of the economy until then.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by marcosdumay on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:28PM (#33087215)
Not all prices at the same time.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:32AM (#33092008)
Sure - goods whose production costs are not deeply tied to gas will not go up in price, or at least not as much. For example, software prices or services shouldn't immediately be affected if gas prices go up but the money supply stays relatively the same.

But electricity, gas, consumer goods, food, housing (via construction costs) - these will all go up, and they form the vast majority of consumer spending.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by wpietri on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:06PM (#33086894)
> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money with no backing.

You do realize that the US has had fiat money for decades, right? Including our longest period of low inflation, a run of nearly 4 decades. So it would seem history teaches us the opposite.

"For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong." -- H. L. Mencken

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:25PM (#33087190)
> You do realize that the US has had fiat money for decades, right?

Yes, since 1914 when the US switched to fiat money.

> Including our longest period of low inflation, a run of nearly 4 decades

The US had zero net inflation from 1800 to 1914. How much net inflation do you think happened in those 4 decades? What would a 1914 US dollar be worth today?

I'll help you out. $29.92

https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by wpietri on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:39PM (#33087372)
> The US had zero net inflation from 1800 to 1914.

This is just absurd. Not only is this a period so different than a modern economy that it's not useful for comparison, but during that period it was a roller coaster of inflation and deflation, both of which are terrible for people. Those curious can see the volatility here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Historical_Inflat...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:00PM (#33087663)
> This is just absurd. Not only is this a period so different than a modern economy that it's not useful for comparison,

I hear that a lot. Nobody is ever able to explain what law of economics changed in 1914. The Law of Supply & Demand was just the same as it always was.

> but during that period it was a roller coaster of inflation and deflation, both of which are terrible for people. Those curious can see the volatility here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Historical_Inflat...

All of the spikes were the result of the US government meddling with the economy (such as bimetalism and other nonsense, see Friedman's "Monetary History of the United States"). Except for the big one, coincidentally coincident with the California gold rush. Or is that a coincidence? Tons of gold flooding into the economy, what would the consequence of that be? Hmmm.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by wpietri on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:34PM (#33089333)
This is a straw man:

> what law of economics changed in 1914

Again, you're just ignoring the fact that our most stable period of low inflation was under fiat money. And that wasn't just true here. Central banks with well-managed money supplies brought price stability to many countries.

I understand that goldbuggery is a religion, which like many religion requires ignoring inconvenient facts. You're welcome to keep proselytizing, but if you do, I'll take my leave.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:28PM (#33089875)
> the fact that our most stable period of low inflation was under fiat money. And that wasn't just true here. Central banks with well-managed money supplies brought price stability to many countries.

Milton Friedman in "Monetary History of the United States" shows with graphs and charts that the instability was higher under the stabilizing hand of the Fed. What the Fed brought was an upward bias to it.

> I understand that goldbuggery is a religion

All I'm pointing out is the true cause of inflation. The voodoo is all the other theories trying to deny what it is.

As for stability, is that what you call the last year? All under the enlightened hand of the Fed. Prices in the supermarket have often doubled in the last year.

> Central banks with well-managed money supplies brought price stability to many countries.

Have they? Compared to what? Which countries since 1914 did not have a fiat money system?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by wpietri on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:06PM (#33098238)
Ah yes, the religious person cites religious texts:

> Monetary History of the United States

That book covers only through 1960, ending 20 years before the low-inflation era I'm talking about. Friedman retired from teaching before the era even started.

So yes, I am definitely done here.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:01PM (#33099866)
I do enjoy the contention that the laws of economics changed in 1960. Nor does "low" inflation prove that inflation is not caused by running the printing press. And nor is "low" inflation actually low. Going through my dad's estate, I'm reminded of how much cumulative inflation there's been since 1980. A 1980 dollar is worth $3.14 in 2020.

https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by senectus1 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:57PM (#33088932)
yes but in August 15, 1971 the US stopped using the gold standard.

Ever since then when the Fed needs more money they just printed it.

Reminds me of that scene in Douglas Adams Hitchhiker Guide to the Galaxy

"“Thank you. Since we decided a few weeks ago to adopt the leaf as legal tender, we have, of course, all become immensely rich. [...]

"But we have also," continued the management consultant, "run into a small inflation problem on account of the high level of leaf availability, which means that, I gather, the current going rate has something like three deciduous forests buying on ship's peanut." [...] "

One wonders when the defoliation stage is going to hit.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:29PM (#33089887)
The US went off the gold standard in 1933. Since it was illegal to trade dollars for gold, any "gold standard" was a legal fiction.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by anon291 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:59PM (#33091045)
This is not obvious at all. 'decades' is a short term in the history of money. It is perfectly reasonable to believe that switching to fiat causes low inflation in the short term but results in long term hurt. I feel if anything, the past few years should have taught us that things that seem easy or prudent in the short term can lead to long-term issues. Why is it such a stretch to believe that about fiat.

Either way I don't think 'decades' should be used as evidence that any monetary policy is good. We can reconsider if we get to centuries.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by boole1854 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:27PM (#33087213)
> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money with no backing.

The government (to be correct we should say: the Federal Reserve) has not been "printing money" for around a year now. Monetary base has actually declined by ~12% in that time:

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=UrKo

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:01PM (#33087664)
Issuing debt is the same thing.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by boole1854 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:07PM (#33090632)
Issuing governance debt is definitely different from increasing the money supply ("printing money"). Debt can be financed by borrowing from the domestic or foreign private sector or from foreign governments / central banks.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:04AM (#33092633)
That can't explain the era of extremely low inflation and it can't explain what is happening in Japan. It also cannot explain the Wörgl emergency money.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by gizmo on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:22AM (#33092735)
The "extremely low inflation era" was also a time of very high inflation in long duration assets. It was an era where we saw one company after the another being valued at over a trillion dollars. It was an era where startups without revenue could get 30bn valuations based on hot air and fanciful renderings.

Printed money has to go somewhere. If it just sits somewhere it doesn't do anything. If it goes to investments you'll see inflation there. If it goes towards goods you'll see prices rise there. For inflation it doesn't matter whether you have a lot of money flowing at a low velocity or a smaller amount of money flowing at a higher velocity. When velocity of money drops because people are worried about the future then you can print money to compensate without producing inflation in either good/services or the stock market/real estate. During a stock mania velocity of money increases and idle money turns into investment money with asset inflation as a consequence.

Wörgl -- economy suffered from too little money in circulation. Printing money fixed it.

Japan -- economy has been stagnant for decades. Printing or borrowing at near 0% is fine for them because idle money doesn't do anything. When the Japanese economy starts growing again and velocity of money increases they'll get inflation, just like everybody else. Having no growth and a flat stock market for 30 years is not a good place to be at.

It's all monetary, but the effects aren't immediate. Prices rise only when it's known the market will support these higher prices, and this price discovery takes time.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by sbf501 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:54PM (#33086682)
The more currency flooding the economy, the less wealthy the rich people are. Inflation occurs because the owners need to remain wealthy, hence prices go up everywhere. If it were possible for the top few to do with a little less, prices wouldn't have to skyrocket.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:34PM (#33087319)
> Inflation occurs because the owners need to remain wealthy, hence prices go up everywhere.

The fun thing about HN is I hear all sorts of unique economic theories not found in any econ book.

P.S. If the wealthy (or everyone else) needs more money, and just raising prices will work, why don't they do that anyway? The answer is Supply & Demand, it's the Law, and is in every econ textbook.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by autoexec on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @07:27AM (#33093985)
> If the wealthy (or everyone else) needs more money, and just raising prices will work, why don't they do that anyway?

companies are constantly raising prices to hit the highest price point customers will tolerate. Normally, when prices get too high too quickly consumers eventually get sticker shock and start to feel ripped off so they stop buying the overpriced good (assuming they have the option), so companies lower prices by a very small amount and a new generation of consumers come into the world where the almost too high price is "normal" since it's all they've known and the whole process repeats and prices just climb and climb which is why everything when your great great grandmother was alive cost a nickle but today you pay using stacks of bills.

Right now though things are pretty messed up because every company had an excuse that let them jack prices up without customers blaming them. Companies said "Supply issues! Don't be mad at us! We're all in this together!" and consumers begrudgingly accepted excessively priced goods because "that's just how it is, extraordinary circumstances" and a generation of consumers now sees those excessive prices are normal. Some companies continue to limit supply, dragging their feet ramping production back up, because they're making money hand over fist and pulling in record profits while consumers are forced to scale back and watch their standard of living decline. Now companies are saying "Don't blame us, it's this damn inflation!" and since consumers are expecting it, they can continue to jack up prices while continuing to make money hand over fist. They don't ever want to lower prices and accept a little less so prices must continue to go up and up just like before, but now it's happening at a rate they couldn't have gotten away with previously.

Companies could accept making a little less profit and lower prices and inflation would drop. They don't want to though because for them greed is the whole of the law and anything less than higher profits and endless growth is failure. Consumers could help by refusing to buy the things they love and have spent their whole lives becoming accustomed to, but they're still traumatized from a global pandemic, they're desperate for normalcy and the goods they were forced to do without for 2+ years and in denial about the fact that their lifestyle is declining and things are only going to get worse.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by sbf501 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:27PM (#33087970)
> why don't they do that anyway?

Ever heard of a company called Apple?

They raise prices all the time because they can.

Same with AT&T, or banks ATM Fees, or gas prices.

Right now gas prices are at an all time high, and so are gas profits.

> The answer is Supply & Demand, it's the Law, and is in every econ textbook.

Also, that's Econ 101. Which isn't quite reality, it's idealized for simplicity because it is an introduction to macroeconomics. But I don't want to digress into Austrian vs. Modern theory because neither of us will do justice to that.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:32PM (#33089908)
> They raise prices all the time because they can.

Why don't they raise the iphone to $10,000?

> Right now gas prices are at an all time high, and so are gas profits.

Have you ever noticed gas pump prices going down? I'm curious as to your explanation for that? Do you notice that pump prices change on a daily basis? What's your explanation for that?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by merely-unlikely on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:14PM (#33088454)
> Right now gas prices are at an all time high, and so are gas profits

Definitely not an all time high, but yes a rapid increase. According to a quick quarterly chart I pulled up, a barrel of oil was last over $100 in June 2014. It spent most of the period 2010-2014 above $80 (it's currently $86). I remember paying > $5/gallon at the pump back then. I see a peak in June 2008 at $140.

Profits are also now coming down, at least according to Exxon's report today:

"(Bloomberg) - Exxon Mobil Corp. gave an early snapshot of its earnings for the third quarter, during which refining margins shrank while profits from natural gas kept climbing. "The largest US energy company said in a filing Tuesday that margins within its energy-products segment, which includes oil refining, were as much as $2.9 billion lower compared with the second quarter. That segment posted $5.3 billion in net income in the three months through June."

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Bud on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:40PM (#33090900)
Which prices is Apple raising? Have you gone and reviewed how much Apple's products cost in the 80s and 90s? You might want to do that, quickly, before the laughter gets so loud that you are deafened.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by nottorp on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:00AM (#33092599)
Interesting enough, i put the price for an iphone 3g (499 in 2009) in an inflation calculator and it said it's worth 688 today.

However, the cheapest iphone 14 is 799..

You may be right about laptops/desktops though.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by merely-unlikely on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:13PM (#33086993)
I'm skeptical of that claim since the rich hold more assets than dollars. To the extent inflation hurts the economy then your claim is true but that is a second order affect. All else equal, inflation can simply lead to asset inflation in which case the rich maintain their wealth.

In economics circles inflation is generally considered a tax on the poor who only hold cash and whose wages are slower to rise vs price inflation.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:04PM (#33087696)
> I'm skeptical of that claim since the rich hold more assets than dollars

You should be. I doubt the rich hold any dollars at all. They invest it all. There aren't any Scrooge McDuck cash vaults.

(Criminals often do hold lots of cash, and they try to get rid of it by laundering it.)

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by seer-zig on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:57PM (#33086737)
I disagree about framing it as the top few. I recommend you look into Islam's Zakat system for something that actually works, and is fair across the board.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by ForHackernews on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:46PM (#33086555)
Ok, but why now? Why not 14 years ago, or 10 years ago, or 5 years ago? We've been in a zero-interest-rate, QE world for quite a while.

Somehow I do not think it is as trivial as your 8th grade econ textbook might suggest.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by BitwiseFool on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:02PM (#33086818)
I have only a layman's understanding of financial markets, so keep that in mind.

The explanation I've heard is that most of the QE in the 2010's was metered out in such a way that the average person wasn't receiving funds and the money wasn't quickly and directly going into the economy. The post 2008 QE purchased troubled assets and freed up institutions to lend money. It could be said that most of that QE money wound up in stocks and assets such as real estate, which is why valuations were going so crazy over the last decade while consumer goods stayed relatively flat.

All of the Covid stimulus, loans, and bailouts were different because so much more of that money went directly into the consumer economy. Price increases were exacerbated because of supply chain disruptions, needing to recoup losses from lock-downs, and the price hikes due to raw materials shortages. There is also a self-fulfilling prophecy that inflation is both higher than reported, and that our officials are lying to us about how bad the problem is. When everyone else is raising prices, it is a lot easier for a business to follow suit.

That's the explanation I've gathered while trying to understand the question and it seems reasonable to me. It may be entirely wrong, however.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by sofixa on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:26PM (#33087196)
You're not entirely wrong, but you're missing a massive piece of the puzzle, a war that is impacting the global markets in multiple very important raw material segments (oil, foodstuffs, various metals, general instability due to war involving a nuclear power in Europe, not to mention the fact that the nuclear power is losing ans it's dictator is starting to sound desperate). When prices of many products go up due to raw materials price booms, you get inflation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by marcosdumay on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:34PM (#33087318)
Have you noticed that every investment instrument saw its price go up, and up, no stop, until it had no relation to how much return it would get you, or how much money the people that wanted it for using in a secondary market could spend, and then it kept going up the same way for 2 more decades?

Yep, that's inflation too. But since the money was mostly circulating there, and the official measurements of inflation don't look at investment, it didn't make into the news.

The really good question is why the money was contained there. I don't have a good answer for it.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by gizmo on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:04AM (#33093014)
Stocks/real estate are mostly owned by richer people (and 401ks). There was plenty of inflation in luxury goods. Watches, private jets, art. Prices went through the roof.

Covid boom put money into the hands of regular people, and that -- combined with a supply shock -- made all the difference.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by marcosdumay on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:04AM (#33096485)
Yes, but it's not easy to understand how wealth can be so concentrated on the hands of the rich that it doesn't impact the "regular people economy".

Rich people buy services, and service providers are regular people. Some of the money always has to disperse, so the impact can only be neutral if there is something with similar intensity concentrating it back.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by rnernento on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:50PM (#33086625)
I don't think you realize just how much of the money has been printed in the last 2 years.

See fed balance sheet over time: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren...

See M2 over time: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by UncleMeat on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:52PM (#33086663)
So? The argument is that inflation always happens when there is fiat printing. We printed a shitload of dollars between 2000-2020, yet inflation was low throughout that period. So the explanation is clearly insufficient.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:13PM (#33086991)
> The argument is that inflation always happens when there is fiat printing.

The whole point of fiat money is to print excessive amounts of it. It's attractive for governments because they can then spend money buying votes without having to raise taxes (though inflation is a tax). Meanwhile, they blame "speculators" and "profiteers" as scapegoats for the inflation.

> yet inflation was low throughout that period

The cumulative was a lot, and note that there was never any deflation.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by prottog on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:08PM (#33086930)
The government is sandbagging CPI figures in order to lower its obligations that are tied to the official inflation rate, like Social Security payments. This isn't some underworld conspiracy theory; look at some of the academic discussion around ShadowStats.

If we take home prices, comparing 2000 to 2019 (before the pandemic-related craziness in the real estate market took place), they went up by 85% in that time period[0], compared to 48.5% in the CPI[1].

[0]: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ASPUS

[1]: https://www.minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/infl...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by vel0city on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:33PM (#33087297)
Compare 2000-2020 on that M2 graph compared to 2020-2022.

Jan 2000 - 4,666.2 Jan 2020 - 15,401.8

An increase of 10,735.6 over 120 months, average monthly increase of 89.46.

Aug 2022 - 21,711.4

An increase of 6,310 over 20 months, average monthly increase of 315.52

M2 grew 3.5x faster on average since 2020 than previously.

I'm not directly stating this is the main or only reason for inflation, but I imagine the rate of increasing the money supply 3.5x faster than before could have some kind of effect.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mixmastamyk on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:52PM (#33090993)
The price of my lunch went from ~$8 to ~$18 during this period, it is noticeable. Had a look at the stock or real-estate markets?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by TexanFeller on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:56AM (#33096376)
That would make me brown bag a sandwich.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by prottog on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:01PM (#33086813)
The price of anything that can be converted to a monthly payment, which is most things in this highly financialized economy, inflates when the interest rate is artificially suppressed. The CPI understates that kind of inflation because it looks at the monthly payment, and not the final price. So there are plenty of things like houses or college degrees that have inflated a lot more than the CPI in that "quite a while". There is no reason to believe that the value of money is immune to the law of supply and demand.

Besides, if you have an argument to make, you can make it without calling somebody an 8th grader.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by joycian on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:59PM (#33086786)
I like that you're asking for the mechanics. Many people just repeat their mantras.

If QE led to inflation quickly and in a simple way, we could have known that long ago. We didn't even have to do it ourselves: Japan did the experiment long before we did.

If you know, please explain it to me.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by 7speter on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:55PM (#33086704)
No one wants to talk about the actual problem, and will blame government printing money. What’s different now from any point in the last 12 years is that we are at full employment. Going over that causes the economy to overheat. As a study partner for an economics course put it (he took more economics than I did): too many hands competing for goods, the prices go up.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:08PM (#33087752)
> Going over that causes the economy to overheat

The notion of an "overheating" economy always sounded like nonsense to me.

> full employment

Those figures are misleading because a great many people permanently left the work force during the pandemic and are not counted as unemployment.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by chasd00 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:32PM (#33087282)
Right, the thing the Fed is doing by raising rates is increasing unemployment but trying to not come right out and say it. Increasing unemployment decreases demand and therefore prices. A hard recession is how this is going to end IMO.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by andrekandre on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:17AM (#33094426)

  > Increasing unemployment decreases demand and therefore prices.
said differently (and maybe cynically): the only way to reduce prices is to make people jobless and potentially homeless, destroying families and potentially peoples lives in the process...

maybe i am crazy, but this seems like a really bad way to run an economy?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by chasd00 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:06AM (#33096505)
You’re not crazy and it is bad but that’s how it operates. At the macro scale, the people making these decisions are just looking at percentages on a spreadsheet and turning knobs to get them where they want them.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:17PM (#33087054)
Because we just went through a massive existential shock with COVID, in which the Fed took on a staggering amount of assets i.e. liquidity - and - we've had material global problems which cause major increase in the cost of goods and fuel.

In 2008 we had a 'banking crisis' but that was an 'accounting crisis' otherwise the economy was normal. We had to re-allocate.

With COVID, we had a real shock to the system, and then lasting shocks due to increased prices.

So both the money printing and regular higher prices are coming back to hit the economy.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:55PM (#33086697)
No - this is completely false.

As an economy expands, it needs more currency to facilitate growth.

A 'very hard currency' would strangle an economy with ugly deflationary issues.

Moreover - with a 'hard currency' the system will fail and collapse when it faces an existential shock such as an internal failure (bank collapse), war, pandemic.

The objective is to provide 'the right' amount of liquidity for the economy as needed, and, during times of crisis to be able to release enough liquidity to see the economy through the crisis.

Yes, the 'price will be paid' in later years for excess liquidity in terms of higher prices, but that's not necessary a bad thing, it's just accounting. It depends on the distortions. If the community accepts that 'yes, resources needed to be diverted to pay for xyz' then that's 'the cost' and it's going to be borne out in higher prices.

And yes, if Central Banks print wily nilly and provide too much supply this will result in hyper inflation.

But fundamentally, this idea that fiat = untenable is completely false.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:09PM (#33087765)
> A 'very hard currency' would strangle an economy with ugly deflationary issues.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33087419

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by vkou on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:52AM (#33091405)
Inflation will continue as long as the economy grows. If you want to experience deflation, all you need to do is start shrinking the real economy over the long term, and make everyone else aware of it.

You'll also shut down lending, strangle spending, and remove all incentive to invest, but fortunately, the dragon hoard of cash that one has hoarded will start increasing in real value year over year.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by JamesianP on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:16AM (#33092703)
You can also cause deflation by increasing productivity, which happens in a growing economy. More competition finds more efficient ways to produce.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by lagrange77 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:46PM (#33086560)
> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money.

That's what you hear a lot, especially these days.

But is it really true? What exactly is the signal path, that leads from more money to a higher inflation? I guess, there is a fair amount of psychology involved.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by rnernento on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:54PM (#33086675)
I mean it's pretty straightforward right? There are now more dollars in play all after the same amount of goods, each dollar has less purchasing power. Why are you so quick to throw out the simplest explanation?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by fladrif on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:02PM (#33086822)
Because sometimes you lose the important details in the generalization. Counter example would be that the dollars created aren't spent depending on how they're distributed. If put under people's mattresses, put into the stock market, or sitting in a savings account, those don't enter circulation and increase the flow of money.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:05PM (#33086886)
What happens to the dollars you put into a savings account or bought stocks with? Do they disappear?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by lagrange77 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:25PM (#33089246)
Another example: A big tech company goes bankrupt, threatening thousands of jobs to disappear. The gov prints some billions to restore the liquidity of the company, which then recovers. After saving the company and its employees, those employees get the same salary as before and therefore aren't spending more. In that case the printing of money did not generate more demand, which could cause the prices to increase, or am i missing something?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:01PM (#33086805)
Because the 'simple straight forward explanation' doesn't make much sense.

As economies grow and expand, they need more money supply to keep prices stable. If you're using 100 tons of Gold as your 'fixed money supply' then you run into deflationary problems.

Also, if there is a crisis in which people get really anti-liquid and tend to hoard and do other bad things, and/or the system needs to allocate resources somewhere fast or else face destruction - then if you only have a big pot of gold split between owners, you are screwed. Mad Max style. If a country is invaded or has a pandemic, most regular levers may not work. But helicopter money can help. It implies an 'unfair' re-balancing of who owns what, but so long as the community at large accepts that, then it's fine. It means a price adjustment for everyone.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:42PM (#33087419)
Some good questions. The answer isn't simple, but I'll try.

It comes down to how banks work with fractional reserve banking. (To keep this post short, I'll refer you to google if you don't know what it is.) Banks loan out a multiple of their deposits. In other words, banks create money when they make loans. Amazing, isn't it? But, banks don't loan money unless there is collateral. The next part is tricky to understand. If I, Picasso, create a painting I create value. I can use the painting as collateral for a bank loan, i.e. because I created value, I also indirectly created money!

With me so far? Next, what happens when I repay the loan? The money disappears!

If you think about it, you'll see that the money supply, through the blind forces of Supply & Demand, tracks the value in the economy, almost like magic. While the gold it represents can sit buried in a vault somewhere and needn't actually be traded.

Inflation happens when the government prints money that has no collateral, and has no correspondence to added value in the economy and so it dilutes the value of the money that is already in circulation.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by lagrange77 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:16PM (#33089160)
> Banks loan out a multiple of their deposits. In other words, banks create money when they make loans. Amazing, isn't it?

I've heard about that, and it's really amazing.

If i understand it correctly, the loan interest i have to pay is money that also does not exist yet, at the point of time, when i get the cash. The bank faces the risk of me not being able to generate (get from others, who potentially also take loans) that extra money, so they demand a collateral as an insurance against that risk.

> Inflation happens when the government prints money that has no collateral, and has no correspondence to added value in the economy and so it dilutes the value of the money that is already in circulation.

What instance decides, if some printed money does or does not have collateral?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:38PM (#33089950)
> What instance decides, if some printed money does or does not have collateral?

A great question. No actual decision is made, it's just that there are more dollars floating chasing the same value, so the price in dollars gets bid up.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:36PM (#33090407)
This is misleading.

There is a 'decision' made and there is always collateral - at the bank, and even at the Fed.

The 'decision' that might be made, is what kind of assets to accept on the Feds balance sheet.

At a private bank, they can do whatever they want with respect to what kind of assets they accept as collateral, within regulatory requirements. They have capital ratios to uphold, but if they take stupid risks, well they are going to go out of business.

The OP is implying that money is printed out of thin air and that is not what is happening.

Your retort that 'money money, in a system of all other things being equal, will raise prices' - but the implication of 'all other things being equal' is never a reality. Economies are usually growing, in which case, they need more money to keep prices from going down actually, and, there can be external shocks, which we see every decade or so.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by landemva on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:31PM (#33090833)
This is misleading.

The Federal Reserve assumprion of bank's underperforming loans was done in 2008 with funds created out of thin air. The value of the underperforming loans was significantly less than face value, which is why banks could not sell them on the market. The Fed gave full value with magic money it created.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:03PM (#33089619)
This is kind of a misunderstanding.

Banks retain assets for loans they make. They don't print money.

But imagine this scenario: you deposit $10 at bank A, they loan that $10 to person B, that person B puts their $10 account at Bank C, thank bank loans out that $10 to person D etc..

You can see all of a sudden, $10 turns into $100! or $1000 in assets!

So what we require banks to do is keep a part of the assets they receive. So if they get $100 in deposits, they can only lend out $90 i.e. they have to keep '10% in reserve'.

This means that banks are leveraged at 90%.

It also means that if there is a calamity, and a 'run on the bank' or it loses 10% of it's assets, the bank is wiped out.

So what all of this means is that there is 'leverage' in the system, and it means there is 10x money going into the economy than is released by the Fed. It definitely adds a lot of flexibility to the system. Banks are still responsible for evaluating risk of their loans and paying the price if they fail.

"The interest on the loan" is mostly a function of risk and the cost of that bank managing that money i.e. getting the depositors to loan you the money in the first place.

The OP's definition of 'inflation' is a bit warped.

Inflation is when there's more money than demand for stuff.

If stuff is harder to make or is more rare, prices will go up irrespective of money supply.

If you throw money in the economy for no reason inflation will happen.

But most economies are expanding a bit, and so they need more money in the supply to keep prices stable, which is why we like to have just a bit of money printing.

All money loaned out - even given out by the central banks has collateral. The Fed keeps mostly TBills (Government Debt) and real estate as collateral.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:45PM (#33090007)
> They don't print money.

Oh, absolutely they do. That's why currency is called "banknotes". The banks printed them. Each bank printed their own banknotes. You can find their images in numismatics books.

In 1914, the government took over the function of printing banknotes. But the banks still print money. We just call them "cashier's checks", "money orders" and "travelers' checks". But more normally, they simply credit your account with created money.

> If stuff is harder to make or is more rare, prices will go up irrespective of money supply.

That isn't inflation, because extra dollars are not being created. For example, tomatoes going up in price in the store because of crop failure isn't inflation, because more money doesn't appear in your pocket to pay the premium. What happens is you wind up with fewer dollars in your pocket, meaning you buy less of other things, and with the annoying Law of Supply and Demand, the prices of those other things drop.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:45PM (#33090470)
Listen, you are really confusing yourself and others here.

That banks used to print notes in the past is not relevant in this discussion, when we talk about 'printing money' what we are referring to is how money comes into circulation. Physical bank notes are barely relevant to the equation as it makes up a tiny portion of the money supply, and of course, they are only printed by the Central Bank.

Money comes into circulation when the Central Bank 'buys' TBills off the free market. That's when the Central Bank 'creates' money.

Then, through fractional lending, a considerably larger amount of money ends up getting into the system by way of accounting.

Finally, the 'credit market' - which is really 10x bigger than even money in circulation, and which is the real thing that matters in business, develops like a bubble on top of that.

"That isn't inflation, because extra dollars are not being created."

Yes - it is 100% inflation and you are absolutely spreading false information at that point.

The 'result' could be as simple as 'less of that product is bought' - meaning, we use 'less gas' when gas prices rise - while every other aspect of the economy remains mostly the same. That is 100% inflation.

Aside from 'buying less of the product with price increase' or 'buying less of other stuff' we can also borrow, use savings, buy on credit etc. to adjust for the price inflation - so it's not going to necessarily work out to be some kind of net price levelling in the economy.

Increasing prices = inflation [1]. That's it. It's not necessarily related to money supply.

And finally - as the economy expands, more money needs to be introduced into the system just to keep prices even. This is an example of where there is more money supply and it does not change prices.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:56PM (#33088275)
I think you are misunderstanding fractional lending and collateral.

Fractional lending seems a bit odd, but it's not like there is 'no collateral' - rather, there ends up being 'partial collateral'.

As it turns out, that 'partial collateral' is enough - it's actually reasonable thing to do, because the vast majority of loans are repaid, it's not necessary to fully collateralize everything on the whole.

Banks have to have some capital requirements, which means, if they 'screw up' too badly, then they go bankrupt! So they are acting in a capitalist manner and have to be careful about how they lend, and at what rates. If random bank acts irresponsibly, then random bank will go kaput by regular market forces.

Instead of thinking of fractional lending as 'missing money' think of it more like leverage.

Basically - the effect of fractional lending is that it's a 'multiplier' to whatever the Central Bank decides to do.

So it exacerbates effects in one direction or the other but on the whole, it doesn't change the real nature of the system.

The way we manage money is sound.

We need money to expand and contract, and we have good ways to measure that.

The 'danger' of fiat of course is political intervention, or a failure of controls.

We had a broad intervention in 2008 that favoured home owners over others, and there are attempts to use the Central Bank to do 'Social Justice' type things, which I think is very risky.

It's a bit like Nuclear Energy: it's very potent, you just have to watch it responsibly.

Finally - currency should be a 'current' asset, not a store of value. We just want it as a medium of exchange. So as long as it's not shifting too much one way or another, then it should work.

For 'stores of value' there are other things, like real estate etc..

"Inflation happens when the government prints money that has no collateral, and has no correspondence to added value in the economy and so it dilutes the value of the money that is already in circulation. "

This is misleading.

The 'government' does not print money, the Central Bank does. And as you indicate, the bank ultimately creates credit via fractional lending.

'Inflation' happens when the cost of goods rise faster than the money in circulation.

Thus 'inflation' can happen because 'stuff is more costly to make'. Like gas in Europe, is more expensive, not because 'money printing' but 'Russia'.

Also, inflation can feasibly happen without money printing or even a rise in inherent cost of goods, if the economy shifts in a way that ends up in excess cash.

But ultimately, if during normal course of 'growth' if there is no expansion in the monetary base, then you'll have deflation, which has bad externalizes.

So the goal then is to adjust interest rates / print or extract money from the economy so that prices stay roughly flat, with just a tiny bit of inflation. That is a dynamic process, not a static process.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:51PM (#33090056)
Rather bluntly, a central bank is central economic planning. Central economic planning always falls short of what free markets do. The idea that a central bank is able to control the financial markets better than free market forces is shown to be false (with actual data) by Friedman in "Monetary History of the United States".

> The 'government' does not print money, the Central Bank does.

I said "print money" as a euphemism for what the Fed actually does, which is the same thing, it just doesn't involve doing the old fashioned way. They do it by issuing debt with no collateral.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by stopping on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:26AM (#33092760)
So why is it that essentially every developed country in the world today has a central bank? How can they all be wrong? If a 100% "free market" solution was more effective than central banking, I would expect at least one of them to have given it a shot and succeeded in doing so.

Also, "A Monetary History of the United States" argues that the Federal Reserve should have done more to combat the Great Depression, not less. How can you think that the book advocates against central economic policy?

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by andrekandre on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:26AM (#33094544)

  > The idea that a central bank is able to control the financial markets better than free market forces is shown to be false
thats probably true in many cases, but that got me thinking: was the great depression a failure of central banking or financial markets?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jollybean on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:13AM (#33092245)
Rather bluntly, this is just not true.

I think there is an erroneous understanding/implication in your statement, which is likely leading you to erroneous conclusion.

The Fed is not 'Central Planning' so much as it is actually trying to make the market more 'neutral' in normal cases.

We'll get to the 'crisis' cases in a bit.

If we just had a hard currency, like Gold (which 'feels' neutral) we'd get into trouble, because of deflationary issues. People would treat it like Bitcoin, and as prices fell slightly would be oriented a bit towards 'store of value' as opposed to currency.

The Fed 'targets' just a 'bit above zero' inflation by policy. That is basically 'neutral'.

That is not really 'central planning', it's more like 'central neutralization'.

As for 'crisis' situations, i.e. when the Fed does start to 'intervene' and does things which you might argue are 'central planning' - well - the government in many cases can absolutely do it 'better than free markets' because only the government has the scale to do it.

For example, 'free markets' could have not have created and executed the Highway road system of the 1950s. It was of a scale and scope far, far beyond any economic actor. That required 'strategic vision' on behalf of the government. Now - private contractors actually did the 'building' - which is how we want it because the government doesn't need to hire individual workers. But it's a government project by virtue of scale and other things.

The meltdown of 2008 was a very scary time - if the government did not intervene, the banks would have collapsed, and it would have taken down the entire economy.

It would be like a human having a 'heart attack' - the heart stops - everything stops.

So the government put together a plan and intervened. A lot of it had to do with 'confidence signals' and other things, extra regulation, but it worked.

There is of course the 'Too Big To Fail' argument i.e. moral hazard i.e. banks take on more risk knowing the 'gov will save' us - that said, the worst actors did definitely lose a ton of money. Also - the problem was not just the banks, it was a systemic failure in a number of sectors.

Basically - the US had an economic cancer and no individual organization was going to be able to contend with it.

So -> intervention. Much like a war, or pandemic.

Having a fiat currency allows that opportunity. If it were a 'Gold Based Economy' it would have fallen down like a house of cards.

Like a brick building during a rare earhtquake: brick 'feels' strong like Gold, but an earthquake will ravage it, which is why you need steel reinforcement - the steel can bend and absorb different kind of tensions.

Milton Friedman is wrong.

Yes, when there is hyperinflation, it's probably because some stupid government is printing too much money, but inflation is not just a function of money printing.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by landemva on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:13PM (#33088448)
> you run into deflationary problems.

Deflation means people who save increase their purchasing power without gambling on stonks. The savers mentality is called low time preference.

Any problems from less consumerism would be felt by junk producers: plastic spinner toys, yet another streaming service, iGadget yearly upgrades. High time preference people are the market for short-lived trash. A currency with disappearing value encourages such consumption because it does not hold value.

Due to technology and manufacturing advances, price decreases (deflation) are natural.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by nichohel on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:54PM (#33086677)
The "signal path" is simply the presence of more money, which means that purchasers have more money to pay.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by saynay on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:20PM (#33087105)
That is a bit of an oversimplification. The presence of money is no sufficient, that money must be in circulation. For example, they can print all the money they want, if they just toss it all in a big bank account and never remove it, there will be no inflation.

That was a big reason why printing a lot of money in the past did not contribute to a lot of inflation: most of that money ended up sitting in the accounts of a few big institutions, who then did not end up spending it on anything.

This time around, we both gave that money directly to people (who then spent all of it), but also were dealing with global supply issues, an energy crunch, a food crunch, etc. Everyone had more money to spend, but there were less things to spend it on, leading to dramatic price increases.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by nichohel on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:33PM (#33087303)
You have a sort of a point; what I should have said was, 'The "signal path" is simply having more money in the hands of buyers, which will then necessarily cause an increase in prices.'
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by lagrange77 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:01PM (#33088985)
> The "signal path" is simply having more money in the hands of buyers, which will then necessarily cause an increase in prices.

So from that point on, the mechanism is supply & demand right? Buyers with money increase demand, therefore the prices increase.