News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:47PM (#33086569)
This is a very simplistic viewpoint. One could also argue that Inflation happens when people don't trust that their government will pay back all the money borrowed.

The US govt has been on a spending spree as of late, but hasn't yet bothered to mention how they are going to pay for it.

In 2008/2009, the US govt was also on a spending spree, but did promise to pay the bill eventually. Inflation didn't spike in 2008/2009.

The bottom line is, nobody really KNOWS, we just have guesses. My guess currently fits all the facts, where yours does not, but that doesn't mean my guess is right, but perhaps it's more correct than your version.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:18PM (#33087075)
> perhaps it's more correct than your version.

My version has lots and lots and LOTS of history backing it up.

Did you know that the US had inflation when on the gold standard during the California and Yukon gold rushes?

Did you know that Spain experienced massive inflation during the period when they were shipping the silver in S. America across the Atlantic?

I could go on and on.

> One could also argue that Inflation happens when people don't trust that their government will pay back all the money borrowed.

This sort of thing happens with private banknotes, which would trade at a discount based on the level of trust. But that is a one-time discount, not a cumulative process.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:03PM (#33088343)
I agree that there is lots of data that shows your version has some merit, but that doesn't mean it's 100% correct. I know of at least one instance where your version was incorrect(2008/2009). Again, I'm not arguing my version is correct, and I'm not even arguing that your version is completely wrong, because we literally do not know.

Read some John Cochrane[0] if you want a more academic defence of my version(which is where I got it from, I'm certainly not smart enough to have come up with it myself).

0: https://www.justicenewsflash.com/2022/01/03/the-grumpy-econo...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:56PM (#33089549)
> I know of at least one instance where your version was incorrect(2008/2009).

One one hand, we have thousands of years of history with what causes inflation.

On the other hand, we have one instance.

I'd say one has to examine the one counterexample for something missed. (Your cite makes no mention of 2008/2009.) Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Recall my other post here about how making loans creates money, and paying the loans back destroys it. Bankruptcy destroys money. I wonder if all the bankruptcies, defaults, haircuts and writedowns removed a vast amount of money from circulation, and the deficit spending simply filled that hole rather than creating more inflation.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:10AM (#33092665)
>One one hand, we have thousands of years of history with what causes inflation.

Yeah we know that inflation is caused by an insufficient internalisation of liquidity costs on the beneficiaries of liquidity.

This makes them destroy the supply of money that is available for transactions which then forces people to create new transaction available money to replace the loss.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:43AM (#33095481)
Thousands of years of pre Adam smith history where the concept of macroeconomics did not exist. Obviously a naive implementation of monetary expansion causes price inflation, that doesn’t mean a well implemented monetary expansion does though.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:22PM (#33099278)
The Law of Supply & Demand is there whether it is recognized or not.

> that doesn’t mean a well implemented monetary expansion does though

Then none of them are well implemented, because all examples of fiat money exhibit endemic inflation. The reason is straightforward - the whole point of a fiat money system is to inflate it.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:44PM (#33099627)
The decade following 08 had exactly the goal inflation even though there was unprecedented monetary expansion.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:12PM (#33090220)
> (Your cite makes no mention of 2008/2009.)

Incorrect: "One may look to politicians’ statements. Even in the Obama-era “stimulus” spending, the administration emphasized promises of eventual debt reduction. " And I have more to say on it later.

My cite is from a world-class economist, not from some random person on the Internet.

> One one hand, we have thousands of years of history with what causes inflation. > On the other hand, we have one instance.

Again, you are assuming facts not in evidence, you assume your version of reality is correct, likely because that is what economics text books taught you, because they also assumed it to be the case, these assumptions do not make it true.

Perhaps those thousands of years of history actually agree with my version also. We don't know what people were thinking across those thousands of years of inflation history, it's possible they were thinking our governments(such as they were) were not trusted to pay it back, as generally speaking, governments that go on large spending sprees tend to not pay it back very well. It's hard to be disciplined with money when there is very little incentive to politicians while in office.

There is no rigorous proof of what causes inflation. There are many well-educated guesses and your perspective was the common wisdom for a long time. That doesn't make it true, no matter how much you want it to be.

I'm pretty sure my version is also wrong, but it's at least an interesting perspective rather than "money printers go brrr inflation then always happens".

> Recall my other post here about how making loans creates money, and paying the loans back destroys it.

I don't agree with the second part of this sentence. I completely agree that the banks create money out of thin air when they decide to loan you $100k. But if you pay it back, more money is created as part of the interest payments on that $100k. If you don't pay it back:

> Bankruptcy destroys money.

True.

> I wonder if all the bankruptcies, defaults, haircuts and writedowns removed a vast amount of money from circulation, and the deficit spending simply filled that hole rather than creating more inflation.

The US government made money on it[0]. I'm almost positive there is essentially a zero percent chance of making any of the trillions we spent in 2020 back. We have to pay all that borrowing off somehow, either we raise taxes or we inflate it away. It seems like we are on the inflation train version for now at least.

Though perhaps your comment is also partially true, there was some bankruptcies(one might argue not enough). A quick web search didn't turn up any good data on the amount(s) though and I'm to lazy to do more research on it, but if you have done some, I'd be interested.

0: https://money.usnews.com/investing/articles/2017-01-19/finan...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:11PM (#33090659)
> There is no rigorous proof of what causes inflation.

There's no rigorous proof that smoking causes cancer, either. All we have is a lot of correlation.

The historical evidence of printing non-collateralized money corresponding with inflation is overwhelming. It corresponds with gold rushes, and silver rushes. It corresponds with debasing coins by mixing in cheap metals.

Me, I'm going where the evidence leads.

> I completely agree that the banks create money out of thin air when they decide to loan you $100k. But if you pay it back,

It is the inverse operation - destroying it. But of course, the bank creates it again for the next loan.

> more money is created as part of the interest payments on that $100k.

No, it does not. I wish I could create money to pay the interest on my loans, but I can't (at least not legally!). I use existing money to pay them.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by chubs on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:17AM (#33093090)
Always fantastic to see someone standing up for basic economics here!

My favourite tech-communicable way to consider it is this: Money is like 'points' for prioritising the way people/resources are allocated in the world, somewhat like agile/scrum planning poker. If you give everyone cards with larger points values, you'll still get the same amount of work done in a given sprint, it's just that you'll get an inflated 'sprint velocity' (eg story points implemented in a fortnight).

Apologies if i've explained this poorly!

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Thursday October 06, 2022 @11:19AM (#33109351)
> No, it does not. I wish I could create money to pay the interest on my loans, but I can't (at least not legally!). I use existing money to pay them.

LOL, wrong perspective, think of it from the banks point of view. They make money from you for creating money and letting you use some of it.

Again, this whole "creating money" thing is very simplistic perspective, they have limits on how much of this they can do, etc.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Izkata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:00AM (#33095674)
Looks like 2008 was a deflationary recession [0], so sounds like that money printing caused enough inflation to counter it and hold ~steady.

[0] https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/040715/were-there-a...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:08AM (#33092653)
>But that is a one-time discount, not a cumulative process.

Providing liquidity is a cumulative process.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by W3cUYxYwmXb5c on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:51PM (#33087536)
Monetary inflation is the increase in the money supply. Price inflation is one of the potential symptoms of monetary inflation. Too often people look at just one symptom to gauge the occurrence of the cause. Currently we are experiencing both, but people seem to want to ignore the inflation of the money supply, and scratch our heads over every other variable that affects prices.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:07AM (#33092649)
Ok, now introduce negative interest rates on cash.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by jnwatson on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:00PM (#33086801)
We have very educated guesses.

The primary difference between 2008 and now with respect to monetary policy is money velocity. Increasing money supply is a necessary but insufficient condition for inflation.

In 2008, much of that money sat uninvested, so it didn’t impact the price of goods. In 2020, most of it got used to buy and invest.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by zie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:21PM (#33088544)
We do have educated guesses, The OP and my comment are 2 of them. There are more of them for sure.

It wasn't un-invested, it just didn't much make it out to buy consumer goods(at least not as directly as in 2020).

Like all things the devil is in the details, which get stupidly complicated.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by dasil003 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:58PM (#33086761)
There’s also a tipping point where inflation is self propelled because everyone is used to it so they just proactively raise prices on a regular basis. I experienced this growing up in Brazil in the 80s and 90s. It’s hard for Americans to relate, but essentially the mentality is spend/invest every penny you get before it loses value. Took some creative policy to break the cycle: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plano_Real
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:22PM (#33087129)
> There’s also a tipping point where inflation is self propelled because everyone is used to it so they just proactively raise prices on a regular basis.

This is called cost-push inflation. Unfortunately, that theory doesn't explain where the extra dollars come from.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by dasil003 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:33PM (#33087302)
Why would you expect there to be some unifying theory of inflation? It's an emergent phenomenon resulting from the actions of many individual actors. I'm quite sure the people raising the prices every week had no idea how much cash was in circulation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:52PM (#33087551)
Fiat money (or anything that increases the supply of money, like gold rushes) is the common factor with all instances of inflation. There are thousands of years of examples of this.

You're right on one point, the Law of Supply & Demand. It is an emergent property of many individual actions, though each might be completely ignorant of the big picture.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by lottin on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:59AM (#33091455)
Another common factor in all cases of inflation was the moon orbiting the Earth, so clearly the moon is causing inflation.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:24PM (#33099315)
Your theory doesn't explain deflation. Mine does.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:35AM (#33092823)
Egyptians used grain money which spoils over time and the grain banks charged the depositors a fee for the liquidity they provide. If you want a stable banking system you are going to have to make depositors pay for the costs they impose onto other people.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:25PM (#33099334)
I suggest reading up on how banks make money from fractional reserve banking. No need for depositors to pay, and in fact lending money is so lucrative banks will pay the depositors.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Izkata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:06AM (#33095750)
One of the reasons to raise price is to discourage people from buying when you have limited stock. Sellers can tell where their supply is coming from, compare it to how much stock they have left, and compare that to normal times. So yeah, they do have such a signal, though it is secondary to the actual reason for the price increase.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by sidewndr46 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:23PM (#33090769)
All you've done here is dress up the "it's really complicated, you wouldn't understand it" dismissal in nicer terms.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mypalmike on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:06AM (#33091497)
Economists working for oil companies certainly don't ignore money supply.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by Calavar on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:50AM (#33092528)
Why would there need to be any extra dollars? If inflation is a matter of supply and demand of currency, as you say, then shouldn't we expect that a demand-side shift could lead to inflation without any change in the money supply?
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by hnick on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:55AM (#33093332)
Makes sense to me, the thing that matters is not total money but active money. Prices go up because there is the same amount of money, but sellers expect more, and buyers are used to paying more. This can continue by having their proportion of earnings/wealth spent increased which increases total liquid money supply, until they are at capacity (i.e. spending their whole income, selling off assets, etc).

Basically the inverse of people being averse to spending and instead hoarding cash, leading to deflation as prices are lowered to tempt them into spending again.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by wahern on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:11PM (#33087789)
AFAIU from reading about the Plano Real and some other cases, the extra dollars come from the central bank being stuck between a rock and a hard place. If they don't print the extra money, then inflation accelerates--a scarcer dollar increases in real value, but non-intuitively this doesn't produce deflation unless you're prepared to hold your ground while the economy and society incinerates in the chaos.

EDIT: I think this is one of the primary phenomenons creating the dilemma for the central bank and government: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_inflation But IIRC from the Brazil case, informal expectations and pricing strategies in the supply chain (from factory to corner store) were at least as important as contracts.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mixmastamyk on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:36PM (#33090863)
Not really, it happened in the US in the 70s and early 80s. Not as high as in some countries, but enough to make a difference in behavior.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by roenxi on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:27AM (#33092772)
There is no reason to believe the situation is complex. The value of money is changing because the authority that controls money is changing it.

Nobody understands the economy. But we can be pretty sure that it isn't the economy destroying the value of the dollar, because there is no reason for consistent annual inflation to be happening. If anything, in the absence of money creation, we should be seeing deflation because of technological improvements. Short term wobbles, sure, maybe even sometimes a few straight years of inflation due to exceptional conditions. But that isn't what is happening.

The only thing that can have caused the dollar to lose value consistently is creating new money. Otherwise we'd see it regularly snapping back to normal value with deflation. Which, in my lifetime, I think may have literally never happened.