News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:30PM (#33087259)
> Of course, that is almost a tautology

Inflation lags the money printing, so it isn't a tautology.

> So what do you do to get that sweet spot of about 1-2% inflation?

I'm amazed that propaganda of a sweet spot gets so heavily embedded into the popular wisdom.

If there is a sweet spot for inflation, it's 0%.

Note that the US had net 0% inflation from 1800-1914, while growing from subsistence farming to superpower.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by woodruffw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:01AM (#33091057)
> Note that the US had net 0% inflation from 1800-1914, while growing from subsistence farming to superpower.

This is grossly ahistorical: in 1914, 2/3rds of the US lived in abject poverty[1]. Individual farming, including subsistence farming, didn't peak until the 1930s[2]. The US's ascent to superpower status can be traced, at the earliest, to lending programs begun during WWI (and repeated, to fantastic effect, during WWII).

The US's phenomenal ascent in international status and power is directly tied to its monetary policy, a policy that has more or less kept inflation around 2% since 1935[3].

[1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20150720050803/https://www.irp.w...

[2]: https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistic...

[3]: https://www.thebalancemoney.com/u-s-inflation-rate-history-b...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:35PM (#33099495)
> in 1914, 2/3rds of the US lived in abject poverty[1]

Your cite doesn't support that. Besides, during the 19th century average height increased enormously (a sign of good and consistent nutrition), mortality rates dropped dramatically, life expectancy increased, and the growth of the middle class was spectacular.

When the US entered WW1, the German soldiers were shocked by how tall they were, and how well fed and well supplied they were.

I.e. your claim is completely false.

> The US's phenomenal ascent in international status and power is directly tied to its monetary policy

None of your cites support that, either.

See "Historical Statistics of the United States Colonial Times To 1970, volumes 1 and 2". I think you can download it from archive.org. It's a gold mine.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by woodruffw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:49PM (#33099710)
> Besides, during the 19th century average height increased enormously (a sign of good and consistent nutrition), mortality rates dropped dramatically, life expectancy increased, and the growth of the middle class was spectacular.

Growth is good, but it's a delta: it doesn't mean that the average life was particularly nice by modern standards. The fact that things improved over time is not evidence that they were good at any instant (and indeed, nobody questions that things improved: they clearly had to in order to get to where we are now).

In 1914, the average male life expectancy was 52[1]. That's over 20 years shorter than our current life expectancies.

> When the US entered WW1, the German soldiers were shocked by how tall they were, and how well fed and well supplied they were.

This is a comparative error: the US's military population didn't need to be well fed by objective standards; they only needed to be better fed than the peasants who were press-ganged into the German army.

Nobody is saying that the US was uniquely impoverished by contemporaneous metrics; the claim is that the US was impoverished on an absolute and modern scale, and that said impoverishment declined as the US established domestic and international policies that are inextricably linked to its monetary policy.

[1]: https://u.demog.berkeley.edu/~andrew/1918/figure2.html

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:47AM (#33095530)
0% inflation is incredibly dangerous. Deflation is just about the worst possible thing that can happen to an economy. It instantly kills money market liquidity as real interest rates rise as they hit the lower bond for nominal rates. People stop spending as much as they can since their money will be worth more in the future. So the question is how can we guarantee no deflation. And the only answer is target 1-2% inflation.

By the way the us was in a recession for practically the entirety of the second half of the 19th century, mostly because of absolutely garbage monetary policy.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:39PM (#33099536)
> 0% inflation is incredibly dangerous.

Oh rubbish.

> By the way the us was in a recession for practically the entirety of the second half of the 19th century

Completely false. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/files/docs/meltzer/cenlon66.pd...

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:43AM (#33092891)
>I'm amazed that propaganda of a sweet spot gets so heavily embedded into the popular wisdom.

Because that sweet spot is very similar to the benefits liquidity confers to the holder of liquidity. Come on grandpa, please don't tell me all the people "bringing their wares to the market" are doing so at no cost and that the holders of liquidity aren't benefitting from stores optimistically stocking goods.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by stopping on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:01AM (#33092603)
Dismissing a contrary position as "propaganda" only stifles debate, and you haven't presented an argument against "sweet spots". It's a good mental model for many situations. What makes you think there doesn't exist an optimal inflation rate?

0% inflation is generally not a safe target. In an economy you want to avoid deflation at all costs. If consumers expect future price drops, demand can dip significantly and induce further drops in price (deflationary spiral). Businesses need consistent, predictable demand, else they enact shortsighted, over-reactive responses (e.g. layoffs) which can further exacerbate an economic downturn. See the Japanese financial crisis. Even a small fluctuation into deflationary territory can have long-lasting effects on consumer perception. It's safer (read: insurance policy) to maintain a slightly positive inflation rate so that consumers are encouraged to make purchase decisions promptly when needs arise versus indefinite speculative postponement.

Of course, the "optimal" inflation rate is context-dependent. Your unique economic situation will dictate which inflation trade-offs you end up selecting.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:45PM (#33099642)
This is all unsupported by any evidence. The "deflationary spiral" theory is as wrong as its sister, the "inflationary spiral".

Inflation benefits borrowers, hurts lenders. Deflation hurts borrowers, benefits lenders.

The sweet spot is 0.

The reason everybody believes that inflation is good for you is because of persistent government propaganda to sell that idea, because what inflation really is is a tax on your money. That's right, a tax.

Now, if you want to argue that the inflation tax is a reasonable way for the government to raise revenue, ok, but be realistic as to what it is. Inflation isn't good for you any more than taxing you is good for you.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by stopping on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:24PM (#33100155)
Nothing of what you said is an argument against the points I made. Where is the error in my reasoning? I literally gave an example of my argument applying to a real life, well studied scenario.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:27PM (#33100198)
The "deflationary spiral" has empirical evidence from a fair number of financial crises in the 19th and early 20th centuries. It happened. A lot. And it was really destructive when it did.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:31PM (#33102938)
Too late to edit, so replying to myself: There also is plenty of evidence for the "inflationary spiral". See Zimbabwe for a recent example.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by rightbyte on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:26AM (#33092758)
> If consumers expect future price drops, demand can dip significantly and induce further drops in price

Sounds awesome? Saves resources. People save money for a rainy day. Lending goes down.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by imtringued on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:52AM (#33092944)
Money is necessary to conduct transactions. If people are incapable of transacting because some people play a hoarding game like with Bitcoin then real people's real basic needs like food or housing won't be met. You will get wholly pointless homelessness.

How do we make sure that money cannot be abused to doom the rest of the economy into an inability to transact? You make people pay for the benefits they receive by holding onto money. People hate free markets, they are against paying for the costs they cause.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by randomdata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:40AM (#33095441)
> Money is necessary to conduct transactions.

Not necessarily. Money is little more than a distributed IOU held from providing past benefit to someone else to be used in exchange for future benefit from someone else. Money records that I did work for you now and in return you will do work for me later, except given that the IOU is recognized in a distributed fashion the work later can also come from other people.

IOUs bring a lot of benefit, but aren't strictly necessary to conduct a transaction. I could work for you now and at the same time you could work for me to provide equal value. Since there is no delay between services rendered there is no need to record that the other party promises to provide a future benefit. The transaction is already complete in the moment.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by KptMarchewa on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @05:19AM (#33093094)
And you get fired from your job because demand for it disappears. Amazing.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by autoexec on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @06:58AM (#33093786)
Demand doesn't disappear. People still want the things they want. They just might not be wiling to pay as much as others would like them to. Lower the prices, and suddenly those people can justify (or even simply afford) satisfing the demand that never went away. People spending leads to more jobs.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by KptMarchewa on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:21AM (#33095917)
>Lower the prices, and suddenly those people can justify (or even simply afford) satisfing the demand that never went away.

Or they can wait more to buy cheaper. Sure, they won't do that if you sell carrots, but they will do if you sell cars.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by autoexec on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:51PM (#33099741)
As if prices are going to come down. If the companies who have been making record profits refuse to accept making a little less profit and won't lower prices how long will you have to wait to buy something cheaper.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by stopping on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:37AM (#33092843)
Not at all. The issue of rampant consumerism is mostly orthogonal to issues of overall economic stability. Deflation will certainly reduce consumption, but at the cost of massive societal upheaval by way of extreme unemployment and all of its ill effects.
Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by randomdata on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:24AM (#33094509)
> If consumers expect future price drops

Which they do. The only time in US history where a significant inflationary spike was not followed by deflation was in the long run up (already making it an outlier) in the 1970s through 1980s, and inflation in that period transpired primarily due to wage inflation. As wages are the stickiest of all, you don't get downward movement on price when the tide shifts, you simply see unemployment shoot through the roof.

When fertilizer availability is no longer the most pressing concern facing humanity, something we are unlikely to not be able to resolve in due time, there won't be much reason for prices to persist. There is little to no stickiness here and it tumbles from there.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by foobarian on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:44PM (#33088149)
I don’t know, the concept just makes sense to me intuitively. There are enough weird effects in systems and math when things are at zero that I just can’t tell what would happen. Example, in queueing theory when input rate is equal to output rate under reasonable randomness you get large backlogs. When everything drains at just a few percent over zero it just seems like a better system.

The US also had a civil war during that period. And then repeated brutal boom and bust cycles until Breton Woods.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:20PM (#33089812)
We still have boom and bust cycles, but with persistent inflation.

As for the Civil War, the US government printed fiat money during it.

Re:Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us? by mixmastamyk on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:39PM (#33090890)
^Became a superpower in the 1940s gearing up for WWII and then the only country left standing with brand new factories.