News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by woodruffw on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:01PM (#32183418)
This is a really excellent read, and neatly summarizes a thought that flashes through the back of my mind whenever someone tells me that public transit is unsafe.

If over 100 people died each day on public transit, we'd have banned it by now. But we accept it in our automotive culture, while simultaneously handwringing over every incident that happens on public transit.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by digdugdirk on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:58PM (#32184158)
I find many of the issues brought up about public transit being unsafe revolve around the people you might encounter on public transit (drug users, homeless, mental illness, etc.) and the waiting around/walking to public transit stops (muggings, thefts, etc.)

I've never had any issues myself, but have absolutely been exposed to those issues while taking transit. I've also witnessed those issues increase during/post lockdown.

I have no solutions, just pointing out a different angle on the "unsafe" issue mentioned above. I'd love to hear if anyone has any experience or ideas to reduce this perception of a lack of safety.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by woodruffw on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:35PM (#32184656)
Right: public transport puts you in media res, exposing you to the other people around you. That's overwhelmingly average folks trying to go between work, home, and errands, but it's also the occasional disturbed person.

I will not deny that you'll find all kinds of antisocial behavior on public transit. What I'll say is this: that it's fundamentally a civic issue and not a public transit issue, and that even with all that behavior we still see nowhere near the amount of death and disfigurement that people experience on America's roads on a daily basis.

To make it pithy: we incorrectly prioritize the feeling of environmental safety over statistical safety. The reality is that the inebriated homeless guy on the subway is much less likely to harm you or take your life than the inebriated driver in the next lane.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by aidenn0 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:21PM (#32184478)
IMO there's only really 2 underlying issues people have with public transit:

1. In nearly all of the US (maybe everywhere except parts of NYC?) it is a worse experience than driving (requires planning, takes longer, can't carry more than one or two bags with you).

2. It is déclassé.

I think #2 is at least partly a result of #1. Also note that #1 is true even for most cities in the US, because cities in the US are unbelievably car friendly compared to cities in e.g. western Europe. I don't see any public-transit solution that doesn't involve intentionally making the car experience worse, and that's going to be a tough sell to voters.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by PaulsWallet on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:19PM (#32185229)
> 2. It is déclassé.

“A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It’s where the rich use public transportation” – Gustavo Petro

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by woodruffw on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:38PM (#32184690)
> I think #2 is at least partly a result of #1

And vice versa. As I said in a thread yesterday[1]: we justify our continuing neglect of public transit by claiming that "polite society" avoids it, which in turn fulfills the prophecy.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32165783

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by aidenn0 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:12PM (#32185846)
That's partly it, but the status quo in the US is of the car infrastructure being so good that driving in the US is a better experience than taking public transit in many places with excellent public transit. Therefore #1 will remain true as long as we don't downgrade (either intentionally or via neglect) the car infrastructure, and taking things away from people is always harder than just not giving it to them in the first place.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by woodruffw on Thursday July 21, 2022 @10:43PM (#32187870)
This is a great point, but I’ll also note: neglect of our automotive infrastructure is a matter of when, not if. A consistent theme among suburbs in the Strong Towns surveys is unsustainable financing of municipal and county roads. Even at the state and federal levels, our road funding doesn’t accurately reflect the biggest sources of wear (trailer and other shipping traffic).

It’s not like we’re ever going to regress into a nation without interstates. But there will be a significant reckoning over the next 50 years over the increasing burden of our overdeveloped road network.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by Aunche on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:28PM (#32184564)
There are plenty of crazy, dangerous people on the road too. Psychologically, you feel more separated than them, even if they may be statistically be more dangerous.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by HideousKojima on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:41PM (#32184743)
They can't mug me or grope me or blast music on their phone 3 feet away from me though. To be fair occasionally there will be idiot drivers blasting their bass so loud it vibrates nearby cars, but that's far less common than inconsiderate assholes blasting music on their phones on public transit.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by mrep on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:50PM (#32184859)
Yeah, basically every girl I have ever dated avoids public transit at all cost because of assholes/creeps.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by scrumbledober on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:38PM (#32185469)
I was thinking something similar. It's easy for me to argue for public transportation as a 6 foot tall man with martial arts training. I still get a little uncomfortable catching a late night bart ride sometimes...
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by whimsicalism on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:35PM (#32185448)
These sorts of things can be self selected. I know plenty of women who take public transit. The dividing line tends to be whether they grew up in a city or moved from the suburbs (and of course affluence).
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by bcrosby95 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:36PM (#32184663)
I definitely feel safer on public transit. I live in an upper class neighborhood and I'm not sure if there's much more dangerous in this world than an entitled, distracted, moderately wealthy person driving an SUV that has places to go.

I leave the actual wealthy out of this because they just pay someone else to drive.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by giraffe_lady on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:06PM (#32184279)
Right, it's not not necessarily about safety it's about needing to feel safe.

A big problem on this honestly is that news media focuses disproportionately on interpersonal crime compared to almost all other kinds of harm that can be done. Combined with generally decreased newsroom budgets, this has led to firmer reliance on, and less questioning of, direct police releases. We basically just let the cops tell us what to worry about, and they predictably tell us to worry about the things that get more funding for police.

We've mostly decided that, while these things aren't good per se, they are downstream of other incentives and requirements that are good, or at least inevitable. I don't agree, but I also don't think there's much value in a "what could be different" conversation without having a "why is it like this at all" conversation first.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kieselguhr_kid on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:07PM (#32184292)
What we really need is a holistic approach to a lot of these issues. Ending the violent prohibition of drugs, building and providing housing for the homeless, better and more accessible mental health programs, denser cities, better transit, etc. We don't have a politics in the US that fully articulates the dynamic interconnectivity of all the issues and aggressively pushes for a set of solutions.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by treeman79 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:15PM (#32184410)
Doesn’t San Fransisco do all of those? They spend a huge amount on it anyway. And being one the dirtiest cities possible.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kelnos on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:21PM (#32184485)
I'm really tired of this "SF is the dirties city" trope. Yes, there are areas that are incredibly dirty, but those areas are something like 5% of the city, and most of those areas are concentrated in a few specific neighborhoods. Most of the city is fairly clean (but to be sure, it's no Singapore) and reasonably well-maintained.

I've been in areas of Manhattan that would rival SF's dirtiest areas, but I wouldn't claim that NYC is a "dirty city".

I'm more worried about the threat of violence from mentally-unstable people on SF's streets, though that's something that's also concentrated in a relatively small number of places (unsurprisingly often coinciding with the dirtiness).

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by woodruffw on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:30PM (#32184597)
> I've been in areas of Manhattan that would rival SF's dirtiest areas, but I wouldn't claim that NYC is a "dirty city".

I've lived here my entire life, and I would :-)

As much as I'm a booster for NYC (and immensely proud of our public transit), we're also a very dirty city (partially for historical planning reasons, resulting in no alleyways or trash disposal consideration).

It's also gotten worse during the pandemic, in no small part thanks to drivers: people have stopped moving their cars for street cleaning, resulting in accumulations of trash and dirt that then clog the drains, worsening our floods (and damaging the subways further).

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by Avicebron on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:29PM (#32184583)
I saw about 5 between the bart station and Berkeley campus on my way to get a curry, and I wouldn't even consider that dirty relative to driving a few blocks down towards the freeway...(I know it might not technically be "SF" but you know what I mean)
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rr888 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:14PM (#32185171)
> I wouldn't claim that NYC is a "dirty city".

NYC is a filthy city. I think most people that live here and love it would agree.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kieselguhr_kid on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:20PM (#32184465)
No city can adequately fund these programs, and San Francisco certainly doesn't build housing for the homeless, have an enlightened drugs policy or have adequate mental health care. San Francisco and other coastal cities mainly differentiate their policies by treating the homeless populations there with malignant neglect instead of outright hostility, which leads to the phenomenon you see where 10-12 cities bear the brunt of a national homelessness crisis. Because San Francisco is one of them, you also see a bunch of entitled tech bros whining about how they have to see a homeless person sometimes on HN.

I will admit that, by American standards, SF has pretty good public transit though.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by whimsicalism on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:37PM (#32185458)
I feel like SF is one of the most permissive places to do drugs in perhaps the entire world. Even if there are laws on the books, they are not really enforced.

I am not coming from a perspective of pro-law & order, just a commentary on drug law & enforcement here.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by treeman79 on Friday July 22, 2022 @12:17AM (#32188478)
https://www.hoover.org/research/only-san-francisco-61000-ten...

Spending for homeless is 61,000 per person

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kieselguhr_kid on Friday July 22, 2022 @04:08PM (#32196529)
It's misallocated through an enormous network of private contractors, ineffectual nonprofits and government bureaucracies. The unaffordable expenditure (public housing or at least publicly funded housing) is completely out of that budget, while the rest of the programs are so watered down and so much have been leeched out of them that they're completely ineffectual. Rebuilding capacity for direct state action, without farming out to all of these parasitic middlemen is a key component, as is reducing or eliminating wasteful and top-heavy bureaucracies.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by goodpoint on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:09PM (#32184313)
Try visiting Japan or South Korea or even central Europe.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by Avicebron on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:12PM (#32184356)
Yes, these are clearly not universal human issues if somewhere like Japan can maintain clean, relatively safe, efficient public transportation. It should be obvious we should be looking outside of the US as to why certain societies are able to solve this issues and others are not.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by BlargMcLarg on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:30PM (#32184595)
Because these societies incentivize individuals to behave and conform for the better of the group, while iterating on their systems. The same way the US has iterated on their car-centric culture.

Take the money and incentives away from building roads, cars, parking lots, traffic safety etc. and stick them into systems which are safer by default, incentives for people to keep things clean and not cause a fuss.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rr888 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:16PM (#32185190)
> why certain societies are able to solve this issues and others are not.

You mean by enforcing a racially homogenous society which does not allow poor (or anyone really) people from other parts of the world?

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by goodpoint on Friday July 22, 2022 @04:04AM (#32189695)
“A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It's where the rich use public transportation” – Gustavo Petro, Mayor of Bogotá

> enforcing a racially homogenous society

Are you implying that criminality is genetic...?

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by Schroedingersat on Thursday July 21, 2022 @07:07PM (#32186360)
Yeah, that's exactly how Melbourne, London, and Paris did it.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by noobermin on Friday July 22, 2022 @01:24AM (#32188808)
Singapore then.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by redox99 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:45PM (#32185559)
I'm not sure what you're trying to point out. I've only been to Japan out of those, and public transport might be fast and clean, but it is much less comfortable and a much worse experience than driving a nice car.

Unless I'm in a hurry I rather have a comfortable private ride, than a less comfortable quick ride packed around strangers.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kelnos on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:17PM (#32184439)
Yeah, this is a good point. I don't think I've ever heard anyone express fear when getting on an SF Muni bus or train that they're going to be injured or killed in a crash. The only safety-related complaints are exactly what you said: drug users and people with mental illnesses on the bus, or sketchy characters hanging around transit stops. Years ago, my partner witnessed someone walk right by her, inches away from her, stop a few feet away, and suddenly punch someone in the face, right out of the blue. I would be much more afraid of that kind of thing happening to me than anything else.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by TylerE on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:18PM (#32183632)
The difference is control.

While a careful, attentive driver in a well-maintained vehicle certainly isn’t immune, their risk is much lower than someone who drives tired, drunk, or high in a car with bald tires and bad brakes.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by wahern on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:38PM (#32183878)
> While a careful, attentive driver in a well-maintained vehicle certainly isn’t immune, their risk is much lower than someone who drives tired, drunk, or high in a car with bald tires and bad brakes.

You could have just stopped at "control". That's the fundamental dynamic by which we can explain this differential public sentiment--a sense of control or lack thereof, independent of whether that control actually exists, or whether that control translates to reduced risk. You went off the rails trying to link it to some objective reality; it's unnecessary, and in any event even the best of drivers takes on more risk while on the road than riding passenger rail.

Control also figures into notions of ethics and justice. We're much more willing to accept losses when we attribute the proximate cause to "nature", "god", "chance", etc. But our moral calculus shifts dramatically when the decision of a particular person or group can be fingered (reasonably or not) as a primary factor. You already subtly did that by insinuating blame upon many traffic victims. (I'm not saying the insinuation was improper or impermissible... we all frequently do that; it's a staple of public discourse and even personal reflection. Just highlighting the extent to which notions of control color our views.)

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by roughly on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:55PM (#32184115)
What's interesting here is that it's a very specific, narrow form of control. The driver of the car feels in control, because they're operating the motor vehicle, yet on the macro scale, they're operating a motor vehicle because of a whole host of other decisions outside their control. For most people, they don't have the option to not operate a motor vehicle and still live where they do, work where they do, etc. Likewise, the road construction and design operates a powerful influence on how they drive and how others drive around them, as well as how safely they can navigate to their destination - this too is out of their control. Regulations on the construction and maintenance of vehicles they and others on the road drive are also out of their control, but affect the environment in which the driver operates, and rules around who can drive and under what conditions similarly are not in the driver's control. The driver of the car exhibits control over only the narrowest and most immediate circumstances of their condition, and yet that veneer of control is sufficient for the majority of observers to put the blame nearly entirely on the driver for the outcome of their trip, absolving or ignoring the numerous other systems and decisions made which put them in circumstances in which accidents are alarmingly frequent.

The article covers suicide, and here too the veneer of control at the point of action hides the entire complex environment in which someone dies of suicide - the social, economic, and political landscape that creates the conditions in which a former service member takes their life is not strictly personal, but we insist on treating it as such, because at the point of action, it is indeed the individual who commits the act.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by zip1234 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:18PM (#32185216)
It is definitely a veneer of control. People's brains and senses have all kinds of strange blind spots that make it a more dangerous activity than it seems. The whole 'zoning out' while driving down a stretch of road for example.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by thehappypm on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:27PM (#32184558)
Yep. We don’t fear things under our control. Do I fear driving my car? No, because I can control my safety (to an extent, anyway). I can drive defensively. I can stay focused. I can avoid dangerous intersections. I wear a seat belt and have a big safe SUV.

Mass shootings are terrifying because there’s no sense of control.

Animals are scary (spiders, snakes) because we can’t control them.

Disease is scary when we can’t control it (cancer); less scary when we can cure it, even something like appendicitis seems tame because most hospitals can get it under control. It’s also why COVID is less scary to the general public, as it gets more under control (via vaccines and treatments and prior infection immunity).

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by mwint on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:49PM (#32185624)
> Mass shootings are terrifying because there’s no sense of control.

For anyone here concerned about this, it doesn’t take very much money in HN-terms to become reasonably well trained. You can:

1) Carry your own weapon, following your state’s laws in all but a few. 2) Learn to use that weapon very well, but more importantly: 3) Learn to use cover and move defensively or offensively 4) Learn to administer basic medical attention to yourself and others 5) Learn to read people and know when something might be about to happen.

After enough training, you will at least probably not freeze in an active shooter scenario. Even if you’re not into carrying your own weapon, doing some training will teach you how insanely hard it is to hit any moving target (or anything at all when the adrenaline is going).

Re. 5), many people in my state carry and I never used to notice them. Now I can pick out who is and isn’t, and usually how long they’ve been doing it (newbies will subtly check their weapon is secure every time they move).

The Secret Service is trained the same way; someone not used to carrying who is about to do something bad will send off all kinds of weird body language signals.

——

No, you don’t need to learn this because shootings are exceedingly rare. But if you’re nervous, learning these things will give you a sense of understanding about the threat, and the basic tools to do something to keep your loved ones safe in that one-in-a-hundred-thousand-lifetimes event.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:22PM (#32185944)
no, if you want to survive a mass shooting, you don’t need to do anything, especially not buy a gun, and your likelihood of not dying by mass shooting stays the same, basically zero. your chances of dying by gun increase much more simply by having one than you could ever hope to reduce the risk of dying by mass shooting by having one. if you were in the exceedingly unlikely scenario of a mass shooting, brandishing a gun increases your likelihood of dying in that situation several-fold, rather than materially increasing your chances of stopping the mass shooter or even saving your own life.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by mwint on Thursday July 21, 2022 @07:24PM (#32186506)
Never brandish a gun. Proper training means going from deep concealment to shots on target in a few seconds, maximum.

Your cited statistic is one reason open carry is a Bad Idea; it puts you first in line to be eliminated. Concealment, all the way.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Friday July 22, 2022 @01:15PM (#32194497)
i'd take that further a say never have a gun, concealed or not. the chances, even with great training, practice, and discipline, to use it in a way that harms only the perpetrator and no one else, especially not yourself, is fantastically small (much less than lightning strike chances).

my veteran friend who trains others on firearms and has a license to carry would say the same thing.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by powerhour on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:23PM (#32185958)
And if the rhetoric is true and stolen guns are disproportionately represented in violent crimes 6) learn to secure your gun when it is not in use so it doesn't get (easily) stolen, FFS.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by thehappypm on Thursday July 21, 2022 @11:17PM (#32188079)
Right, because having a gun definitely will stop the next Mandalay Bay gunman from sniping me out during a rave.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by mwint on Thursday July 21, 2022 @11:24PM (#32188134)
Shootings in general are a very, very rare event. Mandalay Bay was an exceedingly rare event inside that category.

If you're worried about Mandalay Bay, you're right, you will not be returning fire from the ground into an nth floor hotel window with your sidearm.

The other things on the list still apply. Learn to move, learn to use cover, learn to provide basic medical attention. It's not a bad idea to carry a TQ if you're going somewhere with crazy-large groups of people (for reasons other than shootings, which statistically you will not be involved in).

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kelnos on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:53PM (#32184889)
> No, because I can control my safety (to an extent, anyway).

Part of the problem is that this control is much more of an illusion than most people realize. In any car crash where there's at least two vehicles involved, often one driver is at fault, and the other is (or others are) more or less an innocent bystander, who may have been exercising all the care and attentiveness in the world. That person was certainly not able to control their safety in that situation.

And even when not involved in a crash, I don't think it's reasonable to say that one's safe outcome was caused even mostly due to their control over their vehicle. Much of it can be attributable to luck, traffic conditions, and the imperfect, but often sufficient, control that others were exercising over their vehicles.

But I do agree with you that the perceived threat/seriousness of these various bad things does have a lot to do with the perception of individual control, whether or not individuals actually do have much control over them. I know a surprising number of people who get anxious flying on a plane, but don't think twice about getting in a car, despite there being a higher probability of injury or death from a car trip.

Something I just realized: I feel like passengers in a car are also similarly not that concerned about the possibility of crashes, even though they are not actually in control of the vehicle. My first thought would be that they presumably know and trust the person who is driving, but that doesn't explain why people feel safe in taxis. I guess maybe people do feel less safe in taxis, though.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by chasd00 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:52PM (#32184873)
> We don’t fear things under our control

yeah, this is it. This is why people will drive through a blizzard in the middle of the night but will have a panic attack trying to board an airplane. In their car they feel in control but in an airplane they feel helpless and at completely dependent on the pilot/crew/airplane.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by thehappypm on Thursday July 21, 2022 @11:19PM (#32188093)
A relative of this feeling is knowledge. I have thousands of miles of snow driving experience in my car. I have no fucking clue how airplanes work and how they handle turbulence.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ericmay on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:57PM (#32184148)
If only we could take this further. What’s more in “control” than driving? Walking and riding a bike. That’s ultimate control.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by egypturnash on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:07PM (#32184298)
When I am on a bike I am definitely not in control of all the people in cars around me, especially the ones who are drunk, are assholes, or are badly-programmed robots who barely know what a “bicycle” is.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ericmay on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:10PM (#32184327)
Which would be true of any form of transit, including driving or riding a bus or walking down the street. So I’m not following your point here.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kipchak on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:26PM (#32184548)
You're unfortunately either more vulnerable to other cars, less able to take action to avoid them or some combination of both. A motorcycle for example is nimble enough to attempt to avoid a collision but is more vulnerable if a collision occurs, while a bus might be sturdier/larger but your presence can't avoid a collision at all.

As a group the safest option would be smaller vehicles, but individually each person is better off (in terms of safety during a collision) with something larger.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by danaris on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:14PM (#32184399)
This is why, when I have to visit a city, I much prefer to park my car at the first convenient opportunity and walk. Having a car is pretty straightforward and definitely a must in the rural areas where I live (sadly, public transit is effectively nonexistent), but driving a car in a city is difficult and often terrifying, specifically because of the limited control (you're stuck going forward at a particular speed, and if you realize too late that the GPS/map/printed out directions/copilot navigator was indicating that street to turn on, you just have to keep going and hope that you can loop back around somehow without losing too much time...or you risk permanent/exorbitantly expensive damage to your car, someone else's car, and/or one or more humans).
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by whakim on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:50PM (#32184855)
Yes, but the GP wasn't talking about some objective notion of "control" - they were talking about some subjective "feeling" of control and how that translates to perceptions of risk and danger. Driving a car feels like you're in control because you're the one doing the driving and are isolated from your environment even though (as a sibling comment notes) you're at the mercy of a huge number of factors that you don't perceive. That's why folks don't perceive driving as risky. (Consider airplanes as a contrasting example - extremely safe, but you certainly don't feel "in control".) In that context, cycling doesn't feel like you're "in control" because you're surrounded by large multi-ton vehicles moving significantly faster than you. Walking in urban areas feels safe because of the incredible amount of infrastructure that exists to support pedestrians and the normalcy of walking in those areas.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ericmay on Thursday July 21, 2022 @10:32PM (#32187804)
Idk. I feel most in control the further away I move from the transit appliance. I’d order it something like this (there are other options here I’m omitting) in order of least to most control:

Airplane > cruise ship > car > train > bike > feet

But I may just think about this stuff more than most people. I never feel as in control when I’m stuck in a traffic jam or behind a slow driver versus riding a bike. Even trains feel like I have more control because I’m on my feet to/from the train and I could get off at a stop and just walk away. It’s very liberating versus a car.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by gottastayfresh on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:05PM (#32184259)
Exactly, but it's not ultimately convenient. Control ends where convenience begins (that's not to say its totally accurate, but the phrase looks nice).
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ericmay on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:11PM (#32184341)
> Exactly, but it's not ultimately convenient

Strictly by design and active and reinforced choice. Not for any other reason. Period.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by gottastayfresh on Thursday July 21, 2022 @07:58PM (#32186798)
Absolutely! I wasn't implying otherwise. I think in the U.S. the inertia of both design and life choices is more of the problem -- I think convenience captures both of these issues in their present state. I use convenience here not to suggest actual convenience, but the appearance of convenience, much in the way that it's not really control, but the appearance of control that makes us register the preferability of the personal car.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by kelnos on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:45PM (#32184787)
Exactly. There are many places in the world where getting around by transit is much faster and more convenient than driving. It's just rare to find a place in the US where this is the case.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by thehappypm on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:28PM (#32184571)
Wow, could not agree less! In a bike you’re at the mercy of the bikers and drivers around you, with laughable safety features to protect you.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ericmay on Thursday July 21, 2022 @10:29PM (#32187776)
You’re focusing on these other aspects, not the actual control. I can put my bike in a car, I can ride a bike up a hill or on a dirt trail, a bike is comparatively inexpensive, I can take a bike on a train to another city. Etc.

And it would be even more obvious which form of transportation provides the most control if you had bike-first infrastructure.

But you’re also not accounting for lots of things completely out of your control, like where highways get built, potholes, funding, insurance rates, the price of rubber for new tires, oil changes, gas stations, etc. It’s the illusion of control.

We’ve designed cities specifically so that you can feel like you are in control driving a car. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by yongjik on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:29PM (#32183777)
I don't understand. What control do I have over a tired/drunk/high truck driver running a red light into an intersection I'm passing in?

I can be actually assured that no drunk driver will smash into my seat in a subway (the chance might not be zero but it's astronomically low). You may say it's not "control" because I didn't personally force all those drunk drivers out of railroads, but then again, I can't force them out of public roads either.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ModernMech on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:52PM (#32184065)
For one, you can choose the routes you take. Accidents aren't evenly distributed across every mile of road. Some roads are are just statistically safer than others. Accidents also aren't evenly distributed across all times of day and weather conditions. By choosing not to drive at those times and in those conditions, you can lower your risk profile.

Moreover, the route you drive most is your commute to work, so you can choose where you live to minimize travel time and intersections. There's one intersection on my way to work, so I guess theoretically what you describe could happen. But the accident statistics for that particular intersection show that practically no accidents have occurred there. Therefore most of the time I spend driving is going to be quite safe compared to the aggregate stats, and that's by choice.

Delivery driver routes are usually optimized for right turns for this reason. My dad was a UPS driver for 30 years and went without an accident the entire time, not even one that wasn't his fault. You'd think statistically he would have gotten into one over the million miles or so he drove on and off the job, but I think that just goes to show that defensive driving and route planning actually works.

No form of travel is absolutely safe. The best you can do is control what you can and hope for the best.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by cdkmoose on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:58PM (#32185726)
Bu can you be assured that a drunk/tired/* train engineer doesn't run a signal and crash into another train?
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by TylerE on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:30PM (#32183783)
You can assure that you don’t drive drunk.

You can’t assure your bus driver didn’t pop a few pills before they came on shift.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by toyg on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:37PM (#32183864)
You also can't be sure a random guy is not going to come from a side street on a red light at 90mph and T-bone you because he was answering a whatsapp and didn't notice the lights.

I ride a motorbike. As part of training I was repeatedly told to wear protection not because of my riding skills, but because of everyone else's lack of skills.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by willcipriano on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:48PM (#32184021)
Part of riding a motorbike (cycle here) is also driving defensively is it not? I don't assume people are going to stop at a given intersection, I take a look at their current speed and project it forward before determining if it's safe for me to go. If someone is going at a high rate of speed towards a stop sign or red light, I don't pull out just because I have the "right of way" I assume they are going to do something stupid.

Another example: On the highway I get myself into a position where I have plenty of stopping distance for the car in front of me, but also behind me in case I need to stop rapidly myself.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by xyzzyz on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:06PM (#32184280)
> I don't assume people are going to stop at a given intersection, I take a look at their current speed and project it forward before determining if it's safe for me to go.

While I sympathize with your overall sentiment (and indeed, as a fellow motorcyclists, I know a lot about defensive driving/riding), I have never seen people consistently drive the way you describe, ever. For many intersections in the cities (probably most), you simply cannot see if someone is actually going from a side road until you're so deep in the intersection that you have no chance of stopping before it if you notice someone.

Imagine you're driving here:

https://www.google.com/maps/@47.5703087,-122.3952816,3a,75y,...

There's a side road on in front of you. Imagine there is a car going same speed as you, on a crash trajectory (i.e. it is exactly as far from the intersection as you are). Where's the first moment you see it?

Most likely, around here:

https://www.google.com/maps/@47.5703156,-122.3959313,3a,75y,...

where you're around 20 feet from the intersection of your routes. If you begin braking immediately as you notice the other car, you need to be going slower 15 mph if you want to avoid a crash. If you add any amount of time to actually judge the speed of the other car and its intention of stopping, you need to be going less than 10 mph. Needless to say, nobody actually does that, people don't slow down to 10 mph in locations like above.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by willcipriano on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:36PM (#32184669)
First I must say, in the city I'll park my car at the outskirts and take public transit so I admit it's situational. I don't like driving with so many unpredictable pedestrians running around, you could end up in prison because someone had a few too many drinks and fell into the road.

But in your example I'd have a good chance to prevent a collision. I'd already have my foot on the brake due to the crosswalk there. I will have brought my speed down that I will be able to stop should someone suddenly appear within it. A kid could pop out from between those two cars on the right chasing a ball, so you need to have a stopping distance of perhaps 2 - 3 feet maximum, depending what vehicle of mine I am driving that's probably 20 - 25 mph maximum. 25 mph is the speed limit there so I probably wouldn't even get tailgaters at that speed, but I don't care if I do. That intersection is a good place for a rolling stop, where you bring the car down to perhaps 5mph before you proceed, mostly because of the sidewalks on both sides and the risk of kids running around or riding bikes. That's a residential street, there should be no need to move quickly down it.

In addition to all that my car has a top of line collision avoidance system, side curtain airbags, a high crash rating, etc. I always wear my seatbelt and keep my kid strapped in with a age appropriate booster seat.

I'm not saying I'm perfect but being careful can reduce your personal risk considerably.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by xyzzyz on Thursday July 21, 2022 @07:35PM (#32186599)
> That intersection is a good place for a rolling stop, where you bring the car down to perhaps 5mph before you proceed, mostly because of the sidewalks on both sides and the risk of kids running around or riding bikes.

On the arterial street that I linked, intersections like this one are placed every 150 feet. I literally never seen anyone drive the way you describe, ever. Nobody does a rolling stop every 150 feet. Very few drivers even go speed limit there, maybe 1 in 20: most people do around 30 mph, a good fraction does 35 mph. In fact, if you drive the way you describe (which I doubt, because, again, I literally never, ever seen anyone drive like that), you're more likely to get into an accident (most likely getting rear ended), due to being extremely unpredictable.

> I'm not saying I'm perfect but being careful can reduce your personal risk considerably.

This is, of course, right, but my point was not to demand perfection, I just want to point out that what you describe is extremely unrealistic, and virtually never observed in real life driving.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by throwaway0a5e on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:23PM (#32184498)
Not only is what he described simply not realistic, it's likely far more unsafe than "driving normally" because the behavior violates the expectations of many/most other drivers and when people are thrown into situations that violate their expectations things get weird.

"But he should have been using a reasonable following distance" makes for easy low effort internet points but internet points won't get you out of a hospital bed.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by foepys on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:02PM (#32184217)
You will never be able to look into every intersection, even very open ones. You will never be able to look out for cars traveling 50kph/30mph unless you literally stop before entering every intersection.

You also don't have any control over how far behind other cars are. The only thing you can do is to drive faster or to let them by by stopping or changing lanes. The latter is highly dangerous in fast flowing traffic on single lane roads while the first will almost never help as the other car actively wants to go faster.

Being in absolute control is you can drive as defensively as you want, in the end a distracted idiot can take you out and the only thing you can do is minimize the risk.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by toyg on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:13PM (#32184367)
Yes, but let's be honest: none of us has 360º eyes, and very few have split-millisecond reflexes. You control for the front, meanwhile somebody hits you from the rear; you look to the sides, and someone brakechecks you; and so on and so forth. You can reduce chances, but not eliminate them. Statistically, by the simple fact that you are sharing the road with hundreds of other (often terrible) drivers, the chance that one of them will fuck you up is incredibly higher than the chance of that happening on a public-transport vehicle in dedicated lanes (or even rails) driven by someone whose job is to safely move such vehicle from A to B every day.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by googlryas on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:52PM (#32184069)
You can't assure it, but again, you can control your own actions to help mitigate the danger of others being reckless. For example by driving defensively, scanning to the left and right when passing through an intersection, etc.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by hgomersall on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:37PM (#32183873)
The point is, every driver you interact with might be drunk or distracted. In a collision with a drunk in a car, I'd rather be in a bus.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by googlryas on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:53PM (#32184090)
Sure, but you would probably rather be driving a car if your bus driver was suicidal that morning.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by dahart on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:37PM (#32184677)
This goes straight to the article’s point that we tend to care about things that don’t actually matter as much when they seem worse. The hypothetical bus driver suicide seems bad if he takes out other people with him, it’s easy to imagine being a passenger with no control and meeting a terrifying doom. Let’s just nevermind that it almost never happens, and forget that suicide car drivers is a much, much more likely occurrence in the real world. And bad drivers accidentally taking out people near them happens way more often than anything to do with suicides. You’re far less likely to be killed on a bus than in a car, hands down. Wanting to drive a car instead simply highlights our flawed emotional thinking.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by jeromegv on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:05PM (#32184250)
Even if that happened, how many people can seriously be injured in a bus accident in a city? Not talking of bus going through mountains and losing breaks
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by googlryas on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:11PM (#32184350)
Everyone on the bus, if the bus driver decides to drive the bus off a bridge into a river
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by TylerE on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:11PM (#32184348)
Hundreds. Imagine a bus veering off into a busy sidewalk.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by hgomersall on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:55PM (#32184116)
How many suicidal bus drivers have we had? I mean ever.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by egypturnash on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:12PM (#32184360)
I just searched for “bus driver suicide” and it was a pretty even split between stories about drivers saving people who were trying to kill themselves, and drivers killing themselves. The latter was very much largely happening in solitary ways, except for one dude in China who drove his bus into a lake.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by yongjik on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:29PM (#32184584)
You assure your bus driver doesn't have a habit of popping pills by making them go through rigorous certification, give them decent wages, and punishing them harshly when they do pop pills.

You may object it's not perfect, but nothing is, and it does work. In fact, it works exactly the same way you can assure that your brake pad won't suddenly give way in front of a bus coming from your left.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by Spooky23 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:35PM (#32183828)
There’s risk mitigation there in the form of training and testing.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by 1270018080 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:39PM (#32183888)
It was critical for your train of thought to skip the part where other drivers kill you.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by woodruffw on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:24PM (#32183710)
Sure. I also won't claim that driving is dangerous, in the abstract: human beings take all kinds of risks, lots of them for fun, and I'm not interested in restricting others' behavior on that basis.

It's merely thought provoking: every HN thread on transit will have the same half-dozen comments about violence and danger on public transit, when the reality is that two orders of magnitude more deaths occur each year on our highways.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by cgriswald on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:13PM (#32184384)
People feel better protected in their cars. They're in a private rolling cage with all kinds of safety features and a built-in ability to get away from danger. They can also avoid more dangerous areas, practice defensive driving, and otherwise mitigate their chances of being one of those statistics.

Being confronted by a knife-wielding drug addict on public transit is just a scarier proposition all around even if the numbers suggest it shouldn't be. And it feels random where death in a car doesn't, even though for the victim it often is.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by dwighttk on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:25PM (#32184532)
>the reality is that two orders of magnitude more deaths occur each year on our highways.

What is the throughput of highways vs public transit? I wouldn’t be surprised if it was two orders of magnitude greater person hours on roads in non public transit.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by trothamel on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:11PM (#32185137)
You're right. According to https://www.bts.gov/content/us-passenger-miles , in the US in 2020, there were 4,935 billion passenger-miles on highways, versus 32 billion passenger-miles on transit.

The highway mileage includes 306 billion passenger-miles on non-transit buses.

Amtrak (6 billion passenger miles) isn't considered transit.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by masterj on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:48PM (#32185611)
> What is the throughput of highways vs public transit?

Regardless of what the US does, throughput is much higher on public transit than it is on highways. You can fit so many more people on buses and trains than in automobiles.

For the actual numbers, compare deaths-per-passenger-mile in-city and deaths-per-passenger-mile between cities (highways vs buses, trains, etc), and you will see huge difference in fatality rate.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by giraffe_lady on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:10PM (#32184335)
> human beings take all kinds of risks, lots of them for fun, and I'm not interested in restricting others' behavior on that basis.

No but we do have a strong, though admittedly weakening, tradition of restricting the fun of others when the danger posed is not solely to themselves. For example building and setting off bombs is fun as hell but we're not allowed to do it because it's pretty unhealthy for the neighbors.

Driving cars is pretty dangerous not just for the driver but also for other people around who have not necessarily consented to being put in danger. When pedestrians and children are routinely getting killed (as they have been in my city this summer) we should shift the danger assessment a little away from the skydiving end of the spectrum and a little more to the backyard bombs zone.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by cgriswald on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:30PM (#32184594)
You can build and set off bombs. It's just heavily regulated.

However, many people haven't really consented to driving. They drive out of necessity. Where they live and work is only marginally in their control and there are no other transport options. When I was poor, I would have loved to not have to pay for insurance, gas, maintenance, and the vehicle itself. I couldn't really afford it. But without it, I couldn't get to work to eat. There weren't other options. When I made a little more money I could finally afford to live close to work and public transport was an option. The trip was 5 minutes by car, over an hour by bus.

I'm on board for heavily regulating driving and shifting that danger assessment as you suggest. But first I think there is a moral obligation to provide alternative modes of transportation. (This should not be interpreted as excusing drivers from their obligation to be skilled and safe.)

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by giraffe_lady on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:00PM (#32184989)
Yes, agreed. Driving at least in the american context should be understood as basically bimodal: at one end a regressive tax on the poor and at the other a luxury that allows the wealthy to live in the segregated enclaves they value.

Both ends need to be addressed and it will make for a lot of changes in the middle too. But there's no solution that doesn't involve completely rewriting transportation.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by edmundsauto on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:24PM (#32183707)
Do you mean this is an actual important difference, or that it is a difference in how it’s perceived?

My gut is public transit is still safer than even the most attentive and sober driver. So it’s the feeling of control that determines perception rather than an actual materially different risk profile.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by BlargMcLarg on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:31PM (#32183802)
Yet we push millions of people on the roads when they are still dead tired, at once, massively increasing risk factors from multiple sides. Heck, many of them rely on coffee to be anywhere close to a careful and attentive driver.

You might want to elaborate on your definition of control.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by toyg on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:32PM (#32183807)
You say control, I say guilt. Society loves to attribute systemic problems to individual wickedness, because it empowers the judgemental elements while requiring no actual effort.

As you say, careful drivers are not immune. But as long as someone, anyone, involved in the accident can be condemned as sinful (in many cases the sin of being tired from overworking forced on them by societal pressures), it can be explained away.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by libraryatnight on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:58PM (#32184164)
This extends in so many directions. I hear people speak this way about the homeless, the addicted, the laid-off, the sick. Cancer? Begin the list of things the person did, consumed, didn't do that could have caused it (no shortage of headlines to feed the lists). Homeless? Must have acted irresponsibly and made stupid choices. It's sort of hand in hand with the "It can't happen to me" mindset. I remember my wife telling me - during the George Floyd trial - one of her co-workers interrupted when someone referred to him as a man and said "He was a drug addict" like that should end the conversation, like that exempted him from being human, like some of her favorite celebrities weren't drug addicts.

"To the dumb question 'Why me?' the cosmos barely bothers to return the reply: 'Why not?'" - Christopher Hitchens, from Mortality.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by tialaramex on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:15PM (#32184412)
> But as long as someone, anyone, involved in the accident can be condemned as sinful (in many cases the sin of being tired from overworking forced on them by societal pressures), it can be explained away.

And indeed if we look at railway safety this is exactly what we saw. Originally, railway companies would say well, yes two passenger trains collided, killing a hundred people, but conveniently for us both drivers died in the collision so we'll blame them. The problem wasn't us, the railway company, who are great, it's those awful drivers, who fortunately are now dead so no need to investigate further. In fact, since there's no body to examine we can confidently declare that one of the drivers was drunk. Which explains why we've told his widow that she won't be receiving one penny from the death-in-service fund.

Eventually (this kept happening, because of course it did) coroners weren't talking this bullshit, and they said it seems like the problem isn't these lone drivers who are conveniently dead, it's the company hiring them. If the drivers aren't good enough, the company should get better drivers. If instead the problem is elsewhere (e.g. maybe it'd be a good idea to invent signals so that you know if a train just around the corner has broken down so that your express doesn't hurtle into it at full speed...) that's something for the railway company too. This didn't magically fix things overnight, but it did push back against the useless "blame the driver" narrative.

Modern safety agencies, focused on a blameless "Learn from the past, prevent future accidents" model have improved things considerably, but that did not happen automatically, somebody had to call the corporate entities on their bullshit. Maybe we should call individual private car owners on their bullshit too.

One trend I don't like is people who resist the word "accident". It's an accident unless you think it was done on purpose. Accident prevention is a thing. We can, and should, prevent accidents.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by smileysteve on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:59PM (#32184172)
Your details really erase control though;

To stick to the legal ones;

Tired. 40% of Americans report not getting 8 hours of sleep a night. An only partially intersecting group reports they are regularly tired during daily activities. Is a driver's self actualization of tired accurate?

Attentive; bad news, most drivers aren't attentive, hence we're still seeing deaths from texting while driving. Self actualization doesn't exist here either. Add in passengers (children, dogs, friend, partner) - deep thoughts on work, relationships - combined with doing something that is mostly mundane.

Poor Maintenance. Brakes, nails in tires, low air pressure in tires, tires not suited for climate, other cars leaving oils on the roads, poor road maintenance, unexpected or untrained weather, check engine light (25%), potholes impact tie rods and steering, worn shocks, uneven loading. Very few drivers do this or pre-drive check every drive.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by throwaway0a5e on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:26PM (#32184546)
>Poor Maintenance. Brakes, nails in tires, low air pressure in tires, tires not suited for climate, other cars leaving oils on the roads, poor road maintenance, unexpected or untrained weather, check engine light (25%), potholes impact tie rods and steering, worn shocks, uneven loading. Very few drivers do this or pre-drive check every drive.

Your list started off good and then quickly went straight to bad faith BS.

Nobody is getting in a crash because their worn out gas cap is causing the emissions system to pop a code.

Furthermore, it's pretty clear from the statistics available and the widely varying conditions across the US with regard to vehicle inspections, weather and road conditions that these factors pale compared to human judgement related causes.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by userbinator on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:33PM (#32183819)
Control, freedom, personal responsibility. Public transit offers none of that compared to driving. Thus it should be no surprise that many find it better to die or be injured as a result of one's own actions, than those of some faceless bureaucracy, regardless what the actual rates are.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by black_puppydog on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:35PM (#32183838)
So how do the pedestrians that make up a sizeable part of road deaths control the situation then?
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by TylerE on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:43PM (#32183939)
By doing things like not walking in the middle of the street at night in a poorly lit area wearing dark clothes. Has happened several times times in my town recently.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by throwaway0a5e on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:41PM (#32184735)
The same way drivers do. Avoid the handful of behaviors that seem to lead to the bulk of the deaths. Be attentive and maintain situational awareness. Cross your fingers.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by tshaddox on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:50PM (#32184052)
I'd love to see studies that attempt to control for attributes related to "driver skill" or "driver responsibility" that you could objectively test yourself on, so that you could more accurately predict your own risk and compare it against the risk of alternatives like public transit. It's not really good enough to say "I don't drive drunk, and I'm pretty sure I'm a more skilled driver than average, therefore I can discard all studies on the risks of injury of driving versus public transit."
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rustybelt on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:37PM (#32184684)
I don't think you can completely discard all comparisons, but people are intuitively right to recognize that if they don't engage in risky behavior (like drunk driving) they're less at risk of being in an accident. To argue otherwise is basically saying driving drunk is no more risky than driving sober.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by tshaddox on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:07PM (#32185091)
> but people are intuitively right to recognize that if they don't engage in risky behavior (like drunk driving) they're less at risk of being in an accident. To argue otherwise is basically saying driving drunk is no more risky than driving sober.

Sure, that’s why it’s important to know how risky automobiles are if you discard the cases of drunk drivers injuring themselves. I suspect drunk drivers injuring themselves accounts for a very small portion of automobile injuries, but we need to see the data.

It’s not enough to say “I don’t drive drunk, and driving drunk is very dangerous, therefore automobile risk estimates don’t apply to me.” You could make the same argument about driving blindfolded.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rustybelt on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:56PM (#32186279)
A quick google says that 26.8% of drivers killed or severely injured in a car accident had alcohol in their system. Not drinking and driving significantly reduces your risk.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by tshaddox on Friday July 22, 2022 @11:12AM (#32192790)
That’s “drivers (excluding motorcyclists) seriously injured or killed in crashes and whose blood was collected at one of the par- ticipating trauma centers or by MEs” in 2020. There were 474 such drivers, 127 of which had alcohol in their system. But there were 38,000 automobile fatalities in 2020.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by throwaway0a5e on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:28PM (#32184572)
The fact that we rarely if ever see such data sets is a strong data point by itself.

Insurance cost (data is widely available) goes down with age and you can extrapolate from that to safety but it only falls fast initially and the rest is largely a reflection of how driving habits change with age.

Occasionally someone like Tesla or Volvo will trot out some cherry picked data that boils down to "yes the very safe demographics who buy our very safe cars die less than the peasants".

Other than those two there's not much.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by TylerE on Thursday July 21, 2022 @07:27PM (#32186537)
Can you? How about controlling for mileage driven? Older drivers are e.g. more likely to be retired and drive substantially fewer miles due to not commuting.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:04PM (#32184246)
the difference is the illusion of control. you can’t talk yourself past raw statistics that way. you might make a marginal difference in risk, but the bulk of the risk is beyond personal control. even with attentiveness, if you’re 1 of 100 drivers on the road, you’re at best controlling for 1% of that one risk.

and i’d argue attentiveness (anti-distractedness) is the most important mass mitigation we could make, but it’s also practically impossible to maintain over a driving lifetime and nearly as impossible to enforce (without significant rights violations).

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by TylerE on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:16PM (#32184419)
It's way way higher than 1%. 30% of crashes involve a drunk driver. 30% of the drivers on the road are not drunk.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:49PM (#32184844)
and it’s orders of magnitude higher than 100 drivers on the road with you. you’re doubling down on a misunderstanding of risk. you have no control over most of the situations and circumstances that cause collisions, injury, and death. you not drinking and driving doesn’t make all the other drunk drivers sober up miraculously. your “control” has quite marginal effects at best.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rustybelt on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:33PM (#32184638)
Are you arguing that drivers don't have any control over their level of risk on the road? Sure they can't eliminate 100% of risk, but not speeding and not driving drunk absolutely influences a driver's likelihood of being in an accident.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:58PM (#32184963)
no, speeding hardly changes risk at all, but reckless driving certainly can, but that’s beside the point. the point is that changing your own behavior (i.e., “control”) has a negligible marginal effect on reducing your overall risk. nearly all of the practical risk is external and therefore out of your control (unless you manufacture additional risk by being distracted, reckless, and/or impaired).

you can’t really lower risk, which is what “control” implies. that’s simply a falsehood some folks choose to believe that’s unsupported by a basic application of stats & probability.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by zip1234 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:27PM (#32185339)
Speeding doesn't change risk? When 'speed was not a factor' in a crash, it just means that the involved drivers were not driving above the post speed limit. It doesn't mean that the drivers were driving a safe speed. In fact, clearly they were not.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#32185715)
speed increases the severity of collisions, but generally doesn’t cause them (most of what we classify as speed-related is really recklessness, which is also typically a misassessment of risk). distractedness, recklessness, and impairment are the overwhelming causes of collisions, with a small additional portion caused by vehicular homicide/suicide, mechanical failure, and environmental factors.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by zip1234 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @08:23PM (#32186983)
Regardless of semantics, there are known road design and electronic/mechanical techniques that can prevent or discourage speeding, regardless of the reason for speeding. The faster a vehicle is going, the more momentum it has, which correlates with risk of death in the event of crash.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Friday July 22, 2022 @01:22PM (#32194564)
the point is that there's no reason to target speeding specifically. you want to target distractedness, recklessness, and impairment to reduce accidents, thereby obviating the problem with speed exacerbating injury and death.

i'm all for narrowing lanes and adding trees to streets as traffic calming measures in urban neighborhoods, but that's because it increases attentiveness, rather than reduces speed per se. speed governors, on the other hand, are bad because they could prevent a driver from speeding up to evade a collision.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rustybelt on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:23PM (#32185955)
A quick google is telling me that 26.8% of drivers who were killed or severely injured had alcohol in their bloodstream. Assuming that's true, then wouldn't never drinking and driving reduce your risk of death or serious injury by around 26.8%? That seems like a substantial reduction that is completely in the control of the driver.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by clairity on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:31PM (#32186044)
no, you have to get everyone else to stop drinking and driving, not just yourself, to get that sort of reduction.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by TylerE on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:51PM (#32186206)
No you don’t. Over 50% of crashes are single car accidents. I suspect, but don’t have proof for, that that percentage is even higher in alcohol-related crashes (eg driver nods off and drives into a ditch/telephone pole
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rustybelt on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:55PM (#32186251)
How? The 26.8% is just drivers with alcohol in their system. If I never drink and drive, I will never be part of that group. That means the raw rate of traffic fatality or severe injury is 26.8% lower for people like me (non drunk drivers.)
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by neuralRiot on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:30PM (#32184598)
I’d say that it is blame rather than control. We tend to focus more in finding the responsible to point the finger at rather than the cause. If 1000 drivers die in car accidents it’s easy to shift the responsibility at themselves but if 2 die on an Amtrak derailment, the responsible is Amtrak or American Airlines, Airbus, Boeing or whatever.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by UncleMeat on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:50PM (#32184046)
This is true.

But there are two cars in many fatal wrecks. A family friend was killed going to the supermarket by a car running a red light and hitting him in an intersection. A few weeks ago a semitruck slammed into stopped traffic at full speed on 95-S at the Georgia/Florida border. Nothing can be done by a safe driver to prevent that.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by mwint on Thursday July 21, 2022 @07:58PM (#32186796)
Ever since being rear ended in stopped traffic on the freeway, I do make a practice of stopping a bit further from traffic than normal and watching the mirror, ready to speed away on the shoulder, until there’s a decent buffer of stopped carts behind me.

This isn’t reasonable to expect everyone to do, but any individual can realistically minimize their risk in this regard.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ErikVandeWater on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:09PM (#32184314)
I'd say the difference is density of deaths.

When people die in regular road accidents, it's just a few at a time. Not compelling enough for even a mention in national news coverage. When a plane or train crashes, it's hundreds simultaneously. Often with a good debris field too. Good enough to lead with.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by otikik on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:54PM (#32184104)
But the drunk driver can still invade your line on a split-second and frontal-crush you.

If you’re in a bus instead of a car, you will be much more protected against that kind of thing.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by djmips on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:45PM (#32183957)
Not to derail but the lack of control of self driving cars could be one reason there is a big reaction when someone dies as a result of an accident.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by goodpoint on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:48PM (#32184026)
Where is the control when you get hit by a car as a pedestrian or cyclist or car driver?

This is an excellent example of biased thinking.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by wbsss4412 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:07PM (#32184293)
The difference is really just the perception of control.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by jfengel on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:11PM (#32183545)
Or self-driving cars. Every incident is Big News, while ignoring the fact that 40,000 people die every year in traffic accidents (and 4.8 million injuries) -- in the US alone.

People are of course famously bad at putting statistics into context.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by intrepidhero on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:24PM (#32183700)
It's not just that people are bad at statistics (we are though). It's also that we place value on individual agency. Getting into a self-driving car (or onto a train) means giving up some of my agency and because of that I have higher expectations of safety from the self-driving car (or train driver) than I would if I had retained that agency. I don't think that's weird or unreasonable.

We do need to get better at statistics and realizing that when we take on risk, we rarely are the only person impacted if something goes sideways. When I take the wheel of a car I become a risk myself and to others and I need to place as much value on their agency as my own.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by djmips on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:50PM (#32184048)
I completely agree that we put a lot of value into personal agency but I do think it's a bit unreasonable. Agency when driving is only perceived. You could have a heart attack and smash into pedestrians. Your car could fail mechanically. You could be rear ended by a large truck. You could be killed by a drunk or inattentive driver. Your agency can not entirely prevent that. Also you may be in the top percentile in driving but like everything, everyone thinks they are a great driver so you can't take how you feel and generalize it to the population.

I'm not arguing that self driving cars are solved but maybe they aren't quite as bad as people feel. We need proper statistics.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by intrepidhero on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:01PM (#32184201)
That's a great point. Often the perceived agency is an illusion.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by UncleMeat on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:52PM (#32184074)
I'll never forget driving across Georgia on Jan 1st a bunch of years ago. They've got signs up that say to drive safely and show how many traffic fatalities there have been in the state that year. On a random day it just looks like a number.

But driving on the highway and passing a sign that said how many people had died today doing precisely what I was doing at that moment was affecting.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by Spivak on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:07PM (#32184295)
Assuming people are ignorant en masse says more about your understanding of people than the people.

Not all self driving car accidents make the news — self driving car accidents that any human diver could have easily avoided make the news. Statistically safer something something miles driven means nothing to the family of someone who died in a completely avoidable accident.

Until self driving cars reach the point of handing emergency situations — storms, ice, obstacles, children, other accidents, sudden lane changes, tire blowouts — better than humans and stop punting anything less than ideal conditions back to the driver it’s pointless to talk about safety.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by belorn on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:48PM (#32184016)
It wasn't that long ago that a driver instructor illustrated in a video how often they needed to correct the self-driving car in order to drive legal. It was multiple corrections per minute in a busy city.

In term of statistics, the error rates of human drivers are still lower than current self-driving technology. This is why the only certified fully self-driving mode is limited in Germany to operate at speed of less than 30 km/h, only on highways with congestion, and then outside any construction zones.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by mwint on Thursday July 21, 2022 @07:59PM (#32186815)
I mean, how often would the instructor need to correct a human to drive legal in a busy city? The null hypothesis here is that driving legally in big cities is not practical.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by criley2 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:26PM (#32183739)
The accident rate for "self-driving cars" (a nebulous term including both actually autonomous cars like waymo cars as well as driver-attention-required cars operating under the false advertising of "full self driving") is higher than human operated cars.

Currently "self driving cars" get in twice as many accidents as humans do per million miles driven.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by sixQuarks on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:47PM (#32184810)
Every time I bring this up when Tesla bashing is going on here, I get downvoted. The hate for Elon here blinds people to statistics
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by Gordonjcp on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:09PM (#32184318)
Self-driving cars aren't safer than humans, though, and I doubt they ever will be.

All the real love for self-driving cars seems to be in the US, where they are basically competing with completely untrained drivers and a strong drink-driving culture.

No self-driving car on the road today would even come close to passing a UK driving test. They wouldn't last the first five minutes.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by simion314 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:25PM (#32183733)
>People are of course famously bad at putting statistics into context.

We can\t , current self driving is limited in many ways and Tesla is notorious for having the driver save the day multiple time in 30 minutes and Elon is not publishing this incidents. I can't stand the fanboys coming up with fake stats that only 5 people ddied this month in a Tesla where in fact you have video evidence of more people would have died if the driver would have not saved the AI,

A Tesla employee should leak the data and we should then talk about stats, do Tesla saves the driver more then the driver saves the car. (i know that in reality FSD does not mean what the words imply and OP probably had no idea that there are no real FSD cars around that drive with no limitation so we can do real statistics)

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by jandrese on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:10PM (#32183527)
Imagine how angry people would be if at the end of an article about a train crash that killed 4 people the author included an anecdote about how there were 900 train fatalities in the previous year compared to 1.3 million car fatalities.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by pessimizer on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:19PM (#32183647)
> 900 train fatalities

And 600 of them were trespassers walking on the tracks, then the vast majority of the remaining were people who tried to beat the train at a crossing. The number of dead passengers was 6 and the number of dead train workers was 11, if I'm reading this correctly: https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/home-and-community/safety-topics...

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by ratsmack on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:20PM (#32183669)
>... while simultaneously handwringing over every incident ...

And then there's those Tesla accidents that must happen thousands of time a day, because they're always in the news.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by edmundsauto on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:25PM (#32183727)
My concern with auto driver accidents is they may be systemic rather than semi-random. Ie, it’s an attackable vector that can be repeatedly exploited versus the some stochastic human error.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by woodruffw on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:27PM (#32183752)
I don't have a bone to pick there, but an observation: much of that news seems to be driven by a certain prominent car CEO claiming that his cars are (1) safer, and (2) capable of self-driving (beyond a bit of driver assistance).

"Trains are safer" is a fact, but it's not a common part of messaging around why we should all take trains more often. The messaging there usually boils down to convenience, economic, and ecological arguments.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by smegger001 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:05PM (#32184255)
I wish the train was more economical then I could take the train more but it is not economical (on the west coast of the US). I live approx half way between Seattle WA and Portland OR and there is a train station within walking distance of my home. every time I have checked the price of a Amtrak ticket to either city it was significantly cheaper to drive and pay for parking then to buy a single train ticket.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by nonrandomstring on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:47PM (#32184001)
Yes, a very well written piece with good points and reasoning. It isn't just that the long tail of casualties falls below some threshold of attention. Large specialist organisations capable of industrial warfare or building industrial society cannot deal with human effects on an industrial scale. We tried it in the Northfield experiment [1] (mass psychotherapy for war trauma).

[1] https://psychology.fandom.com/wiki/Northfield_experiments

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by hackernewds on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:31PM (#32185391)
That's because you believe you won't be affected since you're driving. While transit would be someone else's responsibility. Same standards apply to why autonomous driving has to clear a much higher bar than beating the averages.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by js2 on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:14PM (#32183573)
It's like a form of the Dunning–Kruger effect where everyone believes they're in control of their fate in a car, but not on public transit. People must think they're exceptional drivers and that they can dodge any accident.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by pbuzbee on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:44PM (#32183953)
If I've learned anything from watching "Idiots in Cars" videos on Reddit, it's that you can go from "driving normally" to "in an accident" much faster than you think. Most people have very little experience reacting to imminent accidents on the road. Overall that's a good thing, but it certainly seems naive to think that simply being an attentive driver is enough to keep you out of accidents.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by djmips on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:58PM (#32184156)
It's a good thing, because yes getting injured or killed in a car accident is horrible but it's not a good thing that they don't have any training at all. If driving was something done only in industry there would be proper training and a lot more safety precautions. I think about this every time I walk down this narrow sidewalk in my town that's 4 feet from the roadway. A friend of mine was recently in the crosshairs of a straying van and he was only saved by the luck of a telephone pole intervening.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rustybelt on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:41PM (#32184745)
Yes, but if half of all accidents involve idiots, not being an idiot is a legitimate way to reduce your risk of being in an accident. Meaning drivers do have some control over their level of risk behind the wheel.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by scrumbledober on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:44PM (#32185544)
half of all accidents involve an idiot, but there only has to be one idiot in a two car collision.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by rustybelt on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:27PM (#32186001)
Reduce risk, not eliminate it. Do idiots and non-idiots have the same risk of getting into an accident?
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by cscurmudgeon on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:44PM (#32183951)
This is a bad way to look at it.

We should ask how many more people would die each day without cars.

Somehow, this basic analysis is absent in all of the car-hate posts.

Not considering pros and cons fairly is a not an honest approach.

You can’t claim to be objective by just looking at negatives and proclaiming cars are bad overall. You need to sum up the negatives and positives (assuming an utilitarian view).

Otherwise, just accept all car hate is based on subjective emotions.

It is not like car users are cackling evil Captain Planet villains. Most of us are not rich enough to live near work and schools.

That brings me to a related issue car haters miss: Bike-friendly cities should be designed for everyone, not just for wealthy white cyclists

https://theconversation.com/amp/bike-friendly-cities-should-...

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by BlargMcLarg on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:50PM (#32184041)
Because that question is practically impossible to answer. You can't extrapolate current circumstances and draw a conclusion from there. The best you can do is compare with other countries, disregard any non-related-yet-ultimately-significant and draw a fairly weak conclusion from there.

Most of those conclusions would not be in favor of cars, either. Especially not in light of environmental damage.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by cscurmudgeon on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:54PM (#32184099)
It is not impossible. Car haters like to think it is impossible.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by BlargMcLarg on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:00PM (#32184188)
Try it. I assure you, almost any angle you take can be poked through.

Cars shine in large, low density zones. For good reasons. Most anti-car people are not in favor of removing cars in these zones or removing cars altogether, so arguing here is moot.

Other places, whether removing a large amount of cars is beneficial or detrimental is decided either by culture, or by reinvestment options. And then, you're still stuck only comparing rationalities, with actual numbers being far harder to judge.

Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by eneumann on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:52PM (#32184066)
The car-hate posts can be quite emotional for a number of (valid) reasons, but understand that reducing cars and car trips doesn't happen in a vacuum. No one is arguing to instantly and immediately eliminate every vehicle out there. It's part of a larger process to replace personal vehicles with transit, walk-ability, bike-ability, and generally car-free or car-reduced places where people live.
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by anotherrandom on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:20PM (#32185244)
Biking is the ideal solution. There is one significant downside, though: the practicality of biking is limited by region and time of year+day. In most places in the Southern portion of the US (regardless of coast), biking any significant distance between the hours of 8am to 9 pm is basically saying "I want heatstroke" for nearly 1/2 of the year
Re:Why we ignore thousands of daily car crashes by standardUser on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:56PM (#32185699)
"wealthy white cyclists"

What in the ever-living fuck are you even talking about?