News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by coldcode on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:09AM (#31919586)
Persuasion was better than Powerpoint in every way; but even when Adobe bought it from Aldus, it could not compete with "free" i.e. PP being part of Office, and did not last long in the 90's. Office also basically killed word processing innovation and spreadsheet innovation for a long time.

Today almost no one remembers any of these types of apps that existed before Office. I remember since I was involved in several of them.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by philistine on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:38PM (#31922525)
Unsurprisingly, the one company still having a separate vision in the office application space is Apple. Pages, Numbers and Keynote are opinionated and very different from Office and the also-ran. The simple idea that your buttons for a Pages document are on the right side and scroll down is a genius use of space, yet Word et al. insist on the crappy top drawers of nonsense.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by systoll on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:08PM (#31926286)
I really wish MS had worked on bringin their 2008, pages-inspired mac UI to windows rather than bringing the ribbon to the Mac.

https://appleinsider.com/articles/07/11/14/road_to_mac_offic...

Since then Apple switched from having a seperate inspector window for the controls to having a sidebar. I see this as a downgrade, but a minor one.

And MS kind of went for the same idea but laid out the blocks horizontally. Which… since text is wider than it is tall, makes labels hard to fit in.

And because people don’t scroll horizontally, they made the available options change based on the window width. So if you want to see everything, you’ll make the window fairly wide, at which point you’ve got the ribbon using up vertical real estate, and blank space on the sides where a side-bar or inspector could’ve been.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by hbn on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @05:27PM (#31925932)
Microsoft's ribbon UI is such a cluttered mess of a design paradigm. Who knows, maybe once you've memorized it, it's efficient. But for the amount I use the Office apps, nothing is ever where I'd expect it to be. And the layout is just insane, there's differently shaped buttons and groupings of functionality, etc. It's like they just came up with a bunch of icons for the different functionality and haphazardly dumped them all over in random tabs.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jmmv on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:13AM (#31928910)
This. I only really started using Office about a year ago (after decades of being off Windows)… and… what a mess. I remember the ribbon being touted as “the next big thing” in UI design when it came out but I just don’t see how that makes any sense.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by bsder on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:25PM (#31926433)
Pages, Numbers, and Keynote were all Steve Jobs being pissy about Microsoft Office.

We have given Keynote the colloquial name "iPreach" for a reason ...

I used to use it, but Pages forced an update and clobbered a final I had made right before I needed to print it out. That was the start of my leaving the Apple ecosystem.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by KerrAvon on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:49PM (#31928276)
It’s not Steve being “pissy” or really caring about the MS apps at all. Such attitudes, people.

Pages and Numbers exist because Apple wanted a modern office-lite suite to cheaply bundle in place of the increasingly ancient AppleWorks for users who needed basic functionality.

Keynote exists because Steve personally preferred to use a particular NeXT app for presentations — I don’t recall the name —- and it was no longer available. It’s bespoke presentation software originally built directly to Steve’s specifications.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by lloydatkinson on Thursday June 30, 2022 @05:48AM (#31930424)
Do you have a screenshot of this?
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by sleepdreamy on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:34PM (#31924009)
Microsoft has a straight up monopoly on Corporate Domains/Operating Systems. Interesting to me that people complain about Amazon/AWS but noone mentions Microsoft being a huge behemoth. Domains..365 Suite..AD etc;
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by tmccrary55 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:10PM (#31924451)
You must be new to the industry
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jamiek88 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @04:16PM (#31925195)
I did a genuine double take there. ‘No one complains about Microsoft being a behemoth’. Erm….what?
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by tiahura on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @05:26PM (#31925922)
There’s no M in FAAnG.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by SgtBastard on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:59PM (#31926770)
FAANG was never about tech dominance (no Cisco, no Oracle, no Microsoft) but was about tech stocks experiencing a period of hyper growth at the time the acronym was coined. MS has been a mature, late stage dominant tech firm for decade.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by makeitdouble on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:29PM (#31926473)
On that part, I never understood why people put Netflix in there, except for making it easier to pronounce. Netflix feels neither like a sheer evil corporation nor an abusive quasi monopoly, nor a giant in any specific way (why would we put Netflix in front of Disney for instance?)
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by selcuka on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @08:18PM (#31927350)
It's all about stock value [1]:

> Overall, it is through strong financial performance such as this that the FAANG stocks have prospered recently. Over the past five years, for instance, Meta and Amazon have seen stock-price increases of 185% and 500%, respectively. For their part, Apple and Alphabet saw price increases of about 175% over that same timeframe, whereas Netflix saw its value rise by nearly 450%.

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/faang-stocks.asp

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jamiek88 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @05:29PM (#31925943)
I’ve always thought it should be faamg anyway!
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by sleepdreamy on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:31AM (#31989394)
I am! About a year in now.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by nray on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:40PM (#31923364)
And Freehand was better than Illustrator IMHO, but Adobe bundled Illustrator with Photoshop to schools and so we lost a great drawing and layout tool.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by spikej on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:32PM (#31924699)
I loved how well the Macromedia products played with each other. Freehand -> Flash or Director just WORKED! Illustrator to these failed miserably.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by BolexNOLA on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:16PM (#31923803)
RIP Gimp
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by r00fus on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:58AM (#31921084)
A study in network effects and defacto standards-based monopoly.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by outside1234 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:31AM (#31920650)
Persuasion (and the rest) was not better in the business sense.

ie. As a CIO, I can go buy a suite of products that work together well. This is what Microsoft recognized - the bundle and integration was the key.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by loloquwowndueo on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:37AM (#31920749)
Others also recognized this (Borland / WordPerfect aligning, and WordPerfect’s strategy was “we interact with other industry leading applications” (like 1-2-3) way before the days of Windows) but they failed to execute for other reasons, so it wasn’t like Microsoft figured out something else others didn’t. They used their first mover advantage and control of the platform to outmaneuver the competition.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by Arainach on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:39AM (#31921703)
WordPerfect couldn't even work well with itself and bungled the transition from DOS to GUI hard. Word's biggest advantage was that it worked great on Windows, while WordPerfect had to tiptoe around offending their existing DOS experts.

History repeats itself in office suites (or at least rhymes) - the modern version of folks offended that the GUI version broke keyboard shortcuts are people convinced that because they managed to find things in the cluttered confusing menus, the ribbon must be awful.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by kwanbix on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:44PM (#31922606)
One of the problems was that most companies where developing OS/2 version of their apps, as Microsoft had promised that was the future, while Microsoft was building Windows apps. By the time they realized their mistake, it was already too late.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by mgoetzke on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:59AM (#31922007)
I still remember how many minutes it took to boot WordPerfect on the schools 486DX2 66Mhz ... I could time it to play a round of doom on another machine next to it.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by happyopossum on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:12PM (#31922167)
I'm guessing that was loading over the LAN, as that's the only time I recall seeing multi-minute load times on a DX2. In that scenario, the speed of the computer was largely irrelevant, as files were being pulled from a NetWare server (reading files of very slow spinning disks) over a 10Mb shared media ethernet network.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by pianoben on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:37PM (#31924756)
> the modern version of folks offended that the GUI version broke keyboard shortcuts are people convinced that because they managed to find things in the cluttered confusing menus, the ribbon must be awful

To be fair, the real "competition" that the Ribbon displaced wasn't just menus, it was toolbars. Yes, the toolbar sections were arbitrary, but so were ribbon sections. Massive amounts of cheese moved, causing lots of confusion, and it also took way more screen real-estate. In Office, it was a net loss IMO.

In the File Explorer, the ribbon was a disaster, in practice if not necessarily in theory.

I wasn't offended by the switch, but it definitely felt like an unforced error.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by KerrAvon on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:52PM (#31928287)
It probably helped that Word didn’t have much of a DOS user base to carry over, so Microsoft felt unconstrained by previous UI convention.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by cafard on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:37AM (#31932883)
I am a slow typist, and I found that I could get ahead of WordPerfect 6 on Windows 95. Truly good typists must have found this to be a problem. I'm not sure how otherwise the 5.1 diehards were offended, though.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by pooper on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:33AM (#31920686)
Maybe this is obvious but this sound like zoom vs Microsoft teams story just in the past.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by marricks on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:41AM (#31921735)
And giving them away for free with an operating system to kill any competition that could exist?

It's impossible to compete without making a whole different operating system when Microsoft was in it's anticompetitive heyday.

Even through the lease of how our world is meant to work that's seems messed up.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by rchaud on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:15PM (#31922215)
The only thing they gave away for free was a PowerPoint viewer software. Same with Word and Excel.

These are multi-billion dollar product lines, why would MS ever give them away for free? If you received it without paying, you likely bought a PC with Office bundled in. Somebody paid for it one way or another.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by criddell on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:27PM (#31923183)
I think they are free on iOS and Android.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by rchaud on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:40PM (#31924094)
Mobile is a different business model, as people are used to paying nothing or very little for apps. It's similar to what used to be called "shareware" or 'trialware' back in the day -- apps with a restricted set of features, designed to entice you into buying the full thing.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jaywalk on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:56PM (#31922787)
> And giving them away for free with an operating system to kill any competition that could exist?

Microsoft never did this, but Apple did. And still does today.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by mardifoufs on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:49AM (#31921854)
Wait, Microsoft used to bundle Office for free with windows? When did that happen? (I'm pretty unfamiliar with pre-2010 Microsoft so I'm genuinely wondering!)
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by hnlmorg on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:24PM (#31922342)
I vaguely recall that in the Windows 3.11 days there was a cut down version of Office (might have been called something else?) which was either free or at least frequently bundled with new PCs in the same way that Windows was.

I can’t find anything online that discusses this though. Most articles seem to talk about recent versions of Office (last 10 or 15 years) but the version I’m thinking of would have been pre-95.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jcheng on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:30PM (#31922409)
You might be thinking of Microsoft Works? I don't remember it being free but it was frequently offered as a low-cost add-on.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by midasuni on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:22AM (#31929960)
Such a great oxymoron

I seem to remember Works was around £80, office 4.3 was around £400.

In reality whatever you had at work was free as you just brought the floppies home and installed it, which led to a generation of people being brought up on Microsoft products.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by hnlmorg on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:37PM (#31924058)
Ahh yes, that’s exactly what I’m thinking of. Thanks for the reminder.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by xtracto on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:21PM (#31923085)
There was Microsoft Write ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Write ) but Word/Office was NEVER bundled with Windows. I used Microsoft products from MS-DOS 5 to Windows 7, and that never happened.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by hnlmorg on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:55PM (#31924271)
Likewise (well a slightly earlier version of DOS since that’s what my high school ran on their ring token coax network, plus some (by that time) old college stand alones that you had to run something like ‘park’ to park the HDD head before powering off). In fact I’m pretty sure I’d written some of my course work in Word for DOS too. Feels like a life time ago now.

Anyhow, there definitely was an office suite (lower case O) that was bundled with some PCs. But as another HNer points out it was Microsoft Works rather than Microsoft Office.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Works

(After reading the above link, Im surprised to see Works lasted so long. The last time I ever saw it “in the wild” was back on Windows 3.11)

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by xtracto on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:06PM (#31924409)
I remember having a hard time looking to open .WKS files from some accountants here in my country who refused to stop using Works for a long time.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by Lammy on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @04:26PM (#31925318)
It's sneaky how Works muddied the water for Lotus 1-2-3 which already used `.wks` for its WorKSheet files: http://fileformats.archiveteam.org/wiki/Lotus_1-2-3
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by mod50ack on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:47PM (#31923444)
With Windows, no. But many, many computers were sold with Office bundled in through the 2000s. It's how my family got Office and how I think most consumer-side people did.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by yabatopia on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:55AM (#31921945)
That never happened.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by emsixteen on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:55AM (#31921953)
I don't remember them doing it at least. Maybe before the '97 versions?
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by cupofpython on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:47AM (#31921811)
reminds me of trying to compete with imessage or facetime today
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by bachmeier on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:34PM (#31923274)
I strongly preferred Quattro Pro to Excel. By the late 90s, it ceased to exist in university computer labs, because every new computer came bundled with Office. I had only a mild preference for WordPerfect, but the QP to Excel migration was painful.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by listenallyall on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:33AM (#31932830)
> Office also basically killed word processing innovation

This is partially true, but importantly, very much untrue as well. Word itself was a massive innovation over the dominant word processing program at the time, WordPerfect. DOS-based, no GUI, obscure commands and yet so widely used that virtually every keyboard came with a WP cheat sheet for the function keys (4 commands per key).

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by neovive on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @07:37PM (#31927083)
Lotus held their own for a while and forced some innovation in the spreadsheet market. Outside of spreadsheets, the bundling of Word, Powerpoint, and Access was too dominant on Windows -- especially since the previously dominant tools were mainly running on DOS (e.g. WordPerfect).
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by listenallyall on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:38AM (#31932896)
Not sure about this. Lotus 1-2-3 for Windows, at least around 1991-92, was awful. Excel was far smoother, faster, easier.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by nojito on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:25AM (#31919785)
Keynote is vastly better than PowerPoint. Apple made the right call in the end.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by PinguTS on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:29AM (#31919834)
You know, that there was no Keynote in the 1980 and 1990. There was no Keynote before MacOS X at all.

As much as I like Keynote, it is still very limited in many ways. One not so unimportant, it is Apple only.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by edf13 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:16AM (#31920434)
I use Keynote on Windows... via the iCloud website. It is Keynote, although a little more limited - but it works for me.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by kalleboo on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:24AM (#31920554)
Huh I always assumed Apple had acquired Concurrence but reality turns out to be far more interesting - the developers were acquired by Sun of all people to develop an OpenStep and then Java office suite...
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by p_l on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:43PM (#31924839)
Even funnier, when Sun showed Looking Glass desktop demo, Jobs apparently called Schwartz with a Cease & Desist demand. Schwartz reportedly answered with equivalent of "nice presentation program you have there, would be a shame if it was canceled for copyright infringement" and the C&D was dropped.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by astrange on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @07:48PM (#31927151)
Related, everyone’s favorite Office feature WordArt was Scott Forstall’s intern project at MS before he led the creation of iOS.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by arbitrary_name on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:41PM (#31922566)
I consulted at Apple for a while, and many people there preferred to use PowerPoint. I was given permission to work with PowerPoint to prevent issues when working with other teams and vendors who did not have keynote.

I found the whole thing hilarious.

Their excel competitor, the name of which i don't recall, had even less utilization internally which i found even more amusing.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by xattt on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:17PM (#31923034)
> Their excel competitor, the name of which i don't recall …

I think they named after whatever spreadsheets are used for calculating, something like Apple Digits or Numerals or Figures.

Does anyone else remember?

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by bdowling on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:30PM (#31923966)
It's called Numbers. I prefer it to Libre Office Calc. Neither are perfect substitutes for a person who really needs Excel though.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by lotsofpulp on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @05:19PM (#31925851)
Pretty sure xattt was attempting humor.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by bdowling on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @05:49PM (#31926129)
Whoosh. Thanks.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by KerrAvon on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:01PM (#31928319)
Probably depends on the specific team, but I’ve never seen anyone at Apple use anything but Keynote since shortly after it became available. Apple is very sensitive to design, and Keynote’s default templates provide good design out of the box.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by Spooky23 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:05PM (#31922083)
Keynote looks great but is essentially unchanged for almost 20 years. PowerPoint is less awful in many ways than it was.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by p_l on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:45PM (#31924861)
Considering that the first releases were cloning an existing program to the point that threat of copyright infringement suit was seen as legitimate, I suspect certain things were forbidden to change at least so long as Jobs lived.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by duxup on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:13AM (#31920394)
Keynote somehow always looks amazing, but is also pretty limited compared to power point.

Having said that ... it also gets the same job done so being limited maybe isn't so bad.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by sdoering on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:44AM (#31920851)
I always said I would miss keynote the most when dropping Mac. I still miss a bit of the ease which with you could create beautiful slides given a decent master.

Not sure why, this was and probably still is a bit better on Mac. But other than that I miss nothing using PowerPoint on Windows nowadays.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by duxup on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:59AM (#31921113)
Every time I dip into PowerPoint it feels so hard to make things not ... look bad.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by innocentoldguy on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:55PM (#31922759)
I agree. I think Keynote's limitations are a solid feature. Presentations should be basic slides with a minimal amount of important information on them. PowerPoints features are excessive and I've seen those features lead to disastrous, in my opinion, presentation experiences.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by april_22 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:13AM (#31920404)
Non-Apple user here. Just out of curiosity: what makes Keynote better than Powerpoint?
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by bombcar on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:22AM (#31920520)
Keynote is more limited than Powerpoint; but unless you're a Powerpoint wizard, Keynote has much better defaults and styles. I've yet to see a Keynote deck that cannot be replicated in Powerpoint; but the average user seems to make better ones in Keynote unless they have a designed template that they stick to very carefully.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jedberg on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:34AM (#31921634)
> I've yet to see a Keynote deck that cannot be replicated in Powerpoint;

Almost every deck I've ever made in Keynote cannot be replicated in PowerPoint. It doesn't have the same support for transitions that Keynote does. Good transitions (not flashy ones) are what make a good presentation great.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by bruce511 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:30PM (#31927767)
Nah mate, I disagree. Good content delivered by a good presenter (or should that be great content and a great presenter) make a great presentation. The slide transitions are eminently forgettable.

Consider perhaps the most famous presentation of them all - the iPhone release - I don't think the slide transitions got too much press, and I don't personally recall what they were.

These days my slide transitions are simple - slide 1 replaced instantly with slide 2. In other words no transition at all.

You may prefer a different transition, but to say it's the transitions that make the presentation great is reaching imo.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jedberg on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:41PM (#31927844)
The transitions never get press or notice, unless they are bad. Then you get comments about how it looked "unprofessional". Apple keynotes are a great example -- they will never have a slide without a transition of some sort (the instant replace that you mention).

I get paid to make presentations, I've worked with other paid speakers, and I've seen 1000s of presentations. All the people who get paid to make presentations use transitions (and almost all of them use Keynote too), and there is a reason. Because it just looks "unprofessional" when you don't.

This book really upped my presentation game, and using transitions is in it with more explanation, if you're really interested:

https://nealford.com/books/presentationpatterns.html

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by mvidal01 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:05PM (#31922895)
Doesn't the content and the public speaking skills of the presenter play a role?
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by jedberg on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @01:39PM (#31923347)
I mean of course it does, but if you have a great speaker with great content and a crappy deck, it really takes away from the message. But if you have a good speaker with good content and an amazing deck, it enhances the message so much that that presentation is perceived very highly.

Yes, you need good content and a good speaker as a baseline, but assuming you have that, the deck is what makes the difference.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by bonaldi on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @02:20PM (#31923847)
PowerPoint has been iterated over the years to be more or less a document publishing app that happens to go full-screen. It has support for lots of embeddings (like Excel), and can help turn especially heavy chunks of text into something slightly more digestible – Smart Art is good at this, in fact.

Conversely, Keynote was and remains an app designed for visually heavy presentations, so it optimises a lot more for aesthetics: gradients, blends, transparency, (sadly still no blur wtf), animation of items on a slide, very complex animated reveal and build, complicated slide transitions, etc. It has also UX optimised for visually precise layout (in areas PowerPoint is frankly unhelpful).

If you just want to make people look at pages after page of charts and graphs that should have been memos, PowerPoint is good and possibly stronger. If you want to make an aesthetically compelling visual presentation, Keynote will get you there for less effort.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by rchaud on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:23PM (#31922323)
I'm an Apple user and a PC user at work. Keynote is a toy that works well as long as your use case is hyper-practiced presentations with timed transitions and animations like Steve Jobs would do. Or, pretty pitch decks with made up numbers for VCs to marvel at.

In the real world, where PPTs are created and shared for presenting information and making decisions, we need good integration of real data. PPT does that by linking directly to the source file. If you have an Excel chart that you copied over to PPT, updating the numbers in Excel will update the PPT chart in real time as well. This was a gamechanging feature that saved a lot of time, and I think it only became available with PowerPoint 2007.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by p_l on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:55PM (#31924964)
The embedding features date from Windows 3.x era, and I think fully came to be with Office 97 or 2000, either of which was implemented fully as set of COM objects with OLE Automation interfaces and essentially embeddable in everything - if you deliver an application on Windows and can specify Office license in your requirements, suddenly you can do a lot more - for example, I've used programs that simply embedded Excel for data entry features, not just as "can import from specially prepared Excel sheets" but directly embedded Excel sheet editor in their GUI and stored Excel data streams internally to their document formats.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by ch_sm on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:18AM (#31920465)
Personal opinion. The animations are smoother and better designed, the templates are nicer, the UI is simpler, the default fonts they ship with are more recognizable and render better (at least on hi-res displays), and it feels a little easier on CPU and Memory.
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by statictype on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:23AM (#31920543)
Its simpler and easier to use. Maybe my usecase isnt very heavy but I have not come across anything in Powerpoint that I couldnt do just as well in Keynote.

Also it exports to video. Which I think Powerpoint doesn’t do? (Older version at least)

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by noSyncCloud on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:55AM (#31921043)
PowerPoint has been able to export to video for ages. You can even export to GIF shudder
Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by Synaesthesia on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:27AM (#31921528)
Keynote has great transitions and appearance the interface for the iWork suite is pretty intuitive and easy to use.

Steve Jobs presentations always made use of it.

But I gotta admit PowerPoint has come a long way and has a ton of great features these days too. Eg it can actually.l design slides for you, quite tastefully on the new 365 version.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by p_l on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @03:57PM (#31924983)
Keynote was made so that Steve Jobs could switch to making presentations on Mac instead of PC running late version of OpenSTEP, and faithfully replicated Concurrence which Jobs used on OpenSTEP.

It was made for Jobs' keynotes as its main goal

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by ska on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:20PM (#31922282)
> quite tastefully on the new 365 version.

This is definitely a YMMV situation.

Re:Microsoft beat Apple to buy PowerPoint for $14M (2016) by sys_64738 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @11:08AM (#31921263)
Probably the fact it isn't PowerPoint. When you use PP you use it will preconceived notions that it's a piece of junk that gets in your face. It is and it does.