News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by o_____________o on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @05:13PM (#31674272)
What changed?
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by _jal on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:21PM (#31675144)
Apple blesses a converged Mac/iOS approach, which in practice means you basically throw away a lot of what made the Mac excellent.

Not that Apple is even following their own guidelines...

https://mjtsai.com/blog/2022/06/08/system-settings/

The incoherent design, weirdly bipolar automation efforts, letting the command line rot, and a new-feature focus on lock-in are making the platform increasingly something I just don't care about anymore.

Not to mention every time I get another Buy Apple Music! nudge or deal with their bratty "not now" dismissal of the fucking credit card offer makes me actively dislike Apple a bit more.

I'm clearly not the customer Apple wants, and all good things come to an end. It just saddens me a bit - I've been using Macs for over 30 years now. Watching them become more annoying and arrogant than IBM sucks.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by ggm on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:07PM (#31675603)
Yea, the memetics of "apple get HCI" is long, long dead. Apple does whatever the hell it wants, and loyalists defend it. Your case of "re-validate to spend" is the classic example of gui gone wrong. The box has validated me time out of mind, and even to get to the door of the store I had to validate but no: it wants to ask again. And again. And again. Oh, and microsoft.app again. and again. Oh, and all those other things, except wierdly ssh in the keychain is just.. fine!
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by jbverschoor on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:23PM (#31675759)
There are soooo many UI inconsistencies recently. It seems that makes it’s being developed by iOS developers who have no clue about keyboard shortcuts, common features, etc. It’s getting worse and worse with each component that’s being replaced.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by gubby on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:57PM (#31675505)
And the atrocious disregard for performance over the last few years. My 2014 OSX 10.14 home Mac Mini is so much faster and more responsive than my 2021 OSX 12.4 work Mac mini (with no notable difference in features) it is difficult to conclude anything other than malice.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by astrange on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:49PM (#31676746)
There is probably something wrong with the machine. If it's M1 it really shouldn't be slow unless it's under serious memory pressure. If it's Intel, it's more possible, but could still be dust in the fans or low disk space or such things.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by dannyw on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:10PM (#31676875)
Since recent versions, macOS now phones home and gets apple's permission over the internet before allowing you to open a binary. This is a synchronous blocking operation.

If your ping is 30ms, you don't notice it.

If your ping is 300ms due to say weak wifi, you do notice a 300ms wait when you open an app.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by astrange on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:25PM (#31676957)
Above post didn't say anything about app launches. There was a popular blog post about that, but it doesn't mean it applies to every issue.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by kbenson on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:02PM (#31677165)
It doesn't need to apply to above post, it can apply just as well to your statement that it means there's something wrong with the machine if it's an M1. If a slow or laggy connection affects responsiveness in launching desktop apps, that's definitely a reason it could feel slower that doesn't mean there's something wrong, as it would be completely by design.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by threeseed on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:05PM (#31677176)
I don't know how a 300ms delay for a first-time app launch would render a machine unusable and requiring regular restarts.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by cassandratt on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:46PM (#31675947)
My M1 Mac blows away my 3 year old desktop outside or raw graphics output due to the desktop having a 1080. It's such a massive power leap, it's difficult for me to believe that you bought a M1 Mac. I suspect you have hardware, or PEBKAK issues.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by Nextgrid on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:53PM (#31676001)
Raw performance as measured in benchmarks, sure.

But the newer OSes do feel more bloated and indeed are sometimes slower. My 12-inch Macbook (low-powered dual-core i5) on Mojave feels much faster at opening built-in applications and simple tasks than my M1 running Monterey, and yet I can't think of any Monterey feature that I actually use over what Mojave already had - my workflow is exactly the same but now I seem to have to withstand a performance tax.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by dannyw on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:08PM (#31676860)
Latest versions of Mac OS connect to the Internet and gets apples permission before opening an app.

If you are on a high latency network, eg weak wifi signals, you'll be waiting 200-300ms.

Those on super fast internet don't notice, and think it's a problem with you, but no, it's Apple.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by threeseed on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:08PM (#31677189)
> Latest versions of Mac OS connect to the Internet and gets apples permission before opening an app.

Pretty sure this is only on first time launch to verify the notarisation.

It doesn't happen every time.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by cassandratt on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:46PM (#31677099)
Is that only for the App Store? I'm not seeing that traffic.

I live in a rural area, city under 40k. We don't have amazing internet.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by sneak on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:30PM (#31677286)
No, it's for all apps.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by cassandratt on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:04PM (#31676086)
This isn't my experience at all. I'm feeling fortunate that we don't use the same stack. ;)
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by AnonHP on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:49AM (#31677659)
A tangential correction: it’s PEBKAC, not PEBKAK, as written in your comment. The last letter stands for “chair”.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by FranksTV on Thursday June 09, 2022 @02:26AM (#31678114)
I'm guessing you're running Intel versions of apps, and the emulation us slowing things down.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by al_borland on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:27PM (#31676973)
My home Mac mini (2018 Core i5) running 12.4 runs dramatically faster than my work MacBook Pro (2019 Core i9) running 12.4-ish. It's malice, but not by Apple. It's from my company installing so many agents that typing becomes problematic. Some days it is down right unusable and I have to reboot every 2 days just to try and make it better.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by sneak on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:14PM (#31677219)
I refuse to install software on macOS that requires root. (With the current single exception of the Creative Cloud, for which I am actively seeking replacements.)
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by al_borland on Thursday June 09, 2022 @04:34PM (#31686466)
Unfortunately I don't have a choice. They silently push all kinds of things to the system. Every week my fans spin up and I look at the Activity Monitor to find a new agent using all my CPU.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by eastbound on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:42AM (#31677924)
Have you found? Affinity Photo and Designer? Krita?
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by andrewjl on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:02AM (#31677727)
Have you tried comparing your i5 Mac mini to an M1 Mac?
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by al_borland on Thursday June 09, 2022 @04:31PM (#31686422)
I have a MBP with M1 Pro, but that doesn't have any work junk on it so I haven't had the need to do any real comparisons. The only thing I could really do is check my FPS on Minecraft, but I don't play it enough or obsess about FPS enough to bother.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by edgyquant on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:29AM (#31677863)
My M1 Mac Mini keeps up (and beats) my 2018 RYZEN with a dedicated graphics card.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by seltzered_ on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:41PM (#31675342)
Oddly, the settings panel in Ventura looks closer to what Gnome Settings looks like. Just without the "Buy Apple Music! nudge" or "credit card offer" elements.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by musicale on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:34AM (#31677892)
Advertising in Settings is pure evil and needs to go away.

Same for pushing ads through Notifications.

Apple's road to hell is paved with OS-embedded advertising and user manipulation in the name of service and subscription revenue.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by threeseed on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:11PM (#31677209)
It also looks like the original Mac Control Panel from 1987:

https://apple.fandom.com/wiki/System_4.1?file=System_4.1

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by Macha on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:59PM (#31675530)
The last redesign of Apple Mail made it look a lot more like Gnome too
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by paganel on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:47AM (#31677945)
> The incoherent design, weirdly bipolar automation efforts, letting the command line rot

Which is a real shame because their hardware had started to be excellent again. What's the point of having a cool machine like a M1 Macbook Air if, in the future, you'll feel as an alien on it? (I mean, from the pov of a programmer)

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by daniel_iversen on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:59PM (#31675533)
Are we moving towards a tablet-laptop hybrid Apple device in the next few years I wonder? (similar to MS Surface).. I know there's the issue of cannibalisation but I think such a device could be awesome (but hard to do right)
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by threeseed on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:17PM (#31677231)
This comes up every year and people still don't listen to the original justification for why Apple used iOS instead of OSX given they had a choice.

OSX is designed for a keyboard and mouse. iOS is designed for a finger.

They have wildly different semantics e.g. precision, gestures that you can't abstract without ending up with a horribly compromised experience e.g. Windows tablet mode. And that's just not in Apple's DNA.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by imiric on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:19AM (#31677502)
> OSX is designed for a keyboard and mouse. iOS is designed for a finger.

That line has been becoming blurrier for years now. iPadOS supports keyboard and mouse inputs, and the UI is moving closer to replicating a desktop experience on every release. macOS has supported touch gestures for a long time, and the UI is moving closer to resembling a mobile experience.

It's not hard to imagine full convergence of both OSs and the devices that run them. As usual, Apple can claim to be the innovator in this change, even though competitors have been doing it, admittedly worse, much earlier.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by kaba0 on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:43AM (#31679612)
iOS is a much more modern OS with secure basis. Keyboard and mouse vs touch is mostly just a “userspace” decision, but from Apple’s point of view, OSX has quite a bit of technical debt in several areas that are possibly impossible to fix, like security.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by RajT88 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:50PM (#31675970)
I will not be happy until my Surface Book 2 is a pile of slag.

But it might be the best effort yet of unifying mobile device and desktop experiences.

The industry just needs to keep trying is all. Eventually someone is going to get it right. It's anyone's game, and all the major players thus far have fucked it up multiple times.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by bombcar on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:07PM (#31675602)
It’s been obviously on the radar for years but it’s moving very slowly - the macbook is now arguably a iPad with a keyboard now so the main thing left is the software unification.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by FranksTV on Thursday June 09, 2022 @02:28AM (#31678131)
I mean the new iPad supports a trackpad and windowed displays, so I think we're already there.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by rad_gruchalski on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:02PM (#31675566)
As long as it comes with 16” screen and can run kubernetes, I’m okay with that.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by jjtheblunt on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:41PM (#31675338)
> letting the command line rot

how so?

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by smoldesu on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @05:30PM (#31674525)
Apparently, they revised a few recommendations to change the look of MacOS Ventura: https://old.reddit.com/r/MacOS/comments/v7o87z/apple_should_...
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by hbn on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @05:59PM (#31674900)
I hate this converging of touch interfaces and desktop interfaces. I get that it's easier than ever to share codebases between your desktop and mobile app, but all you get out of this trend is interfaces that are neither good for touch nor for desktop. They're just... passable and occasionally annoying for each.

It's why I'm against the idea that so many have put forward of bringing macOS to the iPad. It just means that macOS will be forced into being a touch-first OS (since many people use iPads without keyboards, so every interaction now needs to be doable without one) and it'll just be a worse experience for a keyboard and mouse setup.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by gumby on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:22PM (#31676566)
I like, well not convergence exactly, but certainly coherence. TBH the old system preferences with its array of icons is more iOS like and the transition should have gone the other way.

OTOH I agree that the Mac should retain and maintain the primacy of kbd-and-mouse interaction and ipad/phone the finger interaction. Jamming one metaphor into the other is terrible and lazy, which I think is what you were getting at.

Omni group’s apps are good examples of getting it right. The app icons aren’t the same but they rhyme; the visual metaphors are the same but the interactions are appropriate to the tools (kbd/mouse or finger) and sizes of the various devices.

Pity Apple can’t go to the same effort. It’s newly great, or even that great at all.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by bromuro on Thursday June 09, 2022 @12:16AM (#31677482)
> I hate this converging of touch interfaces and desktop interfaces.

In 2022 the first experience with a computer is, for most people, a smartphone. It feels natural removing checkboxex for toggle buttons.

After all isn’t the web UI all about converging touch and non-touch (aka “desktop”)?

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by usrn on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:03PM (#31676825)
tbh mobile interfaces aren't even nice on phones. I own a Pinephone and normal X11 apps feel like an improvement even with that form factor.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by sph on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @05:58PM (#31674883)
That Ventura screenshot looks terrible. Is that real or has it been photoshopped?
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by Gigachad on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:51PM (#31675447)
I like the new one more. Looks kinda cluttered and unorganised with the checkbox version.

But I think I’m general HN tends to hold a very conservative view on UI while the general public does not. The feeling I get is that most users here believe that windows XP was the peak of UI and everything after was worse. Which is not at all what the average person would say.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by zozbot234 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:03PM (#31675573)
What's wrong with WinXP UI? Apart from not being touch-ready (though Microsoft also had pen-driven "Tablet PC" and "Pocket PC" UI's in the same style) or usable with mixed-DPI display settings. I for one find it quite modern and intuitive at the same time. Those old-style UI's were rigorously tested using focus groups of "average" folks, so practicality was very highly valued.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by GeorgeWBasic on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:25PM (#31677267)
Nothing's wrong with it, if you turned off the Fisher-Price theme. It was usable and simple, and displayed information clearly. It wasn't suitable for mixed-DPI, but a replacement easily could be without losing anything. Instead, we get the garbage that is Windows 11. All three desktop platforms have been taking leaps backwards in usability.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by xattt on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:15PM (#31676533)
They were pen-driven interfaces, so targets would have been smaller than a capacitive touchscreen used with fingers.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by Nextgrid on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:01PM (#31676061)
> while the general public does not

The general public spends too much time peck-typing or fighting with ads/spam/etc to even begin to feel limited by the UI "improvements". The problem however is that by removing power-user features and dumbing everything down to the lowest common denominator it also prevents those users from ever levelling up.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by kibibu on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:03PM (#31677167)
From my brief viewing, there doesn't appear to be any loss of features between those two screenshots.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by Fatnino on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:18PM (#31676547)
XP ui was worse than win2k, the actual pinnacle of Microsoft os ui.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by hsn915 on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:04PM (#31676472)
My impression is the general public is far more conservative on the UI than the average HN user.

Only hip designers think coming up with new UI design ideas every year is a good idea.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by usrn on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @10:24PM (#31676950)
IME most people IRL also think XP was the peak of UI design. Personally I prefer Windows 98 (really FVWM if given the choice, and I am given the choice so that's what I run.)
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by gumby on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:23PM (#31676574)
Peak UI was the Ann Arbor Ambassador in 80x48 mode, plus the mode bar at the bottom.

From almost complete arpanet dominance to utter obscurity.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by SllX on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:06PM (#31674987)
It’s real. Not that System Preferences was blowing anyone away, but System “Settings” is Apple answering the question no one asked: what if we had iPhone Settings but on the Mac?
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by SkyMarshal on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:08PM (#31675004)
I like it better actually. Cleaner, less cluttered, everything related to an option is clearly grouped and visually associated.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by cosmotic on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:20PM (#31675127)
It was all clearly grouped before, but also had visual anchors. The new groups don't satisfy the WCAG contrast ratio guidelines. The new view is definitely 'cleaner', but in this case, that's worse. This isn't an artistic effort, this is a human interface. Did the 40 years of HCI research just turn up the wrong answers before? And the all-along more obvious approach is now the supposedly better approach? Unlikely.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by SkyMarshal on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:11PM (#31675645)
> but also had visual anchors.

I only see one visual anchor in the old one, the horizontal rule at the bottom separating Menu Bar. Everything else is just jumbled together.

The new one at least attempts visual anchors with gradient background boxes and by right-justifying all the controls.

I grant you the contrast ratio is worse and Apple should read Contrast Rebellion. And I personally don't care whether they use a checkbox or a switch, as long as its placement is convenient and aesthetic. I use Linux with Gnome 4 on my workstations, which uses switches for settings, and a MacBook laptop with checkboxes, and iPad with switches, and none of that makes any difference to me.

But otherwise I prefer the layout arrangement of the new one. Vertical and horizontal spacing are more orderly, left-justification of text and right-justification of controls improves UI consistency, and grouping within gradient boxes is more aesthetically calmer to my eye. Just my $0.02, to each their own.

https://contrastrebellion.com/

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by astrange on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @09:44PM (#31676716)
New UIs are less contrasty because old UIs were designed for low-quality TN LCD screens. Modern LCDs and OLEDs have better black points, so the UI gets grayer to make up for it.

There's a lot of accessibility options like "increase contrast" and "differentiate without shapes" if you don't like it though.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by dmitriid on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:43AM (#31677928)
> There's a lot of accessibility options like "increase contrast" and "differentiate without shapes" if you don't like it though.

No. Just no. You make these things readable and accessible by default. You don't bury it in a setting somewhere.

I have 20/20 vision and I felt compelled to turn high contrast and button shapes on because the OS is so goddam unreadable.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by positus on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#31685791)
Are you referring to macOS generally or Ventura specifically?

On calibrated monitors I haven't had an issue, but I could see it being a problem if the contrast is too high on a display. I've been using macOS since Snow Leopard but I have not tried Ventura yet.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by dmitriid on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:02PM (#31687516)
If your general purpose OS requires a calibrated monitor for this to not be an issue, it means the OS design is a failure.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by astrange on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:43PM (#31685838)
Sure, but what kind of display do you have?
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by dmitriid on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:03PM (#31687520)
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by kergonath on Thursday June 09, 2022 @02:11AM (#31678049)
> left-justification of text and right-justification of controls improves UI consistency

True, but it also makes it harder to see which text corresponds to which switch, by separating them all with different distances. Before, there was no ambiguity about what each box did. Now, you have to scan the left column to find the item you want; and then either scan right to see the switch (which is error prone because there are no lines to follow) or scan the right column from the top and hope you counted correctly. It is more pleasing aesthetically, but less useable.

I guess the way to have both controls and labels to line up without separating them would be to put the labels after the controls. But it is not great to have the explanation of what a button does after the button. And there would still be issues with drop downs with different widths.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by cosmotic on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:15PM (#31676154)
One of us misunderstands what visual anchors are. I consider the staggered drop downs visual anchors.

I don't disagree with a single point you made about the anesthetics, and still passionately believe the ux is worse now. The new one would look better in a luxury furniture catalog but humans using it would take longer to complete tasks and produce more mistakes.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by mafalda on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:50PM (#31675436)
This makes sense if you came from touch ui. Mouse and keyboard UI favours the old design because the way you hit things with the mouse is different. It is also bad to compare the two screenshots because the sizes are not in the same scale.

The new grouping is not a clear cut, like why is the position of the docked grouped with window behaviour? The older makes it trivial to discover that the dock moves unlike the newer one.

My view is that the design is much less refined and have a lot of space to improve. It isn't bad, the potential is there if you consider a touch + mouse ui. So let's wait I guess.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by SkyMarshal on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:16PM (#31675693)
> The new grouping is not a clear cut, like why is the position of the docked grouped with window behaviour?

Both seem faulty in that regard. Both cram Dock and Window behavior into the same section, when each should be a separate section similar to the Menu Bar section at the bottom. But that's not a fault of the design language here, and can be fixed without changing it.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by smoldesu on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:35PM (#31675297)
Not sure how I feel about detaching controls from their label like that. I thought we learned our lesson with this when we switched to HiDPI displays, but oh well...
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by SkyMarshal on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @07:34PM (#31675850)
Yeah I can see the argument for keeping the checkboxes on the left and their explainer text immediately adjacent on the right.

But the problem is that the choose-boxes and radio buttons at the top can't be treated the same way, and create an inconsistent layout when combined with the check boxes.

Moving all the text to the left, and all the controls to the right, and boxing each choice together with its text using gradient background boxes, feels overall cleaner, more consistent, and better organized.

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by dmitriid on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:46AM (#31677943)
> and create an inconsistent layout when combined with the check boxes.

This is not a Wes Anderson movie where everything has to be symmetric. You're free to mix controls. To put them in grids. To put them in multiple columns. Just go and look at your System Preferences now.

Or https://twitter.com/siracusa/status/1534261202167152649

Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by ushakov on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @06:39PM (#31675313)
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by spupy on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:41AM (#31678576)
What's wrong with the old checkboxes and why are the sliding switches replacing them?
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines by neilpanchal on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @08:03PM (#31676076)
For sure, humans haven’t.