What's wrong with WinXP UI? Apart from not being touch-ready (though Microsoft also had pen-driven "Tablet PC" and "Pocket PC" UI's in the same style) or usable with mixed-DPI display settings. I for one find it quite modern and intuitive at the same time. Those old-style UI's were rigorously tested using focus groups of "average" folks, so practicality was very highly valued.
Re:New Human Interface Guidelines
by GeorgeWBasic on Wednesday June 08, 2022 @11:25PM
(#31677267)
Nothing's wrong with it, if you turned off the Fisher-Price theme. It was usable and simple, and displayed information clearly. It wasn't suitable for mixed-DPI, but a replacement easily could be without losing anything. Instead, we get the garbage that is Windows 11. All three desktop platforms have been taking leaps backwards in usability.
They were pen-driven interfaces, so targets would have been smaller than a capacitive touchscreen used with fingers.
> while the general public does not
The general public spends too much time peck-typing or fighting with ads/spam/etc to even begin to feel limited by the UI "improvements". The problem however is that by removing power-user features and dumbing everything down to the lowest common denominator it also prevents those users from ever levelling up.
From my brief viewing, there doesn't appear to be any loss of features between those two screenshots.
XP ui was worse than win2k, the actual pinnacle of Microsoft os ui.
My impression is the general public is far more conservative on the UI than the average HN user.
Only hip designers think coming up with new UI design ideas every year is a good idea.
IME most people IRL also think XP was the peak of UI design. Personally I prefer Windows 98 (really FVWM if given the choice, and I am given the choice so that's what I run.)
But I think I’m general HN tends to hold a very conservative view on UI while the general public does not. The feeling I get is that most users here believe that windows XP was the peak of UI and everything after was worse. Which is not at all what the average person would say.