OTOH I agree that the Mac should retain and maintain the primacy of kbd-and-mouse interaction and ipad/phone the finger interaction. Jamming one metaphor into the other is terrible and lazy, which I think is what you were getting at.
Omni group’s apps are good examples of getting it right. The app icons aren’t the same but they rhyme; the visual metaphors are the same but the interactions are appropriate to the tools (kbd/mouse or finger) and sizes of the various devices.
Pity Apple can’t go to the same effort. It’s newly great, or even that great at all.
In 2022 the first experience with a computer is, for most people, a smartphone. It feels natural removing checkboxex for toggle buttons.
After all isn’t the web UI all about converging touch and non-touch (aka “desktop”)?
It's why I'm against the idea that so many have put forward of bringing macOS to the iPad. It just means that macOS will be forced into being a touch-first OS (since many people use iPads without keyboards, so every interaction now needs to be doable without one) and it'll just be a worse experience for a keyboard and mouse setup.