Reminds me of that famous Andy Warhol quote from 1975:
What’s great about this country is that America started the tradition where the richest consumers buy essentially the same things as the poorest. You can be watching TV and see Coca-Cola, and you know that the President drinks Coke, Liz Taylor drinks Coke, and just think, you can drink Coke, too. A Coke is a Coke and no amount of money can get you a better Coke than the one the bum on the corner is drinking. All the Cokes are the same and all the Cokes are good. Liz Taylor knows it, the President knows it, the bum knows it, and you know it.
That's possibly one of the best "fooling you while telling the truth" in print.
Just think of the travel experience of the poorest consumers versus the richest.
(The trick in the Coke thing is the petitio principii that you'd want to drink it.)
Rich people have higher security needs, which is one of the reasons they don't fly coach.
Of course, sometimes they do get places a lot faster on private jets.
The magic mouse is so much better than any other mouse I've used (because the scrolling is so much better) and the charge port being on the bottom has not been an issue a single time over multiple years.
Aesthetically the mouse is great, very beautiful, especially for the time it came out.
The design of the mouse is amazing in several ways, but very lacking in others, specifically ergonomics and charging. In fact, had they made the mouse larger, in all dimensions, they could have solved two birds with one stone. The mouse is too small to comfortable use for most people, making it larger would fit the human hand better and decrease the amount of contortion your hand has to do to use it. And with this extra height they could have put a charging port on the front! Win win on the design side of things!
There are several products you can buy that help with this, I have both wings and a palm bump added to my magic mouse that makes it much more comfortable. I tried to take one apart once to explore making a new case for it that addresses some of these concerns, but I ended up breaking it.
I think that final bit really is the crux, the scrolling and gesture support is so good I'm sufficiently motivated to try and solve the problems with the mouse. A beautifully flawed product.
On point. People too often confuse aesthetics with design.
Be as pedantic as you want, but aesthetics is an aspect of design, not exclusive to it.
If I say "the world was not the most important aspect of the policy, _USA_ was", then that does not imply that USA is not part of the world.
(and these days when everything else is USB-C, instead I'm scrambling to find where my damn lightning cable has gone)
Although I get why they would not put the port on the back - their Lightning cables are not built for the repeated motion/strain of a plugged-in mouse. Anything more strain than plugging your phone in and setting it down causes the cables to break down in months.
?
The keyboard has 3-5x the battery life of the trackpad. Not sure how they can be similar to the mouse if they’re not even similar to each other.
...I still prefer my Logitech mouse that works plugged in though.
https://9to5mac.com/2022/03/25/unnecessary-inventions-magic-...
Was this never even considered an issue? As in, did it just never get considered as something bad? Did it never get focus grouped in a wide enough range of users for someone to question this? Was it noticed, questioned, decided it was works as intended?
It just seems like with a company the size of Apple who all work under draconian NDAs, why not have an internal employee focus group? Hubris of the design silos?
We may disagree—I think that surely there must have been some way of solving the problem—but it seems very unlikely to me that they missed it.
They just exercised judgement that I think was suboptimal.
Of course, they are selling millions of products and making billions of dollars doing it, so not sure I can claim I’m unambiguously right.
That’s the theory. In practice, charging it whilst getting a coffee gives it enough battery life to finish the day. Sure, you need to remember to charge it then. But you never have to chose between using it or charging it for more than a couple of minutes in the real life.
It's a stupid location for a charge port but the battery lasts for several weeks if not months; it's just not that much of an issue in real world use.
In my experience, this is exactly why it's an issue.
All my less tech savvy family who use this mouse forget to charge it because "it never needs charging" ... and then it runs out of juice whilst they are in the midst of something and now they can't use the mouse.
I have no idea how this is a problem for anyone.
My Magic Mouses battery only lasts for 5 to 10 minutes... if I could use it while plugged in I could still use it. As it is I can just toss it.
People who don't like pink bags don't buy pink bags.
Unless you use any application that requires more or less precise scrolls. Like any game, or any map in the browser. The experience of using Google maps / Apple maps / Openstreetmap with Magic Mouse is unbelievably shitty. Almost every time I want to make a click it interprets it as a scroll and zooms in or out. I eventually replaced magic mouse because of this with a regular mouse when I use an Apple computer, and it is much much better.
Sure, the iconic designs of the G4 Cube, iMac, metal Powerbooks and later Macbook were what drew people in, but the usability is what kept many people with Apple.
Is the better scrolling a design or a tech thing? Probably tech, but I'm sure it's only that good because someone really understood how people use it and what it really needs to do well and then insisted that the tech worked flawlessly.
Design, from designare - to mark out, to prepare the plans for, especially to plan the form and structure of
Usability is just one area of emphasis for design. Apple simply included too few elements of usability in their efforts.
We may disagree, but the usability used to be and maybe is again the main selling (or at least "staying") point. I think this was lost a bit during Apple's "high design" years before Ives departure. It was often form over function.
So here's the rub, isn't it? Consumer mice from decades ago did NOT require you to check battery levels.
There's no good reason for a charging/wired port on the bottom of the mouse. It may only be a problem rarely, but it could just not be a problem AT ALL.
Of course, just thinking about using the Magic Mouse for FPS games hurts my wrists, so it in particular was never a real consideration anyhow :P
Short of putting a post-it note on my screen, I don’t think I ever will. My brain doesn’t work that way, and the point of technology is to support me, not for me to support technology.
Requiring users to perform their own async mental scheduling of a trivially forgettable pending task like “plug in the mouse” is bad design.
Perhaps some people have an innate ability to perform that kind of task scheduling without it being a significant cognitive load, but many others do not.
The previous magic mouse worked fine; if I ran out of juice, I just swapped the batteries immediately and kept going.
If the current Magic Mouse supported charging while in use, I’d just do that. Problem solved.
The turtle-mode charging is a ridiculous design constraint for those of us for whom “remember this trivial and stupid task to be performed at some arbitrary later time” does not come at all naturally.
My (ridiculous) solution is two magic mice. When one dies, I swap it for the other. No cognitive load, no breaking flow — but it’s silly to have to keep a spare $99 mouse around to solve this problem.
My employer has plenty of spare magic mice floating around, or I’d probably just buy myself a Microsoft mouse that uses AA batteries.
So even if I'm at home where I (almost) always have batteries, this still involves going downstairs, digging a couple batteries out, and swapping them. (In an office I probably wouldn't have batteries handy.)
I won't defend a rechargeable mouse you can't use while plugged in; the Logitech mouse I generally prefer lets me do this. But just swapping batteries isn't clearly better than can't use a mouse while it's charging to me. And with a laptop I'm actually fine with using the built-in trackpad 90% of the time.
The sleep cycle of a mouse microprocessor is 99.9%+. A few minutes charge will get you hours of use.
”Most people make the mistake of thinking design is what it looks like. People think it's this veneer — that the designers are handed this box and told, 'Make it look good!' That's not what we think design is. It's not just what it looks like and feels like. Design is how it works.”
Citing the mouse thing is a prime example of this silliness. First, it ignores that it doesn't matter whether the charging port is on the bottom, because that mouse cannot operate when it's plugged in. Second, it ignores that you can charge the thing in a few minutes, so, again, it doesn't matter that the port is on the bottom.
Only people who don't actually use an Apple Mouse think that this matters.
I think the sleek visual and ergonomic design specifically resulted in the charge port being put on the bottom, which resulted in their decision to disable the mouse when it’s charging. Not the other way around.
By contrast, a wireless mouse is fundamentally a different animal than a wired one. If (say) 90% of your users are going to leave it plugged in 100% of the time (to offset against the ~3 hours per year when they'll actually need to charge it), then a huge percentage of your users will experience an inferior product. It's like buying a mobile phone and then encouraging users to leave it plugged in by their bedside all day.
I can't really decide if the Magic Mouse thing was primarily an aesthetic decision to have no visible ports, or a decision that the user couldn't be trusted to use it "correctly" if it allowed itself to be plugged in normally, or an equal mixture of both. Either reinforces some typical Apple stereotypes which is why it keeps getting brought up even though it needs to be charged relatively rarely.
I have an Apple keyboard and trackpad that I use at my TV wirelessly but have benefited from the ability to use while charging a few times when the battery died. Doesn’t stop me from using it wirelessly 99% of the time because the experience is better.
By the way, I have an older phone I leave plugged in all the time by my bed, the battery life on it has deteriorated but it works perfectly for music.
For some users, the point of a wireless mouse is to be a portable mouse. You can take it on the go with your laptop without worrying about cables. When they are at home, they don't care about cable drag, and they want the peace of mind that the mouse will always have full battery when they need to go. They leave the mouse always plugged in when they can, so they can use the mouse unplugged when they need to.
I think most modern mouses have long enough battery life now, that more people can have the peace of mind without constantly docking their mouse. If the battery lasts weeks, it feels pretty secure.
For example, having the port in front would change the overall design of the magic mouse, would mean that it would be thicker (at least in the front) and might also fight for space with the click switch
But yeah, given it charges to usable in a couple of minutes, it's a non-issue
Which is exactly why many Apple fans had become so frustrated with bizarre "form over function" design in the waning Ive years. Even if the butterfly keyboard hadn't been vulnerable to making an entire computer unusable due to a tiny speck of dust, the "tapping on glass" feel of it was the prime example of "usefulness be damned" at the alter of Ive's bizarre obsession with thinness. If anything, the most recent MacBooks, where they just essentially undid all the bad decisions of the previous 3-4 years, were an admission that they had chased weird design obsessions at the cost of "it just works".
The other commenters have already pointed out the absurdity of a mouse that can't be used while it is charging.
Apple has frequently ignored how it works for looks and still do. They would for the longest time stick all the USB ports on the left hand side of the laptop very close together such that a larger USB stick or a 3G dongle or whatever would block your only other port. They do things like awkwardly hide the power button on the back of iMacs, no fronting facing or side mounted ports, etc.
You need both mouse clicks at the same time to play pretty much any modern FPS and many other types of video games. When a dollar store mouse can do it I kind of expect an $80 one can. Ratcheted scrolling also helps there. There's probably other applications that need it.
I shouldn't have to spend money on a third party app to fix an $80 mouse.
With BTT, I can define all kind of guestures on the mouse (some of it can be defined with the MacOS settings, but BTT gives even more freedom). 1-4 finger clicks, 1-4 finger swipes, you name it. No other mouse offers this.
For gamers, I probably wouldn't recommend the magic mouse, though I am fine with it for StarCraft. But for all other tasks, I just love it.
Video games.
A better example though might be the mess that is the design, or rather lack thereof, of the notification system and haphazard gesture meanings in iOS. I use both a Pixel Android and an iPhone, but mainly the iPhone these days and it’s clear that Apple don’t get everything right.
But the design of having the charge port not on the bottom would not negatively affect how it works. In fact, the port on the bottom goes against "how it works" philosophy.
I use one (several, actually — that’s what work provides) and I absolutely think this matters.
I forget to charge it. I don’t check the battery level. I don’t remember to plug it in at the end of the day.
I also shouldn’t have to. That’s an annoying, unnecessary cognitive load.
If it dies in the middle of something important (and it does), stopping for some unknown number of minutes to let it charge is not a suitable option.
Currently, my fix is to have two magic mice; when the battery in one dies, I swap it out for the other one.
This is the only solution that doesn’t offload the cognitive burden of remembering to charge something at the end of the day onto me.
This is also a ridiculous solution to that problem.
You got that backward. The people who are annoyed by these shortcomings don't use an Apple Mouse.
I actually would use an Apple mouse and I think this matters. I don’t use one because of this issue. See my response above; tl;dr: I don’t ever want to leave the mouse unplugged.
> First, it ignores that it doesn't matter whether the charging port is on the bottom, because that mouse cannot operate when it's plugged in.
Yes, and this is a fundamental design flaw and it should be fixed.
> Second, it ignores that you can charge the thing in a few minutes, so, again, it doesn't matter that the port is on the bottom
Interrupting my flow for a few minutes is really unacceptable.
That's just the spirit of Apple and the place where Steve Jobs wanted it to be.
The genius of Tim Cook lies in doing that while keeping 30-40% margins on the products they sell.
I don't know if it qualifies as genius, however it's plainly obvious that Cook is an exceptionally competent manager and logistician. He has also been a stable hand on an increasingly sprawling behemoth that easily could have gotten out of hand (~$400 billion in operating profit every five years - in the wrong management hands that's a disaster waiting to happen). He's successfully operating a mass consumer product company with the profit of Saudi Aramco, a once unthinkable outcome (Aramco used to tower over the profit of most every other corporation globally). Ten years ago Microsoft was one of the few global profit giants with ~$20b in annual profit; Apple is near six times that scale now. Cook has done a relatively good job of keeping a leash on Apple's financial behavior.
It’ll all change when the AR revolution kicks in and it will all depend on how apple deals with it. If they succeed there again, then Cook will be one of the best CEOs in the business. He’s got his own way but underestimating him after the M1 chip and successful transition seems foolish to me.
> That's just the spirit of Apple and the place where Steve Jobs wanted it to be.
Eh, there's nothing that points in the direction that Steve Jobs wanted Apple to be computers for the rest of us. Apple was always marketed as expensive and exclusive. Which is ironic because Apple devices are clearly mass products, with design that has little variation over the quite limited product line, and almost zero variation between Apple products owned by people. Somehow Apple made people believe it is hip to own the same thing as everybody else, and feel privileged about it, which defies all logic.
Apple's biggest and most persistent strength has never been visual design, it's been holistic UX design. Those often get lumped together but they are different. Letting either visual design or engineering take priority over the user experience is the big pitfall, and while Apple doesn't have a perfect track record here, they're not even in the same galaxy as most of the tech world. I would even say that in the post-Ive world, they may be at an all-time high.
Apple had some pretty nice stuff before Ive, I see no reason it won't have amazing stuff in the future without him.
It could be that the next Magic Mouse revision could address that but I don't think that could really be counted upon. It would make sense though if that the Magic Mouse two or if there was a total revamp of their peripherals got rid of lightning ports and either could be wirelessly charged or charged by USB C
I do take issue with people thinking Apple’s designs are stale. I mean, to an extent this is a matter of taste. My take is that at their best Apple’s designs are so good they are timeless. Is a vintage Leica stale? Is a 1964 Porsche 911 stale? No. People who think these are stale have bad taste I would argue.
Current Apple is never again going to give you something like the “Luxo Lamp iMac”.
On Windows, none of my headsets or controllers would automatically connect, most of the time requiring me to pair them manually every time.
On Mac, pairing would generally stay remembered but I'd typically need to manually select the device I want to connect to in the Bluetooth menu.
On Linux, prior to Pipewire, I had to close all of my audio apps to connect Bluetooth headphones. Now with Pipewire, the connection is so "sticky" that I have to turn off Bluetooth on my desktop if I want to use it on any of my other devices, since it always steals the connection.
I also appreciate that Apple leaves a highly amplified headphone jack on their MacBook pros because there’s tons of Pro applications where Bluetooth headphones just don’t work due to latency.
If the charging port was not on the bottom, a huge percentage of users would just leave it plugged in. Then a wireless mouse would functionally be a wired one.
When I was still working in the office pre-pandemic, everyone with a cordless mouse kept it plugged in all the time, presumably out of fear that it would discharge.
They turned a cordless mouse into a corded mouse. The only difference being that instead of plugging it into their computers, they were plugged into their monitors or hubs.
Rather than the Apple watch being a Vogue-celebrated product for the 1%, it’s an attractive and high quality product for many people. I see it on the wrists fashion icons and on the wrists of people working at my local grocery store. Billionaires and ordinary people can have basically the same phone, watch, and AirPods. That is the true genius of Cook, reviving the “computer for the rest of us”.
I do think Apple’s design has become a little stale, but if there has to be a choice of once vs the other they are currently picking the right one. Let’s not forget that the vaunted focus on design has given us a mouse with the charger on the bottom as well as innumerable other botches over the years. I am glad Apple was willing to push the envelope, but some of that stubbornness has worked against them.