I've heard that some keep propane heaters for backup/emergency. I have used one at a cabin and it's damn effective.
Your example sounds really inefficient.. modern houses should have balanced ventilation, and you should only need one compressor and 2-3 heads. I installed a small balanced ventilation unit (TwinFresh) in a bedroom, and that helps keep the room warm by pulling in warm air from the hallway which is connected to the living room with the heat pump head.
We also have some electrical heaters in the other bedrooms just to make sure it can't get too cold there. Though maybe my perspective is a bit warped: everyone I know likes to sleeping in a cold room.
I would be curious though; as where i grew up in the upper midwest USA, there were always concerns of ice-storms or blizzards knocking out power lines. I'd assume norway would have similar concerns so i wonder how the problem is solved there.
Norway is also much colder than NYC. I would imagine in terms of energy needed for heating, the two would be comparable.
Depending on the system size a car battery and inverter can run a forced hot water system for a pretty long time.
Forced hot air is gonna be worse than that but the electricity to run the blower is still peanuts compared to a heat pump system.
Huge dense city like NYC would be a perfect place for district heating and cooling. No reason for apartments to have boilers, really.
This is not the one that’s being killed in Maine.
https://gothamist.com/news/canadian-renewable-hydropower-hea...
When you think of a place as large as NYC and the scale of making any kind of change, it certainly adds an element of risk if conditions in Canada or failures between NYC and Canada take place.
According to a quick Google search: "The current population of Norway is 5,483,767 as of Friday, December 24, 2021" and NY state is estimated at 20.2 million as of April 2020, and New York City at 8.8 million. It seems you appreciate that Norway is a special scenario. It seems silly to assume something that works there would work in a country that has single cities with larger populations, and states with around four times the population of your entire country.
This may be so, but New York also has one of the oldest electrical grids on the planet. Upgrading it to support larger and larger populations is a challenge, not just to manage it overloading with the density, but also in terms of logistics.
You can't just tear up a major street in New York and upgrade the electrical for a block, without causing massive logistics problems for the city. Upgrading New York's grid is going to be a huge challenge
High-population means high complaining ratio. Also lots of rich companies there who will sue when things go wrong.
Hell NYC already has district heating, adding a tunnel under the existing building could swap things over for 1700+ customers with minimal disruption. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_steam_system
it would also be silly were we to imply that scaling up automatically means less efficiency. in many situations things get significantly more efficient the more they scale.
it also would seem silly to assume that we couldn’t take many of the pieces that are actually working in an entire country and adapt to our situation. We are very good at adapting things for various situations.
It would seem a lot more feasible to go all in on electric when you have that much hydro. Since that much of the production is hydro - I'm assuming it's relatively economical, and not just Norway paying a massive premium to be green.
Rolling blackouts and people freezing to death? Because new housing uses 200 more kWh per month? Are you really serious?
Man-made gas through existing lines? Where exactly is that happening? Where is it close to happening? Where are people even talking about thinking about making it happen? How about any form of energy that has ever, or will ever exist through existing lines? That's what electricity is.
I just... I'm so confused right now.
(But I do hate electric stoves and ovens. Gas ones heat much faster and much more easier to control the flame)
No, no, and no.
First of all, you would never put a head in each of these rooms. The minimum head sizes of Mitsubishi (and all other) mini splits is well beyond the heating or cooling loads of an individual room. Anyone who tries to sell a head per room is a charlatan and has never run a Manual J load calculation in their life.
Furthermore, if your four bedroom house requires 100 amps to heat it with a heat pump, you should have put money into air sealing and insulating it, rather than installing heat pumps.
This would impute a 160,000 Btu/h heat load, which is astronomical in New Jersey. (I know this because I live here, and design these systems.)
In reality you'd use a ducted split system, not 8 heads.
Anyway, are you claiming installing a split system is cheaper than installing a Burnham boiler? The point of the post is to say that boilers/furnaces are much cheaper to install in order to heat your entire house.
I can say it because houses are fairly typical and if the heat loss for a room is greater than the minimum head size for a minisplit, the room probably needs some work before you should be putting a minisplit in it.
This is all just math, and 6,000 Btu/h (the minimum head size) happens to actually be a lot of heating for any normal room.
A boiler alone does not a hydronic system make. Hydronic systems are expensive, all in (piping, emitters/radiators, circulator pumps).
> The point of the post is to say that boilers/furnaces are much cheaper to install in order to heat your entire house.
No new house in New Jersey is getting built without air conditioning. If you're already installing ducting and an air handler, you might as well pay the marginal increase to get a heat pump instead of a cooling only outdoor unit.
2 outdoor units running 110V x 50amps is 11.0kW which using a base efficiency you can expect from a heat pump of 4:1 input electricity to heat results in 44kW of heating / cooling.
If your 4 bedroom house needs 44kW of heating I would be looking at other winter warmers first, like buying glass for your windows.
For comparison a reasonably large heat pump would have a heating cooling rating of 12kW
I'm assuming you're talking about a 4 ton multi-zone unit (which is pretty large). Those call for a 50A MOCP, but in reality, they only draw like 20A while running, plus a couple for the indoor units' fans.
The breaker needs to be able to handle the peak, not the average. Just go Google Mitsubishi hyper heat - it clearly states 50 amps per condenser.
I’m not sure what’s difficult to understand about this.
> I’m not sure what’s difficult to understand about this.
Of course you may expect the casual reader to do the googling themselves. But if you want to make your arguments heard, it’s helpful to put a link to an authoritative source. Of course this is also true for anyone making the counter claim.
Of course the Google link has nothing to do with my claim anyway, since my original post supposed that 50 amps was required by breaker.
I wonder if having higher voltages in the US might be adopted for higher power devices. 110-120V is just too low, including for car charging.
I can’t imagine a permanent high energy install like a heater, shower, car charger, oven or heat pump would be 110v. If you plug in via a standard socket in europe you get about 3kW, which given european driving is probably fine overnight, but you’d want more than that in the US
It's really just our basic receptacles that are 15A or 20A @ 120V. This is plenty for 99.9% of uses, with the exception of some kitchen appliances that produce heat (e.g. a plug-in kettle.) If you bought a unit that required higher voltages and was rated for use in the US, you could always have an electrician wire a 240V circuit with one of the standard 240V receptacle types.
My oven is on a dedicated 30A circuit, but the dryer, washer, dishwasher, microwave, kettle are all on the same 32A circuit with individual 13A plugs and don’t trip it.
Indeed.
My heat pump is 3phase 230v/16A one, that's 11kW peak power, the pump itself is 5kW, though with the rest being a resistive heater. Car charging is similar as well 3phase is quite standard nowadays.
My understanding is that the US power supply is pretty similar to the one in Europe when it comes to delivery, and industrial equipment runs 3phase, 240v - something you can find at a lot (most new) homes in Europe.
There's a political, economic and cultural balance to be struck here, technology changes notwithstanding.
Moving on to electric retrofits, they are expensive but not crazy expensive. On the order of $2500-7500 per SFH to wire 220/30-50 amp circuits to the right places (HVAC, stove, water heater, clothes dryer, EV charger) and maybe upgrade the main panel - a far cry from redoing the entire wiring. It’s not an insane proposition to think we could retrofit all existing housing stock in a 15 year period if we wanted to take it seriously. We are going to need more electricians though.
Do you know what is actually really expensive? Billions or trillions of dollars in climate disaster losses and mitigation which we are seeing ramp up very quickly. If we continue burning fossil fuels even remotely like we are now, in 20 years time the losses we say today will look like peanuts in comparison.
Buildings make up a very significant amount of the CO2e emissions (depending on the location, often tied #1 with transportation) so doing nothing here is not really an option.
If what you were saying were true then economic forces would already have led to dominance of full electric without the need for government mandates to begin with.
Market forces will lead us down this path eventually but they are not instantaneous, and we don’t have much time to wait. Policy can help 1- accelerate, 2- bootstrap emerging markets (eg creating demand for more induction stoves turns that market from a niche to mainstream, with more competition, more choice, and reduced cost, all of which will serve to boost demand) and 3- finance infrastructure investments that may be beyond reach for many.
On gas infrastructure, yes it is in place but it still requires significant ongoing maintenance costs which would be eliminated if it was shut down.
The other thing is that a heat pump can be so efficient, that it’s net beneficial to burn nat gas at a power plant and use that electricity to run a heat pump.
But this all falls apart near and below freezing temperatures.
NYC will still want to have direct-burn natural gas heating for cold days because that’ll be more efficient than resorting to resistive heating.
That's a concern for designs with air-based heat exchangers, but for environments where this is expected to be a problem you can instead exchange heat via pipes into the earth, where it remains a more-or-less constant 50F/10C year-round. Pump heat out of the earth in winter, pump it back in in the summer.
There are heat pumps designed for cold climates that work well into the -30C range or so still holding a COP of 2 or more.
Here are some test results from Finland from a few years ago https://www.scanoffice.fi/vttn-testiraportit-ilmalampopumppu... (Lämpökerroin = COP)
And if one is doing it at district level just pump the heat from the ground or sea where the temperature stays the same all year around.
I agree.
With climate change and unpredictable weather I really wouldn't go all-in on heat pumps. Even with hyper-heat it only works efficiently down to 5 degrees Fahrenheit. NYC rarely gets colder than that, but I wouldn't be surprised if the extreme cold days are the same days where electricity has problems. Those two things together means people freezing to death.
I think buildings should have both, and default to heat pumps.
What is the deal with americans and freezing to death? I’m from Scandinavia, and the only times I’ve heard people discuss that is in the context of someone getting drunk and passing out outside.
Fuck me, even if it somehow reaches -20C inside all you need to do is grab a few extra blankets and stay under them in order to remain warm.
If you’re really worried, just invest some money in a sufficiently warm sleeping bag. Installing gas as a backup would be moronic unless you’re expecting to spend months without power.
Me, I'm in southern Vermont, heat with a wood stove and oil furnace, and just replaced a deteriorating resistive water heater with a big heat pump water heater. I do envy the cooking-with-flame folks, though :)
Your fear of people freezing to death over heat pumps are unfounded. There are backups built in that work with the insulation value of a house. New homes should be very air tight and require less heating, suited for heat pumps.
Even in a house with foam insulation - the highest "normally available" insulation - freezing to death is just a matter of time without heat. When considering city-wide infrastructure it's something that needs to be considered. I'm not saying it's necessarily going to happen, but you'd be dumb not to think about redundancy measures, hence my top-level comment.
This type of redundancy is why many commercial buildings have gas generators, for example.
Heat Pump for heat, Heat Pump water heater is the future for new home builds. Buy a portable generator, a 10kwh gasoline generator is <$1,000 USD and 1/10th the price of a 10kwh batter pack. Problem solved.
They don’t freeze to death.
You can also mix and match a variety of backup/supplemental heat sources (only some of which make sense in an urban context), and of course a ground source heat pump is another (expensive) option for very cold climates.
If we want to prevent people from freezing to death, the best way is to help people get 1. food 2. clothes 3. shelter 4. health care.
I'd argue gas based heat isn't even on the list. As you said, we should not go all-in on heat pumps. We can and should have alternate sources of heat for vulnerable people (I am thinking hospitals, retirement communities, and so on).
I am confident that healthy, well-fed, appropriately dressed people in well insulated homes do not die because the weather outside dips below freezing for under a day.
- A/C units, which can only cool a room but can’t heat it up
- Heat Pumps, which typically do both.
Obviously they are not the most efficient heaters as they are not designed for it but they would still work.
My heating bills have dropped to zero. My cooling bills have jumped, and climbs every year.
Switching to heat pumps will be a minor expense compared to the effects of climate change we’ll have to pay for in the next few decades.
For what it’s worth, much of Manhattan is heated by means of centralized steam, which tends to be more energy efficient than all of the different heating systems you mention:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_steam_system?wpr...
In much of Manhattan natural gas is only used for cooking.
A bigger problem in NYC is electric water pumps: When the power goes out, the water stops when the water tower on the roof empties. This is mostly for buildings over 5-6 stories, older buildings were somewhat height-capped by municipal water pressure. No water means no toilets. Again, people don’t seem to know that toilets use gravity, a bucket will flush them. Big storm coming? Fill the bathtubs with water.
Only time I've had the water go out during a power outage was when I was in a house on well water. Otherwise, the pipes still have pressure. Gas furnaces won't work because of the blower, but the gas itself should still flow.
Gas hot water heaters without power vents are still readily available so its not hard to avoid this problem. If you really must have power venting the power requirements are low and can be powered by minimal backup generation or batteries.
Gas infrastructure is surprisingly resilient to widespread outages. That’s just a fact - how often are there widespread outages? It’s minuscule compared to electricity.
Except freezing, as Texas showed.
But the gas cooktop should work without problem if you light it with a match/lighter.
Again, definitely don't do this, but in a scenario where the alternative is that you freeze to death, it's possible to do so safely.
With modern combi boilers (tankless hot water + boiler) I believe your point stands.
edit: I mention this mainly because in Texas last winter some people froze to death during their electricity crisis.
Our prior home had pilot lights for the gas furnace, stove/ovens, and water heater. No electric igniters. All the items were pretty dated. But when the grid went down, they kept working.
I'm assuming any modern gas water heater is in a similar boat, with an electric starter instead of a pilot light - and it's much more difficult/annoying to light a water heater than a stove with a match.
The spark to light the pilot is a piezoelectric thing, manually operated. Newer models (less than ~15 years?) have a control board which is probably mostly mechanical, but does have a flashing LED. I assume that whatever drives the electronics is charged/powered by something that works off the differential of temperature in the chamber vs outside.
Personally, I'd rather have the generator if I had the space, but this would be a good option for people in townhouses and condos.
Similarly with gas ranges, you may need to manually light it, but the valves are usually manual (the oven is a different story).
Same goes for gas fireplaces that do not have a standing pilot and electrically actuated valves, which many newer appliances have.
It's not all that rare these days in cheap condo units (heck, even SFH...) in large cities to require power vent water heaters due to simply horrible architecture imo. Chimneys may not be a thing in some buildings, and locations of utility closets seem not optimized for venting at all.
A surprising number of gas appliances are slowly requiring electricity to run. I wonder if it's even possible to buy a gas clothes dryer these days without electronic controls without going through hoops? Certainly a fraction of the market.
Modern safety standards also drive "cop out" solutions to them like electronic interlocks with stovetops. I wonder how many modern gas stoves actually function without the A/C plugged in? Think I'll actually test this with my two units tonight!
These exist, but are quite rare in the U.S. Check out air-to-water heat pumps from Sanden[1] and Chiltrix[2]. I seriously considered this for my new house (still in planning stages), but at double the cost of an air-to-water heat pump system it didn't make the cut. If they were more common, the cost would come down, but I think it's a chicken/egg thing at this point.
Of course, water-to-water (geothermal) heat pumps have been in the States for decades, and if I recall there are still federal tax credits available for them, but they're even more expensive and probably only make sense in very cold climates.
[1] https://www.smallplanetsupply.com/sanco2-for-combi-systems [2] https://www.chiltrix.com/air-to-water/
My father recently did exactly that, installing a unit by Mitsubishi. IIRC it has a COP of 2 at -15C, finally switching to resistive heating at -25C or so (which is somewhat unusual, maybe a few days or a week per year over here). He also has his old wood boiler as backup that he uses when it gets cold (it was a dual oil/wood boiler, though the oil burner and oil tank was ripped out as part of the retrofit).
Only if you ignore the externalities
If you are worked about power outages, a <$1,000 gasoline generator would power essentials for one room.
Additionally the compressors in these systems use far less than 50 amps, typically typically around 12 for a 3 ton unit.
The type of system you described is generally used for old construction where adding ducts is impractical. Because it's used for a special situation it will of course be more costly.
Here, natural gas is typically $2 a therm. Efficient furnaces are better than 90%, so $2 for 90,000 BTUs into the house or $1 buys 45,000 BTUs into the house.
Electricity is about 30 cents a kilowatt hour. Good air source heat pumps have a COP in mild weather of about 4-- much worse when cold. This is about 45,000 BTUs/$ best case.
So here, heat pumps are about breakeven vs. natural gas or slightly worse in energy costs... And they're more expensive in capital costs.
Everywhere I've ever lived if the power was out there was no way to burn the natural gas for heat.
Forced air furnace needs power for the ignition, control circuitry, and the fan that actually circulates the heat through the house.
I don't think it's a bad problem to solve, but it's not one that natural gas heating solves.
I'd say that with the hyper heat and appropriate wind baffles, you can remove the resistive aux heat in most of the lower 48. Consult your ASHRAE design conditions for specifics. (2)
I share your concerns however, about not having anything but electric heat. I think of the water pipes in Texas houses bursting as the electric grid failed and the temperature dropped to the kind of conditions seen in a fairly normal northeast winter.
(1) https://mylinkdrive.com/USA/M_Series/R410A_Systems-1/Multi_P...
(2) ashrae-meteo.info/
Is this true on the east coast only, or have I been really lucky my whole life? I currently live in a little cabin in the woods built in the 70s and it has 200amp service, as have all other homes I've lived in the past 15 years.
This would avoid wasting the useful work potential of the gas while probably being no more expensive than heat pumps and avoiding the blackout issues you cite.
Yes, that was pre-this-regulation though. Since the ban applies to the new buildings, they will not be getting 100 amps wiring.
Do we not already have a way to convert radiator/boilers to electricity? It's just boiling water right.
My condo is in a 110 year old building. I love my radiators even if they don't work that great ;) and really would hate those electric baseboard radiators
We probably will have to replace our boiler within the next few years due to issues (neighbors are too cheap to go all electric/vehicle chargers with me so no proactive changes).
I just assumed we could get an electric version? I would hope smaller and not a giant cast iron thing sunk under the house.
Would that not also work for new construction?
Even when you account for the actual cost of heating, not just initial investment?
given a cheap electricity source and increasing gas prices I'd say in the long term a heat pump is cheaper.
I’m all for accelerating innovation, but these stupid bans need to be paired with meaningful incentives.
Random anecdote: in New Jersey installing a Mitsubishi hyper-heat heat-pump in a 8 room house (4 bedroom + 2 bathroom + living room + kitchen) is much more expensive than running hot water baseboard in all rooms. And with most heat pumps you can usually only zone 4-6 heads per compressor, so you'd need two compressors. A single compressor is probably pulling 50 amps alone, so you'd need 100 amps available usually for your breakers. For reference, a normal house usually 100 amps dedicated for the entire house, not just HVAC. Drastic upgrades in electric infrastructure will be required.
Heat pumps heat more efficiently than gas, but I wouldn't be surprised to see in the near future some sort of rolling blackout and thousands of people freezing to death because we went all-in on electric. Will these buildings also have generators to combat this potential problem?
Ideally we could just use existing gas lines and another, man-made produced gas through the same lines that's carbon neutral or negative.
I'm excited to see the development of heat pumps, though. I'm not a huge fan of the forced-air heat pumps. I hope something like a radiator-heat-pump can be made soon.