News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by varunsrin on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:07PM (#2938383)
The first problem with the article here is that some of the buttons (Move To, Copy To) did not exist previously. They are also extensions of existing functions (Move, Copy) - so concluding that half the UI is covered by buttons that were not used is an inaccurate assumption.

Secondly, the actions are being moved from the context menu to the ribbon. Most new computer users find it very hard to remember additional, non intuitive actions like right clicking & context menus. Each of these is a 'modifier' that power users are used to, but which make the mental model of file manipulation much harder for beginners to wrap their heads around. They have to remember to apply these modifiers to see if the functions they want exist. Moving the functions into a contextually aware ribbon will make life much easier for these users.

Third, Move, Copy, Delete & Rename occupy the center of the ribbon. These are the most used commands (by far) and rightfully occupy center stage. Power users will call it clutter, but it will be extremely helpful for beginners.

[Disclaimer: MSFT Employee, but I do not work on Windows]

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:23PM (#2938451)
Most new computer users find it very hard to remember additional, non intuitive actions like right clicking & context menus

I didn't realize this. In fact, if I were asked to guess, I would have answered that most new users would pick up pretty quickly how to use context menus, especially if the context menus had related commands like file manipulation if in Windows Explorer (is it still called that?), or formatting if in a text document, etc.

Hell, rats in a cage can learn what to push in order to eat, so I would have thought that people would be able to learn this. Of course, it would help if they were told somehow and didn't have to discover it.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by 51Cards on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:54PM (#2938604)
Yes but people don't WANT to learn things like this. My mother doesn't want to remember what mouse button to click or that CTRL or ALT is a modifier on this command.

I would argue that THIS is what made Apple's OS hang on all those years it was in the severe minority. There is a segment of the population that wants only one mouse button to click, not 3, not 3 plus CTRL or ALT or etc. Apple did end up having to rely heavily on their option key to extend functionality but at its root the UI was designed so that the average user could do things in a simple, straightforward way. MS sees visually exposing commands to the user as their way to do it and while I may not entirely agree, I don't think it's without merit. My kudos to them for also letting me as a "power user" collapse the "newbie visual noise" off my screen and drop what I want on a custom quick access bar.

Remember: don't let your status as a power user cloud your view of how your grandmother might want to use her computer. There are FAR more 'grandmother' grade users than there are us.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:04PM (#2938659)
Then why are the ipad and iphone taking off? It's really hard to learn to do things on those devices. It's cumbersome to turn off wifi and bluetooth to save battery. The control location makes no sense in the settings menu (to my mind, anyway).

I was a HUGE Apple fan for the early Macs. I totally get what you are saying. But we LOST in the workplace. It was just too slow for the other folks in the office to use (of course, the real death blow was having only a graphics mode to the display so the typing was dreadfully slow-- and the secretaries wouldn't use them- but that's another story).

But I get your point. That's why I phrased my response as I did. I have never done UI/UX testing- maybe the parent has and was sharing his insight.

But if we are all just speculating, I've got to throw out a shout for the other point of view. Yes, too many (how many is too many? I don't know) and it gets to be like using VIM. But two buttons? Seems like it should be ok.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by 51Cards on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:18PM (#2938728)
I understand what you're saying, and despite the content of my above post I've never been an Apple guy, always a Windows one. Every time I went over to the Apple OS I felt I had one hand tied behind my back by lack of options. I also try to keep in mind that I'm not typical. I started on "PCs" in 1981 and have grown with them, this all comes naturally. So when I judge a UI I literally stick my Mom on it... she's 68. I have also had the good fortune to work with a lot of 'artistic types' over the years as well, and in turn I watched how they use a UI. In my experience they just don't use much more than what is presented before them option wise.

Trust me, I agree that this new ribbon is very cluttered and contains too much visual noise, but in turn I don't mind exposing things visually to the end user. I hate MS Office with the ribbon, but I deal with people all the time who love it. Just let me turn it off :)

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by nkassis on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:52PM (#2938919)
". I also try to keep in mind that I'm not typical. ... So when I judge a UI I literally stick my Mom on it... she's 68"

Well she no more typical a computer user than you are I would think. I like to see a curve of typical computer users age distribution (but I understand it would be a little skewed if it's hard for the older generations to use computers).

I feel that ribbon is designed for a select group of new users who need that kind of help. And I hope it's easy to disable it. It's fine for Microsoft to use something like this as a default mode as long as power users are able to turn that stuff off.

This is what turns me off on OS X, there is often no way to do certain more advanced things. Or it's hidden so well it requires hours of searching on the web for what plist to modify.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by rolleiflex on Monday August 29, 2011 @10:49PM (#2939921)
The only thing I felt missing that I needed from OSX Finder is "Rename All". Do you have any other examples of this?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by stephen_g on Monday August 29, 2011 @11:45PM (#2940028)
Cut and pasting files would be useful, but that's about all I miss.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by glhaynes on Monday August 29, 2011 @11:50PM (#2940043)
In Lion, after copying a file in Finder, you have available both Paste and Move.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by stephen_g on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @04:31AM (#2940588)
Thanks, I didn't notice that!

The shortcut for move is Cmd-Option-V, if anyone wants to know.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by jarin on Monday August 29, 2011 @10:36PM (#2939886)
What "advanced" things are you talking about that a regular user would need?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by josch on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @06:34AM (#2940835)
I would love to be able to remove a (huge) file without going through the trash can.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by JadeNB on Wednesday August 31, 2011 @11:06AM (#2945834)
> I would love to be able to remove a (huge) file without going through the trash can.

1. Why?

2. `rm huge-file`

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by DougBTX on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:30PM (#2938795)
I felt I had one hand tied behind my back

That reminds me of the first few times I tried to learn vim.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by william42 on Monday August 29, 2011 @09:21PM (#2939734)
It reminds me of why I stopped using vim after switching to Dvorak.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dasil003 on Monday August 29, 2011 @10:05PM (#2939822)
Shit that sounds painful.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by jbrechtel on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:34PM (#2939338)
Yea. For me it was like two hands... :)

Now though, any other editor that's not Vim or Emacs feels like that...

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by kiiski on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:56AM (#2940422)
"Just let me turn it off"

Just double click on one of the tabs.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by berne on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @04:57AM (#2940638)
Ctrl+F1?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by varunsrin on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:25PM (#2938764)
It's cumbersome because you have to navigate through a bunch of menus - however, its easy because you have a finite, visible set of actions to look through those menus (tap, swipe, repeat) and a finite set of menus themselves.

In a desktop OS, you have a seemingly infinite set of modifiers (Ctrl, Alt, Double click, click, right click, Ctrl + Shift), which are not 'logical' operations like tapping and swiping - they must be learned and remembered.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by whatusername on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:47PM (#2938892)
Tap, swipe, draw apart, draw together, click home button, double click home button, click headset button, double click headset button, triple click headset button, Press external volume button, flick mute/screen-lock button, press lock button, hold lock button.

I'm sure there's a few more buried in there that I haven't discovered. (Like swipe backwards to delete an item from a list)

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:58PM (#2938956)
Don't forget "tap and hold" on Safari. Found that one by accident.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by mitjak on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @01:18AM (#2940217)
Are you referring to tapping and holding images to save them to the library?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by lloeki on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @04:12AM (#2940556)
It works on links too, allowing to open them in a new tab or copy the link.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @09:34AM (#2941333)
I was referring to this. Didn't know about the other.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by zwaldowski on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:07PM (#2939268)
Except that those boil down to a couple of basic gestures: tap, pinch, swipe. The hardware buttons are irrelevant in this case. Oh, and swipe to delete? That's in the "manual" that comes with the device. It's smaller than a dollar, for god's sake.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by heelhook on Monday August 29, 2011 @08:34PM (#2939617)
Wonder how many iPhone users have read their user manual, I sure threw out the manual on day 1.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by bane on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:38PM (#2938842)
which are not 'logical' operations like tapping and swiping - they must be learned and remembered.

And now even those are getting out of control:

http://www.apple.com/macosx/whats-new/gestures.html

Pretty soon I'm going to run out of fingers, and these certainly aren't easily discoverable.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by ugh on Monday August 29, 2011 @09:48PM (#2939787)
Yeah, because those gestures are more akin to keyboard shortcuts, i.e. something for power users. OS X is perfectly usable without complicated gestures. Two-finger scrolling is the most complicated thing an average user has to learn.

This same pattern continues on iOS devices. They don't ever use complicated gestures, certainly not as the only way to accomplish something. The most complicated gesture you need is pinching.

The new iOS 5 has gestures to switch apps and get home, but those are really like keyboard shortcuts since the home button is still there and offers a simpler alternative.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by gurkendoktor on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @05:04AM (#2940651)
There is still a problem when you accidentally trigger gestures. All my friends are scared to touch my Mac because they'd trigger hot corners all the time. With 10.7, you can easily trigger gestures even on default settings. I am worried the iOS5 gestures will have the same problem.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by shabble on Monday August 29, 2011 @08:56PM (#2939669)
I'm not sure if it's just me, but the 'pinch with 3 fingers and thumb' gesture seems to be practically impossible on the older macbooks with a separate pad & button - there just isn't the space.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by irq on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @12:42AM (#2940145)
That's completely okay because those older touchpads don't support gestures beyond two-finger-scroll anyway.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by shabble on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @12:28PM (#2942117)
No, it supports both 3 finger swipe (fwd/back in browsers), and 4 finger swipe (change Space), as well as, iirc 3 finger touch & click (although I haven't got this working since I installed Lion)
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:39PM (#2938848)
its easy because you have a finite,....

Easy? Maybe for some. I bet the same people who have to be told to right-click also have to be told how to work their bluetooth/wifi connection (and never bother to turn it off to save battery).

But I'll grant you this point if s/easy/possible/

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by serge2k on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:16PM (#2938714)
Probably because people think it looks fun and are wiling to put in the few minutes it takes to not a be completely useless with the device.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by bmelton on Monday August 29, 2011 @05:25PM (#2939092)
I don't know why you got downvoted, and I upvoted to try and offset, but ignoring that...

I think that you overstate the importance of turning off wifi and bluetooth. Those are power user options, for sure. When you're trying to conserve battery power, you're trying to streamline how you use the device, which to me, smacks of 'power user'.

The flipside to that argument is that it is ridiculously easy to browse a web site, check your email and play Words with Friends and Angry Birds. These are the things that the majority of people care about... not whether or not a given physical interface is active or not.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @09:33AM (#2941332)
I agree with you- that example may not fit everybody's problem. When I switched from a simple phone to a smart phone it was important to me, but now I don't bother (never too far from a charger).

And you are right, of course, in that ios allows most people to do the things they most care about very easily-- that's probably the takeaway. If you do that, then, apparently even if the other stuff is hard, people will probably figure out how to do it when they need it. Somehow.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by kyleslattery on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:55PM (#2939530)
Yes, absolutely. There is almost no reason to touch wifi and bluetooth settings on iOS devices. I have wifi enabled all the time, and battery life is still excellent.

Android devices on the other hand, need constant fiddling. My Droid would barely last a day with everything turned off, and with wifi, etc. turned on, it would die after only about 6 hours.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by foxylad on Monday August 29, 2011 @08:52PM (#2939659)
I'd hazard a guess your Android experience was a year or two ago. My Nexus 1 lasted barely a day when it arrived, but now lasts 48 hours on Gingerbread (2.3) with everything (including wifi, bluetooth and GPS) on.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by jrockway on Monday August 29, 2011 @11:15PM (#2939964)
Actually, it's probably the mobile network that's killing you. I get about a day of battery life with everyone on, and about a day of battery life with wifi and bluetooth off. But when I turn the cell phone radio off, suddenly my battery life increases to nearly a week. (I found this out by accident. I went to Sweden where my phone doesn't work, so I turned off everything except Wifi. A few days without charging later, I still had about 60% battery!)
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by aquark on Monday August 29, 2011 @10:22PM (#2939858)
Getting on a plane would be a fairly common use case, and independent of the 'power' level of the user.

Disclaimer: I don't own an iOS device, so don't know how intuitive it might or might not be.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by rolleiflex on Monday August 29, 2011 @10:51PM (#2939926)
Well, for plane use, it has "Airplane Mode" as the first option of the Settings app, so at least for that it's covered.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by jrockway on Monday August 29, 2011 @11:17PM (#2939968)
But airplanes have wifi now, so you can still want the cell radio off and have the wifi on. Yup, it's complicated. The world is a complicated place.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by cellularmitosis on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:52AM (#2940416)
That misses the point of "airplane mode". Airplane mode is for use during take off and landing. Ie, you'd need to turn wifi off too.

The only reason to turn off the cell radio but not the wifi radio is to conserve battery, which again puts you well outside the use case of the typical apple user.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by jsight on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @08:44AM (#2941161)
In the US, airlines require that electronic devices be turned completely off during takeoff and landing.

In my experience, this is rarely enforced.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by jrockway on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @08:26AM (#2941103)
No. For takeoff and landing, no power should be applied to any of the electronics. You have to turn the phone off.

(In fact, I just got off a plane, and the announcement is "electronic devices must be off, not in airplane mode. that's for after we're in the air.")

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by ThomPete on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:30PM (#2938798)
They are taking off because they are touch devices and not mouse devices.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by technoslut on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:44PM (#2938869)
I believe that it's only part of it. Another part is the lack of a filesystem. Many, if not most users, just don't like it or understand it. Though there are functions that are seriously lacking in iOS, I can't help but think that they're much closer to what is needed than MS.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by ThomPete on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:13PM (#2939287)
It's only part of it but the primary reason.

The actual removal of abstraction (mouse) have made it much easier to use it. This is why my son at 2 can use the ipad and he can't use the mouse and keyboard for the desktop and laptops.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by technoslut on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:25PM (#2939456)
I agree but what would happen if your son had to navigate Windows Explorer on a touchscreen? He may never have to but if older users are experiencing similar difficulties with the filesystem, little can be done with the command bar to completely fix this issue.

I have no doubt that this UI, though cluttered, will help users out but I question whether this is ultimately the best solution.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by sunchild on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:09PM (#2938683)
This doesn't explain the "invert selection" button. I'm pretty sure that one is indefensible.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by varunsrin on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:20PM (#2938738)
Yeah, while I think that select all & select none are pretty important ribbon items (most people never learn CTRL+A or Shift+Clicking), select inversion feels like a power user option to me.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by StavrosK on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:48PM (#2939379)
"Delete all files except this one."
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by angusgr on Monday August 29, 2011 @09:08PM (#2939709)
I think the argument is less "noone but power users would need this" and more "only power users will know how to apply 'Invert Selection' to get the behaviour they want".

ie there's an inductive leap between "I want to delete all files except this one" and "I can select that one file and then invert selection before deleting". At minimum it requires you to know what "invert selection" means. Ordinary users may take a different, more fiddly, path.

I don't know if that's the case here. My intuition says it is. However, in my optimistic heart I hope Microsoft did a bunch of usability testing and determined that ordinary users do grasp an "invert selection" concept more often than not.

That's how design for mass-use user interfaces works, right? By evidence-driven testing, not by what the programmer/designer thinks makes sense? Clings to idealistic belief.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by deselection on Wednesday August 31, 2011 @12:58AM (#2944392)
Select all, then deselect (ctrl-click) the one item you want to exclude. That's the exact same amount of work, just with the inversion step at the beginning instead of the end.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by richardw on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:35AM (#2940375)
People who don't know about menus shouldn't really be mass-deleting things yet. Alternatively, add a button for "Help! -The Computer lost all my stuff".
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by waitwhat on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @12:23PM (#2942090)
That button is called the "Recycle Bin". I believe it has been on the default desktop since at least Windows 95.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by richardw on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:44PM (#2942683)
A brief Google search confirms that "lost my files" wasn't solved in 1995. I'm pretty sure those aren't all Mac users. Even if 90% are due to other issues, there are many people who would like their data back. I believe many are due to the ease with which a user can delete files compared to the difficulty they experience when restoring them.

The dangerous button is much easier to find than the fix-it button. One is right there, with your files. The other is someplace else, related by metaphor alone. Once you have selected the recycle bin you then have to search through your very long deleted file list, select the file you want, select another button to restore it (which appears in the same place as a different button existed before selecting the file), and then navigate back to the place you were expecting the file to be. We're talking about users who can't figure out a menu, but they can perform this multi-step task. I can easily see a new computer user screwing this up.

Next time you look at the context menu of a removable drive, see that "Format" is right there with the eject menu item. One should be used every time you use the drive, the other very rarely and only when you're sure. The latter should be removed to a sub-menu under "advanced", or similar.

Myself, I'd make it harder to delete things and a lot easier to find them again.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by alextingle on Wednesday August 31, 2011 @02:55PM (#2947004)
Surely Apple's "Time Machine" achieves that? The UI is bizarre and overly flashy, but it's convenient and gets the job done.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by tdfx on Monday August 29, 2011 @05:50PM (#2939197)
If there was ever an option to be hidden deep within the confines of a user-inaccessible context menu, "invert selection" is definitely it.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by doublesprout on Wednesday August 31, 2011 @02:49AM (#2944597)
It's not immediately obvious from the label what the button does, but it is from experimentation. And unlike the multistep 'cut' or 'paste' buttons or 'move to' (which pops up a dialog, I think?), the discovery process for a user is one click.

Or maybe two. One to go from selected file to all other files, and another click to get back.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by yason on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:00PM (#2942502)
I've often wondered why not pop up the context menu with the left mouse button, then. It's what most people seem to use most. How many times you actually have to select a file, except to context-click on it?

Selection only comes handy when you will be doing something to several items at once. Thus, the selection function could be turned on via a menu item or a button: it's a totally different operating mode where you click on or drag around the items to select them.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by Jamiecon on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @07:22PM (#2943646)
Agreed. And not only does the ribbon increase accessibility for novice users, it also encourages advanced use by displaying keyboard shortcuts to a wide variety of functions in an intuitive way.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by cwbrandsma on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:47PM (#2938575)
Work in support sometime. It is EXTREMELY common to find users that really don't know about right-click. Or that double-click everything. These are not new users either, they have been using computers for decades.

For new users I might agree that they could figure out a right click because everything is new. But for users where everything is familiar ("I've always done it this way"), it gets much harder to break those expected actions.

Second part is about explorer itself. While it might seem like a common utility (even necessary), I find it very rare for a general user to know about it (my wife does not, nor my parents, siblings, their friends,...but my wife's father does). Once they see it, they have no idea what to do. Copy a file? Really, they have no idea.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by bane on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:48PM (#2938900)
"Work in support sometime."

Spending 2 years in hell doing phone tech support for an ISP after high school was probably the most valuable career experience I've ever had bar none.

Nothing has prepared me for making and selling software to regular people better than this experience. Entire assumptions about how users interact with computers, ones based on my own experience, were rendered useless.

The ways regular people think about technology is endlessly fascinating because it very rarely has anything to do with how I think about technology.

At my day job, we eventually decided to put our development lead as tier-2 tech support because we couldn't get this across. He receives every single piece of support mail we get and is asked to respond to a pretty good percentage of them.

It's been a 2 year, very difficult, education for him.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by mitjak on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @01:21AM (#2940225)
Sounds like a potentially useful experience but, what does a development lead have to do with designing good UI?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by bane on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @08:47AM (#2941174)
In small companies, people often fill multiple rolls. Our dev lead happens to be our lead UI designer as well -- but we all provide feedback. Sticking him on part-time tech support duty was a creative way of both giving us another tier of support while simultaneously forcing him to deal with our regular 'ol user.

Experiencing the mind of the typical user day after day has caused some major changes in his UI design philosophy. Don't bury things in menus, limit the number of ways you can do something, walk users through set procedures, etc.

There's a bunch of different approaches to interface design and many of them don't work well. We've all seen the beautiful but hard to use designs made by professional designers, and the control-panel-of-a-spaceship design made by developers.

It seems that what both cases miss out on is spending time working with and understanding the average guy on the street. Or rather, good interface design means spending lots of time optimizing for regular users.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by kyberias on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @01:34AM (#2940255)
What are you implying? That development leads should not or could not contribute to designing a good UI?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by mitjak on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @10:57AM (#2941702)
They should ideally not be the only ones designing it.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by chao- on Monday August 29, 2011 @08:14PM (#2939575)
Second part is about explorer itself. While it might seem like a common utility (even necessary), I find it very rare for a general user to know about it (my wife does not, nor my parents, siblings, their friends,...but my wife's father does). Once they see it, they have no idea what to do.

Seconding. Especially before Windows 7 added Explorer as a pinned item by default, the less-technologically-literate persons I know would simply called it "My Computer", and used it in the large-icon, single-paned view. On one occasion while helping a friend find a file, I opened Explorer and switched it to the Details view option. Between that and the folder hierarchy in the left pane, I guess it looked different enough from "My Computer" that my friend was used to and I was given the reaction "Wow, you're really in the guts of the machine, now."

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:12PM (#2938698)
Re: explorer-- then I probably used the wrong term. I was refering to the program you are using when you are on the desktop, and simply want to copy a file. Mac used to call this the "Finder," I believe.

Now the idea that you actually have more problem with experienced users is interesting. I can see that in myself (damn new microwave!). But I still feel like it's no harder to learn, however, than what a bunch of icons are supposed to represent. But once it's shown, then is it really hard for them?

Seems like the problem is one of discoverability, not complexity.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by Stratoscope on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:53PM (#2938923)
You have the right terminology for both platforms. It's still called Finder on the Mac, and Windows Explorer or Explorer for short - in fact the executable is explorer.exe.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by Symmetry on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @01:41PM (#2942427)
The generic term is usually 'file manager'. There are at least of half dozen of them in the Linux world.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by ajross on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:56PM (#2938617)
Do those users use the desktop shell at all though? In my experience with novice users (across platforms: Mac noobs are no better) is that they only know enough to launch apps. They never touch the desktop integration at all.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by alextingle on Monday August 29, 2011 @08:48PM (#2939648)
This is only because the Finder/Explorer has been made harder and harder to use. Apple's OSX Finder is a shocking UI abomination.

Their old MacOS Finder was clear and simple - my wife would spend hours arranging her work in coloured folders, each of which opened in a window whose shape and position she had chosen, and was meaningful to her. It was a powerful tool that enabled her to arrange and group her work.

Now, both Apple and Microsoft compete with each other over how bad they can make their file system interface. Microsoft wanted to do away with the filesystem in Longhorn, and Apple have actually done so in iOS.

Is this progress??

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by GeneralMaximus on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @12:18AM (#2940086)
Are you talking about spatial mode? That still exists in Finder. Just hit Cmd+Opt+T or select "Hide Toolbars" from the View menu.

You're absolutely right. I don't have the citation on me right now, but spatial mode has been found to be easier to grasp for new users in every single test ever. The only reason it was dropped was because (1) Windows Explorer, (2) power users whined about too many open windows and (3) a lot of people got used to URLs opening in the same window thanks to web browsers, so people sought to apply the same principles to file browsers.

Spatial mode used to be default on GNOME for a long time. There, too, it was dropped because of the same reasons.

See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spatial_file_manager and http://www.bytebot.net/geekdocs/spatial-nautilus.html

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by rahoulb on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @05:55AM (#2940757)
I don't know about Windows but on the Mac it's not spatial mode (and hasn't been since OS9) - it's just a poor imitation.

You can easily have two Finder windows open on the same folder, meaning you lose the immediate recognition that spatial mode gives you. My personal take - they should have two types of Finder window - a spatial "folder contents" window and a folder-browser (probably in column-view) that only shows folders and maybe a preview of the files within.

So you can navigate quickly/enter file-paths in the browser, but to actually use a folder, you enter spatial mode, so you have the instant recognition of where you are.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by lloeki on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @04:26AM (#2940580)
> Just hit Cmd+Opt+T or select "Hide Toolbars" from the View menu

The problem is that there's no global switch to force Finder in spatial mode coming from anywhere, anytime. This results in a messy affair when suddenly a non-spatial Finder pops up because you never opened that folder directly and previously put it in spatial mode.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by babebridou on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @03:54AM (#2940517)
There is a crusade against the filesystem in general. We should probably go all the way and design an OS that absolutely does not need the concept of files, extensions and directory trees, even for programmers, else we'll have to deal with this UI debate for god knows how long.

Disclaimer: I believe the best UI for a filesystem manager was Windows Explorer 98, the last iteration with perpetual, irrevocable and non exclusive root access, with Norton Commander as its only rival.

From the moment we cared about maintaining our system's safety from the user's "big fingers syndrome", it all went down (starting with hiding file extensions) to the atrocities we now have to deal with. And yes, I put Seven's Explorer in the same basket as Finder and the likes of Nautilus, mostly due to /that/ horrible folder scrolling bug that MS refuses to hotfix.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by rat on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:41AM (#2940397)
I don't know spatial mode was default in Gnome for a while and I think most users disliked it.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by alextingle on Wednesday August 31, 2011 @02:52PM (#2946993)
Gnome's (and OSX's) spacial mode was rubbish. The whole philosophy of MacOS's Finder ("spacial mode") is to hide applications from the user, and make the whole user experience document-centric. The user opens documents and manipulates them without having to worry about what program they are using to do it.

Wonderful though Linux is, it's applications are not consistent or mature enough to support a totally document-centric UI. Microsoft could achieve that with Office, but they would probably be accused of over-integration, and hit with the anti-trust stick.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by sukuriant on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:06PM (#2938669)
When my grandfather uses the computer, he reorganizes the desktop, and puts files in folders, and sometimes wants to delete things, yes.

All of those actions require knowing how to [delete], [open folders], [drag and drop].

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by iaskwhy on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:34PM (#2938824)
I guess that partly explains the reason behind the single mouse button on Apple computers for quite some time.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by nickknw on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:31PM (#2938802)
> In fact, if I were asked to guess, I would have answered that most new users would pick up pretty quickly how to use context menus

As someone who has done a fair amount of tutoring seniors on basic computer usage, I have a large amount of anecdotal evidence to indicate this is definitely not the case for them. Depending on the person, I would sometimes try to not show them context menus or keyboard shortcuts at all and just teach them how to use the File, Edit, etc. menus.

There are people who just want to learn the correct order of incantations so that they can check their mail and do things with their photos. And that's okay! Trying to show them that that there is more than one way to do a given action often just leads to confusion as they meld them together (right click on Edit..)

I have seen a fair amount of people with a similar approach as well, but my largest body of personal experience comes from the tutoring, which is why I mentioned it.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by xtracto on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:40PM (#2938854)
>There are people who just want to learn the correct order of incantations so that they can check their mail and do things with their photos

I have been seeing the same thing with research colleagues.

What a lot of us in IT or related fields do not "get" from normal users is that the way they "see" the icons and pictures in the computer is completely different from what we do. We have a "mental model" of what Word or Excel or Firefox is doing. Some of us have a more accurate and detailed model than others.

But "normal" users only know what they see and what will happen after they do something (either because they have done it before or because we told them, and they trust us). For them, there is no more meaning to "click on the File menu" than if a Scuba diver told you to "check your SPG every 10 minutes".

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by tjogin on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:52PM (#2938598)
Invisible actions are harder to discover than visible ones, not that illogical really, and one of the key ways in which the Mac is more user friendly as it depends on context menus to a lesser degree.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:17PM (#2938720)
While I agree with all of your points, keep in mind that when 'civilians' were just getting to use computers (being forced to at work, etc.), Mac lost in favor of the IBM-compatibles (what people started calling 'pc's). There are a lot of reasons for this, to be sure, but difficulty of using the PC was not something that carried much weight in the argument (I was there for the arguments, and I was a mac man).
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by wpietri on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:07PM (#2939420)
True, but for reasons closely related to this discussion. Back in the day, the benefits of Macs were mostly invisible to novices when making a purchase decision. PCs looked cheaper and safer.

Apple has learned a lesson here. They are now heavily optimized for ease and comfort of purchase.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by larrywright on Monday August 29, 2011 @09:28PM (#2939743)
It begs the question though... other than children, how many "new" computer users are there?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by Qz on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:25PM (#2939317)
The main problem with right clicking is that right clicking does a myriad different things depending on what is being clicked on, whereas left clicking almost always does the same thing.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by riffic on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:34PM (#2938510)
agree, in fact UI like this encourages a user to develop bad usage habits, which will remain with them for an indefinite amount of time until these behaviors are (if ever) unlearned.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by sukuriant on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:04PM (#2938658)
What are bad usage habits?

(since we're on topic: I'm an MS employee. I do not work on Windows Explorer)

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by bostonvaulter2 on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @12:19AM (#2940088)
I'm guessing riffic meant using the copy and paste buttons instead of the keyboard shortcuts, but I don't agree that that is a "bad usage habit".
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by wtallis on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:30PM (#2938487)
According to Microsoft's data, more than 85% of the command usage in Explorer is through keyboard shortcuts or context menus. Clearly, it isn't that hard to get used to using context menus and keyboard shortcuts.

It seems to me that a lot of people here on HN are simply using this issue to talk about how much better they are at using a computer than the ordinary person, who is apparently quite inept. Unless there is convincing evidence that people that incompetent are still a significant fraction of the userbase, we should stop designing desktop software to accommodate people who are not able to master the use of an iPad.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by varunsrin on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:11PM (#2938692)
This is a classic case of misinterpreting the data - 85% use it because the only way you can copy, without using a context menu or a keyboard shortcut is by holding down Alt and then clicking on the Edit menu.The point is, people use keyboard shortcuts & context menus because they have to today.

This is the danger with reading too much into simple data - just because 85% of the people do X, it doesn't mean that X is good. Do you expect the data to show that people don't copy paste because its not intuitive? No, in most cases they 'have' to learn it, and figure it out by asking a friend, but they don't enjoy the learning process (and indirectly, resent the platform itself).

Everyone who struggled with the concept of right clicking eventually learnt it - the problem is not that right clicking or context menus are impossible to learn. It's that they're not a natural way of interaction, and should be eliminated whenever possible.

You shouldn't have to learn to use a menu to do what you want, especially when 80% of the time you just need 4 actions.

The simplicity of modifiers (tap, double tap, swipe) is what makes touch platforms like iOS very intuitive. A direct, clickable button ensures that novice users can accomplish simple file management tasks by learning a single modifier (the click).

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:34PM (#2938822)
When I browse, I prefer to open pages from hyperlinks in new tabs. For example, if I google something, each result I pursue gets its own tab. Doing that in ios was not at all intuitive, and only discoverable by happenstance. (And it is VERY klunky, but that's another story).

Editing is also a pain in the ass on it. It is a wonderful os for very simple tasks, but as the complexity grows it is very limiting.

Maybe that's the moral of this thread.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by brudgers on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:55PM (#2938615)
>"Clearly, it isn't that hard to get used to using context menus and keyboard shortcuts."

What this may show is that it is mainly experienced users who use Explorer. And based on my personal experience, I believe this to be the case - most people do not know what Explorer is for, let alone how to use it efficiently.

The reason for using the context menu use in my case is that most options are available only from the context menu...e.g. "edit", "extract [from zip] all", etc. and it is only through many years of trial and error that I have developed any efficiency with the context menu - this is because the problem with context menu operations is that they require enough experience to recognize the context and remember what [hidden] commands will be revealed by a right-click.

The advantage of the ribbon is that context menus are made visible when the context is entered, thus allowing less experienced users explore options more easily. Also, the issue with traditional context menus is that they are a mixture of fixed elements [cut, copy, paste, properties] and context specific items [extract all].

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by elehack on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:45PM (#2939515)
Assuming the usage data is from Windows 7, the nonexistent usage of menu is probably largely because the menu is entirely hidden unless you know that hitting 'alt' brings it up. And that is a much newer hidden feature (Win7 era, maybe Vista with early signals in XP) than context menus (at least since Win95).

Besides touch-friendliness, ribbons have huge benefits in discoverability. People can't use features they don't know exist; ribbons organize features into browsable, meaningful panels so they can be found, related to each other, and used. The article seems to entirely miss this point.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by mitjak on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @01:29AM (#2940242)
Actually, I think you missed the point of the article instead. It never argued that having buttons for common functions is bad but instead that some of the most bizarre and rarely used functions, e.g. Invert Selection, are showing up in a major UI element targeted largely at novice users.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by kenjackson on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:05PM (#2939261)
A lot of people have addressed a mistake in your reasoning (selective bias, only way to do things, etc...). Another point is that context menus aren't touch friendly. The ribbon works surprisingly well for touch.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by woobar on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:59PM (#2938631)
'Move To' and 'Copy To' existed for a long time. I have them on Windows XP. They are not on a toolbar by default, by anyone can add them.

Nobody knows about them for one reason - they are useless.

Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/5e5xN.jpg

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by seabee on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:11PM (#2939280)
they're on the toolbar in Vista and Win 7. In XP they're not on the toolbar but they're on the side bar that is shown by default.

Edit: Vista/7 may not be completely true, but it's certainly that way on my untechnically-minded mother's laptop - probably the result of context (e.g. in a library of pictures) or a setting somewhere.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by hernan7 on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:38PM (#2938534)
The "copy to" and "move to" buttons, seem to be some variation on the old "send to" command, which is currently available via both right-click and menu bar. (For those not familiar with Windows: if I select a file, the "send to" options are: compressed folder, create desktop shortcut, documents, fax, email, burn to DVD, network directory.)

Personally, that's an command that I never use; not sure how popular it is with the Windows userbase in general.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by watmough on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:03PM (#2938653)
Yes, here's a place they really could have done something cool with the UI, and spiffed up a be-cobwebbed corner of Explorer.

In XP, there's a folder that you can put folder and program shortcuts in, that will populate the send to menu. In fact, this essentially is my quicklaunch method when using XP. Just put a link to notepad2 in there, and you can view anything in ascii. Rinse and repeat.

It's so useful in fact, that they might have been able to bring it into wider usage, and maintain continuity with older Windows, by adding a context menu such as 'Make me a send to place', which would add a shortcut to the clicked folder or application into the send to menu.

To me on OS X, the Finder sidebar and Dock are the rough equivalent. 90% of my Finder work is selection and dragging to the sidebar, or Dock, the same thing I would use send to on Windows for.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by prewett on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:32PM (#2939471)
I love "Send To". I keep a link to Notepad2 and a hex editor in there (and sometimes Emacs) so that I can easily use a real editor or get a hex dump. It's kind of like "Open With..." except that it's always in the menu and somehow Open With... might not pick up the program you want, so you have to waste time traversing the directory tree.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by ordinary on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:20AM (#2940349)
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by aw3c2 on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:42PM (#2938551)
It is one thing I love to show "normal" people. They can use it to easily copy files to eg USB sticks or even select images to send by mail. These are tremendously useful for those people.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by hernan7 on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:04PM (#2939254)
Fair enough. Usually, when I copy files to USB I have 2 windows open and drag from one to another.

The "send to" email, however: I don't think you can use it with any web-based email, correct? Do people usually have Outlook set up on their machines these days?

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by icebraining on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:26PM (#2939318)
>(For those not familiar with Windows: if I select a file, the "send to" options are: compressed folder, create desktop shortcut, documents, fax, email, burn to DVD, network directory.)

There's one more: if you have a bluetooth adapter (or a laptop with embedded support), it shows a 'Send to Bluetooth device'. I find this very useful for sending files to my phone.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by raster_blaster on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:18PM (#2938729)
Move To and Copy To have existed since at least XP: http://i.imgur.com/NsPGD.png

But they had to be put there by the user. :)

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by azylman on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @12:23PM (#2942088)
Came here to say this, only I don't work for Microsoft. He takes you guys' research that says most people use it from the context menu and uses that to say that it should continue to be that way. It's like, since when are companies not allowed to try to improve their UI? Just because most people use it there doesn't make it the best option.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by rickmb on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:25PM (#2938464)
> but it will be extremely helpful for beginners

Methinks that kind of summarizes the issue: Microsoft doesn't seem to realize it's not 1995 anymore. "Beginners" are no longer a big market, and people are more comfortable with "discovering" software interfaces, as proven by the success of web apps, Apple, etcetera.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by SoftwareMaven on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:36PM (#2938517)
Most "normals" I interact with are beginners every time they use the computer. They are not comfortable discovering anything. I can teach them something and be confident in them forgetting it by the next time I talk to them.

Things like moving files around directories is black magic to them. Directories are black magic to them. The problem I see with this solution is two-fold:

1. The people who understand this stuff will be comfortable using context menus.

2. The people who don't understand this stuff will be just a stymied by the "move to" being in the ribbon versus being in a never-seen context menu.

However, what I would imagine MS is hoping with this is that the people in category two will gradually slide up to category one (well, more like 1a) because these things are in their face all the time.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by sunchild on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:17PM (#2938722)
File systems and file browsers are just never going to be easy for users to understand. That's why Apple is slowly but surely hiding them entirely from "beginners"/"people who don't care to learn how to use their tools".

Microsoft's solution is more akin to the way animal researchers teach apes to recognize arbitrary symbols. It's a subtle and pernicious form of vendor "lock in", because when you try to move those users away from their comfort zone in Outlook or Windows Explorer, they feel lost.

Personally, I think Microsoft and "people who can't be bothered to learn their tools" deserve each other.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by mmatants on Monday August 29, 2011 @05:09PM (#2939003)
This. Files and folders are not an optimal paradigm for this stuff. Partly because even real files/folders are not a "civilian" thing, especially now. Plus, there's typically just one level of folder nesting in the real world.

The actual user story is always: find what I'm looking for. Google got it right with GMail and informal searching - screw manual organization. Power users should be able to set up structures, but typical computer folks don't need that.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by xtracto on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:33PM (#2938814)
Oh my. That reminded me of a colleague of mine who thought I was doing "black magic" when I converted from "text to columns" in Excel. Guess what, she has a PhD in Geography. That really emphasizes your point.

For me, the problem with the ribbon has been (the times I tried to use Office 2010) that there are some more "advanced" commands (like, inserting a cross-reference to a Figure or Table) which became quite hidden away in the Ribbon. Specially, since in the old toolbar mode, I could add buttons to the actions I used most (I actually have a button for text-to-columns in Excel, or to bring the "insert cross reference" in Word, among others).

From my experience, the ribbon does not give you that ability.

Actually, every time I have to use the ribbon (my institute's laptop has office 2010) I start imaging an addon which "learns" what are the most used commands and configures the "Home" (or another) ribbon tab showing icons to access those commands. Surely, someone must have already thought of that no?

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by ak217 on Monday August 29, 2011 @11:35PM (#2940006)
Ummm... do you realize that what you described is exactly the function of the Quick Access toolbar?

Also, do you realize that the Ribbon is customizable in Office 2010, in the same way toolbars were customizable in Office pre-2007?

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by CamperBob on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:19PM (#2939442)
Actually, every time I have to use the ribbon (my institute's laptop has office 2010) I start imaging an addon which "learns" what are the most used commands and configures the "Home" (or another) ribbon tab showing icons to access those commands. Surely, someone must have already thought of that no?

This is similar to what MS did with pulldown menus in the pre-Ribbon days. It sounds like a great idea but it turns out to be a terrible one in practice. During the critical "newbie" phase, as a user begins to work with the program, the UI never seems to look the same twice. Tasks that should become reflexive never lose their dependence on the brain. At the same time, more advanced users are left wondering what interesting features they might be missing.

You really, really do not want a UI that changes behind your back, or in ways that aren't explicitly commanded. Resorting to discrete novice / expert modes is a venial sin in UI design, but "personalized menus" is a mortal one. It's about the worst thing you can do, and IMO there's no reason to think it would be any better in a ribbon-oriented model than in a menu-driven one.

(Edit: I do agree that restricting the adaptive menu scheme to a specific ribbon tab might be a more promising approach than monkeying with the structure and layout of the standard tabs.)

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dhimes on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:23PM (#2938752)
Your comment makes a lot of sense. If true, I think a good series of quick video tutorials would provide a faster outcome.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by CoryMathews on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:34PM (#2938508)
Have you met people not in the tech world?

Tons of people struggle with things as simple as sending emails, or adding music.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by wtallis on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:37PM (#2938525)
I know plenty of people like that. For the most part, they know how to right-click (unless they're using an Apple mouse).
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by testcock1 on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:33PM (#2938820)
I think this is a very subjective viewpoint, which is understandable considering the website we're on, but it still overlooks how huge the PC market really is, along with the Windows userbase, and the nature of a lot of its users. There's a huge segment of the Windows userbase who will always be beginners at computers, and their habits and methods are usually mindblowing to any "knowledgeable" user. One such example was the mass of people who typed "facebook login" into Google any time they wanted to log-in into Facebook, and got thoroughly confused and angry when the first hit suddenly led them to ReadWriteWeb's article on Facebook's log-in, filling the comments section with cries of where is the log-in, what is this crap, shitty re-design, let me in!, etc.

Because of users like this, Microsoft is where it is. Any big revamp, and they'll just get millions of confused customers who suddenly can't make sense of the most basic functionality. It is Microsoft's own doing that they made their users get used to interfaces like this, but it's not as easy as just scraping it and throwing up something new.

It's also easy to forget that Windows has a userbase 10 times its nearest competitor (which is to say this brings in challenges which competitors might not face).

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by hackinthebochs on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @02:45PM (#2942691)
>It is Microsoft's own doing that they made their users get used to interfaces like this

Jesus, the amount of Microsoft-bashing in on this article is insane.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by jvandenbroeck on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:31PM (#2938801)
Your computer science class isn't a good representation of the market. + It's not because 90% knows how to use a browser that they know how to use explorer, right click & use CTR/ALT
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by perlgeek on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:29PM (#2938785)
I don't have a Windows system at hand now, so I can't check it... but didn't "Copy To" exist as "Context Menu -> Send to" before?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dmethvin on Monday August 29, 2011 @04:52PM (#2938917)
There is a "Send To Any Folder" utility that you can put in there, but it's not a standard feature.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by leon_ on Monday August 29, 2011 @06:49PM (#2939382)
What makes you think that new computer users who can't remember "non intuitive" concepts like right clicking and context menus will know what cut/copy/paste on files does?
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by varunsrin on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:01PM (#2939405)
Again, cut/copy/paste are technical terms - the intent a user is likely to form is, I have this word file here, and i need to put it onto this USB drive here. The large copy to button in the ribbon accomplishes that task nicely.

Remember, its not that user's cant remember right clicking, its that they shouldn't have to. Why should you need two different types of clicks, and 2 sub menus to Send a file to a drive, when you can accomplish it with a single click and a single sub-menu (as is demonstrated in the ribbon)

Making the initial learning curve simple will have implications on the overall feel & appeal of the operating system, but this is something that is difficult to quantify with simple software metrics.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by leon_ on Monday August 29, 2011 @07:39PM (#2939492)
> Making the initial learning curve simple will have implications on the overall feel & appeal of the operating system, but this is something that is difficult to quantify with simple software metrics.

Ok, but the file system metaphor with its files and folders is unintuitive. New users get lost or just don't get that metaphor. You won't make anything easier for them by putting bigger buttons into the toolbar when they can't imagine for what those buttons might be used.

Alone the metaphor of "copying" a file is so unintuitive. If my mother wants to take a look at the photos she took with her cam she sure won't think about "copying" them.

My point is: MS is trying to fix the wrong problem. They should think about getting rid of end user facing file systems instead of bolting bigger and brighter buttons onto a horribly user unfriendly application like the explorer.

Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by Kwpolska on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @04:19AM (#2940566)
Move To and Copy To exist in XP.
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by iaskwhy on Tuesday August 30, 2011 @04:27AM (#2940582)
But they are not shown by default on Vista or 7 (which I guess is where their data comes from).
Re:Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody by dendory on Monday August 29, 2011 @03:45PM (#2938560)
"New computer users" ?!

People who use Windows are, for the most part, not new computer users. More and more the new users go to a Mac, tablet or smartphone.

The point of that article is that people already use hotkeys and context menus. So building a bigger menu and toolbar is crazy.