News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by powerapple on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:26AM (#27378863)
One thing I have noticed when listening to the interviews of NFT companies is that, when describing NFT is the future, the arguments from these founders are examples of people/artists made money by selling NFT online. It has become more and more a theme for cryptocurrency technology has well: the reason you should be in is that other people have made money rather than the benefit of the technology itself. It is not a good sign.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by nly on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:39AM (#27378947)
Imho it stems from a lack of understanding and faith in the financial services industry, probably exacerbated by the financial crisis.

A large % of people now believe that the finance industry only exists to work against them and make an elite minority rich. There's a strong sense of "Fuck You, I Got Mine" from the last generation, so the current generation is saying "Fine, I'm going to invent my own system... with Black Jack, and hookers!". Crypto/DeFi is creating a sense of euphoria and hope against a backdrop of helplessness where people are thinking "I will never own a home", "I will never be able to afford to retire" etc, so why not take a punt on the next big thing?

I was intrigued by some comments on HN the other day that dApps are where all the 'innovation' in crypto is today, so spent some time looking in to it.

After many hours I couldn't find anything even remotely interesting.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by qwerty456127 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:53AM (#27379043)
"I will never own a home" is not the only reason. The whole financial system is "fuck you this and fuck you that, incl. when you least expect and depend the most, and we won't tell you why". Yesterday here were news about PayPal terminating an account without explanation again (by the way, even when they don't ban you, their verification and customer services are a disaster anyway). This bullshit has to stop. Every person on Earth (even those with questionable reputation or even convicted felons) should be able to wire/accept some reasonable amounts of money (I don't advocate letting terrorists make million-dollar deals) freely, no questions asked, like in cash. It's a basic thing in today world, like eating and shitting.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by qwerty456127 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:16PM (#27389392)
By the way, perhaps cryptocurrencies may devaluate or even die out if a viable alternative letting everyone unconditionally and anonymously transfer and accept conventional amounts of money is introduced. Perhaps this may destroy the ransomware market which is about sending huge amounts of money in cryptocurrencies.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by cma on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:59AM (#27381451)
> Yesterday here were news about PayPal terminating an account without explanation again

In the past few weeks crypto has shut down energy infrastructure, meat processing, and a major ferry service.

It's also burning 1% of the world's electricity and rapidly growing.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by nkrisc on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:22AM (#27381782)
I'm very cynical about cryptocurrency but that's a stretch. Criminals did that damage to companies and infrastructure, and they would do it without cryptocurrency if it was worth it. I guess dollars sell drugs to kids too and fuel murder for hire.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by foobiekr on Thursday June 03, 2021 @12:20PM (#27383615)
Anyone who doesn’t think cryptocurrency has facilitated monetizing cyberattacks needs to wake up. You can be pro-crypto and still acknowledge that the rise of ransomware has hone hand in hand with the ability to monetize it at dramatically lowered risk. This, in turn, broadened to scope of companies that were interesting to attack.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by nkrisc on Friday June 04, 2021 @08:47AM (#27393040)
You could have cryptocurrency without ransomware attacks, and you could have ransomware attacks without cryptocurrency . It is disingenuous to say cryptocurrency is directly responsible. Cryptocurrency didn’t cause ransomware, it made it worth the effort on the part of the attackers, but so could have a different confluence of events.

Criminals will abuse any technology that benefits them.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by meiraleal on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:38PM (#27388342)
It of course facilitated, but if it didn't exist, online credit card payments would had facilitated the same way so crypto is not at fault. You can be against crypto and still acknowledge that the advocates of a tech/tool are not responsible nor turning a blind eye to the bad uses of it.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Nursie on Friday June 04, 2021 @04:58AM (#27391862)
This is nonsense, online credit card payments would not be able to facilitate multi-million dollar transactions and allow the proceeds to just disappear like that.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by cma on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:24AM (#27381804)
It's not the main things dollars have enabled though.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by driverdan on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:12AM (#27382519)
> In the past few weeks crypto has shut down energy infrastructure, meat processing, and a major ferry service.

You're conflating cryptocurrency with ransomware attacks.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by dleslie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:23AM (#27382691)
I think it's reasonable to link the two, but not conflate them. Crypto has certainly made ransomware a much more viable attack vector. A crypto address is easier to hide behind than a bank account number or mailing address or drop location.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by meiraleal on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:39PM (#27388355)
so you are a proponent of a cash-less society? If Crypto is responsible for this new attacks, fiat is responsible for all others. Including the most violent ones.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by dleslie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:23PM (#27389845)
A cash-less capitalist society looks like Canada and the Nordic countries, where cash use is abnormal and most transactions are with debit and credit; Ie, quite well tracked.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by meiraleal on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:25PM (#27390223)
There are no crimes with debit and credit card? They are still cash.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by dleslie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:27PM (#27390234)
They are safer than paper cash or crypto; credit and debit cards have fraud protection, and banks have account security protections.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by meiraleal on Friday June 04, 2021 @08:46AM (#27393023)
They have now, they didn't have in the past, and is still an annoyance to the customers often. Also online banking apps, SMS phising, etc.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by dleslie on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:59AM (#27394248)
Still more fraud detection and theft deterrence than the alternatives.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by meiraleal on Sunday June 06, 2021 @07:26PM (#27417321)
Nobody rob your crypto with a knife, but people do for your credit card.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by dajohnson89 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:42AM (#27381169)
what if the terrorists broke up 1mil into 1000 $1000-transfers?
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by EarlKing on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:49AM (#27381308)
That would result in the filing of a Suspicious Activity Report because the breakdown looks like it was done precisely to avoid the reporting threshold.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by snypher on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:01AM (#27381481)
...or the bank launders over $10 bullion, pays a $700m fine and everyone walks away free.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by SOLAR_FIELDS on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:32AM (#27381971)
Not possible. How could Some Bank get away with such a Crime with no repercussions?
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by BLKNSLVR on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:56AM (#27382312)
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by addicted on Friday June 04, 2021 @03:15AM (#27391401)
1) The fundamental problem is that countries, especially the US, have basically made companies exempt from criminal proceedings. Any criminal activity conducted as part of the company rarely leads to prosecution of the people in the company, and companies themselves aren’t really ever prosecuted for criminal acts. So any penalty to HSBC wouldn’t be criminal but civil and financial.

2) The articles say that HSBC laundered billions. This likely means it was $3-4Bn at most, but let’s assume it was $19Bn (because if it was $20Bn they would have said tens of billions). These transactions were probably earning HSBC a few basis points. I can’t say for sure since I’m not aware of the market price of criminal transactions, but I suspect the premium was not much higher than a regular transaction for the simple reason that it would make the transaction appear obviously criminal. But let’s say it was 200bp (so 2%, and that’s likely an order of magnitude higher, but for arguments sake). Then HSBC probably made about $400mm - costs (remember, assuming a very high $19bn in transactions). So a $1.9Bn fine is extremely high, being 5x HSBC’s revenue from the transactions assuming very favorable numbers, and not considering the non monetary penalties, such as probation, etc.

3) Finally, if Apple is found guilty of illegally promoting a monopoly through their App Store policies, would a fine of $7Bn be considered laughable, considering it’s about 5 weeks of Apple’s income? And in Apple’s case, the company operates fairly cohesively, and the App Store almost exists for the sole purpose of encouraging hardware sales, so there’s actually an argument to be made to base the penalty on Apple’s total income as a company. OTOH, banks tend to have fairly independent divisions, because they are highly regulated, unlike the likes of Apple, and there are all sorts of restrictions preventing the divisions that are making the kind of transactions from even interacting with most of the rest of the company. Apple collaborated more with its competitors to illegally suppress employee pay than this division of HSBC likely collaborated with any other division in HSBC (and they likely had to actively evade scrutiny from the middle office).

I’m not trying to argue that the punishment was appropriate. However, what I am arguing is that if a non banking company was found to have done something similar, they would have faced punishments that were a much tinier fraction of what HSBC faced. And that’s even before we factor in the fact that banks are orders of magnitude more regulated than nearly any other industry, with them being required to set up entire departments that account for over 10-20% of their workforce purely to ensure they can meet government regulations. Something pretty much no other industry, especially the tech industry, has to do.

Any shortcomings in the punishment imposed on HSBC was a result of leeway’s given to companies in general.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by BLKNSLVR on Sunday June 06, 2021 @10:55PM (#27418527)
The fundamental problem, as you've described in 1) and reiterated in your conclusion lays bare a, mostly unspoken, fundamental societal injustice that's common to many countries.

It really feels like protectionism for the status quo. Which is totally understandable and predictable in the context of basic human behaviour and motivations; the king of the hill will not make it easy for anyone to displace them.

What I find interesting, as opposed to surprising as such, is the myriad ways in which politicians explain these situations away in simultaneously calling the slap-on-the-wrist a big deterrent to such behaviour in future, and playing this slap-on-the-wrist as if it's somehow in the interests of the voting population.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ProAm on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:58AM (#27382335)
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by DennisP on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:01AM (#27381486)
And possibly a felony charge for structuring.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by tim333 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @02:47PM (#27385656)
I'm curious in money laundering laws have ever been noticeably successful in stopping terrorism?
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by KptMarchewa on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:29PM (#27388252)
It's hard to prove that something does not exist. Significant amount of money has been recovered, although it's easy to argue that effects are not enough for the effort and inconvenience of normal customers.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:29AM (#27379256)
Maybe if we would question why we (don't) need money in the first place, and why people turn to terrorism, we wouldn't have problems in the first place.

Let everyone have a home, eat and drink as much as they need, receive proper education and healthcare, and thrive working for something they see interest in not a paycheck/boss and you'll see terrorism will be entirely rid of.

In the meantime, i agree it's a reasonable expectation that people can exchange money freely with the caveat that there should be taxes. As much as i hate taxes because they will fund police terrorizing my neighborhood, big corporations for their next nature-destroying megaproject, and cameras everywhere in the big cities, they are important as long as we live in a capitalist system to ensure we have basic public services.

A system like GNU/Taler is really interesting because it promises buyer's secrecy while retaining public accounting for receivers so that they can be subject to taxes. Cash is better of course as anonymity is guaranteed on both sides, and that's precisely why the chief scammers are pushing for the abolition of cash... so much of informal economy/solidarity would disappear overnight i'm having nightmares over it.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:34AM (#27379281)
> Let everyone have a home, eat and drink as much as they need, receive proper education and healthcare, and thrive working for something they see interest in not a paycheck/boss and you'll see terrorism will be entirely rid of.

Are there sufficient people interested in cleaning toilets, dealing with the mentally ill/infirm, working in crawl spaces and attics, working on a farm an hour plus from everything?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by grasshopperpurp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:06AM (#27379463)
Imo flip these "punishment" jobs into "reward" jobs. As it is, we give the jobs no one wants to people who don't have any other options - or are struggling to exercise their options. We use them as boogeyman for kids when we remind them how important school is.

If everyone is taken care of, these jobs should come with some extra benefits - both socially and financially. Remember all those bs commercials thanking essential workers toward the beginning of Covid? What if society really appreciated its essential workers and compensated them like it did?

Cleaning toilets is somewhat unpleasant, but there's immediate feedback on your performance (the before and after is clear), and people should appreciate the people that keep them clean. There should be an understood, and spoken, sense of "Thank you" for the people keeping them clean.

Perspective -> feeling - > actions. I don't think this is a particularly difficult issue to navigate, but it would require a shift in perspective.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:11AM (#27379489)
> What if society really appreciated its essential workers and compensated them like it did?

The person I was responding to was arguing against compensation as a concept in general.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by grasshopperpurp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:25AM (#27379587)
Very fair. I don't think you can remove compensation. But, I think the post still had some good thoughts and good aims. They need some tweaking. Your post highlighted an area that needs tweaking, and mine tried to build on both posts.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:34AM (#27379684)
That tweak is a universal basic income (or other broad based benefits that establish a floor for quality of life) which would attempt to reduce the impact of one's lineage on one's options.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:39AM (#27379743)
What if monetary or material compensation was replaced with simple respect and appreciation though? As it is, the people who do the dirty jobs of society are often treated like they themselves are filth.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:45AM (#27379806)
Then we would not be living in the same world with the same parameters as we are now.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:56AM (#27379937)
And yet there are functional societies out there today, much as there were in the past, that are not capitalistic societies. Treating people like shit and forcing them to do dirty jobs you don't want to do under threat of starvation is not an inherent property of the human condition.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:07AM (#27380053)
Which societies operated like that? I am not aware of any, that could operate as a country of decent size today. Note that this supposed country would also need to be able to defend itself, if it has possession of anything valuable (such as water, arable land, weather, etc). And also be able to deal with immigration and outsiders coming in, and kicking out people who would mess up the system.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by silicon2401 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:25AM (#27380944)
What kind of idealistic misunderstanding of history do you have that non-capitalist societies were some kumbaya utopia? Korea historically had slavery and extreme class differences. Europe had nobility and serfs who were not far off from slaves (and could be tortured or executed). Ancient Sparta and Persia had slaves and going way back into biblical times (though this still happens today in some places), people could be stoned just for not believing the right things. People today make the mistake of assuming things were altogether better in the past just because one particular aspect they dislike today was better before. Hierarchy and treating each other terribly are an inherent part of being human, and it's taken centuries of work to get to a point that we can even pretend otherwise.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by andrepd on Thursday June 03, 2021 @02:52PM (#27385721)
He said some non-capitalist societies, not all non-capitalist societies that have ever existed.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by silicon2401 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @04:05PM (#27386605)
Which makes it a moot point. The common thread across capitalist, socialist, monarchist, whatever-ist societies with suffering is that humans are involved. Neither capitalism nor socialism is inherently bad; some humans are, especially in aggregate, hence we always need ways to enforce order. The fatal flaw to any utopian society is that the more it depends on trust, the more some people will abuse it and coordinate with others to abuse it. The less trust you have, the more force you need to enforce your worldview on others (which radical liberals and conservatives essentially push for). There is no magical world where we all live in harmony
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by andrepd on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:38PM (#27388339)
I don't understand your point. The corollary to "there is no perfect society, suffering always exist" is not "therefore all societies are equally bad". No, liberalism is an improvement on feudalism. Capitalist “liberal democracies” are an improvement on capitalist absolute monarchies.

All I'm saying is we can do much better than this.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by silicon2401 on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:39AM (#27393471)
You can't go back and forth between theoretical and real-life. I don't accept the claim that democracies are always better than monarchies. Monarchies and authoritarian states are great in theory, if they enforce the worldview you want. Look at how America's republicanism has allowed its own self-degradation through lobbying and regulatory capture. My first point is that everything in the real world is case by case and it's intellectually dishonest to go for such grade-school arguments as saying that democracy = good, monarch = bad. Capitalism can be good or bad. Monarchies can be good or bad, etc. My second point is that the only common theme is that some humans are bad actors, therefore it doesn't matter how your society functions, there will always be people who exploit the system. The only reason you think monarchies is bad is because historical monarchs have been abusive. But there have also been abusive democratic leaders. Humans are the problem, not the systems we create.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by andrepd on Saturday June 05, 2021 @06:16AM (#27403724)
Disagree entirely. Ironically it's your "systems don't matter, it just depends on whether the people in charge are good or not" that is grade-school level. x)

First, I didn't say democracy good, monarchy bad... My point is precisely that western bourgeois democracy is pretty flawed. It is however better than the absolutist monarchies of the 1700s and 1800s.

>some humans are bad actors, therefore it doesn't matter how your society functions, there will always be people who exploit the system. The only reason you think monarchies is bad is because historical monarchs have been abusive. But there have also been abusive democratic leaders. Humans are the problem, not the systems we create.

That's just silly. A well designed system has institutions, checks and balances that prevent bad actors from wrecking the system. An absolutist monarchy has none. Can't you see how that matters? Taking your argument to its conclusion, then absolute monarchies, bourgeois democracies, direct democracies, soviet-style totalitarianism... it's all the same! All it matters is if you're lucky that the people in charge are good.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by curation on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:26AM (#27381855)
Have you read Another Tomorrow by Yanis Varafoufakis?
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by haskellandchill on Thursday June 03, 2021 @01:36PM (#27384704)
The title is Another Now, thanks for the rec!
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:44AM (#27382135)
No.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:45AM (#27379802)
As long as there is money and private property, i agree with your point. Jobs that nobody wants to do by pleasure should be the highest paid and most respected. However that's not how capitalism works (quite the opposite). Like another commentator pointed out, i'm opposed to financial compensation (and all forms of money) as an organizing principle of society. However as long as money hasn't been abolished your point makes perfect sense.

Specifically about COVID though, I don't know about where you are, but here in France "thank you" for health workers was perceived to be very insulting. Because when the government continues to dismantle all forms of public services and keeps on overworking hospital workers (most of whom have months or even years of paid vacations they could never take because of understaffing) and destroying all their social benefits, it's hard not to take this as "fuck you".

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:50AM (#27379877)
> i'm opposed to financial compensation (and all forms of money) as an organizing principle of society.

What does this mean? It is the nature of animals to evaluate and rank each other, least of all for mating purposes. Not using money will not change that, and another proxy will be used.

> Specifically about COVID though, I don't know about where you are, but here in France "thank you" for health workers was perceived to be very insulting.

It was the same in the US. The thank you and hero nonsense was seen through by all, but I guess plausible deniability is worth it amongst the managing class.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:22AM (#27380196)
> It is the nature of animals to evaluate and rank each other

Not at all. Competition is not the norm in the natural world. There's the entire field of ethology to study if you'd like to know more.

If you need a quick intro, "Mutual Aid" by Peter Kropotkin is really dated science-wise (it's almost 120 years old) but is still a pretty good read. If you're into TV stuff, i'd recommend Adam Curtis' series "The trap" and "The century of the self" which explore the topics of how competition and self-interest have increasingly been guiding principles of (at the time) western societies and how we've tried to apply such principles (eg. game theory) to other fields where they in fact do not apply.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:31AM (#27380266)
Primates and other mammals do it. Birds do it. Unless all those David Attenborough narrated shows I’ve watched are wrong or misinterpreted by me, there seems to be extensive use of competition in many species.

Or one can look at data from myriad of dating apps and websites. I would not believe anyone if they told me they did not rank possible partners in life on a variety of metrics such as health, wealth, tribal affiliations (family/other network), intelligence, humor, etc.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by silicon2401 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:32AM (#27381036)
I think this thread is a perfect demonstration of idealism vs realism. Some people are idealistic and believe what they wish were true, even with little to no supporting evidence and mountains of evidence to the contrary. Other people look at reality first and base their beliefs on that.

> I would not believe anyone if they told me they did not rank possible partners in life on a variety of metrics such as health, wealth, tribal affiliations (family/other network), intelligence, humor, etc.

I certainly do, and this is commonplace to the point of cliche. Think of Indian or Chinese arranged marriages where the parents openly and blatantly choose and approve of partners based on what you said: health, wealth, family, etc. It's a documented fact and I've seen it personally that some Chinese parents even disqualify women over 30 or so as partners for their children (to the point there's a word for it: "leftover women"). In the West some people are squeamish about consciously evaluating and ranking people, but everyone still does it, even if it's subconscious, unless you literally throw a dart at at list and pair with whoever you hit. We just talk about it indirectly: having a "type", being "compatible", having similar interests, getting along, having things in common, avoiding "red flags".

I at least certainly have based my relationship evaluations based on conscious ranking and metrics, and it's led to the incredibly happy, successful relationship I'm in now.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:06AM (#27380658)
Do some reading on the question and make an opinion for yourself. There is some competition throughout nature but it's really far from an organizing principle as it has become with the capitalist system.

> I would not believe anyone if they told me they did not rank possible partners in life on a variety of metrics

That sounds really close to the definition of a psychopath, and is definitely not how most people live their lives/relationships. Adam Curtis in "The trap" touches on this topic and how only psychopaths and economists used to behave like according to "measurable rational self-interest". With the commodification of everything (including oneself through social media) it's fair to bet more people behave like that nowadays than previously, but it's still really far from everyone.

Why would you not believe me if i told you i have feelings and affinities that cannot be measured or ranked and do not reflect a material interest? Why is it so hard to accept that not everybody lives through live the same way that soulless suit-heads do?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by silicon2401 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:40AM (#27381149)
You sound like you're arguing from a point of insecurity or emotion rather than making a rational argument.

> Why would you not believe me if i told you i have feelings and affinities that cannot be measured or ranked and do not reflect a material interest? Why is it so hard to accept that not everybody lives through live the same way that soulless suit-heads do?

Why would you not believe that I have a long, committed, happy relationship today that I arrived at through consciously ranking and evaluating qualities of my current partner and other people that I met? Why is it so hard for you to accept that humans are inherently judging and comparing creatures? Why do you think that to just think about important life choices like a partner doesn't make you a "soulless suit-head"? If you want to live your life that way, go ahead.

The fact that you and even most people seem to let your subconscious steer you with important life decisions doesn't affect me. But I don't see why you have to indirectly call the other user names (psychopath, soulless suit-head) just because they do things differently than you. Are Indian and Chinese parents who perform arranged marriages also psychopaths or soulless suit-heads just because they choose matches for their children based on a variety of metrics? Does it make Chinese or Indian culture soulless or psychopathic since they've been doing this way before the "commodification of everything"?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Nursie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:56AM (#27381410)
> There is some competition throughout nature

Competition for mates literally forms and morphs most animal species.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Applejinx on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:09AM (#27381603)
What ethology tells us is that, yes, but a little more.

Competition IS relevant, but it's in the context of other drives like group-oriented behavior, and it is cooperation that some people seem to have a hard time understanding. Cooperation and group behavior is every bit as powerful and rewarding as competition is, and every bit as natural.

I feel like we get into trouble when we try to isolate one side of things and dismiss the other. You're correct that western societies (probably not exclusively western societies) have erred, in leaning way over to the 'competition' side.

You could say law of the jungle except for jungles don't operate in this simplistic way. More like law of the capitalism, which tries to deify one behavior and demonize the other.

I'm not convinced Kropotkin is the final answer here, but he sure serves as a good window into the 'cooperate' side which is unreasonably suppressed in western society.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:52AM (#27379378)
> Are there sufficient people interested in ... ?

There's people interested in caring for others and/or growing food on the countryside. Cleaning toilets is a task nobody does by pleasure but i don't see a reason there should be a specific class in society handling undesired tasks for the others.

Why can't we take turns doing what HAS TO be done? I've lived in communities for about two decades now and it's never ever crossed our mind we should designate someone to clean the toilets for others. I'm happy to do it every now and then if you're happy to do the same.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by prepend on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:10AM (#27379481)
I would rather pay someone to take my turn for me.

There’s a whole theory of competitive advantage [0] where I’m better doing some things than others. I’d rather do the thing I’m good at and use the money to pay others to do stuff I’m marginally worse off doing.

I’ve lived in communities for a few decades and every day it crosses my mind that I want to establish a price for someone to come clean my toilet.

[0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/comparativeadvantage.as...

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Applejinx on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:17AM (#27381708)
When my parents were alive, in their retirement, they'd hire 'Merry Maids' to come and clean for them. As near as I could tell, they were very nice about it, and I remember being over there and the amusing interplay as the maids tried very hard to not impose on the family visiting going on, while the kids tried just as hard to arrange where they were at to not get in the way of the maids :) it was a very Alphonse and Gaston, 'oh no, after you!' sort of thing.

I feel like the real litmus test here is: given that the maid is cleaning your toilet, would you freak out if the maid took a dump in your toilet AND then cleaned it? That cuts to the heart of whether they're a fellow human doing exchange-value with you as a true equal, or whether they're a class that should not be using the employer's private toilet.

I would bet you maid services like that are very strict about not blurring that line, knowing that some people are paying to set up a class dynamic they expect to be honored.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by prepend on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:18PM (#27387469)
> would you freak out if the maid took a dump in your toilet AND then cleaned it? That cuts to the heart of whether they're a fellow human doing exchange-value with you as a true equal, or whether they're a class that should not be using the employer's private toilet.

Ha, no of course not. I also think it’s not a very good test because almost no one would care. Me not being able to afford to buy things or not being skilled enough to command a high wage doesn’t mean I’m not equal as a human being, it just means I can’t afford things.

I would expect that maid services are very strict because some people are super picky about their toilets. I know people who won’t let family members use their toilet, much less some stranger. It’s not worth the risk for a maid service to lose the work. Not really a good indicator of valuing humans.

Maybe a better test would be whether I allow a maid to drink from my water or something like that.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by throw0101a on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:47AM (#27379835)
> I would rather pay someone to take my turn for me.

You're not wrong, but it's not (all) about efficiency but rather about solidarity and social cohesion. As an example, in Japan, children clean the school:

* https://www.japantimes.co.jp/life/2001/11/30/lifestyle/kids-...

* https://www.thejapanguy.com/japanese-kids-clean-their-classr...

* https://www.quora.com/How-do-Japanese-students-feel-about-th...

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:54AM (#27379912)
> I would rather pay someone to take my turn for me.

Yeah, that's precisely what's wrong in our society that it appears normal to pay for inconveniences to disappear. Except of course for most of us who don't have money so we get paid shitty wages for making other people's inconveniences disappear. If such jobs were the highest paid, that would be less of a problem of course. But the highest paid jobs under capitalism are the least useful to society at large because they don't produce anything (CEOs, managers, financial/legal advisors, marketers, etc).

> I’m better doing some things than others.

That makes sense. However some tasks such as cleaning are not skilled labor. Yes it requires (some) learning, but by the second time you've cleaned a toilet you pretty much know how to do it for the rest of your life. Cleaning a single toilet takes about 5 minutes and is not much effort (contrary to doing that for a living)That makes sense. However some tasks such as cleaning are not skilled labor. Yes it requires (some) learning, but by the second time you've cleaned a toilet you pretty much know how to do it for the rest of your life. Cleaning a single toilet takes about 5 minutes and is not much effort (contrary to doing that for a living). Have you considered why you're so reluctant to do it?

> I’ve lived in communities (...) my toilet

We're probably not living in the same kinds of communities then if you've got a personal toilet. In the communities i've resided in everybody's got their personal room but everything else is communal.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by prepend on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:23PM (#27387533)
> that's precisely what's wrong in our society that it appears normal to pay for inconveniences to disappear.

I disagree, it’s what is awesome about our society. It’s a feature, not a bug.

I’ve gotten all the character I’ll get from cleaning toilets and I’m happy that someone else is willing to do it for me.

There’s no way toilet cleaner will be a high paying job because the skill set is so low. As with most manual labor. Low skill set means lots of people will do it means low wages.

I understand how to clean a toilet and the time involved. I choose not to do it. I won’t make me a better person to do it. I have considered why I’m reluctant and understand pretty completely. I grok why I don’t want to clean toilets. I’m comfortable with my understanding in this area.

It’s also ok that we value these experiences differently. I don’t have to convince you to pay someone to clean your toilet. I just have to convince you to continue letting me, and others, pay for toilet cleaning.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:00PM (#27387946)
> Low skill set means lots of people will do it means low wages.

High supply relative to demand or low demand relative to supply means low wages.

It is possible (and very real in many areas) that there are low numbers of people willing to clean toilets in a given area compared to the demand. It could be due to government assistance providing them enough such that they do not need to clean toilets to meet their needs.

It could be better job opportunities opening up nearby such as higher paying factory work. It could be that they move away from the area due to higher real estate prices. There are myriad causes for a low skill task to have few willing suppliers for the labor to perform that task.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by muttled on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:31AM (#27382849)
>Have you considered why you're so reluctant to do it?

It's funny, I had a conversation with a roommate that went something like I said I hated dishes, and that I'd rather be outside in the cold, under the car lifted on jackstands, draining the oil and replacing it and servicing the oil filter, coming back in and cleaning up. For both our cars. And my roommate seemed shocked. It seemed like such a bigger task to them than just quickly cleaning the dishes and throwing them in a rack to dry. But I just hate doing the dishes. And I don't mind changing the oil in the car.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:05AM (#27380030)
> Except of course for most of us who don't have money so we get paid shitty wages for making other people's inconveniences disappear. If such jobs were the highest paid, that would be less of a problem of course. But the highest paid jobs under capitalism are the least useful to society at large because they don't produce anything (CEOs, managers, financial/legal advisors, marketers, etc).

This might be able to be rectified under the current system by giving money to the lowest paid, so that they can go to school and learn a trade which they find has a more acceptable price:undesirability ratio. Ideally, everyone will have the option to not have to do tasks like cleaning toilets, and hence everyone will have to do it themselves or pay a lot to get someone else to do it.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:53AM (#27379389)
> Why can't we take turns doing what HAS TO be done?

What happens when someone does not take their turn?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:32AM (#27379664)
Depends on the reason. You may be temporarily/long-term disabled. Or maybe you were having a really bad week and you'll be happy to take your turn next week (maybe you even said so in advanced and arranged to swap your shift with somebody else?).

Or maybe you just don't care to exploit other people you live with, in which case you're free to go and do that elsewhere because that's the norm in all of capitalist societies.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:40AM (#27379753)
Why would someone that wants to exploit other people leave a place that lets them exploit others?

I’ll cut to the chase. My point is your concept of society does not work at scale. You will have people that want to use the system, you will need to use force and adjudicate in the system, and you will need something more than good vibes to serve as incentives.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:01AM (#27379985)
> Why would someone that wants to exploit other people leave a place that lets them exploit others?

Because we'll kick them out. I'm always up for doing things i don't particularly enjoy because there's value in them, but I certainly don't want to live with someone who treats me like a slave.

> you will need something more than good vibes to serve as incentives

Sure. But you'll probably concede that we live in a world run by psychopaths where children in schools are taught how to become psychopaths themselves. The first thing we teach children is "copying is cheating" and we're wondering why we're fucked? I'm not saying there's a time and place where everything will be perfect and we can all live happily ever after (i'm not a hippy), but there's very rational reasons for the ways everything around us is bad, and very rational courses of actions to fix those.

Abolishing property as State-mandated religion doesn't mean that some people won't have more than others (this would be ridiculous). But at least it would mean that nobody would sleep on the streets while there are empty homes, and nobody would starve while there is wasted food. Both ridiculous situations are the consequence of private property and require considerable amounts of force and resources to apply. It obviously is not working at scale, as we can see from environmental damage and previously-unimaginable levels of inequality.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:12AM (#27380090)
> Because we'll kick them out. I'm always up for doing things i don't particularly enjoy because there's value in them, but I certainly don't want to live with someone who treats me like a slave.

It’s hard enough to get many married couples to live like this, and even harder for small extended families. I would assign something very close to 0% as the probability for viability of this on a country or global level.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ycombobreaker on Friday June 04, 2021 @12:52AM (#27390722)
> The first thing we teach children is "copying is cheating"

Sharing and cooperative play come long before anything resembling an individual assignment.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:37AM (#27379724)
They are ostracized or otherwise lose social status within the community. Functional human societies have existed and do exist in the absence of capitalism.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:41AM (#27379765)
I do not know what definition of capitalism you are using, but I was strictly addressing the ability of society to function without compensation.

I am not aware of any functional society exists today without the use of compensation on a notable scale, certainly not notable enough to be able to defend itself.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:04AM (#27380026)
Considering that functional societies exist, regardless of their size and technological state, without monetary compensation as a primary motivation, I am forced to wonder how much our narrative that we cannot have technological civilization without forcing a class of people into handling unsavory tasks via threat of starvation and death is just part of the self-perpetuating mechanism of our particular societal organization structure.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:12AM (#27380094)
Which societies today function like this, that could be scaled up to country level tasks and responsibilities? Regardless of size would make it a meaningless claim, as the parameters are greatly different between a tribe of 100 vs 10,000 vs 1,000,000,000.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:19AM (#27380167)
> Which societies today function like this, that could be scaled up to country level tasks and responsibilities?

None that I'm aware of, though I am not entirely convinced it is impossible for the reasons I stated. I am forced to wonder: what is the virtue of scale like that if it is largely built on the back of human suffering?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:34AM (#27380300)
So another tribe does not roll over you.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:00AM (#27379977)
To me that's moving the goal posts. There are plenty of nomadic and tribal societies out there that function the same way they have for thousands of years.

Certainly our technologically advanced civilizations as they exist today are founded on capitalism, but I am not sure that is required, it has just become such an ingrained concept that "no one would ever do these unsavory tasks if we didn't threaten them with starvation and death" that we have difficulty imagining any other possibility.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by seedie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:07AM (#27379469)
An interesting question is how the salaries would shift. If everyone can fulfil basic needs without much, will the jobs that no ones interested in doing be the ones on a high pay grade?

edit: just saw that you replied to "maybe money isn't needed at all" so my reply is not really relevant

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:16AM (#27379515)
I thought it was common knowledge that the quality of life for people in the upper quintiles is based on the people in the lower quintiles not having options.

Hence the hotels and fast food and other low paying fields complaint about not finding workers since the government gave them an option.

If everyone was fluent in English and could type well, then the price of rote white collar office work would go down and the price of hard labor and public facing and more undesirable work would go up. Which is what has been happening in the last decade.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by e_proxus on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:41AM (#27379315)
For a good (for some definitions of good) extra paycheck, I guess many would do more work.

Want to buy a cool car? Do some cleaning on the side.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:54AM (#27379395)
The person I responded to was asking why compensation was needed at all for any task.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by losvedir on Thursday June 03, 2021 @02:55PM (#27385761)
> Let everyone have a home, eat and drink as much as they need, receive proper education and healthcare, and thrive working for something they see interest in not a paycheck/boss and you'll see terrorism will be entirely rid of.

It's a nice thought, but I don't think this is actually true. Osama bin Laden and a number of the 9/11 hijackers were actually well-educated, well-off engineers of various sorts, for example.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by NoGravitas on Thursday June 03, 2021 @01:33PM (#27384648)
Love to see you being downvoted into invisibility for suggesting that Another World Is Possible. Our techbro overlords are aiming for Rentism, but they'll accept Exterminism if they can't get it.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by tw04 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:02AM (#27381501)
>A large % of people now believe that the finance industry only exists to work against them and make an elite minority rich.

And what on earth makes them think cryptocurrency doesn't exist simply to make an elite minority rich? Just because it might be a different minority doesn't change the equation. And oh by the way, there is absolutely 0 government protections in the new system. Don't get me wrong, over the last 70 years a lot of the protections in existing financial institutions have been watered down, but I'll still take an FDIC backing on my bank account over: "oh no we got "hacked" and all of your wallets are gone, sorry about that!"

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by tachyonbeam on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:14AM (#27381670)
Same. I lost a small but nonzero amount when a fraudulent crypto exchange went bust. There's a reason FDIC protection exists. This is going to be unpopular, but the value proposition for cryptos isn't there yet IMO. It's either "get rich quick" or "buy drugs online". It really isn't "convenient way to transfer money" yet. I'd rather invest in companies that are actually doing something useful. The value of those seems generally less likely to evaporate overnight. Why would I want to own dogecoins when I can own shares of companies that are changing the world?
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by bgroat on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:31AM (#27381949)
You're forgetting the immense riches that can be made in cybercrime!
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by NoGravitas on Thursday June 03, 2021 @01:25PM (#27384527)
The ransomware market has been booming lately.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by spinny on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:15AM (#27381692)
oh no we got "hacked" only happens if you leave your crypto on an exchange. It's not yours until it's under your control
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by jonfw on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:55AM (#27382289)
The vast majority of crypto owners are not technically competent enough to hold themselves responsible for a crypto wallet, IMO.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by MrMan on Thursday June 03, 2021 @01:27PM (#27384561)
It's not about just technical competence. There are long standing real world reasons why custody of all kinds of assets is a business.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by WanderPanda on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:29AM (#27379250)
Is it lack of understanding of the financial industry or the opposite? I observe that through Bitcoin much more people have become interested in (austrian) economics. I think especially in times when everyone says that the problems e.g. central banks are “solving” are too complex to understand for 99.99% of the people, an uptrend in a much more simple theory (that is hence also more compatible with Occam’s razor) is a good thing.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by nly on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:03AM (#27379448)
For me the ultimate problem with deflationary currencies is that you get rewarded for doing nothing. Every year as keys to wallets are irreversibly lost, or the value of the real economy grows relative to the supply of BTC, your Bitcoin gets more and more valuable.

Many Bitcoin hodlers actually have an expectation of becoming extremely wealthy, despite having done nothing for society, because they've been swept up in the speculative mania and volatility.

Gold bugs don't generally have this expectation. Gold is no longer a broadly accepted currency, and even the most vocal of gold bugs are only expecting a 2x or 5x return in the next few decades, assuming the $ does collapse. They only preach an expectation that N bricks of gold, where N will buy a house today, will buy them a house 50 years from now. The attitude is one of wealth preservation rather than speculation. It's a reasonable expectation assuming the demand for and supply of Gold remains balanced.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by scsilver on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:42AM (#27382111)
You get rewarded for your risk, its not nothing, its second key building block for a financial system. Those that have time, trade risk for money, those that have money trade money for reduced risk over a period of time. If this wasnt the case, people couldn't retire safely, there would be no one to trade their money for lowered risk.

What is interesting is that this setup has been exploiting youth for a long time. Its only now that, with crypto, GME, AMC, the younger investors can ramp up the volitility in the market, creating more risk for older more established investors, who then need to pay to reduce their expose to that risk.

There a lot more to this that further blurs the morality of positioning yourself within this power struggle, but ultimately, its just market forces at work.

At the end of the day, this revolution could be stymied by actually providing the next generations with a foreseeable path to home ownership, a family with good education and healthcare, and the american dream, without having to yolo it all, even on an engineers salary. But it seems the next generation is only path to enact change is by staking their assets for generational speculation war.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Nursie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:46PM (#27388424)
In the situation where a deflationary currency is a country's currency, there is no risk. Neither is there investment, there is merely sitting on currency to gain value.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lazerpants on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:55AM (#27381400)
Deflationary currencies shouldn't be an issue if real prices adjust at a similar pace. The theoretical problem with deflation is mostly that wages are sticky and you can't lower someone's pay very easily. But if everyone has the expectation of deflation it would probably work fine.

Expectations about inflation/deflation are important drivers of these phenomena (not the only ones of course) and if we break the paradigm with cryptocurrencies then it's possible the stickiness problems of deflation could be solved.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Nursie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:34AM (#27381999)
None of that addresses the parent's concerns that idle cash grows in value, effectively benefiting from the economic output of others without even the need for investment.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by lazerpants on Thursday June 03, 2021 @12:01PM (#27383349)
It doesn't grow in value if real prices are adjusting simultaneously.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Nursie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @12:22PM (#27383640)
But you’re talking about a deflationary currency, by definition prices fall compared to currency units.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:42AM (#27379772)
I would say it is even worse than doing nothing when one considers the environmental impact of mining BTC. These people have an expectation of reward for increasing energy usage and pollution in the world for basically no benefit to anyone but themselves.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by StavrosK on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:52AM (#27381354)
> so the current generation is saying "Fine, I'm going to invent my own system... with Black Jack, and hookers!".

This is extremely apt, because in the end they went "in fact, forget the system!" and realized you can just make money from the hype without actually building anything usable.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by jollybean on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:03AM (#27380011)
I'm doubtful that barely rational populism is causing regular individuals to spend $1M on their favourite Baseball card NFT.

NFT is mostly driven by the elite, with common people acting as useful idiots to them by talking, tweeting, watching SNL skits about it.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Igelau on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:01AM (#27382369)
> After many hours I couldn't find anything even remotely interesting.

This has been my issue with dApps as well. It's always "thing that does some stuff with ETH" which is only valuable and interesting if you already assume ETH is valuable and interesting. I guess most people make the leap of faith by putting money into them, but on sheer technical merit, dApps just aren't that interesting.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by sjg1729 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:26AM (#27382760)
I agree in a lot of cases, but a couple months ago I saw a pretty interesting idea on HN: https://sarcophagus.io . While I think there are some issues with this protocol, it convinced me there are some pretty interesting problems that can be solved with new and unintuitive social/technical means with dApps.

(un-disclaimer: not affiliated, not an owner, not a user)

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Igelau on Thursday June 03, 2021 @12:37PM (#27383837)
I really want this to be a shaggy dog spec that ends with a punchline in the FAQ.

Q: Is this a pyramid scheme?

A: No! It's a sarcophagus scheme!

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by K0balt on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:18AM (#27380826)
Definía sort of a system that feeds on itself, not a great model I think. Tokenizarion of real or digital items makes sense for many reasons though, the most basic of which is that it is a system of record keeping that is persistent, trusties, and programmatically immutable where immutability is needed. For digital items, tokenization can make sense from a data durability standpoint, since tokenized data can be stored on chain with its presentation context, for example an in game asset could be globally accessible and playable far into the future beyond where the game would otherwise be available. This and other potentially useful cases are mentioned in some medium articles at prufio.medium.com.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ww520 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:52AM (#27382254)
For dapp, I found the idea of doing asset swap pretty interesting. It’s like the interest swap or the currency swap but with crypto assets and tokens to form a swap pool that functions like a standalone exchange, which anybody can start using the crypto infrastructure.

What crypto presents is the opportunity for lay people to take financial power from the finance establishment. I think that’s why people are so excited.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by southerntofu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:24AM (#27379227)
> A large % of people now believe that the finance industry only exists to work against them and make an elite minority rich.

Yes, because that is the very definition of capitalism: people own, others work. That's the reason modern forms of slavery, colonization and patriarchal control were developed, historically.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_capitalism or Silvia Federici for some great perspectives on the control of births/sexuality, patriarchy of the wage and oppression of women under capitalism.

> people are thinking "I will never own a home"

A lot of people i meet from the younger generation don't care at all about owning a home. They feel concerned that the privileged elites are ruining the show for everyone and by the next decade we'll be more and more struggling for drinkable water and basic survival.

Punks were derided for their "No future" stance, but it looks like the entire world has gone "No future" and just keeps fucking up as much as they can. Spending billions of KWh on blockchains so rich people can speculate on buying their own number (correct me if i'm wrong but to me a NFT is just a number) is just part of this.

We have to stop this madness, abolish private property and the capitalist industry entirely and go back to communal living and producing stuff based on actual needs, not dumb single-use Internet of Shit products and other planned-obsolete non-flashable-single-purpose computers.

> After many hours I couldn't find anything even remotely interesting.

The only interesting "dApp" i've seen so far is radicle.xyz, a decentralized forge built on top of git. Still i'm skeptical of tying money and financial incentives into my software development practices, but at least those folks (free software people) had the decency to make crypto-payments optional by adding opt-in Ethereum integration. Clever move.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by yebyen on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:18AM (#27379528)
> Spending billions of KWh on blockchains so rich people can speculate on buying their own number (correct me if i'm wrong but to me a NFT is just a number) is just part of this.

You say this as if numbers have no utility. Is an IP address "just a number"? What about a /8 cidr block? How much energy should we be allowed to spend to secure global address space and provide a secure implementation of identity for all people? This is one of the actual concrete uses of NFT tech, (see Urbit Azimuth.)

> We have to stop this madness, abolish private property and the capitalist industry entirely and go back to communal living and producing stuff based on actual needs, not dumb single-use Internet of Shit products and other planned-obsolete non-flashable-single-purpose computers.

Good luck making a non-disposable world where nobody has domain over their own numbers or is allowed to have their own distinct and unique identity secured by a leading consensus protocol. I for one am glad that you and others of a like mind are not empowered to tell me or anyone else that I can't have my own number if I want it, or to secure it with as many megawatts and global collaborators as I can muster.

Because you know what happens when private property is abolished? Spoiler, only the well connected and powerful will hold private property, and overall the scope and impact of inequality even broadens.

Edit: I'm getting downvotes but not sure which part you disagree with! Have you ever lived in an area where private property was abolished? (They tried this in Lithuania and USSR and that's exactly how it turned out! When nobody is allowed to own resources, who decides how they are allocated?)

"To each according to his need" sounds great until you get to see what an actual functional implementation of that looks like, and it turns out that Stalin is the one who is in charge of it all.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by rymate1234 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:23AM (#27382699)
> Because you know what happens when private property is abolished? Spoiler, only the well connected and powerful will hold private property

If only a few people can own private property then you haven't abolished private property, you've just limited who can own it.

This was the main issue caused by the massive state control of Marxist Leninist countries like the Soviet Union -- by centralizing all control within one single political party you essentially just replace an economic elite with a political elite. Couple that with the democratic centralism you often find in these single party ML countries and suddenly you have something that's a lot less like the communal living the OP was referring to.

I'm not saying abolishing private property will be some magical fix all, but I also don't think using the soviet union as an example of why it won't work is a good example. You could have a society where usage of resources is governed by consensus rather than "lol stalin said so" but consensus is obviously a lot harder to do on a global scale than a small communal village

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by yebyen on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:46AM (#27383107)
Thanks, that was probably my point. Consensus is hard. Ethereum is one of the global systems that currently exists for tackling the consensus problem. Shouting at clouds is on the other hand, not tackling the consensus problem.

Someone or something has to be at the helm of the command economy. I'm definitely not saying we should "go back to communal living and producing stuff based on actual needs" but I am saying that without a rigorous system for distributed consensus, you really don't have a chance of achieving this.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by imtringued on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:24PM (#27387547)
"I will never own a home" going by reddit and certain message boards the sentiment is pretty much "if boomers are rentseeking with land and shiny rocks then I'll rent seek with money"

Land in desirable locations is a scarce good and land owners extract an economic rent via rising land prices which makes housing unaffordable. That same dynamic exists with cryptocurrencies with a limited supply. You buy early and the value of the cryptocurrency rises as more people start using them.

In both cases the hoarding instinct is drowning out productive activity. When land becomes too expensive you cannot afford to live on it. When Bitcoin becomes too expensive you cannot afford to pay with it. Of course this is under the assumption that you need a fixed amount of land and the equivalent to that would be that you also need a fixed amount of Bitcoin.

The primary difference though is that with land people voluntarily decide to move there because the location is attractive. Cryptocurrencies aren't popular enough to justify choosing them over government currencies. People are buying cryptocurrencies because they are going up.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ansible on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:36AM (#27382028)
> A large % of people now believe that the finance industry only exists to work against them and make an elite minority rich.

And that's because it is true. The vast majority of the financial services industry is designed to screw people over.

The only thing an average citizen can do is let them skim off as little money as possible. Buy stocks in solid companies, and hold on to them for a long time. Index mutual funds with minimal administration overhead. Things like that where you can invest a portion of your life's savings without getting screwed over too bad.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by koheripbal on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:44AM (#27382141)
> The vast majority of the financial services industry is designed to screw people over.

I don't know where to begin with a comment like this. It's being so heavily reinforced by social media, but is so hyperbolically outside reality that I honestly don't know where to start.

It's similar to saying that the vast majority of the medical industry only exists to make people sick. Do people die on the operating table? Sure. Do people contract illnesses in hospitals? Yes. Is the VAST MAJORITY of medicine DESIGNED to make people ill? Convincing someone who believes this is impossible, because it's such an extreme view it cannot possibly be based on logic or evidence.

The financial system is a vast and complex. It's as old as the first Egyptian farmers. Do you honestly believe it was DESIGNED to screw over humanity since inception?

Is it so impossible for you to imagine the utility of bank accounts? Futures contracts? Mortgages? Bonds? Stock Exchanges? Fiat money? If these are all just elaborate scams, why does every society on Earth use them since literally 3000 BC?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ansible on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:29AM (#27382816)
The most useful aspects of the financial industry are the most heavily regulated... by government.

Banks have rules on what they can use the money in your savings account for. They have government backed insurance.

Regular stocks are also heavily regulated. Financial reporting requirements, disclosures, auditing, etc.

Why does all this regulation exist? Because people we getting screwed over, and it was bad enough the government had to step in.

The mortgage industry was not heavily regulated enough, and what happened there? A large financial crash. And who got bailed out? The banks, many of whom were somewhat complicit and profiting off the situation.

Who didn't get bailed out? The little people.

This is still happening now. Most hedge funds, high frequency trading, the lure of day trading, and may other schemes exist to siphon off money from regular people.

Think for a minute about the hedge fund manager who gets tens of millions in bonuses. Where does that money come from? Ultimately the companies and other investors. That money could have gone into higher wages for the workers, but instead is being funneled to a few elites.

Since ancient times, the powerful have sought to retain and grow their own power. They use whatever means are available to them. It can be the use of force, but things have gotten more sophisticated.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by caylus on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:56AM (#27383268)
> Why does all this regulation exist? Because people we getting screwed over, and it was bad enough the government had to step in.

I think the analogy still holds here. Medicine is highly regulated because people sometimes die as a result of medical intervention, and as a result of that regulation (hopefully, but debatably) less people die, but that doesn't prove that medicine is designed to kill people.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ansible on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:21PM (#27389412)
> I think the analogy still holds here.

I really don't think so.

Let me tell you a little story.

Banks have offered checking accounts (now usually via debit cards) for a long time. Everyone understood how they worked, and if you wrote a check, it would be refused payment if you didn't have enough money in your account. This is the classic bounced check, and the merchant would be angry with you.

Fast forward to the 2000's. Banks changed the rules, and now (unless you explicitly disallow it) if your check was going to bounce, they will instead charge you an overdraft fee. Even if your account was in the negative by one cent.

All in the name of profit, because the fee would be like $35. And of course, this hit the poorest people the most. And let's not talk about check cashing services, which really screw over the people.

Now if banks stopped there, that would be one thing.

However, one of the "innovations" that Wells Fargo came up with (it was innovated for the profit margin, for a little while) was to re-order transactions any way they saw fit.

Suppose you have $5 in your checking account. This morning, you deposit $50, and in the afternoon, you withdraw $30, secure in the knowledge that you have $55 in your account. Seems safe, right? You're doing the right thing, and playing by the rules, you'll still have $25 left. You are still out and about, so later, you take out another $5 for a meal. No problem, you still have $20 left.

But Wells Fargo changed the rules. They decided that all the transactions coming in on the same day could be ordered (serialized in database terminology) in whatever order they decided. So they would process the $10 withdrawal first, charge you a $35 overdraft fee, and then apply the deposit, leaving you at -$10. Then, when you take out another $5, this is allowed, but because you're already negative, they charge you another overdraft fee, so now you're sitting at -$50.

That is innovation in the modern age of the financial industry.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by andrepd on Thursday June 03, 2021 @02:51PM (#27385712)
Yours is a ridiculous answer. Modern hyper-financialised globalised capitalism has nothing in common with bronze age Egyptian farmers. Obviously one doesn't need to justify everything in the past 5000 years to be allowed to criticise financial industries today. Silly fallacies.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by hbosch on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:48AM (#27382200)
> And that's because it is true.

And perhaps it's also true that crypto has also made an elite minority rich?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by simias on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:43AM (#27379324)
The only thing that really works with cryptocurrencies and adjacent technologies is to use them for pyramid schemes and using them for illegal payments like buying things on the darknet or paying ransomware. The rest is just empty promises and short term hype.

NFT is just the last in a long series. Before that we had the Lightning network that would revolutionize payments and make cryptocurrencies actually usable, ICOs that would revolutionize startup founding etc...

I wonder how long the cryptocurrency world will manage to maintain this facade of being a miracle tech in order to justify the insane amount of money poured into it, while at the same time continuously failing to deliver on everything.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by didericis on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:11AM (#27379490)
Cryptocurrencies have also been used as a way to escape hyperinflation and retain savings despite a coercive and highly restrictive government, eg Venezuela.

When a system becomes corrupt and dysfunctional and normal transactions and savings become ineffective or illegal, cryptocurrencies have proven themselves as a viable means of escape. The value of that is hard to understate.

I agree that a lot of other applications are overhyped, and that there is a lot of bloat and excess in the crypto space. I think their core use case and value is in providing an extremely difficult to block form of value storage despite restrictive and irresponsible governments. The value of that depends on how restrictive and irresponsible your government is being.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by s-lambert on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:05AM (#27381549)
In cases like Venezuala, what's the long-term goal of holding crpyto though? That the country somehow collapses and is rebuilt with a normally inflationary currency with a less restrictive government? Or is the idea that you build up savings to eventually leave the country?

It doesn't really seem like a long-term solution or one that'd help more than a small amount of people.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by HeadsUpHigh on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:01AM (#27382380)
The idea is to not have your money lose half its value on a daily basis. Or to have relatives send you money from abroad. There doesn't need to be an endgame, it just fulfils a need of these people.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by thatguyagain on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:16AM (#27379518)
Any sources on how many Venezuelans actually moved their money into crypto?
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Nursie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:21AM (#27379553)
Usually this is where someone from Venezuela comes along and tells us that this is a tiny minority, and most people want US Dollars because they can actually use those.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by ac29 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:42AM (#27383038)
I was under the impression US cash apps like Zelle were far more popular than cryptocurrency: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-11-11/zelle-has...
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by aga98mtl on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:36AM (#27379708)
The government controls the traditional US Dollars remittance systems. They can force absurdly bad exchange rates. Crypto shines where the government is messing with banking and currencies.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by FranchuFranchu on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:42AM (#27379777)
I'm from Argentina, people who want to trade US dollars usually do it on illegal unofficial markets with better rates. I think it's likely that it's the same in Venezuela.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by Nursie on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:40AM (#27382090)
That's nice, but you appear to be bringing up theoretical conditions as a counter to actual observed behaviour.

Crypto might well potentially shine under such circumstances, or under your view of what such circumstances might be, but the truth on the ground is apparently different.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by didericis on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:07PM (#27388582)
Cited this article in another response: https://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-adoption-venezuela-research bitcoin adoption in Venezuela is more than theoretical and is being used to send money into the country.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by bhandziuk on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:36AM (#27382020)
> Crypto shines where the government is messing with banking and currencies

but isn't any cryptocurrency still directly tied to some fiat currency? Unless everyone uses crypto then at some point it gets exchanged for dollars at which point the low value of the dollar in a place like Venezuela is realized and you're stuck in the same situation but with more hassle.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by didericis on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:01PM (#27388540)
Volume for p2p bitcoin exchanges in July 2019 was 20million a month: https://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-adoption-venezuela-research
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by tiborsaas on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:34AM (#27378913)
Lots of people got "into the internet" because others have made money on it and not for the technology (html, tcp/ip, dns...)

Yes, crypto is mostly focused on financial apps, so they are harder to understand than "send me 140 chars and we make a timeline of it".

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by eitland on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:51AM (#27379031)
All IMO:

To be honest, that example is also the weirdest one to actually break through, and together with Snapchat the ones who took it farthest into almost unusable and still made bank.

(Yo, and I think a number of other tried even further down that street but has failed AFAIK.)

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by simias on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:49AM (#27379361)
Imagine if Google Search achieved success not by providing a search engine but by publishing a whitepaper outlining how PageRank would eventually work, then selling $GOOG tokens to let people speculate on the hype (but not actually entitle them to anything regarding the company, so it's like venture capitalism, but worse).

Then nothing happens for a decade or so, and then Google finally publishes a first version of their engine that takes 30s to search among a couple hundred websites. Effectively unusable, but hey, it's the early day! Bullish!

I also disagree that cryptocurrencies are "hard to understand", it's only hard because their promoters feel the need to obfuscate with technobabble how dumb and ineffective 99% of proposed blockchain solutions are. It's hard to understand because there's nothing to understand.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by PascLeRasc on Thursday June 03, 2021 @09:50AM (#27381328)
Plus whenever someone criticizes Google for doing something bad, others could jump in and say “well they’re supposed to move to Don’t Be Evil next year, so it’s ok”
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by tiborsaas on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:58AM (#27380569)
You are projecting an existing, well understood stack on a fundamentally different platform. What works on Earth would be silly to assume it should be the same on the ISS and vice-versa.

> Then nothing happens for a decade or so...

I guess you took the comfortable position to choose starting point of the internet as 1998, but what about 1980's or 70's? It was rather slow progress, just as you described.

> I also disagree that cryptocurrencies are "hard to understand"

I was referring to financial apps in general. For most people to think about interests and investments is a challenge even with fiat currencies.

I agree though that a major crypto/blockchain revolution hasn't happened yet and probably it will never replace the current internet, but it will co-exists and be much more significant than today once a group hits a sweet spot with UX, utility and adoption.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by xtracto on Thursday June 03, 2021 @08:42AM (#27380390)
Another example is videogame development: Initially there was pure sweat, blood and passion (around the 80s for PC gaming). But nowadays most of the people in there are for profiteering.

Once the bean counters enter a tech field, they suck all the fun.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by andrefuchs on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:37AM (#27378933)
I'm an artist and collector on hicetnunc.xyz. The culture is totally different there and most artists aren't there to make a quick buck.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by tauntz on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:04AM (#27379103)
Honest question - why are they there then if not to make money? What other reasons exist for selling NFTs if not to make (quick) money? I'm genuinely curious here :)
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by adnzzzzZ on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:07AM (#27379126)
He did say "not to make a quick buck" and not to not make money in general. As an artist, it's cool when you're getting paid for your work, but it doesn't mean it's the primary motivator for everything you do.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by andrefuchs on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:23AM (#27379222)
Exactly. The media is all about the money aspect of NFTs. There is much more to it. At least in the art world.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by croon on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:45AM (#27379333)
You say "Exactly", and then proceed to contradict what they said.

What are the other aspects of NFTs (in the art world or elsewhere)?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by meowkit on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:29AM (#27381898)
NFTs act as unique instances of objects that can be “digital shadows” of real physical objects, or their own thing, wrt the blockchain they exist on.

For the art world, they are a new medium and can be used to secure provenance. In the rest of the world they are being looked at as mediums for selling tickets or keys to access unique experiences (an art piece/door/puzzle that activates or lights up if presented with a valid NFT as a simple example) among many theoretical use cases.

A lot of crypto stuff doesn’t make sense unless we get Decentralized Identities (DIDs) right, so things like NFTs can be associated with with a user.

https://www.artworkarchive.com/blog/what-every-art-collector...

https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by andrefuchs on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:17AM (#27379193)
Artist share their work on Instagram, Tumblr, and tons of other social networks for free. Why do they do this? That doesn't make any more sense either.

About your question: hicetnunc.xyz is basically like Instagram but with an easy option to support the artist by buying their creations directly from them as a NFT. They can showcase their creations, get discovered, and make some money on top.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by bhandziuk on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:39AM (#27382072)
> but with an easy option to support the artist by buying their creations directly from them as a NFT.

Why not buy directly from them without an NFT? What does the NFT bring to the table? Isn't what your describing what places like Etsy already do?

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by prepend on Thursday June 03, 2021 @07:15AM (#27379512)
> Why do they do this? That doesn't make any more sense either.

If someone sees my work, they will buy an original piece. Or buy merch. Or buy a print. Or pay me to teach.

Or I think the main reason is that I like to make art and like people to see it. It makes me feel good for people to see and comment on my work.

Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by yayr on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:58AM (#27379413)
as in any other space it is hard for most artists to get attention for the work that they doing. If you want to get attention you have to share some of you work for free. However, the images you see on those platforms are usually not high resolution and don't come with any usage rights. Those are then the things artists get paid for hopefully.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by NoGravitas on Thursday June 03, 2021 @01:43PM (#27384812)
High resolution, usage rights, and, importantly, commissions. As with most things on the internet, furries have had this figured out for a long time.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by stjohnswarts on Thursday June 03, 2021 @04:45PM (#27387061)
They all sound like used car sales people to me that's the biggest warning sign I've seen.
Re:The NFT market bubble has popped? by agumonkey on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:37AM (#27378930)
another is that every problem becomes an opportunity. things too slow ? new layer on top of the old. Not enough privacy ? side project that will connect with the old. Everybody jumps on everything to grab their share, get funding and start working but it's all stacked potential.. but nothing stable yet.